I hope Harry if son of Snape's then snapes and Lilly never dies ... Look at barrier for him .... Albus , moody , even Snape is master ... He even know what dark loard think .. by his own various creations....
Technically, there's no guarantee Snape and Lily's child would be the chosen one. THere's no guarantee the baby would have been born on the same date as Harry. Remember, Trelawney's prophecy could also have applied to Neville Longbottom. If Lily chose Snape, Harry would not exist at all....Neville Longbottom would have become the "chosen one".
True there is no guarantee, but that doesn't mean there is no chance. Snape's betrayal would have already been defying the dark lord twice. (Choosing a gryfindor, and turning his back on his old house mates possibly even hurting them if he joined the OotP.) His last "defying" of the dark lord couldbe anything. Lily could have also been the one to do the last defyance. Their child could also still be born around the same time.
Well for all we know they might have had a girl, or maybe James would have chosen a different woman and had a son with her. For all we know there might be THREE candidates if they were boys born to people who defied Voldemort three times. That's all the prophecy says. The pool gets bigger if more people fight him and survive.
@@kirbyfazendoummoonwalk9214 and because of snape's. He asked Voldemort to spare her life, otherwise, her death wouldn't provide any protection to harry
Woah! Just like Kylo Ren. Rey was the true hero of the story. Her compassion saved Ben from being fully consumed by darkness, for she was his light side.
Their story is a cautionary tale about the evils of peer pressure. All of these changes could have been Voldermort down fall as easily. Snape changing side could have made others follow him. It's thousands of leaves falling off a tree in a thousand different ways. I love these videos
Yeah no doubt Lucius and the older soon to be DE's were re cruiting like people did for the Hitler Youth. Snape could not have made a more vulnerable target. Bullied, resentful, gifted, a loner, wants power, recognition, and acceptance. How easy it would have been to cosy up to a young Snape, offer him protection in return for hearing them out on their Lord's aims. And I don't buy that Snape's ventures in Dark Magic were maliciously intended. I think he believed that learning about the dark arts, becoming knowledgeable about them is a powerful advantage to protecting people from them, as well as becoming a more knowledgeable person in general. He probably hated dark arts books being censored in the Restricted Section because it kept people from being well informed. I also have a theory that sectumsempra was not malciously created either. I do believe Snape Sr. was very physically abusive, towards Snape and his mother. So I believe he created that spell as a desperate last resort to protect him and his mother. That's the one question I wish I could get JK to answer.
@@ariellann6183yes this thank you. This is eh Snape’s character and story is the most interesting to me. It has a much deeper and thematic narrative than Harry’s chosen one. About the perils of how evil infiltrates, grooms and normalizes radical facist bigotry in society. How if we don’t recognize the signs and help the vulnerable if our communities then they’ll fall prey to evils. And how small simple chances & compassion can change anyone back to goodness which will start a domino effect. Snape should’ve been the main character by the end of the
Honestly, do not believe Snape would've cared about the dark arts, as his love for Liliy, and her reciprocating that love, would've made him a better man. Call me romantic, as love conquers all.
Love conquers all is one of the themes of the series, so it makes perfect sense. In the end, it was his love for Lily that changed Snape, and made him contribute to the order, which helped win the war.
I wish Snape and Lily were explored. I was always curious how things would’ve played out for the both of them. I loved that they had known each other as children and I found it sad that their relationship could have blossomed into something beautiful, whether they became romantically involved or remained platonic. Even maintaining a friendship between the two of them would have been a sweet touch. A Gryffindor and Slytherin.
Snape was obsessed with his idea of what Lily should be. Lily was a good person and tried to remain friends with a monster that at the age of 11 knew more DARK MAGIC then 7th years! He was also equally obsessed with trying to get a group of students expelled just because the leader of the group had a crush on the girl that he happened to be stalking. He was so obsessed with her that he went to the guy who was in the process of hunting her family down and tried to convince him to save her but kill her son and husband in cold blood in-front of her. It’s amazing that the person who personally put the entire series in motion is made into an angel because at the very end of the series he tries to kind of rectify the situation that he caused.
@@dustinvaughn8871 point on. And it still bothers me how exactly Snape could have even dreamed about getting Lily for himself after arranging the murders of her husband and young innocent baby? She would have never forgiven him.
@@dustinvaughn8871 true. I love to hate him actually. He would have needed serious help, and stay AWAY from Hogwarts. If he would have needed a safe location from Riddle jr. he could have changed country, changed name and so on...
You seem to have forgotten that harry was ONLY the chosen one because Voldemort tried to kill him when he was a baby. If Voldemort did not know the prophacy then he never would have tried to killed harry which means there would be no chosen one.
team my oh my. No he wasnt, it wasn’t decided yet, if James and Lily would have never been together then Voldemort would have to mark Neville as his equal.
@@lazer_dindy6455 harry was not the chosen one until Voldemort tried to kill him. He only tried to kill him because he knew (the first half) of the prophecy. If lily and snape would have been together and had a baby, 1 the prophecy would have been different if there was one at all, and 2 he would not have known about it because he only knew about the prophecy because snape overheard. So if snape was with lily he would not have heard the prophecy which means Voldemort would not have known about it (if there was still a prophecy) which means nobody would have been marked.
We should've seen this scene somewhere in the later films: Harry: Why do you hate me so much, Professor? WHY? Snape: BECAUSE YOU SHOULD'VE BEEN MY SON!!!
Anja michels - The death eaters would have anyways come for Potters some day. Death eaters were cleaning up members of the order of phoenix . Just that Voldemort wouldn't try to kill Harry and get fucked up in the process. Instead he would kill/torture James & Lily and walk away ; like it was done to the Longbottoms. Killing a baby Harry won't have meant anything to Voldemort ; he wasn't at all against magical blood. He only wanted immortality and power for himself, death for muggles and all the magical beings to follow him. He only killed those witches/wizards who opposed him.
Lilly's death was even more tragic in the news that Lily had convinced James to talk things over with Severus - despite her ending the friendship with Snape due to him calling her a mudblood - she still cared about him, just not as much as Snape cared for her.
