oh great. yet another scene that makes the fated end of the phantom's heartbreak even more tragic. "she saw my loneliness. shared in my emptiness" she was an orphan. he was an outcast. she alone would listen to his music, so he held on for as long as he could. say what you want. the phantom might have been a villain, but he was not the devil.
If you listen carefully at the end of the movie, when Raoul (Or how ever you spell it) Is at Christines grave, it plays the instrumentals of this song. This song is just wonderful at making me cry
I learned to listen In my dark, my heart heard music. I longed to teach the world Rise up and reach the world No one would listen I alone could hear the music Then at last, a voice in the gloom Seemed to cry "I hear you; I hear your fears, Your torment and your tears." She saw my loneliness Shared in my emptiness No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears...
I agree with you on this. Erik was the only one who who managed to provoke several emotions from the audience in the span of a few hours. When it comes to the Phantom of the Opera, both in play and movie form, it is always Erik that everyone remembers. Yes, people remember Christine and Raoul, but not as much as they remember the Phantom (even if they don't know his actual name).
I'd never heard this song before, I purposefully do not watch anything to do with this movie because when I do I don't stop, so far it's been a week since I first decided to re watch it for the millionth time and I've watched it 3/4 times a day every day and had Music Of The Night stuck in my head for days. But this, this is wonderful, I absolutely love it!! It really helps you to identify with the Phantom and understand his love for Christine, if only she could have heard it.
I always cry with this, it was a mistake to delete this song from the movie, it shows tha even he was a "monster" he had a heart and the right to be loved too...
Look, I really sympathize for Erik. I really do. But people are missing the point. Pity is not love. While I can really feel for all that he has been through, being called a monster as a child, he channeled those emotions into malice and hatred against the world. It led him to murder (and almost another). It's a tragedy in the end. He let his sorrow consume him and made him become just what people originally wrongly judged him of, a monster. However, he learned what love was in the end.
This should've been left in the movie...I was blown away by Gerry's singing talent...He also brings a sexiness to a role that I've always associated as being totally creepy. Gerry is not creepy.
Now why the heck would they cut this out?!!! *sniffle* it's almost as heartbreaking as when Erik listened behind the statue to All I Ask of You!!! Awwww!!
but, in a way, christine really ends up being the heroine, since she's the one who gets raoul free, raoul doesnt actually contribute that much for a hero aspect, I would consider him more the prince charming. But i do agree the only character with depth and who really had development in the story was the phantom
At the end during the credits there is a song called "Learn to be Lonely" sang by Minnie Driver that has the same melody but different lyrics. Its basically the same song but a little different. I like this one more though!
;( why didn't they put this into the movie?!?!?!? It totally sets the mood of how the phantom wants you to feel. He is sharing with us the majority of his life in 2:18!! It's so sad!! And as always Gerard Butler did an amazing job singing this!!
This would been cool at the end after the credits as an extra scene after everything had happened, and to show that he will always love christine. Oh how I love this movie!!! what a good song
Nope. It was was just in the novel that the author begins his narration of the events by saying that "the" tale is a true story. But that claim is just part of the fiction novel. :)
I see why they removed it. It is a beautiful song but i am assuming this goes right at the end. He would have had to remove the famous "Its over now the music of the night!" They have learn to be lonely the spin off of this for the credits though if that clears up the confusion of where people heard it before. Regardless Andrew is a composer that writes beautiful music.
This probably would have been right before he goes to loosen the chandelier. He's wearing the same outfit. I really wish this could have stayed. I know it wasn't in the musical, but it's just so beautiful and heartbreaking.
I can see how they'd nix this because the phantom needed to be vilified in order to be truly appreciated. In a way this showing this song makes a case for his already tragic plight. Eric is not asking for compassion or understanding, he IS the poetry he suffers. It would seem somewhat redundant to show his pain... just my opinion. This way his cause is more compelling BECAUSE the audience makes his case.
I love this movie! It's so moving and I just love it!! My school is performing this show for our musical and I am honored to be a part of it. I am not onstage but I still get to be a part of it and I could not be more thrilled. This song is lovely and shows that the phantom really cares for Christine. The only reason I can think that it got cut from the movie was because it wasn't in the original score for the musical and people might not have appreciated that much deviation. I personally love
As I have seen most of Gerry Butlers movies, his singing voice and acting talents are beyond words that I can describe, including some funny commercials he's been in the past. This song should have been kept in this movie for a more personal touch with the phantom's feelings, and Gerry's tone fitted that well, probably even better than any other "phantoms" who have recorded in the past..This changes some viewers of how he really felt(not as a monster), but shows how compassionate he was..
