What is impressive is how the case is designed to compact everything together in a way that makes it easy enough to access everything. What's not impressive is that someone decided that this type of layout was ever a necessary thing to design at all. Having had to salvage the components from 2 XPS 8920s (which surprisingly didn't have truly proprietary parts beyond the SD card reader), I can say it definitely felt like the case design was the product of brilliant engineers forced to design something that was a complete waste of their talents.
Like you said, some proper engineers, with good knowledge of heat transfer, made that CPU heatsink. They knew their job, they made it well, and like shown if it's open and got plenty of fresh air to do it's job, it does it wonderfully. GPUs have been suffering for like two decades with dissipating more heat than the CPU with way less heatsink area and those kinds of solutions are their saving grace, same with laptops. The issue is the idiot that decided that airflow wasn't part of the heat transfer equation, and decided to smash the fan intake into the power supply. Had there been a 2 cm wider gap or so it would likely work flawlessly.
this is a laptop (honestly, the size of heatsink makes me that came out of a 1466) heatsink, tied to a desktop-grade CPU, tied into a crappy OEM-grade case that turns the CPU into an oven. very cursed design indeed. corners cut everywhere.
Exactly, it's absolute cost-cutting insanity that they then sell at a premium to unsuspecting consumers. This whole laptop motherboard inside a PC case trend is so common now with Dell and HP. And they make it weigh 300lbs so it feels premium.
With so much corners cut, I wonder why they even design this then? Just get a normal atx case and board and you're done. Oh wait.......money. They wanted you to practically return to them anytime you have problems so they can earn that sweet, sweet moolah and people with no tech knowledge won't know.
Things that should be illegal: -Proprietary Desktop Motherboards -Soldered System Memory (common in recent AMD and Intel laptops) -Soldered SSD (fuck apple)
Woah woah woah, buddy, you are suggesting that companies should NOT maximize profits to the bone and screw the user over, since they pay politicians to keep you screwed over? 😮
@@rnicoles9355i once saw a proprietary Mainboard connection using a 8 Pin XLR jack for mouse and Keyboard Not one jack for mouse and one for the Board. One jack that split of into the mouse and the Keyboard. Shit gets WILD
My old HP G60 has dedicated covers for the memory, storage, and wifi chip. Just unscrew the storage panel, unscrew the hdd, and it slides out easily, this thing was made in 2008, by the way.
I used to work on Dell pcs, it used to be something that was worth it's weight in gold because of the people who cared on top. Nowadays it's money, money, money when I worked on the later generations and I knew they're all junk!
Since I quit Apple, I've been running Inspiron Laptops... they've done well for me... I'm not running the very latest, so maybe they've gotten worse, but....
I had an XPS I bought in 2008/2009. It was actually a great PC. Paid about $1200 at the time and besides upgrading the GPU after owning it a few years it ran fine until there was some major error I don't remember, but considering I cleaned it maybe one time ever, prob my own fault lol. It lasted 8 solid years though.
I've been using Dell Precision prebuilt systems since 2015 and they run cool, quiet and with good performance. I do overpay but in return I get a well-tested and well-designed system and when something fails I just call and the next day a Dell tech comes to repair it at my home. So, stay away from their consumer crap but be welcome to buy their professional/business systems.
Thats why I always stick to enterprise grade hardware. It’s much more upgradable and its built to handle heavy workloads while being more reliable. Always buys xeon based tower servers and you’ll be good
And they just end up as E-waste because it's not like you can take the components from this shitty case and put it into a better one, it's all proprietary parts that don't fit anywhere else lol
I honestly find it so sad because all they have to do to give these machines a hope of being good is put mITX holes in the motherboard and of course they don't
@@Dante-420 its more than the form factor. Some Dells do use mATX for the mobos......or so it would appear, with regards to size/form factor The power delivery isn't mATX spec at all making it: junk.
They used to make standard holes in old motherboards, I found an old grey and black dell OptiPlex xp tower in e waste, it was water damaged, but I was able to clean the case and put in a modern motherboard without any modification, in fact it had multiple screw holes you could move to make it different motherboard standards, but now they make the cases duck, they are poor quality, don't hold up, you cannot swap cases, no reuse of motherboards or case, I would personally have tried to modify another case to fit it, but it's a lot of work to do stuff like that
@@dungeonlord1 well... To be fair all options are a little bad in some ways. I like some of MSI's laptops but the premium you pay doesn't always translate to a better experience for example. It's kinda about knowing what "sickness" you're okay with and just ignoring it. HP is fine except for their BIOS wich is often absolute crap, if you don't mind that an HP Omen is a more than respectable laptop, but more advanced users can find themselves frustrated about the limitations, or at leats it was the case not that long ago. The original comment isn't fully serious and it's meant to be an exageration
The XPS line was in it's prime in the 2000's. Just look at how solidly built the XPS 700 series was. My main gaming pc is still built inside the chassis of an XPS 730x.
I still remember when XPS systems were good. I have an XPS 730x and its got these MASSIVE vents on the front with two big fans behind them. Its able to cool the xeon x5690 i ended up putting in it just fine and all the parts are standard atx so it can be upgraded, repaired, or gutted to put something way newer in no problem. It even has battery powered led lights that can light the inside when your working on it! Great system, its sad to see how far the xps line has fallen.
Dell has a huge issue with keeping the same designs for way too many years. The xps desktops, xps laptops, precision laptops all thermal throttle throttle. It actually pisses me off how dell refuses to redesign their pc’s to better suit modern hardware. Dell’s power delivery, thermal solutions and chassis haven’t changed since 4th gen intel and it shows because hardware changed since then and dell’s pcs aren’t holding up
I worked for a Dell EMC service provider previously, and yeah. This design of Alienware Aurora/XPS case is a dumpster fire. What on earth were they thinking.
They use the same case as the business optiplex line and just throw some different plastic on the outside. It's a case designed for an intel i3 to do word processing with, which is fine, until you put in a i7 and a GPU, now you have an oven. They know their customers are stupid as fuck and fall for advertising like idiots and they sell them by the tens of millions per year. It's disgusting.
what impressed me is that the quality isn't the same between the new dell products (lasts 1 month) and the old dell products (lasts 20 years if you take care of it) with upgradability and innovation that was actually good what a waste of good components.
To be honest they are incredibly overpriced when you buy it new, but if someone's trying to build a budget pc this things are great in the used market, you allways find them for arround 100/200 dlls or cheaper and they come with great cpus, just changing the case and heat sink gets you a great pc.
OEM PCs are only good if you need a SFF and buy it used for cheap. Business class PCs are actually ok if you're not looking to do anything crazy with them. It's mostly just consumer grade that is trash,like this XPS or an Inspiron,Vostro,etc
@@serrafersebastian3743You can't change the case because the case, motherboard, and power supply are proprietary and are only designed to be compatible with each other and nothing else. Even Dell's OEM GPUs are usually barebones cooling solutions. The only thing that can be salvaged is the CPU, but at that point just buy your own CPU lol The whole thing always ends up in the landfill because that's where trash belongs.
Actually, when they were newly launched the fan-curve was quite agressive and they would ramp up to prevent overheating but after a couple of bios updates the fan hardly even spins (I had one of these). Seems like they must have gotten a heap of complaints and figured that thermal throttling is preferable to the sound of a jet engine in most office environments.
I owned several Dell XPS Systems from the 400, 8300, 8500, and 8900. Never had a heat problem. I parted ways with them when they started using proprietary power supplies starting with the 8910 series.
You don't get it, according to Dell logic. The air spawns in via a magical teleportation method. This proprietary method is trademarked as "Dell crapcool"... The shutoff is just to let you know its working correctly.... Jokes aside you should outright ban all variations of that specific dell model, Dell also has a obvious windows contracting scheme since they have tailored BIOS FIRMWARE UPDATES for their machine without your permission. Which means Microsoft on the behalf of dell can just break your machine just so you can buy another dell system. HP has done the same thing. Dell has also made it harder for use with Linux by supplying their own WIFI intel-based modules that are deliberately designed to not work with Linux (Dell wireless) unless you use ubuntu.
