@@AmySwain03 maybe he would at the begining, as his parents send him a letter saying that they are dissappointed in him, specially remembering what happened with Sirius, Narcissa and Lucius would be harder on him as they don't want their son to end up like Sirius, and Draco cares about making his family proud.
I dont thibk draco would ever be in Gryffindor. He doesnt have the balls or personality to be there. Because if he was then alot about the story and him would chnage
I think Draco would actually have been most comfortable in Hufflepuff, he is really not a leader that is roles and expectations put on him by others mostly, his father.
I feel like Harry being in Slytherin would definitely impact his relationship with Sirius. Sirius’s impression of Slytherin was mainly based on his family and their associates. Yeah Harry is James and Lily’s kid, but he’s also in the house of Sirius’s tormentors. But, also consider Regulus. Harry is someone that Sirius inherently cares about. Similarly to how Sirius probably cared about his brother before everything tore them apart. Sirius escapes Azkaban, his brother is dead, and his godson is in Slytherin. I feel like Sirius would feel a heavier responsibility to take care of Harry. Not only because he’s his godson, but because he wouldn’t want someone he cares about to be affected by the house and to change like his brother had. In a sense, not only would he see James in Harry like he did originally, but he would also see his younger brother. Someone who has grown up in a broken household and quite literally thrown into a pit of snakes.
This channel is weird. This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact that a Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item. Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videos and even Theorys; told with a straight face. Made-up stuff that just never was true. A weird channel.
@@slevinchannel7589 Well a Horcrux can be used for healing in a sense. Like when it brought Harry back to life unharmed. So it's got some truth based in it but yeah not sure if it really fits.
@@susanross1304 I mean I feel like snape might of tried to expel harry but Dumbledore would talk him out of it because snape was basically Dumbledore's right hand man and would know expelling harry screws the wizarding world
1,What if Ron was a Hufflepuff 2,What if Sirius raised Harry 3,What if Voldemort won 4,What if Peter didn’t betray the Potters 5,What if Umbridge stayed as high inquisitor 6,What if Harry looked like lily 7,What if Tom Riddle was raised by Dumbledore 8, what if lily survived Voldemort 9, what if Hagrid was never expelled 10, what if Voldemort was successful in killing Harry? Write any other suggestions and hopefully dean will see this!
@@captain_dsz6049 Harry Potter and the Potion Master's stone Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets ;p;p;p;p;p And from then on it all becomes a 50 shades of grey copycat
Imagine this: Harry in slytherin, hermione in ravenclaw, Neville in hufflepuff, and Ron in gryffindor, and they’re all still friends. In book 1, Neville recognizes devils snare, Harry does the flying, Ron captains the chess, and hermione still figures out the potion puzzle. The larger story arc would be the 4 of them uniting all the houses against Voldemort.
In my opinion, it’s good but I would Switch Ron and Neville, although Neville was not very brave at the beginning of the series, both the sorting hat and McGonnagle both knew what he had in him, and the trio only were in Gryffindor because they had the bravery to ask to be there other wise Harry would be in Slytherin, Hermione in Ravenclaw, And Ron in Hufflepuff.
Great idea but they didn’t do it because it would’ve taken away too much time and importance from Harry in a Harry Potter movie. Now if they made a movie like that with the original house founders, like rowena ravenclaw, Godrick gryffindor etc, THAT I would see
JK: "It's really important we had characters like Cedric and Luna in the later books to show that people outside Gryffindor can be heroes too." Also JK: *GREEN ROBE BAD!!!*
@MythKp I'm fine with Slytherin being the only house with Death Eaters in it, as pride, ambition and cunning do go to that extreme. My problem is that no Slytherin is ever given the chance to show how ambition and cunning can be used in a positive manner. It's why I think a Slytherin should have been the Hogwarts champion in Goblet of Fire, as only he could use cunning to solve the Sphinx's riddle, and afterwards his friends could join DA to show not all Slytherins were just cruel bullies. I might not have such a problem with this if JK wasn't trying to constantly hammer in "Don't be a racist" as a key message of the books, as well as "Don't judge a book by it's cover," so why being in Slytherin instantly makes you mean, cruel, petty, spiteful or jealous and having no positive personality traits is utterly beyond me.
@@Longshanks1690 I agree. This is why I would of liked it better if instead of a main trio being all of them in gryffindor. Have a core four with all of them being in a different house. This would of made a great message that you can be friends with people who are different from you.
@@rennadiamond7871 Draco 'wanted' to be Harrys friend since his father pressured him to befriend him for the sake of the dark lord and you know the rest..
Interesting!! But she’s definitely a Gryffindor more than Ravenclaw some of her personality and things she’s said would have to be omitted if she would’ve been a Ravenclaw
I saw a theory somewhere that said that Harry, Ron, and Hermione represent the three other houses but were all somehow placed in Gryffindor. Harry represents Slytherin for his cunningness and ambition. Hermione represents Ravenclaw for her wit and wisdom. Ron represents Hufflepuff for his kind nature and immense loyalty to his friends. I truly think each one of them belongs in Gryffindor but possess the traits of the other houses. :)
@Akanni oh? The first year he comes to Harry's place and asks if he can't sit there. How rude! Draco was friendlier. He helps Harry and Hermione in the Troll incident, almost ready to sacrifice himself in the chess game, and that's when they were 11. And yeah, he's always got Harry's back no matter what (except for the one time he was under the influence of the locket), he defends Harry when Seamus accuses him of lying, and yeah, not to mention, Ron Harry Hermion going thru shit everytime but they do it together. Sure Ron is not friendly at all :)
Mm I have to disagree. I love Ron, but he is not friendly at all. He is a good person, but he is full of prejudices and is very flawed. Hermione is not full of wisdom, I mean she is, but not because she is "naturally intelligent" it is because she works so damn hard (which I actually value more). She is a different type of intelligent to, for example, Luna. The harry one kinda makes sense though, but he also is basically a horcrux so that might've twisted what the sorting hat said
I know this has a happy ending, but you forgot three factors: Barty Jr surviving, a good looking Voldemort, and Voldemort not having Harry's protection in his veins.
@@Squoski93 No it wouldn't be necessary as he's back already at the end of chamber. He wouldn't need Harry's blood which makes it impossible for Harry to survive at the end since that connection is what kept him alive. Unless Voldemort is stupid enpught to want to touch him he doesn't need it
Also, without the skill and experience he'd gained during his formative Hogwart years in the original timeline, the entire fight between him and Voldemort would have hinged on the deus ex machina of that protection. It would have made for a very lackluster finale.
I don’t think that Harry would have played quidditch if he was in Slytherin. The only reason McGonagal had Harry play for Gryffindor was because they needed a new seeker since the last one graduated (?).
Exactly! They only hold tryouts when there's an opening on the team. Got Slytherin this would have been in Harry's second year where he had to try out against Draco.
Tryout against Malfoy? More like payout. Besides, I think Malfoy only wanted to be on the team because of Harry getting in on his first year. No way Draco would let anything seem like Harry could be better than him
This channel is weird. This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact thata Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item. Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videosand even Theorys; told with a straight face. Made-up stuff that just never was true.A weird channel.
Harry would have hated being in Slytherin because their personalities reminded him of the Dursleys. I still think his friendship with Ron would blossom in the first year, but there would be suspicion on Ron's side about Harry's character. Harry's friendship with Hermione would face greater odds but not feeling welcome or accepted by Slytherin house, Harry would have no problem breaking his house loyalty to be friends with her. Harry's outcast life in Slytherin would parallel Sirius's and his role as a father figure to Harry would be more prominent.
@Krishna Ammini I think he might have tolerated some Slytherins more than others like his preference for Slughorn over Snape, but he would not have found his people in that house. It's book canon that not one Slytherin student stayed to fight the Death Eaters in the Battle of Hogwarts, so I don't think it's too generalized to assume what their loyalties would are in this case. But Gaius Wyrden brings up a good point, and I agree that his presence in Slytherin would have caused a divide.
It was always funny to me that he was so anti-Slytherin he’d known about the houses for what a week at best? And learned about them from people he just met. Like what if he’d met a Slytherin alumnus before Hagrid or met Draco before Ron?
He did meet Draco before Ron. He met Draco in Diagon Alley when Hargrid took him to get his school things. He initially formed a dislike of Draco because Draco reminded him of Dudley Dursley: spoiled and greedy.
Harry was anti-Slytherin because Ron was. If he'd met a Slytherin or two before Ron told him all that garbage, he might not have been so quick to accept Ron's bigoted views without question.
@@xKage_kunx not if draco told them not to. Remeber his father was onebof the richest in britian. He probably would tell them not to be friends with him for what he did to him when they first met. Just like with dudley
@@jjbum3726 Possibly, but the other kids didn't know about Harry being the boy who lived. This alone would cause some of the children to ignore Draco as just being jealous. And if Harry did indeed become the slytherin seeker over Draco, this would only make more students think this.
Your not giving Slyterins enough credit, Harry story would have remained mostly the same just some of the players would change. Harry would just find a new crew in that first year.
@@kingdavid6286 Ron doesn't like Slytherin's though, it was him in first year that told Harry that being in Slytherin is no good and that a lot of dark wizards came from Slytherin, which made Harry scared so he wanted Gryffindor.
•j a v a• I think even if Ron didn’t like slytherins he may have made an exception for Harry as he rode the train with him and stood up to Malfoy on his behalf.
Everything Harry knows about Slytherin before he gets to the sorting hat, he knows from Hagrid. If Dumbledore hadn’t sent Hagrid, but sent someone else instead, or asked the Ministry to send someone, Harry might have had no preconceptions. So was Dumbledore manipulating the situation by sending Hagrid? I think so
That's so called 'Great Dumbledor's Plan". There's a theory that every move was planned by Dumbedore and even Hagrid had a "mission" to create a certain image of Gryffindor and Slytherin in Harry's head.
Possible, but because he never used Harry's blood, he would still be incapable from even touching Harry. I would also think that because they no longer share blood, Voldimort would would have a harder time getting into Harry's head.
Hmm, if Ron and Harry weren’t friends, Ron would still have said horrible things about hermione cause he was mean to her, she still would of got attacked by the troll but Ron wouldn’t of even noticed she was gone cause ya know, emotional range of a teaspoon, and hermione would have died in the first book! :s
That would shock and traumatize Ron, making him slip into a depression and stray away from others out of guilt. Harry, who still has no friends of his own, would quickly notice that something is wrong with him and start trying to approach him, since they liked each other when they first met. Ron would probably be reluctant to talk to a Slytherin in the beginning, but then remember what happened because of the way he treated Hermione, so he would eventually confide in Harry and they would become friends again. That would help Ron pull himself together and become much more responsible and careful with people, possibly also hardworking like Hermione was, and change his opinion about Slytherin due to Harry's friendship
The reason she was crying in the bathroom was because she overheard ron saying something rude about her to HARRY . MAYBE it wouldn't have turned out with her in the bathroom without Harry.
No, she would not die, Remember, in the book, the actual book, this happened, Harry on Halloween night: where's Hermione: Neville: I don't know if you can tell but she's been in the girl's bathroom all day, crying, showing, Neville knew that Hermione was in there so he would've probably gone to Dumbledore telling him that Hermione was in the girl's bathroom not knowing about the troll. Or maybe when Gryffindor was going up to their dormitory, they probably would've have checked they had everyone and would've noticed Hermione wasn't there, looked for her, and saved her from the troll. There are many ways Hermione would've still survived the troll attack,
@@ZeroEagle667 Had Harry been in Slytherin though he would have been on the Slyrherin table and wouldn't have noticed Hermione was missing so Hermione would have been killed.
Yeah. He would have been put in Slytherin no dought if it wasn't for Harry not wanting to be in Slytherin. He probably would have become part of Voldemorts team.
@youtube watcher Although he might have come to his sense that Voldemort killed his parents and he would want revenge, even though if Harry and Voldemort were on the same team they would be nearly unstoppable.
@@rennadiamond7871 He definitely wouldn't have, as Hagrid tells him day 1 who Voldemort is and what he did to Harry's parents. Also, Voldemort would not allow Harry to join him, as the sole boy who lived, and defeated Voldemort, Voldemort would totally have Harry dead. Anyway, just because Harry is surrounded by evil people it does not mean he would lose his moral character. Sirius didn't, and his family was the worst of the worst. That being said, it's possible Harry's mind could be warped by some of the slytherins' ideas but I'm not sure by how much.
Would Hermione possibly have died to the troll in the Philosopher's stone or would Ron have saved her on his own? Wasn't it Harry who brought up she didn't know about the troll?
Well, maybe when Ron came to warn her and noticed the troll was near, they start to run away from it and manage to run into a teacher in time to deal with it.
@@jeremywatson1905 There was no jokes that made Hermione head for the bathroom. Ron called her a nightmare and commented on how she had no friends, but please continue to think that was what set Hermione off if you like.
This channel is weird. This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact thata Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item. Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videosand even Theorys; told with a straight face. Made-up stuff that just never was true.A weird channel.
@@slevinchannel7589 have you seen/read the chamber of secrets? Voldemort aka Tom Riddle says that he can return to life, if ginny who owned the diary died. Her life force becomes his and voldemort rises...
Draco would have betrayed Harry. His father told him to befriend Harry. In 6th year of course he would try to get close to Harry again. But before that no he believed in pure blood supremacy like his daddy. Harry didn't like Malfoy when they first met. Harry saw that Malfoy was a bully and when he had insulted Ron Harry stuck by Ron. Harry has an experience with bullies. Maybe in book 7 they would have been 'friends'. Or after the war but before that Draco was filled with arrogance.