@@williamhoang4077 I mean it’s not her fault she tried to be his friend but he called her mudblood and hung out with the death eaters, James was a jerk but he didn’t join Voldemort
Snape is playing with his chemistry set actually James Potter was playing with Lily Evans oh how romantic 😍😍😍😍 actually she became pregnant at the age of 20 only so everything over oh how romantic for sure. They are happy with each other
Hey! She woulda chose him if it really was Alan Rickman (or his "son" Adam Driver). I wonder if Snape would have survived the first wizarding war, in that the Slytherins would have seen him as a blood traitor, no?
I read a fan-fiction once, which had an interesting concept similar to this. In it, everything played out the same as in the regular timeline, until the night of the Potters' murders. This version has Lily surviving Voldemort's attack due to a second pregnancy, the spell causing a miscarriage instead of killing her. Snape enters the house and finds her unconscious. Thinking she's dead, he cries and cradles her. She wakes up during this. The story cuts to James's funeral, and to a conversation between Lily and Snape. He tries to comfort her, telling her she can stay at his house until she gets back on her feet. She accepts, and the story ends. If JK Rowling ever put out a series of "what-if?" novels, I'd like to think she'd take this route.
Wow...mind blown. If Harry was a Snape, then maybe everything could change, he might not have met Ron and Hermione, not gonna marry Ginny...and not have the Invisibility Cloak, and not as powerful. Maybe even become Draco’s friend?
What do you mean not as powerful ?Harry is an above average wizard at best despite being James and Lily's son ,If anything he would have been even more magically skilled and powerful due to him being Severus and Lily's Son .Severus is another level of wizard entirely compared to James or any of the other marauders . Though he wouldn't be harry potter .He would have been a completely different person with a completely different set of goals and moral values or whatnot.The only similarity he would have had with harry would be that he was born around the same time as he .The thing that is for certain is he wouldn't have gotten his hands on the invisibility cloak due to him not being a potter .He very well could have met ron or Hermione but whether he would be friends with them is another question entirely and even if he was the entire dynamic between the trio would have been altered to the point that it would have been unrecognisable .There wouldn't have been a trio ,If he does become the choosen one he might have completed all of his adventures alone or on his own if he becomes a particularly remarkable wizard or a wizard on the level of Tom Riddle or Albus Dumbledore .He would have been a more stereotypical choosen one as in being overpowered and highly gifted by comparison to harry
konrad vesterberg Actually, since half-bloods can be Sorted into Slytherin, they can be accepted as Death Eaters, since those types of half-bloods cling onto their Wizarding heritage and are prejudiced towards those with Muggle heritage despite being “half-muggle” themselves. Also, Voldemort himself is half-blood (Witch Mother, Muggle Father). So is Umbitch (Wizard Father, Muggle Mother).
Well for starters, Nevell Longbottom. He would've had both his parents because they wouldn't have been tortured for information on the Potter's whereabouts....possibly making him the one to defeat voldemort.
Honestly i dont think a lot of Things would change, Maybe James would stop Judging Slytherin and Maybe Become Snape Friend (Because by what i Remenber, the only Reason James Bully Snape was Because he was Slytherin)
@@angeieticals3059 James wouldn't have given to tosses about Lily had she been in Slytherin I think. To be perfectly honest, there would have been no competition to begin with, so he probably would have either ignored lily or bullied her right along with the rest of slytherin...
If Snape's entire happiness was dependent on Lily and he couldn't have been happy and down a better path otherwise, then Snilly is unhealthy. And James and Lily were more compatible anyways aside from Lily only marrying James after he grew out of his bullying. More likely, the Chosen One had to be James and Lily's son with the exact same genes. But between James and Lily, the Chosen One would more likely be James's son with another's woman as he's Harry's connection to Voldy via the Peverells and he could still have a son who looked exactly the same with different eyes and the same exact name, Harry James Potter.
Is it not because Lily cast herself in-between Harry and Voldemort which made Voldemort mark him as an equal unintentionally? So I think Lily the more important parent than James, that being if the father was Snape it would have played out completely different. Both parents are important but it's really Lily that gave Harry the protection to take down Voldemort.
@@edengutkin2550 That wasn't just Lily - any mother would have sacrificed herself for Harry if she truly loved him . But if Snape was the father either he would move his family abroad or raise his kid to be loyal to Voldemort - or release a fake birthday .
I love “what if’s” like this. It’s intriguing to explore all of the different possibilities, since this story really could have gone so many different ways. There’s something J. K. Rowling said that sparked my curiosity. She once stated that Lily was planning on reconciling with Snape, and even convinced James to try and patch things up with him. She was pregnant with a second child at the time, and wanted to ask Snape to be the Godfather. If Lily and James survived, and Snape accepted this role (even putting up with James so he could be Lily’s friend again), how would that affect the rest of the story? I think it would definitely be interesting to explore.
Harry Potter Folklore Thank you and keep up the amazing work I enjoy listening to your theory videos of different characters and origin especially while driving they are informative and awesome😆.
Yep. And since he didn't know about the prophecy, (Snape was the one that told Voldemort about the prophecy in the first place) he would've accidentally marked Neville Longbottom as his equal.
but Harry wouldn't be Harry so he would be a totally different person. also he wouldn't be the chosen one unless Voldemort knew because he wouldn't "mark him as his equal
I think the biggest thing that would have changed is that Snape would have just plain been a happier and more sociable person. He probably would have been better liked at Hogwarts, gotten along better with his students, and had more friends.
Hermione, Ron and Ginny might not even be alive (anymore) by the time they would go to hogwarts. Cause if Harry did not kill Voldemort that night, the war would have continued. And there would be no way to predict who would have lived and who would have died
he wouldn't be harry with snape as his dad it's not like snape just adopted him he might not even be a boy (which would mean that the prophesy didn't apply"
Snape truly loved Lily until the day he died... it's sad. Even though he was a Death Eater and potentially put her in a bad position, he still loved her no matter what
Just wanna tell ya that it goes more like: Albus Severus Potter you were name after two headmasters of hogwarts, one of them was a slytherin and he was the bravest man I know.
You did a great job. The magic of that line isn't in the words it's self but in the idea they petray. The magic of Snape letting his grief of what he gave up and what he was doing for the "greater good."out when Harry was grieving too please don't put yourself down.
@@riverdaletales8457 People hit like as they arrived because they were SOOO glad that Dean was back. Then they views and the views moved up 10 minutes later when the video was actually viewed. My thoughts and feelings - glad to see you back Dean ! ! !
