S Jaishankar's 6 phases of Indian foreign policy & 5 axes of Modi Govt’s vision | ep 317
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 тра 2024
- #CutTheClutter #CTC
In 4th Ramnath Goenka Lecture, India's External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar delivered a 48-minute masterclass on evolution of India's foreign policy, where India stands now and the way ahead. In episode 317 of Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta explains what it tells us about Modi government's diplomatic vision, strategy & worldview, and one almost hidden nugget he really likes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/subscribe/
I have heard S. Jaishankar many times, and i never saw any other diplomats with such clarity in thoughts.
@Arun Sar their haven't been as good foreign ministers tho, in my opinion he's the best foreign minister we ever had
@Arun Sar I say he is the best on merit. Of course we have to wait and see what the future holds tho
@@KavateJayesh i agree with you, but a bit difference, Sushma mam was also one of the best.
@@RahulKumar-ng2gh she was definitely the most outreaching one, one with connect with people. But I'd say she wasn't as experienced in diplomacy
Sorry to strike a discordant note;but then a forum of open discussion has never been a one stop shop. As much as I like the FM’s speech, after all he is preaching to the converts. His diplomatic success would rest entirely on converting the non-believers. God knows how many loose ends are there to be tied up. However mellifluous may be the tune he is fiddling. It is the raging fire out there to be doused.
" India is too strong to mess with " That's how we Indians want our motherland India to be.
Just the line "India is now too strong,too powerful to mess with" got me to like this video. I just loved it.
1:40 He is referring to SM krishna. Foreign Minister during UPA
He's forgotten the name
@@ias7271 of course he hasnt - he was being polite! good journos dont forget anything - we consider him one.
Lmao!! the infamous SM Krishna...🥵
Seriously... Going to Google him.
And ironically now a part of the BJP.
*S JAISHANKAR IS A GEM OF INDIA, SO ARTICULATE. NEVER CEASE TO AMAZE ME*
I saw him at a Q&A in the US, he is brilliant. Not just a gem of India, but of all mankind.
“You don’t have to agree on this but that is not the point of CUT THE CLUTTER ...” love that line 👍🏽
Thank you and your team for hard work 🙏🏽
Mr. Gupta is at his best in these types of analyses. India is lucky to have Mr. SJ as EAM. Wish the Govt had made a similar choice wrt the FM position, appointing someone with a lot of finance experience.
Bjp in center is the best for India it's a personal view
@Sumeet tanwar We did a project for an elevator company in dubai. All these folks are experts in their line of work, not IT of course. We had to organize a two week hands on training for them about the whole project. In spite of that, it took them a year to get used to everything..
Now, GST is in use by everyone, be it the biggest company or the smallest shop owner that hasn't even passed tenth grade.. How does one expect them to get used to GST in a short while? Of course they are crying hoarse about not being able to use it.. But as I have personally seen with passport applications ( took me 6 months 10 years ago. Its down to two weeks now), it will help eventually..
Morals : idiots need to look long term.. Ditto for NPAs.. Ditto for reforms... ( maybe not try to tax the industries before they grow bigger)..
@Sumeet tanwar fully agreed.
Seb K I perfectly agree with your observation. I believe government should stop thing on CAD and go with spend and stop taxingnleft and right. Give some breather space and act behind the screens. I hope they deal with vested interested people more intelligently
Kudos to the Shekhar gupta and his Team to work out day and night to give everyday insight news...are you guys and shekhar taking day off or not???
Thank you very much indeed. We all work very hard at ThePrint. We do have a 5-day week though! Thanks for writing... sg
They might after they get 1Million
@@rajeshdaviyal4602 no amount of money will drive you to work hard month after month unless you have passion for that.
Hats off to Shri S. Jaishankar, our non-political Foreign Minister for his brilliant analysis of India's Foreign Policy since independence.
I hv completely heard & watched this Jaishankar lecture. I think Shekhar Gupta is overtly simplifying it. It’s more complex than what Gupta says. Jai shankar also talks about lost economic opportunities & it’s impact on us & restrictions on us due to that.
Nitin Nimkar.Investment you might be right. The idea if cut then clutter is to simplify...sg
13:32. Brajesh Misra's brilliance deserved a mention
Czar of NDA-1
BTW - he isn't talking about Sushma Swaraj at 1:40. He is talking about SM Krishna's speech in 2011. Some clarity what Shekhar missed here.
