Is potassium more important than sodium?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 143

  • @JYAN2852
    @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +68

    Most potassium and magnesium are in the cells. Serum tests for these are almost always normal. Hypertension is usually due to potassium and/or magnesium deficiencies. Not to mention when people eat globs of carbs, potassium gets sucked out of cells to create glycogen. Potassium is needed to link long chains of glucose. Do not lower salt/sodium. Increase potassium and magnesium instead

    • @goddesstc
      @goddesstc 2 роки тому +5

      100%!

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому +9

      Exactly. You would think doctors would know this.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +13

      @@JimWooddell I have come to understand that without their presription pad most doctors are ueseless. For chronic and preventative illnesses anyway

    • @guitaristbeginner1224
      @guitaristbeginner1224 2 роки тому +1

      Hi, is 400 mg magnesium supplement safe?

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +4

      @@guitaristbeginner1224 It varies from person to person. Keep in mind that supplements are chelated or bound to other molecules for absorption purposes. Focus on "elemental" amount of magnesium. Dr Carolyn Dean has many good videos explaining magnesium

  • @oldschoolprepper2273
    @oldschoolprepper2273 2 роки тому +29

    If you’re a carb burner you hold on to salt and
    if you are a fat burner you shed salt and need more

    • @davidrodgers4760
      @davidrodgers4760 2 роки тому

      Nonsense read The Bear owsley.salt is crap as,are supplements

    • @mmabagain
      @mmabagain Рік тому +3

      @@davidrodgers4760 Nonsense.

  • @JimWooddell
    @JimWooddell 2 роки тому +18

    Finally! Someone talking about this!!!! I was salt sensitive. My blood pressure easily spiked. Blood tests showed normal potassium levels. However, I knew electrolytes are very tightly regulated in the body and blood testing was missing the issue. I increased my potassium intake and I am no longer salt sensitive and my BP is down and stable. In the natural world of a carnivore, potassium to sodium ratio is not equal and can be as high as a 4 to 1 ratio....4 parts potassium to 1 part salt. This is fact, not opinion. Look at any meat and you will see at least a 2 to 1 ratio.
    So... Why do electrolyte supplements have it backwards???? The way our body works is we need more potassium than salt. This is also a scientific fact in the way potassium and salt work together in the body. There are only a few electrolyte manufacturers that have a proper human intake ratio. And those pushing the sale of electrolytes to the carnivore communities will not talk about it. I firmly believe based on my own experience if potassium store are low in the body, even though blood tests say it is okay, is when people begin to have pressure issues. It goes very deep into the science on how the body uses, regulates potassium and where it gets it from. There are many UA-cam pages that clearly explain the potassium and salt relationship. Do we loose more salt than potassium? Did nature get it wrong? No one listens.

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому +1

      @Anthony Stewart Keep in mind how potassium and salt works in the body. The ratio in a cell is 2 parts potassium to 1 part salt. To add to this, even the RDA levels are about 2 to 1.

    • @davedelzell9614
      @davedelzell9614 2 роки тому

      @Anthony Stewart Quinn PC

    • @davidrodgers4760
      @davidrodgers4760 2 роки тому

      Agree.im carnivore. Don't like fatty ribeyes, or salt.

    • @candyalexander2196
      @candyalexander2196 2 роки тому +1

      Can u share what potassium u chose to take

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому +2

      @@candyalexander2196 Me? The wife and I started out on Potassium Gluconate and then migrated to Potassium Citrate. My wife said the Potassium Citrate bothered her gut. I also used No Salt which is Potassium Chloride and Potassium Bitartrate. I made my own pills with it at 640mg per pill. This was early on in my diet change to total carnivore. Now, I try not to take any electrolyte supplements and just use electrolyte drops in my water every morning and just salt my meat at least a couple hours before cooking it. I might take a couple potassium pills a week just because I worry about my stores in my body I think once your body adjusts to carnivore, there is not much need for electrolyte supplements but that is just my opinion. They mostly just empty your wallet!

