A Thousand Years - Doctor/River (River's Timeline) | Doctor Who
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 кві 2012
- Doctor/River is one of the only couples for whom this over-used song can really, truly work.
What I wanted to do was go at it from River's timeline, since we pretty much always just see the Doctor's POV. So after the initial scene (the song is wedding themed), we start with Let's Kill Hitler and go on from there. The main eps I wanted to focus on were LKH, The Wedding of River Song, and Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead, and so each refrain is another stage in River's timeline.
I initially had more about the diary in the vid, but it didn't quite fit. I did, during the way, way too long period of time I spent on this, realize that the end of Forest of the Dead is pretty much a perfect encapsulation of them, together. Her diary and his screwdriver, surrounded by all the adventures there could ever be.
Best. Couple. Ever.
P to the S people, this is the best D/R vid I've ever seen. And it's on vimeo and you should watch it: vimeo.com/32695024
As a further P.S., if there's a clip you don't recognize, it's from the minisodes on the s6 DVDs. Buy the DVDs and watch them. Or search for 'Night and the Doctor' or something like that. "River, we've got the wrong fish is" is from that, which seems to be the main thing people ask about. - Розваги
laughing through tears..."River we've got the wrong fish!"
just shows how much he could relax around her
i thought he said wrong bitch 😂
What episode is this ?
God I love River!!!! The only woman dynamic enough to go toe to toe with the Doctor.
Same
THIS IS HURTING MY RIGHT NOW, I ONLY HAVE ONE HEART. STOP DAMAGING IT.
one day I better fucking see mATT EATING ALEX'S FaCE I'm sorry that's innapropriate, Doctor eating River face, I'm crying.
I want a River Song spin off series.
Joy Bignell Me too T.T
The magic school bus
I was scrolling through these comments thinking "i need a river song spin off RIGHT NOW!!' and then i saw your comment😂 great minds think alike!
@@BraydonDCrump Well you're 100% NOT wrong, but also.... that's just.... I mean, you're comparing oranges and oranges. But. Still.
I agree!!!
The BIGGEST evidence of there love is the look on his after she says, "You'll be the death of me." She says it without realizing the pain is caused. But he's look is borderline sick
When my OH and I see moments like that in Doctor Who we both exclaim, "THAT'S face acting!"
Another example is when River Song tells Amy & Rory who she is... Tory's face is a picture.
+blipdriver i know
+blipdriver that's when in the Christmas Special she says he doesn't love her, I was SO SHOCKED
The look on the Doctors face in Husband's of River Song, the look on the Doctors face during her speech.
@@SelenaMulan You could see the lie on her expression, or at least we could... but the Doctor couldn't.
Moffat I think made a great decision on the library scene. Because though we whovians didnt really feel anything at the time. Whovians rewatch episodes all the time. He took that into consideration I think when coming up with river song. And thats what makea it so glorious. Thats what makes this so FANTASTIC. Rewatching and feeling new feelings. Seeing new connections. Doctor who is a brilliant show.
I'm a very recent fan and after watching The Husbands of River Song I rewatched The LIbrary and cried even more. Interesting how Alex didn't think River went beyong her orginal two episode arc but she delivered with such perfection of emotion and heartbreak we'd feel as we watch her come full circle. Alex Kingston deserves all the awards as Matt does as well when 11 gave his goodbye to River in The Name of The Doctor.
You know, I had a hard time with Amy, and sometimes even Rorey, but River... River was the best thing to come out of their storyline.
THIS LIKE MY 100th TIME WATCHING YET IN THE FIRST FIVE SECONDS I BALL UP AND CRY!!
I know it was, I liked them both, but she is my favorite it of the three of them. Mom and Dad pissed me off sometimes
I also had a hard time with Amy (the character, not myself lol). But I wish we saw more of Rory. He was so funny/cute/you kinda felt sorry for him.
I love Matt and Alex on screen together. The two of them had such great chemistry and played wonderfully well off each other. If they can't do a special Dr. who episode together then hopefully they can work together in something else! FANTASTIC video!!!
Even people who don't ship River and The Doctor must after watching this.
