Pak Army EXCLUSIVE | COAS Gen Asim Munir losing Army's confidence with nepotism
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 кві 2023
- For decades, the #pakistanarmy has managed to retain control of domestic politics and influence the country's foreign policy through its internal discipline, meritocracy and chain of command. Not anymore. Since the the exit of #coas #general #bajwa and the new set up of #genasimmunir, the country's most "organized organization" is suffering through nepotism which will likely affect the army's internal politics.
Based between New York, London and Pakistan, Emmy-nominated journalist #wajahatsaeedkhan breaks downs the latest on this issue.
Subscribe to his UA-cam at
/ wajahatskhan
Follow him on Twitter at wajskhan
Like him on Facebook at journalismwsk
Bio: Wajahat S. Khan is an Emmy-nominated journalist and author reporting on Indo-Pacific security and focusing on the Af-Pak conflict. An Adjunct Professor at New York University’s Center of Global Affairs and a Non-Resident Senior Fellow at Washington’s Atlantic Council, Khan is a graduate of the Columbia University School of Journalism and the University of Michigan, and Pakistan’s only Shorenstein Fellow from Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government. He has reported from 16 countries covering conflict, diplomacy, and media for digital, cable and network news. During the final years of U.S. military operations in Afghanistan, Khan was bureau chief in Kabul and Islamabad for NBC News, and embedded with over a hundred NATO, Afghan, Indian and Pakistani military units as he covered South Asia for leading British, Indian and Pakistani networks and publications since the beginning of the 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. He frequently dabbles in cricket, and is the author of the 2019 Amazon / Harper Collins sports bestseller, Game Changer: Being Shahid Afridi. He lives between New York City, London and Karachi and drives a very, very fast car.
When my dad was in Army, he used to talk about these issues and I remember used to get so frustrated about this mafia, now these generals have gone beyond limits, Thanks to you & media for bringing these black sheep out, hats off to you!!
Same here. Back then people used to make fun of the important issues and how political maneuvering and election rigging and lavish spending continued increasing :/.
Now, we try to defend the military in somethings in which people do fake propaganda and people keep bashing them for no logical reason even.
ان سے ہمارا معافہ. ان سے ہمارا معافہ😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Indeed. When Karachi operation cleanup was underway, we Karachi walas were ridicule and called terrorists. But only few military officers told the truth…
My brother in law is shaheed of kargirl, and the stories we were told were lies mostly lies as well.. what is astonishing the ppl of Pakistan always fell for emotional drama instead of seeking the truth and ask questions. In 2018 same establishment openly brought in IK into power and IK took all the benefits of being PM however the supporters practicing selective ignorance and allowing that man to stay relevant in Pakistani politics? Same goes for nawaz sharif’s supporters.
The only solution is to reject these politicians as soon as we establish they have take any help from the establishment. This will bring honest ppl forward into the political scene of Pakistan.
INDIAN ARMY GENERALS... How much they make and how they live, compare with Pakistani generals
ua-cam.com/video/NEA8WjKMsJ4/v-deo.html
I don't think he has brought anything out. What he has said is open knowledge in Pakistan. The problem is no one can do anything about it.
The power of social media…. Cannot imagine this going public few Years ago…unimaginable
majority on social media is always idiot,, cause you will notice they can't even do their OWN research!
100% Agreed.
Agreed 👍 👍 👍
And no proof whatsoever needed. Lovely eh 😂
Army vs Poor people
Thank you for speaking openly about the mother of all issues in Pakistan
Thanks Wajat for this in-depth analysis. I think Pak Army has already lost its image of respect among its public. Now, Nepotism, favoritism have become a pre condition for transfer and promotion in higher rank. This could be the first step in making PAK ARMY Punjab police.
blame only corrupt generals, not the whole Army
Unfortunately Army is going down to drain but it’s taking the whole country with them shame on them 😡thanks for the honest analysis stay safe 🇵🇰🇨🇦
People of Pakistan have essentially been living a lie all these years. It’s one of the most brutal and self serving armies in the world.
Repercussions of decisions made during last 10 years..
Was always in the drain abhi manhole ka cover khula hai
blame only corrupt generals, not the whole Army
Army was my love, but now it's a very sad situation 😢
Eventually your mind is more wider to accept the harsh reality of this land .... unfortunately ....
