Gerrard, Scholes or Lampard - Who do Terry and Carragher think was the greatest? | MNF Q&A
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 гру 2017
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootballSub
PREMIER LEAGUE HIGHLIGHTS ► bit.ly/SkySportsPLHighlights
Former Chelsea captain John Terry joined Jamie Carragher on Monday Night Football to answer YOUR questions from Twitter. Who is the most frightening player he faced? Who was the greatest coach he played under? And if he had to choose one who would he pick; Scholes, Gerrard or Lampard?
Watch Premier League LIVE on Sky Sports here ► bit.ly/WatchSkyPL
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysports
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.com/football
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON UA-cam:
►SKY SPORTS CRICKET: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyCricket
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyF1 - Спорт
What I learnt from this video is Carragher has no friends.
Max Poole Who wants to listen to him rambling and gargling on? Doesn’t even know how to speak properly.
Haha. Carragher “did anyone ask about me” Terry: “No”! Lol.
Bahaha this was funny.
He won't have if he gobs over people.
you dont either since you need to go after other people on internet..lmao
The way terry spoke so highly about Mourinho 👏🏽 can tell he is a champion manager
indeed man...the boss...
@@vogahl34
Not anymore.
FoobsTon that must make you happy... good for you!
Lol....
Yeh mourinho is not adaptable enough... he is done. He will be lucky to get a decent job next... Inter are on the rise and they have a good manager. Where will he go? Madrid hate him, and so does the rest of Spain. Back to Portugal maybe? His brand of football is appalling
John Terry on Mourinho : " i would leave the field in a coffin for him"
Mourinho on Chelsea: "I will defy my touchline ban in a laundry basket for them."
Man utd players to Mourinho: “I would throw you under the bus anytime”
“Literally”
John Terry on Mourinho "I would leave the field to his house when his wife is alone"
Seems to be a common trend. Ibrahimovic said that of all the coaches he had, Mourinho was the the best and that he would "kill for Mourinho".
Say what you’d like about JT but the guy knows what he’s talking about. Great player, great insights, great listen. Well done.
He's been class at Villa.
Yeah,most people will say what they want - the guys an absolute dingleberry
He was suspect for England. I thought he was overrated.
@@jamesrichards4294 You probably started watching football during the twilight of his career.
Sports. News. Sky
First time I've heard John Terry interviewed like that. He's actually very articulate, nothing like his caricature in the press, which shouldn't surprise me.
we was.... hahaha
terry is a total thug... do not be fooled by this act.
"We wuz", only a football fan would think that counts as "articulate" xD
@@slothfromthegoonies8201 ..And you are saying that to say what?
As long as you're not black
Articulate but pronounces three as free 🙄
John Terry is an absolutely fantastic guest to have. Great insight and intelligence with some brilliant stories.
Intelligence! Lol
Thagu Gurkhali Savage
He and Lamps are so well-spoken
@@thagugurkhali8433 well she and Bridge were separated at the time but yeah, was below the belt alright
I would not invite him as a guest in my house. AKA, I am married.
When Terry mentioned Henry, and him and Carra just looked over at each other as if to say “I know”
Really shows what a player Thiery was, his technical ability showed no bounds
yea..come to think of it, he may very well be the most 'skilled' striker in EPL history, if not the world..
Henry was overrated. Choked in major finals he played in.
Claude Makelele did you just call Henry overrated......
Adam chelsea fans still trying to argue drogba, just leave them to there madness
Claude Makelele moron
When I seen this obvious reasons....
Terry : Lampard
Carragher: gerrard
If Neville was in on this: Scholes
The answers will always be the same, with each particular fan as well.
Even Terry knows deep down tho its Scholes
@@jorden1182 I'm 100% with you on scholes but i know every player & fan from Liverpool & Chelsea will always vote for their own.
But the right answer is Gerrard cmon
@@ilqar887 i rest my case...
11:22 for the title's discussion
jonasvm88 saved me 11mins
Hi John Terry how are you doing mate
thanx man . the titles discussion was for 1 min dude
Thx.and tell us who you would choose, and which team you supporting?
@@aishabarozi2730 football sucks
They were all excellent in their own ways:
*Scholes*:
Technically best, superb touch, passing, intelligence, controling team's rhythm... As well as goals especially in earlier part of career. Excellent composure and creativity. Team usually ran through him, most notably when needing goals and breaking teams down. Created the goals when things got tough.
*Gerrard*:
Best all-round game. Tremendous passing, drive, determination, tenacity, work-rate and consistent goalscoring. Tremendous long distance striker and good close distance finisher. Inspirational leader. One man army in many games. Scored the goals especially in moments when team needed him to.
*Lampard*:
Good passing both long and short, good intelligence, unparalleled goalscoring menace from midfield. Incredible consistency. Excellent box finishing (with both feet), very good long range shooting. Very strong mentally, big-game player. Longevity in his consistency and supreme levels of fitness and injury resistance. Consistently (made and) got goals and especially, important, tiimely goals.
