{Wasn't I your first sweetheart?} | Far from the madding crowd | Bathsheba and Gabriel
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 гру 2017
- Never expected this video to blow up the way it did. Honestly it had like 5 views for so long I actually had lost hope of it ever being found then suddenly the views started increasing out of nowhere. If you like this edit, make sure you check out more of my stuff because I have a very distinctive style when it comes to some of my videos. All story centric and are almost like a summary of the movie rather than just a video.
-Bluebell ( 25, 08, 2018)
-------------------------------
Movie : Far From The Madding Crowd
Song : • "Atlantic" - Sleeping ...
Program : imovie
---------------------------------------------
Song is in the description
Thank u
Glad your video blew up! The secrets of the youtube recommendations, I guess! Thanks!
This was beautifully edited and put together. Thank you!!!
🦋🙏💙
Matthias Schoenaerts was glorious in this film. He made the film. Such good, nuanced acting and such male beauty is unparalleled here.
He is such an amazing actor in everything he's in.
Matthias was glorious in every movie he is irrestible
@@minlilia6617 Truth! But this film was special, because Gabriel Oak is such an adorable literary character and Matthias played him perfectly.
@@evelinmenezes9313 Yes. Like Bruno in Suite Française... Clearly not Thomas Hardy but another literary character that breathe and walk and connect with the viewers, like a person, surpassing the uniform and the context, thanks to the skills of Matthias...
I couldn't agree more, his acting made me fall in love with Gabriel Oaks!!!
He is a man that every women dreams about...
Me too
Emilka PLater.. he doesnt exist in reality
@@albreiki5725 malheureusement
You are right.
Sweeeeeeeet sweeeeeet scene of love. 100 likes for you.
When his sheep fell over the cliff, man.. that was heartbreaking. To think that could ruin a man back in those days =(
phantomwaltz his screams did it for me
Yeap, they call it stock market nowadays.
Period drama.
And yet he persevered, never turning to drink or bitterness. In the book, you can tell how he follows God, using wisdom to carry on with his lot whether it be good or bad... Such an admirable character
@@bluebell8557 in the book he is thankful at that moment that he was rejected and didn't have a wife to worry about, which is a better reaction in my opinion, and more true to the character.
The costume designers never get enough credit. This young woman has an amazing seamstress, her clothes are taylored to her perfectly.
If it was me in her place... the movie would've ended in 10 minutes, with farmer Gabriel's unborn child inside me.
LOL correct!
Damn right!! Lmao🤣😆😂
Hah ha fantastic comment - had me laughing out loud
Ja, ja, ja.
😂😂😂
He speaks with his eyes & his smile..and that was enough to know how he feels inside. Matthias is such a wonderful actor ♡♡♡
Gabriel Oak is one of the only fictional characters I've ever wanted to be. He is a model of masculinity that the men of my generation so desperately need to cultivate in their own lives. I have hope that there are still such men out there.
Guigley I agree with you. A rare man of good masculinity that should hopefully re-exist one day in our modern era of tinder, dating apps, and weird dating scene.
They only exist in movies but not in real life
@@rochedihichem4697 You don't believe that men of honor, integrity, loyalty and decency exist in real life?
@@Guigley very few..Honestly, ive probably met a handful of REAL masculinity out there.. strength with gentleness. and they are all about 40 years old and older.. Im 30 and everyone in my generation especially younger lack the qualities of being a real man. I blame social media. they become insecure
Great for you: real people are never only good but you have always to keep in mind the higher standard, not the lower one - that's how you get better with every opportunity!
This sheep scene always gets I feel SOOOO sorry for him
That was his sign to go look for something better. If only we all had a sign.
I loved this movie so much that I bought it. Gabriel is the epitome of faithful love. So calmed and assured, no matter who came between them. He captured my heart.
I love it too and also bought a copy of it ! Good analysis on it.
I highly suggest the book if you love the movie! I enjoyed both versions very much.
Lorelei Noelle may I ask what the name of this book, movie is? I need to get myself a copy asap.
Sweeeeeeeet sweeeeeeeet scene.
I loved this movie so much that I bought the DVD. I have watched it several times.
