Audi RS 3 vs BMW M240i xDrive Review | 4k
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 чер 2024
- Not quite direct rivals, but a question I get asked regularly, Audi RS 3 or BMW M240i?
Please SUBSCRIBE and help me reach 200k
My Instagram - / joeachilles
Adrian Flux Road and Track Insurance (Who I use for my BMW M2, M3 & 7 series) - nam01.safelinks.protection.ou...
#BMW #AUDI #BMWM240i #joeachilles
Running order of this video -
00:00 Intro
01:04 Tech specs
05:44 Testing M240i 0-60
08:03 Testing RS 3 0-60
10:51 M240i on the road
15:28 RS 3 on the road
23:12 Conclusion
Thanks for watching as always, see you at at the next video!
Instagram - / joeachilles
Facebook - / joeachillesc. .
Twitter - / joeachilles
Website - www.joeachilles.com - Авто та транспорт
Hope you enjoy this one guys 🎬
Big thanks once again to my buddy Andy 🙏
Next video will be my 1st look at the M3 Touring 👌
Try without Andy in the car maybe another 0.2 seconds off
Wish ppl would test the 0-60 without revving and launching it like who sits at the lights revving for take off. Be more interesting to see what these cars can do from a dig just stomping on the pedal and going.
How does the RS3 compare to the new M2 you drove
Ohhhh spicy. Loving the recent content. Would you consider a longer discussion about the car industry at the moment. It seems like it’s heating up? BMW especially…
Joe has become a less biased automobile review journalist on UA-cam. He deserves a column in Car Magazine, Whatcar or Car & Driver. You all agreed?
Love the fact you made it clear it wasn’t apples with apples but obviously understand why, fantastic video thank you so much
Cheers Craig, bet people will still call me out for it though 😂👌
Actually made it clear twice in the video, so I hope people got the clarification!😄
The M240i is on my wish list, it looks gorgeous.
Great package for the money 👌
They do look fricking awesome and go like stink. Wouldn't swap mine out for the RS3....
Joe you need to do a video review of Auto ID’s M240 with the Jb4 tune on it. Would love to hear how u compare his one to the RS3 then
I’m thinking of selling my AMG and going for the m240i. I went to my local BMW dealer to see it in person and it looks absolutely powerful and mighty even though it was only a 220i. The M240i looks even more beastly.
Just swapped my M240i xdrive for the RS3 after an epic test drive! Sounds like a lambo@@leccybadger
One of the best comparison vids I've ever seen. No BS races that are flawed by who launches first, just three timed back-to-back launches in each car to see what they can really do.
Continuing to churn out the best content Joe, congrats buddy, for me you're up there now with Shmee and Cars With Luke on content and picture\audio quality, keep up the great work.
This review was very engaging and well put together. Kudos to you Joe as I did not even need to fast forward the video. The 25mins went by so 💨
Thank you Joe, this is an amazing video and got all the info i needed as i am actually comparing them. Please make more video to compare similar models, really interesting!
Great review, thank you! I am a happy owner of a fully specd RS3 Y hatch back since January. And as an old petrol head who owned too many cars I can only share your excitement about the RS3 suspension. I never experienced a car which could do the comfortable cruiser to mountain/backcountry road racer stretch as brilliantly as the compact Audi does. It has to be experienced to be believed. I actually prefer to drive it over my 991.2 convertible.
Do you have the fixed or adaptive suspension on your RS3?
Joe I’m just reading through your subscribers comments. Great comments, all valid points which is great seeing the passion and knowledge. Another well received video of yours buddy, great work Joe 👌so much better than chauffeuring. 🙏👍
Thank you Joe and Andy for this video. I wasn't expecting the RS3 to perform this well. But then again I believe if it was between the M235i Gran Coupe and the RS3 Limousine, the RS3 will take the day anyway. The B58 has so much tuning potential but so does the RS3. I really wouldn't have known about the excellent suspension setup in the RS3 if I hadn't watched your video Joe!