As a psa for new people, buying gaming laptops or desktops stay completely away from any alienware and Dell product. Like seriously, all their products will overheat, go with any other brand I got a secondhand gaming laptop even after repasting the dam thing it still overheated to the point it cooked itself I repasted the cpu and gpu like 3 times it just always ran hot it was only a 45 watt intel cpu I swear such a waste after that failing I don't trust any prebuilt or Dell/Alienware product lol atlewst they gave me a newer laptop through the warranty that was nice I still have it
How about the precision I have an older one that works well and dad just got a 7760 and it’s perfectly fine for over a year Maybe not all prebuilts are bad
Informative and unfortunate. I have a Dell Inspiron 3670 which uses a more traditional case design. The air flow is bad since there's no case fan and it's just open air in the back, but it has a funnel blowing air out the side directly off the CPU fan and there's enough intake that it doesn't overheat for something cheap. They didn't even have to try and they still made a better case design than what I'm seeing here. It's especially disappointing because you can tell the engineers wanted this XPS to be a professional system for people to repair themselves, but put no thought into the longevity.
It was an unlucky gamble that went poorly for them. Dell designed this case when Intel was seemingly sticking with low power quad cores forever but then the core war started and by today we're back to space heater (130+ tdp) processors albeit now with double digit core counts in non-xeons (!). Maybe they should resurrect the BTX format.
I haven’t used a Dell PC for a long time, but I remember their larger sized Optiplex’s being way better than this, despite being pretty low end. Those just used a regular ATX case from what I remember, and would be cool to do a sleeper build with. At least their laptops are pretty nice from what ive seen with the inspirons and XPS’.
Wow.....someone needs a vacation :);)..... cant belive how big that motherboard is !!......I had a rig issue like that once, someone told me I should have it water cooled......so I filled up the barhtub and put it ln......actually worked good, untill I pluged it in......and " oh no"........that was that......guess I didnt have the tub water cold enough....I wont do that again
My wife & I have had two Dell XPS 8930's since November 2017. They are good machines. I had to replace the original Dell Nvidia1050Ti in my machine after 5 years.
I had an XPS 8500 until last year. I bought it for about $80 on Ebay. Apart from the fact it was full of dust, it worked well. The board was the same fit as an ATX. My only real dilslike was the case. It was like a base booster speaker. Every noise sounded much louder than normal. Also it vibrated sooooo much! So I spent quite a lot of time and money on acoustic mats, rubberised screws etc. Even getting quieter fans. After that it was pretty good. I was also a bit fussy about the air flow. I never had any over heating problems. But the GPU was at the bottom of the case. It never overheated but I just wanted it to go down a little cooler. There was no front fans at all. So I was forced to drill some fitting holes for a fan. there were holes already but they didn't line up with the fan. I couldn't fit more than a single 90. But it was right at the bottom where it was needed. Dell really should've cared a bit more about the airflow. Seems like they never do.
Dell is our vendor at work. Dell puts a 13700 inside of a Dell OptiPlex Micro 7000 with a laptop fan. Not the 13700T, just the 13700. I am not an engineer but the thermal events we see in lot are hilarious. One lady was gone for two weeks and her computer had a thermal event. Did the computer shut off? Of course not. It kept running. It fried and it wouldn’t POST. Thankfully it was under warranty.
most bussineses use them because they can get some pretty nice discounts when buying bulk, in both hardware and warranties and they're usually for light work. one other reason is the similar hardware across the board. but yeah, a 13700 makes no sense in this model, but by the time all those optiplexes burn beyond repair, the warranties are over and they're up for replacement with newer models anyway. meh, it's a profitable solution that works very well for the vendors and pretty ok for the buyers.
I hate it when brands air cool the cpu like that. If you want to have silence and performance you wanna go with a big heatsink and a (relatively) weak fan. You can also do the opposite approach and put a freaking jet engine on a tiny heatsink, but that's gonna run loud and hot.
@@redpheonix1000 And would also require a redesign of the case to fit it, and that would be the expensive bit, because I'm pretty sure they're reusing this same case for many of their PC models all the way up to the Alienware Aurora just with a diffrent plastic shell.
@@Izithel For corporate Dell models, such as Precision, the most expensive specs have large, heavy-duty heat sinks (the i9). They still run awful because the case design. Alright, no problem--just choose the i5 then--less heat, right? For the i5 they put the cheap heat-sink in. Same exact case design, same specs otherwise. Just, gotta save that sweet money for more yachts.
You would want to use a larger fan since it doesn't have to spin as fast to move the same amount of air. Fan speed has a large impact on noise. Unless by "Weak" you are referring to low speed.
Dell used to be good. I used to run their older computers into the ground without an issue. What a shame. Just another brand gone to sh*t. SMH. Good job though pointing this out. You have helped make it more apparent and hopefully saved someone from buying a crappy Dell XPS.
That reminds me of the HP Omen Obelisk, that thing was so stupid, especially the look: it has a tempered glass side panel, but all the components were really ugly, the mainboard had no VRM heatsink, the M.2 SSD had no heatsink, the RAM also (I don't say that these improve the performance, but it looks better with a window side panel when such components aren't so "nude") and the CPU cooler was literally a Intel stock cooler, together with the case rear fan completely generic black fans, no LEDs or even RGB LEDs (which was already pretty much around in 2018). At least the GPU had an illuminated "Geforce RTX" but it had a leaf-blower DHE cooler and a little RGB lighting by a strip but that's all. And because of the stock CPU cooler and almost no air intakes in the front (it had the 3.5" drive bays vertically) it also performed rather poorly, the CPU couldn't keep above the base clock for very long. I also get flashbacks of the old Dell Dimension series, especially the smaller (SFF?) variants were prone to overheat due to poor ventilation, saw that on "Dell Clamshell Hell - Dells thermal nightmare pc's of the early 2000's. OptiPlex GX260, GX270, GX280" My Optiplex 7010 SFF and 3040 SFF work fine with i5s, but these also got some proper airflow with a front grille and fan blowing fresh air into the chassis and directly into the PSU, however in the 3040 the PCIe 16x slot is the lower one, so you can only use 1 slot Low Profile GPUs, while the 7010s 16x slot is the upper one so you can use two slot ones; my Radeon Pro WX3100 gets a little warmer in the 3040 but is still far away from critical temperatures, maybe in the 5040 and 7040 the PCIe 16x is again the upper of two slots. That almost nonexistent fan control is almost like Apple's, on some MacBooks they begin to kick in at 80°C but don't rev high to get rid of the heat, but rather slowly, at least you can change that with Macsfancontrol software, on the 7010 you haver either the standard fan mode that is at least rather quiet (but doesn't ramp up when it should, above 75°C core temperature for example) or you deactivate it and get the full blast and these are similar noisy as servers.
I really adore this type of reviews. Being a continuously angry engineer myself, I can definitely relate to how angry you sound at some of these designs...
This desktop PC is begging to be modified. I don't know why PC manufacturers still use loud Delta branded fans. There are much better choices considering how much Dell charges for their XPS line. I own a Dell Alienware m17 r3 notebook computer. The price and performance is amazing but it gets really hot. I decided to modify the intake and exhaust ports to increase airflow. As a bonus the amount of fan noise was reduced. It was a 30 minute job thanks to a Dremel with a cut off wheel disc. This voided the warranty but I happen to love voiding warranties.
Delta make high quality, high power and high CFM fans. Delta and Sunon pretty much have the server and network market between them. The fan being loud isn't a fault of the fan, it's necessary due to the tiny heatsink.
We use one for Church. I upgraded the GPU and PSU, added an NVME. Had it at home while upgrading working all fine. Brought it to church, the darn thing now doesn’t post unless you do something really stupid. I have to unplug all displays from the GPU, plug one monitor to the igpu, then it posts and I can plug all the monitors into the GPU. The only reason we have it is because someone donated it. Dell systems are completely junk.