Matthias's performance was simply intelligent and outstanding. So well done.
Strong women tend to reject their match, especially as their perfect match tends to be as strong or stronger than they are, in character and will. Her rejection of Gabriel stemmed from her knowing, deep in her soul, that she would grow to need him-- he would be her ballast and provide her a steadfast and powerful foundation. She did everything to free herself from reaching out for this, as she desired being that for herself. In the end, she only broke down because he was finally going to walk away and despite herself she didn't-- she really couldn't live her life without him in it.
She wasn't selfish. She was afraid to need him. She was terrified of loving him.
For good and for ill, I am akin to Bathsheba.
She wasn't strong. She was selfish and vain. Notice I said "was". Her character developed throughout the story.
@@pamelamotyka8036
😀 Ha! She was strong, selfish and vane. These are not mutually exclusive things. Her strength grew more entrenched over time, while with maturity she outgrew much of her selfishness and vanity.
I too think she was genuinely afraid of losing herself in his love. But at the same time she was wakened by her lust for a charismatic soldier. She would always tease and berate Gabriel coz she thought he was just a farmer with no class.
Very true! Thanks ❤
You are so Spot on
This movie literally had me thinking that women can make mistakes too. And being with the wrong people in the past doesn't nullify the truth that we all deserve the right person. If we only just repent and learn from our past mistakes. Gabriel is too good for her, yes. But we all have fallen short of God's grace, who are we to judge?
@@rosaliasantos9549 Far from the madding crowd
However, judgment comes to all who have broken the law of God, unless they place their faith in Christ. Important plot point!
@@rosaliasantos9549 Em português fica:Longe desse insensato mundo. O filme é muito bom.
"This movie literally had me thinking that women can make mistakes too"
Derp - if that isn't a telling commentary on the modern world I don't know what is.
If you want to watch a woman make mistakes for far too many hours for one movie, watch _Gone With the Wind._
I read the book and thought being the strong headed woman, she was maybe a bit afraid of Oak because she knew with all her being that its him she truly loved...but to truly love is to give up your power which it was not in her nature to do...so she surrenders in the end because she has suffered enough..
priscilla birungi but she married so I don’t think that’s necessarily the case. In my opinion, I think she didn’t want to be one of those girls to be controlled and she didn’t want to be thrown away “and when your thyme it is past and gone, he’ll care no more for you” but ironically she ended up marrying someone who was using her and she avoided the person who wasn’t.
BEST COMMENT. really hit home too.
@@bluebell8557 it's still fear of losing control. Self preservation.
Plz send me the link of book
@@bluebell8557 Yes also when I read the book, Troy seemed like the first man to make her feel powerless and that is why she fell head over heels with him. I think the case of Gabriel Oak is a tale as old as time, where a man isn't so attractive to a woman at first, but proves how trustworthy and reliable he is, eventually winning her heart. I think that romantic ideas of heart fluttering scenarios where women feel anxious and vulnerable rather than comfortable around a man ( as with Troy) is what really disadvantages sweet and devoted men like Oak.
My heart broke for Gabriel so many times, including the loss of the sheep.
Gabriel and Bathsheba have one of the most fascinating relationships in literature. When we first meet Bathsheba, it isn't her good qualities we see, but her vanity as she stares into a mirror when she thinks no one is looking. Then Gabriel comes to know her as whimsical, impetuous and courageous when she saves his life. He sees her faults and spends the entire story appealing to the better parts of her nature. He despises her behavior toward Mr. Boldwyn and warns her against Troy.
It isn't until she marries Troy and sees what her future looks like with him, that she admits to Gabriel that she married him because Troy played on her insecurities. She's starting to understand that Gabriel expects the best version of her and she's failed him.
Her behavior toward Mr. Boldwyn is less understandable. She seems weak, stringing him along, trying to convince herself she is some type of martyr because she played a dumb prank on him one time. It isn't explainable other than her vanity is getting the best of her again.
I don't think as the audience we're supposed to feel that Bathsheba deserves Gabriel's devotion. She probably doesn't even deserve his friendship. But that isn't the point, Gabriel thinks she deserves it and in the end she finally accepts that too.