No, Snape and Lily weren’t meant to be. Snape got into the Dark Arts and was becoming a Death Eater, which Lily did not support. The final nail in the coffin was Snape calling Lily a mud blood, at which point she realized he was no longer the boy she grew up with and called friend, and wanted nothing to do with him anymore. She could be criticized for “abandoning Snape when he needed her the most”, but their friendship was quickly becoming toxic and she would likely have been seriously harmed or killed if she continued to stay. Voldemort or some other Death Eater would have likely tried to harm or kill her because she was a muggle born, as Snape probably wouldn’t have been able to even at his worst. She could even be criticized for falling for James, one of the boys who was severely bullying Snape. Truth is, James did genuinely care for Lily and changed for the better once they were together. Because of her, he changed to be a better man who became a loving boyfriend, then husband, then father. Meanwhile Snape only grew to be more cruel and spiteful, even jealous as he watched James and Lily’s relationship flourish. Snape didn’t think of Lily when he told Voldemort the prophecy. He only became a double agent for Dumbledore when he realized his actions put Lily specifically in danger. He didn’t care for James and Harry, just Lily even though he begged Dumbledore to hide them all. During Harry’s years at Hogwarts, Snape took out his vengeance on him because he was the spitting image of James except for the eyes, and only protected him because of Lily.
great theory. in response to your question, "harry" would never have received the invisibility cloak nor do i think he would have gotten the marauders map (unless he befriended george and fred).
Neville Longbottom: "Am I a joke to you?" Yeah, in all seriousnes, you forgot a charachter this story would impact immensly on. There is no guarantee that Severus and Lily would concieve their child in the same timeframe as James and Lily did. There is no guarantee that Severus and Lily would thrice defy him. For all we know, they may not even have kids for few years. Maybe James would meet someone else and their child (Harry) would be the chosen one. But most likely is that chosen one burden would fell on Neville. Now, when Voldemort eventually start to hunt Longbottoms down, I assume Frank and Alice, unlike James and Lily, would accept Dumbledore's offer for him to become a secret keeper, making them safe as long as Dumbledore is alive. I assume Neville would live his life in hiding, maybe even recieve special training from early age to match up with Voldemort. Anyway, there are lot of possibilities from here on, so I will end my take right now.
Lily is honestly the best character in the series, even though we don't see much of her. She joined up to fight Voldemort when she was a literal teenager, gave birth to the chosen one, died protecting him (and Petunia's family with the magic), and also saved Snape from becoming evil, which motivated him to help win the war.
PLEASE DON'T STEAL! I'm picturing a daughter. Red hair & dark eyes. Sally Snape. Because Sally means Princess. The half blood prince would have a princess. And she would definitely be in Griphendor because her loving mother was one.
pettagrew would've known about the prophecy and could've told voldamort and James might've agreed with pettagrew until lilly had died and would probably take the role of snape if lilly had chosen Snape instead or a mixture of Snape and Sirius and might've been put in jail because of the same event so Severus jr might go down the same role maybe a bit later down the line like a year most likely so the new "harry" would've probably been 3 instead of 2 when his parents where murdered so it wouldn't have changed much maybe "harry" would've been in Slytherin making friends with draco instead of ron and hermione
One thing that I really love about your videos is that you talk about these topics like they actually happened, you make it sound so real. Keep up the good work!
Surely the whole Chosen One & Voldy plot would've still happened though, I mean... Neville? The Prophecy and all. Given Snape as a character, his personality and background, I'm quite sceptical that it would've been all sunshine and rainbows. I'm so sorry that I'm so negative - I have really missed your videos and I'm so happy that you're back 🥰 this is probably the first of your What If?s that I disagree with and, as I'm a giant nerd, that is a big achievement ;) love you dude xx
I think so too, heck, snape Jr would be a ravenclaw for sure. Right in the middle of the antagonism of slytherin and gryffindor. Just to placate diplomacy in the fam lol
The way I see it, Snape and Lily getting together would change how the original story went. It is due to Snape being a death eater that Harry was the hero. When Snape heard that Voldemort planned on killing either Harry, he informed Dumbledore about Harry being chosen. Which causes the Potter’s to go into hiding, thus caused Voldemort to double down on killing Harry as he viewed Dumbledore picking Harry as the prophetic child. However, if Lily did end up with Snape then their child would have mostly been the one Voldemort choose. Lily would still still fit as a parent who defied three times. Snape would defy him by refusing to join him, marrying Lily(a muggleborn), and fighting with the order. Combine all that with the fact that Snape was someone he would want makes it all the more likely.
Voldormort could’ve still been taken down because just because you change his father doesn’t change the time he goes to Hogwarts so Voldormort would have found out that Harry was the chosen ones one way or another and Harry’s not the only person the prophecy was about Neville Longbottom was the other one so it could’ve been the same. But played out in a different way
If Lily chose Snape over James, Harry would have no connection to the Deathly Hallows. The Invisibility Cloak was passed down from father to son. Lily was never a member of the Peverell family.
I love the energy and joy in is voice, anyone watching the video can see how happy he is to be recording again. And, scrolling through the comments, everyone of them has been liked by you, I love your dedication even when your channel was almost taken down, please never give your joys up, what ever they may be
The only reason why James changed was because of Lily. Without Lily in his life he probably would have done what Pettigrew did and sacrifice Snape to have Lily. This would of course devastate Black more than losing James due to him dying as it would be a betrayal by his best friend he thought of as a brother. Snape wasn't a bully like James was so he'd probably slip further into the Dark Arts and probably not help Dumbledore out like Snape would have.
You can shut the fuck up about James, he wasn't a shitty person his whole life. James isn't responsible for Snape being a Death Eater, in fact Snape was already prejudiced against muggles before attending Hogwarts. The only difference between James and Snape is that James grew up whereas Snape didn't, something that an obnoxious Snape fan like yourself will NEVER understand. James was a lot more braver and ten times the person than Snape ever was. Also, James never 'took' or 'stole' Lily from Snape, Snape was the one who drove Lily away. Lily CHOSE to be with James, something you Snape apologist/fans are jealous of. The one thing I will say about Snape though is he never really changed. Harry aside, he was a jerk to most of his students, look at how he treated Neville, as far as we know Neville’s parents didn’t do anything to him and yet he’s still an ass.
I've just called out the bakeey..lol just kidding, I actually really love Sophie! It's good to be back..