  • @cfoster6804
    @cfoster6804 9 місяців тому +2

    He is so right. I stopped bp pills and told my cardiologist I want to make lifestyle changes instead. I changed my bad habits and got results but noticed that when I took my potassium prescription my BP and heart rate looked great. I'm now focused on getting it through diet and supplement. I see results quickly!

  • @thomashughes4859
    @thomashughes4859 2 роки тому +14

    I take a pinch of salt every morning, and I eat salt to taste. My BP is ~100/60. 💪😎👍💯♥️ I'm 55.

  • @zerocarbdoc
    @zerocarbdoc 2 роки тому +9

    Love when Bret commits and tells it straight.

  • @siriusfun
    @siriusfun 2 роки тому +5

    Redmond Real Salt - as much as I feel like - puts me right.

  • @ronbarber197
    @ronbarber197 2 роки тому +3

    Most people get from a box doctor don't have time to explain this so they make a blanket statement (no salt) it is 300 bucks for 15 min so they just don't have the time

  • @richardmiddleton7770
    @richardmiddleton7770 2 роки тому +3

    Also depends how much you workout and therefore sweat and also your sweat rate.

  • @pong4life
    @pong4life 2 роки тому +3

    Salt makes food tasty, and my blood pressure is great even with all the salt I take. Romans cometimes used salt as currency, which means they knew how important salt is.

  • @finagill
    @finagill 2 роки тому +3

    I know that since starting keto I need to take at least 7,000 mg of sodium a day. I take plenty of potassium as well.

  • @taginn790
    @taginn790 2 роки тому +12

    I avoid salt with anti-caking agents, such as yellow prussiate of soda, as those agents seem to cause edema for me, whereas pure salt does not. So if 'salt' causes edema for, maybe it's not the salt per se.

    • @AP-nx6xo
      @AP-nx6xo 2 роки тому

      Salt causes edema in my ankles I started k2. I’m hoping it’s not k2

  • @3cardmonty602
    @3cardmonty602 2 роки тому +1

    I get AFIB if I eat processed food that has high sodium, ie Canned Soup & Frozen Pizza. Real bad stuff. I found an organic Soybean Pasta that Aldi sells that supplies 1100mg of Potassium per serving. And it’s great tasting.

  • @andrewplus
    @andrewplus 2 роки тому +7

    Great info as always, appreciate this. Wondering what the best strategy for raising magnesium would be? What sources are most bio available? Seems like a lot of plant sources aren’t that bio available.

    • @DrAJ_LatinAmerica
      @DrAJ_LatinAmerica 2 роки тому +2

      And don't forget, with any food you never know the exact amount or lack or any micronutrient. Some foods are reported to have magnesium (just an example), but when tested in a lab, no magnesium was found, this can be a result of the area and ground / soil where grown, "hot house" grown verse outside in natural sun and water supply.... If low, best to supplement. A mix of L-Threonate, glycinate and Taurate very digestible/ bio available. Dosage varies greatly person to person based on many factors: age, race, activity levels, sleep patterns, lifestyle, goals, present health status, past history/ family history, present diet, food quality,.......

    • @drirene57
      @drirene57 2 роки тому +3

      Magnesium glycinate 100mg, 2 tabs about an hour before bedtime (helps sleep). Magnesium citrate as needed for constipation.

    • @lindass5966
      @lindass5966 2 роки тому

      @@drirene57 magnesium glycinate gave me shortness of breath.

    • @MaximoToro
      @MaximoToro 25 днів тому

      I came across a video at random of a guy using magnesium oil spray as a deodorant! No deodorant has ever worked on me! I would stink even not too long after a shower. I tried the magnesium oil spray and it worked amazingly well! I don't stink at all, whatsoever anymore. And it lasts all day. The best part? Apparently you can absorb magnesium through the skin, so my magnesium oil spray also now helps me get more magnesium into my system! It's been such a game changer for me

  • @protoword10
    @protoword10 2 роки тому +5

    WORNING! To all viewers, I used potassium salt, one avocado a day, than, when I visited my doctor for yearly check up, my eGFR drops from 120 to 65! I was scared for my kidneys and doctor told me: Stop taking so much potassium! I did it and my eGFR come back…

    • @alffree4985
      @alffree4985 2 роки тому

      eGFR ?..... Meaning what?
      Thanks.

