It's all about the feeling. The perception of luxury and the signal to others that you can afford it. I think it achieved that image because it's a beautiful and now iconic design. I bought my first (I have 4 Montblanc pens of various styles, including the 149) Montblanc when I started out in business in my late 20's and had achieved a lot of success. It was a symbol to me that I had "made it" ... and a reminder to keep working hard.
Unbelievably, this was my very first fountain pen. I bought it 30 years ago, before I knew anything about fountain pens. I’m glad I bought it back then, because I couldn’t afford it today!
Just got my first fountain pen and it was also quite a jump in price from before. This beauty is a Lamy 2000 in EF that I managed to score for about $125 after fees and taxes, brand new and delivered 🙂
I have 3 Mont Blanca : 2 149s and 1 146. I had the nibmeister Mark Bacas in Cumming Georgia work on each of them and he sure is a professional. Your channel is wonderful. Thank you so much. Keep up the great presentations and discussions. RS. Canada.
Most informative, admirably neutral, and entertaining... I, too, love my 149... was on the fence for a while prior to making its purchase... but if I was to do it... I wanted that 1000 dollar experience, as anything else was just not right. Thusly, I gifted myself with it, last year, brand new... and have been eternally grateful for doing so. It is a jewel in my collection, and nothing else garners the sense of intrinsic fulfillment as my 149. I own Sailors (even the KOP) as well a Pilot 823, in Smoke. But nothing is quite like the extra fine oversized 18kt 149 nib.
Thank you for the kind words. I am glad that you enjoyed my review. I am equally enamored with this pen. There really isn’t anything else quite like it. Enjoy yours and all the best.
Thank you both for the video and the comment! I recently purchased the 149 for my birthday as a self-gift that I was on the edge about for a while, and both the video and the comment pushed me over. I am incredibly happy with the pen, as it's a joy to write with. It makes me smile every time I use it, so thank you both!
I use a MB 149 pen actually 4 MB 149 pens as my daily writers. I have been using MB 149 pens since 1998 or so. Despite being a smallish guy, the large size does not faze me, I use a very light grip, and use very little pressure to write with. Thus, writing with the MB 149s makes the process of writing very enjoyable. As far as buying a MB 149, the best place is to check out the used market. All of my 4 MB 149s were bought used, but is almost new condition, and cost between $350.00 (US $) and $450.00 as opposed to buying a brand new pen that costs over $950.00
My first fountain pen was an old Parker 61 that used to be my grandfathers (50s-60s vintage). That was in 1991 as a sophomore in college. I got the pen with a bottle of black ink and I liked the idea of not having to buy a pen again given I was a desperately poor student. That pen was a daily user and got me thru both undergrad and graduate school. I knew nothing about fountain pens when I got that Parker 61 and I would never have predicted I’d still be using them today as daily users. I had built up quite a collection of FP in those years then started to gift them away - trying to simplify my life some and spread the joy. That brings me to Montblanc. With the exception of that old Parker 61 and two Shaeffer snorkels, my collection is reduced to those plus my 2-149’s and 2-146’s. The MBs range from mid-1980’s to mid-2000’s and are my daily users. 4 MB’s with 4 different color inks. Treat them right and they will last a lifetime always reliably putting ink on paper. I can’t remember the last time I actually bought a disposable pen. Thx for the review!
I recently started watching your channel....I enjoy it very much....I subscribed. I've kept a journal since Nov. 29, 1976. And I have a typewriter my dad bought for me when I took typing classes in high school (which he'd promised to do).....so it's over 56 yrs. old.
Hello Pat, thank you so much and welcome to the channel. I am really happy to have you here and am excited to hear about your experiences. It’s wonderful that you have journals the date back that far, well done! All the best!
I own a 146 and it’s perfect for my hand. I can’t imagine a better feeling pen than that! The 149 is too big for me and even if it was more comfortable to write with, it would feel a little too flashy for the workplace.
I suppose it depends on the workplace and one’s relationship with it. I think I vacillate a bit between the 149 and the 146. I agree with you that the 146 is near perfect. It is my Goldilocks Pen. Yet, sometimes nothing will do quite like the 149 does! So there is that to consider. Thanks for watching.
@HemingwayJones i work in the IT sector and on most days I have to do with clients and while you certainly want them to know that you are solid and tasteful (as well as professional), you don’t want to be too flashy!
Great review and really valid insight into the enjoyment of the writing experience the 149 brings that make it worth it's admission. I have the 149 Red Gold F and 149 Calligraphy and love them both. I agree about the enjoyment of the pen which adds to it's value because I write more with it, I use it every day at work making detailed notes that saved my skin many times, and journal at home. Whether purchased new or pre-owned, these are worth every penny.
Thank you very much for the kind words and eloquent comment. Of course, I agree completely. I’d love to try the calligraphy nib. I bet it’s amazing. All the best.
Thanks for this great video!, your advices are really highly valuable for everybody looking for a pen. I just purchased my M149 medium nib and it's an amazing unique instrument.