[ "Slytherin" exclaimed the sorting hat, confused and a bit shocked Harry walked quietly to the table as everyone there was cheering, "Now you see we are not so different", Malfoy said with a grin on his face, "I guess I was wrong" answered Harry as he reached to Malfoy for a hand shake, "I accept your friendship" ]
Blaise and Pansy would of been the trio. I feel like they talked to Draco and Pansy had a crush on draco but she would of like Harry more if they were together.
Disagree. The people in slytherin and snobs and awful people. I dont think harry would want to be friends with people who remind him of the Dursleys/his tormentors
Ruby Harry and Pansy is very debatable, at first Harry really wouldn’t like Pansy as she is kind of a female version of Draco, she’s prejudice and cruel, but just maybe, she has a chance to turn good but the way I see it, her and Harry would spend more time avoiding each other
I think that the less and less that Harry acted like his father, the more Snape would've liked him. It's possible that at some point he would've cared a great deal for him because he'd see first hand how he resembled Lilly
@@YellowBear-kx1ff Yeah, I also remember him saying all dark wizards are from Slytherin, Ron is not a reliable narrator. His shame of being a Slytherin would be countered by the shame of dropping out and becoming a worthless nobody. So I rather think he would stay and be unhappy about it.
@@Tragiccheese I think they meant to say that people usually like Draco just because he is played by a hot guy but if Harry was in Slytherin him and Draco wouldn't been rivals and we could see a different part of Draco's personality and more people would actually like him for who he is and not just because he is played by a cute guy. Hope you understand.. English is my second language 😅
I feel like Harry's ability to speak parseltongue would have been a much bigger deal if he was in Slytherin and Malfoy would either be Harry's friend or be an outcast in Slytherin. Harry may have even changed alot of Slytherins for the better
With the quidditch question of book 1, Snape would have punished him. Talented or not, the slytherin team was on a winning streak and had no reason to let Harry join the team.
Sorting hat: Slytherin!!! Harry: his mind rang with the phrase *oh no* Snape: "For God's sake i have to put up with James Potter's son in my house". Promptly leaves Hogwarts never to return.
You think so? I think it'd be a more of a story about rifts between Slytherins, as Harry emerged a leader among them and rejected a lot of their more sinister traits. The Gryffindors at most would have been a bit snooty and brusque towards them, but would have been outsiders.
Gryffindors won t be the villains because not all the Slytherins are bad and not all Gryffindors are good . Example, Slughorn and Snape was in Slytherin but they are good and Peter Petitgrew was in Gryffindor and he was bad. And if Gryffindors was the villain , Why Harry will join Voldemort.
In number 2 Harry wouldn’t even be able to get to school because Dobby blocked the entrance to platform 9 and 3/4 and Ron would’ve gone to school without harry
Yeah, but he had a nimbus, so he could have flown there. Or the Malfoys would’ve made sure he got to school, given that they wanted the chamber to be opened and for him to be in the midst of it all.
I imagine since voldemort was still in quirrels body he himself took the diary with him so lucius malfoy never delivered the diary to giny and dobby never knew what was going to happen so didnt try to stop Harry from going to hogwarts.
@@IOFIsickness This raises an interesting question. Where did Lucius get the Diary? It couldn't have been from Quirrel/Voldemort, because he would have done. everything in his power to get Voldemort back to... well, power. I personally think Lucius had the diary from when Voldemort was still in full power, or got it just after he'd fallen at the Potter's.
If harry potter was put into Slitherin Snape would be closer to him and Harry wouldn’t hate him so much but the events that would take place would still stay the same.
Snape is my favorite character and he is one of the complex character in the Harry Potter series and also I wish that there was a book written about Snape how about you?
Maranwë Adalaniell there are other characters that I would be interested to see your book on like James Potter and serious black Remus lupine Peter Pettigrew Albus Dumbledore and others. It would be cool just to see the point of view from the rise but Snape would be my first book that I would read because he is my favorite character as I said.
9:00 if the Chamber of Secrets is never opened, then that means the Sword of Gryffindor isn’t imbued with Basilisk venom so it probably can’t be used to destroy Horcruxes
Also, without Voldy being greedy and using Harry's blood, the horcrux in Harry would either not be destroyed(Harry lives, Voldy kinda lives), or destroyed(Harry dies).
True,but they could just have saved the locket until they had means to destroy them. One scenario would be they get all the horcruxes they find in DH originally (locket,cup,diadem) and they are destroyed in the fiendfyre anyways. Harry WOULDNT die, since even though Voldemort didnt use his blood anymore, therefore no 2-way connection ( Voldemorts soul in harry ,harrys blood in Voldemort) ,and that by this point, harry WAS still a horcrux,regardless of whether Voldemort took his blood or not. So Lilys blood sacrifice ended for Harry since he turned 17, and never continued through Voldemort, like in the original series. So in the forbidden forest, lilys blood sacrifice is non existent. Voldemort still uses Avada Kedavra on Harry with the Elder wand and since harry is still the master of the elder wand , the Horcrux inside him would be the one to be destroyed.
Okay, this needs to stop. Slytherin is not the “BAD” house! Slytherin is full of the cunning, the ambitious, and everyone should want to be like that! They are charismatic, and they are not always evil! MERLIN himself, was a slytherin!
This seems more like "How could the timeline stay the same despite Harry being in Slytherine?" Maybe it would be a more interesting/relevant what-if if you assumed a slight change in attitude from Harry? He's an 11 year old boy when starting at Hogwarts, it's not that far fetched that he would be moulded by his environment. Despite a bumpy start with Malfoy, I do believe in such a timeline Harry would befriend him rather than Ron and Hermione. Alternatively some other Slytherin-students and then square up with Malfoy later. I do think you present an interesting version on how Voldemort comes back here, and I do agree that he would still want to kill Harry out of spite/revenge. However, as you said, he would not need to do so in order to come back. Also, in this version, Voldemort would not be immune to Harry's touch any more (he didn't use Harry's blood to resurrect) so he might want to be careful with confronting him. I'm imagining Harry being allowed to grow up thinking he will become a powerful wizard (maybe he'l be more ambitious rather than straight up evil, and cracks in his friendship with Malfoy would show over the years as their different values comes to the surface.) I think however that Voldemort would put up a facade of wanting to recruit Harry and turn him to the dark side, while secretly planning to kill him. In this version, slytherine-Harry might see himself more as a rival to Voldemort, aspiring to take his place rather than stop him.
@@soo1579 How would they get to know each other? When would they have any reason to talk to each other? Its like Harry and Malfoy in the original timeline suddenly deciding to give each other a second chance and have a normal conversation together, and start becoming friends at some point. They already decided that they are enemies, and are surrounded by people who are convinced Slytherin and Gryffindor are enemies. Even if Harry and Ron in this alternate timeline secretly thought that the other one seemed like a nice guy and they wanted to get to know each other better, there is this thing called peer pressure. Harry might be resistant to it, but Ron, particularly without Harry's influence, doesn't seem like the person who would stand against peer pressure. Particularly not for a Slytherin
Might I remind you that in this *What If* version of events, Quirrelmort would not have encountered Harry in front of the mirror hiding the Philosopher's stone at the end of first year. No fighting going on, therefore he hasn't experienced that Harry's mere touch can burn him like fire. But, during first year Quirrelmort has certainly kept an eye on Harry, watching and observing. He must be surprised and intrigued by this child, his supposedly prophesied mortal enemy, who does not act at all as expected. Everyone including Snape and Quirrelmort expected the Boy Who Lived to have grown up in the lap of luxury, coddled and spoiled rotten, to be instantly sorted into Gryffindor. To bask in his fame. To strut around the castle full of arrogance and entitlement, with an entourage of Gryffindor friends and admirers, just like his father James did. I believe that Quirrelmort and Snape both will be rattled enough by this unexpected turn of events to really look at Harry, to notice all the little things they overlooked in canon because they were both so blinded by their own preconceived notions of who and what this blasted !Potter! boy is. And if they look closely, if they pay attention to how the boy moves, talks, eats, dresses, writes, acts in class and outside of class, keeps his distance to people, wary and distrustful, they might notice that something is definitely wrong. Both Snape and Tom Riddle grew up in harsh conditions, in abusive situations in the Muggle world. They will recognise the signs. Snape might care, because Harry is Lily's child too. Or he might be indifferent, or think it great karma, that James Potter's son has suffered through an abusive childhood with Muggles for ten long years. But Voldemort wouldn't just watch from afar, he'd take advantage of the situation if at all possible without raising suspicion. Facilitate friendly talks with Harry after class in his office, (we know diary!Tom is excellent at pretending to care, of lending a kindly ear to a first year student's woes) possibly recommend some books to read and offer extra tutoring to bring him up to speed with his wizard raised pureblood and half-blood Slytherin House mates. And he might discover pretty soon that Harry is feeling physical pain in his scar in his proximity, and that he's a parselmouth. What? How can Potter speak!? Now that would change everything, if Voldemort realised early on what exactly Harry is! It shouldn't be very difficult to turn Harry against Dumbledore and the light side, who abandoned him all alone on the Dursleys doorstep 10 years ago, forgotten until they deemed the time right to retrieve him and parade him around again in front of the masses. Harry would jump at any chance to go somewhere else during the summer, to not have to return to Little Whining.
@@Uberdude6666 I agree. Canon Ron is extremely biased and prejudiced against Slytherin students in general and the Malfoy family in particular. He'd see Harry's sorting into Slytherin as a 'betrayal', a sign that 'Harry Potter is going dark'. He wouldn't want to be friends with such a cowardly slimly snake... And the peer pressure is certainly an important factor.
@@CM.825 Cool add-ons. If Quirrel doesn't fight Harry at the end of year 1, there is no reason why he should be replaced as DADA-teacher the next year. Also since quirrel has voldemort sticking out from the back of his head, it make sense that he would not be affected by the "curse" on the job. We might see a totally diffetent dynamic, where Quirrel takes on a sort of mentor role over the years instead of Dumbledore. Ofc Dumbledore might get suspicious of the only dada-teacher since voldemort's job interview to last more than a year. And Snape was already suspicious of Quirrel. Speaking of Snape, as he is now Harry's head of house, I believe he would be less inclined to bully him openly in class, especially if he is friends with Snape's favourite golden egg; Malfoy. I believe Snape would be influenced to see more of Lily in Harry (particularly if he sees his good sides and not just him breaking rules and messing around in class) He might take the perspective that the potter-boy can turn out all right after all, and take it upon himself to tutor Harry towards that. I smell a sort of power struggle between Snape and Quirrel over Harry😂 at least until Quirrel is exposed. Maybe in year 4, Quirrel is able to ressurect voldemort per their original plan (quirrel taking on a sort of Wormtail-role after maybe? Since he is like a coward at heart?) Either way his time at hogwarts is over and the story takes a drastic turn as in the original timeline. Maybe its too late and voldemort has already "turned" harry. Year 5 and 6 is then Harry and Malfoy working together for voldemort, and harry helping out with the vanishing cabinet-plot in year 6
This is a good point, but I rebuttal with: would Ron have been close enough friends with Harry for him to stay at his place and fly in the car together?
@@slug.gggyyyyyyy I thought they were more talking about protection from Voldemort, rather than the place he enjoyed, was going with the fact he still had the Fidelius charm at privit drive
Well, then Harry would have spent 7 years being mercilessly bullied by Slytherins because every single member of that house in the books is just a Death Eater in training apparently.
Would Ron actually like Hermione just because they shared classes? He didn't liked her arrogance and style anyway in the first to second year. Harry was the main reason they stuck together. I think Ginny would be the first friend for her and then Ginny introduced her to Ron. Also... If Ron would be friends with a slytherin, how would his brothers react. But yeah... Nice video.
Yesica Licht that’s a good point, I think Harry keeps them together, but I think Ron would still have initially teased Hermione and heard that she was crying in the bathroom. Not sure if he’d go alone, but maybe if he had Dean and Seamus with him he would. He would be able to save her from the troll, which originally brought the trio together. I don’t think he and Hermione would be as close in first year, but maybe they’d be acquaintances or she’d join a group with Dean Seamus and Ron
Yesica Licht that’s more so in the movies than books Ron feels sympathy for Hermione because she’s an outsider no one likes her much he’s always stuck up for her that’s why they end up together not harry and her
@youtube watcher the thing that annoys me is the part where Malfoy steps on Harry's nose in the Hogwarts express, in the book Tonks finds him and fixes his nose, but in the movie Luna did
im sure other plot lines can play out. like maybe harry doesnt go with ron/hermione and find some Slytherin friends who support him as the new dark lord
I do agree with most of this but I have thoughts on the idea that Harry would still have supporters in book seven among the children of death eaters even if for the wrong reasons. By this time Harry has already become friends with a “mud blood” and a muggle sympathizer so I have a hard time believing any of them would still see Harry as a direct replacement for Voldemort especially since the later is actually there again and by this time Harry’s true nature and alignment have been revealed in the ways that he’s stood against Umbridge, stood up for Dumbledore, fought the death eaters at the ministry, and befriended people who are directly against the interests of the death eaters. I think about the time he really became friends with Hermione he would start getting seriously bullied and hated upon by all of his housemates.