@@irisp9536 maybe, hard to imagine. What if uncle Vernon met Voldemort and told him there is no such thing as magic.
I hope Harry if son of Snape's then snapes and Lilly never dies ... Look at barrier for him .... Albus , moody , even Snape is master ... He even know what dark loard think .. by his own various creations....
I missed you Dean !
Harry Potter Folklore wow
Haha! Wait... whose Lily? 😏
RIP Alan rickman 😢
He suited the role of Snape so well
Lexie Ingham except he was about 30 yrs older then necessary.
He was an amazing actor.
And RIP the person who played Mr. Dursley, he was Nice
Alan played Snape well. May he be remembered in our hearts and cinema forever.
Dustin Vaughn He still did good, didn’t he?
Technically, there's no guarantee Snape and Lily's child would be the chosen one. THere's no guarantee the baby would have been born on the same date as Harry. Remember, Trelawney's prophecy could also have applied to Neville Longbottom. If Lily chose Snape, Harry would not exist at all....Neville Longbottom would have become the "chosen one".
True there is no guarantee, but that doesn't mean there is no chance. Snape's betrayal would have already been defying the dark lord twice. (Choosing a gryfindor, and turning his back on his old house mates possibly even hurting them if he joined the OotP.) His last "defying" of the dark lord couldbe anything.
Lily could have also been the one to do the last defyance. Their child could also still be born around the same time.
Well for all we know they might have had a girl, or maybe James would have chosen a different woman and had a son with her. For all we know there might be THREE candidates if they were boys born to people who defied Voldemort three times. That's all the prophecy says. The pool gets bigger if more people fight him and survive.
Or, they would probably not even have a child so soon. Especially considering the fact that a war is going on.
No because the only reason there is a chosen one because Snape told Voldy to spare Lily but she wouldn’t back down Wichita is why Harry survived
Exactly
Wow
How very dare he insult you and snape
Who's Lily?
That's tuff
It is ok Sophie, Snape still loves you
Who’s Lily
Awesome job Dean!
MovieFlame here before your comment blows up
Love your videos!
Love ur channel
Remember me when I’m just another reply
MovieFlame I love your videos so much can you please do more hunger games related videos
Lily was the true hero of the story. Her friendship saved Snape from being consumed by darkness, she was his light
Yesss
And if wasnt for Her, Harry wouldnt live.
@@kirbyfazendoummoonwalk9214 and because of snape's. He asked Voldemort to spare her life, otherwise, her death wouldn't provide any protection to harry
not to mention she was the one that defeated Voldemort everyone says harry did but it was lily using old magic
Woah! Just like Kylo Ren. Rey was the true hero of the story. Her compassion saved Ben from being fully consumed by darkness, for she was his light side.
Harry would have looked so weird
Lillys eyes, Snapes greasy hair. Pasty as hell & flitting around like a rat w/ wings..O.o someone needs to draw that XD
Emma Wang yeah
Lol
Just look up Daniel Radcliffe in Frankenstein.
Oh my gowsh soooooooooooo many likes wowza I'm just an 11 year old bookworm wowzaaaaaa
Their story is a cautionary tale about the evils of peer pressure.
All of these changes could have been Voldermort down fall as easily.
Snape changing side could have made others follow him.
It's thousands of leaves falling off a tree in a thousand different ways.
I love these videos
Wow that’s deep.
Yeah no doubt Lucius and the older soon to be DE's were re cruiting like people did for the Hitler Youth. Snape could not have made a more vulnerable target. Bullied, resentful, gifted, a loner, wants power, recognition, and acceptance. How easy it would have been to cosy up to a young Snape, offer him protection in return for hearing them out on their Lord's aims. And I don't buy that Snape's ventures in Dark Magic were maliciously intended. I think he believed that learning about the dark arts, becoming knowledgeable about them is a powerful advantage to protecting people from them, as well as becoming a more knowledgeable person in general. He probably hated dark arts books being censored in the Restricted Section because it kept people from being well informed. I also have a theory that sectumsempra was not malciously created either. I do believe Snape Sr. was very physically abusive, towards Snape and his mother. So I believe he created that spell as a desperate last resort to protect him and his mother. That's the one question I wish I could get JK to answer.
@@ariellann6183yes this thank you. This is eh Snape’s character and story is the most interesting to me. It has a much deeper and thematic narrative than Harry’s chosen one. About the perils of how evil infiltrates, grooms and normalizes radical facist bigotry in society. How if we don’t recognize the signs and help the vulnerable if our communities then they’ll fall prey to evils. And how small simple chances & compassion can change anyone back to goodness which will start a domino effect. Snape should’ve been the main character by the end of the
Yes... Harry Snape does sound weird
Severus potter is good tho
I like the idea of them taking Snape’s mother’s maiden name, Prince.
What about Hadrian Snape
Who says they would’ve named their childHarry
...Harry Evans?
Honestly, do not believe Snape would've cared about the dark arts, as his love for Liliy, and her reciprocating that love, would've made him a better man. Call me romantic, as love conquers all.
Love conquers all is one of the themes of the series, so it makes perfect sense. In the end, it was his love for Lily that changed Snape, and made him contribute to the order, which helped win the war.
*"and no sophie, he doesn't love you. he doesn't even know you exist..!"*
*sophie crying with her 3 snape wands at hand.*
You shoukd try shifting
Who is marlene mckinnion
I wish Snape and Lily were explored. I was always curious how things would’ve played out for the both of them. I loved that they had known each other as children and I found it sad that their relationship could have blossomed into something beautiful, whether they became romantically involved or remained platonic. Even maintaining a friendship between the two of them would have been a sweet touch. A Gryffindor and Slytherin.
Snape was more interested of Dark Arts then what he was of Lily.
Snape was obsessed with his idea of what Lily should be. Lily was a good person and tried to remain friends with a monster that at the age of 11 knew more DARK MAGIC then 7th years! He was also equally obsessed with trying to get a group of students expelled just because the leader of the group had a crush on the girl that he happened to be stalking. He was so obsessed with her that he went to the guy who was in the process of hunting her family down and tried to convince him to save her but kill her son and husband in cold blood in-front of her. It’s amazing that the person who personally put the entire series in motion is made into an angel because at the very end of the series he tries to kind of rectify the situation that he caused.