Really enjoyed this review, Hemingway! I have tried the 149 but it really was too big for my hand. I have a 146 which, unfortunately, does not have a two toned nib but is still a fantastic writer, and a Mont Blanc, Chopin which has a beautiful two-toned Cursive Italic nib -- absolutely my favorite pen! I just came across your channel a couple of weeks ago and subscribed. Thoroughly enjoying it and working my way through every archived video you've put up. I don't know if you've done a review of the Mont Blanc 146, but it would probably be very similar to the 149 just a smaller version. Thanks for this awesome channel. I Look forward to every Thursday now!
I remember seeing ads in the New Yorker--circa 1969--for the "Magnificent Diplomat." It was definitely the MB 149 of the time, retailing at $39. I was a young grad student, and my fountain pen of choice was a Sheaffer Imperial, retailing at $7.50, the limit of my pen budget. I finally got a 149 for a present in 1987, which I have to this day. It's currently inked with Diamine blue-black, and I use it daily. Wonderful pen. Thanks to your enthusiasm, I recently acquired a MB Egyptomania. Definitely different from the 149, but a wonderful writer. Thanks for the review.
Thank you so much for the kind works and for relaying your pen story. I love hearing what they used to cost. Also, Shaeffer! Nice. I love the Egyptomania and just filmed a follow up video. I hope you like it. Wish you all the best and thanks for the kind words.
I have a Meisterstuck 149 and it is by far my favorite. I also have Visconti Homo Sapiens and also some vintage Conway Stewart's but I always go back to the Monteblanc 149.
Hello Hemingway, this is one of the best videos on an individual pen I've ever listened to. Now talking about colour, black and gold may be trite by now but it will never stop being classy. I do not yet own one but flirt with the model on account of its fabulous nib. I do not mind the size as I have a pianist's hand and deep down would love it in burgundy. Montblanc does exceptionally beautiful burgundy pens, just have a look at the Petit Prince series and this becomes instantly noticeable.
I bought my 149 with a fine nib about six months ago, It truly is a must for the Serious pen collection. I love the big pen size. It goes well with some of my ASC celluloid oversized pens.
This pen is iconic and loaded with history. The design is simplistic, yet recognizable by many. It is also a pen that has eluded my pocession. One day, perhaps I will own one of these pens but until that time, I will continue to cherish my Pelican collection.
Hello Richard, thanks for the comment. It’s always nice to hear from you. The Pelikan pens are awesome. You should be very proud of those. I cherish each of mine. Thanks for checking in.
Thank you for what was an excellent overview of this pen. I've never owned one, but may now consider one. I've always been put off by the size, as opposed to the price tag. I like and use other Montblanc pens (new and vintage), my favourites being the Noblesse (about as different to this as possible!), the 144, the 256 and the 22.
Thank you for the kind words. Those are some great pens. I really like the 22. I think it is under appreciated. Vintage MB are pretty great and I found them to be very reliable. All the best.
Very well presented and articulately narrated video! I have also thoroughly enjoyed your video on the rationale/or the lack thereof for collecting fountain pens. I have a number of vintage and modern fountain pens, and had recently purchased a Montblanc 22 (CIRCA 1961) fountain pen. These are far less expensive options to initiate oneself with the snowflake of Montblanc pens, but I am sure that for the ultimate experience one must use the Meisterstück 149. My 22 nevertheless writes very well, and is a smooth writer. The workmanship of these German pens, and some of the vintage Sheaffer's and Parker pens can be very addictive. If you happen to own a Sheaffer's Snorkel pen or any other vintage pens it would be great to have a video from you on one of them. I am located in Dhaka, Bangladesh, and here we have quite a few fountain pen aficionados. One of the nice things about You Tube is that you win over fans and followers all over the world. Wishing you success with this channel. Warm greetings from Dhaka!
Hello Shamim! I am very pleased to meet you and thank you for the kind note. I have heard that fountain pens are still very popular in India. That is wonderful. I will be doing reviews of vintage pens, including the Montblanc 22. I have one as well and I adore it. it is a great writer. I have always thought that it is similar to a Parker 51 in its nib. Great pen and I will do something on it soon. I have a 246 and a 152 too. Expect some more vintage content. Vacumatics, Stewart Conway, Duofold. We’ll do a lot of interesting things. All the best and keep in touch.
enjoyed this thorough and expert review! i purchase one some months back with a silver trim ; unfortunately, i'm still waiting for it to arrive. seems montblanc is having issues with acquiring materials lately, at least according to the retailer i bought it from. it's understandable, and as they say, good things come to those who wait. thank you again for the video :)
Thank you for the kind comment. I appreciate it. I am just getting started on here and I feel as if I am posting into the darkness. Thanks for bringing in some light. I am sorry that your pen is taking a long time. This seems to be the way of the world right now. But once it comes, you will be so pleased. Wishing you all the best and stop by again.
Great review. Have watched many 149 reviews, and I think this must rate as one of the best. Personally I have 4 149s with different nibs. Two of them were pre owned. The oldest one which I got used, is from the mid 60s, absolutely amazing nib. I had to do some restoration work I.e. really good cleaning and a good polish. Looks almost new. BTW, relating to the "precious resin" debate, I read a blog some time ago, that the term is actually a translation from a German term for good quality resin, unfortunately it comes across pretentious.... I did a google translate on the Precious Resin to German. The term can also be translates as Fine Resin, or Noble Resin
Thank you very much! It sounds as if you have a very nice collection. The nibs are so nice and personally I feel that is what I am paying for. Thank you so much for the kind words and check in again. All the best.
