From Inside GHQ | COAS Gen. Asim Munir's 4-Month Report Card
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 кві 2023
- It's been four months since #Pakistan's #COAS #genasimmunir assumed office as the country's most powerful man. But is he up for the job? Gen Munir has rapidly lost more traction within the Pakistani military as well as in the court of public opinion due to his support for the inept and unpopular PDM government. Will his falling popularity affect Pakistan's domestic, security and foreign policies?
Based between New York, London and Pakistan, Emmy-nominated journalist #wajahatsaeedkhan breaks downs the latest on this issue.
Subscribe to his UA-cam at / wajahatskhan
Follow him on Twitter at wajskhan
Like him on Facebook at journalismwsk
Bio: Wajahat S. Khan is an Emmy-nominated journalist and author reporting on Indo-Pacific security and focusing on the Af-Pak conflict. An Adjunct Professor at New York University’s Center of Global Affairs and a Non-Resident Senior Fellow at Washington’s Atlantic Council, Khan is a graduate of the Columbia University School of Journalism and the University of Michigan, and Pakistan’s only Shorenstein Fellow from Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government. He has reported from 16 countries covering conflict, diplomacy, and media for digital, cable and network news. During the final years of U.S. military operations in Afghanistan, Khan was bureau chief in Kabul and Islamabad for NBC News, and embedded with over a hundred NATO, Afghan, Indian and Pakistani military units as he covered South Asia for leading British, Indian and Pakistani networks and publications since the beginning of the 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. He frequently dabbles in cricket, and is the author of the 2019 Amazon / Harper Collins sports bestseller, Game Changer: Being Shahid Afridi. He lives between New York City, London and Karachi and drives a very, very fast car.
Kudos to social media for speaking the utter truth. Downfall of generals is inevitable
tm yoothiaoon ko fouj is waja sai buri lag rhi hai ku kai fouj imran khan ko ab support nhi kar rhi hai aur is dirty politics sa bahir hogai isleya tm yoothia bila waja fouj per jhootay ilzam lagatay hoo unper hamlay kartay ho apni gandi politics kai chakar main tm ghatiya logoon nai fouj jasay Pakistan ke security ka most important institution ko badnam kardeya tm ghatiya logoon ko sharam ani cahiya
tm yoothiaoon ko fouj is waja sai buri lag rhi hai ku kai fouj imran khan ko ab support nhi kar rhi hai aur is dirty politics sa bahir hogai isleya tm yoothia bila waja fouj per jhootay ilzam lagatay hoo unper hamlay kartay ho apni gandi politics kai chakar main tm ghatiya logoon nai fouj jasay Pakistan ke security ka most important institution ko badnam kardeya tm ghatiya logoon ko sharam ani cahiya
Asim Muneer is slave of Maryam Nawaz
Yes. Of those who initiated and played fake Tabdeeli project.
How do you know it is truth?
Next level journalism, WSK! I can say with high degree of confidence that you always come with a great homework! Appreciate your work!
Easy to point fingers on others
WSK is running successfully the campaign of IK along-with Raja Adil
Spot on, he knows Adil Raja stuff is selling at the moment so he has jumped on the band wagon. Cheap journalism.
@@tanzilmalik2850 very true 💯/ all traitors are gathered for personal Gain ALLAH Pak hidayat de 🤲
شروع میں مجھے لگا کہ آپ کبھی بھی فوج کے بارے میں بات نہیں کرو گے۔ لیکن آپ نے اپنے آپ کو پاکستان کے ساتھ کھڑا کر کے بہت بہادری کا ثبوت دیا۔ سلام ہے آپکو بھائ 👌🇵🇰👌
Im 67 llive in Calgary Canada. I love yours, Adil Rajas, Imram R. Khans Vlogs just started watching recently and impatiently awit for the next one.
ALLAH BLESS PAKISTAN ALL OF YOU AND THE AWAM OF PAKISTAN.
