9 and 10 were in love with Rose. 11 was in love with River. 12 loved her differently. He wasn't in love with her like the other three loved her and Rose. He loved her like a husband loves his wife of many, many years. Completely and for a long time. Like it's all he's known. Especially with them spending 24 years on Darillium. The love of a long "suffering" husband, who hasn't really suffered.
I still get slightly heartbroken when River was saying how the doctor wasn't there and that he's not there for her, he was behind her all along and she never even knew it.
It's so sad that River thinks the Doctor doesn't love her because he does. It's so obvious that he does but she ignores the signs because he's never told her using words, only his actions
The one thing that always gets me is that we will never get any more Twelve and River because Peter Capaldi and Alex Kingston had an amazing chemistry. Those two. Honestly. Thank you. Loved the vid!
this was perfect! one of the best doctor/river vids ever! i loved how you mixed the lyrics with the scenes and the different voiceovers! i just love how cute funny and tragic their story is! thanks so much for sharing this amazing vid with us :)
ya know, i used to hate the doctor/river pairing, it just didn't seem to bond. But...this...that special, and this video, it brings it all together. To the point where this video made me tear up and utterly love them together!
+TheVolterra13 Moffat left a small hint or two along the way........it would be great to see him get her out of the Library, but with the new show runner taking over, I'm not sure if he'll feel that River is a character that he wants around. We'll see, I guess.
+Anastacia Morgan I thought this this thing where there is an alleged tapestry of time, akin to the three sister's tapestry in Greek mythology, and the 12th doctor meets up with the 11th doctor, re see the tapestry and make it so that she doesn't die, but regenerates at the library. The time power then saves her
Noor Bashir ah yes, The Three, I always did like that myth and it would make a lovely chapter to the story that is the Doctor and River for sure. I always like to think that River gets herself out of the library. because, no prison, not even a library planet afterlife could ever hold River Song..
+Anastacia Morgan I agree completely, I don't think any prison could hold river song, not even Stormcage could keep her in one place, and that's the strongest containment facility in the universe!
River is his soulmate. I wish we saw more of them together. It is foolish to think he doesn’t love her just because she wasn’t lying when she said he didn’t. Just because you believe something doesn’t make it true. Wonderful video. 💗💗💗 Also who is covering this song? It’s amazing.
This is sooooo amazing! Thank you so much for sharing this excellent work! This song fits them so much, it seems like River and the Doctor's story is punctuated by Hello's and Goodbyes. So lovely...
After TATM and before TNOTD, the doctor and river spend a lot of off screen time together, I would love to see that off screen time....... Well......the bits that are appropriate to see!!! For example, that mini-sode, the rain gods, that's after Rory and Amy die, so that means that Clara was asleep of something and they went on a nightly outing, like during First Night and Last Night....overall I think River's coming back, whether she is dead or alive, or if it is past, present or future, or even if it is just the doctor thinking about her!
Incredible video !!!! I loved it !!!! I love this couple! A series of wonderful Christmas!) And you managed to convey the mood of this couple! Thank you for that!)
that was amazing. I loved your video💖 This is a beatyful melody and my tears can fill a pond. Really, i'm crying a river. I can't stop listening this song (sorry😁)
The cursive font "hello from the other side" in the thumbnail of the video looked like "hello from the otter side." It made me think of that time 12 was interacting with Clara in the Caretaker episode and said, "I lived among otters once for a month! Well, I sulked. River and I, we had this big fight--" I was really hoping for an otter montage, but your video is cool too XD
awesome I love it thou I miss Clara and "watch us run" seemed like her quote. Love both the loves stories. Hope to get Clara or River's references in S10 & s11. I might ship Doctor x Bill too. River does know Clara changed him into falling in love with people so do not tell me the special wasn't about #Whoffaldi too i loved that
"I hate you."
"No you don't."
That was an emotional roller coaster!
translation.."I love you" "I love you too" :)
9 and 10 were in love with Rose. 11 was in love with River. 12 loved her differently. He wasn't in love with her like the other three loved her and Rose. He loved her like a husband loves his wife of many, many years. Completely and for a long time. Like it's all he's known. Especially with them spending 24 years on Darillium. The love of a long "suffering" husband, who hasn't really suffered.
Yeah
She died with 10, lived with 11 and loved with 12
I still get slightly heartbroken when River was saying how the doctor wasn't there and that he's not there for her, he was behind her all along and she never even knew it.
You can see the pain on his face during her speech. That he feels guilty for making her feel that way.
It's so sad that River thinks the Doctor doesn't love her because he does. It's so obvious that he does but she ignores the signs because he's never told her using words, only his actions
agreed
I know I cried when she said he didn't! I know he does
+A Bourg the look on his face. It made me so sad. This scene made me finally accept him as the Doctor lol.