@@dustinvaughn8871 point on. And it still bothers me how exactly Snape could have even dreamed about getting Lily for himself after arranging the murders of her husband and young innocent baby? She would have never forgiven him.
helene4397 he was an awful person
@@dustinvaughn8871 true. I love to hate him actually. He would have needed serious help, and stay AWAY from Hogwarts. If he would have needed a safe location from Riddle jr. he could have changed country, changed name and so on...
It would have been if Snape didn't call her mudblood
And if he wasn't into future Death-Eaters.
crystal_skillet its "mudblood"
crystal_skillet it’s mudblood lol
crystal_skillet hah... no.
@@bace914 fake potterhead?
You seem to have forgotten that harry was ONLY the chosen one because Voldemort tried to kill him when he was a baby. If Voldemort did not know the prophacy then he never would have tried to killed harry which means there would be no chosen one.
team my oh my. No he wasnt, it wasn’t decided yet, if James and Lily would have never been together then Voldemort would have to mark Neville as his equal.
@@lazer_dindy6455 harry was not the chosen one until Voldemort tried to kill him. He only tried to kill him because he knew (the first half) of the prophecy. If lily and snape would have been together and had a baby, 1 the prophecy would have been different if there was one at all, and 2 he would not have known about it because he only knew about the prophecy because snape overheard. So if snape was with lily he would not have heard the prophecy which means Voldemort would not have known about it (if there was still a prophecy) which means nobody would have been marked.
@@udubhuskies2537 That's assuming Voldemort didn't assign someone else to listen in on Dumbledore doing teacher interviews.
@@Katatasuni true, but like I said there my not have been a prophecy to hear.
@@udubhuskies2537 Why do you think there might not have been one? I don't think I've seen anyone ever bring it up.
“Harry Snape”
My mind: HARRY, SNAPE, HARRY, SNAPE, HARRY, SNAPE, HARRY, SNAPE, HAR- DUMBLEDOREEEEEEEE
like potterpuppetpals? get it? okay i’m gonna lead myself out.
i forgot i wrote this, wtf was going through my head
InternetAsian
Lmaooo I found it Hilarious XD
Harry Dumbledore.....
Sounds Intresting.... Ew
Mr Potter
Mr snape.
HERMOINE!
Ron, Ron, Ron Weasely!
I'm Harry Potter, Harry Harry Potter.
HEEEEERRRRMIOOONE!
We should've seen this scene somewhere in the later films: Harry: Why do you hate me so much, Professor? WHY? Snape: BECAUSE YOU SHOULD'VE BEEN MY SON!!!
Lol
That would’ve been awkward
What if Snape never heard the prophecy?
Anja michels - The death eaters would have anyways come for Potters some day. Death eaters were cleaning up members of the order of phoenix .
Just that Voldemort wouldn't try to kill Harry and get fucked up in the process. Instead he would kill/torture James & Lily and walk away ; like it was done to the Longbottoms.
Killing a baby Harry won't have meant anything to Voldemort ; he wasn't at all against magical blood. He only wanted immortality and power for himself, death for muggles and all the magical beings to follow him. He only killed those witches/wizards who opposed him.
*What if Snape Never Heard The prophecy?
Heard
Subhadeep Ray you mean Phoenix?
@@kira-9756 yeah, I meant phoenix. The auto correct made it sphinx
Neville Longbottom would have been happier. His parents would have never gotten tortured.
Or his parents would have been killed just as the Harry Potter parents
Also because Trelawney's prophecy could have applied to Neville. So he probably wouldn't have that much of a happy life. Just guessing though
Exactly!
They would’ve been killed.
Of they were killed and he would have been raised by his grandmother.
They wouldn’t have been tortured, they would have been dead...
Lilly's death was even more tragic in the news that Lily had convinced James to talk things over with Severus - despite her ending the friendship with Snape due to him calling her a mudblood - she still cared about him, just not as much as Snape cared for her.
That never happened. After their sixth year, Lily basically left Snape to his own devices and most likely didn’t care much about him.
@@williamhoang4077 I mean it’s not her fault she tried to be his friend but he called her mudblood and hung out with the death eaters, James was a jerk but he didn’t join Voldemort
@@Ckrost I’m just saying that Lily never asked James to talk things over with Severus..... nor should she; it just wouldn’t work
Snape is playing with his chemistry set actually
James Potter was playing with Lily Evans oh how romantic 😍😍😍😍 actually she became pregnant at the age of 20 only so everything over oh how romantic for sure.
They are happy with each other
Actually when James pranked Severus, didn't Lily chuckle. She was not the pure angle that Severus thought of her.
"Lily will become pregnant for Severus" How thoughtful of her!
Just kidding, this is the best alternate video you have done so far!
Hey! She woulda chose him if it really was Alan Rickman (or his "son" Adam Driver). I wonder if Snape would have survived the first wizarding war, in that the Slytherins would have seen him as a blood traitor, no?
I saw a question about Rickman and Driver: I refer to the meme of Snape with the caption: Kylo Ren -- I am your father.
I think he would have, he is a very powerful wizard after all, and one who doesn't hold back.
I read a fan-fiction once, which had an interesting concept similar to this. In it, everything played out the same as in the regular timeline, until the night of the Potters' murders. This version has Lily surviving Voldemort's attack due to a second pregnancy, the spell causing a miscarriage instead of killing her. Snape enters the house and finds her unconscious. Thinking she's dead, he cries and cradles her. She wakes up during this. The story cuts to James's funeral, and to a conversation between Lily and Snape. He tries to comfort her, telling her she can stay at his house until she gets back on her feet. She accepts, and the story ends. If JK Rowling ever put out a series of "what-if?" novels, I'd like to think she'd take this route.
Link?
Do you know where I can find this fan fiction and what it's called? I'd love to read it :)
@@Esther-sf1vc I would really like to know this, too
link? I would love to read it.
Miss gurl are you going to tell us what it’s called or what
lily *snape*
harry *snape*
the *snapes*
*that just doesn’t sound right*
Ikr
Etanashe Harry prince and lily prince ☺️
Or Harry *Potter* that Sounds right
Jily forever
Maybe they would have had a girl and named her Tabitha Snape.
Ye
Wow...mind blown. If Harry was a Snape, then maybe everything could change, he might not have met Ron and Hermione, not gonna marry Ginny...and not have the Invisibility Cloak, and not as powerful. Maybe even become Draco’s friend?