AAMEEN SUMMA AAMEEN. ❤
Even a brave man like you is talking about all of this mess after going abroad but you were unable to talk that freely when you were in Pakistan, this shows how brave Arshad Sharif was he did not stop talking the truth before and after regime change, lost his life but did not give up.
tum sy tu sb hi behtr hy tum tu nam tk nai likh skty comments my pattu kahi ky🤣🤣
Every big mouth and dirty tongue is called brave strange 🤐🤫
We are up to our necks iwith these army officers. The romance over for the political .goonsin khaki by thebloody civilians.
@@Nothing...555 If that's the case Maryam Safdar is the bravest🤣🤣
@@afaq3053 Yes you are right she is
You summed up the problem of Pakistan. And nice of you to point the direction for some who matter. Stay blessed❤
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
This is called brilliant journalist... You always impress us by your work... You always have inside information... May Allah protect you.
ہم کھڑے تھے ، ہم کھڑے ہیں ، ہم کھڑے رہیں گے ، یقین کے ساتھ ، ایمان کے ساتھ ، پاکستان کے ساتھ ، عمران خان کے ساتھ ، ان شاء اللہ✌️🇵🇰🇵🇹
Thank You for the report card that was exactly what we wanted to hear. Pakistan Zindabad.
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
To stop these Generals working against Pakistan, they must be brought under justice and should be held accountable. Otherwise they will never stop.
I used to fight my peers who used to talk like you. I used to tell my wife that I was meant to be a soldier, but now, because of these generals, I hate it. Salute to the soldier but hate these corrupt officers. 😤
Wow! This is amazing analysis of a COAS, who is not acting for the nation or his citizens!
More power to you WSJ.
Stay safe,Stay blessed,Stay strong.
WSJ = Wall Steet Journal
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
Thank you Wajahat Bhai for giving us the insight of the current crisis in the country. I always wait for your video. Good work👏🏻
Excellent vloging
How is Asif Ghafoor doing ??
ua-cam.com/users/shorts2CngE627NpM?feature=share4
پاکستان زندہ باد ❤️ 🇵🇰 اسلام زندہ باد ❤️ pak army zindabad 🇵🇰
JazakAllah khayr
Allah bless you and protect you.
حافظ قرآن تو یزید بھی تھا
قوم نے ان سے بہت محبت کی مگر افسوس انہوں نے سب پامال کر دیا
In internal politics he deserves big F not D
About a dozen army generals need to publicly court marshalled for the atrocities and extra judicial killings.
100% agree this needs to happen. The only army chief in recent history that I think is good and mohib E watan is general Raheel Sharif. The others like Bajwa and kiyani were American slaves.
Agree
@@siriussaracen8371 Even he was debatable. Recording of private videos was going on even during his tenure.
Make it a couple of dozens
@@siriussaracen8371 raheel khabis dushman hai ham pashtun aur baloch ka khanzir insan hai
Masha Allah wajaht Sahib. Your analysis, your unique style, your knowledge, your confidence is Allah's gift.
Thank you for providing us the information we would never be able to have without you.
You and Moeed Pirzada are my favourites.
Dear Wajahat, just discovered your channel. I love fact based analysis! thanks a lot for your effort and sincere analysis/opinion.
What a candid and accurate Report Card!
Well done Wajahat Sb
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
D
Salute to you brother for bringing reality to us. All the information is necessary for the public to know what actually is happening especially with our taxes!
It’s very simple … army is corrupt
@@goldenboots507 The direct and indirect taxes which we are paying for our country's development but are not using in this way so wasting in wrong decisions, bad management, elite politics and their enjoyments then ultimately we have to go to the IMF so then again we have to pay the more taxes in term of petrol levy, utilities etc on the behalf of their mismanagement to acquire the loan so this incompetence cycle should be stop 🛑
@@goldenboots507 1% this is a big kid joke and i don't believe on this so called 1% myth. Every person is paying taxes may it's direct or indirect so are you not buying petrol with taxes? So how can you say 1%.
@@goldenboots507you need too much. Those who are not paying taxes this is not my duty to collect tax so this is the incompetency of government but we middle class are paying heavily and in return zero benefits.
