@Dominic Barrell right Oswald wasn't always heavy set the Gotham show actually used the silver age early Oswald ..he didn't get fat until he go into politics
I have a risky idea, Gabrielle Union as Clayface. And when you compare her struggles as an actor to Clayfaces origin it only makes more sense. There would be like so much you could do with that.
I've heard people say Tennant as Riddler before, and as much as I love Tennant I'm not sure it's ideal. The thing about him is that it's difficult for him not to come off as confident, and the Riddler is inherently a character driven by insecurity.
I disagree slightly. The Riddler is driven by a bit of insecurity, but he covers it up with a facade of cockiness and a desire to be seen as the smartest in the room. Tennant has played characters who can give off a “I am cocky out of insecurity” relatively well, in my opinion. He does not suffer a fool. He has played both characters who like to be seen as smarter than those around them, and characters with a bit of darkness in him. I have little doubt that he could handle the role. Besides, his insecurity should be something that he is intentionally trying to hide, so it should be a little cocky.
I really want to see Manbat. My top choices are Andy Serkis, Alan Tudyk, Ben Mendelssohn, Peter Capaldi, Sharlto Copley, David Thewlis, and my number 1 choice, David Wenham. Doug Jones is also a good choice if he goes the prosthetic route, and would provide sympathy and creepy movement in equal parts.
Honestly, I feel like Bill Skarsgard would be a great Scarecrow. He already has the look of being tall, skinny, and could pull of intelligent. He also has the experience of playing a role like Scarecrow. Pennywise is a lot like him. Both characters control fear and use it against their foes/enemies.
Bill Skarsgard is my pick for Joker, alternate to the dream casting of Willem Dafoe. Facial muscles and his expressions fully fit the role for Bill. He’d thrive if we’re doing Clown Prince of Crime, purple tux, running through Gotham being chaotic and everything.
Alan tudtk would nail it as crane. His role in resident alien shows his acting ability and his role and tucker and dale shows his physical acting. Listen to his voice deepened and warbling and you’ll see it.
@@XtoverusRex “sort of” No he isn’t, casting a non-Hispanic actor as Bane is disrespectful to the character. Bane being Hispanic is very important to his character since he is a literal Luchador.
Have you seen David Tennant as Denis Nilsen, it was a British drama about a real murderer, the performance is daunting, he has this calm and menacing feel that almost makes you feel bad for him. It's called "Des" and aired on ITV
I'd like to see Deadshot, Deathstroke, Clayface, Man-Bat, Carmine Falcone, Hush, Thomas and Martha Wayne, Azrael (Jean-Paul Valley), Bronze Tiger, Killer Croc, Solomon Grundy, Terry McGinnis, Calvin Rose, Talos, Victor Zsasz and from the women - Catwoman, Poison Ivy, Harley Quinn, Talia Al Ghul, Barbara Gordan, Cassandra Cain and Batwoman (Kate Kane) and Vicky Vale, Huntress and obviously Ace:)
@@marvelpugs6964 and He was in Batman begins and will be in the Robert Patterson Batman I'd love see the Mad Hatter, Poison Ivy and Calendar man (he was in the new suicide squad played by Sean Gunn) in the dceu And Zantanna in the dceu eventually
Awesome castings! Couldn't do better even if i try, but i will try. Here are my casts: Two Face: Eric Bana Scarecrow: Rufus Sewell Penguin: Joe Pantoliano Bane: Edgar Ramirez (who is hispanic just like Bane) Riddler: Paul Bettany Mr Freeze: Ben Mendelsohn Other villains: Catwoman: Krysten Ritter Poison ivy: Anya Chalotra Deathstroke: Pablo Schreiber Hugo Strange: Stellan Skarsgård Victor Zsasz: Milo Ventimiglia Black Mask: Colin Farrell Carmine Falcone: Kevin Bacon Killer Croc: Laz Alonso Ventroloquist: Michael Emerson Scarface (voice): Matthew Mercer
@@rudranshu65sengupta14yeah Bettany would do a great job as the Scarecrow. I have not seen Ruth Wilson in anything so i cant say if she would do the part well.
Cant see Paul Barnes for Black mask, I think noone else could play Black Mask better than Micheal Shannon, although black mask in birds of prey was good, I wasnt what alot of people were expecting
He absolutely would, but i always try to go outside the box while fancasting. And after seeing Barnes as Billy Russo, I think he could be a solid black mask. But i totally agree with both you and Bryan that Michael Shannon would be an amazing Black mask.
I really wish we could've gotten more of Joe Manganiello as Deathstroke, he's such a great actor and has played such a wide variety of characters (though he was the best in True Blood imo) I think he'll be in the Snyder cut, but still it's a shame he couldn't be in a Batman/Nightwing/Titans movie instead (assuming they'd eventually make Titans/Young Justice, and Nightwing into a movie).
All great choices for these roles. If I wanted to see any other villains, then, in terms of male characters, it would be Clayface, Killer Croc, maybe curious about Hush (will you use the same actor for Batman or someone who looks similar), Mad Hatter (and maybe Alice too, if you want to go the same route as they did in Batwoman) and while they're not villains, I'm curious who you would get for the Waynes.