Harry potter wouldn't exist .
lmao there wouldn't be a harry
What do you mean not as powerful ?Harry is an above average wizard at best despite being James and Lily's son ,If anything he would have been even more magically skilled and powerful due to him being Severus and Lily's Son .Severus is another level of wizard entirely compared to James or any of the other marauders . Though he wouldn't be harry potter .He would have been a completely different person with a completely different set of goals and moral values or whatnot.The only similarity he would have had with harry would be that he was born around the same time as he .The thing that is for certain is he wouldn't have gotten his hands on the invisibility cloak due to him not being a potter .He very well could have met ron or Hermione but whether he would be friends with them is another question entirely and even if he was the entire dynamic between the trio would have been altered to the point that it would have been unrecognisable .There wouldn't have been a trio ,If he does become the choosen one he might have completed all of his adventures alone or on his own if he becomes a particularly remarkable wizard or a wizard on the level of Tom Riddle or Albus Dumbledore .He would have been a more stereotypical choosen one as in being overpowered and highly gifted by comparison to harry
Maybe you can do a: 'What if Harry Potter had a (twin)brother/sister?'
I would love to see that it sounds so interesting that would be a great 👍 video
Dallas Jensen 😊
The Private Internetter probably survive exactly like Harry protected by lily
Abdisamad Farah yeah but how would his/her reputation be? Would this brother/sister be famous too?
Then harry won't be so depressed
00:20 *SHOTS FIRED SHOTS FIRED*
it could of been a girl
@Lina El cause it does
@Lina El yes
he said whatever they call their child. Child, not son
Then the entire timeline wouldn't exist. Voldemort would still kill Lily because she was muggleborn and not a pureblood.
But snape would be dead to he’s a halfblood
konrad vesterberg Actually, since half-bloods can be Sorted into Slytherin, they can be accepted as Death Eaters, since those types of half-bloods cling onto their Wizarding heritage and are prejudiced towards those with Muggle heritage despite being “half-muggle” themselves. Also, Voldemort himself is half-blood (Witch Mother, Muggle Father). So is Umbitch (Wizard Father, Muggle Mother).
in the 4th book, at the start, it says voldemort kills anyone, pureblood or mudblood.
@@YellowBear-kx1ff "Umbitch" 😂😂😂
konrad vesterberg Voldemort was also a half blood.
Well for starters, Nevell Longbottom. He would've had both his parents because they wouldn't have been tortured for information on the Potter's whereabouts....possibly making him the one to defeat voldemort.
Not Potter’s whereabouts, Voldemort’s
I'm trying to imagine Snape's smile when he saw his son take his first steps. Or his laughter. It's an odd thought
What if Lily Evans was sorted into Slytherin?
Honestly i dont think a lot of Things would change, Maybe James would stop Judging Slytherin and Maybe Become Snape Friend (Because by what i Remenber, the only Reason James Bully Snape was Because he was Slytherin)
: D James would still bully slytherin but he would never make fun of lily
@@angeieticals3059 James wouldn't have given to tosses about Lily had she been in Slytherin I think. To be perfectly honest, there would have been no competition to begin with, so he probably would have either ignored lily or bullied her right along with the rest of slytherin...
First of all, Lily was a muggleborn.. which is she will not be in Slytherin in the first place..
@@manfromearth7854 exactly..
Good job Dean, keep going, your videos are just so damn good I wouldn't know what to do without HarryPotterFolklore. Thanks
that means the world..thank you
Movieflame is way more better !!!
@@shahinasharafudeen6689 he doesn't like the videos udo's are the characters of life I mean e breaks down the characters of life
What if it wasn't Lilly's child that is destined to stop Voldemort? What if it's James child that he has with someone else?
Or Neville Longbottom
@@soundninja99 what if James Marry Neville Mom on his Alternate Timeline?
@@kirbyfazendoummoonwalk9214I think the longbottoms were several years older than James's age
If Snape's entire happiness was dependent on Lily and he couldn't have been happy and down a better path otherwise, then Snilly is unhealthy. And James and Lily were more compatible anyways aside from Lily only marrying James after he grew out of his bullying.
More likely, the Chosen One had to be James and Lily's son with the exact same genes. But between James and Lily, the Chosen One would more likely be James's son with another's woman as he's Harry's connection to Voldy via the Peverells and he could still have a son who looked exactly the same with different eyes and the same exact name, Harry James Potter.
Tasha9313 I think the guilt of accidentally causing Lily’s death made him unable to be truly happy
Is it not because Lily cast herself in-between Harry and Voldemort which made Voldemort mark him as an equal unintentionally? So I think Lily the more important parent than James, that being if the father was Snape it would have played out completely different. Both parents are important but it's really Lily that gave Harry the protection to take down Voldemort.
@@edengutkin2550 That wasn't just Lily - any mother would have sacrificed herself for Harry if she truly loved him . But if Snape was the father either he would move his family abroad or raise his kid to be loyal to Voldemort - or release a fake birthday .
I love “what if’s” like this. It’s intriguing to explore all of the different possibilities, since this story really could have gone so many different ways. There’s something J. K. Rowling said that sparked my curiosity. She once stated that Lily was planning on reconciling with Snape, and even convinced James to try and patch things up with him. She was pregnant with a second child at the time, and wanted to ask Snape to be the Godfather. If Lily and James survived, and Snape accepted this role (even putting up with James so he could be Lily’s friend again), how would that affect the rest of the story? I think it would definitely be interesting to explore.
Umm didnt Voldemort need to mark the child as his equal to be the chosen one?
That was my thought exactly
Why would he try to kill the child thereby accidentally leaving a part of himself in the child thus creating his equal then?
He did, his scar.
Voldemort didnt know this part though..Snape only overheard the part that the kid will be born as the 7th month dies
@@potatoface1041 and by going after harry, that marks him as his equal
Couldn’t the chosen one be Neville Longbottom in this theory since Bellatrix could’ve convinced Voldemort to attack his family.
great idea
Harry Potter Folklore Thank you and keep up the amazing work I enjoy listening to your theory videos of different characters and origin especially while driving they are informative and awesome😆.
Yep. And since he didn't know about the prophecy, (Snape was the one that told Voldemort about the prophecy in the first place) he would've accidentally marked Neville Longbottom as his equal.
