Rambling about motherboard manufacturers
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 вер 2022
- My Patreon: / buildzoid
Teespring: teespring.com/stores/actually...
Bandcamp: machineforscreams.bandcamp.co...
Twitch: / buildzoid
Twitter: / buildzoid1
Facebook: / actuallyhardcoreovercl...
#overclocking #motherboard - Наука та технологія
BRO - YOU NEED TIMESTAMPS
MSI: Do not, under any circumstances, send Buildzoid any more motherboards. He likes us.
I feel like that should be replaced with Gigabyte.
Cant hate MSI when you dont have MSI boards
Absolute big brain moment
@@jritechnology PC repair tech of 10 years here. I have replaced far too many Gigabyte boards and don't trust them
@@mirknight 20+ years here - I do not think I have ever owned a Gigabyte board since 2006 and have not recommended one either.
@@mirknight 2021 Apex Z690 owner (2 of them) one came with one defective bios the other just died, both of them can't do 6600 ram, i blamed my kit and imc, now i know and i am glad to buy a Ζ790 Aorus Master as a replacement.
I know there are many many PC with cheep Gigabyte motherboards like DS3 line (40-50$ motherboards) and they don't last, but we are talking for some crazy expensive motherboards here, not the bottom line junk.
Btw my last cheap motherboard was an Asus B350 prime A, also burnt..
I hope we'll get to see now more motherboards from EVGA.
@@hotaru25189 "Primary profit machine"? Are you talking about their GPU business? The *profit* of GPUs is crap. Do not confuse it with revenue. EVGA made roughly as much profit on PSUs (I *think* that was listed as their second biggest revenue category), from a lot less revenue and certainly a fraction of the headaches of dealing with nVidia.
@@hotaru25189, keep in mind there is a difference between sales and margins. Their GPUs being 80% of their sales bled money like nobody's business.
I hope, too. Their GPU support has always been a pleasure, would love to have that on a decent mid-range board.
@@hotaru25189 The motherboards they do make are targeted towards hardcore OC, not something many people do. It would be cool if they made more MBs but they aren't exactly high margin products so its probably unlikely.
they are pretty expensive 🤔
"scrolling is just better than digging through menus"
With how complex UEFIs are getting I won't be surprised if they start using search tags.
Psst.. they already have search in msi bios nowadays, at least in z690
... and it doesn't find results for SOME of the items, which hurts.
They already exist.... And they should be MANDATORY these days, lol
Yeah i never know where spread spectrum is in my msi b550i always go to it using search.
"This video is way longer than it needs to be"... Buildzoid, please, PLEASE, never change. I absolutely LOVE putting your videos on in the background while Im playing games or doing housework and I absolutely LOVE your longer, rambling videos about things like this. I end up learning a BUNCH of things that are the kinds of stuff that is VERY difficult to find or figure out from reading tech forums and/or watching other PC hardware UA-camrs as they are often very specific, less known and/or are things that just dont come up often in standard situations but can end up being SUPER handy to know.
Looking forward to your AM5 board "rambles". I love those videos of breakdowns on motherboards. I always watch your stuff before I head out to buy a motherboard.
Listening to Buildzoid ramble is ALWAYS a good idea before a purchase!
for those who did not watch the whole video...
1.MSI - ok to great, BIOS is good.
2.Gigabyte=Asus - BIOS are janky and the boards are inconsistent with VRM, Memory topology, etc.
3. Asrock - Most feature complete but BIOS is jankier.
But the real judge is PRICE!
Appreciate that you're *always* sharing your vast knowledge! Thank you . . .
gave 10 dollars to an asshat who couldnt be bothered to say thanks LOL
"Who's your favourite motherboard brand?" NONE lol.
The BIOS is the reason I buy MSI.
I could tolerate ASRock and Gigabyte BIOS but I'll never buy another ASUS board again because of their BIOS. There are so many settings in the ASUS BIOS that are named differently from other brands? everything is so overly complicated for no fuckin reason. Primary, secondary, and tertiary memory timings are all mixed up, everything is just a mess. Also, I couldn't set my fans lower than 50% in the ASUS BIOS? On my MSI board, I not only can control the fan voltage exactly however I want, but MSI BIOS shows you the fan RPM changes in realtime.
asus changing the names is extremely annoying.
Thanks for acknowledging potential biases beforehand. Really interesting to see the diverse picks despite gigabyte sending every motherboard under the sun to you, just makes it more interesting.
Ive used gigabyte boards for years, just built 3 new ones with Aero am4, fantastic boards. NEVER had an issue.
Want to thank you for all you do for Motherboard info, your vids really help me fine tune my choices.
I think one stereotype with Asus is you won't get a backplate and dual BIOS at the same prices as other brands. Like only boards above the Hero will have backplates and none of Asus' boards have dual bios , whereas with other brands, their counterparts with the Hero, like MSI's Ace, Gigabyte's Master and ASRock's Taichi all have backplates and dual BIOSes. The Hero often costs more than those too.
