Engineers Test WIX vs Autozone Oil Filters
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 вер 2024
- 👍Want to help support the channel, so we can continue testing products👍
Please consider buying us a coffee at: www.buymeacoff...
📦 PRODUCTS IN THIS VIDEO 📦
WIX - amzn.to/3XcHhp0
Napa Gold - amzn.to/3wQKhgm
Baldwin - amzn.to/4bxSLbb
STP - www.autozone.c...
We tested 4 of the most viewer suggested oil filters to see which one was the best. We simulated hot and cold temperatures, their ability to filter out fine particles, and sent them off to a laboratory to assess their filtering performance. #oil #filter #test
The link to these products may be an affiliate link, which means you pay the same price as always but we make a small commission, this supports our channel immensely so we can continue providing great content, Thank You!
** As an Amazon Associate, Brand Ranks earns from qualifying purchases. The content in this video is accurate as of the filming date. Some of the offers mentioned may no longer be available.
Thank you all for your support! We are testing Air Filters Next! Any brands you want to see?
Would love to see k&n vs a stock filter.
K&N, Supertech, FRAM, Ecogard, STP, Purolator
Why are you not using wix XP for the oil filter test
@@j_zales1390 they have already tested the WIX XP previously. Go back to their earlier videos to see more.
Toyota brand would be great
This channel is a must watch for true car enthusiasts.
Thank you so much! Your support is greatly appreciated!
You should add Anti-Drain Back valve performance to your testing procedure, which is crucial to prevent dry starts. Maybe by installing the filter base upside down and test how much oil, if any, drains back the inlet after a period of time, or reverse flowing the filter to see if any oil gets past the valve.
that would be a very nice comparison, me personally I think toyota filters should be highly ranked on that regard, their ADBV works very well
I swapped to a Purolator Boss oil filter after watching your previous videos, and I am still using them. Thank you for sharing all of this information.
On the oil side, I had been using Pennzoil Ultra Platinum, but recently swapped to Valvoline Restore and Protect.
The visit by the Motor Oil Geek to Valvoline’s facility to learn a bit more about this oil was a very interesting video. I am intrigued
Why,? Project Farm's test shows the Pennzoil Platinum as the best oil.
@@kb9826 keep in mind Valvoline Restore & Protect came out into the market much later than that Project Farm Review. Valvoline Advanced was close to Pennzoil Ultra Platinum but the Valvoline Extended Protection and Restore and Protect are BETTER than the VALVOLINE ADVANCED. In all honestly though if you just change the oil frequently it makes little difference. But it might help a little using the better oil. It makes a bigger difference when doing long oil change intervals which I do not recommend.
@@sc3ku keep in mind Valvoline Restore & Protect came out into the market much later than that Project Farm Review. Valvoline Advanced was close to Pennzoil Ultra Platinum but the Valvoline Extended Protection and Restore and Protect are BETTER than the VALVOLINE ADVANCED. In all honestly though if you just change the oil frequently it makes little difference. But it might help a little using the better oil. It makes a bigger difference when doing long oil change intervals which I do not recommend.
Valvoline ultra high mileage even if you aren’t high mileage is the best when it comes to the cheaper side. If you really want the best schaffers or redline I person just switched to redline and use a Purolator boss filter.
Man this channel rocks, I wish you guys nothing but success.
Thank you so much for your support! your comment means a lot to us and keeps us motivated.
$40-90k for a vehicle and your going to cheap out on one of the most critical parts of your engine to save 5-10 bucks every 6 months!!? Change the oil every 5000 miles and use HIGH quality oil and filters is very cheap insurance. Use your brain people...
Oil filters aren’t as important as people think.
Aircraft engines used screens till the late 70’s.
The oil filter didn’t raise the TBO, time before overhaul.
Every 5k miles? Maybe for some vehicles. But for me I change my oil every 2500k miles. Then again I’ve spent so much money on my engine I just want the best lubrication and filtration for the motor to keep it happy.