@@HarryPotterFolklore I don't answer video.Please add TURKISH SUBTITLE🙏🙏
but Harry wouldn't be Harry so he would be a totally different person. also he wouldn't be the chosen one unless Voldemort knew because he wouldn't "mark him as his equal
I think the biggest thing that would have changed is that Snape would have just plain been a happier and more sociable person. He probably would have been better liked at Hogwarts, gotten along better with his students, and had more friends.
"What if lily chose snape over James"
Me: I would be the happiest Lily X snape Shipper ever
You ain't alone.
nope
Me too
If she choose Snape, The Lily x Snape Shippers wouldnt even Exist.
The best thing in the wizarding world
Peter might not have the need to betray his friends
Don’t you dare say a bad word towards Sophie! She is a gem and can fan girl all she wants 😂
I really love Sophie :)
😂
Same i like him too 😊
Who’s Sophie?
My name is Sophie but I don't think it was was me...
Also I think that it would change everything harry might not meet hermonie or ron which means harry won’t marry Ginny
Hermione, Ron and Ginny might not even be alive (anymore) by the time they would go to hogwarts. Cause if Harry did not kill Voldemort that night, the war would have continued. And there would be no way to predict who would have lived and who would have died
he wouldn't be harry with snape as his dad it's not like snape just adopted him he might not even be a boy (which would mean that the prophesy didn't apply"
But Ginny in the movie looked like Lilly. So there is still a chance if the both arrived at Hogwarts.
Snape truly loved Lily until the day he died... it's sad. Even though he was a Death Eater and potentially put her in a bad position, he still loved her no matter what
It was lust and nothing else
"Albus... James... Snape... you were named after two of the bravest men I knew."
Just wanna tell ya that it goes more like: Albus Severus Potter you were name after two headmasters of hogwarts, one of them was a slytherin and he was the bravest man I know.
WOW .... That's kinda mean Folklore. Let Sophie dream. Dreams are free
The dark lord would have to mark him as his equal. Neville Longbottom fits the proficy too.
“Fight back! You coward, fight back!” Harry
“I am many things Potter, but I’m not a coward!” Snape
Sorry if I butchered Snapes line
You did a great job. The magic of that line isn't in the words it's self but in the idea they petray. The magic of Snape letting his grief of what he gave up and what he was doing for the "greater good."out when Harry was grieving too please don't put yourself down.
Me and my friend watching this video
Friend: but that would never happen-
Me: BUT THIS IS HARRY POTTER FOLKLORE
Lily married James so that Draco can call Harry *pottahhh*
Harry lily snape.....🦁🐍⚡️
Then James would never be happy and die alone
Son Gohan that’s sad
Who can say? Were there any other females James had the eye for?
Well James was always after Lilly no other girls and remember Sirius was the one that had girls after him
But he probably would have lived longer 🙊
I'm sure he'd have found someone eventually
Yaaaaay!!! Snily is life!!! The perfect video for Valentine's day!!! Much love!!!
lol no ,i prefer james and lily for more if severus and lily married ,i believe that they would not been together for so long
Has anyone done: What if Harry was sorted into Slytherins?
The thumbnail....
If it was Snape Jr. then their child would be SNAPE SNAPE instead of SEVERUS
Omg yass. I loved James and Lilly but Snape and Lilly were always a cute idea
I ship Jilly so hard
No views and 6 likes
Okay?
I think views and likes are calculated differently and separated
@@riverdaletales8457 People hit like as they arrived because they were SOOO glad that Dean was back. Then they views and the views moved up 10 minutes later when the video was actually viewed. My thoughts and feelings - glad to see you back Dean ! ! !
*THEBAKEEY HAS LEFT THE CHAT*
No, Snape and Lily weren’t meant to be. Snape got into the Dark Arts and was becoming a Death Eater, which Lily did not support. The final nail in the coffin was Snape calling Lily a mud blood, at which point she realized he was no longer the boy she grew up with and called friend, and wanted nothing to do with him anymore. She could be criticized for “abandoning Snape when he needed her the most”, but their friendship was quickly becoming toxic and she would likely have been seriously harmed or killed if she continued to stay. Voldemort or some other Death Eater would have likely tried to harm or kill her because she was a muggle born, as Snape probably wouldn’t have been able to even at his worst. She could even be criticized for falling for James, one of the boys who was severely bullying Snape. Truth is, James did genuinely care for Lily and changed for the better once they were together. Because of her, he changed to be a better man who became a loving boyfriend, then husband, then father. Meanwhile Snape only grew to be more cruel and spiteful, even jealous as he watched James and Lily’s relationship flourish. Snape didn’t think of Lily when he told Voldemort the prophecy. He only became a double agent for Dumbledore when he realized his actions put Lily specifically in danger. He didn’t care for James and Harry, just Lily even though he begged Dumbledore to hide them all. During Harry’s years at Hogwarts, Snape took out his vengeance on him because he was the spitting image of James except for the eyes, and only protected him because of Lily.
Pura jalada mbe
James potter era un asco de persona
great theory. in response to your question,
"harry" would never have received the invisibility cloak nor do i think he would have gotten the marauders map (unless he befriended george and fred).
The smallest of butterflies can cause the biggest reactions
Welcome back, mate!
Welcome Back!
it's great to be back..
You should do a what if Snape and Sophie video🤔
Please do that !!!
Who is Sophie
@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 Who's Lily**
Shamim Khan Harry’s mom
Who is Sophie
Neville Longbottom:
"Am I a joke to you?"
Yeah, in all seriousnes, you forgot a charachter this story would impact immensly on. There is no guarantee that Severus and Lily would concieve their child in the same timeframe as James and Lily did. There is no guarantee that Severus and Lily would thrice defy him. For all we know, they may not even have kids for few years. Maybe James would meet someone else and their child (Harry) would be the chosen one. But most likely is that chosen one burden would fell on Neville. Now, when Voldemort eventually start to hunt Longbottoms down, I assume Frank and Alice, unlike James and Lily, would accept Dumbledore's offer for him to become a secret keeper, making them safe as long as Dumbledore is alive. I assume Neville would live his life in hiding, maybe even recieve special training from early age to match up with Voldemort. Anyway, there are lot of possibilities from here on, so I will end my take right now.
I love this video man! Looovvveee it.