I have one that no longer works and I'm quite surprised it wasn't the CPU or Motherboard that failed me after 6 years of abuse with how dusty my uncleaned, dusty room in the middle of the desert, but rather, the PSU (lmao. It still needs airflow and dust still is an issue for that) I do plan to scavenge the GPU for whatever I might use it for
I own a dell XPS 8930 and it's not THAT bad while the CPU is at full load, the stock cooler has to cool an i5 8400. While the fan noises do skyrocket to cool it down, it never ends up overheating and shutting down like said in this video. I do agree with you on some parts here though, the way they built it is wonky and kind of janky.
What’s even worse is that Dell has been using that heatsink design for at least two decades. There’s some SFF Optiplexes with Prescott Pentium 4s (another CPU known for being very toasty) that have that same exact heatsink design and it didn’t work then, either.
it is extremely difficult now to find a normal laptop, without a regular problems of soldered SSD,CPU, GPU and RAM. Some vendors even put a glue drops on the side of the soldered RAM, to make it impossible to reflow.
have a coworker i stayed with for a bit and my wife both tell me i should advertise to build PCs for people. but living within range of a microcenter im not sure if there would even be a market for me to do that. because it would have to be, they buy the parts and then i could assemble it for them and granted i would likely give them ideas of what would work fine within a budget to give them a decent gaming pc. but again having a mega store nearby where people can get it done for a small fee.....not sure how many of the "i dont know how to assemble a computer" people live near me. i had minimal knowledge getting into it going from an older used xps, to a secondhand pc that i had to fix case headers and reinstall windows on to buying guts and case for a whole new build minus ssd as i just swapped it. my only exeperience goes back about 20 plus years when i upgrade a walmart bought HP pavilion with a graphics card and i might have dabbled with adding a sound card in there. or being able to add drivers for external peripherals like an external zip drive.
I remember being on a forum years ago where someone was complaining that they had three computers commit seppuku in four months and couldn't figure out what was going wrong. I commented that perhaps he should stop buying Dell, and he replied with "How did you know they were Dells?"
Just did a case swap in a 3630 for that reason. Same layout. Put a dual fan tower cooler on it and the temps dont even get into the 70s and its dead silent. That blower cooler is loud as hell.
For Dell, its all about corporate clients. Accountants depreciate the equipment down to nothing and in the fourth year, it goes in the dumpster. No one involved minds the subpar design (the employees might, and IT certainly will complain but they don't matter to the suits). That is the sad truth about why these things are such garbage.
I feel sad becouse my old Dell precision workstation works perfectly after 15 years. I have upgraded it with a new GPU but otherwise it woks perfectly and now I see how it has gone for them. Anyways great video
I have two of those (8910 and 8930), but neither mine have that weird heatsink thing. They came with just normal fans. This is very odd. Both machines have had their power supplies replaced as for some reason, both computer’s psu fans just didn’t spin. It was very strange. Should also be noted that both machines are i7s (6700 and 8700), but you would think the i9 would get a better heatsink than the i7s.
Dell fan control is garbage. All of the fans only have 3 settings off, low (30%), and high (100%). One of the best mods to any dell desktop is a fan speed controller such as a Corsair commander or Noctua NA-FC1 to just bypass it. If you are performing this mod, I would also highly suggest using a tool such as Intel XTU to set steady P1 and P2 power states to help with performance and thermals. I just fixed a brand new XPS desktop that had a 215W P1 and 65W P2 state from the factory (a stable 115W or 90W all of the time is much better). Also avoid buying any Intel CPU from Dell that isn't a K series. They do some really stupid things with Power Limits to cheap out on CPU coolers.
You know what, Dell designed this case around the time 6th-7th gen Intel cpus were out and they were pretty cool-running. Even then the ventilation wasn't ideal but with 8-9th gen cpus getting hotter, the case design was hopeless. This style case didn't stick around very long too, only about 3 years, and their current xps case is far better optimized. The design that came before was one that Dell was using for about a decade with only small internal layout adjustments.
Like you showed, the case open keeps it cool enough. It's in fact a brilliant heatsink design, made by engineers that know heat transfer properly. Then someone decided that airflow was NOT part of the heat transfer and took a huge dump on top of all that brilliant engineering. Thank you. Nice f**** job. I can bet that if it had like 2 cm wider of a gap between that CPU cooling fan and the PSU, it would work well.
After the side panel was opened, I couldn't help but wonder, why is the power supply SO CLOSE to where the CPU is? As if the heat coming from the power supply weren't a big enough problem, it also looks like it's part of the restricted airflow problem!
I have an Asus G20AJ. Proprietary mainboard, proprietary cooler, requires laptop RAM and laptop optical drives. But it does keep cool at least. What it didn‘t keep is enough space to fit Lupe‘s gi- graphics card in there. Not only that, finding a graphics card that exhausts the heat to the back is tough nowadays.
once upon a time i too bought and became highly dissatisfied with the prebuilt desktops! i decided to be a system builder and assembled them myself with every part selected by me haha
It reminds me of those turbo buttons on old 486 era systems, that would clock your CPU down, if your physics were to fast in game It's not a button, that slows your PC down when pressed, its a hinge
This bad design problem is not only limited to XPS, optiplex series suffers from same problems. I got a 9th gen running i5 and oh boy did it liked to cook stuff up. I replaced stock bs cooler and fan with a low profile 140mm fan, had to tinker a bit as that fan won't fit easily. After that I installed one small 80mm case fan powered via Sata connector and I still couldn't keep the side panel on as the temps were still high for my liking. So now instead of side panel, I installed a large mesh having sides lined by magnet to stick it there. Under load temps hover between 70 to 80 celcius, and idle the tenp is below 35. So lesson is only buy these if you're getting them dirt cheap and ready to tinker with them.
my first desktop was a 2012 Dell XPS 8700 and to say it was slow was a understatement. I tried using it as a NAS recently but the old i5 CPU is just so slow its a huge bottleneck
And here I thought seeing my DIY pc temps at 70 something Celsius was something i should fix! I did, but I later found out that those aren't terrible temps for air cooling.
This issue would be solved very easily if they put a front fan, or if the heatsink is attached to some kind of guide and has more or less the same area of the upper fan. Another un-wise design consideration is the usage of a "generic form factor" PSU. Unbeliebable how they can outsource to make all sorts of components, but not a power source well suited for a compact enclosure. A complete disaster. The quality disparity in those dell computers is scary.
I had a Dell G5 5090 for a year and a half and it had a better heatsink, but it was still worse than the Intel fucking stock heatsink. That CPU (i7 9700) went to 100°C in a few seconds before its boost window ran out, and it was at around 85°C while gaming. I ended zp replacing that shotty cooler with a much better low profile one ans now I really had to try actively in order to get this thing to throttle. I left the 4500RPM 80mm case fan in because the 92mm fan I installed was quieter but also didn't move nearly enough air. The stock fan profile on mine did actually wramp both 80mm 4500RPM to 4500RPM when the CPU got close to 100°C, but they were set to take like 10s to get there slowly. It was ridiculous. The RTX 2060 it had was decent, but also had one single not-so-quirt 3600RPM fan. That luckily never had to turn up that high and the stock fan profile was okay but I ended up making a custom one. With the better CPU cooler, I could unlock my CPU'S default 75W power limit, but the VRMs couldn't handle more than 140W sustained unless the side panel was open. The max I could see in games was only around 120W, but the VRMs still mostly sat at around 90°C because they had NO COOLING ON THEM AT ALL!!! That was the reason why after only two years of owning it, I built my own PC. It was a fucking piece if garbage for my use-case (gaming mostly). It did come woth dual-channel RAM, which seems to be a premium in prebuilts nowadays, but I threw an additional 2x16GB kit in. I ended up selling that shitbix to a friend of mine that makes music and could profit from my 48GB of RAM (they were still working on a laptop with 8GB at the time)
I have heard Dell makes some good laptops. But I've never believed that because every time I see a video talking about their PCs? Alienware or otherwise? They're just ovens. Ovens filled with proprietary parts in a case that fits no other standard. I've seen folks say proprietary parts aren't a big deal but, no. The company went out of their way and spent millions to design something that is harder to replace, that makes you married to that set up or the company for parts. This rig is such a disaster and maybe those folks were right and their laptops are good- but I can't believe them because their desktops are this, bad.