Espero el año entrante comprar mi 149. Pienso que es una de esas estilográficas que hay que tener en la colección. Saludos cordiales desde Medellín Colombia.
They are great writing pens, constructed well and look great - Worth the money? Considering every one I own has gone up in value - sometimes 2.5x - I would say they hold and often increase in value, so while initially expensive, they are money in the bank if you keep them in good shape. Can’t do that with many other pens - if any.
Interesting! It's not a pen I've ever purchased, but I do own some vintage Montblanc pens, and find them to be quite well made. Even the lower cost "student Pens" that Montblanc made were of good quality. Your description of hand feel was very thorough, and not something I usually hear from other reviewers. Also glad that you compared it to the Pilot 823: a pen I own and enjoy.
Thanks so much. I appreciate the feedback. I have a few vintage MBs myself that you will see up here eventually. A 22, 246, and a 152. Also, the 823. I will definitely do something on that. It is wonderful.
Awesome video, thank you for making videos. FYI Jinhao released the X850. It is to replace the X458. The sad part is that it looks like the MB 146 like the Jinhao was to be the MB 149.
Over the years I bought pens that I liked at the time.. I know much more today about pens today than I did at the time of purchase. I have been buying these pens for probably 20 years or more. I recently went through my Montblancs and without intention I have a 164 BP, 144M,146B and a 149M...... Synchronicity! 🤓
I always wanted a 149 since college days; it was my dream pen. Years later, I got a 146. One step away. The following year, I have a vintage 149 on the way. I still can’t believe I’m finally getting one.
Hace un mes que la tengo, en versión platino. Me encanta, es magnífica. A pesar de su precio. la recomiendo🙂Saludos desde Jerez de la Frontera, tierra del vino y del caballo. (España)
Dear Sir, Your way of presentation is very good, its clasic. The way you explain each and every aspect of a fountain pen really catches my mind and heart. I am glad that you own this wonderful piece of writing instrument which carries its own history. Love it or hate it, but no one can ignore this masterpiece ever created in history. Sir, please create a detailed video on Pilot Custom 823 and Sailor King Of Pens. Hope to learn more from you. With love and care, Stay safe and healthy. Vivek Kumar ( Dehri On Sone , Bihar , India) Dehri On Sone is a small town in Bihar state of India.
Thank you so much for your kind words about my channel. I appreciate it very much. I do have a review of the Pilot Custom 823 up. I hope you catch it. I don't have a King of Pens, so I cannot do that one until I happen across one. Thanks so much for your kindness and friendship! A huge hug to you from Massachusetts. Keep yourself well.
@@HemingwayJones Sure sir I will catch up with your video on Custom 823. Sir, Your friendship is greatly appreciated and welcomed from bottom of my heart. With love , Vivek Kumar
Hi, I was signposted to your channel by WaskiSquirrel. I enjoyed your review of the Montblanc 149 fountain pen. There are some things in life that are not what you would call 'value for money' or 'bang for the buck'. However, this does not make them less desirable. The 149 is a pen that is always on my wish list. Earlier this year I had a bad experience with Montblanc. I was given a brand new Montblanc pen as a gift, not a 149, but the nib was defective. Constant hard starts and skipping with any ink or paper. It was returned for a full refund. Despite this, I am not completely turned off the brand. Your idea of a lightly used example could well suit me in the future.
Hello and thank you for the comment. I like what you said about “value for money.” There are some things that you simply must have. I wonder about the current MB line up. Mine is now 10 years old and all of my others are even older. I hope that the quality is still there. If I were to buy another, I would go used. I buy a lot of vintage pens now. -Thanks for dropping by and say hello again sometime.
I have a rare 149 the Kingsman edition, it has a solid gold nib, I also have the platinum 149. I love these pens so much. That’s a beautiful GMT Master II btw, I also match my Rolex with my MontBlancs 👍🏽
:one your channel. I have a MB 149 but want to change the nib to an EF. I can't find any place to send it to for a swap out. I am way beyond their 6 month free nib swap out deal. My problem is where to get it done. MB does not make it obvious on their site. The next issues is: can they be swapped out?
I believe they can. Will they do it for a fee? You could Inquire. Otherwise check with the nibsmiths. Get a pro’s opinion. Let me know what happens and thanks!
I may have posted earlier that one of my first pens was the Montblanc 149 (at the time I got mine in 1992, it was a 14K nib; metal piston fixture); however, it was a gift from an alumnus for whom I had done some free legal work. (I am not a licensed attorney in California where I served as a professor; hence, I could not ethically charge for any legal work.) I was naive about the pen’s value, so I took it with me on a tour of Spain (a trip with over 20 students). I had the pen clipped to my shirt. An Italian-born student cam up and said, “Professor, yo cannot display that pen in tourist areas here. Someone might harm you to get that pen!” I responded, “You mean this is that expensive?” Of course, its price in 1992 was significantly less, but it was far more money than I had spent on anything other than a Montblanc ballpoint. As an aside, I did carry the pen in my favorite suit, clipped in the inside coat pocket. Normal body movements throughout the work day cause the cap to come unscrewed. By the time I discovered that the pen was cap-less in my suit jacket, I had done irreparable damage to the suit (despite two different dry cleaners trying to remove the Montblanc ink! After turning pen fanatic shortly after 2010, I have discovered other pens that I think write even better, but I know it is still the most acceptable fountain pen in an upscale business setting. I do not rail against it, I just prefer to write with a few other pens. Again, I am enjoying your reviews and your point of view. Best wishes in building your channel!