Army corrupt nhi, kuch Seniors corrupt hen. We love our Army ❣️⚔️🇵🇰
you do know that many soldiers are being martyred every single day in different parts of the country but unfortunately no one is showing that ;/
blame only corrupt generals, not the whole Army
@@jahanzaibbaloch2218khan ko goud mein utha ker choomiyan dete thay tab tum sab k abbu thay na army walay itni aukaat agar Hai na sarhad per jao sambhalo aik raat mulk ye UA-camrs dollars kamatay jhoot or nafrat phila ker yaad rakhna aik aik ko khuda ne naisto nabood kerna Hai kyun k es mulk ki hifazat ki zimaydari khuda ne khud li Hai in logon ko to ye mitti apnay seenay mein jaga tak na de gi
بہت خوب زبردست تجزیہ کوئی دورائے نہیں سو فیصد اتفاق کرتے ہیں
Pak Army has been the culprit from its inception. After British left Pakistan was colonized by Army starting from 1954. It’s always been like that, it’s just that social media has opened our eyes.
ملک اور قوم کے ڈوبنے میں کوئی کمی نہیں رہ گئی
absolutely agreed! Army isn't just an institution but a symbol. Nepotism was the reason every civilian institute is destroyed. However, the army has to stop this from spreading now and now.
Unbelievable! Simply painful situation 🥲🥲🥲
We always thought that army was most competent and professional institution but turns out its quite opposite. The nepotism, favouritism and power grabbing tactics has ruined the repute of army. People are now questioning the role of Army and ISI openly and are very disappointed. A love story turning into a hate story. Unfortunate!
Exactly 💯
زمانہ جاہلیت میں اکثر پاکستانی یہی سوچتے تھے 😂
Actually rephrase “Pakistani’s thought it was their army you also believe Pakistan ka matlib إله إلا الله 😅😅😅. The rest of the world knows the truth, but at least it only took you 75yrs to figure it out. 😅😅
@@taameer_sohail or ab wo yad ker k apna aap bewaqoof lgta hy
They are simply business dealers, and agents who do anything for money. Occupied large lands of Our country Pakistan for their personal business.
The fact is that Mr. Bajwa has destroyed the very fabric of Pakistan defence forces.
Gen bajwa destroyed only the army, not the defence forces. Thank God, Airforce and Navy are saved from his evil plans and dirty games.
We all blame him when the seeds were sown at least as back as Zia ul Haq
True
Bajwa general faiz and Imran khan also
@@QasimAli-dd9eu Why Imran Khan?
Indeed your mention of field marshal shaib touched my heart I come from an entire family every uncle my father and all known friends of the family of the wardee clan and I failed my physical exam because of a heart murmur to go to the PMA and asked my father to intervene and he refused so heartbroken was I that I left the country for the next 3 decades but truly I have lived with heartache for not being a a part of the family of the armed forces till these last few months and today I am with out that pain I carried all my life of missing out my purpose of serving my nation but with all that said this lot has broken my heart and continues to do so with each passing day seems like I have lost a near loved one .Alas it must be the reality of the times and the calibre of people and such is the leadership.
Thanks for telling us your story, no doubt emotions dictate false narratives based on individual experience
I fully share your sentiments as I applied for the airforce in September 1965 and was rejected but ISSB Kohat approved me for induction the army which I did not accept. I proceeded to UK and live in the USA but always thought that maybe i should have joined the army. But after observing the army for all these years I am now glad I did not and Bajwa has certainly been the nail in the coffin as they say. My dad joined the Pakistan National Guard after partition as a major and resigned because of certain inappropriate actions of a colonel who he caught red-handed and questioned him. The army has lost all respect with the average Pakistani no one I know supports the army anymore.
Wajahat S. Khan, your coverage is a gem of a quality. Your voice and open presentation of issues are commendable. Having studied and lived in U.S., you’ve seen the best of the western world. Ultimately, you know good and bad of both the world.
I’ve been in the U.S. since 1978 and like your views.
🌺🌷❤️🍀👏🙏🙏
Jubilant to see that Wajahat is analyzing situation very smartly and boldly. It takes a lot of courage to do that these days. Hats off!
He isn't talking from Pakistan!😐
He's in London
😂😂😂
Crisp, Straight forward & eye opener Vlog for the establishment, Indian dream has been turning into a reality, a weakened, divided Army.
Once again, can not stress this enough, thanks for taking time and keeping us all in the loop/know
As i know pak army, these things was happening alot before but we dont want to listen them but nowww when we found out that it was one sided love affair now we start accepting these things😊
This is rightly said that this Army has become a very unprofessional and undisciplined force based on nepotism and favoritism.😊
You've hit the nail on the head company use to be plc and now its being run as private limited Co.
Soon the generals will be sqeaky cleaning for sharifs like punjab police.
Lt Col and Above level only.....
