Piers Debates Transgender Activist Over Genderless Acting Awards | Good Morning Britain
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 тра 2017
- Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
Piers and Susanna talk to transgender activist Juno Dawson about the ways younger people are engaging with non-binary or genderless identities following the introduction of 'gender-free' acting categories at the MTV Movie Awards.
Broadcast on 09/05/17
Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
The Good Morning Britain UA-cam channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
Join Susanna Reid, Piers Morgan, Ben Shephard, Kate Garraway, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am.
Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
UA-cam: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
www.itv.com - Розваги
If sex and gender are two different things, then you shouldn't complain or demand for gender neutral awards, because those two categories simply fall in the description of sex not gender.
Exactly ❤
Checkmate
Exactly
Gender is sex and sex is gender.
It has always been this way for thousands of years.
Mic drop!
This video was years ago, now look at where we are. Absolute clown world.
This comment was 10 months ago now look at where we are 😂
^ This comment was a month ago, now look at where we are. Disgusting 😂
@@Manzell5 this comment was 54 minutes ago NOW look where we are!!
@@NecessaryDramaAddictionNDA that was 2 mins ago, NOW!!! Look at where we are
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@Manzell5 48 mins. I’ll revisit this in one week!
If you can't accept the way or what you were born to be then 90% of society won't accept you either..
Thats true
Please see ecyranot's response in reply to the previous thread.
@Benny-FrankI don’t think he was talking third person ?
Period 🎤
@Benny-Frankdefinitely forgot to switch accounts 😂
"The nurse decided the sex.." No. When someone is handed a basketball, he doesn't "decide" it is round. He makes an empirical observation. That's what people do upon seeing an infant - if it has a penis, it's male, if it has a vagina, it's female. Of course there are marginal exceptions but generally, sex is almost completely binary.
😭😂😂 seek a therapist
@@lildunks272 Ah, ad hominem... the only retort for people who cannot make a logical argument.
@@lildunks272ou the one who need therapy
@@lildunks272 hahahahah
Your mortal self laugh too
Well... this is a man. Clear like water.
SMH
No why should he be fired
The “M” on my birth certificate next to gender stands for Male, not makeup.
It doesn't stand for maybe?
I thought it was called fashion , not gender. Hair, makeup clothing
the world has gone mad.what the f**k is being discussed.
Well , rather than seeking an excellent psychologist and or psychiatrist, to have a come to Jesus moment of biological facts , we as a confused nation , that are afraid of hurting anyone’s feelings , prefer chaos !
@@cricketshields8664 what would Jesus do?
@@s-max3941Jesus would accept transgender people for who they are and love them as his children because he’s our father right? He loves every single and one of us whether we are transgender or not.
@@casstitudy That's a lie and we both know that. Jesus would say wait for the punishment to come down.. pls wake up
@@s-max3941 bruh you wake up. Being transgender and being born one is NOT a crime. Besides, transgenders will and have always existed in history, so suck it up and deal with it because they will always be here whether we like it or not or whether your religion or Jesus likes it or not.
I identify as a dinosaur. My pronouns are RAWR/ GRRR. If you dont accept that, you are a dinophobe.
😂
Are you a Trannosaurus Rex?
@@TrevC-co6xk 😆 🤣
HAHAHAHAAHAHHAAHHAAHA
Lol
“I can’t understand what it is to be deaf if I’ve never been deaf” but he understood what it was to be a woman even though he had never been one. Interesting
Good catch!!!
Edit: the sh*t is confusing and when they talk they make it even more confusing
Way to miss the point. Trans "women" claim to be women due to this idea that they think like women...But it's literally impossible for them to know how actual women think, since they're not adult human females.
@@jkweilimaybe you just aren't intelligent
😂 the contradictions are never ending
Yes exactly
PLUS the comparison between trans and deaf is a totally stupid argument based on a false equivalence.
There’s no option to chose if one is deaf or not and a hearing person may be able to imitate a deaf person but a deaf person can never imitate a hearing person.
Plus it’s not a feeling or an internal concept. It’s a fundamental difference in how they experience the physical reality of the world the deaf person lives in and how the world interacts with them.
This is just SICK! My god!!
Leave god out of this.
@@lonewulfmo9128 it's fuc.... sick
🤮🤮🤮🤮🤢🤢 that thing looks very weird
I love how he shops himself when he says sex, for mammals, is binary. Thank and goodnight.
Someone abused this man at a very, very early age & grew up confused.
Yes, it's very possible that's what happened. Being trans can be a trauma response.
The nurse doesn’t decide the sex of a new born baby, she/he merely calls out what she/he sees.
I have a bad feeling that my kids will live terrible times when they will reach my age. Mad World to step in.