That is a great story. Awful that the cap came undone. Fortunately that hasn’t happened yet. I have had issue with ink bottles that have freshness seals! I have so much trouble getting it off and especially without splatter; very unpleasant, indeed. All the best and stop by again.
They are made out of resin. There is just one resin that we could call "plastic", it is used for small and cheap bags in supermarkets or other shops. But generally speaking, it is incorrect to say, that Montblanc pens are made out of plastic because they are not. The question is if it is a natural resin they use or not, because the material has a certain "warmth" to it, that you do not have when you touch plastic.
It’s only 'boring' because there are now so many newer pens with design and colour options to entice us. But the 149 is a classic and a style icon. I was very fortunate in that I found one in a friends pencil tin by his telephone. It had belonged to his father, but as he never used it, he gave it to me. I spent €10 to get the piston fixed (not by Mont Blanc), but the nib was, and still is perfect. I never post, as I like to hold the cap in my left hand while writing.
I haven’t used it yet. Like you, I have been searching you one. It looks amazing. The nib on my Egyptomania is soft, so they definitely know how to make them. I am so glad you liked the review. All the best.
“It's all in the name. The Meisterstück - German for masterpiece - is both a piece of art and a rich slice of history. Almost 100 years after its first introduction in 1924, the Meisterstück is the best known writing instrument of any Montblanc collection.” From Montblanc’s website. Thanks.
@@HemingwayJones Your video - which I enjoyed by the way - focusses on the 149, which does not stem from the 1920s. Just a fact check. :) It's also a copy of a Sheaffer design, but that's another story.
Cramping has nothing to do with the girth of a pen, but with poor technique (especially grip tightness). Consider writing with a #2 pencil and minimum pressure.
@@HemingwayJones Well, you're entitled to your opinion but dystonia is usually associated with poor technique, poor posture, of simply overuse. And in roughly 20% of cases it is hereditary. Nothing to do with pen size, sorry.
@@davyj5216 Yes exactly. I am the foremost authority on my opinion and yes, a thicker pen is more comfortable for me due to the simple fact that it is more comfortable. It has everything to do with pen size for me.
@@HemingwayJones Does it? Have you tried changing your grip technique, or even trying to write with a whole arm movement instead of finger writing? You likely find the thicker pen more comfortable because it compensates for poor grip and technique. Speaking from personal experience as a guy with very large hands I can say that I don't experience writer's cramp no matter what the girth of a pen. Probably because I was actually taught to write with the correct technique. The point is that you are limiting the range of tools you can use by not addressing incorrect technique. By the way, the 149 is not a big pen to me, about average really.
It's all about the feeling. The perception of luxury and the signal to others that you can afford it. I think it achieved that image because it's a beautiful and now iconic design. I bought my first (I have 4 Montblanc pens of various styles, including the 149) Montblanc when I started out in business in my late 20's and had achieved a lot of success. It was a symbol to me that I had "made it" ... and a reminder to keep working hard.
Thanks for the comment. It is similar to how some or even many people view Rolex; as symbols of success along the way. All the best.
Unbelievably, this was my very first fountain pen. I bought it 30 years ago, before I knew anything about fountain pens. I’m glad I bought it back then, because I couldn’t afford it today!
That is a great choice for a first pen and you got it at a good time. I got mine 8 years ago and it was much less then. All the best!
Just got my first fountain pen and it was also quite a jump in price from before. This beauty is a Lamy 2000 in EF that I managed to score for about $125 after fees and taxes, brand new and delivered 🙂
My 149 was my second fountain pen, I purchased it in 1984. Before that I used my 1965 Parker 45. Still have and use both.
I have 3 Mont Blanca : 2 149s and 1 146.
I had the nibmeister Mark Bacas in Cumming Georgia work on each of them and he sure is a professional.
Your channel is wonderful.
Thank you so much.
Keep up the great presentations and discussions.
RS. Canada.
Thank you so much for the kind words of encouragement!
Most informative, admirably neutral, and entertaining... I, too, love my 149... was on the fence for a while prior to making its purchase... but if I was to do it... I wanted that 1000 dollar experience, as anything else was just not right. Thusly, I gifted myself with it, last year, brand new... and have been eternally grateful for doing so. It is a jewel in my collection, and nothing else garners the sense of intrinsic fulfillment as my 149. I own Sailors (even the KOP) as well a Pilot 823, in Smoke. But nothing is quite like the extra fine oversized 18kt 149 nib.
Thank you for the kind words. I am glad that you enjoyed my review. I am equally enamored with this pen. There really isn’t anything else quite like it. Enjoy yours and all the best.
Thank you both for the video and the comment! I recently purchased the 149 for my birthday as a self-gift that I was on the edge about for a while, and both the video and the comment pushed me over. I am incredibly happy with the pen, as it's a joy to write with. It makes me smile every time I use it, so thank you both!