There is no such thing. Army is as professional as it was. It is nothing but speculation. Khan has created an environment of Blame game and then the six generation warfare from outside has taken over.
Nepotism and favoritism is a cancer that destroys institutes and countries...
@@amitbfl Well Pak Army is only brave and ruthless when it comes to fight with India.... Thats why Indians always remain in fear and panic from it.....
Thank you Wajahat S. Khan! This Corruption is a complex issue that can have significant negative impacts on society, including political instability, economic inefficiency, and social inequality. Understanding the causes and consequences of this type of corruption is essential for combating this problem and promoting transparency and accountability in PAKISTAN ARMY institution.
INDIAN ARMY GENERALS... How much they make and how they live, compare with Pakistani generals
ua-cam.com/video/NEA8WjKMsJ4/v-deo.html
😂😂😂😂😂
It's everywhere.... Even in states
Painfully very true face of Pakistan Army... May Allah keep our country safe from these hypocrites and hidden enemies of their own nation.
They are getting exposed thanks to electronic and social media. They think they can keep on doing the same as it was 20 years ago without any loss in popularity.
Thanks for an amazing analysis.
Another mind blowing analysis on the current situation by WSK sir keep up the good work
You are showing us the true face of pak army. It's one hell of a thing to do. I always feel sad to say what they did to arshad sharif. Stay safe and keep up the good work❤
true face,
seen you own true face,, flawless right ! ?
@@amitbfl lol this army was still able to serve some fantastic tea so based on that how bad is your indian army if in your own words this sad state of an army is able to distroy your jets
@@amitbflyour army is no saint you indian get a life
@@ibrahimkayani2824yes they are only good for serving tea, not for fighting. Even a ragtag TTP pokes fun at the Pak army's fighting abilities. Pak army's core competence lies in running businesses and serving tea, not in fighting.
70 saal or intezar kr lete to baat Zara or wazeh hojati
Thank you so much for the bold and detailed coverage of Pak politics. AM and the few like him have ruined all the hopes and aspirations of the Pakistani people. 😢
Well done bro, this is 2nd vlog in a row you have produced in which I can find no flaws, nor any grounds for suspicion!!....I'm thinking that perhaps this holy month is having a positive and enlightening subliminal impact on your thinking...I really hope that you can keep up this good analytical form in coming vlogs also bro... 👌🏻💥👌🏻
when they started targeting journalists and punjabi politicians only then you realized who the evil was. Baloch and KPK/ FATA were screaming to tell you, but you all didn't listen. Karma !
💯
Yuppp ❤❤
Yes, we never beleive our ISI was ding so unless the same game started in Punjab. It exposed that even bangali were true in their complaint. We all very unforunate having such an ISI.
💯%
Wrong,wrong ,,,,i stand with all victims of cruelty. Who ever.
But these issues will not be bothered by these egoist generals
Finally WSK in his own۔ Stay blessed۔ May Allah protect you from all evils۔Ameen۔
You Are Doing Great Work 👍
Wajahat Bhai, it's really painful to hear it all. Like u, all patriots r deeply worried sad state of affairs
Nice to hear from a educated analyst
He doesn't tell the full story deliberately.
@@hashimawan2433 jitni batai hai that is enough
Really disappointed to see such a situation in Pakistan May Allah help our country 😑
We were blinded by sheer love and respect for our armed forces.
It's so disheartening to find the real truth about the top brasses of the military.
I protested like hell when one of my uncles refused to fill in the admission form for the reason that looked unreal in 1981.
*"Army is no longer a place to Serve".*
_I didn't believe him, at then, but now I am thankful for his sincere advice._
It’s what happens when you live a life without questioning or being curious about anything.
Mr. Wajahat Khan great in depth analysis thanks for posting it. You are correct in describing the current Pakistan Army leadership’s weaknesses. Unfortunately, Pakistan never had a taste of a true democracy. Military dictatorship with each dictator implementing his own policies to run the country has damaged their (Army) ability to demonstrate professionalism. It will take decades for Army to fix this OR if this continues Army will be responsible for the situation. Economic crisis coupled with law and order situation in Pakistan and Army top brass doing what you described is nothing other than a recipe of disaster.
Thank you Wajahat Sahab for sharing the truth narrative of COAS, Allah bless you with his blessings and prayers for giving courage to face the bad deeds.
You know its a good start to your day here in Australia when you’ve got a glass of long black in your hands caffeine is starting to kick in and this guy is playing in the background. Doesn’t get better than this. Keep it going my man.