IN HARDY'S OWN WORDS A THE END: They spoke very little of their mutual feeling; pretty phrases and warm expressions being probably unnecessary between such tried friends. Theirs was that substantial affection which arises (if any arises at all) when the two who are thrown together begin first by knowing the rougher sides of each other's character, and not the best till further on, the romance growing up in the interstices of a mass of hard prosaic reality. This good-fellowship-camaraderie-usually occurring through similarity of pursuits, is unfortunately seldom superadded to love between the sexes, because men and women associate, not in their labours, but in their pleasures merely. Where, however, happy circumstance permits its development, the compounded feeling proves itself to be the only love which is strong as death-that love which many waters cannot quench, nor the floods drown, beside which the passion usually called by the name is evanescent as steam.
He was too good for her. She didn't deserve him tbh.
completely agree
agree.
She fucking deserve him. I'd be so sad of they were not together. I know this sounds selfish but sometimes people deserve chances.
Terrie Smith on paper (the book) yes. But Carey Mulligan can pull off characters you should hate. She's quite remarkable in how she does that.
ikr
who needs a darcy when you have an oak, cried so much with that story, absolutely loved it
Viviana V oh i still need my Darcy 😓
Darcy has a special place in my heart but Gabriel came pretty close. You should check out Tom from Lights Between Oceans. Beautiful book and movie.
Going to watch this just because hes better than Mr Darcy, my ultimate man ever
Mr Darcy is unique. ❤️
I am for Mr Rochester side 😍
When she said at the end “ Wasn’t i your sweetheart? “ i hated her completely. Even after all the years he has been through she says “ you have to love me i don’t care how you were hurt “. Love isn’t about take advantage of someone who loves you. She took so long to realize that he was the one. Not because she realized she loved him but she needed him as a comforter , helper, admirer because other guys took advantage of her. She is no different than other two guys. She doesn’t deserve Gabriel period
She didn't know what she wanted. It took her some experience to know that she truly loved him. She didn't have any other experiences and was just discovering her romantic emotions.
Dark Druidess agree. She thought she could do better. She had to Zlearn the hard way what a man REALLY is. I mean , a Good one. Lol
Windy Citiz I think I see where you’re coming from. My experience tells me that MANY women are like this: foolish conceited self-willed ignorant of what actual real love is. But she came to see, understand and responded to his love for her. And his love for her changed her. This is a woman. This is my observation of actual life and experience if ever anyone is so loved by such a man. Unfortunately, this story is so insightful to the character of many you g and foolish women who make foolish choices.
Windy Citiz it’s just a movie calm down lol
Windy Citiz
Agree
While she is super harsh and abrasive towards him I also think this story is realistic in that she grew to love him for more than what he looked like. She tried passion amidst her independence and found that fleeting, then almost chose convenience but she didn’t respect those men, and while they made her feel a certain way , they were shallow. In the end she chooses Gabriel because she grew to see him as more than what he had been. He was real and he respected her beyond her looks or money. He showed her that he loved her not because of shallow things but because he truly believed in her snd valued and respected her strength, he wasn’t afraid of it. I feel like she spent so much of the movie wanting to be something dainty or submissive and settling for what she thought she wanted. In the end she realized what she truly valued in love was the equality and respect that gave gave her. I may be alone I. This but I love the fact that this story is messy because learning to love someone can sometimes be messy.
What a fine man Gabriel is (sigh) If only there were more men like him ❤
Gergana Margaritova - there are ....We friendzone them mostly !!!
Madhumita Jana Yep, most of the time we're all about the bad boys, aren't we ☺
Gergana Margaritova - most often we do ..! And if we don't choose a bad boy also , its just that ...Gabriel kinda guys often goes unnoticed or friend zoned !! ( Though to be fair noone really wait like Gabriel anymore ...No one waits ...Life has become fast , hollow and robotic )
Madhumita Jana You're so right! People keep getting more reticent and insensitive. That's why as a hopeless romantic I've always had a soft spot for characters like Gabriel, Colonel Brandon, William Dobbin - caring and deeply loving men.