Not that it's super important, but it makes handling boards less of a pain in the ass and gives a little mental comfort too.
it's not important at all. I'd take better memory traces over a backplate every day of the week.
Ugh, my Tuf Gaming came with a backplate, as well as every other Asus board I have ever owned, going back to 2008
@@Mach141 They stopped doing backplates on their TUF boards. Also note I mentioned Hero tier and below boards.
@@ahmetrefikeryilmaz4432 Asus doesn't always have the best memory traces either. _And_ asus doesn't have dual bios at the same price points too. Bigger deal imo.
@@WilliamChoochootrain dual bios is bigger deal? You are using XMP aren't you?
Thank You Buildzoid!!! I am going nuts with impatience over all these impending releases and this video is just what I need right now. I almost never buy anything, but I am considering upgrading my whole system this time around.
I usually look forward to new releases just so I can watch tech-tube videos like yours. I can listen to you ramble and opinionate. I can watch your PCB breakdowns. ETC.
Also, I needed this after all the EVGA doom and gloom and bitter feelings and blaming and getting old and such.
I agree!
|(these are the only videos longer than 20 minutes tha I not only watch to the end but look forward to.
It's so much better than anyone else at breaking everything down so you actually feel like you come away KNOWING things. Good things.)
@@ClockWorkJake If the 4080-90 is not on PCIE 5, I will be kind of upset.
31:31 Buildzoid's BIOS Ranking: 1 MSI 2-Tie Gigabyte Asus 3 Asrock
Complaints:
Asrock Asus Gigabyte - BIOS layout sucks, boatload of sub-menus *You'll get used to it if you stick to one brand, switching between is a nightmare
Asus - Unconventional naming conventions
Asrock - Too much automation
MSI - No VTT DDR control, BIOS profile-saving functionality unreliable on AM4 boards
Pros:
MSI - BIOS layout and function make sense, simple no unnecessary sub-menus 45:15 What a decent layout looks like
Asrock Gigabyte - VTT DDR control ok, they don't bother to delete these settings. Same chip, copies the BIOS code across all of the boards.
Gigabyte - BIOS profile saving feature
1:02:17 Overall impression / opinion:
Gigabyte - If we could just put all the best parts of our boards onto one board instead of like five different boards we would have an incredible motherboard
Asus - Their top-end boards come in one of two variants: very good or very bad, no in between lmao
1:12:50 Who's your preferred motherboard brand?
Probably MSI. If I'm feeling brave and adventurous, I buy an Asus or a Gigabyte board because with either of them you never know what you're gonna get.
It gets too technical for a casual like me so this is all I could list. Hope it's still helpful! Enjoyed listening in.
thank you for your honesty and detailed comments about everything, pretty sure you’re the best source of information about motherboards on youtube
Quite the epic ramble. Thank you Buildzoid.
Here is my asrock experience:
I had asrock z77 extreme 4 (2012) back then, asrock continues to support that board and it had bios updates until late 2018. (not just security ones but adding new features too)
Turns out it supports Vt-d and saved me well when i needed it. (As far as i know has the only vt-d functionality over z77 which normally does not support it),
Non-k intel auto overclocking feature without compromising power saving feataures (which obsolotes 3770k, so you can grab 3770 which support vt-d)
Received bios update and got boot functionality of nvme ssd's over pcie slot which worked flawless.
Got spectre security updates... It was marvelous board and support from asrock.
So i grab asrocks when i switch ryzen. One day during installation of b550m steel legend, i break couple of smd's on the board. emailed them position of parts for self repair, they immediately sent part no's of related parts and their and picture of pcb layout marked related positions of parts.
I hardly buy any other brands unless i cant find asrocks around.
''In order to overvolt graphics cards in the past, one needed to have a steady hand to solder, but amidst the numerous tiny resistors in LN2 smoke, that can be a bit difficult. Using the VGA hotwire feature, simply solder two wires on to a graphics card and connect them to a dedicated header connection on the motherboard and you’ll be overvolting your graphics card in no time.''
thanks BZ. your takes are helpful in figuring out what i want out of these things
1 hour and 26 minutes of rambling.
I'm in. 🙋
EZ-Tune actually WORKING would make Gigabyte boards SO much better! And now that some of them build in an auto-bios kickback, it would be REALLY NICE if they would create a log file for startup issues; I feel like the biggest strength for MSI is that every setting is named exactly what you expect it to be!
The deal with gigabyte is "their stuff would be great if it wasn't terrible"
My favorite board was my DFI Lanparty NF4 Ultra-D AMD socket 939 which I modded to enable SLI (more expensive board version feature). I brought it open box used, and saved so much money, especially with that mod. That board was chock full of the latest Chipset features (NForce 4..yes..NVidia had the best chipsets for AMD back then, lol!) at the time and I loved how all the components were arranged. RIP DFI consumer enthusiast boards.