Spot on
I think he skipped it on purpose to avoid unnecessary controversy
He is talking about Sushma
@@deepakvaidya9074 nope!! It's SM Krishna
PPL who dunno famous inci of krishna embarrassment in UN and speak confidently it was swaraj, are shame for country equal to sm krishna was 😁
We need more Patriotic and Experienced Civil Servants leading Ministries.
Amazing analysis Shekhar Gupata sir as always. I watched entire speech by EAM Jaishankar. I liked his small comment about "Liberal Fundamentalism" and "My reputation is not decided by a news paper in NY". I have never heard such clarity and explanation in only two comments.
#FREEHONGKONG
Theek hai
#freehongkong
@Nom Anor ok
@@ias7271 padhai karo bhai babu banna hai
@Nom Anor Free Baluch,Free POK,Free Sindh
I saw the whole video in playback speed 2. Interestingly I understand everything
@@harishkiran3663 thanks
@@navigator5375 thanks
@@ias7271 hahaha😅
I always watch videos in 2x. For Shekhar Gupta, I've to recheck if I've enabled 2x or not.
Really very good episode by Mr .Gupta ..helping aspirants like me to declutture the international relations for UPSC ...and great to have such a EAM like Mr.Jayshankar having vast experience in foreign relations
Most Important messages to young peoples of our country
Sir, I wish you had included a ,”chapter” on our foreign policy vis-a vis our neighbours”,too
I feel this is all about his perfect speed of saying things, neither too fast to make u hard to catch up and hence becoming boring nor too slow. Perfect cadence!! Eureka moment😆😆
Dear Mr.Gupta, would you please discuss topic on Tashkent agreement and mysterious death of our beloved Prime Minister Mr.Shastri. I heard it was a conspiracy. Is it a fact?
Sekhar Ji, please accept my respects and its due to the fact that you have credited the episode on this topic to your junior. respect you sir.
Vishnu VV thank you very much. We have a very fine young team at ThePrint and I am fortunate to have them... sg
This CTC should be included in school courses.....amazing.
Love your way of explaining things. Could you sometime discuss political biases in Indian media groups.
Ndtv, The Hindu, The Wire, ThePrint etc?
Aur kaun bhai baaki sab to bhagwan hain
@Abhijit Sanyal This is an age old flim flam ploy called "good cop bad cop" routine. Still works wonderfully fine if deniability is uppermost on your mind.
That would be the day ! Though long overdue.
@@aagantuk7370 yeah because aaj tak, times now, india today are champions of media? Media is supposed to keep the govt in check. Not lick the govt foot like they do of Modi.
I must say this is real journalism. No question marks, no breaking news, no personal hate towards particular ideology.
Absolutely wonderful episode, Mr. Gupta.
I wish, we had a Finance minister too like Mr. Jaishankar.
very informative. Keeping in view the demise of TN Seshan, it would be great if you made an episode of CTC about him, and why we need officers of his calibre and integrity.
Do a video on South China Sea
And on civil war in Yemen
Since its an Islamic country committing genocide against an Islamic country, we(and at large the left) don't talk about such matters here.
Sweater ka time aa gaya 😮
Check his watch.. He changes his watch in every episode.. 😅 👆
Sweater-weather
@anonymous opinions i wore a similar sweater today I think it looked alright. Body type uncle ka hai inka.
I'm sitting in my room with the AC on because it's bloody hot 😩 most of the trees have been chopped down in Hyderabad and now the weather is messed up
thode time baad mufler man aayega khasta hua
Even though Mr Jaishankar was diplomat all his life. He is politically very mature. He remains grounded in many ways.
Thank you Shekhar sir for improving my knowledge ☺️
Calculated risks might really lead to India's good strategic development in global politics.
Knew about American operations in Himalayas to observe Chinese nuclear program but never knew that USA had put up a Delhi mission under a 2 star general.
That’s a fact. It was a full-fledged military assistance mission.... sg
@@ThePrintIndia please do give a episode on nuclear spying of US upon china by building a station on himalayas on indian side. This was the time when US and india were not an ally. Please it's a request
@@ThePrintIndia Thank you for the reply sir. Keep enlightening us.
His words will become lessons in history. Jai Jai Goenka
Absolutely Brilliant decluttering. I was expecting an episode on this and here you are 😊
Ajay Prabhu thank you very much, Ajay ...sg
The most wonderful aspect of ThePrint is that they working hard to set an alternative to the present scenario in media. Electronic media has poisoned Indian journalism by aligning themselves to ideologies and not to the media ethics.