I've always related to the phantom. Though I'm not exactly like that, I have been to many places, and now I've come to a place that is basically a suburb, and I'm used to the street areas. So everybody else has had a pretty much handy dandy life here, while mine has been hard and cruel. So I'm practically the outsider, that's why I relate to characters like that.
I really loved this film. I just saw les mis at the cinema and all I can say is I think they got these sets just right for phantom, where as in les mis there were too many close up shots. 'Too'...'many' still a lovely film. But I honestly think phantom scrapes top spot for musical movie adaptation.
I'm listening, and thinking, WHY THE HELL DID THEY REMOVE THIS SONG!?!?!?! If there's a really good and emotional part about the Phantom, here it is, why delete??? No really? why??
Why the heck was this cut out of the movie?!?!?!! This shows a lot of His feelings for her and explains so much!!!!! They make him out to be some raging psychopath!!!! This should have been in the movie!!!! >:(
I'm crying!! :'( Christine should have gone with the phantom, not Raul! The phantom fell in love with her once he herd her sing, Raul didn't even notice her until she put on that big dress!
Hello Bella! This is from The Phantom of the Opera by Andrew Lloyd Webber, movie released in 2004 with Gerard Butler&Emmy Rossum.In 2012 Love Never Dies was released in Melbourne,Australia with Anna O'Byrne&BenLewis! It's the sequel ten years after Phantom oc the Opera. :) Enjoy ~Joanne
Think so too - it´s a very great song... You can hear the melody in the movie, after the song Masquerade, when gerard butler goes downstairs, a little second before he take christine´s necklace... but the whole video in the movie would be great... don´t understand them...
Christine darling, if you prefer Raoul, then I'll have Erik
This song does a lot for the Phantom's character development. It shows how he is when he's by himself in the place he's spent his whole life. Sad.
It shouldn't of been deleted it explains a lot and its beautiful,
COME ON! If he only sang that to Christine, instead of killing people and threatening.
It would have worked a lot better!
why was this deleted from the movie?!
when he sits at puts the rose on his lips I was just like :( come give me a hug. i'll live with you :)
The phantom is too damn hot in this version, even with a half mutilated face i find him more attractive than Raoul.
oh great. yet another scene that makes the fated end of the phantom's heartbreak even more tragic. "she saw my loneliness. shared in my emptiness" she was an orphan. he was an outcast. she alone would listen to his music, so he held on for as long as he could. say what you want. the phantom might have been a villain, but he was not the devil.
If you listen carefully at the end of the movie, when Raoul (Or how ever you spell it) Is at Christines grave, it plays the instrumentals of this song. This song is just wonderful at making me cry
I learned to listen
In my dark, my heart heard music.
I longed to teach the world
Rise up and reach the world
No one would listen
I alone could hear the music
Then at last, a voice in the gloom
Seemed to cry "I hear you;
I hear your fears,
Your torment and your tears."
She saw my loneliness
Shared in my emptiness
No one would listen
No one but her
Heard as the outcast hears
No one would listen
No one but her
Heard as the outcast hears...
Gerard Butler's voice is so soft and gently that i becomes tears in my eyes.
I agree with you on this. Erik was the only one who who managed to provoke several emotions from the audience in the span of a few hours. When it comes to the Phantom of the Opera, both in play and movie form, it is always Erik that everyone remembers. Yes, people remember Christine and Raoul, but not as much as they remember the Phantom (even if they don't know his actual name).
I'd never heard this song before, I purposefully do not watch anything to do with this movie because when I do I don't stop, so far it's been a week since I first decided to re watch it for the millionth time and I've watched it 3/4 times a day every day and had Music Of The Night stuck in my head for days.
But this, this is wonderful, I absolutely love it!! It really helps you to identify with the Phantom and understand his love for Christine, if only she could have heard it.
It seems like it's implied to go right before the Don Juan scene, seeing as we see his stage designs for it.
I always cry with this, it was a mistake to delete this song from the movie, it shows tha even he was a "monster" he had a heart and the right to be loved too...