I use a MB 149 pen actually 4 MB 149 pens as my daily writers. I have been using MB 149 pens since 1998 or so. Despite being a smallish guy, the large size does not faze me, I use a very light grip, and use very little pressure to write with. Thus, writing with the MB 149s makes the process of writing very enjoyable. As far as buying a MB 149, the best place is to check out the used market. All of my 4 MB 149s were bought used, but is almost new condition, and cost between $350.00 (US $) and $450.00 as opposed to buying a brand new pen that costs over $950.00
I wholly endorse everything you say here, My Friend. All the best!
My first fountain pen was an old Parker 61 that used to be my grandfathers (50s-60s vintage). That was in 1991 as a sophomore in college. I got the pen with a bottle of black ink and I liked the idea of not having to buy a pen again given I was a desperately poor student. That pen was a daily user and got me thru both undergrad and graduate school. I knew nothing about fountain pens when I got that Parker 61 and I would never have predicted I’d still be using them today as daily users. I had built up quite a collection of FP in those years then started to gift them away - trying to simplify my life some and spread the joy. That brings me to Montblanc. With the exception of that old Parker 61 and two Shaeffer snorkels, my collection is reduced to those plus my 2-149’s and 2-146’s. The MBs range from mid-1980’s to mid-2000’s and are my daily users. 4 MB’s with 4 different color inks. Treat them right and they will last a lifetime always reliably putting ink on paper. I can’t remember the last time I actually bought a disposable pen. Thx for the review!
This is a great comment. Thanks very much. You cannot go wrong with 146s and 149s! Great stuff.
I recently started watching your channel....I enjoy it very much....I subscribed. I've kept a journal since Nov. 29, 1976. And I have a typewriter my dad bought for me when I took typing classes in high school (which he'd promised to do).....so it's over 56 yrs. old.
Hello Pat, thank you so much and welcome to the channel. I am really happy to have you here and am excited to hear about your experiences. It’s wonderful that you have journals the date back that far, well done! All the best!
I own a 146 and it’s perfect for my hand. I can’t imagine a better feeling pen than that!
The 149 is too big for me and even if it was more comfortable to write with, it would feel a little too flashy for the workplace.
I suppose it depends on the workplace and one’s relationship with it. I think I vacillate a bit between the 149 and the 146. I agree with you that the 146 is near perfect. It is my Goldilocks Pen. Yet, sometimes nothing will do quite like the 149 does! So there is that to consider. Thanks for watching.
@HemingwayJones i work in the IT sector and on most days I have to do with clients and while you certainly want them to know that you are solid and tasteful (as well as professional), you don’t want to be too flashy!
Great review and really valid insight into the enjoyment of the writing experience the 149 brings that make it worth it's admission. I have the 149 Red Gold F and 149 Calligraphy and love them both. I agree about the enjoyment of the pen which adds to it's value because I write more with it, I use it every day at work making detailed notes that saved my skin many times, and journal at home. Whether purchased new or pre-owned, these are worth every penny.
Thank you very much for the kind words and eloquent comment. Of course, I agree completely. I’d love to try the calligraphy nib. I bet it’s amazing. All the best.
Thanks for this great video!, your advices are really highly valuable for everybody looking for a pen. I just purchased my M149 medium nib and it's an amazing unique instrument.
That is wonderful. What a great purchase. I am so glad that you are enjoying it. Thanks for the kind words and all the best.
Really enjoyed this review, Hemingway! I have tried the 149 but it really was too big for my hand. I have a 146 which, unfortunately, does not have a two toned nib but is still a fantastic writer, and a Mont Blanc, Chopin which has a beautiful two-toned Cursive Italic nib -- absolutely my favorite pen! I just came across your channel a couple of weeks ago and subscribed. Thoroughly enjoying it and working my way through every archived video you've put up. I don't know if you've done a review of the Mont Blanc 146, but it would probably be very similar to the 149 just a smaller version. Thanks for this awesome channel. I Look forward to every Thursday now!
Thanks so much! I need to get a 146. I don’t have one. I want it in Burgundy. Thanks very much for the kind feedback.
Gorgeous pen. Montblanc are truly functional works of art.
Thank you so much!
I remember seeing ads in the New Yorker--circa 1969--for the "Magnificent Diplomat." It was definitely the MB 149 of the time, retailing at $39. I was a young grad student, and my fountain pen of choice was a Sheaffer Imperial, retailing at $7.50, the limit of my pen budget. I finally got a 149 for a present in 1987, which I have to this day. It's currently inked with Diamine blue-black, and I use it daily. Wonderful pen. Thanks to your enthusiasm, I recently acquired a MB Egyptomania. Definitely different from the 149, but a wonderful writer. Thanks for the review.
Thank you so much for the kind works and for relaying your pen story. I love hearing what they used to cost. Also, Shaeffer! Nice. I love the Egyptomania and just filmed a follow up video. I hope you like it. Wish you all the best and thanks for the kind words.
I have a Meisterstuck 149 and it is by far my favorite. I also have Visconti Homo Sapiens and also some vintage Conway Stewart's but I always go back to the Monteblanc 149.
The 149 is such a great pen. Fantastic choice!
Hello Hemingway, this is one of the best videos on an individual pen I've ever listened to. Now talking about colour, black and gold may be trite by now but it will never stop being classy. I do not yet own one but flirt with the model on account of its fabulous nib. I do not mind the size as I have a pianist's hand and deep down would love it in burgundy. Montblanc does exceptionally beautiful burgundy pens, just have a look at the Petit Prince series and this becomes instantly noticeable.