As a development professional working in the conflict ridden Manipur, I am daily witnessing realities of where we went wrong as a democracy and how things are being shown in media. I have already written to ThePrint through a mail that I wish to work with them. This is by far the only media platform with least or almost no bias in presenting the news. Thank you team ThePrint. Let me know, if there are opportunities in your team where I can contribute. Best Wishes ✌️🌸
Sir he speaks Japanese, chinese, Russian, little Korean, Ukraine
Seriously ?
@@saurabhmishra2363 yes..
Would like to appreciate Mr Shekhar Gupta on the fact that he always gives due credit to his junior journalists who would've done most of the leg work in topics where Mr Gupta isn't an expert. It makes us respect him even more. Wish you and your colleagues well sir!
Great speech by MEA, even greater analysis by Gupta ji. You dont know how great a service you are doing to the youngstars (and not-so-youngs) in having an informed knowledge about our policies.
I only watch this channel for you sir.
Otherwise this channel will be the last one i would watch.
The top four ministries - foreign, defence, home and finance - should be held by bureaucrats or some experts. Atleast they will talk some sense among the cesspool of stupidity and mediocrity.
Absolutely...All key ministries should be with professionals who understand the domain well and can take correct decisions....Run of the mill ministers from mixed political backgrounds can never do justice to their jobs though there would be civil servants in the background.
That is against democracy. Bureaucracy follow orders. Bureaucrats are not answerable to anyone in that case.
@Yash Patil Everyone knows with current rate of growth India won't reach $5 T in 2024...
So Swamy isn't a genius for telling you what others including Modi already know.
The 5% growth this year is final nail of that dream....
@Yash Patil Accepting Publicly in a Country like India has consequences...
Swamy speaks out because he doesn't have to stand in front of others when asking for vote.
The truth is govt is working hard behind scenes,the recent corporate tax cut was part of it...
Privatising Bpcl,AI is in work.
Swamy is good I agree but he is reckless,you need someone with Maturity in Finance seat
I think finance and foreign
India settled two disputed borders with Bangladesh and Myanmar after 2014.
Always appreciate anecdotes shared by Shekhar Sir in Cut the Clutter Series. Would love to see a The Print series on 'Post Independence India' hosted by sir.
Regards
I just look forward to your videos... Just love them so informative and interesting
kaustav kalita thank you very much, Kaustuv... sg
Can you cut the clutter on Kalapani/LipulekhTerritory dispute with Nepal?
@@mrabsent3273 Well i wouldn't exactly say Nepal is the "only" good neighbor around. But yes disputes are problematic for any country (Especially amoung good ones) So yah, hope the dispute through bilateral diplomacy, like back in 2015 with Bangladesh
It is territory belong to Nepal which India annexed for national security and security against China.
@Adam Romanov lol
Brilliant presentation by the External Affairs Minister Shanker the worthy son of K. SubramaNiyum which has stimulated Sekhar Gupta & his team which has done a brilliant summary without loosing the essence. Kudos to PM Modi for creating an excellent Team of Professionals & Effective Politicians like home Minister to understand the complex route to take. Organisation like the Supreme Court & DRDO have risen to their Task with strategy & Foresight. Enjoyed the renderation. Thank you . Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia.
This guy was a good addition to the cabinet . And he is so well spoken that it's amazing to listen to him
Sir I am preparing for UPSC, studying at Yale University- wish to be in the IAS. Your channel is diligently articulate!
Hat off to Shekhar Gupta! Hope he lives forever and continues to provide uncluttered gyaan to us Aam Aadmis!
Chacha is on a roll if great videos.
Uday Rathod thank you very much, bhatija! ...sg
Of great videos*
@@ThePrintIndia lol nice sense of humour, appreciated #respect
Thank you sir for the de clutter.Please bring some topics like this that aren't too current or ephemeral.
jaishanker'sspeech in the US was the most insightful strategic understanding of localization VS globalization and bilateral VS multilaterals
He is too good ...
Just brilliant ....
Wish we have same caliber in key portfolio
Salute to you sir. Because of your cut the clutter I m able to have very good current affair classes with my students.
Excellent perspectives on a subject not widely known ! Thanks.
Excellent video. Please do more videos on explanations of the complex issues.
Very informative sir.. Thank you so much for your Short and to the core view of each and every topic you are giving with Cut the clutter. I am become a big fan of you. Now I am realising how so passionate a person can be in journalism.