Look, I really sympathize for Erik. I really do. But people are missing the point. Pity is not love. While I can really feel for all that he has been through, being called a monster as a child, he channeled those emotions into malice and hatred against the world. It led him to murder (and almost another). It's a tragedy in the end. He let his sorrow consume him and made him become just what people originally wrongly judged him of, a monster. However, he learned what love was in the end.
I really wish this was part of the movie!
we're listining, Erik.....
No one would listen
No one but her
Heard as the outcast hears.
Shamed into solitude
Shunned by the multitude
i wish i could just go in thier and just hhug him and be with him forever :(
I wish this scene had not been deleted. I watch it on the extra disc each time I watch the movie.
This should've been left in the movie...I was blown away by Gerry's singing talent...He also brings a sexiness to a role that I've always associated as being totally creepy. Gerry is not creepy.
I STILL LOVE YOU PHANTOM
The Phantom's love for Christine is really tragic, and that is why they could never be.
Gerard Butler has the most romantic voice ever listened in the story of cinema...
I THINK I'VE FELL IN LOVE...
he loved her so much to let christen go!
and he was so scared to loose the only person that exseped him!!!
Now why the heck would they cut this out?!!! *sniffle* it's almost as heartbreaking as when Erik listened behind the statue to All I Ask of You!!! Awwww!!
but, in a way, christine really ends up being the heroine, since she's the one who gets raoul free, raoul doesnt actually contribute that much for a hero aspect, I would consider him more the prince charming. But i do agree the only character with depth and who really had development in the story was the phantom
At the end during the credits there is a song called "Learn to be Lonely" sang by Minnie Driver that has the same melody but different lyrics. Its basically the same song but a little different.
I like this one more though!
This is te saddest song in the history of the world. I cry every time I hear it. I'm crying now because it's on in the background as I type this.
;( why didn't they put this into the movie?!?!?!? It totally sets the mood of how the phantom wants you to feel. He is sharing with us the majority of his life in 2:18!! It's so sad!! And as always Gerard Butler did an amazing job singing this!!
I love how you can hear his lovely accent
I really wish this was in the actual movie, it reveals so much of the Phantom's character and it shows his softer side.
If this song wasn't deleted from the movie i would cry so much.
This would been cool at the end after the credits as an extra scene after everything had happened, and to show that he will always love christine. Oh how I love this movie!!! what a good song
Nope. It was was just in the novel that the author begins his narration of the events by saying that "the" tale is a true story. But that claim is just part of the fiction novel. :)
I see why they removed it. It is a beautiful song but i am assuming this goes right at the end. He would have had to remove the famous "Its over now the music of the night!" They have learn to be lonely the spin off of this for the credits though if that clears up the confusion of where people heard it before. Regardless Andrew is a composer that writes beautiful music.
Gaston Leroux claims that Erik, the "Phantom of the Opera", was a real person.
Because Erik is real to everyone
Oh I love his soul... how could she resist such beauty.. >.<
This probably would have been right before he goes to loosen the chandelier. He's wearing the same outfit. I really wish this could have stayed. I know it wasn't in the musical, but it's just so beautiful and heartbreaking.
i feel so bad for him.......i would give him a super big hug
if you replace all the her's with he's and so on then this song is basically how i feel like EVERY DAY!!!
The guy who wrote the book believed the phantom actually did exist
i think i've fallen in love with the phantomm...
I wish i were Christine to make the best decission...LOVE THE PHANTOM 4EVER!!
I can see how they'd nix this because the phantom needed to be vilified in order to be truly appreciated. In a way this showing this song makes a case for his already tragic plight. Eric is not asking for compassion or understanding, he IS the poetry he suffers. It would seem somewhat redundant to show his pain... just my opinion. This way his cause is more compelling BECAUSE the audience makes his case.
this is my favorite movie and when i say that i mean it... they have inspierd me to sing i think this is the most romantic movie ever...
This has the same melody as "Learn to be lonely" at the end of the movie O.o"
I love this movie! It's so moving and I just love it!! My school is performing this show for our musical and I am honored to be a part of it. I am not onstage but I still get to be a part of it and I could not be more thrilled. This song is lovely and shows that the phantom really cares for Christine. The only reason I can think that it got cut from the movie was because it wasn't in the original score for the musical and people might not have appreciated that much deviation. I personally love
As I have seen most of Gerry Butlers movies, his singing voice and acting talents are beyond words that I can describe, including some funny commercials he's been in the past. This song should have been kept in this movie for a more personal touch with the phantom's feelings, and Gerry's tone fitted that well, probably even better than any other "phantoms" who have recorded in the past..This changes some viewers of how he really felt(not as a monster), but shows how compassionate he was..