I have a XPS 8940 from 2021, 11th gen i7. The interior is a clean layout, much different than the 8930. It still gets too hot when the GPU is maxed out. I need to added another fan to pull air in. I upgraded the CPU heatsink/fan assembly and added VRM heatsinks to try to keep this P.O.S. alive. These were Dell aftermarket/upgrades from Dell. Windows 10 Pro as supplied new has issues as sometimes after power on, one of the SSD's goes into a 100% utilization and locks the system. Other times, I press the power button, system turns on, then off. 2nd press it powers up properly. Cheap bastards did'nt even supply a HD activity light on the front panel, it's located on back! I will 'never' but another Dell XPS again. At least the Optiplex XE3 I bought years ago has been trouble free.
They really should have stuck with the design of the XPS 8300, thats what i have right now and it works fantastic! despite only using DDR3 ram and a 12 year old i7-2600 its still a nice computer
I had an XPS 8500 and it was indeed a piece of shit, I lost two motherboards and a core (idk about the other core) . I didn't know it was restarting again and again because of overheating. I didn't know much about such things back then
The problem with most of dell computers is that they only have 3 fan speeds: inactive, audible and way too loud. And they use crappy loud fans and design their cases so that they accumulate a lot of dust (pull fan config). I had Inspiron 5680 with aircooler and they didn't even bother to mount vrm heatsinks (I think watercooled one had them), put ssd slot behind gpu (which wasn't such a bad thing, because when I was transfering lots of data I just turned on gpu fan and it didn't throttle). Motherboard of that piece of shit also had a feature that would check if all parts are present, which would be ok if it wasn't impossible to turn off. I replaced stock cooler for noctua nh-u9s and it kept showing message at boot that fan was not detected. And eventually I also replaced a PSU, because its fan was really loud and was making knocking sound. Then I upgraded the case and it was showing that front panel is missing (so they must have some checking if stuff is theirs). When I started using my pc as server, I had enough of those bios messages (because it didn't continue to boot, but just waited for someone to press escape) and bought a normal motherboard. I also upgraded from 2 unmatched sticks of samsung and gskill 2600 and 2400 MHz 16 gb of ram to 32 gb 3200 MHz. I also swapped stock ssd for Crucial p5 and the only original components are cpu, gpu and 1tb hdd. TLDR: If you need a desktop PC, don't buy Dell and if you need a cheap laptop also ignore Dell and just get an older used thinkpad.
Hey now I have built a Computer I built an AMD Ryzen in 2018. I was not really happy with it because I am an Intel guy. So, I wanted an Intel i7. I found out I could buy an XPS 8930 cheaper with everything I wanted. I purchased an XPS 8930 Late 2019. Mine has been fine and it has a Different fan. Maybe I got a newer version of the XPS 8930. You are not the only one who has complained about these overheating.
I just had a look at my mother's old HP laptop, which was never particular performance oriented with a modern Pentium, however while it had a heat pipe to a small heatsink at the side, the rest of the case had absolutely no vents, so I have no idea where the air was coming from that the fan was supposed to pull, random ingress air from the gaps and the keyboard I suppose.
Lets not mention their inspiron line that when you open the laptop the screen covers the exhaust vents trapping all of the heat inside the case. You either use an external monitor or use a laptop always throttled.
I bought an XPS 17 years ago .. the motherboard failed and toasted the cpu 1 month after the warrenty ran out. I paid for new cpu, they gave me the new board. When the exact same thing happened again, i junked it and built my own ...
Buddy of mine had an XPS laptop a long while back. He said XPS stood for xpensive piece of shit. I had heard that XPS laptops are actually quite good now, but if this desktop is anything to go by...
As one of the 12 people that watch your videos, I appreciate your work! Also: F@ck Dell... Sincerely: One of the 12 watchers of the "Greatest Technician that's ever lived..."
Its almost a better option to pull the cpu, gpu, ram, storage, throw that POS case in the trash, and get a new case, motherboard, and PSU (it didn't look like that swinger special came out)
at first i wanted to dislike unrecommend and report this video , thinking that they talk about much older XPS , but as i watched i realised this is similar to what i saw at Gamers Nexus and they added a CLC for the CPU . those are the only instances where i would even think of putting a CLC , considering all the flaws of this type of coolers . alternatively , Dell should've use a case like GameMax MeshBox and i'm shure they'd be fine , BUT , ANY company wants clients to buy more of their products , if you know what i mean
I love your videos, they make me laugh always! i am from argentina, and here the story it is so different...that pc here is a GIANT! but customers conta afford it!
What is impressive is how the case is designed to compact everything together in a way that makes it easy enough to access everything. What's not impressive is that someone decided that this type of layout was ever a necessary thing to design at all. Having had to salvage the components from 2 XPS 8920s (which surprisingly didn't have truly proprietary parts beyond the SD card reader), I can say it definitely felt like the case design was the product of brilliant engineers forced to design something that was a complete waste of their talents.
Well said!
@@SalemTechspertsyup. My little sister she sucks hard to cool the temps.
@@tibettenballs4962?
@@tibettenballs4962sweet home Alabama
Like you said, some proper engineers, with good knowledge of heat transfer, made that CPU heatsink. They knew their job, they made it well, and like shown if it's open and got plenty of fresh air to do it's job, it does it wonderfully. GPUs have been suffering for like two decades with dissipating more heat than the CPU with way less heatsink area and those kinds of solutions are their saving grace, same with laptops.
The issue is the idiot that decided that airflow wasn't part of the heat transfer equation, and decided to smash the fan intake into the power supply. Had there been a 2 cm wider gap or so it would likely work flawlessly.
Fun fact:
Recirculating hot air is exactly how a convection oven works. This computer is so poorly designed, it is literally cooking your components.
who knows? Maybe cooking food is it's main purpose with the added benifit of running windows on it.
@@Redwan777Wait a minute. You’re saying I can bake a pizza in my Dell XPS? Hold my beer.
@@fruitbouquet5479 Giving "winner winner, chicken dinner" a whole new meaning.
It’s planned obsolescence I assume
Weird too because Dell computers from my experience tend to be pretty reliable.
this is a laptop (honestly, the size of heatsink makes me that came out of a 1466) heatsink, tied to a desktop-grade CPU, tied into a crappy OEM-grade case that turns the CPU into an oven.
very cursed design indeed. corners cut everywhere.
Exactly, it's absolute cost-cutting insanity that they then sell at a premium to unsuspecting consumers. This whole laptop motherboard inside a PC case trend is so common now with Dell and HP. And they make it weigh 300lbs so it feels premium.
so many corners have been cut even circles don't seem round in comparison.
@@SalemTechspertsfell has been reusing cheap old cases for 10 years. Cheap, reused, unsold parts in a warehouse in China. Overstock buy outs
This is why i built 2 custom pc's for my friend's business.
With so much corners cut, I wonder why they even design this then? Just get a normal atx case and board and you're done. Oh wait.......money. They wanted you to practically return to them anytime you have problems so they can earn that sweet, sweet moolah and people with no tech knowledge won't know.