@@goldenboots507 your thinking and mental level is really like your name boot 👢 because you are living in world of fool and you are reluctant to raise voice on basic rights so no need of further arguments🙏
It is absolutely daring and ballsy to really say all that you said. Wajahat, you are doing what even great scholars of Islam couldn't do back in the 13th Century or Bahadur Shah Zafar couldn't do in the 19th Century: taking a stand against injustice and tyranny. I have massive respect for you. May Allah save you from the spite of these worldly monsters. May Allah protect you.
Great Sir well done salmat rahio
Comments under your video are the pulse of the people. Sadly our Army Chief is the most hated person amongst our youth 😔
Wajhet should become Cheif himself
@@zahidabbass1919 😂
Let me say Not the youth but all the Pakistanis detest General Asim Munir because being a nominetee by Nawaz Sharif he is brutaly dealing with Imran Khan,s supporters.
They worked hard for that reputation.
Nope, that is not the case he is just doing his job and not interfering in anyone else's job, he is doing good in defense that's all. He is not serving Imran or anyone else but the state and that is why Imran has unleashed all kinds of propaganda against him.
Hands down; You can’t analyze better than this. You add the numbers/grades to anything and the universe start to make sense.
Son keep writing we love your v logs
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
WSK bhai! Salute to you for the top info.. keep up the brilliant work.. May ALLAAH swt protect guide & protect. Ameen!
Hahaha Shutongra ?
ISI Wala Dogi ?
OMG🧐, what a great analysis with strong evidence, facts, and figures
Excellent journalism skills 👏 maximum respect for your efforts and bold comments keep it up sir Pakistan 🇵🇰 zindabad
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
You broke a news which even Adil's Khamoosh Mujahids probably did not know. It really shook me to know a QMG was running a parallel intelligence network
Adil goes out of control many times it appears he is doing one sided propoganda .. after his khamosh mujahid reference comes 90 percent lies that's why he appears irrevelant that's why I stopped taking him seriously infact wajahat moed peerzada and haidar mehdi are very much analytic and relevant
The likelihood that the QMG all this while was also directing the films along with the stinking harries; Bajwa, though confesses he was the video specialist
@WSK: May Allah Protect and Bless You and Your Family Always. Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰💚 Indeed To Allah We Shall Return.
What a realistic, informative vlog by a knowledge patriotic Pakistani.
Very much appreciated.
Excellent Analysis. Really good and full of information. You get A+ Mr. Wajahat for this VLog
Keep working independently my support always with you ❤
Always
yes even if you criticise khan still but independently not Imranophobia 😉😉
@@WajahatSKhan pet's are always pet's congrats Jew's successful lobbing
WSK what a wonderful wonderful analytical views? Allah bless you, it may open eyes, ears and minds of generals in GHQ who are servant and guardian of this country.
Well done for speaking the truth. Hats off
Thank You for the report card that was exactly what we wanted to hear.
Pakistan Zindabad
Thanks, Champ. This RC got me in trouble though!
Great analysis. It seems very close to reality👍
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
Insha Allah Allah Imran Khan ko kamyab karay ga insha Allah Imran is a great leader not a politician love you sir Imran Khan ❤❤❤❤
I got to know more about GHQ and ISI how it works within the institution because of the Report Card your given grades are accurate .Every Mahaz is excellent and on the top your casual style ( Quetta wala) MashaAllah Stay safe ,healthy and blessed Aameen
I am happy to listen to you as you are bringing more factual informations with daring and vocal way
I liked his Karachi vlog
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
Very bold and thought provoking analysis.
Excellent vlog. Keep it up Wajahat. It requires huge courage to upload such analysis, especially in this tough time
Ya Allah Wajahat S Khan jaisey Beton ki hifazat farma Ameen 🤲🤲🤲🤲😢😢😢🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Keep up the good work the true Patriot and son of the soil.
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
What a superb report card. Bravo
Another brilliant episode. Thank you sir Wajahat.