@@OwenstiHow the vehicle is being used makes a difference. My car is just a cheap enough daily driver. I put a lot of miles on it because I've got a 120 mile daily commute, but it's all steady speed driving on long country back roads, so the oil has plenty of time to circulate the engine between startups and isn't necessarily getting that much load, and in addition, with how many miles I'm driving I can't afford to change my oil every 2500; that'd be once every month and a half.
Yes I also agree. My car is a performance vehicle so that is also a factor on why I change it frequently. If I were you I’d investigate in some higher viscosity oil for your car that would probably last longer and won’t burn as fast. Also keep in mind if you are in a colder climate state I wouldn’t recommend it.
Wix, Mann and Puralator are all made by Mann Hummel. But the design of the filters and build locations of the filters are changing. I literally have three filters with the same part #, all Wix filters that are totally different. One is the old Wix I'm used to with the seven round holes "made in the USA". One that looks like a euro Mann Hummel filter with 5 holes half covered by a metal ring " made in China" and one that looks like a Puralator filter with 7 oval holes "made in USA" Things are getting confusing right now with Mann Hummel's product line.
Going to go with the Boss filters from now on until I see change in build design and or build location. Please keep updating you findings ..... Mann Hummel seems to be in a state of change at the moment with their production design and production facility locations.
Thank you for reviewing the filter I requested (STP XL). While I've been using them with no issues and the oil looks fairly clean after a 5k mile change interval, now I'm likely going to spend the extra couple bucks per change going with the Purolator Boss because it *still* appears to be the top performer overall.
Of course, thanks for the suggestion! Glad we were of help. Remember that the most i.portant thing is keeping up with maintenance, but yeah the Purolator is definitely better. Thanks for watching!
Already way ahead of you with the 'keeping up with maintenance' bit. That's why I do 5k mile oil changes and not the 10k mile that my owners manual says to do (2019 Ford Fusion Hybrid).
Wix and Napa used to be the same but not anymore. Mann humel bought wix and made in USA. The Napa is made in China.
True. And they should be using the Wix XP.
Napa filters now appear to be made by MicroGuard. Royalty Auto Service channel was the first to bring this to light when Napa recalled their entire stocked inventory.
@@shakerman55 Wix XP has been downgraded to blend media witn no more backing.
@@memopadilla5931 Is that bad? I've been using Wix XP for years.
Huh?? My local Napa still supplies me all NAPA Gold filters which are made by Wix.
I was just checking your channel earlier today to see if I had missed a video. Was very happy to see you pop up in my feed shortly after!
Same
Please test the Purolator One next!
They tested in one of the previous videos
@@thatcrazyfriend It is not shown in the results. The Boss is shown, but I don't see the One.
@@tid418 gotcha yea understand
Amazing high quality content! Was hoping Project Farm would cover oil filters, but after finding you guys I can see why hasn't bothered.
i want this channel to do well. as a tip you should show all the filters you have tested so far in the video icon along with your face with each updated oil filter video. it will being more views (according to videos i have watched about increasing views strategies
Thank you so much for supporting us and the recommendation. We are still learning and trying new stuff, including changing the thumbnails up. Yeah this last one is not doing as good so we may change up the thumbnail and see. Again, thank you for taking the time to write this comment and support us.
Thanks.... awesome oil filter testing.
Than YOU! Your support is much appreciated!
Love these videos! You're one of only 2 people I've seen do actual scientific research on oil filters, keep up the great work!
You should definitely test the FRAM Titanium from Advanced Auto Parts next. A guy from Ascent Filtration did an ISO 4548-12 Oil Filter Lab Testing Comparison using professional equipment, and the old FRAM Ultra got hands down the best filtration results of an oil filter I've seen. Luckily, FRAM didn't abolish this amazing filter and they instead rebranded it as the Titanium with the exact same design as the old Ultra. By comparing and contrasting the data from both you and Ascent Filtration, in comparison to the new FRAM Ultra that you tested, the Titanium should have better DP, slightly worse capacity, and his test showed 99% filtration at 15 microns. If there's any filter that can take the crown from the Purolator Boss, it's the FRAM Titanium!