Great video Joe! Love this format ❤🔥
Brilliantly done once again Joe's the man 🙏❤️💜
Hi Joe love and greetings from Toronto Canada u did such a nice comparison test although it wasn't proper test bcoz one is proper RS model and other is M lite model actually u mentioned that too but u have ur own unique way of doing which I like most u never let us down although these days u r not making many videos but whenever u do u do excellent work I can't understand why u r getting more subscribers u deserve it mate
Superb video Joe! Not driven the M240i but I can wholeheartedly agree with everything that you said about the RS3! It’s worlds apart from the previous generation that I had although I’d definitely rather have the very dated but brilliantly put together interior out of that car. I think the new M2 is going to be brilliant if this M240i is anything to go by
Great work 🍻
Great review Joe! Gap is closer between m car and m lite but you’re right, brakes and steering feel is where you notice the difference!
Great review Joe as always. I appreciate they aren’t a like for like in terms of RS vs M Lite but not sure I can forgive Audi with the slide in interior quality for a ~£60k car. If it had the same interior quality as the previous generation then I think the extra cash would be worth it but personally I’d save £10k and go for the BMW
Brilliant as always Joe👍👍
Nice review, also one of the first to review the m2 , been a good week
Finally the edit is here! Nick's video held you back only so much 👍
😂😂😂 Nick is my idol, love that guy 🙌
Same! There's a few in the business that just bring unbiased quality reviews and many hours of entertainment. Yourself and volkswizard are definitely up there with Nick
*Two stunning cars against each other I'd take any of them* 👀
Great review as always! You mentioned you’d be interested in an RS3 if prices weren’t so high; do you mean instead of your M3? A comparison of the two would be interesting.
I have the M240i, i looked at the RS3 but the waiting time was too long and the £10k premium didn't end up sitting well. A whole 20% more in cost is a lot at this range. £60k+ with options is getting too near Porsche territory. Also, you're not going to get any discount on an RS3, whereas I got about 7.5% off my M240, meaning a well specced model came in at a chunk under £50k, so £15k cheaper!
Great review! I very much enjoyed the video! It's actually a rather surprising result as I have just read a comparison test done by Car Magazine arriving at the exact opposite conclusion. Super interesting that different journalists would rate the same cars so differently. I would naturally assumed that RS3 would be a more engaging car than a M240i. Can't wait for M2 though!
Great review Joe 👍
Brilliant video Joe 👌
A fantastic and honest review from you the BMW fan boy.I also like the look of the RS3 better than the M2.I just wish I could afford one.
I'm going to possibly buy the RS3 when I can pay msrp for one, and not marked up like crazy!
M240i is a dream car of mine now, only behind the Z8 and i8!
Brilliant comparison. To me, the conclusion came as quite a surprise. Thanks, Joe.
Great video Joe 👌🙏the M240i looks great I can’t wait for the M2 it’s going to be crisp! 👌👏
Awesome vid fella, loving both these cars right now. Shame the M240i doesn’t have better steering feel I agree but what a car for the money in this modern day.
Brilliant review, surprising results!
Nice video mate!
Fancy seeing you here!
Joe nice video!😀 I have to ask, which watch do u have? It seems like Casio?🤔
Brilliant thorough and honest vid as ever, Joe. As a real fan of the brand, it would be very easy for you just to say you like the BMW best.
I’ve considered both and have gone for the M240i (on order) for the following reasons. An equivalent spec RS3 is as you say £10k more, the interior material quality is as you say a bit low rent and I think the RS is more likely to attract the wrong sort of attention. In addition I don’t want a hardcore car more what I’d describe as an enthusiast’s luxury car- I therefore think the BMW is the best car for me.
But ultimately they’re both great cars and we should celebrate that their respective manufacturers have seen fit to build them. We’re all different and we all like different things. Let’s enjoy watching, reading and debating about them while we all can. 2030 is not far away..
Honest question, why not go for a previous gen m240i? Same engine, same transmission, adaptive suspension, lighter and a better looking car. Not to mention way cheaper
@@marked_one Various reasons although mainly because it’s not a daily I plan to keep it for a long time so want the latest model with the best tech, new 3-series style curved screen etc. in it so it’s as future proof as possible
M240 with a set of Ohlins or similar could be the sweet spot. I have Birds Bilstein dampers on my m140 and it's amazing how much of a difference an upgraded suspension set up can make.
Bravo dear sir bravo...great video as allways ...unique opinion as a bmw fan boy and multiple bmws owner 👍
Hi Joe what apps u use on phone for test results any link thanks great video.
you are very nice !
Great test
I subscribed to your channel
Too early to say your thoughts on the preproduction M2 vs RS3? Appreciate the unbiased review despite being a BMW man. Great vid and effort.