You should fan cast for a hypothetical "Next Avengers: Heroes of Tomorrow" movie or actors for a hypothetical red dead redemption 2 movies. Or actors for Percy Jackson series or hypothetically actors for the characters of "young justice"
I’ll give you my castings for red read 2 Arthur- Chris Pine Dutch Jeffrey Dean Morgan John- Liam Hemsworth Hosea- Willem Dafoe Abagail- Zooey Deschanel Bill- David Harbour Pearson-Nick Offerman Sadie- Margot Robbie Lenny- John Boyega Tilly- Yara Shahidi Micah- Peter Blomquist Strauss- Christoph Waltz Mary Linton- Lauren Cohan Sean- Domhnall Gleason Javier- Micheal Pena Reverend Swanson- William H Macy Molly- Amy Adams Mary Beth- Lacey Chabert Karen- Holland Roden Charles- Eddie Spears
@@aarongarcia5590 I agree with most of your picks but some to me are too young for the roles like for example Holland Roden but idk about Chris pine for Arthur Morgan and liam hemsworth as John though idk think they really fit the characters, however. Willem Dafoe as Hosea and Jeffrey dean Morgan as Dutch is pretty good
I think the main problem with Percy Jackson casting is that most of the main characters are very young. It would probably be similar to Harry Potter where he wouldn't cast the main characters, but it would be interesting to see him cast the gods and such.
I know that it's a very weird opinion but I think that he could make for an interesting Professor Pyg. I can however definitely see how Riddler may fit him as well.
I've always wanted Tom Hollander as Penguin and Giancarlo Esposito as Mr. Freeze. I also quite like the idea of LaKetih Stanfield as Riddler (just watch him in Death Note)
Penguin is interesting. He portrays himself as a cosmopolitan gentlemen about town, he is extraordinarily vain and concerned with appearances, and he's also very clever, sociable, and knows how to deal with people on an intellectual level, but just underneath the surface he's a vicious, spiteful little bastard. He's almost like the Kingpin, but a little shy in the area of physical power. I grew up with Batman Returns too, and Danny DeVito captured the inner spirit of the Penguin, his rage and his cruelty, but while he still dresses in finery and portrays himself as a gentleman, the monster is too close to the surface, too easy to see. I feel like an ideal Penguin should be someone easy to underestimate, a funny little man you can't picture hurting you until he slits your throat with a broken bottle. Toby Jones is a good fit for that, I agree, but he'd have to work a lot harder to maintain that veneer of respectability, despite his physical deformities.
Anarky- Cameron Monaghan KGBeast- Callan Mulvey or Dolph Lundgren Professor Pyg- Jack Black or John Carroll Lynch Mad Hatter- Fred Savage Ventriloquist- Micheal Emerson
@@aarongarcia5590 Very good But I would go with Josh Gad or Paul Giamati as Pyg Simong Pegg or Harry Melling as the Mad Hatter And John Lithgow as Ventriloquist Even though your options are not bad
Be interesting to see Punchline in live action, I know she's a very new character, but she seems to have quickly become a fan favourite, and come to think of it, Joker War as a Movie would be pretty cool.
I really agree with all your choices- and I’m also a huge fan of the Riddler and David Tennant, but for me, I would love to see Benedict Cumberbatch in that role, and I would like to go more into the human side of the Riddler rather than the serial killer side of him.
Tennant can do human side exceptionally well, though. Arguably even better than Benedict. Just look at his work in Broadchurch, or especially as the Tenth Doctor. It was impossible how he felt both human and alien in that role, but he pulled it off
I'd want to see Clayface, Deadshot, Firefly, Hush, Killer Croc, Hugo Strange, Mad Hatter, Mr. Zsasz, The Ventriloquist (Arnold Wesker), Solomon Grundy, Man-Bat, Killer Moth, Anarky, Maxie Zeus, Electrocutioner, Great White Shark, Copperhead, Calendar Man, and Baby Doll (From the Animated Series)
My Picks Two Face: Oliver Jackson-Cohen Scarecrow: Ethan Hawke Penguin: Paul Anderson Bane (To keep him comic accurate, I chose a Hispanic actor): Pedro Pascal The Riddler: Andrew Scott Mr. Freeze: Michael Shannon
I stopped watching Gotham after season 2 and one episode into season 3. It got far too silly and over the top. I felt like I was watching a cross between the Schumacher and 60s TV show era’s just with a similar aesthetic to the Burton films. Sure there was violence, but the tone was so corny it actually made me embarrassed to keep watching.
I loved him as The Doctor in Doctor Who, he is my Doctor and I loved his performance in the series and stopped watching the series once he left. And his performance as Kilgrave scared the shit out of me!
My picks are: -John David Washington as Two-face -Steven Yeun as Scarecrow -Patton Oswalt as the penguin -the mountain(body) and Danny Trejo(voice) as Bane Your choices for riddler and Freeze are literally perfect.
@@bironjames9948 Danny Trejo is swole he can play bane pre venom and can do mocap post venom ..and funny enough he voiced a muscled bound huge Mexican wrestler in Hitman
Two-Face: Chris Pine Scarecrow: Jackie Haley Penguin: Toby Jones Bane's Physical: Dave Bautista Bane's Voice: Javier Bardem Riddler: Jim Parsons Mr. Freeze: Mark Strong
Two-Face: James Franco Scarecrow: DJ Qualls or Noah Taylor Penguin: Jim Carter Bane’s Physically: Dave Bautista Bane’s Voice: Eric Lopez - Voice for Bane on Young Justice Riddler: Adrian Brody Mr. Freeze: Mads Mikkelsen
I like your choice of Mathew Mccaunahay as two face. Did you see him in frailty? He played a character who's identity was careful hidden in complex narrative.