They did abolish the filter. Titaniums on the Advanced Auto Parts shelf are old stock. New Titaniums have the new design just like Fram Ultra. Still plenty good though.
I heard that as well over a year ago. But I just bought 2 different models of the Titanium filter and they both still have the metal backing screen. So I suppose not all the models are the same
Great Video. Thanks for providing data instead of just putting your face in front of the camera and rambling about your opinion for 10 min. trying pass it along as fact or truth.
Thank you so much for watching and supporting. So glad you enjoyed!
Love this series guys…I know you tested an AC Delco filter but it was without an anti-drainback valve. Can you test something like the PF63 which is a very common filter application across GM as it has a synthetic media and has an anti-drainback valve
You guys kick ass! Excellent video. I also watched your other oil filter test. Good watch!
It seems to me, obviously use quality oil, the correct viscosity oil provided by one's owner's manual, and a good quality oil filter, it is most important to change that oil frequently. I feel it is important to go above and beyond the manufacturer's 10,000 miles interval. I personally change my engine oil and filters at 5,000 miles, even though Toyota states less frequency or 10,000 miles. I feel clean quality oil is an inexpensive insurance policy for a long trouble-free engine life. However, that's my opinion. After the purchase of a brand-new vehicle, I do my first oil and filter change at less than 1,000. Then go to my "normal 5,000 miles increments on the odometer" oil change frequency from then on. Every 5,000 miles is easy to remember by looking at my odometer. 5, 10, 15, etc...
We’ve been waiting! Appreciate this one. Shared! Some engine oil testing and even oil additive or engine flush testing would do great! Especially Prolube and BG products.
Thanks for the great ideas! I know it's been awhile and we really wish we could post more often, but being full time engineers and spending time with the family really doesn't leave much time in the week. Hopefully one day we can do this full time and bring you guys awesome content at a more consistent manner.. thank you a gain!
I would like to see how the Purolator One filter does in comparison to the Boss. My guess is that it will be close to the Fram Endurance and push the Boss down to 4th place in the efficiency ratings.
1:03 Not anymore. Royalty auto service did a video on this recently (We Talked To Napa About The Filters… Here’s The Update!) and I guess premium guard now makes oil filters for napa. Not sure if they're the only supplier or if they are multiple.
When I worked at AutoZone back in the early 2010’s, I was there when they came out with the STP Extended Life oil filters. I loved using them! The other guys teased me about it, but I thought that it was better than the Bosch for about the same price.
You should test Service Champ filters since alot of quick lubes use those
Great addition to the oil filter series! Any plans on branching out to other test like cabin/engine filters?
Hey thanks for watching! And yes, this is actually our last oil filter one ( for now) we are testing air filters next! Taking suggestions in the pin comment! Again, thank you for the support!
How about cartridge style filters?
One concern I have about your testing method for checking how much the filter isn't filtering is that some of these filters can contain much more before reaching the stopping point on flow rate. Are you taking measurements at specific intervals after adding a measured total of dust or after it maxes out on capacity? If it's the latter then any filters which hold less before reaching max psi will have a bias.
*JP: Since Oct 2022 I truly appreciate your testing efforts and results. Big however is that hose kink leading to your catch funnel. Sorta renders your upstream ball valve a bit redundant. Pretty sure that is not your intention. Cheers!*
Hey! Thank you so much for supporting us since the beginning! Much appreciated. Yeah, we went through many iteration trying to build a rig that looked pleasant and at the same time fit in a wall that would frame well for the video. We tried several hoses also and some broke. You all get to see the end result but it was quite a bit of work to get this all working. That ball valve was actually quite necessary to control the flow rate, so we can do our hot and cold flow tests. Yeah we could've just linked the hose but then you'd see one of us linking the hose for. Awhile while we read a stabilized result. We want to always be transparent and show you everything so we used the ball valve so you could see how the flow changes on the flow meter on the right as we actuate the ball valve going upstream to the catch can. Again, thank you so much for all your support and feedback!