Q. WHO'S BEST?
A. What are you looking for in your player? All three were key to their teams and controlled their team's play, scored and created goals.
All won major honours and played at the highest level for a very, very long time.
scholes
you have to much spare time
definitely gerrard
This is one of the best replies i've ever seen. I don't get the fuss people make over this. I mean I absolutely love gerrard and believe he's the best as his game attracts me the most with his overall play and that capability to drag the team through the games but obviously not everyone would want to do the same things.
gerrard. 0 pl titles
Terry captained Carragher in this interview .. lol
I know, he said they are not your mates 😂
Well the interviewer was mainly focusing on JT
Well Terry was the guest on the show so kinda makes sense to ask him most of the qts
@@rossslattery7183 Terry's left toe is a better defender than Jamie ''own goal'' Carragher.
@@claudemakelele2856 we were talking bout an interview u moron. Terry was very good defender must been all the extra training he got in with his mates missus
Great to see Terry honestly acknowledge how special Scholes’ ability was.
anyone that watches football knows they would pick gerrard come on
@@jamieroach5755gerrard was more hit and hope scholes passing was very effective even past his prime
@@jamesk3784 absolute rubbish
@@jamieroach5755 I actually watched the game scholes short and long range passing helped Manchester United win games once Gerrard lost pace he became average
@@jamesk3784 every player declines in their 30s but what did zidane say about gerrard in his prime. could you name one thing gerrard could not do? i could name plenty scholes could not do
Did he ask about meeeeeeee?
No Carra, only Stevie.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
EeeeeeeeeeeeeeerrMMM
Terry and cavalho were the best defensive pair in the world, didn't need Carragah
Who else is watching after Lampard managing Chelsea announcement
A bet every Chelsea fan ain't lol YNWA
Jaye Fletcher incorrect
He managed to get Top 4 with academy graduates.
When they ask Terry about Chelsea not giving young players enough chances I thought of something. Terry will never be as good a manager as Zidane. While Terry only sees value in the players that contribute the most, and the rest become disposable, Zidane knows that every player can make a contribution to the team, no matter who plays the most (and he has the personality and credibility to deal with the egos). That's why Madrid under Zidane always has kind of a "B team" full of the younger players that always performs really well, because they know they have a chance to prove themselves (like Fede Valverde this season, for example); and, in the end, those "B players" end up contributing in important moments, like Asensio in the CL final against Juve.
Now watching when he just got sacked
Who's wife and kids was he out at dinner with? Can't ever be sure with old JT
😂😂😂
P.3YD 1 bridge's
Biggest scumbag in football, carragher aswell
Good one 😂
@@sookmajoaby why ?
Zlatan once said “I could go out and kill for Mourinho”, that kinda motivation he gives to his players.
JT is great! Calm and his explanations are 🔥 🔥
wack nah wont go that far
He'd be a good pundit. One of the easier ones to listen to and has a charm and cheekier side about him, too, which you'd know if you've watched enough of his interviews
wack...you are a fool
Terry is one of those players you hate on the other team but is very good when he is your teamate.
Mn B unless you're a full back
Terry, one night on the job and looks like a natural
thats what your wife said
a natural thicko and thug?
@@Fleathemighty 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Just don't your wives around him
Alonso
“Fans in Spain rate him very highly and I admire him a huge amount. To me Paul is a role model. He is the best midfielder I’ve seen in the last 15 or 20 years.”
Best
“The boy can play”
Charlton
“Paul Scholes is my favourite player. He epitomises the spirit of Manchester United and everything that is good about football.”
Davids
“Every one of us is just trying to become as good as him. Everyone can learn from Paul Scholes”
Fabregas
“He is the one whose level I aspire to. He is the best player in the Premier League.”
Ferdinand
“Paul Scholes, aka Sat Nav, went from a scoring midfielder to a dictator of the game (changed his game while still at top of the game). Genius.”
Figo
“I’m star-struck when I see Paul Scholes because you never see him. On the pitch you can’t catch him. Off the pitch he disappears.”
Giggs
“I have played with some great players during my time at United but I would have to put Paul Scholes down as the best.”
Guardiola
“He is the best midfielder of his generation. I would have loved to have played alongside him.”
Henry
“I can’t understand why Scholes has never won the player of the year award. He should have won it long ago. Maybe it’s because he doesn’t seek the limelight like some of the other ‘stars’.”
Law
“He’s the best all-round. A joy to watch.”
Lippi
“Paul Scholes would have been one of my first choices for putting together a great team.”
Maradonna
“His technique is unique.”
Mourinho
“Why isn’t he playing for England? It is crazy. Only in England. Scholes is a great, great player. So experienced and still, for me, one of the best in the world in midfield. Manchester United are lucky to have him.”