I hate to be rude, but i have to admit, the bad boys are the ones to have fun with when you are young. And while we are at it, men like Gabriel are the ones who fly under the radar. And when we come to our senses, there they are waiting patiently. It's the same for both the sexes more or less.
Gabriel was too good for her. He was so respectful. When they wanted to kiss each other but she was married to the other guy, he resisted even though he really wanted to kiss her cause he didn't want her to be a cheater and him a homewrecker. I would give my life for a man like that
She didn't really deserve him - he's too good for her.
shtfu
Yes he deserves me actually..
he shouldve gone rhett butler on her "Frankly, my dear, I dont give a damn"
VolumeImpact hahah best man ever
😳👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
i always loved Gabriel's character so much, and also how his last name "Oak" was a testament to his character: strong, steady, grounded. i watched this film about 2 years ago with my mom, and I always wished to find my own Mr. Oak after that..and thankfully, not long after, I did (but I wasn't about to turn him down the first time, hahah) :') the universe seemed to really do me a solid, huh?
fanofthings awww that’s actually really sweet❤️ wishing you a blessed life with your Mr. Oak.
BlueBell :’)) thank you so much💚💚
this gave me such hope lol. when you met your love, how long did it take for you to realize he reminded you of Oak?
@@depresso___espresso oh that's so lovely to hear omg :') and, honestly? ...i noticed very early-on! He pretty much immediately felt like a safe space for me to be myself, and he felt the same with me. His strength was clear, through his actions and character, more than words (although words are great too lol). I've been able to better heal many parts of myself over time with his continuous support. we're now even engaged as of this past sunday :')
@@n0xparad0x god bless you both omggg that is so exciting!! I am wishing you nothing but health and happiness!!!🖤🖤🖤
Oh God, I’m in love with this man in every movie he’s in
Nothing so beautiful as a beautiful man...Matthias Schoenaerts...a beautiful specimen of manhood. Reminds me of my husband 20 years ago!
Öyleyse çok şanslısınız
I have to give Bathsheba props, she had the guts to turn down that perfect specimen.
Or stupidity.
Gabriel is a dedicated, and forthright man. I am of the opinion that if they have struck it right from the beginning Bathsheba would not have loved and respected Gabriel much. The experience she gained from her relationships led to a soul-searching for her and the realisation that love might not come in the form you have envisaged.
yeah, you are right. Actually, Gabriel is some how sensitive and self-abase.
I wouldnt say Gabriel is self-abase...rather I would say he is a humble and unassuming person
You're exactly right. If you read the book, he sees her faults from the off. She's vain. But she's got spirit, pluck, a big heart and courage. She's immature, but he's' patient. And you know from the book (and this novel does a good job of it), when one wins Bathsheba heart... she's loyal
yeah, their relationship matures from both sides; she matures also and he gets to know her better with good points and flaws so his commitment at the end is truly a more mature one ( after all you don't ask to marry a woman after just having seen her milking the cow and having spent some time on a lawn, do you?)
That's true bc she did like him from the beginning but she wasnt mature enough to be with him yet. However , with that being said I feel like she was manipulative and selfish bc she knew his love was unconditional for her. Sometimes we just have to do what is right ,she knew it all along but she was playing hard to get. Gaining experience is great but look at all the senseless heartache she endured just to end up with the person she knew she loved.
Was so obvious that Grabriel was her true love, since the first minute!!!
Oh Batsheba, what a blind you were!!!! Great song.
Gabriel is a man of honour....a man of words...hats off to him...
LOVED this book. Don't know why people prefer Pride and Prejudice. I love that this film did the two characters and the growth of their relationship justice.
This Man is Utterly beyond gorgeous to me for some reason and i have seen quite a few of his films🥰
this was one of the the most, my top most heartwarming romance films of all the time. I wish nowadays they could make romance movies as good. I love him too, such gentle gorgeous eyes for such a manly looking, well, man haha.
couldn't have said it better my self haha
I fell in love with Gabriel in this movie. OMG! How can anyone be so quiet, so loving and so protective at the same time?