Been waiting for this…
Hope it didn't disappoint!
Cannot wait to see the comparison, new M2 vs RS3.
It the effortlessness that the 240 comes with that I want, I believe that is a sign for further potential
Personally I’d take the 240 , in my opinion the b58 is the better engine with the more potential for tuning , rs3 is a great car but I think overpriced.
Now when you have tried the prototype of the upcoming m2, would you say it’s on the same level as the rs3 or maybe even better?
Joe great in-depth comparison. You gotta check out Carwow where Matt raced with a tuned RS3 hitting the 1/4 mile in 9.9 sec
Hey Joe, with the RaceBox mini, which tape did you use to transfer between different cars?
Excellent review Joe & Andy. Very balanced call. As previously mentioned you were fair to both car manufacturers. Having recently taken delivery of an Audi A3 Vorsprung totally agree Audi cost cutting on interior quality and although my car is the very average engine to have the same trim effectively in R/S is not acceptable. BMW have a much higher quality interior but the petrol engine range was not as good in my opinion. Looking forward to the next video👍🏻
Good on ya for having S.Vettel holding the speed logic app for u
This video says "4k" in the title but for me there is only a 1080p option. Anyone else have this? Or is there something wrong on my end? In any case, great video again Joe, very nice and complete comparison. This is exactly the content why I like this channel so much. Had the chance to drive the M240i recently as a loaner because my car was in the shop. It is a fantastic machine, really fun to drive, an animal when you push it but really subdued at the same time when you want it to. It goes around corners like a go-cart. It pained me having to give it back when my car was fixed. Might have to get one as my next car. Thanks for the video!
Videos on UA-cam first upload on the lower qualities and will introduce the higher qualities later on. After a couple of minutes most quality options will be available, but it’s common to have to wait an hour or two for 4K to be available
@@slideways8022 Ah, I see. I (obviously) did not know this, thanks for the info!
Interesting you say the RS3 has good steering feel as opposed to other reviews I’ve seen. Seems like the RS3 sounds better from the drivers seat but I do like the glorious straight 6 sound from the outside. How do they compare in rolling acceleration test?
Thanks Joe, as usual excellent content. I have been researching for some time on whether I buy the m240i or the new RS3. I recently pulled the trigger and have ordered the RS3 - 12 month wait though. Your feedback from previous videos and this on helped shape my decision. Ultimately the better sound, handling and practicality of 4 doors has made me go with the Audi. For me, the way the car makes you feel is paramount - and the sound is a huge part of that. I am located in Australia. Thanks again and keep up the great work - love your videos.
I’m in Aus too did you test drive the M240?
@Tim Pullens I’m also from Australia . I’ve ordered a RS3 sportback as well 2 days ago,and was told waiting time between 12-15 months.
Awesome review 🤍
Quick question: What measuring method do you use? With rollout?
RS3 is just badass. Would be my choice.
But at the same time it can behave smooth, matured, comfy. That's what makes it unique.
Great video 👍
Thank you 👊
Is your M240i equipped with the bigger (374mm) brake discs? You think that helps with the brake power / problem you mentioned?
Interesting review. Like you, Whatcar mag preferred the RS3, but Car Magazine went for the M240i, declaring it the more engaging car! Either way, both great cars.
But is the RS3 now overrated , after all the prices it’s going for is Porsche and e63 prices which should be now be it’s comparisons .
Cheers, i'm def more with What Car? on this one 👌
Interestingly Car Magazine actually much preferred the steering on the M240i and sound of the B58 over the Audi.
As an M240i owner I choose to believe Car Magazine. 😅
The funny fact is that we can argue about which we prefer between an Audi RS and a Bmw 'lite-M', but imagining the opposite (real M vs Audi S, M2 vs S3 for example) is fun just to say.
This shows the level of competition between Audi and Bmw.
@@KUDANTOURAGE rubbish. It’s comparisons are the cars in its same category and price range. What they’re fetching in this era is due to shortages and demand.
Now that you ve driven both this and the 2023 m2, which one would you say is the better drivers car?
This has been killing me trying to figure this out - how do you specifically get the seats shown in the M240i in this video? I know you can spec the blue contrast stitching, but how do you spec the M logo up by the headrest? Is this only available outside the U.S? Does it automatically come with the shadowline or premium package?