Sad state of affairs…don’t know who and how this will get fixed
We the people of Pakistan are helpless but we have complete faith and belief that Allah Almighty will Protect our country and our people from all the hypocrites and traitors whosoever they are. Inshallah
حسبي الله ونعم الوكيل، توكل على الله، لا حول ولاقوة الابالله العلي العظيم
Army itself needs to stop following illegal orders
First, you have your own grave. You will not be asked what Nawaz Sherif did or someone else did. YOU are responsible for YOU.
Second, civilizations rise, decay, fall and then may rise again and go through this cycle. Tough times create good men. Good men created good times. Good times create weak men! Weak men create misery. Only CONSTANT is: Allah SWT is a Victor Undefeated!
Lastly, be content with what Allah SWT sends your way and you have conquered ALL time and mastered Universal Wisdom!
May Allah SWT open our hearts and minds to ULTIMATE reality and not get stuck in who will fix who!
Ameen!
Your care for good Muslim nation and agony that is does not materialize will not go unawarded! Guarantee!
Justice
Accountability
merit
no corruption
No bribing
is the main thing if these are in the foundation of the nation then nation succeed
Great analysis. It is real unrest within their own establishment.
Thank you for Very critical brave and strong analysis.
Well done man. Unfortunately these generals have destroyed the whole country. What so you described that is true ground reality. When we will see the accountability of these generals
Kya koi bata sakta hain
Pakistan me retirement ka kya processes hai
Captain kitni Age ne retired hote hai ?
Major kitni Age kitni age me retired hote hain ?
Lieutenant colonel kitni age me retired hote hai
😂😂😂 galiya khani hai
I love the way he refers to the people " bloody civilians"
Great analysis as usual. Really liked the way you connected the dots and built up an analysis. It seems like you got a new fan :)
Very good analysis. Army Gens are losing their credibility and integrity very rapidly.
We know Asim Munir is a Nawaz man .Bajwa/ Nawaz nexus,appointed after retirement
You are literally true bro Army lose their accountability day by day May Allah get rid from corrupt generals🙏
Recently my cousin came from a cadet college. He told the situation about a lot of bad activities happening there.
فوج کے اندر سے بغاوت اور انقلاب کے امکان کو مسترد نہیں کیا جا سکتا خدا را اتنا ظلم نا کیا جائے
فوج کے اندر سے بغاوت اور انقلاب کے امکان کو مسترد نہیں کیا جا سکتا خدا را اتنا ظلم نا کیا جائے
Establishment reputation is down ever in the history. There is no honor exist in the hearts of nation for Pak-army.
Well Done WSK we need more people to openly talk like this so that our nation have the knowledge that what's going on in there behind the curtains and I really think the day is about to come soon when the rotten eggs of Army will be accountable.
Lucid , brilliant exposition, eminently listenable!
Thanks young man for straight forward views and facts ... Our motherland is melting, those took oath to obey and guard our constitution and land failed or became sold out cheap commodities ...
Very good information, but sad to hear about army integrity
What you Sow so shall you Reap....Jai Hind and Pakistan should face The Music....we Indians are enjoying your discomfiture...Vande Mataram and to Hell with your Ghazwa-E-Hind...if you have the courage then come,we shall not disppoint you Guys and in Particular this Wajahat Khan.....I know the likes of him...he stinks....
INDIAN ARMY GENERALS... How much they make and how they live, compare with Pakistani generals
ua-cam.com/video/NEA8WjKMsJ4/v-deo.html
No words. Simply the best one
Not a single respectable family wants their kids in pak army which is very unfortunate. Wajahat I really respect urs inner side view. Keep it up buddy. U r a real soldier of Pakistan
Walikumasalam
Yes Pak Army has become Punjab police, Its time for GHQ, to take strict action against illegal actions, armed forces of Pakistan once loved by people, but now , it shows fascism, wrong actions within or out of Pakistan, thanks for truthful analysis 👍🇵🇰
Great job my son God bless you. Pakistan 🇵🇰 Zandabad.
I pray and wish for your safety and security.
Very credible information which is core base of an independent journalist. Really appreciable and we believe that Ppl of Pakistan must be updated about such information in future also. Excellent
Disgrace is the only word one can say
Mr. Khan- I believe you are an investigative reporter therefore can you please do a video on why the Army Generals are in bed with corrupt, criminal politicians? Since everything revolves around money, what financial benefit/gain is there for these generals?
Well done for covering
Well done
Court-Martial for Bajwa & Co.
What a Brave man you are!!!!!