There’s just something about Gabriel’s eyes that are so intriguing
this was a set book in high school for our Cambridge exams...it shocked me that the other girls found the book to be boring...I on the other hand, was totally enamored by the love story, head over heels in love with Farmer Oak and terribly cross with Bathsheba for not recognising the gem right in front of her eyes.
How does he play this role so perfectly ?? Does he share some traits with the character?... his eyes and aura tells so much it’s both vivid and confusing...
I have never met an Oak in real life but it would be amazing to do so... wow
What lies beneath must be interesting. To figure out what could cause such a personality such a soul to exist would be...
Ikr...how can a man be so chivalrous? he was filled with honor, bravery, loyalty...idk I think you're either born an oak or you aren't. In my opinion these traits are either with you or they aren't. As for Matthias schoenaerts, he always embodies the roles he plays. He's an amazing actor. You know if I had to choose a man for me, it wouldn't be oak, it would be a character called Tom from the movie "light between oceans". You should check the book out. Amazing.
Yesss!!!
@@bluebell8557 hahaha, the bravest of all, huh? yet veeery reserved, not talkative at all - are you sure you could live on an island alone with him? ;)
Irina Firuti hahaha I’m assuming you mean if I could live with Tom? You’re right, he might drive me crazy but I think I’d still go for him anyway.
He’s very different from the character but he plays out so well it’s most believable
Matthias it's a perfect Gabriel Oak!
Matthias is a belgian actor, very famous 😚
I’ve never seen this movie but if a person as strong and caring and kind asked me out, I would simply say yes immediately. But people like Gabriel are few and far between.
Gosh i am sooo inlove with this movie. I was screaming and half the time yelling at her, CHOOSE HIM!!! ugh so good
for a woman who didn't want to marry, she sure changed her mind quickly when a young, charming and handsome soldier told her she was pretty.
BEST Version by far and when she SINGS~! It's magical :) What a voice.
I tried so hard to like her but I just couldn’t. Gabriel is such a gentleman and deserves so much. I felt like she used him as her last option after she had her heart broken and didn’t have anyone else. She was selfish, she used people whenever she wanted and even though I’m always rooting for a happy ending, I don’t believe she was the right one for him at all.
From the beginning she was interested in him but I think that youth, fear, new opportunities made her let go and she chose to do without him. She had little experience, then the officer arrived and dazzled her with his charms. She made the wrong choice but paid for it. Gabriel (proud, firm and loyal) was always there in the background and she had a second chance to choose better. I like both characters.
Goodness, this video just gets better every time I watch it. The music, the editing… it’s better than the movie itself. The music sweeps you into their great romance.
When Gabriel and Bethsheba first meet she is a very young woman who lost her parents in childhood. I think this loss affected her emotional development. Gabriel is attracted to her beauty and free spirit. He is eight years older than her and sees her immaturity. Like an older brother he watches over her telling her things she needs to hear about herself that no one else could because she had no one. At one point he even tells her he will leave her one day because he knows eventually he will. Along their journey the things that he tells her, though she often does not heed his advice, she realize too late her foolishness. In the process she matures letting go of childish ways, realizes what love is and does not want to lose him by telling him her true feelings.
I saw this last night. I was hesitant because I really was equally surprised by the Julie Christie/Alan Bates version. But, these two are two of my favorite actors and I've always enjoyed seeing their work. I'm glad I know about them. Need more...
"Would you like to marry me" jeez PLEASE 🙏😊💙
haha Ikr?
who wouldn't?
👏😊
She deserves Gabriel and he deserves her because he loves her. You deserve the person you love and the one that loves you.
This is beautifully done & captures Gabriel & Bathsheba’s romance in the best way, I love it! 😍
I think she was always torn between what she wants and what she deserves. Never self aware.
Came here after watching it in Walt Disney stream. And the last scene, I can't get enough of the chemistry. So so intense. :) My heart beats fast as i watch Matthias Schoenaerts. :) thank you for this video.
Love this book. Never warmed to Bathsheba though. This trailer is making me want to read the book again. Huge fan of Thomas Hardy.