Thanks so much for the kind words! I agree completely on the Burgundy. Such an awesome color. Thanks!
I bought my 149 with a fine nib about six months ago, It truly is a must for the Serious pen collection. I love the big pen size. It goes well with some of my ASC celluloid oversized pens.
That’s a great get! Congratulations!
This pen is iconic and loaded with history. The design is simplistic, yet recognizable by many. It is also a pen that has eluded my pocession. One day, perhaps I will own one of these pens but until that time, I will continue to cherish my Pelican collection.
Hello Richard, thanks for the comment. It’s always nice to hear from you. The Pelikan pens are awesome. You should be very proud of those. I cherish each of mine. Thanks for checking in.
Thank you for what was an excellent overview of this pen. I've never owned one, but may now consider one. I've always been put off by the size, as opposed to the price tag. I like and use other Montblanc pens (new and vintage), my favourites being the Noblesse (about as different to this as possible!), the 144, the 256 and the 22.
Thank you for the kind words. Those are some great pens. I really like the 22. I think it is under appreciated. Vintage MB are pretty great and I found them to be very reliable. All the best.
Very well presented and articulately narrated video! I have also thoroughly enjoyed your video on the rationale/or the lack thereof for collecting fountain pens. I have a number of vintage and modern fountain pens, and had recently purchased a Montblanc 22 (CIRCA 1961) fountain pen. These are far less expensive options to initiate oneself with the snowflake of Montblanc pens, but I am sure that for the ultimate experience one must use the Meisterstück 149. My 22 nevertheless writes very well, and is a smooth writer. The workmanship of these German pens, and some of the vintage Sheaffer's and Parker pens can be very addictive. If you happen to own a Sheaffer's Snorkel pen or any other vintage pens it would be great to have a video from you on one of them. I am located in Dhaka, Bangladesh, and here we have quite a few fountain pen aficionados. One of the nice things about You Tube is that you win over fans and followers all over the world. Wishing you success with this channel. Warm greetings from Dhaka!
Hello Shamim! I am very pleased to meet you and thank you for the kind note. I have heard that fountain pens are still very popular in India. That is wonderful. I will be doing reviews of vintage pens, including the Montblanc 22. I have one as well and I adore it. it is a great writer. I have always thought that it is similar to a Parker 51 in its nib. Great pen and I will do something on it soon. I have a 246 and a 152 too. Expect some more vintage content. Vacumatics, Stewart Conway, Duofold. We’ll do a lot of interesting things. All the best and keep in touch.
enjoyed this thorough and expert review! i purchase one some months back with a silver trim ; unfortunately, i'm still waiting for it to arrive. seems montblanc is having issues with acquiring materials lately, at least according to the retailer i bought it from. it's understandable, and as they say, good things come to those who wait. thank you again for the video :)
Thank you for the kind comment. I appreciate it. I am just getting started on here and I feel as if I am posting into the darkness. Thanks for bringing in some light. I am sorry that your pen is taking a long time. This seems to be the way of the world right now. But once it comes, you will be so pleased. Wishing you all the best and stop by again.
The mont blanc 149 is my favorite pen I own, the proportions are just perfect. Not too big, not too small, not too ornate, and not too simple.
I agree completely! Glad you like it.
My MB149 is consistently inked. I have been using it for last 15 years, every day. 90% times filled with MB Royal blue. A true classic indeed!
Truly! An excellent pen.
Great review. Have watched many 149 reviews, and I think this must rate as one of the best. Personally I have 4 149s with different nibs. Two of them were pre owned. The oldest one which I got used, is from the mid 60s, absolutely amazing nib. I had to do some restoration work I.e. really good cleaning and a good polish. Looks almost new. BTW, relating to the "precious resin" debate, I read a blog some time ago, that the term is actually a translation from a German term for good quality resin, unfortunately it comes across pretentious....
I did a google translate on the Precious Resin to German. The term can also be translates as Fine Resin, or Noble Resin
Thank you very much! It sounds as if you have a very nice collection. The nibs are so nice and personally I feel that is what I am paying for. Thank you so much for the kind words and check in again. All the best.
The precious resin is a sort of resin plastic
Espero el año entrante comprar mi 149. Pienso que es una de esas estilográficas que hay que tener en la colección.
Saludos cordiales desde Medellín Colombia.
I agree completely! Good luck and let me know your thoughts when you get it. All the best.
I’m excited. Ordered one today.
Congratulations! That is a very big deal.
Thanks for the review, I just bought one, and I`m loving it! Ill make videos of this piece of art! Keep it the good work!
Thank you very much! Enjoy your new pen. It is awesome.
They are great writing pens, constructed well and look great - Worth the money? Considering every one I own has gone up in value - sometimes 2.5x - I would say they hold and often increase in value, so while initially expensive, they are money in the bank if you keep them in good shape. Can’t do that with many other pens - if any.
That is a very good point, My Friend. Thank you for that. It is an absolutely beautiful pen. All the best.
Amazing video! Would love to own one of these someday.
Thanks My Friend! Nice to see you over here.
Love the review and the overall tone of the video!