A few questions for you if you can address them in your subsequent vlogs.
1. Do you think the current army chief has made some compromising promises to the external powers along the line of Bajwa doctrine i.e. recognition of Israel, compromise on Kashmir policy, drone passage etc.?
2. What could the Sharifs and Zardaris have on the current army chief? I know you did mention it will come out someday. Hoping you could break it for us soon. No pressure.
3. Do you not think he has simply failed to put his country and the Army as an institution before his personal vendetta against Imran Khan and there should get a ‘F’ and do a ‘D’.
4. Why so many (not all) Pakistani army officials can be easily compromised against the country they are supposed to protect and who are supposed to be the most trust worthy.
5. Is corruption deeply rooted in Pakistan Army and if so what can done done about it. There are several books written on all the businesses they run. Why? Even Bajwa was not interested is persecuting the corrupt politicians. Why? Could Arshad Sharif’s documentary (apparently it was going to be on Netflix) have anything to do with his murder? Haven’t heard much about that documentary after his death.
6. Do they listen to your vlogs?
7. Be safe please.
Jaza klAllah o khair
impressed by the investigative journalism of his appointment, you need to tell us the details. Very well summarised, Very accurate. Please beware of Black Vigo
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
ہمیشہ وہی لوگ یا صحافی سچائی سامنے رکھتے ہیں جو حقیقتاً محب وطن ہوتے ہیں سچ کڑوا ضرور ہوتا ہے مگر ٹھیک سمت کا تعین ضرور کردیتا ہے
پاکستان زندہ باد
The problem doesn’t simply come from the army, the politicians, or the judiciary, and how they have made a mess of the country. They have been able to do this because no one has held them accountable, until now. It’s now or never.
SHAME ON GHQ+PDM
Awesome work wajahat bro god bless u ❤❤❤
Educative and very informative you are truly an investigative journalist waiting for more WSK
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
what a balanced and reality based opinion hats off
Amazing analysis indeed, to the core matter of fact especially the last closing just nailed it. Keep them coming these Bold journalism. Good job
Good analysis and grading as usual! jazakum Allaah(swt) khair
لاجواب زبردست 💪💪👏👏👏👏
You have so much information and experience in the field of journalism
You had a hit show on TV
Love your style and truthfulness
I wish and pray for your long life and a prosperous future
Qualified person like you should have a position in the next government to help the nation
No doubt about it
Brilliant defence journalist Pakistan has ever produced, outstanding and pragmatic analysis. Hats off to you Wajahat, real inspiration for IR and media students.
This is what THE REPORT CARD well said
You’re absolutely right
Another excellent episode. Keep up the good work Wajahat .
Great job Wajahat - you explained everything so well and connected all the dots.
I always found you a brave Journalist ❤love you dear
Stay blessed Wajahat bhai. The way you speak, apnay apnay lagtay hain. And thanks for speaking up always.
Always thank you for splashing the inside information, great independent analysis.
Pakistan zindabad
One more outstanding Vlog, full of information with reality based. 🙌👏 General Asim I’d clue less what to do n just fulfilling PDM wishes as some SHO do for his appointers.
WK zabardast maloomat ka shukria.
Always wait for your vlog love the way you explain everything keep it up 👍
وجاہت بھائی۔۔۔۔قوم اب loc والے باتوں میں نہی آنے والی۔۔۔۔بہت ڈرامے رچائے ائ ایس پی آر کی طرف سے۔کبھی ملی نغمے،ترانے،ڈرامے،فلمز،پر کوئ اعتبار نہی کرتے۔
😊😊😊😊 right 👍😮
Spot on Report card. Journalism on point. Way to go, WSK!
واہ۔ زبردست تجزیہ 👍
Ab to mulk ka Allah hi hafiz hay
From Norway
powerful series of Vlogs Wajahat, simply hooked on them, please make more.
WSK you are by far the ‘best’ in explaining the current socio political situation inclining with the military mindset analysis
More power to you
Continue
May Almighty protect you from evils!