Things that should be illegal:
-Proprietary Desktop Motherboards
-Soldered System Memory (common in recent AMD and Intel laptops)
-Soldered SSD (fuck apple)
you forgot
-proprietary PSUs
-locked bios
Woah woah woah, buddy, you are suggesting that companies should NOT maximize profits to the bone and screw the user over, since they pay politicians to keep you screwed over? 😮
@@rnicoles9355i once saw a proprietary Mainboard connection using a 8 Pin XLR jack for mouse and Keyboard
Not one jack for mouse and one for the Board. One jack that split of into the mouse and the Keyboard. Shit gets WILD
Memory that Apple uses (not only them). there is no version to be inserted into a slot.
My old HP G60 has dedicated covers for the memory, storage, and wifi chip.
Just unscrew the storage panel, unscrew the hdd, and it slides out easily, this thing was made in 2008, by the way.
I used to work on Dell pcs, it used to be something that was worth it's weight in gold because of the people who cared on top. Nowadays it's money, money, money when I worked on the later generations and I knew they're all junk!
Since I quit Apple, I've been running Inspiron Laptops... they've done well for me... I'm not running the very latest, so maybe they've gotten worse, but....
Same is true with HP too.
@@manojgail pre built PCs just ain't it anymore
Sad facts how they messed up so badly
I had an XPS I bought in 2008/2009. It was actually a great PC. Paid about $1200 at the time and besides upgrading the GPU after owning it a few years it ran fine until there was some major error I don't remember, but considering I cleaned it maybe one time ever, prob my own fault lol. It lasted 8 solid years though.
This is why you never buy mass-produced prebuilts as a private person.
100%. They’re meant for corporate clients at best.
I am a public figure, so I can thankfully buy as many as I want
@@stevens1041 wouldn’t put an xps in any environment possible, an optiplex, on the other hand i would recommend to anyone
I've been using Dell Precision prebuilt systems since 2015 and they run cool, quiet and with good performance. I do overpay but in return I get a well-tested and well-designed system and when something fails I just call and the next day a Dell tech comes to repair it at my home.
So, stay away from their consumer crap but be welcome to buy their professional/business systems.
Thats why I always stick to enterprise grade hardware. It’s much more upgradable and its built to handle heavy workloads while being more reliable. Always buys xeon based tower servers and you’ll be good
And they just end up as E-waste because it's not like you can take the components from this shitty case and put it into a better one, it's all proprietary parts that don't fit anywhere else lol
Exactly, it's incredibly wasteful.
I honestly find it so sad because all they have to do to give these machines a hope of being good is put mITX holes in the motherboard and of course they don't
e for "engineering"-waste
@@Dante-420 its more than the form factor. Some Dells do use mATX for the mobos......or so it would appear, with regards to size/form factor The power delivery isn't mATX spec at all making it: junk.
They used to make standard holes in old motherboards, I found an old grey and black dell OptiPlex xp tower in e waste, it was water damaged, but I was able to clean the case and put in a modern motherboard without any modification, in fact it had multiple screw holes you could move to make it different motherboard standards, but now they make the cases duck, they are poor quality, don't hold up, you cannot swap cases, no reuse of motherboards or case, I would personally have tried to modify another case to fit it, but it's a lot of work to do stuff like that
You know it's bad when HP seems like a good option
If i cant choose hp or dell what do i choose
@@dungeonlord1 well... To be fair all options are a little bad in some ways. I like some of MSI's laptops but the premium you pay doesn't always translate to a better experience for example. It's kinda about knowing what "sickness" you're okay with and just ignoring it. HP is fine except for their BIOS wich is often absolute crap, if you don't mind that an HP Omen is a more than respectable laptop, but more advanced users can find themselves frustrated about the limitations, or at leats it was the case not that long ago. The original comment isn't fully serious and it's meant to be an exageration
Dell = Doesn't Ever Last Long.
same
my dell desktop lasted for ever
My dell laptop is still working since 2009
At this point they just focus on Latitudes, Optiplexes and Precisions, nothing else.
I remember when XPS was the high-end lineup. Now they're just typical crappy prebuilts.
Yep, back in the day they had a really decent set of gaming laptops. Though mine had a crackling sound issue that took months to fix.
XPS 13 9365 ?
The XPS line was in it's prime in the 2000's. Just look at how solidly built the XPS 700 series was. My main gaming pc is still built inside the chassis of an XPS 730x.
4:20 I never expected TheGreatestTechnicianThat’severLived to become an actual raccoon under the desk lol, you’re content is amazing BTW
I still remember when XPS systems were good. I have an XPS 730x and its got these MASSIVE vents on the front with two big fans behind them. Its able to cool the xeon x5690 i ended up putting in it just fine and all the parts are standard atx so it can be upgraded, repaired, or gutted to put something way newer in no problem. It even has battery powered led lights that can light the inside when your working on it! Great system, its sad to see how far the xps line has fallen.
Haaahhh, i have one too. But with the i7 870
@@sysierius Very nice!
All 5 people last year, all million people this year. Time flies! Congratulations on your insane growth!
Dell has a huge issue with keeping the same designs for way too many years. The xps desktops, xps laptops, precision laptops all thermal throttle throttle. It actually pisses me off how dell refuses to redesign their pc’s to better suit modern hardware. Dell’s power delivery, thermal solutions and chassis haven’t changed since 4th gen intel and it shows because hardware changed since then and dell’s pcs aren’t holding up
did you see new XPS?
Dell makes both incredibly good computers and incredibly horseshit ones, no inbetween, this one is an example of the latter.
I worked for a Dell EMC service provider previously, and yeah. This design of Alienware Aurora/XPS case is a dumpster fire. What on earth were they thinking.
They use the same case as the business optiplex line and just throw some different plastic on the outside. It's a case designed for an intel i3 to do word processing with, which is fine, until you put in a i7 and a GPU, now you have an oven. They know their customers are stupid as fuck and fall for advertising like idiots and they sell them by the tens of millions per year. It's disgusting.
Very interesting and informative! Keep keeping it real and running!
Thanks dude! Appreciate it!
what impressed me is that the quality isn't the same between the new dell products (lasts 1 month) and the old dell products (lasts 20 years if you take care of it) with upgradability and innovation that was actually good what a waste of good components.
No, they've been doing ridiculous proprietary parts for literally 20 years now.
This is why custom pc always rules!! Buying OEM desktop is absolutely pointless
OEM Desktop's have their place in certain situations, but this is simply a poor effort at money grabbing people who don't know any better.
@@SalemTechspertsA great example is the ultra small Factor PCs
To be honest they are incredibly overpriced when you buy it new, but if someone's trying to build a budget pc this things are great in the used market, you allways find them for arround 100/200 dlls or cheaper and they come with great cpus, just changing the case and heat sink gets you a great pc.
OEM PCs are only good if you need a SFF and buy it used for cheap. Business class PCs are actually ok if you're not looking to do anything crazy with them. It's mostly just consumer grade that is trash,like this XPS or an Inspiron,Vostro,etc
@@serrafersebastian3743You can't change the case because the case, motherboard, and power supply are proprietary and are only designed to be compatible with each other and nothing else. Even Dell's OEM GPUs are usually barebones cooling solutions. The only thing that can be salvaged is the CPU, but at that point just buy your own CPU lol
The whole thing always ends up in the landfill because that's where trash belongs.
Actually, when they were newly launched the fan-curve was quite agressive and they would ramp up to prevent overheating but after a couple of bios updates the fan hardly even spins (I had one of these). Seems like they must have gotten a heap of complaints and figured that thermal throttling is preferable to the sound of a jet engine in most office environments.
I owned several Dell XPS Systems from the 400, 8300, 8500, and 8900. Never had a heat problem. I parted ways with them when they started using proprietary power supplies starting with the 8910 series.
You don't get it, according to Dell logic. The air spawns in via a magical teleportation method. This proprietary method is trademarked as "Dell crapcool"... The shutoff is just to let you know its working correctly.... Jokes aside you should outright ban all variations of that specific dell model, Dell also has a obvious windows contracting scheme since they have tailored BIOS FIRMWARE UPDATES for their machine without your permission. Which means Microsoft on the behalf of dell can just break your machine just so you can buy another dell system. HP has done the same thing. Dell has also made it harder for use with Linux by supplying their own WIFI intel-based modules that are deliberately designed to not work with Linux (Dell wireless) unless you use ubuntu.