Something that seems wrong with Harry, concerning how he would be after living with in the Dursley household and all of the abuse. I can't see how he would be happy or even nice to anyone. He would be angry and wouldn't let anyone get close. This another is another possible what if video.
people deal with this kind of emotion differntly i had been abused and treated hoorably i chose to make it a drife to promise my self i would never make someone fell the way i felt plus make me apprcaita when people being nice and thoughtfull also it make me always stand for people cuz i would love if someone stand for me sorry for my english i'm learning and writing comments is part of my practise plz corect me
@@xenorogue8447 I think he would have been like all the other death eaters. Unless he was to turn on voldemort then his story would be similar to regulus black's
Abuse victims handle things differently depending on the person. There are many ways a child might try to cope with it or how they'd turn out, but I'd think instead of angry, Harry would be more like Neville. Unsure of himself and a bit clumsy due to constantly being treated like nothing at home. He'd also be either more distrustful of people's intentions, or too eager to conform in order to gain the approval he lacks at home. In that case I'd think Hufflepuff, with it's bright demeanor, would make a better house for him. Since Harry was never an academic (so not Ravenclaw) and both Gryffindor and Slytherin students would be too eager to influence him down a certain path. Sorry for the blather. Character stuff like this is just my cup of tea. :)
@@Nalothisal but in this video they clearly stated that after being soldering in the Slytherin Harry's and Ron's relationship took a hit and they barely talk for the rest of the year so he wouldn't have been talking to Ron and order it no Hermione ran into the bathroom or whatever so yes she most likely would have died
Yes, the troll would have most likely seriously injured or killed her, because nobody would have cared to search for Hermione. After all in book canon the only person even noticing and caring that Granger is not present in the Great Hall in this moment when people are panicking about the troll is Harry! For - reasons. As a Slytherin student - or alternatively, if he'd been sorted into Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw - Harry would not have had any reason to think much about Granger. He would hardly have known her. She doesn't have any friends at this point in time. What Ron said earlier on this day was insensitive, but true. People don't call her Hermione, they refer to this Muggleborn girl only as Granger. She was extremely unpopular amongst the student body and the teachers for her obnoxious, attention seeking attitude , she was barely tolerated inside her own house! Percy Weasley didn't even make a head count and ask the group of first year Gryffindor girls and boys where their missing year mate was, although he as the fifth year Prefect was actually responsible for looking after them!
@@rubielopez952 well, yes and no. Ron was angry and exasperated because Hermione Granger kept pointing out his flaws, always correcting his pronunciation. Le vi OH sah, not levio SAH! If you look at this scene, and remove Harry, because he's been sorted into ANY other House - regardless if Harry was a Slytherin or Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw, he would NOT sit next to Weasley or Granger, he wouldn't talk to Weasley or Granger, because he would sit with his own house mates, he'd try to fit in with the other boys, his dorm mates, just the same way canon Harry does, because he's desperate to belong somewhere, to stay at Hogwarts, to not be kicked out and sent back to the loathsome Dursleys, you still have the same situation regarding our dear Miss Granger! Since starting at Hogwarts, this eleven year old Muggleborn girl is behaving in a way that doesn't earn her any friends at all. She's an attention seeking teachers pet, a know-it-all, believing in authority figures and the school rules, desperate to prove she's just as much a Witch as all the other first year girls, who are either coming from a half-blood family or some pureblood family. Hermione doesn't get on with any of her dorm mates, (Lavender Brown, Parvati Patil, very probably Sally Ann Perks and another girl like Fay Dunbar not mentioned in the books but who is on the students list JKR used for planning, please read the essay "The Secrets Of The Class List" on the online HP lexicon dot org) she hasn't managed to connect to any other Gryffindor (or Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff) students - girls or boys - so far at this point in time. At least we never read a word about it in the book, because the reader sees everything through Harry's biased, naïve eyes! Muggleborn / Mudbloods are a minority group amongst all the Hogwarts students. Only the Light side wizards (Dumbledore's followers) don't hate them on sight. It's considered being 'modern, progressive', to be welcoming to Muggleborn students in general. But that doesn't mean that the other students and teachers like everyone coming new into the wizarding world. The neutral party families tolerate the Muggleborn students more or less, the dark sect families despise, loathe, hate them on sight. In every school, everywhere, Muggle or Magical, such students like Hermione Granger with her attention seeking ways, her righteous goody-two-shoes, Know-it-all attitude, are despised by the student body. Professor Snape treats her harshly, tells her to stop it, to sit down, for a good reason. (only canon Harry doesn't get it, obviously, he just sees unfairness). Granger tries to be a teacher's pet, always waiving her hand into the air to get the teacher's attention, and often blurting out answers and full out quotes from text books without being called on to speak, thereby preventing and hindering other, slower students to find the answer and to think for themselves. Maybe in her previous Muggle primary school such behaviour was tolerated, but most teachers don't want to see this behaviour in a secondary school like Hogwarts. Hermione Granger would behave exactly the same like she does in book canon, or in the 1. film, getting on other people's nerves, alienating her class mates more and more, every day. It doesn't depend on Harry Potter being a fellow Gryffindor at all. In this Charms lesson on 31. October 1991, Samhain or Halloween, like the Muggles call this day, she tries to "help" the students seated on her left or right side, although nobody wants her help. Either Ron articulates what he thinks of her, Know-it-all, etc. out in the corridor or another student criticizes her. It doesn't matter. She's heard this all her life, she's sad, upset, can't understand why nobody likes her, why all her attempts to make friends fail. Miss Granger hurries away to cry in the girls bathroom. Stays there for several hours. The troll finds her. She freezes in panic, instead of fighting or ducking and trying to run away. He swings his club, reduces the toilet stalls to rubble. Granger dead. Either at once, or after becoming a quick troll snack. End of story. Nobody noticed in canon that HG was missing in the Great Hall, besides HP. Or rather, some of the other girls did notice that HG was inside that toilet stall sobbing her heart out and bemoaning her fate, but they didn't do anything about it. Maybe they smirked in glee, gossiping about stupid, arrogant Know-it-all Mudblood Granger, but they certainly didn't tell a teacher or prefect like Percy Weasley. (Besides the heroic too good to be true HP, because honestly, which real world eleven year old boy would care for such a girl he barely knew in such a situation of chaos, inmidst a crowd of panicking children, if she wasn't his sister?) Nobody cares, nobody comes to her rescue in this scenario. Neither Professor McGonagall (after all, she is Head of House Gryffindor and Deputy Headmistress, an adult who should know better!) or Percy Weasley or another Gryffindor prefect did a head count in book canon, noticed that one first year student, or several students, were missing, like they should have.
I feel like in year 2 when Ron and hermione confront Harry he would draw his wand because draco would slowly put anti-muggleborn ideas in his head by order of his father
What if the trio and Draco's houses are changed (Harry = Slitherin, Ron = Hufflepuff, Hermione = Ravenclaw, Draco = Gryffindor) and they are all friends?
What? No Hermione does have many Ravenclaw characteristics, but it’s shown on the movies/books that she finds bravery more important than intelligence. Being sorted into a house is not just having the house’s traits, you also need to value its characteristics. For example, Harry, who had many Slytherin characteristics, but he was more interested on being brave, so BOOM, Gryffindor.
Can see it now instead of that dramatic pause when snape says " people might get the feeling you were ... up...to something" ( I feel I've butchered that quote😂) when he gets taken to snape and suggests him as there new seeker snape replies " maybe you being a slytherin mr potter wont be a (catches harry scowling at him) ...complete disaster after all"
If Harry had been destined for Slytherin in this alternate universe, maybe he never refused Draco's friendship. He may have become a powerful and successful Slytherin, possibly even more focused on his studies. He may have been more aligned with Snape, and even mentored by him directly. It could be that he eventually fought Voldemort, possibly even refusing him, and due to not having the close relationships and support he had in Gryffindor, that he could not ultimately defeat Voldemort. If he did defeat Voldemort, Harry might choose to become some sort of powerful leader of his own. That's just what I would imagine. I also have Luna saving Buckbeak, with the help of Hermoine, and the two of them heroically riding him into the sunset. He may have been a Sylytherin version of Cedric Diggory, so he was still possibly even dating Cho at some point. He may not ever have dated Ginny, and actually marries Cho. He might have still been entered into the cup against Diggory, if so.
i think had harry been sorted into slytherin house i feel like he'd make it his personal mission not to turn out like every evil witch or wizard, and show you can be friends with other houses.....imagine if harry was the heir of slytherin and controlled the snake ordering it never to attack another muggle-born student The other houses would look at harry and say this boy is the heir of slytherin yet he hasn't attacked anyone why? or something like that which shows Harry's determination to not only redeem slytherin house and show that he's nothing like Salaazar Slytherin or voldemort
Then he would have died in many situations. Hermione saved Harry and Ron's life MANY of time. Also Draco would be in danger and so would be his other friends.
Yeah. This would not have happened anyway because the author would have obviously changed a few things. No way they could keep everything the same but Harry would be in a different house. It would make no sense.
i don't think the hat would have disregarded harrys wishes. what would have more likely lead to this scenario would be hagrid never bringing up the houses to harry so harry just goes in with an open mind. i would also believe that snape would taken great interest in harrys development, but even if he didn't, he wouldn't have hurt slytherin as a whole just to pick on him, thus i believe that harry would have trusted snape in a way similar to how he trusted minerva. i also disagree with your interpretation of book 2, quirrel likely would not have attended another year since dumbledore would have caught him red handed, trying to get the stone, as voldemort himself only escaped because harry got there first, thus a duel between dumbledore and quirrelmort would have occurred, leaving quirrel dead and voldemort weakened once again, left to lick his wounds. coming book 2, lucy still would have tried to give the diary to ginny, the chamber is opened and the basilisk does what he does, harry hears voices coming from the walls, but now ron isn't around to tell him that hearing voices is bad, so harry opens up about it to the only person he trusts, who, in this scenario, is snape. sanpe and dumbledore, with the information now available to them, figure out that a basilisk is involved, they need harrys help to enter the chamber, but forbid him from coming along, harry does so anyway and this becomes important at the second door, at the same time ron convinces lockheart to hunt down the basilisk after finding the note on hermione, his dilemma plays out like normal as they arrive after the others. young tom riddle and the basilisk are no match for dumbledore and snape, with snape fighting tom and dumbledore fending off the basilisk together with fawks. book 3 plays out just as it did except for harry not being allowed in hogsmede and also never getting there because he doesn't have the marauders map, so he never learns that sirius is the prime suspect in the potter case, he just think sirius is coming for him for being a death eater. this is probably also the year where harrys friendship with ron and hermione really starts as harry is still friends with hagrid ever since the start of book one, so malfoy being a dick to hagrid is going to piss harry off and he would likely ask to join ron and hermione in their efforts to save buckbeak. in this year sirius also attacks ron in his bed, prompting fred and george to give the marauders map to ron as they believe him to be in danger. since ron now has the map, he starts roaming the corridors at night but, because he does not have an invisibility cloak, gets caught by snape, who gives the map to lupin as he did in the books. now, because ron and hermione can not sneak out without the cloak or the map, the fights in the shrieking shack play out without harry, ron and hermione, lupin and sirius confront petigrew, snape shows up to arrest sirius, but he has no invisibility cloak in this scenario so sirius and lupin can best him together, petigrew escapes, sirius blasts a hole into the wall and tries to chase him in dog form but looses him while lupin stays in the shrieking shack until snape awakens, calms him down and drinks his wolf medicine. later lupin tells harry the whole truth and gives harry the marauders map and provides a note from sirius that allows him to visit hogsmede, buckbeak is still killed in this scenario. book 4 happens pretty much as in the book as harry and ron are now friends, they go to the quidditch cup together, death eaters happen yadayadayada, harry becomes champion of hogwarts, snape, being competent in legilimency, can tell that harry was not at fault here and instantly knows that something's up so he takes to personally teaching harry roughly the same spells harry studied with ron and hermione over the year, ced dies, voldie comes back, enter book 5 book 5 also happens roughly as in the book, except for when harry is sent to attend occlumency with snape, now since harry does trust snape in this scenario, harry might actually succeed in this, voldemorts plan to steal the prophecy fails and, instead the battle in the ministry is handled entirely by the order of the phoenix voldemort shows up personally since only he can retrieve the prophecy, but is driven off by dumbledore, sirius probably still dies dueling bellatrix in this scenario, but harry doesn't witness it.
Harry never saw Peter pettigrew on the map in the books. Doesn't make a difference since lupin wouldn't have seen him on the map since he wouldn't have got it anyway, but still important to point out
I really think we should’ve been given more “good” students from Slytherin. Also, just having more prominent characters from each house would’ve been neat.
@@eridejj naw. without Ron, I assume Harry would have taken Draco's hand and they would have become friends. This could have been a very different story where Draco goes against Voldemort because of his freindship to Harry.
From the perspective of a Drarry fanfic writer: 1st year: Harry and Draco make up and become friends. He still finds a way to bond with Ron and Hermione though and most plot remains the same. 2nd year: Harry and Draco fight when the chamber of secrets is opened. Harry has never liked Draco's obsession with blood purity. Their fight leads Draco to change a little and offer to help find the chamber with Harry, Ron and Hermione. Plot commences normally. 4th year: Draco and Harry start to realise they have feelings stronger than friendship for one another as he helps Harry figure out the challenges of the Triwizard Tournament but they have some internal struggle over accepting their own feelings. 5th year: They confess and get together. 6th year: Draco is loyal to Harry and refuses to become a death eater (as he realises the dark lord wants to kill Harry). He runs away from home. 7th year: Draco is not on the dark side and works together with Harry against the dark lord and his parents, although it is incredibly difficult and he suffers. In the end, he is reunited with his parents who accept him for who he is, the dark lord is defeated and they live happily ever after. Also, who needs plot when the genre has done a complete 180?