Imagine a storyline with Batman going to Mexico and seeing bane in the ring and then he discovers that bane is a crime lord and joker supplies bane with a serum on the condition that bane comes to Gotham to work over there and Batman then sees the jacked up bane killing people on the streets and I think Dave Bautista is a good pick for bane
For the women, do Harley Quinn, Punchline, Poison Ivy, Batwoman, Red Alice, and Batgirl, and for the one after, Hugo Strange, Man Bat, Hush, Killer Croc, Talon, and Mad Hatter
@@kurankrishan8971 Batgirl is good, but Since it’s an older take and the characters are older, I’d have Sonoya Mizuno as punchline, Melissa Rouch as Harley Quinn, and Rosario Dawson as Poison Ivy
Regarding Bane, if you plan to have him speak a little bit, he needs to be a little on the Latino side. If he was masked, you could get away with having Danny Trejo in the role
Danny Trejo would be great he is one of my favorite actors. Hadn't thought of him for Bane because he's not ridiculously muscular, but I guess the Venom would make him bigger. So I'm with you that'd be perfect.
I think the person that can be perfect as Two Face would be Glenn Jacobs (or for any WWE fans know him as The Big Red Monster himself Kane) because he technically is Two Face Glenn Jacobs is a mayor and Kane is an evil twisted monster that will destroyed anyone who get’s into his way
oh that would fit really well jackle earl i mean in the game version withe robert englund it kinda worked but i think jE hayley fits the role really well hope he keeps the freddy kruger on while poioned the victim with his fear toxion that would be more terrifying compared to murphy. (just only hopping if it did happen or not)
I was getting HEAVY Professor Pyg vibe from that Jason Issacs clip you showed more than Mr Freeze, tbh I don’t think many people can get that character down, they were very close in Gotham but they killed his wife and in turn they ruined the whole point of the character. I’d honestly go with Wentworth Miller, yes he is probably the best Captian Cold we’ve had but they way he played Cold was very sympathetic yet still kinda a shitty person who only wants to protect his sister and I feel like he’d just capture it like no one else. Would be weird seeing him cast as two different Ice gun wielding characters but he’s just perfect for the role
You know at one point, I referenced Jackie's take on Rorschach for my depiction of Scarecrow. Who would've guessed. Great picks on the characters. I think I'd like to see Mad Hatter, Hugo Strange, Hush, but the rest is up to you.
I know this won't be a popular opinion, but it would be great to have an episode dedicated to underground, B-Tier villains, like Kite Man, or Calendar Man
I kinda wanna see Robert Englund as Scarecrow. Edit: I just realized he also played Scarecrow in Injustice 2. All the more reason to make him a live action Scarecrow.
I'd like to see Deadshot and Deathstroke. For girls, I'd be interested in seeing the Birds of Prey (Oracle/Batgirl, Black Canary, Huntress, etc.), as well as some others like Talia al Ghul and Harley Quinn
Riddler is my favorite Batman villain as well and I have always wanted David tennant as the riddler I wanted him to be the riddler for years but it never happened.
@Bryan Seeker. Have you seen the Gotham Show? Very relevant for recasting these people and the Penguin in there, played by Robin Lord Taylor, is GREAT! Cant stress that enough.
I mean, Javier Barden has to be Bane, right? Size, voice, terror. Anton Chigurch in a wrestling mask. There's no contest. Also, jeffrey combs should be Scarecrow. He was the voice of him in the New Animated Advebtures, and as Scarecrow is 90% mask anyway, and I've never heard of a creepier voice for him, he'd be perfect.
Great video man: you have made some very intersting choices. Here there are my choices : Two Face: Jake Gyllenhaal Scarecrow: Richard Armitage Penguin: Jonah Hill Bane: Javier Bardem Riddler: Matt Smith Mr. Freeze: James Spader
How about this: Two-Face: James Franco Scarecrow: Noah Taylor/DJ Qualls Penguin: Jim Carter Bane: Dave Bautista Riddler: Adrian Brody Mr. Freeze: Mads Mikkelsen/Alfred Molina
Here are my picks - I know people want him to play the Joker but Willem Dafoe as Two-Face would be spectacular. Aussie actor Ben Mendelsohn as scarecrow. He has the range to be a believable psychologist and madman. Peter Dinklage as Penguin and not just because he's short but the performance would blow people away. Bane is a difficult one because I think they should CGI a regular guy into a beast of a guy like they do Bruce Banner and The Hulk and I see Benedict Cumberbatch annihilating that role. The Riddler is a tough one because people have expectations (and Jim Carrey met all of those with his portrayal) and although it is a camp character that would suit a silly Paul Reubens type, I would cast Timothee Chalamet but just because I wanna see what dark direction he would take the character. Mr. Freeze for me is a no-brainer, there is a no question, Bryan Cranston would steal the entire franchise if he played Mr. Freeze.
This was amazing! Is there any chance when you get through Batman and some of the others, you could do some video game fan casting? Like GTA 5 or Uncharted or RDR2 or whatever? That would be awesome
Love all your choices. Only thing I would change, is the Riddler. While I’m sure David Tennant would be great in the role, I would actually have Tennant as the Mad Hatter, and Neil Patrick Harris as the Riddler. Could you cast Professor Pyg, Firefly, Hush, and Deadshot.
I’d like to see Man-Bat, Mad Hatter, Firefly, Deadshot, and Deathstroke casted
I honestly think Manu Bennett is the ideal choice for Deathstroke but it would be cool to see Bryan recast him
Man-bat mad hatter firefly - Gotham
Deadshot - suicide squad
Deathstroke - Titans
But itd be nice to see them in a Batman movie all together
@Anonymous
I don't recall seeing Man Bat in Gotham which season was it?