Sex is not just about your genitals dude! Beneath and inside those gonads are chromosomes, XX and XY.
And one in 600 amabs have XXY
1 in 600 males.
It used to be an easy phrase to say.
Actually gender is derived from male and female sex and its connoted by social cultures which are inspired by the male and female sex( state of being). lets not confuse people here. And also the mere fact that LGBT is always interjecting when people speak is because they are not trained to reason they are trained to impose, it seems a little bit occultic for me. They seem to be like people who are meant to protect and impose a certain cult and they are frustrated by anyone who challenge them because we shouldn't be disagreeable instead we should just adapt which i find very weird.
I mean you’re right, it’s free speech, it should be allowed and I’m sorry that the transgender community is making people like me look terrible and uneducated or spoiled. I promise not all of us are like that, people just pick the bad apples out without listening to our own organized debates. You’re allowed and should be free to say whatever you want even if it’s discrimination.
Okay!
I identify as an Ambulance 🚑
My pronouns are WEE/WOO 💯
100%ing yourself looks a bit weak.
All transgender should compete with fellow transgender in every kind of sport
It would be a way forward, for sure.
This is just ridiculous how confusing it is . I mean it's not Multiple Variable Calculus nor Differential Equations. It's Nothing more than Gender Babble.
As a teenager myself I've seen kids YOUNGER then me(15) claim to be transgender as a trend which is apsoloutly and utterly stupid tbh. I respect transgender people as in male, female and ill even respect non binary, but give me more than those i will laugh in your face. And now they want to get rid of actress/actor categories. Thats just mad.
Actually reasonable. I'm dating a trans woman and she's the sweetest person ever, I respect everything about her. But going beyond that seems like a bit much. The true LGBTQ community just wants it to be that LGBTQ not LGBTQIA2++ stuff
Man they keep trying to say this has existed forever, its BS.
How can you change the world if you can't make your mind up whether you're boy or girl.
I identify as a garden gnome
🗿😹
@@candytime-_- don’t laugh! You stand in the garden and see what it feels like having a cat or dog piss on you or shit whilst trying to hold a smile.
@@tonymontana7097 💀🤣🤣
Those don't talk
@@Raven_Fable no sh1t!!! How did you know??
Funny how in many languages sex and gender translates to one word
god! let me get this straight:
when i was a child, i was taught that there are 2 genders: male and female. and THATS IT.
people are now giving UNWANTED meanings to these words, like, wth?
guys, i am so embarassed to ask this simple question but, somebody pls tell me, whats the meaning of 'they'?
People who claim they are neither female or male want to use “they” as a pronoun, because it’s neither feminine or masculine.
It’s a red herring to claim that “they” can only be used when referring to the plural. “They” has been used to refer to the singular for a very long time. Often instead of using s/he.
The real issue is - how to you work out you’re not female or male?
It can surely only be done by seeing whether you like things ascribed to women, or men.
Yet, we have known for a long time, that many women like doing things that were once thought manly, like earning a wage and voting, and many men enjoy doing things once thought feminine, like feeding, and changing babies.
Your sex is not at birth your sex is determined at conception
This dude with this adams apple
I would call her an abstract trans-artist. She manage to transform from a feminine male into an ugly lady. This is pure abstract art.
It's a sick world. I'm glad I don't have children. Someone once said to me, "Do not have children." I now understand why. It's no longer safe or simple to raise children. I blame these people. They make it seem 'cool' to children who have no idea. Children like to be 'cool' and 'different'.....
3:58
As a teenager, let me be very clear. No doubt the elders are gonna feel a generation gap with us on these topics of trans rights and gender identities, but no rational minded person, regardless of their age, would ever agree on the logical existence of around a 100 gender identities. It's completely and utterly absurd! Gender identities have now become a trend among people of my age and I find it a waste of time with no use of brains. Out of those 100 gender identities, around 5 or 6 sound logical to me at least.
Exactly! I’m a transgender person but I believe it can be categorized into three gender identities: male, female, non-binary/transgender umbrella. Gender shouldn’t have to be a trend, it should be a self expression and just move on with our days.
@@casstitudy I'm glad someone from the trans community is agreeing with me.
If you have a penis Your Man if you have a vagina you're a woman that is basic biology that is science
Piss poor
Three or four genders is reasonable and traditional in many cultures
The delusion in the world today is ASTOUNDING.
“They talk about gender in a very different way” because they have been fed all these confusing choices…poor kids
I'm surprised Some people actually put up to this stupidity. This is nuts.
I can't believe this is the interviews people like to see nowadays.
That guy just looks totally ridiculous! 🤣🤣🤣 How the presenters keep a straight face is beyond me!