I came to watch this movie just recently, I love adaptations; they never disappoint! Gabriel -Mr. Oak- is added to the list of real men like Mr. Darcy, Mr. Thornton, Mr. Wentworth, Mr. Knightly ... he is a real gentlman whose love is unwavered and his loyalty and devotion are rare. Now many say that 'Wasn't I your first sweetheart' is the utterance that changed his mind, I think what came after 'weren't you mine' is the key; as he heard her saying these words he realized that he matters to her too that's why he carried on and asked if he can love and marry her. His doubts mirrors Mr. Thornton's in 'North and South' as he kept repeating to his mother that he does not think a woman like 'Margaret' would care for him, and she did the same as Bathsheba carred for Gabriel, but fools as we are, we sometimes take unnecessary long time to figure out our emtions!
Great work on the video
I completely agree. Also, thank you for mentioning Mr. Thornton. I’m absolutely in love with him
That man is perfection
I literally adore this movie. Excellent performances and especially the most beautiful soundtrack in the history of cinema!
Matthias Schoenaerts is such a wonderful actor. I can watch and listen to him while he reads the dictionary.
MrsCash Morrisey talented guy with a beautiful voice
The most epic kiss in cinematic history. I could watch the ending a thousand times and never get tired of it.
My exact thoughts ..
I can't watch that kiss and NOT lose it. How I long to kiss a woman like that one day!
One of my absolute favorites. I could watch this movie on repeat and have. Cry every time. To have this kind of love and have it back would be amazing!
What a handsome man is Matthias! I love him. Great actor!
Gabriel was 1000 times more handsome,charming and sweet gentleman. I'd marry him in the blink of an eye
This is such a beautiful summary of this two hearts dancing around each other 💖😍. Love it!
Brilliant acting & fantastic scenery bring Thomas Hardy's far from the madding crowd to life in beautiful Dorset.oak never gave up on Bathsheba even though he was repeatedly rejected by her.what a wonderful film ,all credit to the director & camera work & of course the actors.
She doesn't deserve him. He's too good for her
I had forgotten how much I liked this movie, from years ago when I first saw it. So thank you for uploading and inspiring me to watch it again. I love the actors who portray the two leading characters. They have such depth in their acting, their subtle looks, the emotions. Their performances are quite remarkable. Whoever did the casting, did an excellent job. I love this movie!
This was the very first film by Matthias that I watched. Then I went to see Rust and Bone, and then Bullhead.. And I'm like: Oh, crap... not another unattainable actor crush. Screw my life 😭 Nice montage, BlueBell!
This is the second film I've watched from him. I just came from Suite Francais. He is purely amazing
This film really got me into Thomas Hardy‘s work.
I just love how Matthias protrayed Gabriel❤
She is independent in a man’s world. In a time when women were not encouraged to be independent. He believes in her and loves her independence. We all can be hard headed and short sighted. He sticks around because he knows she loves him too and because love is always worth it. Period.
I would submit that if the genders were swapped, we would say the relationship was dysfunctional and emotionally abusive. Which it is. She took advantage of his feelings for YEARS and strung him along. That's not love AT ALL.
@@sitcomchristian6886 you're totally right
the chemistry in this is so sizzling i should just bring some marshmallows out
Gabriel is a good name for Matthias's character, because he is like an angel watching over Bathesheba and being there for her. Just saying even if one doesn't believe in angels it fits their profile, OK.
My Name ist Gabriele and i'm a woman 🙋
As is typical of writing in this genre and time, all of the names have additional meanings. Gabriel Oak is both a saving angel and a steady, reliable force. Boldwood is confident and straightforward, but too old for Bathsheba (thus his name is like bald-wood, or an old tree). Frank Troy is obviously only interested in money, troy being a measurement of weight and wealth. And then there's Bathsheba, the woman named after a Bible character who seduced David, who then conveniently put her husband in harm's way, ensuring that the husband would die and David could marry Bathsheba. I think her name is meant to be ironic, in that she is alluring to several men, but she does not destroy them, though they fight for her.
@@carolannhook554 I agree with the meaning of the names, except that Bathsheba didn't do any seducing. 2 Samuel 11: King David saw her bathing from his rooftop, took her and lay with her, and then when she sent to him telling him she was pregnant, David tried to hide his adultery by calling Uriah back from war in hopes that he'd sleep with his own wife and nobody would know it was David's kid, but when Uriah wouldn't go back home, David had her husband murdered.