Nasri
“Sad to hear Paul Scholes is retiring, great player, world class player, the English Zizou.”
Pallister
“When you talk about the greats of Manchester United, he’s up there with Georgie Best, Bryan Robson, Ryan Giggs and Bobby Charlton just purely for the amount of medals that he’s won, he’s going to be greatly missed by Manchester United.”
Pele
“If he was playing with me, I would score so many more.”
Ronaldinho
“I want to pass like him. Who taught him how to do that?”
Ronaldo
“Scholes is the best i’ve played with and he helped me a lot when I was young. He’s amazing.”
Rooney
“The best player I’ve played with or against.”
Schevchenko
“They have two of the world’s best young players in Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney, but the player who most impresses me is Paul Scholes. He is United’s most important player, he makes most things happen on the field.”
Shearer
“If you ask footballers to pick out the player they most admire, so many of them will pick Paul Scholes.”
Xavi
“In the last 15 to 20 years the best central midfielder that I have seen - the most complete - is Scholes. I have spoken with Xabi Alonso about this many times. Scholes is a spectacular player who has everything. He can play the final pass, he can score, he is strong, he never gets knocked off the ball and he doesn’t give possession away. If he had been Spanish then maybe he would have been valued more.”
Zidane
“My toughest opponent? Scholes of Manchester. He is the complete midfielder. You rarely come across the complete footballer, but Scholes is as close to it as you can get.’”
Wow you must have no life to comment all of this. Lmao
Wow you must have no brain to think i wrote all that.__ Ever heard of copy and paste??? Lmaooo
So I'm dumb for thinking something you commented was written by you. Ok... also to find all of those quotes, and then copy and paste all of that is still pretty pathetic.
They were all in the same place and i knew where to find them in 2 seconds. Stop crying like a lil b.itch. Scholes was the best... Fact
Fight me
8:26 “you was definitely a moaner” 🤣🤣🤣
His face when he says it too. Like he is flirting... WTF
Love listening to JT. Always disliked him unfairly during his playing career. He certainly does come across well. Needs to be on Sky more regularly
All 3 players were world class but not sure you can really comapre. Gerrard for me is the best all round midfielder, but Scholes would control the whole game and could create a bit of magic (similar to Gerrard) but Lamps goal scoring record speaks for itself. All 3 were different and had different qualities.
Eyedeas Never Die very different midfielder
In your opinion you cannot compare the three central midfielders because they had different styles? Thank goodness you were never a manager.
He was playing at a top ten European club and he won the silver Ballon Dor and the Silver Fifa player of the year. He was the Uefa midfielder of the year. So in your opinion Scholes was not world class? Gerrard was not world class?
As for the flair part, I'm guessing you have never watched lampards goals.
Gloria, you are aware that Lampard was the closest out of Gerrard and Scholes to win a Ballon D'or, hate to be that stat guy but look how many assists and goals Lampard got compared to Scholes, and Scholes was in world class teams, even Ronaldinho urged Barcelona to sign Lampard.
lmao wtf is this? am i having a dream
I never realised how articulate John Terry is. This is an awesome interview. JT will undoubtedly make a supreme manager , id put my house on it.
Better get used to the cold then
Maybe I should know better, but I didn't know Terry was such a great speaker.
He was the the captain of Chelsea and England for a reason
Respect to john terry about thierry henry
Thierry Henry was amazing my all time favorite
12:10
The best player in premier League ever Henry.
Dafyd Maddz biggest load of waffle I’ve ever read
JT basically said "well I have to say Lampard...but really Scholes" 😂😂
Haha that's how I heard it too
Nah he liked Scholes Wife more than Lampards
The midlfilerds of today need to watch the long yards paces of scholes
He said Lamps but deep down they both know it is Scholes. All three were phenomenal players but there was a reason Pep's Barcelona team studied classes on Scholesy at Le Mesia.
Xavi "In the last 15 to 20 years the best central midfielder that I have seen, the most complete, is Scholes".
"He can play the final pass, he can score, he is strong, he never gets knocked off the ball and he doesn’t give possession away. If he had been Spanish then maybe he would have been valued More."
Zidane "My toughest opponent? Scholes of Manchester. He is the complete midfielder. Scholes is undoubtedly the greatest midfielder of his generation."
Pirlo "The only great English midfielder in my career was Paul Scholes. He has elegance in him. Others were pretenders."
Ronaldo "He is the phenomenon."
Bielsa "There is but one truly serious philosophical problem and that is Paul Scholes."
Show less
Kurt what over Gerrard? Are you high? Scholes wasn’t anywhere near as good as lampard let alone Gerrard.
I could listen to John Terry talking all day, for someone of his stature he is humble, honest and a better speaker than I thought he would be, no wonder he has been a top captain for so long. Dare to say he probably learned a lot from playing and training with Lauren Blanc and Marcel Dessailly - the immovable object and the unstoppable force.