*sobs in guilty*
I'd also like to think that on my wedding day my future husband will hand me a tardis notebook during our vows and say "I vow to have FANTASTIC adventures with you and make stories worth writing." I will cry so hard at that moment.
The first time I saw the Library episodes; I knew she would be someone important. The last speech she gives, and I was right
I didn't feel much when i saw the library/Forest of the dead when i first saw it, because i was into the idea of the 10/Donna ship, and then during the entire series of the 11th doctor, as i got to know and love more and more about River, i sometimes curse Steve Moffat for making regret not feeling so sad at her 'death' during the first viewing of Forest of the dead and became hopeful at 'The Name of the Doctor' when i saw her tombstone at Trenzalore, and the doctor saying he always, sees, hears, and feels her, and it hurts him. I became hopeful that she'll be freed from the library, and both will become Linear partners, and not the timey wimey, time traveling lovers who keep staying a step ahead or behind the other. Maybe it'll happen with River and Capaldi aka the 12th Doctor who knows. If they try to make any episode that involves them on a date to the Singing Towers, i'm sure that millions will cry knowing that this is the last time the Doctor will be with River Song based on her timeline before the library.
I cryed Like a Baby When I saw the Forest of the Dead and She died Cuz u could see that was truly inlove with the doctor and He knew it deep in his heart as well, Ever since the first time I seen River She has Been my fav Charcarter in the show I will be sad if after the 11th(matt Smith) Doctor Dies if we don't see anymore RiverSong.
Kaykay brown just watch this please, /watch?v=gv0Q_zxOSCE
i can't tell you what it is, Spoilers, you need to see it, it'll make you smile.
I have Have watched it A thousand times it my fav Doctor Who Music Video off All Time!, Love this as Much as Rose is still Around with the Song Still Around -3OH!3 u should check that one too its like a FanEpisoade .music video
When I saw Silence in the library I was like "Oh thats one of those things where they just bring someone in to make it intresting but then you never see them again" But after I actually did not reconize her so when he said "River?"
I jumped up and down
Nosara Snow I completely agree, i never felt bad when River died the first time, but when i see that episode now i cry the whole time, because i know what it coming and it slightly breaks my heart. Then when the doctor was on Trensilor, and saw he i started balling all over again. She is my favorite character ever.
A universe, and 13 lifetimes better love story than twilight!
by infinity
+Joe DeMarco Times invinity!!
Never forget that we see River Song only because of the power of the Doctor's love for her.
"I have died every day waiting for you." Damn, that line gets me every time.
This is the best love story in Doctor Who... I don't like the Rose/Ten's love... I mean Rose is okay to have a Ten's clone, even though he's not The Doctor just as long as he looks like him. But River, no. River is in love with The Doctor, what he truly is. She loved him with his different faces and personality. It is so perfect, this is true love. Not just sexual attraction. Well, beautiful video !
Naerys. yes my friend THE BEST LOVE STORY IN DOCTOR WHO!!!!!
I disagree that the human Ten was not really The Doctor. What makes a person? Anyway... other than that, agree with everything u said about River. I think in River, the Doc finally met his match. All his other companions he loves but sees as sort of... grandkids/students/"You fascinating, inspirational puny humans with your short lives!" River has been the only one so far in the new series that can truly keep him on his toes.
And as we see in The Husbands of River Song, she doesn't expect him to love her back. She thinks it would be unreasonable, and somehow Rose though was demandable?!
Chris same here for me it's the same
Clara and doctor cloctor
notice when the doctor is kissed he is akward but when river kisses him its so adorable he doesn't move
"River, we got the wrong fish!" I don't care how sad the video is, I will laugh at that line 100% of the time.
It's 5 years later and I still come back to this video. It honestly doesn't feel like it's been that long. Still love the doctor and rivers relationship even after all this time
People ask me why i think river is better than rose and its pretty simple, I could imagine river being with any other version of the doctor and it still fit. Hartnell through capaldi i could still see them have the perfect chemistry unlike rose who I think would only fit with 9/10/11. just a humble whovians opinion though :)
Caleb90ex well try to Match river with jodie whittaker
Since River married Cleopatra too i really don't think it would be a problem to her to stay with jodie's doctor too XD anyway i think River story is closed/ended and we won't see them together :)
than a guestion is river fit 13 :D
I never liked rose. Never saw there spark. However i loved river.