A company I worked for was talking to DFI about carrying their motherboards. Everything was on track and we just had to get the final OK to start promoting them. I had made the web pages for every current motherboard they had, mirrored their drivers, manuals and BIOS. Everything was uploaded and ready so all I had to do was push the changes for the main page and the navigation and we would be up and running. But the mails from DFI got fewer and fewer. Time passed and our contact stopped answering. Then the news dropped that DFI was leaving the consumer market to concentrate on industrial solutions. So much time was spent on getting it ready ready and then I was told to delete everything...
@@blahorgaslisk7763 ok I wondered if the industrial board maker was the same dfi. But never knew. The boards look sooo different but somehow I could see the same mind behind them.
I had DFI Infinify P965 Dark before . That is the only motherboard that I had to RMA twice in my whole life. They just die all of a sudden . I switched to Gigabyte and never looked back since.
I remember Nvidia pulling out of chipsets and their support went with it. Probably why I have a negative opinion of them!
Thank you for your honest reviews on these. Saves us a lot of time and effort doing the research ourselves + helps us understand what goes into making a good mobo. Very insightful!
Great video BZ! We all know that we don't live in a perfect world. Can't expect perfection in all of the designs of motherboards! You did manager to show quite an array of motherboards so that was quite awesome!
Gigabyte knows what they're doing sending you all those mobos lol. Having used both i can confirm Asus naming things their own way is irritating, that said their Bios was more stable for me than Gigabyte's so i agree with them being on a tie. Both of them tend to hide things on weird places and sometimes i have to really go around looking for the setting i wanna change. Asrock i disappointed a friend by recommending him a H670 motherboard and he had to RMA it after less than a month so i have a negative opinion on their motherboards.
Gigabyte is also stable although it may take them a revision/update longer than Asus.
I have a AX370 K7 and it's running a R7 5800x3d with 4x8 3600mhzcl16 CJR die with no problems whatsoever. CO -30 all core offset runs cool.
What happened to the good ole times when you could actually find replacement bioses for many boards that could open up a board with a standard Ami Bios to tinker with much more stuff than they came with mostly because the companies was to lazy to spend time on giving people the ability to change some settings that the engineers didn't took into account for, or just god forbid that a user got the power of actually making some more stability or overclock it too much.
@@mrdali67 lol, I actually remember those good ole days...I replaced a few BIOS chips myself back in the day... unfortunately those days are long gone.
@@GSP-76 I can't really remember if it was a hack or not. But was always exciting when you popped in the Eprom and booted the first time. Technically it should still be doable today but propably a lot harder to get the original bios back when it's not a physical chip you can just replace ... It's kinda what makes retro computers fun to tinker with if you have the equip for programming your own Eproms
My first ever custom PC was built on same Sabertooth V2.0 and FX8350 with 32 gigs HyperX Fury. It was an amazing machine at the time.
i mostly agree with the ranking list however i would move asus down below gigabyte instead of having it tied because (at least on my Maximus 9/10 Apex) i have to babysit it way more than i ever had to on any MSI or Gigabyte board. wanna post 3800+ on a budget MSI or Gigabyte board? sure it just works. wanna do that on an Apex? lol get 55'd unless you remember to set PLL Termination voltage. i never had to do that on any other board but this thing keeps having issues unless you manually set certain settings that the MSI and Gigabyte would just figure out on their own
I repair Motherboards and Almost all oft the unrepairable ones are Asus. Memory OC is also trash because the system never resets to a save state and just bootloops until eternity, when bad settings are used. But I like their itx designs.
Yeah that's the thing about ASUS boards, you pretty much *have* to set everything manually.
Otherwise it'll push voltages dangerously high or simply way too low, or ridiculously long timings that kill any performance, or ridiculously short timings that'll never boot...
@@killersberg1 Did you by chance encounter the BD_PROCHOT issue on older Intel SKUs? (throttles down all CPU to lowest speed and stays locked there, I suppose it's due to a failed temperature sensor). Their ITX are really cool, but sadly much like their STRIX "-E" SKUs I feel it's mostly deceitful cashgrabs.
@@victor38542 No I have only used their am4 boards.
This was great; also a great reminder about what Buildzoid wants in a motherboard versus me looking for a daily driver platform
10:54 One of my favorite boards is the X99 Taichi. Awesome board in both looks and function. Was great at OCing and as a daily driver. And because it was released later in the x99 cicle, it has more m.2 slots and other improvements.
I still have it and i’m keeping it for as long as i can
The MSI AM4 profile saving bug was an issue on one of the recent betas where the profiles would get wiped when clearing cmos. Msi support pissed me off to no end when i tried to report it but instead of acknowledgimg the issue they would try to make me jump through the hoops validating different settings that would make the board work ok instead of requiring clear cmos. Then they'd go "see? There is no problem, anyway we can't reproduce it." Jesus christ just save the profile and clear the cmos, the settings don't actually matter! "Nope we can't do that, can't reproduce it, btw we ran these settings and it booted fine..." 🙈
Man you and you alone are the reason i bought MSI mother boards for my AM4 CPU'S thank you for your advise and good luck in whatever you are doing now.