As you said Harry would have started his own DADA class but Cedric wouldn't be there because according to the 4th book he was in 7th year. So how come he would be a member of that class??
He probably had to redo year 7 because he certainly couldn't pass his UTZ's while doing the goblet of fire thing XD But good point, if it wasn't the case, how would he be there and why?🤔
It wouldn't change much but there'd be one more person to tell everyone Voldemort was back, so there'd be more proof. And he would still be Cho's boyfriend so Harry never got together with her.
I think in the beginning when Harry is chosen as a Slytherin, Draco would give Harry a warm welcome gift and more gifts to come bringing friendship more closer. I think of that because Draco is Pure Blood, and the family are usually rich.
Cedric would found the DA. ZHarry would have joined as his second. Feeling alone he would betray his house and act as a spy for the DA. Harry would also fall in love with Jinny much sooner as he marveled at her magic skills.
The only real problem I have with you version is that harry didn't make any slytherin friends the first year. He was desperate for friendship that is why he defended ron when draco insulted him since he was harry's first friend. Growing up he was alienated in school by his bully cousin and his gang so he didn't have any friends from school and he was required to to straight home after school which didn't allow him to make any other friends. Ron & his family were the only people who were genuinely nice to harry except for Hagrid up until that point in his life that he could remember. So Harry would have definitely gained a group of slytherin friends that first year. If harry played quiddich it wouldn't have been until his 2nd year since they already had a seeker.
Great video, however there's a massive oversight. Not only would Hermine not be friends with Harry or Ron, but in all likely hood, the troll would have killed her back in book one. It was Harry who remembered Hermine was absent when the warning of the troll came
If Quirrell stays on as DADA teacher in the 1992-1993 school year, what would happen with Gilderoy Lockhart? Would he still be Obliviating famous wizards? Would he help defeat Voldemort?
Hey There is this one thing Diary was in possession of Lucius Malfoy who intentially put diary in Ginny's cauldron so how would Quirrel obtain the diary? Also at one point Harry obtains it but he doesn't wanted to dispose it like Ginny so it seems quite impossible for Quirrel to get the diary.
You're forgetting one major detail. Harry and Ron's friendship started all the way back at Kings cross platform 9 3/4, aboard the Hogwarts express with Harry being both impressed and curious about Ron, and his family. They spent a significant amount of time together on the train to Hogwarts, being all the way north toward Scotland I do not for a second believe that Ron or Harry would ditch each other the moment they were separated in different houses. Their friendship might've become more difficult as Harry had to sneak around to keep in contact with Ron, the kind hearted Harry would be just as persistent to not adhere to the Slytherin house traditions as he was in the real books.
that's why i think harry potter would be the perfect poster boy for the Boy who lived that was sorted into slytherin house who treated everyone as an equal no matter what house they were in no matter their status half-blood or pure-bloods.............I think it would be Harry's personal mission to redeem slytherin house into a modest kind house hold slytherin students may look at harry and say this boy made it his mission to show the rest of the school you can be sorted into slytherin house and not turn out evil thus turning a new leaf for slytherins house, You can be sorted into slytherin house and not turn out to be evil imagine how the other houses may think they may have a different view on slytherin thanks to harry and who knows they can actually be a school and have a friendly rivalry
I want a Slytherin AU where Harry and Draco end up being friends as they realize they can learn to tolerate themselves, then they see how much they have in common. This would make Draco very conflicted when his father wants him to become a Death eater.
James K. Good I think it’s because Harry was the 6th horcrux Voldemort made, it‘s only 1/64 piece of soul in Harry. If my math is right, that’s a rather small piece. Also maybe it even had a little influence... we don’t really know how he would have done at school without that piece of Voldemort 😅
@@maxi1968 how you came to 1/64? I think we don't konw how big the part of the soul in a horcurx is. We konw killg people rips the soul. But Voldemort killed hundrets. And when he made the first horcurx he has killed 3 People. So was the first part 1/3 of Voldemorts soul? And I don't think if you kill only one person and make a horcurx the halfe soul would go into the horcrux.
@@lostcinema5189 You split your soul for a horcrux. A split is 1/2. Each horcrux is 1/2 of the remaining soul. Doesn't matter how he makes it, the soul splits off.
@@inkvampyr so let's see : Diary: 1/2 Ring: 1/4 Hufflepuff's Goblet: 1/8 Slytherin's Locket: 1/16 Ravenclaw's Dieidem: 1/32 Harry: 1/64 Nagin 1/128 So does this mean Voldy himself still has 1/256 of his soul?
This what if doesn't work. Voldmort has to take Harry's blood. It's the only way Harry can survive Voldemort killing the Horcrux in Harry. And the Horcrux has to be killed for Harry to kill Voldemort.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
What if Draco was in Gryffindor?
Answer: Wait till my father hears about this.
I don't think Draco would of cared that much if he was a gryffindor
@@AmySwain03 maybe he would at the begining, as his parents send him a letter saying that they are dissappointed in him, specially remembering what happened with Sirius, Narcissa and Lucius would be harder on him as they don't want their son to end up like Sirius, and Draco cares about making his family proud.
I dont thibk draco would ever be in Gryffindor. He doesnt have the balls or personality to be there. Because if he was then alot about the story and him would chnage
@@jjbum3726 true he definitely was a coward
I think Draco would actually have been most comfortable in Hufflepuff, he is really not a leader that is roles and expectations put on him by others mostly, his father.
according to the thumbnail, if harry was sorted into slytherin his eyesight would have gotten better
LMAOOOOOO💀
👁️💧👄💧👁️
Lol
Not like you how do you even see krabby patties
harrys eyes where already green just in the movies dan was elergec to the green contacts so in the movies he has blue eyes
I feel like Harry being in Slytherin would definitely impact his relationship with Sirius.
Sirius’s impression of Slytherin was mainly based on his family and their associates. Yeah Harry is James and Lily’s kid, but he’s also in the house of Sirius’s tormentors.
But, also consider Regulus.
Harry is someone that Sirius inherently cares about. Similarly to how Sirius probably cared about his brother before everything tore them apart.
Sirius escapes Azkaban, his brother is dead, and his godson is in Slytherin.
I feel like Sirius would feel a heavier responsibility to take care of Harry. Not only because he’s his godson, but because he wouldn’t want someone he cares about to be affected by the house and to change like his brother had. In a sense, not only would he see James in Harry like he did originally, but he would also see his younger brother. Someone who has grown up in a broken household and quite literally thrown into a pit of snakes.
.....THAT'S deep...
Wow. Best comment award goes here.
This channel is weird.
This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact that
a Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item.
Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videos
and even Theorys; told with a straight face. Made-up stuff that just never was true.
A weird channel.
@@slevinchannel7589 Well a Horcrux can be used for healing in a sense. Like when it brought Harry back to life unharmed. So it's got some truth based in it but yeah not sure if it really fits.
james should of been put in slytherin
Snape would have done both, made potter seeker and punished him.
Ol' Severus.
Classic Severus.
@@susanross1304 I mean I feel like snape might of tried to expel harry but Dumbledore would talk him out of it because snape was basically Dumbledore's right hand man and would know expelling harry screws the wizarding world
This is slytherins impact
Ah. Having the cauldron cake and eating it too!
Harry be like: "Not Slytherin, not Slytherin, not Slytherin!!!"
And then he wonders why Slytherin people don't like him...
That's some proper bs
Miguelle Landry is a perfect 10 Nobody said anything about ravenclaw........so what’s your point??
@Angel thanks mate, didn't check that👍
I'm a slytherin but I like Harry, he's just a little ignorant but it's not his fault.
@@infjelphabasupporter8416 same but I don't like Draco.
I love how having a sleek hairstyle instantly makes Harry look more like a Slytherin.
RIGHT?! He already had the green eyes lol
423 likes but only 1 reply
@@MarkedTableG 463, and 3 replies
@@bobthebuilder8110 470 likes and 4 replies
OMG LOL!
Sorting Hat: NOT Slytherin, eh? Well if you're sure... better be... SLYTHERIN!
omg 😂😂😂
Lmao
Lol right
Harry: ExCuSe Me!? HoW rUd. >:v
Students: Yayyyyyyyyyyyyy!
1,What if Ron was a Hufflepuff
2,What if Sirius raised Harry
3,What if Voldemort won
4,What if Peter didn’t betray the Potters
5,What if Umbridge stayed as high inquisitor
6,What if Harry looked like lily
7,What if Tom Riddle was raised by Dumbledore
8, what if lily survived Voldemort
9, what if Hagrid was never expelled
10, what if Voldemort was successful in killing Harry?
Write any other suggestions and hopefully dean will see this!
What if Harry had been a girl? (Harry x Ron confirmed :p?)
@@Shutforever that would be interesting
if harry was a girl i believe he would look just like lily but with james eyes and snape eould have a predatory liking to him
@@captain_dsz6049 Harry Potter and the Potion Master's stone
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets ;p;p;p;p;p
And from then on it all becomes a 50 shades of grey copycat
Question about #10
Is this referring to baby Harry in Godric's Hollow or during the Battle of Hogwarts?
Imagine this: Harry in slytherin, hermione in ravenclaw, Neville in hufflepuff, and Ron in gryffindor, and they’re all still friends. In book 1, Neville recognizes devils snare, Harry does the flying, Ron captains the chess, and hermione still figures out the potion puzzle. The larger story arc would be the 4 of them uniting all the houses against Voldemort.
Love this idea!
In my opinion, it’s good but I would Switch Ron and Neville, although Neville was not very brave at the beginning of the series, both the sorting hat and McGonnagle both knew what he had in him, and the trio only were in Gryffindor because they had the bravery to ask to be there other wise Harry would be in Slytherin, Hermione in Ravenclaw, And Ron in Hufflepuff.
Great idea but they didn’t do it because it would’ve taken away too much time and importance from Harry in a Harry Potter movie. Now if they made a movie like that with the original house founders, like rowena ravenclaw, Godrick gryffindor etc, THAT I would see
I love this so much, actually.
Actually hermione said in the books or movies that she was almost sorted into ravenclaw.
JK: "It's really important we had characters like Cedric and Luna in the later books to show that people outside Gryffindor can be heroes too."
Also JK: *GREEN ROBE BAD!!!*
@dr103 And a fully grown man. Not one student from Slytherin house shows anything even resembling a positive personality trait in all seven books.
I know. JK even said that everyone who is racist is in Slytherin. She really hates Slytherin's
@MythKp I'm fine with Slytherin being the only house with Death Eaters in it, as pride, ambition and cunning do go to that extreme.
My problem is that no Slytherin is ever given the chance to show how ambition and cunning can be used in a positive manner.
It's why I think a Slytherin should have been the Hogwarts champion in Goblet of Fire, as only he could use cunning to solve the Sphinx's riddle, and afterwards his friends could join DA to show not all Slytherins were just cruel bullies.
I might not have such a problem with this if JK wasn't trying to constantly hammer in "Don't be a racist" as a key message of the books, as well as "Don't judge a book by it's cover," so why being in Slytherin instantly makes you mean, cruel, petty, spiteful or jealous and having no positive personality traits is utterly beyond me.
@@Longshanks1690 I agree. This is why I would of liked it better if instead of a main trio being all of them in gryffindor. Have a core four with all of them being in a different house. This would of made a great message that you can be friends with people who are different from you.
Lol ikr
According to the thumbnail, slytherin would've given him laser eye surgery
Do you mean lasik by any chance?
Dude, don't ask questions. Let's just enjoy the sleeker, darker, green-eyed, parsel-tongued version of Harry 😍
Of course they would they’re rich asf
Or contacts
and they would've gotten his eyebrows done
Imagine Harry and Draco actually becoming good friends, and Harry maybe influencing Draco in a good way
Draco only wanted to be Harry's friend bc Harry was famous
@@rennadiamond7871 Draco 'wanted' to be Harrys friend since his father pressured him to befriend him for the sake of the dark lord and you know the rest..
Methods of Rationality 👀
@@lynx4755 The only reason Draco didn't like Harry is bc Harry made a fool out of him bc Harry didn't want Draco as a friend
@@rennadiamond7871
And considering how Draco is a terrible bigot, he made the right choice
Interesting topic: What if Hermione Granger Had Been Sorted into Ravenclaw?
The story would have ended with book one lol
I’ll tell you this, Harry and Ron would have died like eighteen times over
Interesting!! But she’s definitely a Gryffindor more than Ravenclaw some of her personality and things she’s said would have to be omitted if she would’ve been a Ravenclaw
Hermione would have died
Kyle Wantland well everyone will die and also it took the sorting hat to sort mcgonigal in ravenclaw or griffindor
I saw a theory somewhere that said that Harry, Ron, and Hermione represent the three other houses but were all somehow placed in Gryffindor. Harry represents Slytherin for his cunningness and ambition. Hermione represents Ravenclaw for her wit and wisdom. Ron represents Hufflepuff for his kind nature and immense loyalty to his friends. I truly think each one of them belongs in Gryffindor but possess the traits of the other houses. :)
yeah
I believe that Harry represents Gryffindor. Every person represents all 4 houses.