Oh... Nehru erred in 1947-48,his daughter erred in 1972,only vajpeyee show guts in 1999,no doubt, pak channel anchors crib,"har baar do kadam hamse aage kaise hota hai india".
Indira Gandhi stood up to USA . Only nehru tried to appease entire world
I have lived thru' all those years, and seen the country prosper. All the PMs did what they had to, with the exceptions of Nehru and Vajpayee to some extent. Foreign policy is part of the job to be looked into in tandem with defence, internal securities, etc
Excellent Explanation.
I must say sekhar u guys are absolutely working hard and bringing out the news what ppl like me want to watch and hear kudos to u guys keep working hard
May god bless #print and team
Everything sounds great except when you said you don't care about POK and Aksai Chin. Why should India give up on their own land?
The use of ‘revanchist’ is a very interesting and I’m hearing it a long time after my student days of reading Franco German history. I’d like to hear from Jaishankar how far India could have gone during the Simla days without pushing Pakistan into revanchist path openly. The other issue which I’d like someone to seriously discuss is whether India could’ve done something more emphatic at the time of the impending hanging of Bhutto. Was India’s indifference correct both diplomatically and morally?
Thank you
Happy to hear you, always
Modi's foreign policy is Hara Hara Mahadev!!!! ISI backed Sonia, Rahul is no match.....
Really childish Quote
What do you call for Sonia running to Batla house crying on the death of Islamic terrorists and her home minister calling Hindus Saffron Terrorist!!! No wonder, Mallarapuram genocide of Hindus was easily made a non-issue.
S jaishankar and sushma swaraj are the best EAM india has ever had.
Have started following you and have realised that even the left thoughts should be listened to have a better view of politics as such ..Cut the clutter is the best series on you tube I have seen
Very knowledgable episode...thank you Shekar sir...by the way colour of your sweater is awesome!!
I would strongly recommend that Mr. Gupta have a conversation with Dr. Jaishankar and discuss those disagreements with him in an intellectual and respectful manner to satisfy readers’ intellectual curiosity! I hope he will invite Dr. Jaishankar and he accepts the invitation.
salute to you for your respect and encouragement for your younger colleagues
Watch with 1.25x
It helps
Sanket Daware Ha Ha... I have always been told I speak too fast so I am slowing myself down, actually... SG
I always watch in 2x
Wow just...brilliant ,i am impressed shekharji
Following your videos for sometime now. Very informative. 👍
Vidhya Sathy thank you very much, Vidhya... SG
After mr Patel the Nation is being led by a bunch of patriots who relate themselves to their soil, vandemataram
Most of the places bosses takes away all the credit for the work done by juniors and here you are giving due credits to your junior collegues which is great.
I love how he gives credit to the people who help him out.
You are helping many upsc aspirants like me thank you very much
Sir... Thank you so much
Thank you for in-depth analysis.
Handing over the credits to junior fellows. " Big heart = Big man"!
Really nice analysis sir. As a IR student it was much useful for me...
Your optimism about Narendra Modi settling border disputer could come true
1. He peacefully settled the enclave problems with Bangladesh
2. He should settle the disputes with Sri Lanka on fishing rights and fishermen problem because it's related to kathatheevu island
3. Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir should be reintegrated with India
4. Aksai chin should be reintegrated with India
5. Clarity on Arunachal Pradesh should be made up
I hope our PM does all this, and I am optimistic towards it too
Great Shekhar sir... I love your shows...
Good summary . Thank you
Love this analysis.. thank you so much
Mr. J Shankar's policy OR Indi'a External Policy is very crystal clear now
You forgot to mention the enclave agreement (chhit-Mahal pact) with Bangladesh which finishes boundary disputes between India n Bangladesh...
Brilliant presentation Sir.
Respect sir👌
excellent episode ...
thank you so much for this video!
Thank you for this!
He is by large the best MEA of India, which the world respects.
Loved it
Super explain by sir
Brilliant explanation Shekharji. Your depth of experience and clarity of thought reflects in every word. Commendable the way you support and nurture team talent. My question; please can you de clutter Indo China 🇨🇳 relationship and potential outcomes in future.
Best wishes - Himanshu
At the end of the day, watch SG's CTC and go to bed with a lot more clarity in thoughts! 😊
And also try to watch other channels too... If we depend on one channel.. U will be biased without knowing full point.. Print is the same which disagree on some real point too by their biasness