As a psa for new people, buying gaming laptops or desktops stay completely away from any alienware and Dell product. Like seriously, all their products will overheat, go with any other brand I got a secondhand gaming laptop even after repasting the dam thing it still overheated to the point it cooked itself I repasted the cpu and gpu like 3 times it just always ran hot it was only a 45 watt intel cpu I swear such a waste after that failing I don't trust any prebuilt or Dell/Alienware product lol atlewst they gave me a newer laptop through the warranty that was nice I still have it
How about the precision
I have an older one that works well and dad just got a 7760 and it’s perfectly fine for over a year
Maybe not all prebuilts are bad
This made me even gladder that I went the extra mile to build my PC myself.
Same.
Informative and unfortunate.
I have a Dell Inspiron 3670 which uses a more traditional case design. The air flow is bad since there's no case fan and it's just open air in the back, but it has a funnel blowing air out the side directly off the CPU fan and there's enough intake that it doesn't overheat for something cheap. They didn't even have to try and they still made a better case design than what I'm seeing here.
It's especially disappointing because you can tell the engineers wanted this XPS to be a professional system for people to repair themselves, but put no thought into the longevity.
It was an unlucky gamble that went poorly for them. Dell designed this case when Intel was seemingly sticking with low power quad cores forever but then the core war started and by today we're back to space heater (130+ tdp) processors albeit now with double digit core counts in non-xeons (!). Maybe they should resurrect the BTX format.
I was just about to buy a Dell XPS workstation, but thank heavens I stumbled upon your video.
A HUGE THANK YOU!!!!!
I haven’t used a Dell PC for a long time, but I remember their larger sized Optiplex’s being way better than this, despite being pretty low end. Those just used a regular ATX case from what I remember, and would be cool to do a sleeper build with.
At least their laptops are pretty nice from what ive seen with the inspirons and XPS’.
Wow.....someone needs a vacation :);)..... cant belive how big that motherboard is !!......I had a rig issue like that once, someone told me I should have it water cooled......so I filled up the barhtub and put it ln......actually worked good, untill I pluged it in......and " oh no"........that was that......guess I didnt have the tub water cold enough....I wont do that again
Hahahah you kill me George!
My wife & I have had two Dell XPS 8930's since November 2017. They are good machines. I had to replace the original Dell Nvidia1050Ti in my machine after 5 years.
I had an XPS 8500 until last year. I bought it for about $80 on Ebay. Apart from the fact it was full of dust, it worked well. The board was the same fit as an ATX. My only real dilslike was the case. It was like a base booster speaker. Every noise sounded much louder than normal. Also it vibrated sooooo much! So I spent quite a lot of time and money on acoustic mats, rubberised screws etc. Even getting quieter fans. After that it was pretty good. I was also a bit fussy about the air flow. I never had any over heating problems. But the GPU was at the bottom of the case. It never overheated but I just wanted it to go down a little cooler. There was no front fans at all. So I was forced to drill some fitting holes for a fan. there were holes already but they didn't line up with the fan. I couldn't fit more than a single 90. But it was right at the bottom where it was needed. Dell really should've cared a bit more about the airflow. Seems like they never do.
Dell is our vendor at work. Dell puts a 13700 inside of a Dell OptiPlex Micro 7000 with a laptop fan. Not the 13700T, just the 13700. I am not an engineer but the thermal events we see in lot are hilarious. One lady was gone for two weeks and her computer had a thermal event. Did the computer shut off? Of course not. It kept running. It fried and it wouldn’t POST. Thankfully it was under warranty.
most bussineses use them because they can get some pretty nice discounts when buying bulk, in both hardware and warranties and they're usually for light work. one other reason is the similar hardware across the board. but yeah, a 13700 makes no sense in this model, but by the time all those optiplexes burn beyond repair, the warranties are over and they're up for replacement with newer models anyway. meh, it's a profitable solution that works very well for the vendors and pretty ok for the buyers.
I hate it when brands air cool the cpu like that. If you want to have silence and performance you wanna go with a big heatsink and a (relatively) weak fan. You can also do the opposite approach and put a freaking jet engine on a tiny heatsink, but that's gonna run loud and hot.
A big heatsink costs money! Can't have that!
@@redpheonix1000 And would also require a redesign of the case to fit it, and that would be the expensive bit, because I'm pretty sure they're reusing this same case for many of their PC models all the way up to the Alienware Aurora just with a diffrent plastic shell.
@@Izithel For corporate Dell models, such as Precision, the most expensive specs have large, heavy-duty heat sinks (the i9). They still run awful because the case design. Alright, no problem--just choose the i5 then--less heat, right? For the i5 they put the cheap heat-sink in. Same exact case design, same specs otherwise. Just, gotta save that sweet money for more yachts.
You would want to use a larger fan since it doesn't have to spin as fast to move the same amount of air. Fan speed has a large impact on noise. Unless by "Weak" you are referring to low speed.
@@iiisaac1312 Yes by weak was referring to a big fan that doesnt spin too fast (Because it doesnt have to spin fast since it has a large heatsink)
Dell used to be good. I used to run their older computers into the ground without an issue. What a shame. Just another brand gone to sh*t. SMH. Good job though pointing this out. You have helped make it more apparent and hopefully saved someone from buying a crappy Dell XPS.
That reminds me of the HP Omen Obelisk, that thing was so stupid, especially the look: it has a tempered glass side panel, but all the components were really ugly, the mainboard had no VRM heatsink, the M.2 SSD had no heatsink, the RAM also (I don't say that these improve the performance, but it looks better with a window side panel when such components aren't so "nude") and the CPU cooler was literally a Intel stock cooler, together with the case rear fan completely generic black fans, no LEDs or even RGB LEDs (which was already pretty much around in 2018).
At least the GPU had an illuminated "Geforce RTX" but it had a leaf-blower DHE cooler and a little RGB lighting by a strip but that's all.
And because of the stock CPU cooler and almost no air intakes in the front (it had the 3.5" drive bays vertically) it also performed rather poorly, the CPU couldn't keep above the base clock for very long.
I also get flashbacks of the old Dell Dimension series, especially the smaller (SFF?) variants were prone to overheat due to poor ventilation, saw that on "Dell Clamshell Hell - Dells thermal nightmare pc's of the early 2000's. OptiPlex GX260, GX270, GX280"
My Optiplex 7010 SFF and 3040 SFF work fine with i5s, but these also got some proper airflow with a front grille and fan blowing fresh air into the chassis and directly into the PSU, however in the 3040 the PCIe 16x slot is the lower one, so you can only use 1 slot Low Profile GPUs, while the 7010s 16x slot is the upper one so you can use two slot ones; my Radeon Pro WX3100 gets a little warmer in the 3040 but is still far away from critical temperatures, maybe in the 5040 and 7040 the PCIe 16x is again the upper of two slots.
That almost nonexistent fan control is almost like Apple's, on some MacBooks they begin to kick in at 80°C but don't rev high to get rid of the heat, but rather slowly, at least you can change that with Macsfancontrol software, on the 7010 you haver either the standard fan mode that is at least rather quiet (but doesn't ramp up when it should, above 75°C core temperature for example) or you deactivate it and get the full blast and these are similar noisy as servers.
I really adore this type of reviews. Being a continuously angry engineer myself, I can definitely relate to how angry you sound at some of these designs...
This desktop PC is begging to be modified. I don't know why PC manufacturers still use loud Delta branded fans. There are much better choices considering how much Dell charges for their XPS line. I own a Dell Alienware m17 r3 notebook computer. The price and performance is amazing but it gets really hot. I decided to modify the intake and exhaust ports to increase airflow.