He is the best Phantom! And they should kept this song!
Ooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh this is soooooooooo sad!!! I just wanna hug him! :(
I would listen!
I adore him!! How can she resists him?? _
I Love This Song, Gerard Did A Fantastic Job it Melted My Heart
I've always related to the phantom. Though I'm not exactly like that, I have been to many places, and now I've come to a place that is basically a suburb, and I'm used to the street areas. So everybody else has had a pretty much handy dandy life here, while mine has been hard and cruel. So I'm practically the outsider, that's why I relate to characters like that.
Depressing :(
i love Phantom of the Opera I LOVE Gerard Butler
the phantom is awesome as anyone could ever be.....The phantom is my hero
i love the phantom, i would listen to him
I really loved this film. I just saw les mis at the cinema and all I can say is I think they got these sets just right for phantom, where as in les mis there were too many close up shots. 'Too'...'many' still a lovely film. But I honestly think phantom scrapes top spot for musical movie adaptation.
thats right. i feel his pain too. all he wanted was love. but noooooo. he got stood up.
This is stuck in my head all the time and i cry almost every time i hear it :'(
This song is simply amazing.
He's a great singer ♥
I'm listening, and thinking, WHY THE HELL DID THEY REMOVE THIS SONG!?!?!?! If there's a really good and emotional part about the Phantom, here it is, why delete??? No really? why??
Omgosh he's so sweet and such a gentleman
Dear Phantom,
I'd listen to you! Any day!
;)
Oh my god this song is just gorgeous
Such a beautiful song, even if a tad sad. Such a wonderful voice Gerard Butler has. Makes me swoon when I hear it. Gerard as The Phantom....LOVE
give him a hug someone please
THIS SONG SHOULD BE IN THE FILM!!!! i
someone needs a hug :'(
beautiful. I hear you Gerry!
I LOVE PHANTOM! He's soo cute.
Wonderful song. I almost crying.
♥ Gerard
Why the heck was this cut out of the movie?!?!?!! This shows a lot of His feelings for her and explains so much!!!!! They make him out to be some raging psychopath!!!! This should have been in the movie!!!! >:(
Aww, I love this song!! ♥ It was seriously deleted from the movie?? I can't believe it... I WANT IT IN THE MOVIE!!!
The author claims it was a true story.
I'm crying!! :'(
Christine should have gone with the phantom, not Raul!
The phantom fell in love with her once he herd her sing, Raul didn't even notice her until she put on that big dress!
why did this not get put in the movie?! it would have explained so much more about him!
really good song :) i love it :D
this song is too perfect, but so sad ;(
In a way, this song is the Andrew Lloyd Webber's "Phantom of the Opera" equivalent of "Heaven's Light" from Disney's "Hunchback of Notre Dame".
Ha! The greek style statue in the background with the phantom's mask on at 1:18!
Hello Bella! This is from The Phantom of the Opera by Andrew Lloyd Webber, movie released in 2004 with Gerard Butler&Emmy Rossum.In 2012 Love Never Dies was released in Melbourne,Australia with Anna O'Byrne&BenLewis! It's the sequel ten years after Phantom oc the Opera. :) Enjoy ~Joanne
i would listen phantom! no one listens to me too! we could listen to each other! :')
Thank you so much for uploading all these videos... it's very touching
my heart broke :(
hes beautiful :)
When we watched the movie on video, this was under "deleted scenes & extras"
i love this i'm so sorry they deleted this from the movie it would have been so beautiful if they kept it
Beautiful!
Think so too - it´s a very great song... You can hear the melody in the movie, after the song Masquerade, when gerard butler goes downstairs, a little second before he take christine´s necklace... but the whole video in the movie would be great... don´t understand them...
my god:(( soo beautiful
I wished this song was on the soundtrack CD. it miss alot great songs T__T
IT'S SO BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!! [':
Aw, I wish they'd kept it in. It's perfect
This ought to have been in the film! It would have helped people understand his character better!
oh my freaken gawd. He is so freaken handsome. unbelievable
Someone please get this man a kitten ...
I was like wait, this isn't in the movie. wish it was...
In my case...yes?