You trolling?
He’s an absolute div
@@kencarson3451 Sounds like you are as well.
When did he play and train with Laurent Blanc (im guessing thats who you meant, never heard of lauren blanc)????
Oh thats right he didn't
He became captain @ 21.
I would love to see the show, where Carra, Neville, Terry, Lampard, Gerrard etc., maybe some legends from other countries would sat together and talk about football, like their biggest personal enemy, friend in team, greatest/worst moments. NBA does that thing perfectly with NBA Open Court and I want the same thing but about football
Carra not keeping in touch with any teammates is just sad, you spend every day with them, so most would definitely have good friends
Ot is rumoured that during his time with the bulls rodman and jordan did not speak
John Terry is very well spoken!! He'll be a great TV host!!
Blokes a prat but a great talker and so much better than carra
5:06 Tactically we wus a lot bettah , how organised we was .
Yeah very well spoken for a shaved ape
Terry, well spoken? Chavtastic.
@@willybigshow1042 thats just his accent
Young city assbandit. Yeah but to say that he's well spoken is an insult to humanity
The professionalism of JT resonates to this day. One of England's greatest ever defenders and was sold on the idea of winning no matter what.
jt is so calm and relax makes it easier to understand his points.
If I wanted a 60 yard ping on six pence I’d pick Scholes. If I wanted to comeback from three goals down I’d pick Gerrard. If I wanted goals per game I’d pick Lampard.
Couldn't have said it any better
Just one comeback bullshit
@@tejasmohite2651 one?
You mean five pence?
Connor - How about Didi Hamann's role in that European Cup final 3-3 comeback?
If I wanted to win a game of football I'd pick Scholes.
Villa fan here. It's truly a privilege to have JT wearing the captain armband for us. If we're fortunate enough to get promoted, I'd be 100% ok if he sat out the Chelsea matches.
Me" after listening John I can understand English easily!
Carragher" no don't you dare to listen me 😂
What a great discussion. I was captivated the entire time.
JT is a natural... A leader and the best defender of his generation.
Rio Ferdinand was much much better and won far more. Liverpool fan. Ricardo Carvalho carried Terry for years as did Rio at international
yeap natural cheater as well, ask his wife lol
Mark Newton Rio Ferdinand was miles better
Vdic and Rio
Ferdinand was overrated. He only looked good because he had vidic next to him
Carragher has no friends 😂😂😂
Jayson Kwok lmfao
Jayson Kwok why would he care he’s ruthless like that
Doesn’t have friends but he had a champions league trophy mate! YNWA
Arthur Kennington haha
what about a league title?
Great interview! Always hated John Terry, purely because he was such a good player. I must admit, it's great listening to him talk. Respectful, knowledgeable. 🤝
Everton fan here. For me Gerrard was definitely the most well rounded out of himself, Lampard and Scholes. He could do absolutely everything on a football pitch. All three were magnificent players but Gerrard for me was the best. He would have won absolutely everything in the game if he had left Liverpool.
well you in full right to have your opinion in this but Scholes never folded during the big games. And i dont only mean the Leuge games but in the national team as well. Lampard and Gerrard acted like frightend Children as soon as they got the national shirt on them. Two HUGE players in their clubs but never lived up to anything at the biggest stage there is. But that is just my 2 cents of an opinion. :)
1 Scholes
2 Gerrard
3 Lampard
As a liverpool fan i 100% agree with the fact gerrard would have won the lot had he left for a team like real madrid. If he was in the team now under klopp in his prime we'd have won the finals we were in and probably the league this year. Mainly because of the leadership he brings as opposed to his quality. The previous finals we got to we lost mainly because of lack of experience in the big occasion and mentality. The current liverpool squad is more equipped right now mentality wise and thats as important as quality.
Fascinating insight by JT and excellent moderation by the host!
Scholes came out of retirement to win United the league
They would not have won it without him
If you don't understand how good Scholes was then it's a real shame
You are really missing out
Scholes doesn't take pens or freekicks either
Ryan W nah I just saw what he can do
And now I see no one else around is in the same league
Is it a coincidence that United aren't the same without him?
Ryan W it doesnt take utd fan to know that, its common sense
Why didn't Scholes take freekicks or penalties? Because he was as good at them as the other two! Is that safe to say?
Anthony Mcintyre no idea
But if you are talking about goals
Scholes is damn close to Gerrard in goals from open play
And he spent the majority of his career playing further back
You are very wrong about Scholes being deployed further back. Do you not remember Scholes, the attacking midfielder of the nineties and early noughties? He was still playing as a false nine on occasion when Van Nisterlooy was there. The thing that gets me is, Scholes in Europe, did not control games. He was dropped for so many big games by Ferguson and despite his awesome ability, he did not really have the huge impact on certain matches that Gerrard and lampard had. Man Utd fans can tell people to shut up all they want about the tackling but he was horrendous on so many occasions, although I miss him and Keane bullying midfields with their bullish defensive nous while still playing the other side of the game in such a elegant manner.