I'd like to see Pedro Pascal as Deadshot
@@Werewolf914 he was part of fish mooneys monster gang but he went by the name of tweaker
Finally, someone else suggests Toby Jones!
I was getting sick of hearing other actor's names getting thrown around just because they are over-weight.
@Dominic Barrell right Oswald wasn't always heavy set the Gotham show actually used the silver age early Oswald ..he didn't get fat until he go into politics
I’d love to see Hush, Clayface, and Professor Pyg
Clayface is the most underrated Batman villain
What Bout calendar man?
@@droupscoup3541 yess and clock king
Honestly, Hush is essential if you're doing RedHood in my opinion.
I have a risky idea, Gabrielle Union as Clayface. And when you compare her struggles as an actor to Clayfaces origin it only makes more sense. There would be like so much you could do with that.
No spoilers: that last casting, Bryan, is GENIUS! Wow.
That actor is underrated and I always say he’d be perfect as Doctor Doom in the MCU
I've heard people say Tennant as Riddler before, and as much as I love Tennant I'm not sure it's ideal. The thing about him is that it's difficult for him not to come off as confident, and the Riddler is inherently a character driven by insecurity.
I disagree slightly. The Riddler is driven by a bit of insecurity, but he covers it up with a facade of cockiness and a desire to be seen as the smartest in the room. Tennant has played characters who can give off a “I am cocky out of insecurity” relatively well, in my opinion. He does not suffer a fool. He has played both characters who like to be seen as smarter than those around them, and characters with a bit of darkness in him. I have little doubt that he could handle the role. Besides, his insecurity should be something that he is intentionally trying to hide, so it should be a little cocky.
*looks at Des from ITV* eeeeeeh, I'm not sure about that.....
@@brandon91191 how about Adrien Brody as the Riddler
@@brandon91191 Yea it’s covered up that’s the thing idk if Tennant could do that in the awkward way Riddler does
As much as I love tenant, I think the actor who played riddler in Gotham would be a good choice
Manbat, Killer Croc, Clayface, and Andy Serkis as Hugo Strange.
Was thinking Serkis would be a better mad hatter, but I could see both.
@@Jack-zz7bc Yeah he will be. A better mad hatter
I really want to see Manbat. My top choices are Andy Serkis, Alan Tudyk, Ben Mendelssohn, Peter Capaldi, Sharlto Copley, David Thewlis, and my number 1 choice, David Wenham. Doug Jones is also a good choice if he goes the prosthetic route, and would provide sympathy and creepy movement in equal parts.
Andy Serkis is playing Alfred in the new Batman
@@jamesdaniels8297 I am aware. But this is a different Batman.
I really do think Paul Dano is the perfect choice we weren’t expecting
Honestly, I feel like Bill Skarsgard would be a great Scarecrow. He already has the look of being tall, skinny, and could pull of intelligent. He also has the experience of playing a role like Scarecrow. Pennywise is a lot like him. Both characters control fear and use it against their foes/enemies.
Bill Skarsgard would be my second choice for Joker, right after Willem Dafoe.
@@realjoemavro yeah
Bill Skarsgard is my pick for Joker, alternate to the dream casting of Willem Dafoe. Facial muscles and his expressions fully fit the role for Bill. He’d thrive if we’re doing Clown Prince of Crime, purple tux, running through Gotham being chaotic and everything.
Alan tudtk would nail it as crane. His role in resident alien shows his acting ability and his role and tucker and dale shows his physical acting. Listen to his voice deepened and warbling and you’ll see it.
@@realjoemavro ye
Coincidentally, Dave himself, declared that he would LOVE to play an iteration of Bane on the big screen. He'd definitely be perfect for that role.
just seeing david tennant in the thumbnail makes me excited for this one!
David Tennant was great in Jessica Jones and I'd love him as ridler
He would be great, Aidan Gillen (Littlefinger from GoT) would have been my first choice but Tennant might be even better
Just imagine him in a green suit.
He should be allowed to utilised his distinct Scottish accent a lot more, like in Ducktales. He sounds like a Scottish Liam Neeson.
Toby Jones would be a PHENOMENAL penguin, I never even thought of that.
Edit: Thanks for all the likes, I’ve never gotten this many before!
16 is not a lot of likes
@@G_money333 Well it’s the most I’ve ever gotten so shut up, Brainiac is literally my least favorite villain in all of comics
@@teddy-fl6hm Ok was trying to be nice lol. And you wonder why you get no likes
@@G_money333 that's what you consider being nice?
@@skodedickinson6544 I was just stating that 16 is not a lot
Have to disagree, bane really should be played by a Hispanic actor.
Bautista is half Filipino, which is sort of hispanic.
I agree
@@XtoverusRex Filipinos can be considered sort of Hispanic but we're asian so it still wouldn't really work
@@XtoverusRex “sort of” No he isn’t, casting a non-Hispanic actor as Bane is disrespectful to the character. Bane being Hispanic is very important to his character since he is a literal Luchador.
Javier bardem
Bryan uploading makes my day. Would you ever consider doing a casting for the next Bond?