I don't remember where I read this or who said it, but to quote them: "Rose loves 10. River loves the Doctor. Big difference."
This video is amazing. It is a perfect way to describe them, two time travelers going in opposite directions, absolutely in love with one another, and it breaks my heart because River was so afraid of looking at him and having him not know who she is, and that's what she got in the end, a Doctor who has no idea who she is, and it killed her.
this is painful to watch its so beautiful
I just can't stop watching that video it. Made me cry like a baby
me 2
And I've often wondered, how did it all start?
Who found out that nothing can capture a heart
Like a melody can?
Well, whoever it was, I'm a fan
- ABBA
I love the Doctor and River. Their story is so sad and funny and happy, I would've loved to see their relationship being explored a bit further before they had gotten married in the story. Definitely hope to see River in the upcoming season, just give me a story that justifies her presence and I'll be happy.
Actually there are a couple mini episodes (first night, last night, and kind of sort of bad night) that show them having an adventure. It's kind of all in the same period after their wedding. (And right before rivers death ;-;)
But it is sad they didn't have adventures before the wedding...
Kat Plays I know, I did see them, they were pretty awesome. I just sort of wanted their relationship evolve a little more in the actual series because wife is kind of a huge deal, you know? But you take what you can get.
blackdice1001 In the impossible astronaut when river has a scene with rory she does mention the doctor visiting her as a "young girl" knowing everything about her maybe 11 or capaldi or another doctor will visit her earlier in her timeline.
3:34 kills me. Every time. It's all in there - the way they were always waiting, the way they were slowly losing each other, the fact she died the first time he met her, all in that one line.
This song is perfect for this
I just thought of poor Amy...
First she has a crush on the doctor.
After the doctor fixed her relationship she finds out she is pregnant in about the last day of her pregnancy.
Her child is taken away and brainwashed.
She finds out her childhood friend actually IS her daughter, so she named her daughter after daughter after all...
Her daughter marries the doctor.
THAT must be confusing.
And I'm his...
Mother in law 😐
I started crying instantly, I feel like River could have been in SO MUCH MORE and SO MUCH LONGER!! Bring her back Steven! *runs off crying*
So sad. Words do not describe how my heart feels for River. The pain she must be feeling in loving someone who just grow farther and farther away is so... Shattering.
it's been so many years (a thousand? lol), i haven't watched dw for so long, and i still keep coming here to bawl my eyes out
thank you
also river is the most magnificent being ever created and i will fight for her till my last breath
Crying wasn't on today's agenda, but you just ripped out my heart sooooo...
Please re-cut this with "The Husbands of River Song" added!
I know, still can't believe she didn't know; when she says he didn't love her, my mouth dropped open. It's so obvious he does
I cry from start to finish at how rapturously beautiful this is. Your love for the story and characters is here in spades.
I heard this playing in a shop and I almost cried because of this.
Oh God, don't cry, don't cry, oh God......
*cries*
I feel like I need to tell you, in case I haven't already, that this is my all-time FAVORITE Doctor/River video. I agree about the song: it fits them and few others. Thank you for the time and effort you put into this!
This made me tear up by the end. So lovely and fitting for the two of them. I have to say I like River more the more we see her.
This video has convinced me to use this song for my first dance at my wedding. Still the best River fan video I've ever seen.
Whovian
E
D
D
I
N
G
I have literally watched this at least 20 different times and I cry every time ngl...This is my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE Yowzah edit!!!! I love this so much.. UGHHH
I think "I have died everyday waiting for you" wouldn't that fit Rory more if you know what I mean? xD
Omg lololol
i don't think i have cried so hard...i'm still trying to recover...The Doctor and River Song the greatest love in all of time and space
I keep watching this from time to time and since I'm a first round Doctor Who watcher who's in the middle of Season 5 right now, this keeps getting better and better. Absolutely beautiful, brings tears to my eyes.