Now I have stated the issues I have with Scholes, but I still see him as the one of if not the best English midfielder of a generation. After debating the Scholes/Lampard/Gerrard thing for nearly a decade, I've decided that there really is so little between them when you look at how they affected a game at the very top level.
In the twilight years of there careers, Scholes wins hands down because of his style.
At the edge of he box probably the most exciting players in premier league history as a collective. This has been said so many times - Had England the right manager at the time, I think England win a World Cup or a European championship.
Adding this gem, to my playlist. Can learn a lot from these two players!
I have to say, I know JT is at Villa and honing his management skills there but.........he comes across as very sharp, perceptive, confident and knowledgeable. Carragher didn't interrupt him either when he spoke - like he does with Gary Neville. JT just commands respect from whoever he is in the company of and that in itself speaks volumes. He was a brilliant captain for Chelsea, possibly their grestest ever - right up there with Tony Adams at Arsenal - I'm a City fan too but I hope one day JT becomes a good PL manager, it would be great to see hm pacing up and down the touchline Mourinho-esque and bawling someone out.
As a non-English speaker, I'm struggling to understand Carragher's words because of his accent
That’s coz he’s Scouse, not English
It's ok, the English struggle to understand him as well.
You thick . Im English . Attention seekers pretend hes hard to understand .
English people struggle to understand a Scouse accent sometimes
Nguyễn Hải Dương Ross Barkley is quite hard to understand his accent too
Lampard : the best Attacking Mdf
Scholes: the best playmaker
Gerrard : the best Box to Box Mdf
in Today's game though .. Lamps fits perfect!
Gerrard > Lampard > Scholes
Kyle Muckian
Gerrard < Lampard < Scholes
Lampard>Gerrard, Scholes
The truth is they r all different players and i would say all of them r on the same level
Gerrard and lampard above scholes?.....I laugh in cantonese
Stevie was more complete and a great leader. Scholesy was a genius on the ball, but not off it and Lamps was best finisher. Pity that England never found a way to get the best out of them in the same team. JT is an absolute gem and I could listen to him all day long.
Lampard and Gerard was better on the ball for me. Id never see scholes scoring and running past prime real Madrid/AC Milan players.
@@hamzah1325 He did prime Barcelona semi final and knocked out argubarly the great team out ya tit.
@@hamzah1325 lol kid doesnt watch football properly
@@hamzah1325 Scholes was that gifted he didn't dribble because he knew where to pass before he even had the ball. Same mentality as Xavi and Iniesta who are worse versions of the same template. The heartbeat of the team so to speak. Give and go.
How many times did scholes win player of the season for the premier League, no infact how many times did he win player of the season in man utds awards. 0, not one award, no team of the years. He was very good don't get me wrong, but Gerrard and lampard were in the ballondor podiums, Toty multiple times. Gerrard has the most totys in the premier League. He was the best player in his position in 8 years, that's crazy. Scholes never did. Lampard played in 10,8,6 roles like Gerrard, still got the most goals for a midfield and doing what scholes did. I'm sorry I can't agree that scholes is better.
Say what you like about Terry, that defensive diving header for England shows why he was so revered as a player, a defender and a captain.
Lamps, Didier, Ash, Ivanovic, Peter Cech
great interview, good insights!
I'm a United fan. Loved watching scholes. What He did mostly went unnoticed, a great player, great passed and could control the tempo of a midfield. As much as I hate to say it, so could the other two. They scored important goals at important times, as did Scholes, but not as often. I wouldn't pick one of them. They all had something special and were all as important to their respective clubs as each other.
Lies again? GSL GST
@@NazriB What?
Well obviously you’d say that, didn’t need to mention how you were a United fan 🤣
Well said
well said, altho scholsey was miles ahead at controlling a game imo, it's why players love him
for me i cant say whos best love all 3 and im a chelsea fan
scholes =maestro
lampard =talisman
gerrard =powerhouse
all 3 are different but all 3 can shoot,pass,score goals,tackle etc...
bEwater LEE scholes couldn’t tackle to save his life
@@MisterMahseer yes he could
I disagree Scholes and Lampard couldn`t tackle to save their lives also Gerrard was a born leader on top of his skills
Every time Scholes tried to tackle the only thing he won was a yellow card, lol
Scholes is the best mildfielder England would ever have,Gerald comes second and Lampard 3 but Scholesy is equal to none not only in English game but in the entire world of football,period
Gerrard and lampard were class but scholes was just next level
no gerrard and lampard were both way better than scholes
Scholes was just next level he even allowed Milner to have more assists than him in the premier league
wharsmetoothpicson how much assist does your club's winger have this season??
Peter Crouch got more assists than scholes mate
Anyone who says Gerrard and Lampard were better clearly didn't see Scholes at his peak.