    • @protoword10
      @protoword10 2 роки тому +1

      @@alffree4985 Filtering Rate for your kidneys. If is it below 60, your kidneys not works so well…

    • @alffree4985
      @alffree4985 2 роки тому

      @@protoword10 Thanks. What about the avocado? Did you eliminate from your daily intake?

    • @protoword10
      @protoword10 2 роки тому

      @@alffree4985 I didn’t, just shrink dawn on one half or quoter of it, depend on my meal, but I was carreful about other food containing potasium…

    • @ryanmozert
      @ryanmozert 11 місяців тому

      whats potassium salt

  • @pointshealthcoaching8474
    @pointshealthcoaching8474 2 роки тому +3

    Dr David Brownstein's book 'Salt you way to health'.... explains it well... + if your insulin is high it causes kidney to hold on to sodium and refined salt is always problematic....

  • @gwenj5419
    @gwenj5419 2 роки тому +7

    My husband has AFib and when he tried keto, his Afib incidents greatly increased (from once in 2months to 4 times in one month.) Could this be lack of potassium?

    • @gypsypath1
      @gypsypath1 2 роки тому

      That or magnesium, which I recently learned helps control the ability of potassium to get into cells. I get PVCs, so this is something I try to understand as well.

  • @karunamayiholisticinc
    @karunamayiholisticinc 2 роки тому +1

    I have been found low on sodium and potassium before. I know people who needed sodium injected because of being too low. But salt should be avoided in outside processed foods. I usually add enough salt in my food. But I have seen when others cook your food there is either days of literally no salt no taste and need to add more or other days when there is too much that it is poison to taste buds as well. When someone doesn't have to eat your food and cooking for others they will not know right quantity. There are many days i added extra Himalayan salt to my food when I start living with my mom because she doesn't have concept of how much to add. Even in her home made snacks I have to be strict with her so she doesn't ruin it.
    She is very careful not to overdo on those. But salt should be according to taste. The fact that people cooking for others will either add too much or too less, it is ideal to add a little less and let people add on top as they require.
    Because when you eat your rice and all you taste is salt it is nothing but poison to our taste buds also. You have to hate someone to give them such food. Not saying my mother hates me but definitely people are ignorant and don't want to listen. I am not against salt considering my blood pressure is usually very low mostly and I have been detected low on sodium before but I will not opt for refined salt any day except washing my mouth. I will eat Himalayan salt as much as I like and my tastebuds can handle.
    The problem with salt is when it I refined and added to processed foods. One eating whole foods of any kind can add salt upto their taste. I can't handle no salt food either. Many times I have added on top.
    Which is why I feel salt should be people's preference. Everyone's body tells them how much to eat and when to stop.
    The problem with MOST processed foods is that it is addictive and even if body tells us to stop mind does not want to.
    Whether it is processed bread from store or processed noodles.
    I do eat very small quantity of home made millet bread at times but I can never get addicted to it as i did when I used used eat market bread. It is not just not the same taste or even texture.
    Everything added in store makes a huge difference.
    Anyways salt is individual preference. I have to yell at my mom for both NO salt and too much salt because both are poison to me because my body needs certain things and it knows it which is why I think it is good to add little while cooking and let people add on to as to their taste.
    It is not salt it is how it is present in processed foods the problem.
    Our body is our best guide. When I ever eat a processed biscuit once in a while at all I end up throwing it too which is something people will not notice because our eyes tend to see what it wants to.
    Our body tells us that we need some salt, good fats whether from plants or animals but only whole food sources and not processed food sources whether plants or animals.
    If we listen we know what we need.