@Akanni oh? The first year he comes to Harry's place and asks if he can't sit there. How rude! Draco was friendlier. He helps Harry and Hermione in the Troll incident, almost ready to sacrifice himself in the chess game, and that's when they were 11. And yeah, he's always got Harry's back no matter what (except for the one time he was under the influence of the locket), he defends Harry when Seamus accuses him of lying, and yeah, not to mention, Ron Harry Hermion going thru shit everytime but they do it together. Sure Ron is not friendly at all :)
Mm I have to disagree. I love Ron, but he is not friendly at all. He is a good person, but he is full of prejudices and is very flawed. Hermione is not full of wisdom, I mean she is, but not because she is "naturally intelligent" it is because she works so damn hard (which I actually value more). She is a different type of intelligent to, for example, Luna. The harry one kinda makes sense though, but he also is basically a horcrux so that might've twisted what the sorting hat said
Hermione may be intelligent but she does not have creativity but she has bravory.
Soooooo the biggest difference in this, is that Voldemort would probably have a nose...
Omg best comment so far😂😂
Best comment !
LOL
LOL
true because he would have became tom and not the snake thing he does become
I know this has a happy ending, but you forgot three factors: Barty Jr surviving, a good looking Voldemort, and Voldemort not having Harry's protection in his veins.
Pandadude12345 that’s a good point. Voldemort’s plans in Goblet would still be necessary in this timeline. So Cedric would probably have died anyway.
@@Squoski93 No it wouldn't be necessary as he's back already at the end of chamber. He wouldn't need Harry's blood which makes it impossible for Harry to survive at the end since that connection is what kept him alive. Unless Voldemort is stupid enpught to want to touch him he doesn't need it
Yesss
True
Also, without the skill and experience he'd gained during his formative Hogwart years in the original timeline, the entire fight between him and Voldemort would have hinged on the deus ex machina of that protection. It would have made for a very lackluster finale.
I don’t think that Harry would have played quidditch if he was in Slytherin. The only reason McGonagal had Harry play for Gryffindor was because they needed a new seeker since the last one graduated (?).
Exactly! They only hold tryouts when there's an opening on the team. Got Slytherin this would have been in Harry's second year where he had to try out against Draco.
Yea and Snape wouldn't have given him that chance cuz well....CHILDHOOD grudges?!?!?!!!!??!!
Tryout against Malfoy? More like payout. Besides, I think Malfoy only wanted to be on the team because of Harry getting in on his first year. No way Draco would let anything seem like Harry could be better than him
This channel is weird.
This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact thata Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item.
Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videosand even Theorys; told with a straight face.
Made-up stuff that just never was true.A weird channel.
Charlie?
"Not Slytherin, eh? Better be HUFFLEPUFF!"
Not Slytherin,eh? Better be GONE get outa here
*claps in green and white pukwudgie*
quallity comment
Harry would have hated being in Slytherin because their personalities reminded him of the Dursleys. I still think his friendship with Ron would blossom in the first year, but there would be suspicion on Ron's side about Harry's character. Harry's friendship with Hermione would face greater odds but not feeling welcome or accepted by Slytherin house, Harry would have no problem breaking his house loyalty to be friends with her. Harry's outcast life in Slytherin would parallel Sirius's and his role as a father figure to Harry would be more prominent.
first he'd hate it, then he'd get used to it, and finally he'll enjoy it
he wouldn't mind it tooo much but .... he would be a little disappointed (I would be a little disappointed too) :P
@@kavinh10 So true
@Krishna Ammini
I think he might have tolerated some Slytherins more than others like his preference for Slughorn over Snape, but he would not have found his people in that house. It's book canon that not one Slytherin student stayed to fight the Death Eaters in the Battle of Hogwarts, so I don't think it's too generalized to assume what their loyalties would are in this case.
But Gaius Wyrden brings up a good point, and I agree that his presence in Slytherin would have caused a divide.
@@kavinh10 no he wouldnt. A slytherin killed his parents a slytherin bullied him slytherins were voldemorts followers. He is not harry if he joined it
Harry:Not in Slytherin not in Slytherin.
All Slytherin students:We feel insulted!
My father will hear about this!
Yes indeed
@@veronicadiaz337 I know but Theirs a Dark lord in that house So, He don't want to
@@veronicadiaz337 Is that a threat?IS THAT A THREAT!?
Alex Stergiou how does draco M. Feel
It was always funny to me that he was so anti-Slytherin he’d known about the houses for what a week at best? And learned about them from people he just met. Like what if he’d met a Slytherin alumnus before Hagrid or met Draco before Ron?
He did meet Draco before Ron. He met Draco in Diagon Alley when Hargrid took him to get his school things. He initially formed a dislike of Draco because Draco reminded him of Dudley Dursley: spoiled and greedy.
He was a kid dude very easily influenced
Sunmal that would be my point
He was told no good people go into slytherin be wanted to be anywhere else other than slytherin
Harry was anti-Slytherin because Ron was. If he'd met a Slytherin or two before Ron told him all that garbage, he might not have been so quick to accept Ron's bigoted views without question.
harry i think would probably have been a loner because at this time he already did not like Malfoy
or maybe he would reach out to students in the other houses, bringing a sort of unity among the houses.
Or he would befriend other slytherin student but since draco was a rich pure blood, just like dudley did, force them not to be friends with him
While i dont think that pure bloods would like Harry, I would think that half bloods would be drawn to him.
@@xKage_kunx not if draco told them not to. Remeber his father was onebof the richest in britian. He probably would tell them not to be friends with him for what he did to him when they first met. Just like with dudley
@@jjbum3726 Possibly, but the other kids didn't know about Harry being the boy who lived. This alone would cause some of the children to ignore Draco as just being jealous. And if Harry did indeed become the slytherin seeker over Draco, this would only make more students think this.
Your not giving Slyterins enough credit, Harry story would have remained mostly the same just some of the players would change. Harry would just find a new crew in that first year.
Fenris30 I think it could bR Blaise zabini in there and Ron.
@@kingdavid6286 Ron doesn't like Slytherin's though, it was him in first year that told Harry that being in Slytherin is no good and that a lot of dark wizards came from Slytherin, which made Harry scared so he wanted Gryffindor.
Fenris30 Nah. Without Hermoine, and Ron, loads of things wouldn’t work out.
Fenris30 Oh and if he was in Slytherin, in his second year, he wouldn’t be able to slay the basilisk cause the sword of Gryffindor wouldn’t show up.
•j a v a• I think even if Ron didn’t like slytherins he may have made an exception for Harry as he rode the train with him and stood up to Malfoy on his behalf.
Everything Harry knows about Slytherin before he gets to the sorting hat, he knows from Hagrid. If Dumbledore hadn’t sent Hagrid, but sent someone else instead, or asked the Ministry to send someone, Harry might have had no preconceptions. So was Dumbledore manipulating the situation by sending Hagrid? I think so
That's so called 'Great Dumbledor's Plan".
There's a theory that every move was planned by Dumbedore and even Hagrid had a "mission" to create a certain image of Gryffindor and Slytherin in Harry's head.
@@prk2543 Maybe Dumbledore actually wrote the whole series under the pan name...JK Rowling...
Voldermort would have got to him quicker. Shorter story.
Possible, but because he never used Harry's blood, he would still be incapable from even touching Harry. I would also think that because they no longer share blood, Voldimort would would have a harder time getting into Harry's head.
Kage kun the scar was the reason for the connection between harry and Voldemort not the blood lol
night k wrong, it was Voldemort’s soul
@@akchanneltv4084 also his blood that's why he took the blood of his enemy so he could finally touch him.
WOULD HAVE
Hmm, if Ron and Harry weren’t friends, Ron would still have said horrible things about hermione cause he was mean to her, she still would of got attacked by the troll but Ron wouldn’t of even noticed she was gone cause ya know, emotional range of a teaspoon, and hermione would have died in the first book! :s
That would shock and traumatize Ron, making him slip into a depression and stray away from others out of guilt. Harry, who still has no friends of his own, would quickly notice that something is wrong with him and start trying to approach him, since they liked each other when they first met. Ron would probably be reluctant to talk to a Slytherin in the beginning, but then remember what happened because of the way he treated Hermione, so he would eventually confide in Harry and they would become friends again. That would help Ron pull himself together and become much more responsible and careful with people, possibly also hardworking like Hermione was, and change his opinion about Slytherin due to Harry's friendship
The reason she was crying in the bathroom was because she overheard ron saying something rude about her to HARRY . MAYBE it wouldn't have turned out with her in the bathroom without Harry.
@@kathleencrane7314 Touché
No, she would not die, Remember, in the book, the actual book, this happened, Harry on Halloween night: where's Hermione: Neville: I don't know if you can tell but she's been in the girl's bathroom all day, crying, showing, Neville knew that Hermione was in there so he would've probably gone to Dumbledore telling him that Hermione was in the girl's bathroom not knowing about the troll. Or maybe when Gryffindor was going up to their dormitory, they probably would've have checked they had everyone and would've noticed Hermione wasn't there, looked for her, and saved her from the troll. There are many ways Hermione would've still survived the troll attack,
@@ZeroEagle667 Had Harry been in Slytherin though he would have been on the Slyrherin table and wouldn't have noticed Hermione was missing so Hermione would have been killed.
The thumbnail be like:
*Harry got sorted into Slytherin so he didn't need his glasses anymore*
fr tho
he also has slick backed hair now
Maybe the sorting hat “sensed” a Slytherin in Harry because a part of Voldermort lives inside him?
Yeah. He would have been put in Slytherin no dought if it wasn't for Harry not wanting to be in Slytherin. He probably would have become part of Voldemorts team.
@youtube watcher Although he might have come to his sense that Voldemort killed his parents and he would want revenge, even though if Harry and Voldemort were on the same team they would be nearly unstoppable.
@@rennadiamond7871 He definitely wouldn't have, as Hagrid tells him day 1 who Voldemort is and what he did to Harry's parents. Also, Voldemort would not allow Harry to join him, as the sole boy who lived, and defeated Voldemort, Voldemort would totally have Harry dead. Anyway, just because Harry is surrounded by evil people it does not mean he would lose his moral character. Sirius didn't, and his family was the worst of the worst. That being said, it's possible Harry's mind could be warped by some of the slytherins' ideas but I'm not sure by how much.
@@mastersword6470 Voldemort probably would have let him in, maybe to be a trap for more of the professors from Hogwarts or to kill Harry easier.
@@rennadiamond7871
No way he would have joined Voldemort he hated him it’s more likely for him to clear slytherins name by defeating Voldemort
Would Hermione possibly have died to the troll in the Philosopher's stone or would Ron have saved her on his own? Wasn't it Harry who brought up she didn't know about the troll?
Thunders oh yeah and along with Voldemort’s original looks from behind the scenes
Would she have still been in the bathroom the jokes that made her storm to the bathroom were between Harry and Ron in a class they don't share now
Well, maybe when Ron came to warn her and noticed the troll was near, they start to run away from it and manage to run into a teacher in time to deal with it.
@@jeremywatson1905 There was no jokes that made Hermione head for the bathroom. Ron called her a nightmare and commented on how she had no friends, but please continue to think that was what set Hermione off if you like.
Thats what I was thinking!
The amount of people still alive if Harry was in Slytherin
*PERIODTTT*
This channel is weird.
This youtuber just MADE-UP the fact thata Horcrux can be used as a Healing-Item.
Very irritating how Made-up stuff is just used for Videosand even Theorys; told with a straight face.
Made-up stuff that just never was true.A weird channel.
@@slevinchannel7589 You keep saying this. What are you talking about? Are you watching the same video as us? And you liked your own comment lmao
@@slevinchannel7589 have you seen/read the chamber of secrets? Voldemort aka Tom Riddle says that he can return to life, if ginny who owned the diary died. Her life force becomes his and voldemort rises...
@@slevinchannel7589 He would use Quirrel's lifeforce to do it, instead of Ginny's.
I like to think harry and draco would have been friends.
Draco is a bully harry hates bullies due to Dudley
Draco would have betrayed Harry. His father told him to befriend Harry. In 6th year of course he would try to get close to Harry again. But before that no he believed in pure blood supremacy like his daddy. Harry didn't like Malfoy when they first met. Harry saw that Malfoy was a bully and when he had insulted Ron Harry stuck by Ron. Harry has an experience with bullies. Maybe in book 7 they would have been 'friends'. Or after the war but before that Draco was filled with arrogance.
@@marcusclarke5628 nah Harry is just a presumptuous wimp..
Or lover. Haha
[ "Slytherin" exclaimed the sorting hat, confused and a bit shocked Harry walked quietly to the table as everyone there was cheering, "Now you see we are not so different", Malfoy said with a grin on his face, "I guess I was wrong" answered Harry as he reached to Malfoy for a hand shake, "I accept your friendship" ]
I always thought that Blaise and Harry would’ve been close friends if he was in Slytherin
Blaise and Pansy would of been the trio. I feel like they talked to Draco and Pansy had a crush on draco but she would of like Harry more if they were together.
@@RubyMVmistress disagree.