Now, there's no evidence of her objecting to the situation, and we can presume from the story that maybe she would have gone along with David and not told her husband, but she's a pretty ambivalent character. A better woman would have refused the king, and, best case scenario, been sent home untouched, or worst case, been raped by the king anyway, but it's not like she set out to seduce anyone. I think that's why Hardy's character is named Bathsheba, in that she was involved with a couple of men, and ended up caught in the middle of things by her own lack of character/weakness/ selfishness, but she didn't set out to do harm. Bathsheba in the Bible suffers the loss of a husband - killed because of her, but not by her design -- and loses the son who resulted from the adultery with David, but she also has a happy ending in that she gives birth to Solomon.
@Ayisha S. Good to clarify. Thanks. I was trying to keep the post shorter and couldn't figure out another way without using a word like seduce, but I agree that the word misrepresents her actions. I like your theory on her name. I wonder if the name is to also suggest the idea of the judgement of others (in the madding crowd) who see only her actions and not the delicate complexities of love. Pretty much every love story in the novel is a convoluted, complicated relationship, filled with misunderstandings. I loved the movie, but I feel the portrayal of Troy is simplified too much, making it easier for audiences to hate him rather than see him as a flawed, proud lover.
@@carolannhook554 Yeah, I like your assessment about the complexity of her actions. Have you seen the longer miniseries from the 90s? Nathaniel Parker, Jonathan Firth, and Paloma Baeza? I thought it was a really excellent adaptation, and long enough to deal with the complexity. Troy's character makes more sense: he's weak, but complex, and the situation he got into with Fanny has more backstory. I also think that Bathsheba is more likable -- one understands and respects her decisions more. Nathaniel Parker isn't as handsome as Mattias Schoenaerts, but his rural accent makes more sense, and even though he wasn't how I pictured Oak in the book, he does a good job. Anyway, any time you try to squeeze a novel into a blockbuster-length film, you're going to miss a lot. Not only is it short, but it has a very strict and limited structure that does not allow for subplots. The miniseries structure works a lot better, and is my favourite film structure.
He deserved so much better. She just played with his heart and kept him around if it was convenient to her
I was always unsatisfied with this ending.
He was too good for her, and he deserved better.
Dear person reading this,
I hope your day has going well, if not, I hope it gets better. You are an amazing person who will inspire others to do great thing so keep up:) the hard work.
I know you may feel unimportant or insecure at the moment but know that you are beautiful human being inside and out and you are important!
Jusr try to be nice on the INTERNET, sometimes we need such a massage! :)
I hope this comment helped you a bit and if not, I'm sorry
Sincerely,
Zahra dhG
Thank you for the wonderful message Zahra.
I'm having a particularly hard night. I just feel awful.. Thank you for the kind message.
Thanks for the sweet words
They hit a sore spot inside me
They really made my day
Thank you, thank you! My husband left me with two daughters to raise by myself , my heart is broken, feeling guilt and shame. Thinking I am an awful person otherwise he hadn't left me... you helped.. feeling God talking to me through your message
@@karinaterceiro6339 Find videos of Les Brown and listen/watch. Trust me. Your daughters will give you strength. I was a single mother too. Stay strong and show them you can rise above it all and you can. Be good to yourself and things will get better.
I love how he loved her thru all the hardships or problems he never gave up ❤️
Margie Baez you should read a book called “the light between oceans”.
BlueBell I’ll see if i can find it I love to read thk u👍😉👍
@@margiebaez8299 haha this is unbashful self advertising but I actually have an edit on them. It's filled with spoilers though so watch it after you watch the movie and/or read the book.
www.goodreads.com/book/show/13158800-the-light-between-oceans
Here's the link to the goodreads page.
BlueBell lol thks
A choice for a woman. an old fashion man with integrity, an unsophisticated wealthy man and a ravishing good looking all action man. If you are a material girl choose Mr boldwyn, if you are adventurist choose mr troy. if youre on for a long term commitment choose mr oak.
So true.