  • @rogerwilcojr
    @rogerwilcojr 2 роки тому +6

    I'd be interested in if the lower blood pressure associated with higher potassium intake is inversely associated with a higher pulse. I recall having read that a low sodium diet produces a higher heart beat that is overall worse for you than an elevated blood pressure.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +1

      Yes bc sodium is used by kidneys to regulate water in the blood. Low blood volume activates adrenals to make heart pump faster to get blood up to the brain

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому

      Not in my case.

    • @MaximoToro
      @MaximoToro 25 днів тому

      I saw another video on Sodium/Potassium ratios, and lost count of how many comments i saw where people got racing hearts after taking potassium supplements

  • @toni4729
    @toni4729 2 роки тому +2

    My only salt is sea salt and I use it in abundance. Being almost carnivore I find it a necessity.

  • @sifelaver
    @sifelaver 7 місяців тому

    take a look at any plain salted potato chip nutrition label. the sodium to potassium ratio is about 1:1!

  • @iang3728
    @iang3728 Рік тому

    Informative and cited videos are my jam ❤

  • @amyrevis9239
    @amyrevis9239 2 роки тому +1

    I have stage 3a kidney disease and have been told to keep sodium and potassium to 2,000 mg a day. Since I’ve been in keto I just wonder if I’m getting enough. I get leg and foot cramps at night. I’m taking some magnesium and it’s helping.

    • @ryanmozert
      @ryanmozert 11 місяців тому

      just eat a teaspoon of cream of tartar w/ spring water each mornin.
      in two weeks your kidney disease will evaporate into
      thin air.
      gone.
      forever!❤❤

  • @PistolPete3322
    @PistolPete3322 2 роки тому +2

    What potassium supplement should I take? How many mg's?

    • @ai.activezone
      @ai.activezone Рік тому

      when considering a potassium supplement, it's best to consult with a healthcare professional who can provide personalized advice based on your health needs. They can recommend the appropriate dosage and type of supplement based on your medical history and any potential interactions with other medications you might be taking

    • @PistolPete3322
      @PistolPete3322 Рік тому +2

      @@ai.activezone thanks but I won’t go to a doctor for nutritional advice. They still don’t recommend keto or low carb for type 2 diabetes. They’re a joke.

    • @ryanmozert
      @ryanmozert 11 місяців тому

      ​@@ai.activezonecream of tartar

  • @ut561
    @ut561 Рік тому

    good information I think but you bounced around so much it was hard to follow. For example we don't need to know "absence of proof is not proof of absence". what in the world does that mean? and do we really need to hear it?

  • @fredsmit3481
    @fredsmit3481 2 роки тому

    Did they measure serum potassium and how does the results affect the guidelines relating to potassium? I added potassium salt to my water, but measured high, outside the recommended serum potassium levels. My doctor told me to stop adding potassium salt to my water and my serum levels went back to normal.

  • @Merzui-kg8ds
    @Merzui-kg8ds 2 роки тому

    Answer: Morton Lite Salt...half sodium and half potassium. When I "salt" my food, I am using moderate salt (because what is sprinkling down is only half salt) and I am getting potassium.

  • @sherbear8097
    @sherbear8097 2 роки тому

    Ty great information

  • @vidviewer100
    @vidviewer100 2 роки тому

    Thanks again !

  • @CC-iq2pe
    @CC-iq2pe 2 роки тому +1

    Why do table salts not include potassium salts?

    • @philthompson1097
      @philthompson1097 2 роки тому +4

      "Lo Salt" is 50/50

    • @drirene57
      @drirene57 2 роки тому +2

      It doesn’t taste as good.

    • @ai.activezone
      @ai.activezone Рік тому

      Table salt primarily consists of sodium chloride (NaCl), which is the compound responsible for the salty taste. While potassium chloride can also be used as a salt substitute, it has a slightly bitter taste and might not provide the same flavor enhancement that sodium chloride does. Additionally, some individuals may need to limit their potassium intake due to specific medical conditions, so having a standard table salt without potassium chloride ensures that people can control their sodium and potassium intake separately. However, there are salt blends available that combine sodium chloride with potassium chloride for those looking to reduce sodium intake while increasing potassium intake. Always consult a healthcare professional before making significant changes to your diet.