I would cast Robert pattison. And that would be a good video
His castings are sort of generic, so I’m pretty sure he’d just cast Tom Hardy or Henry Cavill as Bond
@@fchwqosome of his choices are generic but I'd say that he's the best caster on UA-cam by a long way and he puts in lots of research as well
@@fchwqo who's your choice for bond
@@CD-603 Oliver Jackson Cohen or Dan Stevens are my picks for 007 :)
Have you seen David Tennant as Denis Nilsen, it was a British drama about a real murderer, the performance is daunting, he has this calm and menacing feel that almost makes you feel bad for him. It's called "Des" and aired on ITV
Yes i watched it. He was amazing in it.
After seeing the show, I heard of someone who compared the real Dennis Nilsen to Jeffrey Dahmer, as they both targeted gay men & wear similar glasses.
Literally every single actor in this is SOOO perfect
Scarecrow is my favorite character, and I think the Dark Knight Trilogy version was cool
Wish you went with a Hispanic choice for Bane, but I could see Dave. I think Pedro Pascal or Laz Alonso would work
Pedro Pascal would be perfect. Can we pretend that WW84 never happened (although his performance was really good) and just cast him as Bane?
Pedro only works if they pull a CGI as well done as the MCU’s Brolin to Thanos.
Javier Bardem
@@kenelliott4872 they could use him as the voice since bane does wear a mask with Batista being the physical bane
@@kenelliott4872 , yeah and many audience are feeling that CGI is being overused for movies.
Hugo Strange, Mad Hatter, Azreal, Talon, Hush, Killer Croc, Deathstroke, The Batman Who Laughs, Anarky, Victor Zsasz for a start
Mad Hatter: Michael Sheen
I'd like to see Deadshot, Deathstroke, Clayface, Man-Bat, Carmine Falcone, Hush, Thomas and Martha Wayne, Azrael (Jean-Paul Valley), Bronze Tiger, Killer Croc, Solomon Grundy, Terry McGinnis, Calvin Rose, Talos, Victor Zsasz and from the women - Catwoman, Poison Ivy, Harley Quinn, Talia Al Ghul, Barbara Gordan, Cassandra Cain and Batwoman (Kate Kane) and Vicky Vale, Huntress and obviously Ace:)
So... everyone?
Carmine falcone in Gotham
Michael Jai White would be perfect as Bronze Tiger.
I think that man bat should be played by Rami Malek honestly. Also I'd love to see a Daniel Sharman Azrael.
@@marvelpugs6964 and He was in Batman begins and will be in the Robert Patterson Batman
I'd love see the Mad Hatter, Poison Ivy and Calendar man (he was in the new suicide squad played by Sean Gunn) in the dceu
And Zantanna in the dceu eventually
Every choice just works for me. I can see the world your building not just the red hood but the tone and reality of this Gotham. Good stuff bro
Ah yes my favorite member of the church- David “Baptista”
Funnily enough with the name mistake, his original character was Deacon Batista
OH MY BROTHER... TESTIFY!!!
I would love David Tennant as Riddler, he's such a cool actor, who I think would definitely fit the Riddler vibes.
If he was meant to be older, I can easily see Michael Emerson as Riddler. Maybe as Hugo Strange?
I can see him as Like ventriloquist too
Awesome castings! Couldn't do better even if i try, but i will try. Here are my casts:
Two Face: Eric Bana
Scarecrow: Rufus Sewell
Penguin: Joe Pantoliano
Bane: Edgar Ramirez (who is hispanic just like Bane)
Riddler: Paul Bettany
Mr Freeze: Ben Mendelsohn
Other villains:
Catwoman: Krysten Ritter
Poison ivy: Anya Chalotra
Deathstroke: Pablo Schreiber
Hugo Strange: Stellan Skarsgård
Victor Zsasz: Milo Ventimiglia
Black Mask: Colin Farrell
Carmine Falcone: Kevin Bacon
Killer Croc: Laz Alonso
Ventroloquist: Michael Emerson
Scarface (voice): Matthew Mercer
Gordillio Nerd Talk I personally think Paul Bettany would go better with Scarecrow. For Poison Ivy I cannot think of anyone better than Ruth Wilson
@@rudranshu65sengupta14yeah Bettany would do a great job as the Scarecrow. I have not seen Ruth Wilson in anything so i cant say if she would do the part well.
Cant see Paul Barnes for Black mask, I think noone else could play Black Mask better than Micheal Shannon, although black mask in birds of prey was good, I wasnt what alot of people were expecting
He absolutely would, but i always try to go outside the box while fancasting. And after seeing Barnes as Billy Russo, I think he could be a solid black mask. But i totally agree with both you and Bryan that Michael Shannon would be an amazing Black mask.
I really wish we could've gotten more of Joe Manganiello as Deathstroke, he's such a great actor and has played such a wide variety of characters (though he was the best in True Blood imo) I think he'll be in the Snyder cut, but still it's a shame he couldn't be in a Batman/Nightwing/Titans movie instead (assuming they'd eventually make Titans/Young Justice, and Nightwing into a movie).
Paul Dano’s riddler is gonna be the highlight of the Batman
And he was
I'd have loved Phillip Seymour Hoffman as Penguin
I love to see The Rock as Bane and Nicolas Cage as Scarecrow
Jack Earl Hayley, the casting I never knew I wanted, now the one I need
I'd actually like to see Rami Malek as Scarecrow.
Not terrifying enough though.
Caleb Landry Jones as Scarecrow will be better imo
Dave Batista is the perfect casting for Bane he even wants to play this role
Can't wait for other recastings of dc property. I'd like to see your vision on a rebooted dc cinematic universe
Clay face, man-bat, and killer croc would be dope, perhaps Andy sircus for one of them?