There's no one else who's motherboard experiences I value more highly, thank you! I also found it interesting that you preferred MSI bios, I often heard people say that Asus had the best bios.
In my experience (msi & amd) they are also usually the quickest to release the bios updates when there is a new agesa version etc. As a downside i do see them quite often release newer low-end stuf before higher end but older (like a cheap b550 board will get the update before the top of the line x470)
Amazing video BZ!! I was one of those asking for your opinion about motherboards brands. Since my first build, a pentium 4 506 system, until now I have only used Asus motherboards. 6 in total, 4 intel and 2 ryzen, and they have always been problem free. My next one will be a B660 and I'll probably go with Asus or maybe I'll give a try to MSI depending on reviews of specific models around usd 220.
Hearing you echo the exact same sentiments I have about the R5E(which is still my daily driver) is so validating.
I enjoy this,subscribed because i want to learn some basics about overclocking
I've had two experiences with EasyTune from Gigabyte.
The first one: Installed EasyTune. App would not open, it would crash with some error every time I tried to open it. Tried to uninstall EasyTune, would crash with the same error. Tried to delete the files, said it was still running. I don't remember if I ever got it uninstalled on that system lmao.
The second one (just from last week): Installed EasyTune. App actually opened. Had a default and an OC mode. OC mode said 25GHz. I clicked it for lolz and it stuck my CPU at base clock. Default had it boost to 5.2GHz, but OC mode stuck it at 3.7GHz. I tried to click advanced mode and it crashed. I tried to click Default mode, but it still left my CPU at base clock. I uninstalled the app (which failed the first time but succeeded the second time) and restarted my system and thankfully it released its death grip on my CPU haha.
So I'm just impressed you got EasyTune to function at all XD
My first PC build I got an ASUS P5N-T Deluxe and I was all excited ASUS looked good and I decided to try them out. The motherboard would corrupt data as it was written, I always thought it was something I was doing wrong and I lived with that thinking it was normal, until I got an ASUS P5Q-E which had no issues.
You just about touched on it at the very end, regarding the Z690 Apex, that early boards we "apparently mostly ok", but nowhere else did you seem to mention other's experiences verifying your own, to rule out getting a board from a duff batch or whatever isolated issues arise now and then.
Aside from that, very informative and helpful as usual. Thanks (and best wishes with not getting black-listed by all of the manufacturers). ;-)
MSI x570 Creation has been a joy to daily since its launch it really hit the nail on the head on what I wanted out of a board. I really want to see more boards like that.
I had so many issues with that board personally, but everyone else seems to have had a flawless experience 😅
Another great video that I really enjoyed and learned a lot
Rampage iv extreme was also my first ever motherboard with 3960x! Great bit of kit. Had z370 / 390's past few years, ones to note are obviously the evga dark, quality board It just seemed a bit slow posting, etc. Currently on the Asus gene xi and really enjoying it so far but I've got to be honest out of all of them my Gigabyte Aorus gaming 7 z370 wins. Absolutely love that board, sold the Dark z390 and kept that, had my 8086k at 5.6ghz with it and 9900k at 5.3ghz for very lengthy periods of time. Vrm's got crazy hot though, especially with the 9900k. Retiered her now for the gene xi. Thanks for the great content as usual BZ.
This somewhat ends up very informative, having some experience since the LGA775 era i find this awesome
Couldn't agree more with the MSI bios. Simple, easy to navigate and straight to the point.
You know why gigabyte frustrates me?
They don't put beep codes in manuals.
On the faq page, they have core2 duo time beep fault codes(not the same as modern boards).
I asked them to update that webpage, and now, that webpage is down for 30 days now.
I'm honestly concerned with the insane cost of MB's now and how little features they do have in the $300 range. The new $500+ range actually includes things like reset/flashback buttons, post codes, etc. for the z670 upcoming boards, and that's unfortunate.
dont pay attention to sticker price, a little patience and minor deal hunting can get you a good deal, relatively speaking - end of oct'22/nov'22 I grabbed a GIGABYTE Z690 AUROS ULTRA for $199.99 brand new (and then I flashed it for my nicely undervolted 13700K).
LOL, thanks for releasing the video. Great info on the quirks of various mobo models and brands.
What do you think about Maxsun motherboards? I just got a Maxsun Z690 WiFi and I found its BIOS kinda too basic for its purpose (sometimes struggles with Auto settings as well). But it is robust, seems to have a great power delivery.
Seems like a blind draw every time I buy a motherboard. I decide what I want in a Mobo. How much i am willing to pay. Then I go out and look at all the Manufacturers and decide what Mobos I want to look closer at. Then I start watching/reading reviewers of those boards. Its been this way for 25 years for me. It seems to me you take each mobo you have contact with from a fairly unbiased point of view. Thanks. Carry on.
Love this kind of content, and just found your channel through JTC recently about those z690 hero boards catching on fire.
I've been rocking an ASUS X99 Deluxe with a i7-5820K for over 8 years now, still runs like a champ, though I'll likely be moving to a b650e + 7800X3D soon.