  • @JimWooddell
    @JimWooddell 2 роки тому

    Salt is not normally a concern in the diet of Americans. We, as a whole, get plenty of sodium and chloride in our diets. This includes carnivores and ketovores. However, potassium in the American diet is generally found to be low, as a whole. That said, I question why people think they need supplements if they are eating a proper human diet??? I understand every body has different needs.

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому

      Morton salt adds dextrose to keep the added iodine from evaporating out.

  • @TheReader6
    @TheReader6 2 роки тому +1

    I have 10g of sodium per day. I have low blood pressure.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +1

      Are you getting in enough potassium and magnesium?

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +1

      Consider temporary high dose B1 benfotiamine. Elliot Overton EOnutrition channel has good vids explaining strange conditions that can be resolved using simply B1 and other cofactors

  • @sgeorg80
    @sgeorg80 2 роки тому +1

    👍

  • @ronbarber197
    @ronbarber197 2 роки тому +1

    What we do without plants hmmmm half the world it's to cold to grow plants year round wonder how we made it without avocados or other so called healthy plants the vegans would say well you didn't live as long and that was true but that had nothing to do with diet

  • @ronbarber197
    @ronbarber197 2 роки тому

    Only 3 salt sources in the world

    • @ai.activezone
      @ai.activezone Рік тому

      Three major salt resources in the world are the salt mines in Khewra, Pakistan; the Salar de Uyuni salt flat in Bolivia; and the Great Salt Lake in Utah, USA.

  • @ronbarber197
    @ronbarber197 2 роки тому

    Is this another epidemiology study???

  • @CarbageMan
    @CarbageMan 2 роки тому

    99mg potassium supplements are stupid. You need to take half a dozen at a time for those to be useful. I fill my own gelcaps.

    • @HappilyCarnivore
      @HappilyCarnivore 2 роки тому +2

      I buy potassium gluconate powder and add it to my water.

  • @MichaelLoweAttorney
    @MichaelLoweAttorney 2 роки тому +3

    Salt is overrated in the low carb world

    • @davidrodgers4760
      @davidrodgers4760 2 роки тому

      Agree.*SALT NOT NEEDED,AS IS PUSHING FATTY RIBEYE ON ZEROCARB CARNIVORE!

  • @georgeholman6745
    @georgeholman6745 2 роки тому +11

    End users need more science-based input on this topic. Oh, and an explanation of why the FDA limits Potassium supplements to 99mg and then tells you, 'You need 4700mg per day' (WTF?). The only food that will provide the average KETO individual with 4700mg of potassium/day are tubers, grains...etc. and/or electrolyte supplements (the food source is not KETO acceptable, and the electrolyte supplements are CRAZY expensive). My opinion is there is no way in Hell on a KETO diet that you can consume 4700mg of potasium!!!

    • @HappilyCarnivore
      @HappilyCarnivore 2 роки тому +2

      I don't seem to absorb potassium from vegetables at all. I was very deficient in potassium and had to start supplementing. I buy potassium gluconate powder and add it to my water. I get a little over 4700mg that way. I would have to take fist fulls of potassium pills to get that much. I was taking a bit more than that, but I switched to carnivore a year ago and was able to reduce the amount I used. I was hoping I could reduce it completely, but when I try and cut back further my symptoms come back.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +1

      Some ppl actually take too much potassium supps can create heart issues as a result that's why. I take electrolytes powder to get around the 99mg limit. But I try to get potass and magnesium thru foods first

    • @georgeholman6745
      @georgeholman6745 2 роки тому +2

      @@JYAN2852 I would love to get it thru food also, but I can't eat that much in a day... I would have to eat a half dozen whole potatoes to get even close to half the recommended FDA dose. Oh, and KETO folks don't eat potatoes - Catch-22.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +1

      @@georgeholman6745 4700mg is way too high based on personal anecdote. I am 5-8 medium build 160lbs eat mostly beef and maybe a cup of electrolytes 1000mg potass citrate (containing only about 300-400mg elemental potass). No energy issues and blood pressure is a perfect 110/60

    • @x.y.7385
      @x.y.7385 2 роки тому +1

      @@JYAN2852 what brand of electrolytes do you take?