Disagree. The people in slytherin and snobs and awful people. I dont think harry would want to be friends with people who remind him of the Dursleys/his tormentors
JJ Bum the thing about Blaise is that he is very quiet and mysterious, I think that Harry would bring out his character more and get close
Ruby Harry and Pansy is very debatable, at first Harry really wouldn’t like Pansy as she is kind of a female version of Draco, she’s prejudice and cruel, but just maybe, she has a chance to turn good but the way I see it, her and Harry would spend more time avoiding each other
I think that the less and less that Harry acted like his father, the more Snape would've liked him. It's possible that at some point he would've cared a great deal for him because he'd see first hand how he resembled Lilly
What if Ron Weasley was put in Slytherin?
after all, he was resentful towards his older brothers' successes, so he was ambitious to prove his worth.
karsten69 In Chamber of Secrets, Ron said that if the Hat put him in Slytherin, he’d take the train home.
@@YellowBear-kx1ff Yeah, I also remember him saying all dark wizards are from Slytherin, Ron is not a reliable narrator. His shame of being a Slytherin would be countered by the shame of dropping out and becoming a worthless nobody. So I rather think he would stay and be unhappy about it.
i think the best one should have been the twins or maybe percy
@@beregarcia8655 Percy is very ambitous
Percy should’ve been in Slytherin
If Harry was a Slytherin then a think people would actually like Draco without Tom Felton playing him. Glad your back Dean
What's your problem with tom he was great for malfoy. Like he did what they wanted him too.
@@Tragiccheese I think they meant to say that people usually like Draco just because he is played by a hot guy but if Harry was in Slytherin him and Draco wouldn't been rivals and we could see a different part of Draco's personality and more people would actually like him for who he is and not just because he is played by a cute guy. Hope you understand.. English is my second language 😅
We would've, hopefully, seen character growth in him, a lot faster too
I liked Draco in the books without seeing the movie
I disagree
I feel like Harry's ability to speak parseltongue would have been a much bigger deal if he was in Slytherin and Malfoy would either be Harry's friend or be an outcast in Slytherin. Harry may have even changed alot of Slytherins for the better
With the quidditch question of book 1, Snape would have punished him. Talented or not, the slytherin team was on a winning streak and had no reason to let Harry join the team.
If he was sorted into Slytherin maybe Snape would see him as Lily's son instead of James's
@@runaway871 maybe... but he looked like James in every way except for the eyes, and Snape thought he acted a lot like his father, so I doubt it.
I love how in your theory the trio's friendship is inevitable.
Sorting hat: Slytherin!!!
Harry: his mind rang with the phrase *oh no*
Snape: "For God's sake i have to put up with James Potter's son in my house". Promptly leaves Hogwarts never to return.
What about “What if Neville has been attacked and not Harry”
If Harry became a Slytherin, Gryffindors would be the villains of the books, not the slytherins.
You think so? I think it'd be a more of a story about rifts between Slytherins, as Harry emerged a leader among them and rejected a lot of their more sinister traits. The Gryffindors at most would have been a bit snooty and brusque towards them, but would have been outsiders.
Gryffindors won t be the villains because not all the Slytherins are bad and not all Gryffindors are good . Example, Slughorn and Snape was in Slytherin but they are good and Peter Petitgrew was in Gryffindor and he was bad. And if Gryffindors was the villain , Why Harry will join Voldemort.
As a Slytherin I would be totally fine with that. But I’d feel bad for the innocent Gryffindors. Ehhh it’s fine haha.
In number 2 Harry wouldn’t even be able to get to school because Dobby blocked the entrance to platform 9 and 3/4 and Ron would’ve gone to school without harry
Yeah, but he had a nimbus, so he could have flown there. Or the Malfoys would’ve made sure he got to school, given that they wanted the chamber to be opened and for him to be in the midst of it all.
Or he couldve sent a letter with hedwig like mcgonagall said they shouldve so a teacher or hagrid could come for him
@@Max-js7zr Yeah, that's possible, too, but I wouldn't be surprised if Dobby tried to intercept their owls
I imagine since voldemort was still in quirrels body he himself took the diary with him so lucius malfoy never delivered the diary to giny and dobby never knew what was going to happen so didnt try to stop Harry from going to hogwarts.
@@IOFIsickness This raises an interesting question. Where did Lucius get the Diary? It couldn't have been from Quirrel/Voldemort, because he would have done. everything in his power to get Voldemort back to... well, power. I personally think Lucius had the diary from when Voldemort was still in full power, or got it just after he'd fallen at the Potter's.
One of your best videos yet Dean! Incredible job!
Omg hi movie flame
Big fan of you and Dean
You should do this video but with your opinions
If harry potter was put into Slitherin Snape would be closer to him and Harry wouldn’t hate him so much but the events that would take place would still stay the same.
Maria Bagry well yeah because his father had belittled him so it’s understandable if we see his point of view
dr103 yes he was and I still think that Harry could’ve been closer to Snape maybe there would’ve been some changes maybe not we don’t know.
Snape is my favorite character and he is one of the complex character in the Harry Potter series and also I wish that there was a book written about Snape how about you?
Maranwë Adalaniell there are other characters that I would be interested to see your book on like James Potter and serious black Remus lupine Peter Pettigrew Albus Dumbledore and others. It would be cool just to see the point of view from the rise but Snape would be my first book that I would read because he is my favorite character as I said.
*L*i*z*z*z*z*z*z*z*z*z*z I agree. I think that they could be good friends too.
9:00 if the Chamber of Secrets is never opened, then that means the Sword of Gryffindor isn’t imbued with Basilisk venom so it probably can’t be used to destroy Horcruxes
Also, without Voldy being greedy and using Harry's blood, the horcrux in Harry would either not be destroyed(Harry lives, Voldy kinda lives), or destroyed(Harry dies).
True,but they could just have saved the locket until they had means to destroy them. One scenario would be they get all the horcruxes they find in DH originally (locket,cup,diadem) and they are destroyed in the fiendfyre anyways. Harry WOULDNT die, since even though Voldemort didnt use his blood anymore, therefore no 2-way connection ( Voldemorts soul in harry ,harrys blood in Voldemort) ,and that by this point, harry WAS still a horcrux,regardless of whether Voldemort took his blood or not. So Lilys blood sacrifice ended for Harry since he turned 17, and never continued through Voldemort, like in the original series. So in the forbidden forest, lilys blood sacrifice is non existent. Voldemort still uses Avada Kedavra on Harry with the Elder wand and since harry is still the master of the elder wand , the Horcrux inside him would be the one to be destroyed.
Harry chanting not Slytherin not Slytherin
Slytherin student - this is racism.
Not racism, classism, or groupism.
KiraXBara456 blitz bro it‘s a joke
@@lisadallmeier2854 I know. Just want to find the right term
KiraXBara456 blitz well but if u say “groupism“ instead of “racism“ it‘s not funny anymore because that‘s what it actually is lol
@Oma Cool ToT that's bullying :(
Okay, this needs to stop. Slytherin is not the “BAD” house! Slytherin is full of the cunning, the ambitious, and everyone should want to be like that! They are charismatic, and they are not always evil! MERLIN himself, was a slytherin!
PERIOD
Ya most people think slytherin is BAD cause tom riddle/voldemort was a slutherin and because of draco
Ya most people think slytherin is BAD cause tom riddle/voldemort was a slutherin and because of draco
Say it louder for the people in the back!
Slughorn , he’s slytherin
This seems more like "How could the timeline stay the same despite Harry being in Slytherine?" Maybe it would be a more interesting/relevant what-if if you assumed a slight change in attitude from Harry? He's an 11 year old boy when starting at Hogwarts, it's not that far fetched that he would be moulded by his environment. Despite a bumpy start with Malfoy, I do believe in such a timeline Harry would befriend him rather than Ron and Hermione. Alternatively some other Slytherin-students and then square up with Malfoy later.
I do think you present an interesting version on how Voldemort comes back here, and I do agree that he would still want to kill Harry out of spite/revenge. However, as you said, he would not need to do so in order to come back. Also, in this version, Voldemort would not be immune to Harry's touch any more (he didn't use Harry's blood to resurrect) so he might want to be careful with confronting him.
I'm imagining Harry being allowed to grow up thinking he will become a powerful wizard (maybe he'l be more ambitious rather than straight up evil, and cracks in his friendship with Malfoy would show over the years as their different values comes to the surface.) I think however that Voldemort would put up a facade of wanting to recruit Harry and turn him to the dark side, while secretly planning to kill him. In this version, slytherine-Harry might see himself more as a rival to Voldemort, aspiring to take his place rather than stop him.
I still think that Harry would be friends with Ron, despite not being in the same house they have a lot of the same classes with one another
@@soo1579 How would they get to know each other? When would they have any reason to talk to each other? Its like Harry and Malfoy in the original timeline suddenly deciding to give each other a second chance and have a normal conversation together, and start becoming friends at some point. They already decided that they are enemies, and are surrounded by people who are convinced Slytherin and Gryffindor are enemies. Even if Harry and Ron in this alternate timeline secretly thought that the other one seemed like a nice guy and they wanted to get to know each other better, there is this thing called peer pressure. Harry might be resistant to it, but Ron, particularly without Harry's influence, doesn't seem like the person who would stand against peer pressure. Particularly not for a Slytherin
Might I remind you that in this *What If* version of events, Quirrelmort would not have encountered Harry in front of the mirror hiding the Philosopher's stone at the end of first year.
No fighting going on, therefore he hasn't experienced that Harry's mere touch can burn him like fire.
But, during first year Quirrelmort has certainly kept an eye on Harry, watching and observing. He must be surprised and intrigued by this child, his supposedly prophesied mortal enemy, who does not act at all as expected. Everyone including Snape and Quirrelmort expected the Boy Who Lived to have grown up in the lap of luxury, coddled and spoiled rotten, to be instantly sorted into Gryffindor. To bask in his fame. To strut around the castle full of arrogance and entitlement, with an entourage of Gryffindor friends and admirers, just like his father James did.
I believe that Quirrelmort and Snape both will be rattled enough by this unexpected turn of events to really look at Harry, to notice all the little things they overlooked in canon because they were both so blinded by their own preconceived notions of who and what this blasted !Potter! boy is.
And if they look closely, if they pay attention to how the boy moves, talks, eats, dresses, writes, acts in class and outside of class, keeps his distance to people, wary and distrustful, they might notice that something is definitely wrong.
Both Snape and Tom Riddle grew up in harsh conditions, in abusive situations in the Muggle world. They will recognise the signs.
Snape might care, because Harry is Lily's child too. Or he might be indifferent, or think it great karma, that James Potter's son has suffered through an abusive childhood with Muggles for ten long years.
But Voldemort wouldn't just watch from afar, he'd take advantage of the situation if at all possible without raising suspicion. Facilitate friendly talks with Harry after class in his office, (we know diary!Tom is excellent at pretending to care, of lending a kindly ear to a first year student's woes) possibly recommend some books to read and offer extra tutoring to bring him up to speed with his wizard raised pureblood and half-blood Slytherin House mates.
And he might discover pretty soon that Harry is feeling physical pain in his scar in his proximity, and that he's a parselmouth. What? How can Potter speak!? Now that would change everything, if Voldemort realised early on what exactly Harry is!
It shouldn't be very difficult to turn Harry against Dumbledore and the light side, who abandoned him all alone on the Dursleys doorstep 10 years ago, forgotten until they deemed the time right to retrieve him and parade him around again in front of the masses.
Harry would jump at any chance to go somewhere else during the summer, to not have to return to Little Whining.
@@Uberdude6666 I agree. Canon Ron is extremely biased and prejudiced against Slytherin students in general and the Malfoy family in particular. He'd see Harry's sorting into Slytherin as a 'betrayal', a sign that 'Harry Potter is going dark'. He wouldn't want to be friends with such a cowardly slimly snake... And the peer pressure is certainly an important factor.
@@CM.825 Cool add-ons. If Quirrel doesn't fight Harry at the end of year 1, there is no reason why he should be replaced as DADA-teacher the next year. Also since quirrel has voldemort sticking out from the back of his head, it make sense that he would not be affected by the "curse" on the job. We might see a totally diffetent dynamic, where Quirrel takes on a sort of mentor role over the years instead of Dumbledore. Ofc Dumbledore might get suspicious of the only dada-teacher since voldemort's job interview to last more than a year. And Snape was already suspicious of Quirrel.
Speaking of Snape, as he is now Harry's head of house, I believe he would be less inclined to bully him openly in class, especially if he is friends with Snape's favourite golden egg; Malfoy. I believe Snape would be influenced to see more of Lily in Harry (particularly if he sees his good sides and not just him breaking rules and messing around in class) He might take the perspective that the potter-boy can turn out all right after all, and take it upon himself to tutor Harry towards that.
I smell a sort of power struggle between Snape and Quirrel over Harry😂 at least until Quirrel is exposed. Maybe in year 4, Quirrel is able to ressurect voldemort per their original plan (quirrel taking on a sort of Wormtail-role after maybe? Since he is like a coward at heart?) Either way his time at hogwarts is over and the story takes a drastic turn as in the original timeline. Maybe its too late and voldemort has already "turned" harry. Year 5 and 6 is then Harry and Malfoy working together for voldemort, and harry helping out with the vanishing cabinet-plot in year 6
What if Neville got what he wanted and became a Hufflepuff?
great question
And why was not Hermonie placed in Ravenclaw, that would have made very much sense too if she was.
Then he would of been a nobody.
Ron in Slytherin
Hermione in Ravenclaw
Harry in Gryffindor
Neville in Hufflepuff
That would make more sense
@@Michijoy ok interesting
If Harry was in Slytherin Then Snape would have expelled him for the flying ford thingy.