Yup, but in the end I think the happier choosing (if not for a fling) is Mr. Oak.
Zatoichiable I choose the one who will be faithful , loves me and won’t spend all my money as “soldier boy” lol.
Me too.
Zatoichiable mr.oak
I somehow can't sympathize with the leading actress. Gabriel's love for her is unconditional, while her affection for him seems opportunistic. Even at the end it seems more like she just wants to be with him because she needs his companionship because she's lonely now and his advice because it was always so helpful to her. Not because she really cares about him
I didn't like her either. I think she got her karma though. Her whole problem or conflict was the fact that she was worried she was going to be used by a man. "for when your thyme it is passed and gone, he'll care no more for you". And that's why I think she refused Oak at first. She thought of herself too independent and not needing a man. Then she really did fall for someone who used her. It's one of the finest ironies in my opinion.
Yeah you could also say she learned her lesson to appreciate the goodness in Gabriel by having experienced relationships with bad men
Mathu Art very true.
You're of course entitled to your opinion and I can see how you could think that about it, but I think she finally realized what Gabriel meant to her , and not because she was lonely or needed him to help with the farm either. Sometimes people don't realize what they have until they lose it or are about to lose it.
I agree with that point of view. I guess that's the "moral" of the story. But i cannot believe Gabriel means the same to her as she means to him. She does seem to realize his worth at the end yes, but I believe love is more about giving than receiving. If people can't realize what they have until they are about to lose it, they are more concerned about what they can get, which I think is opportunistic. How many times has Gabriel "lost" her to other men? But he never stopped loving her.
This might be my favorite Thomas Hardy novel. I enjoyed this adaptation. The cast was outstanding and the scenery was stunning. I for myself identify with William Boldwood.
What a well-produced video clip! Thanks for sharing this.
Time to watch this again for the millionth time. I just adore this edit of the movie ❤
Matthias Schoenaerts is amazing in this film. He can speak and express volumes with a look and words aren’t necessary. Carey Mulligan is outstanding and together they are magical.
What's great is having seen it and learned that she wanted him to play the role after seeing his Rust & Bone performance. He's the Real Thing.
I just happened upon this by accident and I'm THRILLED!!!! I love this movie! I've seen all Mattias Schoenaerts films and they are all EXCELLENT. He's a amazing actor and he was fabulous in this film. If you haven't seen it I highly recommend it. Thanks Blue Bell!
I absolutely adore him. great actor. Highly underrated. You're most welcome hon 💕 Glad you liked it.
What do you think about la suite française ?
He's wonderful. One of my favorites. Watch him in Bullhead - outstanding.
This film still haunts me and i don't really know why .. i think it's because of her
how i love this! can't stop watching it!!!
She honestly don’t deserve him
Beautiful edition!
Most beautiful edit of a most beautiful film! I've watched this a thousand times. Seriously the flow is like a mini movie. xx
I have always loved this energy .
Such a lovely tribute ! Thanks !
veda pierce you’re most welcome
@@bluebell8557 Cuál es el filme?
Wich is the film?
Espero tu respuesta gracias.
Tu trabajo genial!!!
This is brilliant I've seen the film of many time and this is great way to see it again like this thank you please do more !
aww thank you. I have more similar edits like these if you're interested ;)
I just loved his movies. I really like the way he acts, well done mrs. Gabriel 🥰🥰🥰
Good video that captures the best scenes between Oak and Batshiva. Thank you very much.
One of the best intriging movie, a true love story.
Oh my gosh!!! This is the first time I've heard of this movie. I have no words to describe what my heart is feeling right now!!
understand the times: women needed a man to provide for them and all the pressure was on them to marry money, forget love, and that's the sense of the story: love overcoming necessity.
She's definition of "I'm ready to settle down now" 🙄
stay focus, gents. Sometimes, she for the streets.
This is one of the best videos I have seen in a very long time. Bravo! That was excellently done.
Stephanie S oh gosh thank you so much!!
I married my Mr Oak
Oh you lucky 🍀 one!
I did too.💗
This made me tear up. I remember wishing I had a friend like Gabriel when I first read the book three decades ago. Thank you for rekindling that love. 🥹