@@BrandRanks *Thanks for replying. My only criticism was the kink in the hose, not of your process, presentation or methods. Cheers!*
Would love to see other car products tested too, like both cabin filters and engine air filters and so on
Hey, thank you so much for watching! Yes, this was our last oil filter one (for now) we will be testing engine air filters next. Always taking recommendations so thank you!
I’ve began using the purolator boss after watching your videos! Thank you so much!
So glad to hear! Thank you so much for your support!
id love to see MicroGard Select oil filter be tested thats what i run on my performance engines.
I like your final ranking table, it would be really interesting to see if the premium filters WITHIN A BRAND are worth the price difference -- Purolator Classic -vs- Purolator One -vs- Purolator BOSS would be a great video given the BOSS is the chart leader.
With the Baldwin having such a high particle count, Wouldn't you think that it is doing a better job of filtering out the particles. The other three are allowing the particles to pass on through. I don't get it.
The particle count is in the oil where it should've been filtered out. Baldwin is the only one that did worse than my Fram Extra Guard.
I think your testing will be a kick in the A for the manufacturers to improve their products! I have 2K miles on my orange can of death (Fram Extra Guard) that I ignorantly bought because Autozone didn't carry the Purolator Pure One that I used to buy from Pep Boys. Another 1K miles and the Boss goes in.
Filter makers I want a filter with #1 ranking in each category. Get going. Fram, make your new Fram Endurance a 1/2 inch to 3/4 inches taller. Will increase flow in all cases while keeping fine particle filtration. Go Fram.
11 GPM? That sounds like an unreasonable amount of oil flow. How about testing these at what one would expect as a normal amount of oil flow? Does it really hurt if the filter bypasses some of the oil for the first few minutes? It isn't like there's a copious amount of dirt in the oil needing to be filtered at startup.
People be putting a restrictive oil filters and are suprised they get knock at a dry start just put a cheap one and change your oil
Please do the two grades of walmart filters and the Purolator one filter
I have yet to have a problem with any oil filter ! My 94 chevy s10 2.2 has 661,000 miles on her and 23,000 hrs of use ! I'll stay with the fram ultra syn ! $7 ! Best filter for the buck !
Is that an overall ranking in order at the end of the video? If not, where can I find an overall ranking list
How can Wix XP and Toyota change 1st & 2nd place in this video compared to last video.
Great video, would love to see how different the results are with paper filters instead of canisters
Thanks, BR, for all the great work you guys so!
Thank you so much for watching and supporting us! Greatly appreciated
Please add a chart scoring the filters on their actual performance data, not just category rankings. Will be more useful!
9.99? Napa here is over 13!
Wix XP should be in the line up. Designed for better flowing synthetic oil.
Hey, make sure to check out our other videos in the series, we included the Wiz XP! Thanks for watching
@@BrandRanks
I just checked out the other videos, and I just watched one with the XP. 👍
@@shakerman55 Wix XP now downgraded to blend media with no more backing. 🤠
@@memopadilla5931
Darn. Sad to hear. Another good one sliding down the hole.
Shouldn’t the filter that has the most contaminants be the best filter?
That makes sense to me. I don't understand how in the smallest micron category, the smallest number is the better performing filter. 🤷🏻♂️
Can you do the oem Honda oil filter 🙏
As a service manager of a Napa Autocare Center. I can attest to ordering a Napa gold filter and getting a Wix filter with a Napa part number on it.
really hope one day you guys will do the "cartridge" style filters
Same here, my car uses this style.