This is a good point, but I rebuttal with: would Ron have been close enough friends with Harry for him to stay at his place and fly in the car together?
Snape cannot expel Harry because if he did then Harry would loose protection at Hogwarts.
@@klaudiagrob he would still have protection at his aunt and uncles
Alex Campili but his uncle and aunt abuse him, so Hogwarts was Harry first place he made first
@@slug.gggyyyyyyy I thought they were more talking about protection from Voldemort, rather than the place he enjoyed, was going with the fact he still had the Fidelius charm at privit drive
What would they use to destroy horcruxes if Harry never went to the Chamber of Secrets?
Not to mention the sword only presents itself to gryffindor students apparently
@@bartbouwmeister1784 not it presents to those who ask for it help or deserve it help
@@thefanshipper4604 i thought only a true gryffindor can use it? I may be wrong but that's what i thought
@Smash yeah only a true gryffindor and those who are in need and deserves its help
@@bartbouwmeister1784 yea but it never absorbed the basilisk's venom... So it won't be able to destroy the horcruxes
actually harry would not even know that Sirius is his godfather or he killed his parents because he could not get into hosmade
He would probably sneak in.
What's hosmade?
@@klaudiagrob sorry wrong spelling
Just me yes
You got a point🧐
Well, then Harry would have spent 7 years being mercilessly bullied by Slytherins because every single member of that house in the books is just a Death Eater in training apparently.
Video: "What If Harry Potter Was Sorted Into Slytherin?"
Me: "Drarry"
YES QUEEN
Yesss for sure!
istg we would have more Drarry scenes and i LIVE OFF OF DRARRY SKS+PO@EWUFOIWEHF)IWBQEJFKL
No
@@mayaperez381 what- why?
Would Ron actually like Hermione just because they shared classes? He didn't liked her arrogance and style anyway in the first to second year. Harry was the main reason they stuck together. I think Ginny would be the first friend for her and then Ginny introduced her to Ron. Also... If Ron would be friends with a slytherin, how would his brothers react.
But yeah... Nice video.
Yesica Licht that’s a good point, I think Harry keeps them together, but I think Ron would still have initially teased Hermione and heard that she was crying in the bathroom. Not sure if he’d go alone, but maybe if he had Dean and Seamus with him he would. He would be able to save her from the troll, which originally brought the trio together. I don’t think he and Hermione would be as close in first year, but maybe they’d be acquaintances or she’d join a group with Dean Seamus and Ron
Yesica Licht that’s more so in the movies than books Ron feels sympathy for Hermione because she’s an outsider no one likes her much he’s always stuck up for her that’s why they end up together not harry and her
Short story Harry is suspended for speaking to snakes and people think he is the heir and that is a big plot twist
This just makes you appreciate how the books / movies actually played out
Movies were trash. Chamberpot of fire, Order of the Chicken and Halfwit prince removed Dobby and Winky and that was unnacceptable.
@@shinigamiphantom1391 you are trash
@youtube watcher the thing that annoys me is the part where Malfoy steps on Harry's nose in the Hogwarts express, in the book Tonks finds him and fixes his nose, but in the movie Luna did
@@noonecares18 ...THATS the thing that annoys you? Its one little minor change, there's so many other things, and thats the thing you pick?
im sure other plot lines can play out. like maybe harry doesnt go with ron/hermione and find some Slytherin friends who support him as the new dark lord
I do agree with most of this but I have thoughts on the idea that Harry would still have supporters in book seven among the children of death eaters even if for the wrong reasons. By this time Harry has already become friends with a “mud blood” and a muggle sympathizer so I have a hard time believing any of them would still see Harry as a direct replacement for Voldemort especially since the later is actually there again and by this time Harry’s true nature and alignment have been revealed in the ways that he’s stood against Umbridge, stood up for Dumbledore, fought the death eaters at the ministry, and befriended people who are directly against the interests of the death eaters. I think about the time he really became friends with Hermione he would start getting seriously bullied and hated upon by all of his housemates.
If Harry was sorted in Slytherin, it would had been easier for him to slider in the chamber of secrets...
I feel like Harry would still be friends with Ron. He knows how to tell the right sort for himself, after all.
This sounds like a better timeline for the characters, but not for interesting stories.
Something that seems wrong with Harry, concerning how he would be after living with in the Dursley household and all of the abuse.
I can't see how he would be happy or even nice to anyone. He would be angry and wouldn't let anyone get close.
This another is another possible what if video.
people deal with this kind of emotion differntly i had been abused and treated hoorably i chose to make it a drife to promise my self i would never make someone fell the way i felt plus make me apprcaita when people being nice and thoughtfull also it make me always stand for people cuz i would love if someone stand for me
sorry for my english i'm learning and writing comments is part of my practise plz corect me
Sounds like he'd end up just like voldemort.
@@tima.r8925 imagine if harry joined him
@@xenorogue8447 I think he would have been like all the other death eaters. Unless he was to turn on voldemort then his story would be similar to regulus black's
Abuse victims handle things differently depending on the person. There are many ways a child might try to cope with it or how they'd turn out, but I'd think instead of angry, Harry would be more like Neville. Unsure of himself and a bit clumsy due to constantly being treated like nothing at home. He'd also be either more distrustful of people's intentions, or too eager to conform in order to gain the approval he lacks at home.
In that case I'd think Hufflepuff, with it's bright demeanor, would make a better house for him. Since Harry was never an academic (so not Ravenclaw) and both Gryffindor and Slytherin students would be too eager to influence him down a certain path.
Sorry for the blather. Character stuff like this is just my cup of tea. :)
Actually if harry had been sorted into Slytherin, Hermione might have died to the troll
Probably not because Ron was chatting with Harry about her attitude in Charms.
@@Nalothisal but in this video they clearly stated that after being soldering in the Slytherin Harry's and Ron's relationship took a hit and they barely talk for the rest of the year so he wouldn't have been talking to Ron and order it no Hermione ran into the bathroom or whatever so yes she most likely would have died
Yes, the troll would have most likely seriously injured or killed her, because nobody would have cared to search for Hermione.
After all in book canon the only person even noticing and caring that Granger is not present in the Great Hall in this moment when people are panicking about the troll is Harry!
For - reasons.
As a Slytherin student - or alternatively, if he'd been sorted into Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw - Harry would not have had any reason to think much about Granger. He would hardly have known her.
She doesn't have any friends at this point in time.
What Ron said earlier on this day was insensitive, but true.
People don't call her Hermione, they refer to this Muggleborn girl only as Granger.
She was extremely unpopular amongst the student body and the teachers for her obnoxious, attention seeking attitude , she was barely tolerated inside her own house!
Percy Weasley didn't even make a head count and ask the group of first year Gryffindor girls and boys where their missing year mate was, although he as the fifth year Prefect was actually responsible for looking after them!
@@CM.825 But she wouldn’t even have been in the restroom. Wasn’t she was only in the restroom crying because of Ron and Harry talking about her?
@@rubielopez952 well, yes and no. Ron was angry and exasperated because Hermione Granger kept pointing out his flaws, always correcting his pronunciation. Le vi OH sah, not levio SAH!
If you look at this scene, and remove Harry, because he's been sorted into ANY other House - regardless if Harry was a Slytherin or Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw, he would NOT sit next to Weasley or Granger, he wouldn't talk to Weasley or Granger, because he would sit with his own house mates, he'd try to fit in with the other boys, his dorm mates, just the same way canon Harry does, because he's desperate to belong somewhere, to stay at Hogwarts, to not be kicked out and sent back to the loathsome Dursleys, you still have the same situation regarding our dear Miss Granger!
Since starting at Hogwarts, this eleven year old Muggleborn girl is behaving in a way that doesn't earn her any friends at all. She's an attention seeking teachers pet, a know-it-all, believing in authority figures and the school rules, desperate to prove she's just as much a Witch as all the other first year girls, who are either coming from a half-blood family or some pureblood family.
Hermione doesn't get on with any of her dorm mates, (Lavender Brown, Parvati Patil, very probably Sally Ann Perks and another girl like Fay Dunbar not mentioned in the books but who is on the students list JKR used for planning, please read the essay "The Secrets Of The Class List" on the online HP lexicon dot org) she hasn't managed to connect to any other Gryffindor (or Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff) students - girls or boys - so far at this point in time. At least we never read a word about it in the book, because the reader sees everything through Harry's biased, naïve eyes!
Muggleborn / Mudbloods are a minority group amongst all the Hogwarts students. Only the Light side wizards (Dumbledore's followers) don't hate them on sight. It's considered being 'modern, progressive', to be welcoming to Muggleborn students in general.
But that doesn't mean that the other students and teachers like everyone coming new into the wizarding world.
The neutral party families tolerate the Muggleborn students more or less, the dark sect families despise, loathe, hate them on sight.
In every school, everywhere, Muggle or Magical, such students like Hermione Granger with her attention seeking ways, her righteous goody-two-shoes, Know-it-all attitude, are despised by the student body.
Professor Snape treats her harshly, tells her to stop it, to sit down, for a good reason.
(only canon Harry doesn't get it, obviously, he just sees unfairness).
Granger tries to be a teacher's pet, always waiving her hand into the air to get the teacher's attention, and often blurting out answers and full out quotes from text books without being called on to speak, thereby preventing and hindering other, slower students to find the answer and to think for themselves. Maybe in her previous Muggle primary school such behaviour was tolerated, but most teachers don't want to see this behaviour in a secondary school like Hogwarts.
Hermione Granger would behave exactly the same like she does in book canon, or in the 1. film, getting on other people's nerves, alienating her class mates more and more, every day. It doesn't depend on Harry Potter being a fellow Gryffindor at all.
In this Charms lesson on 31. October 1991, Samhain or Halloween, like the Muggles call this day, she tries to "help" the students seated on her left or right side, although nobody wants her help.
Either Ron articulates what he thinks of her, Know-it-all, etc. out in the corridor or another student criticizes her. It doesn't matter. She's heard this all her life, she's sad, upset, can't understand why nobody likes her, why all her attempts to make friends fail.
Miss Granger hurries away to cry in the girls bathroom. Stays there for several hours.
The troll finds her. She freezes in panic, instead of fighting or ducking and trying to run away. He swings his club, reduces the toilet stalls to rubble. Granger dead. Either at once, or after becoming a quick troll snack.
End of story.
Nobody noticed in canon that HG was missing in the Great Hall, besides HP.
Or rather, some of the other girls did notice that HG was inside that toilet stall sobbing her heart out and bemoaning her fate, but they didn't do anything about it. Maybe they smirked in glee, gossiping about stupid, arrogant Know-it-all Mudblood Granger, but they certainly didn't tell a teacher or prefect like Percy Weasley.
(Besides the heroic too good to be true HP, because honestly, which real world eleven year old boy would care for such a girl he barely knew in such a situation of chaos, inmidst a crowd of panicking children, if she wasn't his sister?)
Nobody cares, nobody comes to her rescue in this scenario.
Neither Professor McGonagall (after all, she is Head of House Gryffindor and Deputy Headmistress, an adult who should know better!)
or Percy Weasley or another Gryffindor prefect did a head count in book canon, noticed that one first year student, or several students, were missing, like they should have.
I feel like in year 2 when Ron and hermione confront Harry he would draw his wand because draco would slowly put anti-muggleborn ideas in his head by order of his father
As a Slytherin this is the kind of content I signed up for!! 🐍🐍🐍💚💚💚
Topic: What if Ron was the main character in the series?
there will be more "Bloody Hell" and "Are you mad?" 's in the series
Ron weasley and the philosofers stone
I wouldn't mind
Hes actually one of the maim charchter
@@renadmalfoy6663 THE main character not A main character
What if the trio and Draco's houses are changed (Harry = Slitherin, Ron = Hufflepuff, Hermione = Ravenclaw, Draco = Gryffindor) and they are all friends?
I think if Harry = Gryffindor, Ron= Hufflepuff, Hermione = Ravenclaw & Draco = Slytherin would be suited nicely for them.
What? No
Hermione does have many Ravenclaw characteristics, but it’s shown on the movies/books that she finds bravery more important than intelligence. Being sorted into a house is not just having the house’s traits, you also need to value its characteristics.
For example, Harry, who had many Slytherin characteristics, but he was more interested on being brave, so BOOM, Gryffindor.
Yeah i thought the same. But maybe replace draco with neville
Can see it now instead of that dramatic pause when snape says " people might get the feeling you were ... up...to something" ( I feel I've butchered that quote😂) when he gets taken to snape and suggests him as there new seeker snape replies " maybe you being a slytherin mr potter wont be a (catches harry scowling at him) ...complete disaster after all"
I can hear Alan Rickman talking in my head. Thank u.
@@oskar5709 same!!!!😅
If Harry had been destined for Slytherin in this alternate universe, maybe he never refused Draco's friendship. He may have become a powerful and successful Slytherin, possibly even more focused on his studies. He may have been more aligned with Snape, and even mentored by him directly. It could be that he eventually fought Voldemort, possibly even refusing him, and due to not having the close relationships and support he had in Gryffindor, that he could not ultimately defeat Voldemort. If he did defeat Voldemort, Harry might choose to become some sort of powerful leader of his own. That's just what I would imagine. I also have Luna saving Buckbeak, with the help of Hermoine, and the two of them heroically riding him into the sunset.