I like the fact he chose the newer Freddy as scarecrow, and Robert Englund, the other guy who played Freddy, voiced scarecrow in Injustice 😂
All great choices for these roles. If I wanted to see any other villains, then, in terms of male characters, it would be Clayface, Killer Croc, maybe curious about Hush (will you use the same actor for Batman or someone who looks similar), Mad Hatter (and maybe Alice too, if you want to go the same route as they did in Batwoman) and while they're not villains, I'm curious who you would get for the Waynes.
You should fan cast for a hypothetical "Next Avengers: Heroes of Tomorrow" movie or actors for a hypothetical red dead redemption 2 movies. Or actors for Percy Jackson series or hypothetically actors for the characters of "young justice"
I’ll give you my castings for red read 2
Arthur- Chris Pine
Dutch Jeffrey Dean Morgan
John- Liam Hemsworth
Hosea- Willem Dafoe
Abagail- Zooey Deschanel
Bill- David Harbour
Pearson-Nick Offerman
Sadie- Margot Robbie
Lenny- John Boyega
Tilly- Yara Shahidi
Micah- Peter Blomquist
Strauss- Christoph Waltz
Mary Linton- Lauren Cohan
Sean- Domhnall Gleason
Javier- Micheal Pena
Reverend Swanson- William H Macy
Molly- Amy Adams
Mary Beth- Lacey Chabert
Karen- Holland Roden
Charles- Eddie Spears
@@aarongarcia5590 I agree with most of your picks but some to me are too young for the roles like for example Holland Roden but idk about Chris pine for Arthur Morgan and liam hemsworth as John though idk think they really fit the characters, however. Willem Dafoe as Hosea and Jeffrey dean Morgan as Dutch is pretty good
I think the main problem with Percy Jackson casting is that most of the main characters are very young. It would probably be similar to Harry Potter where he wouldn't cast the main characters, but it would be interesting to see him cast the gods and such.
I
T h idk about young justice
Is impossible to have a better casting for this roles! I'll recommend Hugo Strange, Mad Hatter, Man-Bat
I think Rainn Wilson as Riddler would just work so well.
honestly his role as dwight despite being comedy driven really sells me on him playing the riddler
also i just know he could play a darker role
I know that it's a very weird opinion but I think that he could make for an interesting Professor Pyg. I can however definitely see how Riddler may fit him as well.
@@T0X1CM8 oh noooo, pyg
I've always wanted Tom Hollander as Penguin and Giancarlo Esposito as Mr. Freeze. I also quite like the idea of LaKetih Stanfield as Riddler (just watch him in Death Note)
Scarecrow should be Robert Englund. I know he already voiced him in Injustice 2, but he’s just too perfect.
If not him, I’d cast Ben Mendelson
Penguin is interesting. He portrays himself as a cosmopolitan gentlemen about town, he is extraordinarily vain and concerned with appearances, and he's also very clever, sociable, and knows how to deal with people on an intellectual level, but just underneath the surface he's a vicious, spiteful little bastard. He's almost like the Kingpin, but a little shy in the area of physical power. I grew up with Batman Returns too, and Danny DeVito captured the inner spirit of the Penguin, his rage and his cruelty, but while he still dresses in finery and portrays himself as a gentleman, the monster is too close to the surface, too easy to see. I feel like an ideal Penguin should be someone easy to underestimate, a funny little man you can't picture hurting you until he slits your throat with a broken bottle. Toby Jones is a good fit for that, I agree, but he'd have to work a lot harder to maintain that veneer of respectability, despite his physical deformities.
Please, make a chapter about less known villains, like KGBeast, Professor Pyg, Anarchy, Mad Hatter, the Ventriloquist ...
YEA
Anarky- Cameron Monaghan
KGBeast- Callan Mulvey or Dolph Lundgren
Professor Pyg- Jack Black or John Carroll Lynch
Mad Hatter- Fred Savage
Ventriloquist- Micheal Emerson
@@aarongarcia5590 Very good
But I would go with Josh Gad or Paul Giamati as Pyg
Simong Pegg or Harry Melling as the Mad Hatter
And John Lithgow as Ventriloquist
Even though your options are not bad
@@albert42 Micheal Emerson in Arrow showed he can play a sane psychopath so that’s why he’s my pick
@@aarongarcia5590 Yes I know, it's another very good choice
Be interesting to see Punchline in live action, I know she's a very new character, but she seems to have quickly become a fan favourite, and come to think of it, Joker War as a Movie would be pretty cool.
I really agree with all your choices- and I’m also a huge fan of the Riddler and David Tennant, but for me, I would love to see Benedict Cumberbatch in that role, and I would like to go more into the human side of the Riddler rather than the serial killer side of him.
Tennant can do human side exceptionally well, though. Arguably even better than Benedict. Just look at his work in Broadchurch, or especially as the Tenth Doctor. It was impossible how he felt both human and alien in that role, but he pulled it off
Human side of him? Gotham season 1-3
If Scarecrow kept his mask on during most of the conceptual movie, I think Kellen Geoff, the VA of Fiddlesticks, should do his voiceover.
did you watch the Gotham show, it could help some strings connect it
Wish you casted every person in every film ever
A favorite Riddler fancast for me has been Matthew Gray Gubler or Matt Smith but Gubler is my FULL choice
Beautifully done. I want to see Man Bat, Clay Face, Hush, The Batman who Laughs.