I am curious about the Purolator One filter. After talking to the factory rep, the “Boss” allows more particles to flow through the filter until a higher mileage is reached so it doesn’t clog the media too soon. I was told to get the “One” since I change my oil at 5,000 miles or less. Is there a way you can do the test on the “One”?
Thank you and I love your videos.
How does the Wix compare to the Wix XP ?
I love this channel, thank you so much for all of your hard work
Have you considered a video where you check consistency of the filters over time? Perform the same tests for the top 5 an additional 3 times and taking the average of the results. How far does that deviate from your initial results?
Glad yall did one with a wix filter
Your rankings are way off. How do you have them in that order? I'll help. Lowest # wins...
1 = Purolator Boss - 16
2 = Napa Platinum - 24
3 = Wix XP - 24
4 = Mobil 1 - 31
5 = Baldwin - 31
6 = Mann - 34
7 = Toyota - 36
8 = Napa Gold - 39
9 = Fram Ultra - 40
10 = Royal Purple - 40
11 = Fram Endurance 41
12 = Amsoil - 41
13 = K & N - 44
14 = Bosch - 44
15 = Wix - 48
16 = Motocraft - 50
17 = STP - 59
18 =Fram Tough - 59
19 =Fram Extra - 72
looking at the final graph, it seems that filters with the least efficiency in filtering (redundance sorry) have the best flow and capacity, and the same goes the other way, the filters with the better media have decreased flow and capacity...
Would love to see some of the JDM tuning companies (HKS, Greddy, Blitz, Nismo, Trd, Sti) filters tested, are they worth the extra money? I’ve always assumed no and stuck with oem.
I really want to see an OEM Subaru filter. There is so much controversy surrounding the OEM Subaru filter being so good and having the “right bypass pressure”. I’d like to see it proven or disproven. I personally believe the high bypass pressure is due to the poor filter media flow rate, not special oil system needs of the Subaru engines.
The legend is back 🙌
🤣🤣Thank you so much for watching. Really wish we could post more but doing YT and full time engineer is quite a lot. Hopefully we get to do this full time in the future! Next up...air filters
@@BrandRanks results from the lab taking weeks to come back doesn't help either. thank you and look forward to new uploads then 👍will share with friends and family
Another nice test. I have to ask where these filters are made? I think Wix and Napa moved to China.
WRONG!!! still made in NC, USA Even their PRO TEC shop filters are made in USA
It seems like MOBIL 1 is the best OVERALL for protection and hot and cold flow... when compared to the other top ones. It's not as restrictive..
Wouldn't it be more applicable to perform the particle count test using the same amount of aluminum powder absorbed into each filter system? The Baldwin absorved twice as much powder as the other filters so there was more in the system that could potentially be dispensed into the sample.
Great video - I’m still waiting for the test of an OEM Honda filter (bought from a dealer of course)
Outstanding!! Thank you, guys...
Thank youuuu!!! Really appreciate you watching!
I wish you re-test the purolator boss, just to make sure that the results are similar.
Wix or amsoil ea
New video been waiting!🤙🏽
keep this type content rolling, great content
Thinking HOT flow makes a big different if always driving for a long time.
i love your testing/comparison videos ! would you be able to test OEM oil filters from bmw, honda, mazda please? i wonder how they compare to these
the fram endurance is the same filter as the Amsoil
Not surprising the STP has the best filtration and the most restriction. Although how it lets more larger parts through that the WIX yet catches 50% more of the smaller particles is strange. Hard to explain that one.
Please review these for the ongoing list. Carquest Standard, Carquest Premium, Fram Drive, Fram Force and Fram Titanium all from Advance Auto Parts.
Thanks 👍
Any chance you could do an analysis of diesel truck filters? baldwin, donaldson, luberfiner etc. There is nothing on youtube comparing them like you do.
I only use NOS Pulolator or Wix filters
Love you man will u be able to do the best fuel system cleaner test please 🥺
I'd like to see this test done with a K&P Engineering filter too. That would be rad.