As a bonus the amount of fan noise was reduced. It was a 30 minute job thanks to a Dremel with a cut off wheel disc. This voided the warranty but I happen to love voiding warranties.
Delta make high quality, high power and high CFM fans. Delta and Sunon pretty much have the server and network market between them.
The fan being loud isn't a fault of the fan, it's necessary due to the tiny heatsink.
We use one for Church. I upgraded the GPU and PSU, added an NVME. Had it at home while upgrading working all fine. Brought it to church, the darn thing now doesn’t post unless you do something really stupid. I have to unplug all displays from the GPU, plug one monitor to the igpu, then it posts and I can plug all the monitors into the GPU. The only reason we have it is because someone donated it. Dell systems are completely junk.
I have one that no longer works and I'm quite surprised it wasn't the CPU or Motherboard that failed me after 6 years of abuse with how dusty my uncleaned, dusty room in the middle of the desert, but rather, the PSU (lmao. It still needs airflow and dust still is an issue for that)
I do plan to scavenge the GPU for whatever I might use it for
I used to have an XPS 720, and seeing dell ruin the XPS brought immense disappointment.
I own a dell XPS 8930 and it's not THAT bad while the CPU is at full load, the stock cooler has to cool an i5 8400. While the fan noises do skyrocket to cool it down, it never ends up overheating and shutting down like said in this video. I do agree with you on some parts here though, the way they built it is wonky and kind of janky.
DELL is only good as a laptop company, not as a desktop company.
Especially the Business-Class laptops.
What’s even worse is that Dell has been using that heatsink design for at least two decades. There’s some SFF Optiplexes with Prescott Pentium 4s (another CPU known for being very toasty) that have that same exact heatsink design and it didn’t work then, either.
it is extremely difficult now to find a normal laptop, without a regular problems of soldered SSD,CPU, GPU and RAM. Some vendors even put a glue drops on the side of the soldered RAM, to make it impossible to reflow.
have a coworker i stayed with for a bit and my wife both tell me i should advertise to build PCs for people. but living within range of a microcenter im not sure if there would even be a market for me to do that.
because it would have to be, they buy the parts and then i could assemble it for them and granted i would likely give them ideas of what would work fine within a budget to give them a decent gaming pc.
but again having a mega store nearby where people can get it done for a small fee.....not sure how many of the "i dont know how to assemble a computer" people live near me. i had minimal knowledge getting into it going from an older used xps, to a secondhand pc that i had to fix case headers and reinstall windows on to buying guts and case for a whole new build minus ssd as i just swapped it.
my only exeperience goes back about 20 plus years when i upgrade a walmart bought HP pavilion with a graphics card and i might have dabbled with adding a sound card in there. or being able to add drivers for external peripherals like an external zip drive.
I remember being on a forum years ago where someone was complaining that they had three computers commit seppuku in four months and couldn't figure out what was going wrong. I commented that perhaps he should stop buying Dell, and he replied with "How did you know they were Dells?"
Just did a case swap in a 3630 for that reason. Same layout. Put a dual fan tower cooler on it and the temps dont even get into the 70s and its dead silent. That blower cooler is loud as hell.
Yes, this is the "beauty" of planned obsolescense + propritary parts to make Hell-Dell/Alienware + HP tons of money
They say fool me once.....
For Dell, its all about corporate clients. Accountants depreciate the equipment down to nothing and in the fourth year, it goes in the dumpster. No one involved minds the subpar design (the employees might, and IT certainly will complain but they don't matter to the suits). That is the sad truth about why these things are such garbage.
Mistakes : Bought a prebuilt from a big manufacturer.
Would buy a PC from like, memory PC so I can choose the parts and put less money in it
I feel sad becouse my old Dell precision workstation works perfectly after 15 years. I have upgraded it with a new GPU but otherwise it woks perfectly and now I see how it has gone for them. Anyways great video
At first glance, I thought this video was about using a Dell computer as a point of sale machine, before I realized POS stood for "piece of "
I have two of those (8910 and 8930), but neither mine have that weird heatsink thing. They came with just normal fans. This is very odd. Both machines have had their power supplies replaced as for some reason, both computer’s psu fans just didn’t spin. It was very strange. Should also be noted that both machines are i7s (6700 and 8700), but you would think the i9 would get a better heatsink than the i7s.
Did you double check that the psu fans didnt have a zero RPM mode?
Wow your a Genius
Dell fan control is garbage. All of the fans only have 3 settings off, low (30%), and high (100%). One of the best mods to any dell desktop is a fan speed controller such as a Corsair commander or Noctua NA-FC1 to just bypass it. If you are performing this mod, I would also highly suggest using a tool such as Intel XTU to set steady P1 and P2 power states to help with performance and thermals. I just fixed a brand new XPS desktop that had a 215W P1 and 65W P2 state from the factory (a stable 115W or 90W all of the time is much better).
Also avoid buying any Intel CPU from Dell that isn't a K series. They do some really stupid things with Power Limits to cheap out on CPU coolers.
The worst thing is that I have like an old HP desktop back from like 2010 or something and it's still working and it's not running that hot
You know what, Dell designed this case around the time 6th-7th gen Intel cpus were out and they were pretty cool-running. Even then the ventilation wasn't ideal but with 8-9th gen cpus getting hotter, the case design was hopeless. This style case didn't stick around very long too, only about 3 years, and their current xps case is far better optimized. The design that came before was one that Dell was using for about a decade with only small internal layout adjustments.
They fixed this on newer models I believe
love you bro!
I suggest a 10mm drill bit and plenty of cooling holes
that's not a computer... that's a vacuum cleaner: loud as all hell and sucking up all the dust around itself while staying really, really hot
Like you showed, the case open keeps it cool enough. It's in fact a brilliant heatsink design, made by engineers that know heat transfer properly.
Then someone decided that airflow was NOT part of the heat transfer and took a huge dump on top of all that brilliant engineering. Thank you. Nice f**** job.
I can bet that if it had like 2 cm wider of a gap between that CPU cooling fan and the PSU, it would work well.
After the side panel was opened, I couldn't help but wonder, why is the power supply SO CLOSE to where the CPU is? As if the heat coming from the power supply weren't a big enough problem, it also looks like it's part of the restricted airflow problem!
Had a dell xps many years ago when it was a full size atx case (like mid 2000s); big cpu cooler, 2 big case fans, but no problems with staying cool.
I have an Asus G20AJ. Proprietary mainboard, proprietary cooler, requires laptop RAM and laptop optical drives. But it does keep cool at least.
What it didn‘t keep is enough space to fit Lupe‘s gi- graphics card in there. Not only that, finding a graphics card that exhausts the heat to the back is tough nowadays.
once upon a time i too bought and became highly dissatisfied with the prebuilt desktops! i decided to be a system builder and assembled them myself with every part selected by me haha
Dell is like the modern Packard Bell lol
Geez, I thought we left those designs behind in the early aughts. Reminds me of a Fujitsu-Siemens desktop unit.
It reminds me of those turbo buttons on old 486 era systems, that would clock your CPU down, if your physics were to fast in game
It's not a button, that slows your PC down when pressed, its a hinge
This bad design problem is not only limited to XPS, optiplex series suffers from same problems. I got a 9th gen running i5 and oh boy did it liked to cook stuff up. I replaced stock bs cooler and fan with a low profile 140mm fan, had to tinker a bit as that fan won't fit easily. After that I installed one small 80mm case fan powered via Sata connector and I still couldn't keep the side panel on as the temps were still high for my liking. So now instead of side panel, I installed a large mesh having sides lined by magnet to stick it there. Under load temps hover between 70 to 80 celcius, and idle the tenp is below 35. So lesson is only buy these if you're getting them dirt cheap and ready to tinker with them.
my first desktop was a 2012 Dell XPS 8700 and to say it was slow was a understatement. I tried using it as a NAS recently but the old i5 CPU is just so slow its a huge bottleneck
Omg it’s the greatest technician who ever lived on UA-cam
He answered the question as to why the Dell XPS is an "xtra piece of sh*t".