I’m just waiting for your take on Percy Jackson, while also enjoying these of course
imagine if they pulled this off and poached the Green Goblin and Kilgrave for Joker and Riddler
I'd want to see Clayface, Deadshot, Firefly, Hush, Killer Croc, Hugo Strange, Mad Hatter, Mr. Zsasz, The Ventriloquist (Arnold Wesker), Solomon Grundy, Man-Bat, Killer Moth, Anarky, Maxie Zeus, Electrocutioner, Great White Shark, Copperhead, Calendar Man, and Baby Doll (From the Animated Series)
Mad Hatter: Michael Sheen
Kevin Kline as ventriloquist and Scarface
My Picks
Two Face: Oliver Jackson-Cohen
Scarecrow: Ethan Hawke
Penguin: Paul Anderson
Bane (To keep him comic accurate, I chose a Hispanic actor): Pedro Pascal
The Riddler: Andrew Scott
Mr. Freeze: Michael Shannon
I think Jackson-Cohen would be a neat Hush as well
Slightly older choice, but Christoph Waltz would be perfect as Mr Freeze.
@@rudranshu65sengupta14 agreed
@Lego I see him as Reverse-Flash though
PoStED Wit mY
BrUdDA SiPPin oN WOck 🧛🏿♂️‼️
I'm probably the only one who wants to see David Tennant as Two face aka Harvey Dent
He would be good as him to.
Simon russel Beale would play the perfect penguin
Deathstroke, firefly, killer croc, calendar man, clayface, and ragdoll. Love the series keep it up!
Calendar man was in the latest suicide squad
I can't believe he mentioned Riddler without talking about the Fox Gotham version
That's what I was hoping for. That was an amazing representation of Riddler
I stopped watching Gotham after season 2 and one episode into season 3. It got far too silly and over the top. I felt like I was watching a cross between the Schumacher and 60s TV show era’s just with a similar aesthetic to the Burton films. Sure there was violence, but the tone was so corny it actually made me embarrassed to keep watching.
@@thomaskilroy4573 Yes but we can't deny they got so many characters right although the plot kinda died after season 3
David Tenannt was really good as Kilgrave. He was the Highlight in Jessica Jones.
I loved him as The Doctor in Doctor Who, he is my Doctor and I loved his performance in the series and stopped watching the series once he left. And his performance as Kilgrave scared the shit out of me!
This has to be the best casting for anything I’ve ever seen
It would be interesting to see the live-action cast for Attack on Titan.
Jason Isaacs is a really good choice I’ve not heard before, but I still hope we get Giancarlo Esposito as Freeze
My picks are:
-John David Washington as Two-face
-Steven Yeun as Scarecrow
-Patton Oswalt as the penguin
-the mountain(body) and Danny Trejo(voice) as Bane
Your choices for riddler and Freeze are literally perfect.
Banes voice should be deep n grounded spanish accent like dudes from Nicaragua or Chile maybe Venezuela
@@bironjames9948 Danny Trejo is swole he can play bane pre venom and can do mocap post venom ..and funny enough he voiced a muscled bound huge Mexican wrestler in Hitman
Could you please do a justice league after your done with Batman’s Gallery
Edit:in this same batman universe
Two-Face: Chris Pine
Scarecrow: Jackie Haley
Penguin: Toby Jones
Bane's Physical: Dave Bautista
Bane's Voice: Javier Bardem
Riddler: Jim Parsons
Mr. Freeze: Mark Strong
Two-Face: James Franco
Scarecrow: DJ Qualls or Noah Taylor
Penguin: Jim Carter
Bane’s Physically: Dave Bautista
Bane’s Voice: Eric Lopez - Voice for Bane on Young Justice
Riddler: Adrian Brody
Mr. Freeze: Mads Mikkelsen
@@ebenezeronile i don't know a lot of them but the ones that I do know, I'm not huge on. thanks for sharing your opinions though
I like your choice of Mathew Mccaunahay as two face. Did you see him in frailty? He played a character who's identity was careful hidden in complex narrative.
David Tennent would be perfect
Imagine a storyline with Batman going to Mexico and seeing bane in the ring and then he discovers that bane is a crime lord and joker supplies bane with a serum on the condition that bane comes to Gotham to work over there and Batman then sees the jacked up bane killing people on the streets and I think Dave Bautista is a good pick for bane
Deathstroke, Owlman, Madhatter, Falcone, Hugo Strange, Professor Pyg, Clay Face
Mad Hatter: Michael Sheen
I want to hear your take on killer Croc, mad hatter, Hugo strange who is really underrated and at last hush
For the women, do Harley Quinn, Punchline, Poison Ivy, Batwoman, Red Alice, and Batgirl, and for the one after, Hugo Strange, Man Bat, Hush, Killer Croc, Talon, and Mad Hatter
Mad Hatter: Michael Sheen
Batgirl: Emma Stone
Harley Quinn: Margot Robbie
Poison Ivy: Eva Green
Punchline: awkwafina
@@kurankrishan8971 Batgirl is good, but Since it’s an older take and the characters are older, I’d have Sonoya Mizuno as punchline, Melissa Rouch as Harley Quinn, and Rosario Dawson as Poison Ivy
@@anubusx i think he has the acting skills to pull it off, but he’s not who I’d go for look wise
Hush: Nicolas Hoult
Hugo Strange: Bryan Cranston
I think Jackie Earle Haley is a great pick for Scarecrow. But I’d also like to see Sean Harris give it a shot.
