Another vote for Glenn Gould but I loved hearing the others. Some gorgeous photos. I only saw pics of Nikoleyva old...she’s so lovely young. And young Clara Haskill so sweet. 💗🎵💗
All of them are great, but my arrangement looks like this: 1. Wilhelm Kempff 2. Nikolayeva 3. Alfred Cortot 4. Clara Haskil 5. Glenn Gould. At the same time the Concerto itself is the greatest with its author I:S. Bach.
bellissimo confronto tra fuoriclasse, in un brano di tale bellezza che anche se fosse suonato da un dilettante sarebbe bello lo stesso. Comunque tra queste esecuzioni proposte quella che a me piace di più è quella della Nikolayeva, seguita da Gould.
Все прекрасны, но Alfred Cortot вызвал самый сильный эмоциональный отклик, кажется. потому что играл наиболее чувственно, хоть и своеобразно вольно. Также сильно меня трогает исполнение Баха Марией Гринберг❤
It's funny, to me it feels like Cortot is totally off - timing is wrong, he comes in late, etc. Amateurish. But to others, he has the best rendition. Funny how taste can differ so much. Gould is the one for me, although this version is not his best.
Cortot has forgotten that this peace of music is a contrapunct,and not romantic Chopen…He tended to say about Haskil,one of the greatest pianist ever,that her taste is nothing more than that if a talented houswife…This is exactly how he plays the Bach,like a bimbo in love…
Love this piece. Didn't like any of the interpretations. Sorry it it offends the church of Gould, but it's not for me. If I have to choose one, it's no 5.
Merci pour cette comparaison fort utile. Cortot, mon pianiste préféré qui fait dans Bach des rallentandi complétement à côté de la plaque... Pour moi le plus beau chant est celui de Clara Haskil, mais ce n'est pas original du tout comme avis.
Cortot a un gros soucis rubato-masturbatoire ici 😅. En tout cas il s'égare, c'est sans intérêt musical. Nikolayeva accentue grossièrement et à contresens des notes c'est vulgaire et stupide. Gould reste le maître pour Bach. Il a montré la voie pour les musiciens sérieux. Il aurait tout de même fallu donner des indications sur les enregistrements.
Wilhelm Kempff et Alfred Cortot sont mes preferés
Благодарю!
Все пять исполнений гениальны!
Нет слов!
This is a Divine melody. Elegant, celestial, ethereal, and everlasting. You can play it in an infinite loop till the end of time.
정말 이런 훌륭한영상 올려주셔서 감사드려요 제가 좋아하는 존경스런분들의 연주들 … 그 아름다운 선율에 흠뻑취하고 갑니다
no me cansaré nunca de escuchar esta partitura celestial
Amazing !!!!!!!!!!! thank you for this excellent team of greatest pianists
Another vote for Glenn Gould but I loved hearing the others. Some gorgeous photos. I only saw pics of Nikoleyva old...she’s so lovely young. And young Clara Haskill so sweet. 💗🎵💗
Agreed about Glenn Gould, there is just something hypnotic and heartbreaking...
Loved your chronological photo selection!
thanks
What a great selection of some of the greatest maestros
thanks
2:50 - Nikolayeva is my favorite
An excellent idea to put five great pianist’s together. I prefer Cortot and my girlfriend prefers Gould.
All of them are great, but my arrangement looks like this: 1. Wilhelm Kempff 2. Nikolayeva 3. Alfred Cortot 4. Clara Haskil 5. Glenn Gould. At the same time the Concerto itself is the greatest with its author I:S. Bach.
Makes me stop and bring back a few of my most intense life encounters. I am so grateful for this auditory dream
Magnifique 👍
Buenísima selección!!
Mi voto por Kempff, sólo piano❤
Hay un genio más igual a estos, el que diseño y compagino esto.
bellissimo confronto tra fuoriclasse, in un brano di tale bellezza che anche se fosse suonato da un dilettante sarebbe bello lo stesso. Comunque tra queste esecuzioni proposte quella che a me piace di più è quella della Nikolayeva, seguita da Gould.
Meine Faworiten : Glen Gould und Clara Haskil
정말 감사합니다!
Все прекрасны, но Alfred Cortot вызвал самый сильный эмоциональный отклик, кажется. потому что играл наиболее чувственно, хоть и своеобразно вольно. Также сильно меня трогает исполнение Баха Марией Гринберг❤
Cortot and Kempff....my favourites
Cortot, for the purity of sound
Crying now........................
Amazing!!!❤❤❤❤
Amazingly divine
Glenn Gould : of course the best !
It's funny, to me it feels like Cortot is totally off - timing is wrong, he comes in late, etc. Amateurish. But to others, he has the best rendition. Funny how taste can differ so much. Gould is the one for me, although this version is not his best.
I don't think his timing is off, it's his personal kind of adding a romantic contemporary touch of rubato to this baroque piece...
Cortot has forgotten that this peace of music is a contrapunct,and not romantic Chopen…He tended to say about Haskil,one of the greatest pianist ever,that her taste is nothing more than that if a talented houswife…This is exactly how he plays the Bach,like a bimbo in love…
Собрание шедевров!
Гульд и Николаева, потом остальные..
Love this piece. Didn't like any of the interpretations. Sorry it it offends the church of Gould, but it's not for me. If I have to choose one, it's no 5.
Merci pour cette comparaison fort utile. Cortot, mon pianiste préféré qui fait dans Bach des rallentandi complétement à côté de la plaque... Pour moi le plus beau chant est celui de Clara Haskil, mais ce n'est pas original du tout comme avis.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Gould! No one else…If there’s any hint of playing this mechanically…it is lost…
👍
Cortot is off. He comes in late, he comes in early. But Tatiana, oh Tatiana!! That twinkle in your fingers puts. a twinklle in my eyes
Nikolayeva se la lleva
Kempff y Haskil
Nikolaeva is the best!!!!
OMG
Whilhem Kempff Is the best!
Cortot misplaces the timing. It sounds so weird!!!!
Gould.
Cortot a un gros soucis rubato-masturbatoire ici 😅. En tout cas il s'égare, c'est sans intérêt musical.
Nikolayeva accentue grossièrement et à contresens des notes c'est vulgaire et stupide.
Gould reste le maître pour Bach. Il a montré la voie pour les musiciens sérieux.
Il aurait tout de même fallu donner des indications sur les enregistrements.
ua-cam.com/video/yl8ZZKNKOBY/v-deo.html&ab_channel=Museum-ReserveofSergeiRachmaninovIvanovka
Stop right now and shut that trap off. Their harpsichord concerto nit piano concerto. What terrible interpretations.
I wonder what would become of all these sheet music robots if one took their sheet music away.