Ah man, the good old times when 6c12t was the productivity benchmark.
My favorite motherboard manufacturer used to be DFI, too bad they went out of business
to be accurate, they didn't go out of business, they just stopped making consumer products, whereas another bummer loss was Abit, which went completely away.
Both those used to be my go to brands. Epox too sometimes.
X370 Taichi owner.
I would describe the bios as a game without autosave, one false move without a save and you need to start a new game building up the bios again from nothing.
Have also tried a couple of times where I had to do the memory settings first and then reboot, before setting the rest of the settings. It was not able to do all the changes in one go.
It still runs well with a 5800x now in my daily.
Abit BH6 the original overclocking board! DFI LanParty (they hired ex-Abit engineers and gave them “no budget”). My favorite two boards.
That was way way back, Oscar Wu was the man.
I had an Abit BH6 that was great, but BP6 with Dual Celeron's running BeOS was the absolute best.
@@MostlyHuman I hear ya! I bought a used Abit P2B-DS and ran dual p3e 700's at 933mhz for a few years. Even before multithreaded games it was faster playing warcraft 3 tower defense maps than my 2.4ghz Athlon MP LoL! That was how much overhead the OS, networking and playing mp3's had back in single threaded days.
Still running a FX8350 on a gigabyte 970a ds3p on a spare computer. The motherboard run HOT, always had the side off and a tablefan blowing on the VRM and chipset. When I stopped usig it daily and moved it I zip tied a 120mm fan inside the case blowing directly on the VRW and the chip on the middle on the board.
I enjoy your videos especially the ones you call rambling.... Keep on a rambling brother...
I used a Rampage IV Extreme from 2012 to 2019 with a 3930K.
Far from my first board, of course. The first motherboard I bought separately was Socket 3. Don't even remember the make and model at this point, though I should still have it around here somewhere.
Buildzoid has excellent rambling performance
love these kinds of videos
Buildzoid should start a show called "Hells motherboard manufacturer" Where he goes in like chef Ramsay but throws motherboards instead of beef wellingtons.
23:54 I ended up buying the MSI X470 Gaming Pro Carbon years ago because of your videos about it haha. Thanks man!
I am between the MSI MPG X670E CARBON WIFI and the Asus ROG STRIX X670E-E GAMING WIFI, for the new 7000 amd cpu, right now I have the Asus ROG Strix Z690E gaming wifi with the 12900k, it was my first PC build that I did this year, I am new to PC gaming and this would be my second build so I am not familiar with MSI or any other motherboards, what do you think?? after watching your video I am heavily leaning towards the MSI MPG X670E CARBON WIFI.
Big warning about the Rampage IV Extreme, very common issue of randomly dying. I've had one.
The R4BE's also have the black screen issue which is nice.
Listening to your Asus motherboard issues rambling reminded me of back in the AMD socket 939 days, I had an Asus AN8-SLI with a 3800+. I forgot what I overclocked it to but after a couple months, my screen just went black and stayed black. Tested everything else in the system and the motherboard was dead. So bought another new one and the same exact thing happened a couple months of use. Luckily, I was shipped out for Army training for a couple months, came back and Intel's Q6600 became my first build from coming back and I used a Gigabyte P35-DS3L. Still have that system and it's still overclocked to 3GHz after all these years. And since then, I've been using Gigabyte motherboards for all my builds. Did a 3570K build with a Z77-UD3H, a 7700K build with Z170X Gaming 5, and now, my current 5900x with an X570 Aorus Elite Wifi.
And after Gigabyte's latest fiasco with PSUs exploding and giving customers shit, I think I'll give my MSI a try with my next build. Or even try out Asus again as towards the end of the video, it seems Asus motherboards are a lot better then 15 years ago.
I don't really feel like "hating" a brand this way is warranted. These companies are huge and each product category has its on department with its own people. What I mean by that is I wouldn't judge Gigabyte motherboards by their PSUs and vice-versa. Just like I wouldn't judge Asus routers by their motherboards and vice-versa. In so many ways they are like separate entities, they just share a brand name. The products should be compared within their respective market.
i have ASUS crosshair hero x570 and you are 100% correct about the menus in the bios... OMG i get lost so quick. they are by far my most favorite manufacture though ATM... just their build quality / components alone seem to be a step up from basically anyone else. gigabyte is probably my 2nd favorite they have come a LONG way since i started building like 30 (ish) years ago
Buildzoid: "Eeeeehhh"
UA-cam: [Music]
I love a BZ ramble. looking forward to the x670e content
If you like the b550 steel legend, how do you feel about the b550 extreme4?
It seems they're just about the same board, with only a few minor differences.
I know it isn't like you get a chance to do hands on testing every single motherboard that comes out, but I'm just wondering if maybe you've heard something negative about it that I havent. I got one about a year ago cause it was a little cheaper than the steel legend at the time
AFAIK they are basically the same board so it should also be very good.
Your experience with Asus motherboards pre rampage v extreme, exactly mirrors mine. I was ride or die for Asus up until then lol.