I know; its heartbreaking!!! I accepted him along time ago
The one thing that always gets me is that we will never get any more Twelve and River because Peter Capaldi and Alex Kingston had an amazing chemistry. Those two. Honestly. Thank you. Loved the vid!
this was perfect! one of the best doctor/river vids ever! i loved how you mixed the lyrics with the scenes and the different voiceovers! i just love how cute funny and tragic their story is! thanks so much for sharing this amazing vid with us :)
+ƊƛƝƳЄԼԼƛƬƦƻƻ thank you so much, hun ♥
OH MY GOD THIS IS SO F*KING BEAUTIFUL HUN
+CaroFreeSpirit thanks :)
this is one of my all time RiverxDoctor fanvids! the feels are high! such an amazing job :D
ya know, i used to hate the doctor/river pairing, it just didn't seem to bond. But...this...that special, and this video, it brings it all together. To the point where this video made me tear up and utterly love them together!
river always be my favorite. nice vid. thanks
WhyI tortured myself watching this great video, the relationship of River and The Doctor is beautifully tragic!!! Spoilers!!!
+Anabella James thank you
Will forever and always be my favorite fan video for the Doctor and River
Good Lord, it's been month's since I last watched this but it still brings me to sobbing tears! This is just to beautiful with all the feel's.
i am watching this, like, everyday
That's so amazing i started crying right at the beginning
I almost cried! The clips and the music are meant for each other!
that just made me cry - you did such a lovely job editing
I don't know who sings this version, but I love it better than Adele's version.
Agreed 😉
This is not the end of their story, right? Right?
This video is so beautiful. One of the best I've ever seen on this 2 ♥
+TheVolterra13 Moffat left a small hint or two along the way........it would be great to see him get her out of the Library, but with the new show runner taking over, I'm not sure if he'll feel that River is a character that he wants around. We'll see, I guess.
+Anastacia Morgan lets hope that he would want her around lol she's always the best with all the doctors
+Anastacia Morgan I thought this this thing where there is an alleged tapestry of time, akin to the three sister's tapestry in Greek mythology, and the 12th doctor meets up with the 11th doctor, re see the tapestry and make it so that she doesn't die, but regenerates at the library. The time power then saves her
Noor Bashir ah yes, The Three, I always did like that myth and it would make a lovely chapter to the story that is the Doctor and River for sure. I always like to think that River gets herself out of the library. because, no prison, not even a library planet afterlife could ever hold River Song..
+Anastacia Morgan I agree completely, I don't think any prison could hold river song, not even Stormcage could keep her in one place, and that's the strongest containment facility in the universe!
River is his soulmate. I wish we saw more of them together. It is foolish to think he doesn’t love her just because she wasn’t lying when she said he didn’t. Just because you believe something doesn’t make it true. Wonderful video. 💗💗💗 Also who is covering this song? It’s amazing.
This is sooooo amazing! Thank you so much for sharing this excellent work! This song fits them so much, it seems like River and the Doctor's story is punctuated by Hello's and Goodbyes. So lovely...
OMG ! I'm speechless ! The best tribute river/dr..... just brilliant !!!
This video was so heartbreaking and beautiful. I am seriously a crying mess right now.
This is so amazing! Absolutely amazingly beautiful!
Whoever is responsible for this masterpiece. Thank you for filling the empty void in my very soul. k thanks
I've gotta say: I think this might be the single BEST DoctorRiver video I've ever seen. #bookmarked
It's fantastic! I'm so in love with these two, and your video is just amazing 💙
Congrats. You just made me have all the feels. Beautifully done.
why?? this video is so beautiful. I'm emotional. thank you
so love the doctor and river... obsessed 😭😭😭😭
this was so perfect! i hope to see more river song next season!
i almost died watching this x_x
Best doctorxriver video I've ever seen, literally cryin' it's beautiful❤️💍
I'm teary - this is beautiful.
Damn, I really didn't think the lyrics would fit as well as you've just made them fit... holy crap, that was amazing!! Perfection in every way.
+VidDuality thank you :)
amazing! one of the best river/doctor vids ive seen!
This is so well done. I drag it out and watch it and remember how good it was before.
my favorite edit ever
They are so adorable!!! I am gonna cry :(
the colouring is gorgeous!!!
There is no way for me to express my gratitude towards how lovely that was. Like a breath of fresh air. Thank you.
After TATM and before TNOTD, the doctor and river spend a lot of off screen time together, I would love to see that off screen time....... Well......the bits that are appropriate to see!!!