Mr Rodgers is not rolling in his grave he's trying to dig himself out.
Just look at her facial expressions. That woman is completely gone
Man.
Sorry but there's only one woman in that studio.
I thought gender was “girl” “boy”
And sex was making babies
___________________________________________________________________________________
You see, my friend the other day, asked me why I look so boyish? And I said, It’s my style, she said, that’s intersex, I said, no intersex, is a condition where you were born with a combination of male and female, she went on telling me that you can identify as anything so you can identify as intersex.
I said, I can identify as anything? I am biologically a female and that’s how I identify, so do not tell me what i can identify as.
She is now questioning her identity._. And changes it every few weeks. I know and think, she is biologically a female. I will not force her to identify as a female. But that is what she is.
I will not let mentally Ill people run around and act like you can tell people what they are.
What is moral decay in the society?
It means gross reduction in the moral values in a particular society. Thus, moral decadence appears to be a fall' in the moral standard of the society. It seems to be deterioration or a collapse in upholding our societal values, beliefs, norms and ethical standards.
We really need to open up and broaden the criterias for admission to all the closed asylums again. I’m left , but this is insanity.
"She spends time with teens" no wonder they are confused! This crap is CRAZY!!! God doesn't make mistakes, but she wouldn't know that, as she does not know who he is!
They/Them can't be used to describe 1 person They/Them means multiple people and has always meant multiple people.
How long shall we pretend to be something that we don't???
As long as these fake human(transgender) live..
Please nature finish this humanity as early as possible, due to heavy work load you have started making a lot of errors like these 😅😂 Covid was a good attempt though 😅
No the nurse didn't decide your sex, genetics decide if you're a boy or girl. 😊
The young generation is targeted with this who are willing to try new things and ideaologies.We need to be careful and warn our children about it.If not then they will live in a very different world where there would be no coming back.
Been watching a lot of these debates recently and Juno is only person I've warmed to regardless of their opinion. They seem happy, kind, grounded, non-judgemental and maintain a compassion for others - attributes which get lost really quickly in the extremely heated trans conversations.
Never been deaf, so you don't know what it's like. Just like you'll never be a woman, so you'll never really know what it's like.
That man isn’t working for him. Trying to talk like a women. Is a joke
Do you know how crazy you sound to say your not a male or female 😅
No matter how many hormones you take surgical removals or add ons you get you're NOT what you think you are
Regardless if I agree or not, I think she was incredibly polite and did a great job sharing her opinion.
"Oh come on" like that wasn't a fully legitimate question the way she spoke about genders 😆
TO BAD THSIS IS NOT THE 1800'S AGAIN CAUSE THIS SHIT WOULD NOT BE GOING ON
I just wanna get off this earth. Such weirdo. This is what happens when we become so detached from reality and make up new things.
My favourite two spirit penguin black lesbian is back 😁
she seems nice and respectful and not passive aggressive at all
Firstly, the word “they”is always plural. Secondly, the nurse never decided what sex you was at birth. Your penis or vagina does that 😂.
Is it me, or has anyone else noticed. How non binary women dress like/present themselves like men and the non binary men present themselves like women. If that’s the case, haven’t they actually chosen a gender?
they is not always plural. i'll give u examples. "i went to see the doctor today" "what did they say?" ur talking about the doctor who is one person. Or maybe ur on the bus and theres a wallet "someone left their wallet." One person.
@@pippa4511 they is plural. You would say what did she/he/you say. Not they.
@@keepingitnatural7601 it is most definitely predominantly plural but it is also singular. i studied english language at further education and they was never treated as solely plural. any linguist would tell u it’s singular and plural.
5:03 If they were cast in a role of a girl or a guy then that's the category they should be nominated in. It's not confusing at all. If they're cast in a trans woman role, a trans man role, a non-binary role, then maybe you can talk about a different category.
When he asked his mom when is he going to be a girl, his mom should've told him the truth and said "Never"
The Trans Community would be outraged if I took it upon myself to assign labels to them. So where do they get off saying I'm Cis-Gendered? No I'm not, I',m just a male! What nerve!
He just said he “should have been a women” that statement along is acknowledging that he knows he is not. Then he said he “knew” he was a woman at the age of 3. If you know you were born a woman??? Then why are you transitioning. And why are you using the physical features of a bio woman as your standard?
A debate on 'they' - 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
How dare than Nurse who studied years and learned all about sex and biology decide his gender, HOW DARE SHE!!
I have arachnophobia,
transphobia, and also acrophobia.