My first motherboard was an Asus Pentium 2 400 (I have no idea what model it was, I was eight years old, and I've never seen what that motherboard looks like. If I think about it, I had the impression that there were some magicians in that box under the monitor) :)) the second motherboard was a gigabyte GA-EP43-UD3L (terribly short of saying the least), the third was the Asus MAXIMUS FORMULA -SPECIAL EDITION, a hidden gem I still have with the q6600, the fourth was an Asus Tuf Z390 Pro Gaming is an ok motherboard, but it's the only one I've seen like this, all the SATA ports were burnt (I still use it on my daughter's PC). And the 5th is the MSI Z690 Edge. I have nothing to complain about, it's exceptional. I bought it on your recommendation last year, thank you very much if I haven't thanked you yet.
Buildzoid.
Always rambling.
Never trembling.
Super surprised ab Rampage V Extreme X99, that was a lovely powerfull board, true that memory preferred x133 strap and run only around 3000MHz but other than that it was a blast with 5960X. Shame mine died 2y ago with code 00. In that time it was one and only 8/16 core/threads wonderfully running with Titan X Maxwell in SLI.
I was wondering if the AORUS x570 extreme revision 1.1 has cleared up the major complaint you had about the memory overclocking? And if so are there any other complaints you have about that motherboard?
MSI is so good with memory overclocking and support
I had a Z370 Carbon and it's still to this day the only mainboard that trained my 4X8GB 3600 cl14 Gskill Trident Z kit on command rate 1
when the screen opened up with the RIVE I was like "oh here we go.." XD I had one too, thing had to be warmed up to operating temps with a hair dryer to get it to boot other then that great board, had it running 3way sli GTX580 at one stage XD
If I send you a 1680v2 would you consider doing a blast from the past session with that Rampage IV?
Hey Buildzoid!
How about EVGA, or the crappy Biostar motherboards?
I wonder if you could manage getting one of those cable tester and use it to test memory traces.
x79 asus sabertooth was one of my first really good boards i bought i loved that thing. it was a step or two down from rampage i believe
Since EVGA are stopping their GPU production I hope they reallocate resources to their motherboard division. They used to make some great motherboards for most price points but then started to really only focus on the high end and really narrow their options. My first was a P55 LE, a $120 board, then a P55 Classified 200, a $300 board. But since they didn't make a board for Ryzen when it came out (still rocking 1700X as an early adopter) I jumped ship to Asus for a X370 Crosshairs Hero VI. There is still a nice large market for both AMD and Intel boards and with EVGA's history of making great boards they should really flesh out their product stack to get some good $$$.
EVGA's biggest problem with motherboards is the availability.
You basically can't get them in a lot of the parts of the world (other than importing yourself at huge price increases due to shipping costs, local taxes, import duties etc.)
If they would get some solid distribution channels going, they would be able to get a lot more marketshare in the top segment, as their quality is really good.
I don't remember my ddr3 boards, one was a dfi infinity something that the fan on it died, and I had to figure out a replacement. Both my ddr4 boards have been msi, a b450m and the x570s edge wifi max and love em
Can confirm about that Rampage V Extreme, I had that board and a 5960X, I ended up shelving that and replacing it with a 1st gen Ryzen (1700) when it came out and later Threadripper.
I had constant issues with that system and at the end something was so fucked up it would just get stuck in some boot loop where it wouldn't load into windows, to this day I don't know what was wrong with it in the end, I reused every part of that system in AM4/TR4 GPU RAM PSU SSD, everything worked except the board/CPU? As for 1st gen Ryzen, never noticed any issue other than the RAM not running XMP out of the box BIOS.
I just gave up on it, still have those 2 sitting around in my closet, maybe I'll pull them out and try to get it working again.
The ASUS B550 Pro Art board and any of the Pro Art boards might surprise some. The B550 Pro Art has dual x8 while intel B660 doesn't. You gotta fork over $400+ for that. Lately i picked up a z590 OC FORMULA for $200 with the 6900XT OCF to match, for $600. I also picked up the Z590 DARK and 10850K for $400. These are new items by the way. My favorite deals were the 5700XT Nitro SE's for $200 and 6900XT TOXIC EE "AIR"'s that have 2.543GHz boost clocks right out the box. $800. I binned 2 TOXICS that actually run 3GHz flat with 19Gbps on the ram. Takes some S and H mods but they do it.
who cares how much you have paid for the shit you have?
I love Asus AM4 series with ECC support. It doesn’t only support ECC but it also has the circuitry to inject errors so that you can test functionality. I can’t say that for the gigabyte ECC supporting AM4 motherboards or AsRocks IIRC. I’m almost 100% sure. MSI doesn’t even bother supporting ECC on AM4. At least for most models if there is any.
afaik the ability to inject ECC RAM errors is software-based and provided by the memory controller itself. As such is not particularly trustworthy. Although I've seen that feature mentioned in BIOS option of Asrock boards I have so I think it's at least supposed to work.