  • @zamfirtoth6441
    @zamfirtoth6441 2 роки тому +9

    Not only are we warned to stay away from salt, but we are told to consume 8 or so glasses of water daily. I wonder how many of the folks that carry around a water bottle like it's an appendage end up with late day fatigue. I love RealSalt.

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +9

      Overhydration depletes sodium and other electrolytes. We keep getting horrible harmful advice.

    • @cfoster6804
      @cfoster6804 9 місяців тому

      ​@@JYAN2852Yep!

  • @BonjourCoco1
    @BonjourCoco1 2 роки тому +5

    I’ve started combining Redmonds salt with Losalt (which is high in potassium chloride) to ensure I get adequate potassium

  • @Johneseed
    @Johneseed 2 роки тому +2

    Listened to this and now even more confused as to go high, low, or just continue. Not very helpful!😖

    • @JYAN2852
      @JYAN2852 2 роки тому +2

      Dont worry about salt intake listen to your palate. Increase potassium and mangnesium instead thru foods or supplements. Electrolytes need a good balance for optimal bodily and cellular function

  • @Jack-hy1zq
    @Jack-hy1zq 2 роки тому +2

    I put a pinch of Himalayan salt in my tea 6-8 times per day. I also sprinkle my one meal a day with salt. My BP is 110/70!

  • @goddesstc
    @goddesstc 2 роки тому +2

    Yes, the standard american diet of processed food is high sodium and low potassium. Balance the two and no problem.

  • @DiarioCarnivoro
    @DiarioCarnivoro 2 роки тому +1

    Great video!

  • @DarthNoshitam
    @DarthNoshitam 2 роки тому +2

    Is meat really a "great potassium source"?

    • @godzilla4189
      @godzilla4189 2 роки тому +3

      Yes, actually. I actually looked it up, amd meat on average has more potassium then most vegetables aside from Leafy greens.

    • @taginn790
      @taginn790 2 роки тому +3

      16oz sirloin steak or 16oz pork chops is about 1500mg of potassium.

    • @DarthNoshitam
      @DarthNoshitam 2 роки тому +1

      @@godzilla4189 so meat is relatively a great potassium source, but is it also empirically a great potassium source?

    • @DarthNoshitam
      @DarthNoshitam 2 роки тому

      @@godzilla4189 wow that's pretty good!

    • @DrAJ_LatinAmerica
      @DrAJ_LatinAmerica 2 роки тому +2

      @@taginn790 maybe or maybe not. Depends on the animals and conditions it lived. Test in a lab, ten pieces, from ten different cows all raised in different conditions and results would vary greatly

  • @fsabbagh
    @fsabbagh 2 роки тому

    Would love to hear about your thoughts on Pro-Metabolic “diet”

  • @rashie
    @rashie 2 роки тому

    👍👍

  • @x.y.7385
    @x.y.7385 2 роки тому

    How do you tell if you are salt sensitive ?

    • @JimWooddell
      @JimWooddell 2 роки тому +1

      Blood pressure will spike more than normal when you ingest it.

    • @ai.activezone
      @ai.activezone Рік тому

      Salt sensitivity refers to an individual's susceptibility to changes in blood pressure due to variations in salt intake. You can determine if you are salt-sensitive by monitoring your blood pressure when you consume different levels of salt. If your blood pressure increases significantly when you consume high-sodium foods and decreases when you reduce sodium intake, you may be salt-sensitive. However, it's important to consult a healthcare professional for accurate assessment and advice.