❤❤ I salute u as a retired military uniform person u brave and true ainker I have been closely observing situation sine 1976 shockingly saying injustice is there Sir only blood revolution is solution Only at the end u absolutely right ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bravo WSK. I had some suspicions about claims made by Aadil Raja. You have totally exposed the 2x culprits who have undoubtedly sold out their souls to the devil. Pak Army had always been our romance but the same is steadily eroding with every sun set. May Allah Kareem protect the Army, its Jawans & Young Officers from the greed & nepotism of the Chief.
Pak army was once my best army and i feel so proud of them. Now hearing all their backdoor plans the respect has gone down a lot. The soilders might be still patrotic but upper officers are so currupt, polluted and became too involve in others privacy which is not their job. Their intellectual level is gone down specially bajwa and this current hafiz guy. They talk also no one finds any roob and dabdaba.
blame only corrupt generals, not the whole Army
Bravo!
Very well said!
❤ I agree with your assessment one hundred percent.
Keep up the good work.
Fauj was like this since the beginning, only difference is that people have social media for awareness and to know the truth.
پاکستان زندہ باد
Well done ❤
Rana is hindu rajput surname
Your true words today. We want a Army Chief like Imran Khan who will never support corrupt people.
Great analysis.
It’s really alarming for the Pakistani military that sincere intellectual like WAJAHAT is raising questions on Army.
Excellent analysis
WSK , we are impatiently waiting for the report card ♦️ . Thank you so much for your efforts ❤
We are trained to stand with the righteous , so everyone in senior position has to be mindful of this
اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو اپنی حفظ و امان میں رکھے آمین ثم آمین
Millions salutes for you Wajahat Bhai for telling us bitter truth and putting yourself in danger
You’re one of the most daring and Casual journalist with dignity and bravery
Keep doing your best for the Country 🇵🇰🫡💪
Can someone name the son in law of asim and brother of Bajwa.. We need to make it public
You are absolutely right bro
Impressed by the way you are explaining terms 👏
And this COAS is just getting on the nerves seriously..
Kya koi bata sakta hain
Pakistan me retirement ka kya processes hai
Captain kitni Age ne retired hote hai ?
Major kitni Age kitni age me retired hote hain ?
Lieutenant colonel kitni age me retired hote hai
Brother salute to your braveness
YA ALLAH PAKISTANI FOUJJ KO INN CORRUPT LOGON SE BACHA AMEEN 🤲🤲🤲😢😢😢😢😢🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
buchana kya ha vohi tou in logo ko la k bethay ae hn ajj tak😅
@@Whitepearl215 samja nhi brother
Pagal na banian. Royal army is the problem. Ttp matlad Islam zindabad.
PAK FOUJ ITSELF IS MOST-CORRUPT !!!
ALLAH INSE PAKISTAN KO BACHAAE !!!
Stay safe bro, you've taken a bold stance
We stand with Imran Khan Sahab ♥️ pakistan Zindabad ✊🇵🇰
I been looking for you luckily found you again. You have best analysis when it comes to Army and their relations .
Bound to rise . ❤
Jazak Allah khairan for spreading Truth and Knowledge. May Allah SWT bless you and all patriotic Pakistanis. Aamin
Ameen Ya Rab Al Alameen ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Very insightful update. Thanks for sharing.
More power to you, WSK 💪 Pakistan Zindabad
An Army loses its credibility and respect when it does any thing against the will of the nation, when it supports criminals, bring them in power as a Dummy.
It will take decades of decades to restore the reputation and respect of Pakistan Army...💔💔💔
Wow... You add a completely different flavour to the precedings......respect
حقیقی آزادی کے تمام مجاہدین کو قوم کا سلام ہے وہ دن دور نہیں جب آزادی کا سورج طلوع ہوگا اور عوام اپنے حقوق و عظمت گروہ یزید سے چھین کر آزادی کا پرچم لہرا ئے گی اور اپنے مستقبل کی محافظ خود بنے گی انشاءاللہ
Powerful analysis 👍🏻Bravo
Thank you for aware us.
Wasn’t the appointment of the COAS Asim Munir illegal considering he was a retired Lieutenant General in the first Place.
Who the hell told you that he was retired ??😂😂🤦♂️
Yes
@@cibtehacan no amount of your whaboutery is going to change the fact that he was not officially retired. He was a serving Lt general when he was promoted to 4 star general and subsequently appointed Army Chief. this was all as per the Army Act.
@@cibtehacan also kindly go check when he was promoted to Lt gen (Sept 2018) and thereafter he took command as Lt General two months later
@@wkhan5 youthiyon ko ye baten maj adil raja btata hy
WSK great research 💯 % agree.
Well done CJ Omer Atta! Military Establishment should live within Law and Constitution. No more Badmashi acceptable. Let Pakistan grow, Establishment should stop their Treason to Pakistan.