He may have been a Sylytherin version of Cedric Diggory, so he was still possibly even dating Cho at some point. He may not ever have dated Ginny, and actually marries Cho. He might have still been entered into the cup against Diggory, if so.
i think had harry been sorted into slytherin house i feel like he'd make it his personal mission not to turn out like every evil witch or wizard, and show you can be friends with other houses.....imagine if harry was the heir of slytherin and controlled the snake ordering it never to attack another muggle-born student
The other houses would look at harry and say this boy is the heir of slytherin yet he hasn't attacked anyone why? or something like that which shows Harry's determination to not only redeem slytherin house and show that he's nothing like Salaazar Slytherin or voldemort
Could Harry have started the DA without having trained for the triwizard tournament? Thats where he learnt a lot of his spells.
Can you do the same with Hermione but she is a Ravenclaw instead! Brilliant video btw!
He made one a long time ago already
He did actually
What if harry took dracos hand I think this would be very interesting since the story would change A LOT 💙
Then he would have died in many situations. Hermione saved Harry and Ron's life MANY of time. Also Draco would be in danger and so would be his other friends.
10:36
Actually Harry did not see Wormtail on the map in the books
UA-cam Life really? (I haven't read the fourth book in a long time)
@@amaranthexe5132 it's the third book but yeah
@@amaranthexe5132 fAke fAn its the third book
yeah, Lupin saw it.
@@Le-nl4nb It does not mean she's a fake fan. You don't have to memorize all details in every book to be a fan.
One issue for the Battle of Hogwarts...a Danger Noodle with Evil Eye is a card on table for Mr No Nose. Aka Basilisk in Chamber of secrets.
😂
i like how we're making theories about this completely unreal story.
Yeah. This would not have happened anyway because the author would have obviously changed a few things. No way they could keep everything the same but Harry would be in a different house. It would make no sense.
Damn, Harry be usin’ those Snapchat filters like crazy in the thumbnail.
i don't think the hat would have disregarded harrys wishes.
what would have more likely lead to this scenario would be hagrid never bringing up the houses to harry so harry just goes in with an open mind.
i would also believe that snape would taken great interest in harrys development, but even if he didn't, he wouldn't have hurt slytherin as a whole just to pick on him, thus i believe that harry would have trusted snape in a way similar to how he trusted minerva.
i also disagree with your interpretation of book 2, quirrel likely would not have attended another year since dumbledore would have caught him red handed, trying to get the stone, as voldemort himself only escaped because harry got there first, thus a duel between dumbledore and quirrelmort would have occurred, leaving quirrel dead and voldemort weakened once again, left to lick his wounds.
coming book 2, lucy still would have tried to give the diary to ginny, the chamber is opened and the basilisk does what he does, harry hears voices coming from the walls, but now ron isn't around to tell him that hearing voices is bad, so harry opens up about it to the only person he trusts, who, in this scenario, is snape.
sanpe and dumbledore, with the information now available to them, figure out that a basilisk is involved, they need harrys help to enter the chamber, but forbid him from coming along, harry does so anyway and this becomes important at the second door, at the same time ron convinces lockheart to hunt down the basilisk after finding the note on hermione, his dilemma plays out like normal as they arrive after the others. young tom riddle and the basilisk are no match for dumbledore and snape, with snape fighting tom and dumbledore fending off the basilisk together with fawks.
book 3 plays out just as it did except for harry not being allowed in hogsmede and also never getting there because he doesn't have the marauders map, so he never learns that sirius is the prime suspect in the potter case, he just think sirius is coming for him for being a death eater.
this is probably also the year where harrys friendship with ron and hermione really starts as harry is still friends with hagrid ever since the start of book one, so malfoy being a dick to hagrid is going to piss harry off and he would likely ask to join ron and hermione in their efforts to save buckbeak.
in this year sirius also attacks ron in his bed, prompting fred and george to give the marauders map to ron as they believe him to be in danger.
since ron now has the map, he starts roaming the corridors at night but, because he does not have an invisibility cloak, gets caught by snape, who gives the map to lupin as he did in the books.
now, because ron and hermione can not sneak out without the cloak or the map, the fights in the shrieking shack play out without harry, ron and hermione, lupin and sirius confront petigrew, snape shows up to arrest sirius, but he has no invisibility cloak in this scenario so sirius and lupin can best him together, petigrew escapes, sirius blasts a hole into the wall and tries to chase him in dog form but looses him while lupin stays in the shrieking shack until snape awakens, calms him down and drinks his wolf medicine.
later lupin tells harry the whole truth and gives harry the marauders map and provides a note from sirius that allows him to visit hogsmede, buckbeak is still killed in this scenario.
book 4 happens pretty much as in the book as harry and ron are now friends, they go to the quidditch cup together, death eaters happen yadayadayada, harry becomes champion of hogwarts, snape, being competent in legilimency, can tell that harry was not at fault here and instantly knows that something's up so he takes to personally teaching harry roughly the same spells harry studied with ron and hermione over the year, ced dies, voldie comes back, enter book 5
book 5 also happens roughly as in the book, except for when harry is sent to attend occlumency with snape, now since harry does trust snape in this scenario, harry might actually succeed in this, voldemorts plan to steal the prophecy fails and, instead the battle in the ministry is handled entirely by the order of the phoenix voldemort shows up personally since only he can retrieve the prophecy, but is driven off by dumbledore, sirius probably still dies dueling bellatrix in this scenario, but harry doesn't witness it.
He still would have talk about it with Draco and Ron, so his opinion would still be biaised
I really enjoyed reading that. Thank you for voicing your opinion on it.
Sorry didnt understand one bit, why would Sirius attack Ron in his bed? And would Harry still be in the tri-wizard tournament?
Snape was nice to Draco because he’s dad was a prefect when he was sorted to Slytherin with open arms and treated him like a friend
Harry never saw Peter pettigrew on the map in the books. Doesn't make a difference since lupin wouldn't have seen him on the map since he wouldn't have got it anyway, but still important to point out
They wouldn’t have Cedric as a teacher because he would’ve graduated by then
Cedric would probably just apparate'd himself onto the back gate and sneaked in
cedric was a sixth year in goblet of fire so of course he would be in order of the phoenix as a seventh year
I really think we should’ve been given more “good” students from Slytherin. Also, just having more prominent characters from each house would’ve been neat.
We need to thank Ron for Harry being in Gryffindor!!!
Or in the books, Hagrid.
Or maybe Draco...
@@eridejj naw. without Ron, I assume Harry would have taken Draco's hand and they would have become friends. This could have been a very different story where Draco goes against Voldemort because of his freindship to Harry.
From the perspective of a Drarry fanfic writer:
1st year: Harry and Draco make up and become friends. He still finds a way to bond with Ron and Hermione though and most plot remains the same.
2nd year: Harry and Draco fight when the chamber of secrets is opened. Harry has never liked Draco's obsession with blood purity. Their fight leads Draco to change a little and offer to help find the chamber with Harry, Ron and Hermione. Plot commences normally.
4th year: Draco and Harry start to realise they have feelings stronger than friendship for one another as he helps Harry figure out the challenges of the Triwizard Tournament but they have some internal struggle over accepting their own feelings.
5th year: They confess and get together.
6th year: Draco is loyal to Harry and refuses to become a death eater (as he realises the dark lord wants to kill Harry). He runs away from home.
7th year: Draco is not on the dark side and works together with Harry against the dark lord and his parents, although it is incredibly difficult and he suffers. In the end, he is reunited with his parents who accept him for who he is, the dark lord is defeated and they live happily ever after.
Also, who needs plot when the genre has done a complete 180?
what about the 3 year lol?
So Harry and Draco become gay?
Dude wtf
I can finally be friends with Pottah.
As you said Harry would have started his own DADA class but Cedric wouldn't be there because according to the 4th book he was in 7th year.
So how come he would be a member of that class??
He probably had to redo year 7 because he certainly couldn't pass his UTZ's while doing the goblet of fire thing XD
But good point, if it wasn't the case, how would he be there and why?🤔
He Was In His 6th said by J.K.R
What if Cedric survived and returned back to School with Harry.
It wouldn't change much but there'd be one more person to tell everyone Voldemort was back, so there'd be more proof. And he would still be Cho's boyfriend so Harry never got together with her.
isnt thbat like the whole premise of the cursed child
Cedric would be a vampire wizard
@@troytakahashi1402 Vampire Wizard Vigilante
@@troytakahashi1402 lol
I think in the beginning when Harry is chosen as a Slytherin, Draco would give Harry a warm welcome gift and more gifts to come bringing friendship more closer.
I think of that because Draco is Pure Blood, and the family are usually rich.
Can uou talk about every wand core like ALL of them
Basilisk horn
And the american wand cores.
I DO STUF F Basilisks don’t have hornd.
@@avianbuilds4420 i thought so too but Salazar Slytherin have a Basilisk horn as his wand's core so it's weird
"horn"
I think it would Cedric who founded the DA and it would be a very different organisation
Cedric would found the DA. ZHarry would have joined as his second. Feeling alone he would betray his house and act as a spy for the DA. Harry would also fall in love with Jinny much sooner as he marveled at her magic skills.
The only real problem I have with you version is that harry didn't make any slytherin friends the first year. He was desperate for friendship that is why he defended ron when draco insulted him since he was harry's first friend. Growing up he was alienated in school by his bully cousin and his gang so he didn't have any friends from school and he was required to to straight home after school which didn't allow him to make any other friends. Ron & his family were the only people who were genuinely nice to harry except for Hagrid up until that point in his life that he could remember. So Harry would have definitely gained a group of slytherin friends that first year. If harry played quiddich it wouldn't have been until his 2nd year since they already had a seeker.
what if Ron was sorted into Hufflepuff?
"Ahh, another Weasley! I know where to put you. HUFFLEPUFF."
hey try doing a what if dudly was a wizard just like this video all 7 books
redakai1 Yeah, I want that too.
He did I think
wonder if any of his kids were wizards...
Great video, however there's a massive oversight. Not only would Hermine not be friends with Harry or Ron, but in all likely hood, the troll would have killed her back in book one. It was Harry who remembered Hermine was absent when the warning of the troll came
If Quirrell stays on as DADA teacher in the 1992-1993 school year, what would happen with Gilderoy Lockhart? Would he still be Obliviating famous wizards? Would he help defeat Voldemort?
Alex Downs no DADA professor lasted for more that a year.
Hey
There is this one thing
Diary was in possession of Lucius Malfoy who intentially put diary in Ginny's cauldron so how would Quirrel obtain the diary?
Also at one point Harry obtains it but he doesn't wanted to dispose it like Ginny so it seems quite impossible for Quirrel to get the diary.
You're forgetting one major detail. Harry and Ron's friendship started all the way back at Kings cross platform 9 3/4, aboard the Hogwarts express with Harry being both impressed and curious about Ron, and his family. They spent a significant amount of time together on the train to Hogwarts, being all the way north toward Scotland I do not for a second believe that Ron or Harry would ditch each other the moment they were separated in different houses. Their friendship might've become more difficult as Harry had to sneak around to keep in contact with Ron, the kind hearted Harry would be just as persistent to not adhere to the Slytherin house traditions as he was in the real books.
that's why i think harry potter would be the perfect poster boy for the Boy who lived that was sorted into slytherin house who treated everyone as an equal no matter what house they were in no matter their status half-blood or pure-bloods.............I think it would be Harry's personal mission to redeem slytherin house into a modest kind house hold
slytherin students may look at harry and say this boy made it his mission to show the rest of the school you can be sorted into slytherin house and not turn out evil thus turning a new leaf for slytherins house, You can be sorted into slytherin house and not turn out to be evil
imagine how the other houses may think they may have a different view on slytherin thanks to harry and who knows they can actually be a school and have a friendly rivalry
I want a Slytherin AU where Harry and Draco end up being friends as they realize they can learn to tolerate themselves, then they see how much they have in common. This would make Draco very conflicted when his father wants him to become a Death eater.
@dr103 Then he feels even worse, having to choose between his family and his friends.
I've always wondered why Voldemorts soul fragment in HP didn't influence his skill level or ability to pick up new spells
James K. Good I think it’s because Harry was the 6th horcrux Voldemort made, it‘s only 1/64 piece of soul in Harry. If my math is right, that’s a rather small piece. Also maybe it even had a little influence... we don’t really know how he would have done at school without that piece of Voldemort 😅
James K. Good or what about Voldemort’s original looks
@@maxi1968 how you came to 1/64?
I think we don't konw how big the part of the soul in a horcurx is. We konw killg people rips the soul. But Voldemort killed hundrets. And when he made the first horcurx he has killed 3 People. So was the first part 1/3 of Voldemorts soul?
And I don't think if you kill only one person and make a horcurx the halfe soul would go into the horcrux.
@@lostcinema5189 You split your soul for a horcrux. A split is 1/2. Each horcrux is 1/2 of the remaining soul. Doesn't matter how he makes it, the soul splits off.
@@inkvampyr so let's see :
Diary: 1/2
Ring: 1/4
Hufflepuff's Goblet: 1/8
Slytherin's Locket: 1/16
Ravenclaw's Dieidem: 1/32
Harry: 1/64
Nagin 1/128
So does this mean Voldy himself still has 1/256 of his soul?
I like that you didn’t push us to SMASH that like button and to subscribe until the end of the video. Great content
This what if doesn't work. Voldmort has to take Harry's blood. It's the only way Harry can survive Voldemort killing the Horcrux in Harry. And the Horcrux has to be killed for Harry to kill Voldemort.