Please respect my phobias. It's not easy
I support transgender rights, but I also believe it's important to consider the potential impact on other groups, such as women's rights and sports teams. I think it's crucial to find a balance between individual rights and societal concerns. However, I worry that the movement's approach may sometimes be overly divisive and potentially undermine democracy and the American way of life. I hope we can find a way to promote equality and inclusivity without pitting different groups against each other. I fear that some extreme liberal thinking based on the rights of those who are transgender may be influenced by communist ideology, which aims to destroy the rights of others.
I feel like I wanna be a giraffe today
Told his parents - "when will I be a girl?" Means that he has acknowledged that he was born male.
It knows it will never get away with this In the Olympics or any other international competition.
Even 'They' cant get it right!! What a world we live in!
I am going to sue an airline. Why bc I identify as a plane crash victim. People need to respect my identity and do everything in their power to keep me happy and comfortable. I think I would be comfortable with 20 million.
Which plane crash were you in? Was it televised?
@@laquisab love it! Malaysia Airlines flight 370! I have the secret!!!! 🤫
@Rebornation0712 I'm glad you survived that. I hope you get all of the help and the millions of dollars that you are demanding from others at this time.
WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT THING??
Don't be rude. We are human people too
Modernity
An idiot that’s what
They in the English Dictionary means two or more. Why are we live a world of confusion? God made male and female..
I hope she doesn’t neglect her annual prostate checkup
That dude has a big Adam’s apple.
The Native American Indians gave us 2 Spirit.
Remember not to far back if someone did not like your person they would say" Who do THEY think THEY are. Lables are nothing new.
then why did they invite you?
"The genital mutilation community are almost exclusively religious" Christopher Hitchens 1949 to 2011. Are these people religious???
Maybe they're earthworms now, dual gender...LOL
regardless of what u think about all this they can be used to refer to one person when said person is not included in the conversation
I do not know this woman on here however out of all the different transgender/gender debaters I have heard, I do respect her bias viewpoint and commitment. She is dedicated to her choice to live a female lifestyle but NOT pushing others to say or conform to her ideology but simply trying to explain what is going on in this new age identity crisis and mediating things between us who learned and see only 2 genders and those who see almost a 100 genders. She just comes off as a great advocate for gender perceptions on both aisles of the street. In other words she does not frustrate me with her explanation of this VERY radical and ludacris situation! Bravo ma'am and yes I DO recognize people identity choice when they ask and demonstrate themselves as a lady but not those who try and force me too while acting like.....a female dog🤨😅 so my lady I thank you for helping me see I was born in a different time when we kept things simpler but this new generation will have more modern take on thongs just like my generation was open to biracial relationships my parents were thrown off by and would never try because the 50s was not open to mixed relationships so I say fair enough🤷🏾♂. My wife and I would NEVER be married if we were born just 1 generation sooner!
Few fries short of a happy meal
Def not courageous to lie to yourself and convince others of that same lies. Delusional yes, misinformed yes but courageous no.
This all matters to those in their community, they don’t seem to understand no one else gives a toss. Have your unsavoury club on an app or in a room . Its pure attention seeking from this sector of the community .
Men dressing as women is thousands of years old , us laughing at men dressed as women , thousands +1 years old
We still live in a free society, right? Why is the sensitivity Gestapo dictating everything we can and cannot say?
Whos this guy with a wig on🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Crazy eyes and facial expression says it all
Respect to the transgender, she was very polite and made good points.
I was thinking the same thing, kept her emotions in tact and respected the debate. She obviously very comfortable in her own skin.
He
She didn’t make good point at all 😂
Her head is gone
It's still a dude!
This is doing my head in.
My pronouns are ze/zir
After reading your other comments i think you're not joking about your made up pronouns. If you're genderless what's wrong about using they/them? It's been a valid single person pronoun even in shakespearian times.
@@FuneFox definitely not joking. I put years of thought into ze / zir to validate my identity as intersexed and I guess technically I want to go back to being intersexed like I was meant to be. They/them is often just so clunky and I don't want people to think I am some schizophrenic amalgamation I am just one person in my head not multiple but I respect those that have that issue.
I’m a cat-/dinosaur Anybody else who calls me different I’m going to Sue them lmao 😂
I agree with peirce, but this other speaker wasn't combative or rude or demeaning or aggressive..dont see much of people who are willing to discuss instead of argue!
Am I the only person seeing an avatar?😂
This MAN that Pierce interviewing
motions with his hands to try and stifle Peirce.
Delusional 🥴
No one. NO ONE is born in the wrong body. That was lie number one
Ok, if you are actually THEY, “THEY”have to PAY taxes, so if you consider yourself as “THEY”, they means plural, there fore you have to pay a plural tax 😌😌😌
You cannot claim “both.”