I like the new intro
(I think it's new)
It is
I love how the fake fanfic relationship name is causing an argument now over whether to call it Snily or Lape
Lape lol... omg dude are you lape-ing? yeah man I lape all the time
Wait if Voldemort never new of the prophecy from Snape then he couldnt mark harry as his equal.
Lily is honestly the best character in the series, even though we don't see much of her. She joined up to fight Voldemort when she was a literal teenager, gave birth to the chosen one, died protecting him (and Petunia's family with the magic), and also saved Snape from becoming evil, which motivated him to help win the war.
Happy Valentine's day!🤗
Watch out ... don't eat any unknown treats. Might have a love potion added to the chocolates
Snape should have joined Lily in Gryffindor.
no the sorting hat chooses, the students dont choose
@@ravensucks The sorting hat does take their choice in deciding.
@@AgnosticProle ikr but Snape didnt wanted to be in Gryffindor it just made him upset that Lily was in Gryffindor and he wanted to be in slytherin
You forgot to include the part about Neville being with his parents
Well done, I love that background music
PLEASE DON'T STEAL!
I'm picturing a daughter.
Red hair & dark eyes.
Sally Snape.
Because Sally means Princess.
The half blood prince would have a princess.
And she would definitely be in Griphendor because her loving mother was one.
pettagrew would've known about the prophecy and could've told voldamort and James might've agreed with pettagrew until lilly had died and would probably take the role of snape if lilly had chosen Snape instead or a mixture of Snape and Sirius and might've been put in jail because of the same event so Severus jr might go down the same role maybe a bit later down the line like a year most likely so the new "harry" would've probably been 3 instead of 2 when his parents where murdered so it wouldn't have changed much maybe "harry" would've been in Slytherin making friends with draco instead of ron and hermione
I don’t like snape but this is a very good and interesting video
How could you not be totally and completely in love with Snape? What is wrong with you? Lol
I don't love or hate Snape I have mixed feeling about him
Same, I hate him to hell and was happy when he died.
James is the best if can chose I would chose snape or James totally James.
If Snape got together with Lily, and they married each other. So would he never have become a death eater?
0:20 - 0:24 Light hearted little tease at Sophie. What a legend. (Good to see you back man.)
One thing that I really love about your videos is that you talk about these topics like they actually happened, you make it sound so real. Keep up the good work!
Someone else likely would have been made Potions Master and Head of Slytherin following Slughorn's retirement.
One thing: Snape would have not have to kill Dumbledore
I would love to see a video “how would the battle of Hogwarts gone If dumbildoor was in charge?)
Dumbledore*
Ryan Snape would've been a great name for their son if they had gotten together
Neville Longbottom would’ve been the only Chosen One and therefore would’ve become the primary protagonist
Surely the whole Chosen One & Voldy plot would've still happened though, I mean... Neville? The Prophecy and all.
Given Snape as a character, his personality and background, I'm quite sceptical that it would've been all sunshine and rainbows.
I'm so sorry that I'm so negative - I have really missed your videos and I'm so happy that you're back 🥰 this is probably the first of your What If?s that I disagree with and, as I'm a giant nerd, that is a big achievement ;) love you dude xx
If snape was harry's dad, Voldemort would already be dead.
omg yes
I thank he would be friends with Hermine and Ron. I thank Snape jr would have fallen in love with Hermine.
I think so too, heck, snape Jr would be a ravenclaw for sure. Right in the middle of the antagonism of slytherin and gryffindor. Just to placate diplomacy in the fam lol
thanks, Dean I've always wondered about this. So many things would've changed, I love these what if videos. Keep up the great work.
Dolores
I prefer Houdini Eric Snape.
The way I see it, Snape and Lily getting together would change how the original story went. It is due to Snape being a death eater that Harry was the hero. When Snape heard that Voldemort planned on killing either Harry, he informed Dumbledore about Harry being chosen. Which causes the Potter’s to go into hiding, thus caused Voldemort to double down on killing Harry as he viewed Dumbledore picking Harry as the prophetic child.
However, if Lily did end up with Snape then their child would have mostly been the one Voldemort choose. Lily would still still fit as a parent who defied three times. Snape would defy him by refusing to join him, marrying Lily(a muggleborn), and fighting with the order. Combine all that with the fact that Snape was someone he would want makes it all the more likely.
Please do a video about if Voldemort mastered the Elder Wand.
Voldormort could’ve still been taken down because just because you change his father doesn’t change the time he goes to Hogwarts so Voldormort would have found out that Harry was the chosen ones one way or another and Harry’s not the only person the prophecy was about Neville Longbottom was the other one so it could’ve been the same. But played out in a different way
In defence of Sophie
Who’s Lily ?
'Are you Lily!?'
Who’s Sophie
If Lily chose Snape over James, Harry would have no connection to the Deathly Hallows. The Invisibility Cloak was passed down from father to son. Lily was never a member of the Peverell family.
I love the energy and joy in is voice, anyone watching the video can see how happy he is to be recording again. And, scrolling through the comments, everyone of them has been liked by you, I love your dedication even when your channel was almost taken down, please never give your joys up, what ever they may be
Co you do please
What if Harry married cho?
The life of mad madam Hooch?
Mad Madam Hooch?
*SEES SNILLY IN TITLE * gives 100 likes
Short said: No Harry Potter.
*BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOM*
I feel like Harry or whatever they named him and Draco would have been good friends.
The only reason why James changed was because of Lily. Without Lily in his life he probably would have done what Pettigrew did and sacrifice Snape to have Lily. This would of course devastate Black more than losing James due to him dying as it would be a betrayal by his best friend he thought of as a brother.
Snape wasn't a bully like James was so he'd probably slip further into the Dark Arts and probably not help Dumbledore out like Snape would have.
You can shut the fuck up about James, he wasn't a shitty person his whole life. James isn't responsible for Snape being a Death Eater, in fact Snape was already prejudiced against muggles before attending Hogwarts. The only difference between James and Snape is that James grew up whereas Snape didn't, something that an obnoxious Snape fan like yourself will NEVER understand. James was a lot more braver and ten times the person than Snape ever was. Also, James never 'took' or 'stole' Lily from Snape, Snape was the one who drove Lily away. Lily CHOSE to be with James, something you Snape apologist/fans are jealous of.
The one thing I will say about Snape though is he never really changed. Harry aside, he was a jerk to most of his students, look at how he treated Neville, as far as we know Neville’s parents didn’t do anything to him and yet he’s still an ass.