Regarding Bane, if you plan to have him speak a little bit, he needs to be a little on the Latino side. If he was masked, you could get away with having Danny Trejo in the role
Danny Trejo would be great he is one of my favorite actors. Hadn't thought of him for Bane because he's not ridiculously muscular, but I guess the Venom would make him bigger. So I'm with you that'd be perfect.
I think the person that can be perfect as Two Face would be Glenn Jacobs (or for any WWE fans know him as The Big Red Monster himself Kane) because he technically is Two Face Glenn Jacobs is a mayor and Kane is an evil twisted monster that will destroyed anyone who get’s into his way
Hush Is in my opinion, the greatest comic book ever written.
oh that would fit really well jackle earl i mean in the game version withe robert englund it kinda worked but i think jE hayley fits the role really well hope he keeps the freddy kruger on while poioned the victim with his fear toxion that would be more terrifying compared to murphy. (just only hopping if it did happen or not)
These are probably some of my favorite casting decisions you’ve ever made.
I was getting HEAVY Professor Pyg vibe from that Jason Issacs clip you showed more than Mr Freeze, tbh I don’t think many people can get that character down, they were very close in Gotham but they killed his wife and in turn they ruined the whole point of the character. I’d honestly go with Wentworth Miller, yes he is probably the best Captian Cold we’ve had but they way he played Cold was very sympathetic yet still kinda a shitty person who only wants to protect his sister and I feel like he’d just capture it like no one else. Would be weird seeing him cast as two different Ice gun wielding characters but he’s just perfect for the role
Speaking about batman villans can you do a video on recasting superman villans please
Clayface, Deathstroke, and Hush are my picks
I love Jason Isaacs. But otherwise, Mads Mikkelsen as Mr Freeze.
You know at one point, I referenced Jackie's take on Rorschach for my depiction of Scarecrow. Who would've guessed. Great picks on the characters. I think I'd like to see Mad Hatter, Hugo Strange, Hush, but the rest is up to you.
Mad Hatter: Michael Sheen
I know this won't be a popular opinion, but it would be great to have an episode dedicated to underground, B-Tier villains, like Kite Man, or Calendar Man
I kinda wanna see Robert Englund as Scarecrow.
Edit: I just realized he also played Scarecrow in Injustice 2. All the more reason to make him a live action Scarecrow.
I'd like to see Deadshot and Deathstroke. For girls, I'd be interested in seeing the Birds of Prey (Oracle/Batgirl, Black Canary, Huntress, etc.), as well as some others like Talia al Ghul and Harley Quinn
Riddler is my favorite Batman villain as well and I have always wanted David tennant as the riddler I wanted him to be the riddler for years but it never happened.
You’re going to get shit for that Bane casting
@Bryan Seeker. Have you seen the Gotham Show? Very relevant for recasting these people and the Penguin in there, played by Robin Lord Taylor, is GREAT! Cant stress that enough.
I mean, Javier Barden has to be Bane, right? Size, voice, terror. Anton Chigurch in a wrestling mask. There's no contest.
Also, jeffrey combs should be Scarecrow. He was the voice of him in the New Animated Advebtures, and as Scarecrow is 90% mask anyway, and I've never heard of a creepier voice for him, he'd be perfect.
Great video man: you have made some very intersting choices. Here there are my choices :
Two Face: Jake Gyllenhaal
Scarecrow: Richard Armitage
Penguin: Jonah Hill
Bane: Javier Bardem
Riddler: Matt Smith
Mr. Freeze: James Spader
How about this:
Two-Face: James Franco
Scarecrow: Noah Taylor/DJ Qualls
Penguin: Jim Carter
Bane: Dave Bautista
Riddler: Adrian Brody
Mr. Freeze: Mads Mikkelsen/Alfred Molina
God I wanna learn how to photoshop onto actors like that. I wish there was a tutorial
I'm still sticking with my choice to play Scarecrow and that is Adrian Brody. 🙂😌
Here are my picks - I know people want him to play the Joker but Willem Dafoe as Two-Face would be spectacular. Aussie actor Ben Mendelsohn as scarecrow. He has the range to be a believable psychologist and madman. Peter Dinklage as Penguin and not just because he's short but the performance would blow people away. Bane is a difficult one because I think they should CGI a regular guy into a beast of a guy like they do Bruce Banner and The Hulk and I see Benedict Cumberbatch annihilating that role. The Riddler is a tough one because people have expectations (and Jim Carrey met all of those with his portrayal) and although it is a camp character that would suit a silly Paul Reubens type, I would cast Timothee Chalamet but just because I wanna see what dark direction he would take the character. Mr. Freeze for me is a no-brainer, there is a no question, Bryan Cranston would steal the entire franchise if he played Mr. Freeze.
i would like to see hugo starnge , mad hatter, clayface, azrael, solomon grundy, the ventriloquist, victor zsasz, professor pyg and definently HUSH
Love to see Black Mask.
Maybe because I haven’t seen Jason Issac in many things but the last one seems off. I’m still going with Ben Kingsley as Mr Freeze.
This was amazing! Is there any chance when you get through Batman and some of the others, you could do some video game fan casting? Like GTA 5 or Uncharted or RDR2 or whatever? That would be awesome
Love all your choices. Only thing I would change, is the Riddler. While I’m sure David Tennant would be great in the role, I would actually have Tennant as the Mad Hatter, and Neil Patrick Harris as the Riddler. Could you cast Professor Pyg, Firefly, Hush, and Deadshot.
WB NEEDS to hire you
Matt McConaughey ok, David Tennent ok, Dave Bautista ok! Christopher Waltz for Freeze, Marilyn Manson for Scarecrow!