Best interview and insight I have seen. John Terry has opened my eyes further.
As an arsenal fan that Chelsea dressing room at the time was full of winners just listening to the names he mentioned , Lamps, Dider, Cole, Peter and the German captain Ballack. Brilliant honestly.
Dont u forget that cole was a judas to arsenal
Terry’s voice is so soothing 🥺
That's how he ended up sleeping with teammates wives
Little wonder how he nailed bridges' broad.
Wow. i love the way Terry speaks. Very professional
Scholes was the best at passing, Lampard was the best at shooting and imo Gerrard was a jack of trades as he was good all round so for that reason i'd say Gerrard but to each his own opinion!
Good points.........I was just thinking as an Arsenal fan. I'd say Gerrard was the best all rounder. Lampard got so many goals. Scholes was no better passer than Gerrard and he couldn't tackle. 1. Gerrard 2. Lampard 3, Scholes.
Good at slipping too.
Childish comment.
Gerrard's passing was as good as Scholes and long shots were as good as Lampard. But Scholes concentrated on being a ball playing midfielder, Lampard concentrated on being a fox in the box, Gerrard concentrated on being everything!
Mr Slippy,.
As a West Ham fan John is one of the best centre half’s to play the game. Hates me to say it but he was a quality captain
Yeah as a United fan, he was sensational, especially watching him against Barcelona, he would block everything, that Chelsea team was really strong and only team to keep Barcelona at bay.
Would love a Cb roundtable of Rio, Terry, Vidic, Sol Campbell talking about defending !!
carra read this and cried
Can imagine that with Rio and Terry there. Good luck
Scholes - Talent
Gerrard - All round
Lampard - Hard worker
Darts Re no wonder
Lampard hard worker?? He was an elite goal scorer
James Odeku yes I agree - also he was maybe not as natural as scores so I’m saying he worked hard for what he had
Darts Re Scholes had talent and he was a really hard worker. Lampard had talent and he was a very hard worker. Gerrard had talent and he was a semi hard worker. It's funny that people generalize the greats. They are all hard workers and they all have great talent or you wouldn't be talking about them.
Juan Ramirez stop arguing of course they all work hard and have talent
Frank Lampard. His goal-tally is compared to striker's records. Scholes is a different player though. He's more of a deep-lying playmaker who dictated games from the centre of the park, and was brilliant at it. Lampard/Gerrard were more directly involved in attacking play, in which Lampard easily comes out on top.
Lampard is an example to young kids on how to get the best out of yourself. but in terms of ability scholes was just miles ahead of him, it probably was too easy for him in training so he didnt really have someone to aim for, was always just a given that scholes was best in training.. Gerrard had everything to be fair, very english in style but such a force.
Mn B as an example to kids Lampard for sure. I think Lampard is the only top player I know who actually got physically better in his mid 20s, can't think of another example? Footballing wise different players and hard to compare.
Why does it always come down to goals though. Terry has scored more goals than Iniesta. Doesn't make him a better midfielder or even player than him does it.
Poor example. Terry was a defender so he's main goal was to prevent conceeding goals. But the fact that he managed to kept cleansheets AND score more than 20 goals is outstanding for a centre back.
Lampard and Gerrard are primarily attack minded midfielders so their job is to assist/score goals and dictate plays. That is why they are rated by goals.
I think it is almost wrong to class lampard in the 05-08 chelsea teams as a central midfielder. He was pretty much playing as a number 10 who would attempt to get back to defend but barely and would be off again getting close to drogba. Not saying that was a bad thing, it worked in that chelsea system but to say he was a central midfielder scoring all those goals is a bit misleading.
John Terry what a absolute class act great pro that from a utd fan, loyalty & professional.
I'm a lifelong City fan and 100% agree.
Mad respect from JT towards Mou. Love to see it ❤️
Really good insight. Love video like this.
CFC finest....brilliant defender
JM forever in our hearts 💯🔥
JT so good at this💯
Some insightful questions put forward by the interviewer and he chaired this superbly.
So Scholes then
Joker I
Scholes came out of retirement at 37 and nearly won Man Utd the league with his contribution in 2012. He has 11 premiership titles! And is very highly regarded by the elite of football. I spent years watching him dictate games like nobody else, was truly stunning to watch. But then you could get all on your high horse cos he couldn’t tackle, doesn’t have as many assists as you’d think and surprisingly wasn’t hyped by uefa/fifa/F.A like the other 2
colin mcmahon name me the season where Scholes was the best player in his team. Not saying he got carried but it’s really easy to be good in a team full of world beaters. Giggs ronaldo Keane cantona. When you have these guys in your team it’s so much easier. I ask you this question, if you take Scholes from united and put gerrard in that team, what changes?