I'm personally just sticking to the old and battle-tested method of covering some DIMM data pins with tape and using a linux live-CD to run memory testing and collect the ECC error logs
@@marcogenovesi8570 I read somewhere that you needed extra circuitry to support that. The problem is the ECC reporting which seems to change from BIOS to BIOS starting from B350 because AMD didn’t want to eat into their Threadripper segment I assume. Otherwise why would they take functionality away with a BIOS update. So I’m split but I feel like it’s better than nothing.
@@KaziQTR ECC function (and error injection and VT-X/d/AMD-VI for that matter) requires firmware in the BIOS to support the feature. To make more space for newer CPU support (which again need space for their firmware in the BIOS) some vendor decide to remove "less important" features to make space.
There was a debacle some months ago about AMD motherboards having too little flash space to allow upgrading to newer CPUs. This is one of the effects.
Afaik that's what Asrock is doing where some options, some older CPUs and ECC support disappear in the later BIOS versions of older chipset boards.
So in my experience if you want to be sure that you buy a board that supports ECC on your CPU it has to be at the same release year or one year older and you have to test BIOS versions to find the latest one that still has ECC options available. For example on both Asrock B350 and 450 chipset boards I can still use a 3400G Pro (an APU with ECC support) with ECC functions enabled and tested.
On 3xx and 4xx Asrock boards (I have a few but the bios is more or less the same across the same gen so I can generalize) you can always rollback and "update" bios to whatever version you want, even to an older version.
The Gigabyte B550 vision D has proper ECC support with error injection. Just fyi
@@daethar I did build with that motherboard and it didn’t have injection when I did. TY FYI
in MSI you can look up BIOS settings with CTRL + F if you don’t remember where they are
I'm glad you liked the Gene XI. I've got it in my main rig, and besides minor quirks it works very well daily.
i used to be all in on ABiT before they folded (shows my age i guess) then i had two gigabyte boards that left a good impression before gb went all in on the rgb craze with their aorus branding, then i had two decent asus boards, so right now i guess im in a healthy spot where i could just get a board from any of the main manufacturers without much bias, well maybe not asrock
ABIT was so great. I ran a Celeron Tualatin 1200 on the BX133. You needed to pull some pins from the CPU and connect others. CPU ran at 1600Mhz. My capacitors died a few times because I think the biggest CPU for this board used to be the 850Mhz Pentium III?
Anyway I grew tired or replacing them and went to AMD Thunderbird.
I wish someone could make a video about MB brands and how many years of Warranty, how many years of BIOS support they provide
Heartily agree on the MSI BIOS. They typically have very solid upper mid-range and high-range boards as well. Dissapointed this time around in terms of pricing though........my AM4 socket B550 Carbon I picked up for $200.00 brand new 2 years ago however the recently released AM5 socket B650 Cabron is selling for $330.00.
Just finished listening wasn’t sure what to do, thought it would be a great ending to throw on Zeps “Ramble on”.
I saw your first motherboard and realized how young you are. Damn, I feel old.
My first motherboard was in a prebuilt in the mid 90s with a Micro Star International with almost no branding on the board. It had a blazing fast Pentium clocked at a mind blowing 100mhz. After overclocking it by moving jumpers I upgraded it with a Barracuda HDD for the low price of $300 for 300MB of cutting edge speed. Dollar per MB was insane!
Many years later of building many systems for many people, and _especially_ having to troubleshoot those motherboards for random people. Building liquid cooling systems from Eheim aquarium pumps, medical tubing, and automotive transmission radiators.
I actively avoid Gigabyte because I've had too many problems I couldn't even explain, let alone repair, and dealing with their horrible support. I only buy Asus for Asus fanboys that believe their "ROG STRIX BRO!" bullshit gamer marketing while charging the most for the same features and VRMs as anyone else. Asrock for the cheap consumer that wants a miracle for 49 cents. MSI for anyone that asks "What would YOU buy?"
Not an MSI fanboy by any means and I can't forgive them for being the first AIB to get caught scalping their own GPUs at the beginning of the GPU armageddon, but they simply give you the best quality motherboard when you go through your needed features and VRMs at the best price.
But holy f*ck is their dragon software suite the worst pile of dogshit buggy bloatware I've ever seen. MSI, for the love of God, kill Dragon. It's embarrassingly bad.
PS: Now that I finished the video I'm glad you released it. You weren't bashing by any means and any company that shuns you for being honest should be put on blast. People don't watch you for getting free motherboards, they watch you for being honest with them. If any company can't take constructive criticism they shouldn't get our business.
100Mhz Pentium? Young whippa snapper!
486SX 25!
inb4: Next person's 386 10 or something :)
@@ChrispyNut Well, that's the first one I actually owned cause they were expensive back then and I was poor. I wanted one for years. First ones I messed around with though were around 1982 but not mine, always the school's.
So, yeah lol. Literally even before the 386. Floppy drives were actually floppy. But I'm not _that_ old. Only late 40s.
@@ChrispyNut Typing this on an abacus. Get off my lawn!