More power to you for speaking the truth.. Stay blessed.. and keep telling the truth to the people of Pakistan.
So impressive 👏👏 bravo 👍 great analysis 💯
In a famous play enttitled Dr Faustus the protagonist Faustus makes a deal with the devil for ultimate power and wealth and afterwards a good angel visits Faustus and tells him to review the deal and repent but Faustus says"My heart is hardened i cannot repent" Like Faustus our military,bureaucratic and political elites hearts have been hardened and their lust for power and money have made them indifferent to the hardships of common pakistanis.
TRULY SPOKEN ....... YOU are expressing my thoughts .....
Brutally straight forward.. respect ✊
Army Chief should stay in his limits he’s just a 22grade officer 🙄they r their to serve the country and people so Asim Munir stay in your limits along with your corrupt mafia 🤨we all Pakistanis local and overseas support and stand with Imran Khan 👍🏻🇵🇰🇨🇦.. thanks for the honest analysis stay safe 👍🏻
Who are you pick up your overseas ghamand and get lost shame on you
Just 22 scale officer kisi bhi institution me bn kr dikhao batein krni asan hain 😂😂😂
@@ammarhabib5471 oh really how u can say that do u know me 🙄stop being a tout of corrupt mafia 🤨
@@sabeennoor8152Imran khan is just another guy who would not be able to make a difference trust me he is not that capable he can just speak and say big things he is not that great of a statesman . It's just our public is quite foolish and ignorant they are always lured by politicians and military leadership wether it Bhutto or nawaz sharif or Musharraf or even Zia ul haq they have always been the same and our bholi bhaali awaam would always do victim blaming never understand Thier flaws and problems and hypocrisy where do these generals come from they are also part of this country how many buerucrates honest to Thier jobs how many govt professor's and doctors do Thier jobs correctly whoever gets money finds haram ways of earning more power and money this is the sad story of Pakistan Kaisi bhagairat or munafiq qoum Hoti hai hukamran waisa hi hotay hain phir fouj bhi waisi hi Hoti hai . These matters are extremely deep and if you start looking at connections between different matters whether related to defence healthcare leadership politics or smuggling theya relinked together and the perpetrators and handlers of these dirty games are all Pakistanis most of them coming from humble backgrounds turning Thier head away from country and religion.
Finally the report card
عمران خان کے ایک درباری کا انعام کی امید میں بڑی محنت سے لکھا گیا تجزیہ ،،، ٹیکنیکل خوشامد کی یہ شاندار تصویر
appreciated for being straight forward .
Very well disclosed sir, more power to you.
Great job Wajahat.. logical analysis
Excellent!!! Amazing analysis, full of information. You get A+ 😊.
Wow, thanks!
Well done Mr wajaht Khan nice to see u after a long time now I will see ur v, and logs regularly u r one of my fav people looking forward to seeing your next report card Masha Allah looking with great spirit.👍
سر آپ سے درخوست ہے کہ میجر راجہ صاحب کے ساتھ ملکر ایک پرگرام ضرور کریں پلیز
Right 👍🌹
17:00 report starts
Wahajid know sb I salute you for being a honourable Journilist. Pakistan 🇵🇰 Zandabad.
آپ کلمہ ء حق میں اس لیول پہ آ چکے ہین کہ آپ پہ رشک آتا ہے۔
زبردست وجاہت!
Really likee your report card...
I wish one day you will be holding decision making post in pakistan..ameen!
True n very absolute report card...WSK.... BRAVO
😂😂
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
Thank you
Allah Pak Bless You Wajahat Sahib Grate Brave journalists Media king 👑 You Tube Hero world 🌟
You forgot to mention his nickname is Hafiz Whisky.
😂😂😂😂
😂
I love his name 😂😂whisky 😂
Chachu whiskey
Shame talking about a Hafiz
Simply excellent 👍🇵🇰
Especially ISI Composition Vlog Story by Munir Shah
ua-cam.com/video/WUChx90p_IU/v-deo.html
Well done Wajahat. Please continue this series...…..
Nicely balanced. Loved it