Steve Gerrard you're literally in every comment where someone admits scholes was the best out of three. Give yourself a break once you're not convincing anyone especially with your profile picture and name it's easy to see you're quite biased. Oh yeah btw Toni kroos the other day picked scholes out of the three as the best just another great footballer who knew scholes was by far the most technically gifted and superiror to the other two.
Steve Gerrard jhon Terry didn't even mention Gerrard but even he couldn't deny that scholes was naturally the best in terms of ability.
Steve Gerrard i would say 2002-2003 he was definitely the best player in that Man U team. And yeah i get he was surrounded by class and Gerrard would have won plenty at Chelsea or Man Utd. But on the otherhand Stevie G played in some brilliant sides. Like in 2001, 2009 and 2014. I don’t like the myth of him being the big fish in a small pond at Liverpool
Steve Gerrard you're not gonna win anything or convince anyone with your comments especially in a UA-cam comment section there is no hiarchy in these sections just opinions made by fans that have no impact on the actual footballing stage whatsoever.
The way Carra describes struggling to play right back against Henry, Cole and Pires is like how I feel every football match
terry :mourniho was so good he touched our heart in a deep meaningful way
carra : did rafa ever touch you ? hahahaha
I love Terry as a pundit
Tee M He is a manager in the making not Pundit
Ezenwata Damian you’re absolutely right about that
"You are there to win"-Carra
How ironic when u won squat.
Champions League. Fifth one, mate.
Six by Saturday 10pm.
Going back on that discussion Carra brought about Chelsea managing young talents, I'm looking at what Tuchel is doing now at Chelsea with the young players and it gives me great satisfaction because I know Chelsea won't keep losing players that can be influential in the next 3-5 years.
But we lost Tammy
JT come across very well, great discussion
Wow, great talk by JT . You should have more interviews with him especially on match days . As a Chelsea fan , he was and will be one of greatest Chelsea players in my mind . ALWAYS MY CAPTAIN , thumps
6:00 about the 4 or 5 players who would run the dressing room, Emery started off at Arsenal and said straight away he wants 5 or 6 captains. I understand what he means now.
Good ebening
This video was from December 2017. It's October 2019. I want to see JTs updated view on Chelsea now.
One of the most fascinating footie discussions I have heard
It's pretty mad really the amount of backlash by fans in this debate towards Scholes, when in reality when you look at the remarks made by all the great players of this generation such as Iniesta, Zidane and Xavi, all of which presumably have more insight and knowledge than any of us commenting, they say Scholes was leaps and bounds ahead. Even Toni Kroos said it last week when asked on Twitter..
TJ yeah Scholes is better than both, the man with less assists than James Milner and Thierry Henry. Definitely better than Gerrard and Lampard, without a shadow of a doubt
Remember when Gerrard retired, the amount of legends that spoke about him regarding him as the best midfielder of his generation
That means absolutely nothing, and even if it did, for every quote by a major player in praise of Scholes, you can find another in praise of Gerrard - from Zidane, Henry, Pirlo, Kaka, etc. - to make it meaningless. Google them if you like.
bananapotato Zidane - “Gerrard was the best midfield player in the world, it is unusual to get complete midfield players who can do everything, but that’s what he was”
bananapotato Alex Ferguson - “he has become the most influential player in England, bar none”
Scholes is a Regista,
Gerrard is a box to box midfielder
Lampard is an attacking midfielder.
It's like asking, Pirlo vs Iniesta vs Vidal.
Put Football Manager down lad, they all played CM for England in a 4-4-2, thus it's worthy of debate, it's nothing like Pirlo/Iniesta/ Vidal...
How could you even put Vidal in the same sentence as iniesta and pirlo
What is a regista?
Lampard is box to box, Gerrard is attacking midfielder
Dean what a great comment.
All this bullshit, regista, trequartista
John Terry is intelligent.
When he was asked about KDB, Lukaku, and Salah. I love how he answered the question. Those players came to Chelsea when Chelsea team has incredible players
Pleasantly surprised by Terry. He kind of admitted Scholes was the best really...
12:05 Henry still giving him nightmares 😂
3:34
there were players like that and that's why Mou used to be successful, he comes in at Man Utd and you have the most undisciplined players of all time with the likes of Paul Pogba and all these young guys who don't have their head in the game. They'll be unhappy with a coach who'll smack em around if they slack off. So it was either letting go of Pogba or Mou, Pogba was expensive so Mou was let go, its the players fault for underperforming, not mou's bad management
Year old comment but man to think Terry - club captain, club legend, and the defensive stalwart the season prior, to be substituted at half-time and simply admit "the manager's the boss" is almost unheard of in today's age.
Genuinely what's lacking in modern society today, the ability to just suck it up and move on.
What a terrific interview. John Terry is a natural.
I never have gotten totally used to seeing and listening to former players - even stalwarts of their respective teams - as these two, only talking about the sport.. For so many years they were just simply a huge part of what was happening on the pitch in my sport of football, every week!!.. Miss em still being out there, for sure!!