FRAM Please take the Endurance filter add an extra 1/2 of height . Then you can win every category. We will buy it.. Endurance needs better Hot flow numbers.
Baldwin shows that BT223 to Absolute at 40micron. I believe BX 75 if IIRC. Thats not that good but Baldwin filters vary a great deal I;m assuming based on the OEM spec they originally made the filter for.
I have a dodge with a Baldwin that is BX75 at 30 micron
My wifes car Chevy has a Baldwin that is BX75 at 27 micron
Bx75 is 98.7% removal of all particle sizes from the oil filter testing
Their specs vary considerably depending on what manufacturer they are making the filter for
Hold on, I'm not an engineer, but I do have a 132 IQ... logic tells me, that if the pressure resistance while cold, doesn't ruin the engine, then ANY of these filters, regardless of the flow, will be just fine at lubricating the engine while warm temperatures (like in Texas), because even the worst filter here has a better flow rate than the best filter here, when it's cold. So really the flow rate while warm, doesn't really matter.
I was thinking that too. If you are changing your oil every 5000Kms, then the filter capacity is not important, leaving filtering as the only important factor.
Hey a suggestion, ive seen some people claiming old filters were better, any chance of being able to get some vintage oil filters for testing?
Why not any Purolator filters? We should have had some Premium filters for comparison, for people who Like their engines... Do some in the air filter category for sure, I'd love to see how they stack up there
Hey, thanks for watching! We tested the Purolator Boss in another video in the series. Make sure to go check it out!
@@BrandRanks I found it, thanks for the heads up! If I might, could I suggest perhaps listing future comparisons with the best tested, and cheapest tested? Maybe with a link to a list of up to date test results? Seeing my money was well spent on my own cars that I really like is nice to know, but it'd be neat to know how big the gap is between them to better weigh value, you know? Maybe you want to recommend a minimum to a friend or family member more budget conscious, or less demanding with mileage or the right foot. I feel like it's a useful yardstick for a lot of people.
Keep up the good work, the Algorithm™ only graced me with your channel today, and I like what I see already!
@@supramanx1997 same, robot overlords must have pulled their heads out of their butts and realized we actually want to see this material. My filter purchases are officially changed after watching this and the other tests.
You guys should start testing motorcycle oil filters too
Thank you for the recommendation and for your support!
Try a Denso oil filter vs Toyota oil filter
How about OEM filters, AC Delco, denso Toyota, honda etc
Sick one boys!!!!!!
Thank you so much! Always appreciate your support
Yes this is awesome
Thanks for watching and supporting the channel!
Just FYI JP is Project Farms son....they started this channel together
You should do the same for ATV oil filters and oils
as normal you did not disappoint thank you for a new great video,
Thank you so much for always being present and supporting us! Next up we have air filters, very excited to switch it up a little
@@BrandRanks air filter is a great idea
Next do diesel oil filters! Like from CAT
Where is the Microguard Select?
Would like see more car band oil filters. Would like see diesel and motorcycle oil filter
Kind of what logic would dictate......... A filter with better flow will allow more particles to pass. Only way to combat that is to use more restrictive media, BUT to add lots more media to make up for the flow rate.
Wix XP
I use bosch filters on my infiniti, Kia and my zero turn mower, with zero issues
Would really like to see a test on PPE (Pacific Performance Engineering) diesel oil filter. I use them (filter# 114000740) thinking they are the best for my 2024 GMC 2500 HD AT4 truck (6.6L Duramax diesel). I would like to see how they do compared to the Purolator Boss (PBL22500) for the same vehicle.
In my experience that Baldwin filters at a very fine micron rating but is VERY restrictive. I’m guessing your filter was bypassing when it shows those insanely high micron numbers.
Great videos! Can you guys test Air and Fuel filters?
Can you try MOPAR filters, please?