@@infinity2z3r07 Oh hey, lemme get off of that thing. ;-)
@@madalin4802 The faster stuff makes it to the trash, the higher GDP is, the better the economy.
Modern "economics", driving us to self-extinction faster by the day!
MSI Z87 Mpower here, this board deserves a mention, I have used and abused it and it continues to behave well, the only issue is that my mouse does not work in the BIOS
I've been working in IT for 25 years and really few brands gave me the headache that MSI gave me in the past, it's true that I haven't tried anything from them for about 4 years, but many problems with motherboards and video cards of this brand, On the other hand, with other brands I had much less problems, especially with gigabyte. The good thing is that we have a variety of brands for everyone.
Yep as someone who's run a PC store for 20 years I avoid MSI like the plague.
Great honest motherboards review. The best motherboard I ever bought and use is an ASUS Motherboard and the worse is an Asrock. The Gigabyte motherboards I have used never let me down. It's just that the bios was confusing to use. I now use X570 Unifi MSI motherboard AMD 5800x for applications such cad, 3dmodeling and simulations with NVIDIA 3090 with absolutely no issues. The MSI bios is very user friendly and make over clocking very easy. I play game from Microsoft xbox subscription with good frame rates. My favorite is Microsoft flight and forza horizons series of games. I have an Asus motherboard I use for some cad and real world 3d simulations with Intel xeon 18 core processor. I find the bios really great and easy to use. It has great over clocking potential but I am only interested in using it for multicore applications for rendering and engineering system simulations. It runs for hours with no overheating with an Amd 5700xt. Great system build for the case use. I will peak Asus bios any day over the msi for the flexibility it provides and it's feature rich. The Asus motherboard has served me well for years, but has been killed by Microsoft Windows 11. I will keep running Windows 10 and hope Microsofts will have a change of heart and release an update that will enable continued use of this great system. I have learned from your review that buying a motherboard can be a lottery. I will keep checking the reviews to see which Asus motherboard will best serve my needs. Many thanks for sharing your findings. Great research.
@Acutally Hardcore Overclocking What do you think about EVGA motherboard?
I wanted an asus board for my first build. Compared to msi the price was much higher. The msi board offered similar vrm and memory overclocking so I went with that. It has held up very well and not had any problems. The easy bios layout is another plus. If I had to choose another board I would go by vrm and memory peformance and what features I wanted at the best price. I would wait for reviews from other users as well to make sure there aren't any quirks you don't want to find out after you bought it. Especially with the higher prices of mbs these days.
Ni I iiiiiiiiii😅i😅😅😅i😅i😅i😅i 😅😅i😅i😅i😅i😅i😅i😅i😅i😅
My 1st motherboard was a Gigabyte with a hot chipset that had me worried but ran fine.
My last motherboard B550 is also a Gigabyte motherboard. Price to performance is fantastic.
But my most impressive board was an ASRock ITX board that blew away my expectations.
I've owned MSI before too, no complaints there. Was an i5 6500 that stuttered a lot but I bought it used so idk if the board or CPU was to blame.
the pc that got me into pcs was on an Asus Sabertooth 990FX r2. I loved that motherboard. or the BIOS at least. the copper and poorly matched tan with black would've had it rough in the tempered glass side panel era.
I had Ram issues with My x570 Taichi and power issues too. I paired it with a 5950x and a 5900x and it did not work properly. Crashes on high extensive applications and games.
I switched to the MSI 570s Carbon max wifi and issues gone. Also I can run my ram at 3600 mhz and no problem at all. All resolved now.
I tried many things and send it to different technicians and nobody could tell what caused my blue screens while working or games crashing. They did not find any issue.
My Taichi worked great paired with a 3800x and the RX5700XT. I changed PSU and got the 5900x paired with the 6800XT. Tried different UEFIS, different setups with 16Gb of ram 3600 trident z (2×8Gb). With (4x8Gb) of the same ram it was fine when I lowered the ram at 3200. Then I decided I'll need more ram for my projects and future proof. Bought 2x32Gb at 3600 and the Taichi could not handle it. Even at 3000 mhz I had stability issues.
The mobo change fixed all my issues.
Regarding Bios layout. You can go overboard with the sub-menus, but for most people a good subdivided UI layout is WAY better than a big long list of settings. A huge list is overwhelming for the average user and makes it harder to find things for most people. This is the same reason ASUS's bios boots into a literal "EZ-Mode" by default, because if you throw the full BIOS at the average user they're going to get overwhelmed and there are decent odds of anything from "welp, no clue" and exiting to fiddling with settings and getting the system into a state they can't recover it from.
Also, if you organize everything, it's faster to navigate just because you don't have to scroll too much.
Also the newer ASUS boards have duplicate settings. There's an overclocking menu and a regular menu, and they duplicate some settings between the two. It's not the greatest decision, but everything isn't quite so scattered.
I would love for you to go through the upcoming Z790 boards, as many leaks have already apeared, and I am to upgrade from an ASrock Z370 Pro4 to something better :D