Gerrard was the most complete, Lampard was the best at getting goals but Scholes was the best of the three. His passing and vision was comfortably above both. Gerrard and Lampard were very good passers but at times struggled with their passing under pressure, and didn't have that same level of complex passing Scholes did. Scholes in his prime was incredible. His dribbling was so good when he was in his early to mid 20's. Add to that, he had a knack for scoring great goals. The only downside was his reckless tackling, which was intentional more than it was clumsy.
Viktor Kruger that's the truth tho
Assane Keita
No it’s not
Gerrard was the best passer for a Time in the pl
He’s not as good as Scholes but they are relatively close
Lampard and Gerrard both passed well under-pressure, check Lampards assist to Ramires against Barcelona in 2012, produced an amazing through ball at an awkward angle. But indeed Scholes was the better passer, however shouldn't discount that Gerrard and Lampard were both excellent passers, out of the three, Scholes had the passing, Gerrard was the all round midfielder who had stamina and to control a game all by himself not to mention a hard worker, and Lampard was the composed excellent goal scoring midfielder who can produce a great pass, and was also hard working same as Gerrard.
only a man utd fan would put Scholes above Gerrard. Seriously, if you ask a neutral fan on who he would pick of the 3 in his team 90% will choose Gerrard. When Real Madrid wants you, it means something.
Ioannis just ask Guardiola, Zidane, Xavi etc etc who's the best
“Should we be giving players a chance” ... oh how times have changed 😁 come on Lampard
Good listen this episode, 💯
I like when he asks Carra if he and Gerrard ran the dressing room “uhhh yeah?” Lol just say no.
Terry is on another level to Carra, we all know this.
Of course Carra ran the dressing room, he is a scouser.
John Terry really broke down the loanee system well, it is imperative that a potential has experience to REALISE that potential. You can't expect a young baller to be great from the start unless you're a prodigy like Messi.. I agree with JT
Loads of love from Afghanistan to John Terry u n lamp fantastic great players n loveable guys.. what he said about Mourinho was spot on even zlatan Ibrahimovic said exactly the same to Mourinho.. he expect from u 200%
As a Chelsea & Jose's fan, I'm so glad I've watched this
Scholes on another level compared to other two. Lampard scored the most but took penalties for 10 years. Gerrard was well-rounded but didn't win enough. Scholes scored 100+ goals and is comfortably the best technically. Scholes also won the most silverware and came out of retirement to win the league for the 11th time.
silverware comes down to being in the best team although i do think he is better than the other two
hustler666100 Gerrard is miles better. Name one time Scholes actually changed a game like Gerrard did against Olympiacos,West Ham,AC Milan etc.
Funny Scholes is always called the maestro of the 3 but had the least assists of the 3
"Gerrard was well-rounded but didn't win enough"?? Thats down to the team not him as a player.
Hereward of Liverpool maybe he shouldn’t have slipped
1. Scholes
2. Lampard
3. Have a nice trip, see you next fall.
@825Gabe WTF
See your dad in the hospital with life support
Savage! 😂😂
what about when terry slipped ? champions league hahahahha
1.Lampard 2.Scholes
Fair play to you John... The Manager makes the decision, players understand & accept that
Love how he makes sure to mention Ivandinho.
I've never seen Scholes have a bad game, even if he got sent off he had a good game. I think the neutral supporters are the better judge on this one and most people pick Scholes. People will talk about who scored more goals but Scholes could score goals too. The difference is Lampard and Gerrard didn't have the ability Scholes had when it came to controlling a game, first touch, making the right pass, he could do everything even headers. Iniesta even named his son after Paul Scholes. Xavi even said he was the best midfielder of his generation. They literally modeled their games on him and they were part of arguably the best footballing side of their generation so that alone speaks volumes. Only true footballing fans pick Scholes. People who enjoy the heart, workrate, kick and rush of the game will pick Gerrard. If you appreciate the hard worker and goalscoring midfielder then you pick Lampard. It's all preference but the top top level neutral footballers always pick Scholes so that settles it all.
The Bizness ai think neutral will pick Gerrard or Lampard over Scholes as they are bigger brands comparatively. Besides I haven't seen many people talking about Scholes whereas Gerrard and Lampard were the talking points of that period. Maybe Scholes was under the radar in such a talented united side. But it's a fact that most neutral will pick either Gerrard or lampard.
@@nazmulfahad3044 nah arsenal, Tottenham, City and Leeds fans pick Scholes
Iniesta and Xavi might think that but they rarely played either.
When Shearer Wright and another retired PL player had to make their PL all time xi. They didn't even give Scholes a mention. They instantly went to Gerrard, Lampard, Viera, and Kean. All of those (perhaps not Wright but still) played all three way more then Xavi and Iniesta did.
If you wanna make the argument that Scholes is better because other players think so. You'd have to ignore that other players with more experience on them preferred Lampard and Gerrard.