Its the Apple II computers all over again minus the tech line telling you to drop the unit just to fix it.
Wow, I'm glad I got a CyberPowerPC for my most recent computer two years ago after years of buying Dells. The circulation on this POS is atrocious.
And here I thought seeing my DIY pc temps at 70 something Celsius was something i should fix! I did, but I later found out that those aren't terrible temps for air cooling.
This issue would be solved very easily if they put a front fan, or if the heatsink is attached to some kind of guide and has more or less the same area of the upper fan. Another un-wise design consideration is the usage of a "generic form factor" PSU. Unbeliebable how they can outsource to make all sorts of components, but not a power source well suited for a compact enclosure. A complete disaster. The quality disparity in those dell computers is scary.
I had a Dell G5 5090 for a year and a half and it had a better heatsink, but it was still worse than the Intel fucking stock heatsink. That CPU (i7 9700) went to 100°C in a few seconds before its boost window ran out, and it was at around 85°C while gaming. I ended zp replacing that shotty cooler with a much better low profile one ans now I really had to try actively in order to get this thing to throttle. I left the 4500RPM 80mm case fan in because the 92mm fan I installed was quieter but also didn't move nearly enough air. The stock fan profile on mine did actually wramp both 80mm 4500RPM to 4500RPM when the CPU got close to 100°C, but they were set to take like 10s to get there slowly. It was ridiculous. The RTX 2060 it had was decent, but also had one single not-so-quirt 3600RPM fan. That luckily never had to turn up that high and the stock fan profile was okay but I ended up making a custom one. With the better CPU cooler, I could unlock my CPU'S default 75W power limit, but the VRMs couldn't handle more than 140W sustained unless the side panel was open. The max I could see in games was only around 120W, but the VRMs still mostly sat at around 90°C because they had NO COOLING ON THEM AT ALL!!! That was the reason why after only two years of owning it, I built my own PC. It was a fucking piece if garbage for my use-case (gaming mostly). It did come woth dual-channel RAM, which seems to be a premium in prebuilts nowadays, but I threw an additional 2x16GB kit in. I ended up selling that shitbix to a friend of mine that makes music and could profit from my 48GB of RAM (they were still working on a laptop with 8GB at the time)
I have heard Dell makes some good laptops.
But I've never believed that because every time I see a video talking about their PCs? Alienware or otherwise? They're just ovens.
Ovens filled with proprietary parts in a case that fits no other standard.
I've seen folks say proprietary parts aren't a big deal but, no. The company went out of their way and spent millions to design something that is harder to replace, that makes you married to that set up or the company for parts.
This rig is such a disaster and maybe those folks were right and their laptops are good- but I can't believe them because their desktops are this, bad.
The. Greatest. Technician. That's. Ever. Lived.
Bro started beefing while cooking
Funny, my 990 is rock-solid. It's also more than 12 years old.
I have a XPS 8940 from 2021, 11th gen i7. The interior is a clean layout, much different than the 8930. It still gets too hot when the GPU is maxed out. I need to added another fan to pull air in. I upgraded the CPU heatsink/fan assembly and added VRM heatsinks to try to keep this P.O.S. alive. These were Dell aftermarket/upgrades from Dell. Windows 10 Pro as supplied new has issues as sometimes after power on, one of the SSD's goes into a 100% utilization and locks the system. Other times, I press the power button, system turns on, then off. 2nd press it powers up properly. Cheap bastards did'nt even supply a HD activity light on the front panel, it's located on back! I will 'never' but another Dell XPS again. At least the Optiplex XE3 I bought years ago has been trouble free.
They really should have stuck with the design of the XPS 8300, thats what i have right now and it works fantastic! despite only using DDR3 ram and a 12 year old i7-2600 its still a nice computer
I had an XPS 8500 and it was indeed a piece of shit, I lost two motherboards and a core (idk about the other core) . I didn't know it was restarting again and again because of overheating. I didn't know much about such things back then
This is why people steer clear of pre-builts & why I haven't ever liked Dell computers
Dude, you're gettin a Dell POS!
The problem with most of dell computers is that they only have 3 fan speeds: inactive, audible and way too loud. And they use crappy loud fans and design their cases so that they accumulate a lot of dust (pull fan config). I had Inspiron 5680 with aircooler and they didn't even bother to mount vrm heatsinks (I think watercooled one had them), put ssd slot behind gpu (which wasn't such a bad thing, because when I was transfering lots of data I just turned on gpu fan and it didn't throttle). Motherboard of that piece of shit also had a feature that would check if all parts are present, which would be ok if it wasn't impossible to turn off. I replaced stock cooler for noctua nh-u9s and it kept showing message at boot that fan was not detected. And eventually I also replaced a PSU, because its fan was really loud and was making knocking sound. Then I upgraded the case and it was showing that front panel is missing (so they must have some checking if stuff is theirs). When I started using my pc as server, I had enough of those bios messages (because it didn't continue to boot, but just waited for someone to press escape) and bought a normal motherboard. I also upgraded from 2 unmatched sticks of samsung and gskill 2600 and 2400 MHz 16 gb of ram to 32 gb 3200 MHz. I also swapped stock ssd for Crucial p5 and the only original components are cpu, gpu and 1tb hdd.
TLDR: If you need a desktop PC, don't buy Dell and if you need a cheap laptop also ignore Dell and just get an older used thinkpad.
As a former dell xps helpdesk employee.. this thumbnail hit home.... These were overpriced , underengineered and just fucked by design.
This was my grandfather's computer design.
Hey now I have built a Computer I built an AMD Ryzen in 2018. I was not really happy with it because I am an Intel guy. So, I wanted an Intel i7. I found out I could buy an XPS 8930 cheaper with everything I wanted. I purchased an XPS 8930 Late 2019. Mine has been fine and it has a Different fan. Maybe I got a newer version of the XPS 8930. You are not the only one who has complained about these overheating.
I just had a look at my mother's old HP laptop, which was never particular performance oriented with a modern Pentium, however while it had a heat pipe to a small heatsink at the side, the rest of the case had absolutely no vents, so I have no idea where the air was coming from that the fan was supposed to pull, random ingress air from the gaps and the keyboard I suppose.
Lets not mention their inspiron line that when you open the laptop the screen covers the exhaust vents trapping all of the heat inside the case. You either use an external monitor or use a laptop always throttled.
I bought an XPS 17 years ago .. the motherboard failed and toasted the cpu 1 month after the warrenty ran out. I paid for new cpu, they gave me the new board. When the exact same thing happened again, i junked it and built my own ...
Buddy of mine had an XPS laptop a long while back. He said XPS stood for xpensive piece of shit. I had heard that XPS laptops are actually quite good now, but if this desktop is anything to go by...
As one of the 12 people that watch your videos, I appreciate your work!
Also: F@ck Dell...
Sincerely: One of the 12 watchers of the "Greatest Technician that's ever lived..."
I remember those Dell fans videos here on YT. 10.000rpm sounded like a jet. xD
Its almost a better option to pull the cpu, gpu, ram, storage, throw that POS case in the trash, and get a new case, motherboard, and PSU (it didn't look like that swinger special came out)
never knew dell was so bad at pc builds. Makes me glad I saved up and got someone to build one for me
at first i wanted to dislike unrecommend and report this video , thinking that they talk about much older XPS , but as i watched i realised this is similar to what i saw at Gamers Nexus and they added a CLC for the CPU . those are the only instances where i would even think of putting a CLC , considering all the flaws of this type of coolers . alternatively , Dell should've use a case like GameMax MeshBox and i'm shure they'd be fine , BUT , ANY company wants clients to buy more of their products , if you know what i mean
5:10 the Dell is about to take off.
My vacuum cleaner is quieter than that fan at full blast.
I love your videos, they make me laugh always! i am from argentina, and here the story it is so different...that pc here is a GIANT! but customers conta afford it!