Close call between Mercedes and BMW for best infotainment, would love to see you compare the A45s with the RS3 Joe
Hi Joe, when will the 7 series video be coming out?
I’ve been waiting years for you to speak highly of a Audi!!😂👍
I think fans of both brands can say this was a fair, detailed and engaging review. Well done, Joe! BMW for the commute and Audi for the weekend!
Thank you buddy 👊
In Germany the round stearing wheel is an option. I don't like the flat bottom steering wheel in the S3 or RS3 because the airbag and buttons are weird. And I wanted the adaptive cruise control which you can't get with the flat bottom steering wheel.
Great video, but have you seen the new interior for the M240i? Gone are those nice controls and stick, hello touchscreen and cheap gear selector. It's not a surprise all the press demo cars have the old one...
Hi Joe! Excellent video and review overr both car, I have test both car for some reason my heart went toward the rs3 but both are cracking motor. However after j done extensive research.. the bmw m240i has been dyno'd and was touching 400bhp. I assuming bmw has lied about the power figures. Would be interesting if you could dyno the m240i to see the true power figure.
Can you do a review on the CLA 45s Joe?
Hey Joe, I saw this before in your videos, the m240i does not have adaptive suspension as standard. It is a £500 extra. Otherwise thanks for the content, love your videos as usual.
Both these cars are amazing and on fire 🔥!!!!
Agree!
Hi Joe. Thx for this video. I have done some research... No luck so far. What would be the extra money per year if owning a m240 compared to 220i? Let's say for an average 10k miles per year. I am doing very little spirited driving. Greetings from France.
Here in Canada a dealer is not allowed to sell a car above list price however it doesn;t mean that can't equip it with spupid options to get her sold.
Any date for a 2023 M2 review Joe? Love the video.
Will be circa end of March buddy 👊
I'd love to have either lol....I feel this RS3 is one of the best looking cars ever made. Taking into account the markups where I live and everything else, I'd take the M240i I do despise the new 'truck' looking 2 series though). B58 is such a modern marvel and the aftermarket for it is insane. Great content, would be blessed to own either of these gorgeous machines.
Joe you drove the pre-prod M2, how do you rate it vs RS3 in terms of feel/fun to drive?
Curious to see if you get any response! I didn't when I asked the same question after he recently drove the new M2!
I love RS models all of them obviously but the 2 series especially this one and the M2 are perfect cars in my eyes
Both are the real hot Cars in the Compact-Class! We´ll see in 2023 the S3 and the M2 ...
Joe… another incredible video. My day gets better seeing you upload a new video. QUESTION: Can you justify the extra £££ for the G80 M3. A new M3 xDrive is slightly out of my price range, however a clean used one is. Do you think it’s worth stretching the budget and going for the M3. I know they are in different leagues but I feel there’s no one more qualified to answer this other than yourself. Cheers from down under 🇦🇺
I had an S3 from 2018 to 2021 and an RS3 from 2021 ubtil now. I just upgraded to a brand new M3 comp xdrive (118k € in Germany). As much as i love Audi and the 2.5 5-pot, the M3 is on a whole new level. 3.6 seems fast? I am clocking 3.2 with my M3. 100-200 km/h = 7,3 seconds.
Go for the M3 mate 👍🏻
@@haviiithelegogunner907 that’s awesome. I currently have a 2020 Golf R 7.5. Love it such a great all rounder but my wife can have it, and then I’ll upgrade. Glad to hear you are loving the M3. Can’t wait to get one
Of course Joe, you said the steering feel is a little bit numb in the Bimmer, but you are sitting on the wrong side of the car. It's a German car and it's supposed to be sitting on the left side of the car. Again, a nice comparison video.
One thing I've noticed that the brakes on the bmw's I've had are shite. I had an M140i and now have an M340i and the brakes are awful. Just don't have the stopping power. They're really mushy and take ages to stop the car rather than biting and being sharp
Epic video 😎
Wait, you've got an M240i for 3 months and you've not mentioned the best feature? You now have identical machinery to Pete and Dan (Petrolhead Tours fame) for the next time you meet them on the road! Definitely the cars best selling point IMHO ... Will be interesting to find out whether it's any harder on its tyres on tour vs the M2 Comp's. The weight and softer setup might play a part in eating through tyres a dab quicker
I’m not sure if you’re prepared to say, but the roads you drive on look familiar, what part of the world do you typically test?