For example, that mini-sode, the rain gods, that's after Rory and Amy die, so that means that Clara was asleep of something and they went on a nightly outing, like during First Night and Last Night....overall I think River's coming back, whether she is dead or alive, or if it is past, present or future, or even if it is just the doctor thinking about her!
This is one of the best Doctor Who fan videos that I've seen yet. It was beautiful. Nice job!
tears have been shed.
GAH!!! My emotions!! THE FEELS!!! I love this vid so much! River and her Sweetie!!
I cry every time, its soo beautiful
Please! Please! PLEASE! Never remove this video from UA-cam. This is a masterpiece. Oh, my God.
+Saiyan God Don't worry, I am not planning to :)
I just love this so much.
Incredible video !!!! I loved it !!!! I love this couple! A series of wonderful Christmas!) And you managed to convey the mood of this couple! Thank you for that!)
+Margarita Life thank you
The ending made me cry. :') Good job.
This vid is so beautiful and it made me cry
Trying not to cry while watching this; because its beautifully done.
God I hate you, I didn't need to cry today...
I'm just bitter, you did a beautiful job
Oh! My! God! This was so beautiful. I cried at end of the video.
Oh my god!!!!! I wasn't prepared for that, I love love love it 💕💕💕
Love Love Love!!! My eternal couple. oh how I wish she would come back next season for more adventures
Favorite part of the video, "There's such a difference between us!" Because the way they circle the each other, IT'S true, they were BOTH different.
I cried.. thank you for this vid!
This is so beautiful
Whose cover is this because it's amazing!!!!!!
Love the video as well can't help but cry
Amg, this is CRAZY BEAUTIFUL! I love this video so very much
+my own fictionxx thank you so much
Aww, this is so beautiful!
+DarkEleni thank you
amazing amazing amazing!
Why am I crying!!? 😭😭😭
Truly amazing.
OMG!! This moved me! Beautiful, eyes welled up around 40 sec in, lol
I wish I could give you 1000000 likes. This is the best!
ohhhhhhhh no no no
this is to perfect !!! MY FEEEELS !!!!
I can't even begin to describe how powerful this video is
+LoveIsLove thank you so much!
WOW!
This was really beautiful :)
I loved it from the beginning till the end :) awesome :)))
+Estaaaas thank you
the feels...😭😭😭😭
this is absolutely beautiful love it
+QueenMorgana thank you
oh bloody hell that was so good
I CAN'T STOP WATCHING
Why would you do this me? It's like i dont even need a heart, bc its already in pieces!! this is amazing!!
Awesome job with this video!!! I loved it!!!
Incredible.
the feels, make them stop
that was amazing. I loved your video💖 This is a beatyful melody and my tears can fill a pond. Really, i'm crying a river. I can't stop listening this song (sorry😁)
This is perfect 😭
is it weird i cry every time i watch this?
you know I didn't need my heart its fine I'm good. Great vid btw
Now I'm crying. Damn you.
It's beautiful :)
i'm crying
The cursive font "hello from the other side" in the thumbnail of the video looked like "hello from the otter side." It made me think of that time 12 was interacting with Clara in the Caretaker episode and said, "I lived among otters once for a month! Well, I sulked. River and I, we had this big fight--" I was really hoping for an otter montage, but your video is cool too XD
I love it so much. :'(
so beautiful :))) love them so much :$
that hurts
I am die. THIS IS PERFECT. Ugh. So. Effing. Good. (#sogoodsogood)
River will always be my favorite. Till we meet again Sweetie.
Now I really think that this song was mare just for this video
beautiful ^^
it was great! if someone would make a video showing how many times "hello sweetie" is said and writen in dr who!
that would be cool
Okay, you're evil. That's the only answer for this. Now excuse me while I continue crying my heart out.
+CrownedHeart oh, I am so evil ;-)
i wanted to use this song too, but i won't, because this is perfection. absolutely love it!
who is singing this cover?
+ATimeLadyD thank you, it's Bri Heart & Jervy Hou cover
as much as i love peter, as soon as matt came on i thought "oh shit i miss him"...
awesome I love it thou I miss Clara and "watch us run" seemed like her quote. Love both the loves stories. Hope to get Clara or River's references in S10 & s11. I might ship Doctor x Bill too.
River does know Clara changed him into falling in love with people so do not tell me the special wasn't about #Whoffaldi too i loved that
They do make a great couples I'd love to see their children and grandchildren later on future tv series if river return to show?
I swear this works for every single companion
Beautiful! I wish you could've used the Adele version though!
+Cailyn K. Me too, I just didn't want this to get taken down :( but thanks
I know. It's so unfair! Can you do an Adele version and put it on vimeo?
I would have to remake it all because of the rhythm of the song, so probably not, but If I ever decide to remake it, I'll let you know
Oh,ok. Thanks!