Alice Burton, thank you, again, for this perfect compilation. I have watched it so many times, since seeing it the first time a few years ago. It touches my soul, every time. So beautifully done. You capture the emotion and love of these two amazing characters.
lol "River you got the wrong fish!" love it! This song really suits the Doctor and River's story. You did a beautiful job at showing their love for each other. :)
Hey in the library when river dies .... everyone who was uploaded by the library was brought back to life by her sacrifice... who's to say river cant just be redownloaded??hmm?? I mean obviously their physical bodies disintigrated otherwise how could they live in a computer right??.... so that means their minds were put into reconstructed bodies... just a few buttons and BOOM!! New River Song!!... i hope this is true because otherwise my brain is playing cruel sick jokes on me!!
Yes, that can happen. I honestly think that the Doctor did that.
Thinking about it just makes me fangirl so hard... i honestly love the Doctor and river together!! i always wonder if 13 and river would work, since he is so different from 12.
But if 11 did that he would be crossing his own time line, which would create a paradox that would rip the universe apart... stupid timey wimey stuff!!.... and also if he did manage to stop her 10 would have to sacrifice himself and then the doctor would be gone ... dead.. kaput :(
Eileen Adams WHYYYYY
Laura Beth T i KNOW HOW YOU FEEL!! I really just want river back at this point!! i would love to see how 13 and her pan out!! :(
"Hippie"
"Archeologist"
40 seconds in and tears are welling up in my eyes. I love this vid. The song works so well with this relationship between River and The Doctor.
i demand the creator of this video pays to remove the flooding from my home
xD Oh Blimy! LMAO
I didn't want to ship them but I guess it couldn't be helped. Lovely video!
This fits SO much better than it does with Twilight. Plus this pairing is 1,000x better
I LOVE DOCTOR WHO AMD I LOVE THIS SONG!!! MY TWO FAVORITE THINGS BEING PUT TOGETHER
When River met 10 during his era. The line "One day we will meet and he will have no idea who I am, and I think its going to kill me" From 11s era made me sob into a ball! Ah! This show is incredible and Sad and humorous and wonderous! She really was HIS wife!
So much better than Doctor/Rose
True 🐾
NO D:
timeladie
True
Quinn Roux I love 11/River but there is no need to degrade Rose and 10's relationship. They were best friends and eventually that friendship turned into love. There was virtually no lust involved, which is very rare in today's shows and movies. They clicked so perfectly together and were just happy to be in each other's company, and it was absolutely beautiful. The trust and understanding between them was part of what made their bond so unique. As I said before, there was no lust, just a genuine love and care for each other. That to me is the best kind of love.
So please, don't try to bring a ship up by putting another down. 11/River is by no doubt beautiful, but 10 and Rose will always be fantastic.
I loved how they planned River's timeline way back in 10's time, in Silence in the Library.
Really! This is perfect!! I love that!❤️ love story of River and Doctor is the best!!Best couple forever!!❤️❤️i'm little bit addicted of River and Doctor 😅
Perfect, just perfect
I want River back!
I've listened and watched this several times and the editting and sound are supurb. Thank you for this. It brings a tear to my eye ever time I listen
Watching this for the first time and I'm SOBBING. Beautiful video! I miss them!
To many feels I ended up wrapped in a blanket blubbering
Who said River didn't visit future Doctor's? She can be in the following seasons if they can come up with more stories.
Absolutely brilliant! I love how it fit with both the song and her timeline perfectly. Well done!
So sentimental. I loved it! I cried so much. The pictures and music are perfect. Thank you.
They are so cute !! >w
"Doctor/River is one of the only couples for whom this over-used song can really, truly work." Truest statement EVER. You've taken two things I don't particularly like...this song (both for it's ties to Twilight and the fact that it never FITS for the never-ending parade couples it's inevitably used for) and Doctor/River, and you've squished them together into something I really REALLY like. It shouldn't be possible but here we are. No flashy editing...just simple and beautiful.
I don´t know how many times I´ve watched this video... ut you have no idea how much I love it
I cry every time I watch this. I love it so much. Please never delete it. ♡
Can't wait to see her with Capaldi this christmas!
Wait, that's real!? AHhhhhhhhh.