Thank you so much, Eric! I appreciate that.
Another great video! Can’t wait for the next one!
Thank you very much!
Our office is thinking of buying one for our boss who is retiring. We were considering the 146 at first but managed to raise enough funds for a 149.
The 149 is epic. What a nice gift. Well done indeed.
Interesting! It's not a pen I've ever purchased, but I do own some vintage Montblanc pens, and find them to be quite well made. Even the lower cost "student Pens" that Montblanc made were of good quality.
Your description of hand feel was very thorough, and not something I usually hear from other reviewers. Also glad that you compared it to the Pilot 823: a pen I own and enjoy.
Thanks so much. I appreciate the feedback. I have a few vintage MBs myself that you will see up here eventually. A 22, 246, and a 152. Also, the 823. I will definitely do something on that. It is wonderful.
Great videos. I'm here from Tiktok. Keep it up!
Thank you! Happy to have you here.
Awesome video, thank you for making videos. FYI Jinhao released the X850. It is to replace the X458. The sad part is that it looks like the MB 146 like the Jinhao was to be the MB 149.
Thank you Andrew! For the kind comment. I appreciate it. I’ll seek that one out.
@@HemingwayJones I love your videos. And your motto “write your way through “ gets me through tough times at work.
@@andrewscott9610 That is so wonderful to hear. Thank you!!!
Over the years I bought pens that I liked at the time.. I know much more today about pens today than I did at the time of purchase. I have been buying these pens for probably 20 years or more. I recently went through my Montblancs and without intention I have a 164 BP, 144M,146B and a 149M...... Synchronicity! 🤓
All great choices
Good job with the suspense and ticking clock when you asked if you would buy it again! ⏰
I always wanted a 149 since college days; it was my dream pen.
Years later, I got a 146. One step away.
The following year, I have a vintage 149 on the way.
I still can’t believe I’m finally getting one.
Congratulations! It’s a wonderful pen! The 146 is pretty great too. You have chosen wisely!
Excellent, excellent review. Much thanks.
Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
Hace un mes que la tengo, en versión platino. Me encanta, es magnífica. A pesar de su precio. la recomiendo🙂Saludos desde Jerez de la Frontera, tierra del vino y del caballo. (España)
Thank you! I am so glad you enjoy this pen as well. Wish you all the best!
Beautiful presentation!
What nib size are you using?
Thank you! Medium on this one. Thanks!
Dear Sir,
Your way of presentation is very good, its clasic.
The way you explain each and every aspect of a fountain pen really catches my mind and heart.
I am glad that you own this wonderful piece of writing instrument which carries its own history.
Love it or hate it, but no one can ignore this masterpiece ever created in history.
Sir, please create a detailed video on Pilot Custom 823 and Sailor King Of Pens.
Hope to learn more from you.
With love and care,
Stay safe and healthy.
Vivek Kumar
( Dehri On Sone , Bihar , India)
Dehri On Sone is a small town in Bihar state of India.
Thank you so much for your kind words about my channel. I appreciate it very much. I do have a review of the Pilot Custom 823 up. I hope you catch it. I don't have a King of Pens, so I cannot do that one until I happen across one.
Thanks so much for your kindness and friendship! A huge hug to you from Massachusetts. Keep yourself well.
@@HemingwayJones Sure sir I will catch up with your video on Custom 823.
Sir, Your friendship is greatly appreciated and welcomed from bottom of my heart.
With love ,
Vivek Kumar
Hi, I was signposted to your channel by WaskiSquirrel. I enjoyed your review of the Montblanc 149 fountain pen. There are some things in life that are not what you would call 'value for money' or 'bang for the buck'. However, this does not make them less desirable. The 149 is a pen that is always on my wish list. Earlier this year I had a bad experience with Montblanc. I was given a brand new Montblanc pen as a gift, not a 149, but the nib was defective. Constant hard starts and skipping with any ink or paper. It was returned for a full refund. Despite this, I am not completely turned off the brand. Your idea of a lightly used example could well suit me in the future.
Hello and thank you for the comment. I like what you said about “value for money.” There are some things that you simply must have. I wonder about the current MB line up. Mine is now 10 years old and all of my others are even older. I hope that the quality is still there. If I were to buy another, I would go used. I buy a lot of vintage pens now. -Thanks for dropping by and say hello again sometime.
Great review, and costing me money once again. And thank you. :-)
I have a rare 149 the Kingsman edition, it has a solid gold nib, I also have the platinum 149. I love these pens so much. That’s a beautiful GMT Master II btw, I also match my Rolex with my MontBlancs 👍🏽
Thanks so much. I love this watch. That Kingsman pen sounds fun. All the best!
Hello, does this dual (multi) tone gold nib have a model number? I see the current version on Montblanc only has the border of the nib in gold. Thanks
Mine is from over a decade ago. I imagine it has changed.
You're a real writer man. You buy pens to write. That's good. Very good.
Thank you!
Nice explanation i ver heard from others....thx sir
Thanks!
:one your channel. I have a MB 149 but want to change the nib to an EF. I can't find any place to send it to for a swap out. I am way beyond their 6 month free nib swap out deal. My problem is where to get it done. MB does not make it obvious on their site. The next issues is: can they be swapped out?