Brilliant video, Top Gear beckons.
Great video although I wish you would measure 1-100 mph, or ideally standing quarter mile with trap speed. The latter will tell you so much more than these blink-of an-eye 0-60 times which are all about traction and the transmission.
I fund these myself and doing 0-100mph or 1/4 mile requires massive budget which I don't have.
Great review Joe as a owner of a new m240i I agree it’s a great daily car. The balance of performance and comfort is fantastic. I came from a Merc A45 which my wife did not like. Like most people I think the steering is lifeless and the brake pedal soft.
Your wife 😂😂😂😂😂
Wait for the M2!
The trouble is nowadays is theres so much choice of flipping good cars , choosing one over the other is not easy . They are all bloody good!
Could someone tell me how the driving experience of S3 compare to the RS3? Audis are not known to be the most engaging of cars, is RS3 just a rare exception?
I testdrove both and the BMW is a true split personality and therefore the BMW is capable to satisfy both types of drivingmood. This is my pick.
Cannot wait for the m2
Thanks for the confirmation the RS3 is a great driver.
Great viewing
After driving both the m240i was it for me. 10K less, no difference in Performance, More Special Look and an Interior a Level above rs3. Honestly Interior of the Audi is a real dealbreaker. 82K Price in Euro and Look and Feel of a VW Polo inside…
But honestly everyone says the suspension, handling, engine sound, and steering feel are all better in the RS3! I'm a BMW guy, and imo your getting the better driver's car in the RS3, but it cost more of course!
@@germanengineering204 I disagree with Suspension and Engine Sound. But Yeah RS3 is better handling and mutch more „hardcore“. But as I said: Coming into that cabine killed my vibe for the Car every fuckin time. 😁🙈
@@IngmarStadelmann let's be honest sir! This RS3 was said to have as good of a suspension set up as a 150k M5CS that's insane!😀
@@germanengineering204 It is. I got a e63s and it doesnt felt better then this.😆 Maybe because of Winter-Tires.
@@IngmarStadelmann According to this review! He mentioned that the ride quality whether in sport or comfort mode is exceptional, and is on par with the M5 CS did you miss that?
It's such a shame that BMW are putting the hideous looking iDrive 8 in the M240i from July builds onwards. I'm seriously considering cancelling my order (placed in March) as it won't be built until late this year or even early 2023. IDrive 7 dashboard looks far better in my opinion. Great content as always 👍
I ordered mine two months ago and it just went into production yesterday as a 22’ model (vin verified). 23’s won’t arrive til end of Fall at the soonest per my dealer (biggest bmw dealer in California). I’m not sure where you live but that’s my experience.
@@Bimmer_Bill I ordered almost 3 months ago at a UK dealer and they advised at least a 10 month wait at that point. My order also hasn't gone into production as yet, so it's highly likely I'd end up with a MY23 unfortunately. Dealer has said they cannot confirm either way until it reaches the next step.
@@MW_1981 sorry to hear that
Wow the BMW binnacle and instrumentation looked so much better than the current one which has a giant cheap screen.
Still can’t believe that Audi doesn’t offer the flat bottom alcantara steering wheel with the colored details in UK like they do in mainland Europe… would definitely help that interior.
Been trying to get either a RS3 or an M2. RS3 is 10k over and M2 is 15k. I just don't know if I'm willing to do either and it really sucks.
can’t go wrong with either car
Bearing in mind the BMW is almost 10k cheaper i wonder what performance mods could be added to bring up that 370hp. Id imagine fully spec the m240i add a few suspension mods and a remap and it would make an amazing rival for the RS3 and all within the base price of a RS3
Very good point, although I believe it would still lack feel compared to the RS 3, Audi have really done something special with it 👌
Stage 2 bootmod since it already has the upgraded hpfp will give nearly 500bhp. Stage 2 audi RS3 will be slightly less. Once you throw hybrid turbos on them both (cars) and E85/Meth etc they can both make over 700bhp easily.
I got one what you wanna know m240i ua-cam.com/video/BajqvaOnDzg/v-deo.html
The M240i is pushing more than BMW's quoted figures out of the box, certainly been a couple measured at nigh on 400bhp.
@@leccybadger id be interested to see a new m240i on the dyno
The flat bottom steering wheel is an option delete actually.....