+heinekencobra wait what! I haven't seen them yet, SPOIIIIOERS! Don't mind tho
capaldi is a bitch boy
I know Alex Kingston will probably never see this but there is a small chance so I just want to say thank you. Everytime I watch a video with you in it makes me happy even if for the briefest moment it still makes a difference. But most of all you make me feel stronger, you stopped me doing the most ridiculous and stupid things that I hope never cross my mind again. I wldnt be the person I am now if it wasn't for you.
Thank you Alex Kingston xxx
I'm posting this on as many of her videos as possible so (in the small chance that she will see it) she will understand that she is an amazing woman and she has touched so many lives.
This is beautiful. So well done and a perfect song to describe their relationship. Loved it!!!
I just cant stop watching this video. Its beautiful. Very well done.
People who don't river song and eleventh or rose nine/ten need their heads examining and as for the fans who don't like the snogging in Tardis I say get real already!
Getting threatened with a copyright takedown, so sorry if this disappears soon. :(
😨😰😱😓 this is my favorite video
It is not copyright
***** just put the song in the description and that's not copyright
***** Nooooooo, this is my favorite video!!
***** I've been watching this video repeatedly since it first went up!
This is so beautiful that it makes me weep. Thank you for all you put into it.
Thank you so, so very much for this video. I finished rewatching all seasons yesterday (I was sick and had a looot of time) and just had to rewatch Forest of the Dead / Silence in the Library, and I needed this video so bad! I've been crying all the time, River is such an amazing character and I can't believe she's dead for good now in the timeline.. I still have hopes we see her again in a later episode. Although River just belongs to 11, they are so cute together...
I watched the 11th doctor before I watched the 10th so when River died in that episode she appears for the first time it was even worse for me :,(
"THIS MEANS YOUR GOING TO ALWAYS KNOW HOW IVE BEE GOING TO DIE"
+The Doctor & The Tardis I know
everytime I watch this i cry
I love River and this is one of the best videos I've seen of them, especially after the season ender a few days ago which broke my heart. Thank you so much.
Beautifully done. The River and Doctor arc has been my favorite part of the last several years & its very nice that you included some of the Night & the Doctor clips. Gonna miss those 2.
Did you notice the part with the regeneration energy looks like a Rose?
Thanks to you, my kids call this the Doctor Who Song. Yes, I watch your video that often. LOVE LOVE LOVE it!
It’s insane how much of an impact this video has had on my life. Because of this video this song is my favourite song. Every time I listen to it I think back to this amazing video. It’s weird but it’s helped me through so much. Coming back and remember better times. So thank you for creating this all those years ago.
It's been so long since I last saw this. I had no idea that it would still have me in tears before the first minute was done. Beautifully put together, and a guaranteed heart breaker. Thanks so much for creating it!
For the past week, and for as far as I can see in the future, this is my new nightly tradition (as in I now watch this video right before I go to sleep every night)! I love it! You did a great job! :) :D
The lyrics fit this perfectly... beautiful job. Keep up the good work.
this is one of the most beautiful videos I've ever seen! 😍😭😍
Thanks really, this videos always gets me
I adore this. Thank you!
this has been added to my favorites list here on the magical youtube. not only do i love the song and the way its portrayed with my favorite show on tv, but it is such a pretty moment and reminds me of an important part of my life.
this is fabulous lol i mean helpful :D I'm trying to catch up and this really helps
THIS IS VERY BEAUTIFUL TOO
Scenes and words match perfectly,thank you.
Absolutely fabulous...can't tell you how many times I have watched this!
this was so beautiful!! thankyou!!!
This is amazing, and was a very firm kick right in the feels.
This is, literally, the first time this song has ever made sense to me. Brilliantly done, wonderful couple - I now can actually enjoy listening to this. Thank you. Ah, fantastic introduction, by the way, using the actual scene there. Loved it.
OMG, I'm balling my eyes out right now! SO MUCH BETTER than the other one I saw by someone else. GENIUS use of these scenes. FAVORITE! CAN'T STOP CRYING!!
Ok, I've watched this so many times, whether I just watched one of the main Doctor/River episodes or just because I can, but it never gets old. Thank you so much for making this, it is absolutely amazing.
absolutely love what you did with this song and video!!!!!