I believe they can. Will they do it for a fee? You could Inquire. Otherwise check with the nibsmiths. Get a pro’s opinion. Let me know what happens and thanks!
Do you have a preference between the Monblanc 149 vs. Pelikan M1000?
I am a Montblanc guy, but I have never owned the M1000… yet!
I may have posted earlier that one of my first pens was the Montblanc 149 (at the time I got mine in 1992, it was a 14K nib; metal piston fixture); however, it was a gift from an alumnus for whom I had done some free legal work. (I am not a licensed attorney in California where I served as a professor; hence, I could not ethically charge for any legal work.) I was naive about the pen’s value, so I took it with me on a tour of Spain (a trip with over 20 students). I had the pen clipped to my shirt. An Italian-born student cam up and said, “Professor, yo cannot display that pen in tourist areas here. Someone might harm you to get that pen!” I responded, “You mean this is that expensive?” Of course, its price in 1992 was significantly less, but it was far more money than I had spent on anything other than a Montblanc ballpoint. As an aside, I did carry the pen in my favorite suit, clipped in the inside coat pocket. Normal body movements throughout the work day cause the cap to come unscrewed. By the time I discovered that the pen was cap-less in my suit jacket, I had done irreparable damage to the suit (despite two different dry cleaners trying to remove the Montblanc ink! After turning pen fanatic shortly after 2010, I have discovered other pens that I think write even better, but I know it is still the most acceptable fountain pen in an upscale business setting. I do not rail against it, I just prefer to write with a few other pens. Again, I am enjoying your reviews and your point of view. Best wishes in building your channel!
That is a great story. Awful that the cap came undone. Fortunately that hasn’t happened yet. I have had issue with ink bottles that have freshness seals! I have so much trouble getting it off and especially without splatter; very unpleasant, indeed. All the best and stop by again.
They are made out of resin. There is just one resin that we could call "plastic", it is used for small and cheap bags in supermarkets or other shops. But generally speaking, it is incorrect to say, that Montblanc pens are made out of plastic because they are not. The question is if it is a natural resin they use or not, because the material has a certain "warmth" to it, that you do not have when you touch plastic.
Agreed! I have a video coming up on this that you will love. I revisit the MB 149 soon. Stay tuned to the channel and let me know what you think.
It’s only 'boring' because there are now so many newer pens with design and colour options to entice us. But the 149 is a classic and a style icon. I was very fortunate in that I found one in a friends pencil tin by his telephone. It had belonged to his father, but as he never used it, he gave it to me. I spent €10 to get the piston fixed (not by Mont Blanc), but the nib was, and still is perfect. I never post, as I like to hold the cap in my left hand while writing.
Wonderful find!
Just bought this. Love your review 👍🏻 actually I wanted to have a flexi nib but they don’t have this in stock. What do think about the 149 Flexi nib?
I haven’t used it yet. Like you, I have been searching you one. It looks amazing. The nib on my Egyptomania is soft, so they definitely know how to make them. I am so glad you liked the review. All the best.
@@HemingwayJones thank you for your response, love your other videos too. I have been liked your other videos & bought some other pens you reviewed 👍🏻
@@HemingwayJones also try to buy your 149 Flexi nib from Truphae, best price I can find. Bought few pens from and great one
The price is high but remember its the epitome masterpiece of fountain pens lovely review. I personally like it also I like the Pelikan m1000
Thanks very much! I agree completely. All the best.
Great video!
THANK YOU!
thanks
Thank you.
The 149 model was introduced in 1952, not the 1920s.
“It's all in the name. The Meisterstück - German for masterpiece - is both a piece of art and a rich slice of history. Almost 100 years after its first introduction in 1924, the Meisterstück is the best known writing instrument of any Montblanc collection.” From Montblanc’s website. Thanks.
@@HemingwayJones Your video - which I enjoyed by the way - focusses on the 149, which does not stem from the 1920s. Just a fact check. :) It's also a copy of a Sheaffer design, but that's another story.
I've never had a 149, but love my 144 to death. Nice vid.
Thank you so much! I appreciate that.
Mine is scratchy and horrible. Emperor's cloths.
They have a nib exchange. You should have taken advantage of it. Sorry that happened to you, but there was a fix.
Cramping has nothing to do with the girth of a pen, but with poor technique (especially grip tightness). Consider writing with a #2 pencil and minimum pressure.
From personal experience, I disagree. All hands are relative. Thanks for watching and I appreciate your POV.
@@HemingwayJones Well, you're entitled to your opinion but dystonia is usually associated with poor technique, poor posture, of simply overuse. And in roughly 20% of cases it is hereditary. Nothing to do with pen size, sorry.
@@davyj5216 Yes exactly. I am the foremost authority on my opinion and yes, a thicker pen is more comfortable for me due to the simple fact that it is more comfortable. It has everything to do with pen size for me.
@@HemingwayJones Does it? Have you tried changing your grip technique, or even trying to write with a whole arm movement instead of finger writing? You likely find the thicker pen more comfortable because it compensates for poor grip and technique. Speaking from personal experience as a guy with very large hands I can say that I don't experience writer's cramp no matter what the girth of a pen. Probably because I was actually taught to write with the correct technique. The point is that you are limiting the range of tools you can use by not addressing incorrect technique. By the way, the 149 is not a big pen to me, about average really.