Metallica: One (Official Music Video) REACTION This is emotional Metallica nearly had me in tears.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 тра 2022
- ⚠ IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: IF you don't like any of my uploads for whatever reason, please don't make a scene - contact me here on UA-cam by sending me a private message or send me an e-mail tumanyashimd@gmail.com & i will happily cooperate and take it down!
© Copyright Notice:
We make these videos to motivate people and inspire them for better workout. We do not own the clips and music we use in most cases. Our understanding is that it is in correlation to Fair Right Use, however given that it is open to interpretation, if any owners of the content clips would like us to remove the video, we have no problem with that and will do so as fast as possible. Please email us if you have any concerns at tumanyashimd@gmail.com
FAIR-USE COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
1)This video has no negative impact on the original works (It would actually be positive for them)
2)This video is also for teaching purposes.
3)It is positively transformative in nature.
4)I only used bits and pieces of videos to get the point across where necessary.
The original video : • Metallica: One (Offici...
I’m not the owner of this video.
No copyright infringement intended. I do not own this video. All rights reserved to the owner of the video.
#Metallica #AndJusticeForAll #Metallica #Reaction #TheCharismaticVoice
This man was 100% fighting for his death not life. It was cruel to force him to live in that situation. There is nothing wrong with dying. People are so scared of it like you failed at living if you die. Of course it's sad for those you leave behind but for him dying is a mercy and a blessing.
In the case of people are so badly wounded no one is allowed to even visit them, there is no cruelty in ending the life if they so wish.
It's not like anyone's gonna notice it anyway.
And these people existed for real. Some WW1 victims were so disfigured they were locked into remote corners of a hospital and their family was told they died. Because they thought it was better than letting family see the mutilated but living body.
That's a horrible way to spend rest of your life.
We understand putting a suffering animal down is the moral right thing to do. But we see a human in the exact same situation and for some reason, the light-bulb just NEVER GOES OFF. It's scary how little people can draw the parallel.
When you can't see, hear and move death doesn't sound too bad
He didn't die. The nurse tried to mercy kill him but she was stopped by the Officer. He will stay as he is, trapped in a body that cannot move, see, hear, and be ignored and forgotten because his existence is too painful for others to bear in a world that sends young men like him off to die or worse in wars.
You completely miss the point, He doesn't fight to live, on the contrary, he prays to die, which is clearly understood from the lyrics of the song and from the video.
This was my first Metallica experience when I saw this video as a teenager on MTV. Few videos have ever impacted me as much, the definition of living Hell!!!
Twenty five years later as a Veteran who has fought in war, I am just thankful that I didn't have such a fate!
This was my first Metallica song as well, good on you though, this shit scared me straight out of joining any military
Thankyou for your service !!
There are worse fates than death.
This was the song that got me into Metallica way back in middle school and I'm 46 now.
The sound of that bomb howling towards the Earth still gives me chills many years later! Johnny Got his Gun has to be the most depressing movie I've ever seen. I also think that anyone planning on joining the military should watch it at least once before they make their decision.
war is a fact. and so is life. as a veteran. take time to enjoy music, food, hopes and dreams. family. in a moment it will begone. thank you. for your heart felt reaction. to this work and those who carry on.
Thank you for your bravery good sir
Absolutely brother. I'm a vet. Second lieutenant marine corps and it's people like these that make fighting for worth it.
@@brownwestmoreland1077 yes, true. Nothing more. Regards from polish vet Brothers
I fought to keep you from fighting a useless war. Sorry we couldn't stop them.
no guns..mostly rocks and Molotovs.
The movie was based on the book Johnny Got His Gun about WW1. It was one of three books banned from the troops during WW2. The author was persecuted for writing the story. The nurse knew that the soldier wanted to die tried to kill him but was stopped. He was asking God and the authorities to let him go. They should have granted his request but kept him alive as an example of their medical skill and for religious reasons.
I always took the ending as the nurse that was trying to give him peace, being stopped and he is left to suffer alone in darkness for no telling how long. He is begging for death as there is nothing left in this life but pain. The last scene is staff celebrating, while he lays alone in hell, in the next room.
Metaphorically I have always taken this song to be about depression and isolation, the fear that nothing you say or do will matter and no one will ever be listening.
all word are true to me. i recognisid the ending scene same. also to me, when you realise this, you took lightyears to the meaning of the song. great comment! 🤘
all words are true to me. i recognised the ending scene same. also to me, when you realise this ending scene, you took lightyears to the meaning of the song. great comment! 🤘
@skr I saw your response and wanted to add something. I have habit, I'm told, to see and express the dark side of situations. I wanted to add a lighter thought. James Hetfield recorded this in 1988 that's 34 years ago and in that time has played before tens of millions of paying fans. The man singing about never being heard, is one of the most listened to artists in human history.
thats a fair edit
@ James moore I have always interpreted it that the nurse was trying to help him and the guy stopped her so "Johnny" was teased with having his pain and suffering come to an end only for it to not be true and as he lies there with his words getting slower and more slurred was him accepting his situation and descending into despair, depression, and insanity all within himself. And on the other side of the wall a celebration that further adds to his torment and torture.
I have seen quite a few reactions to this song and all of them assumed that he died in the ened which makes it a very moving and emotional experience but the way I interpret it is exponentially so much worse to the point of not being able to think of anything worse that could happen to someone. Then to all of a sudden get that glorious feeling of hope and then just as quickly have it ripped away then to have the celebration or party right there as a kicker to the torment.
I don't know I could be way wrong but that is the sense that penetrates my soul while I see the video and feel the music intensity building and perfectly matching the events in the video.
There are many songs that I can feel and they touch my emotions but no other song has ever gripped my soul and evoked as much emotion and empathy from a place I never even knew existed inside me.
That is why Metallica is the greatest band that has ever existed and will always be just that in my opinion
The basic story is a young soldier in World War One steps on a landmine (per song lyrics) and loses his sight, hearing, speech, both arms, both legs, is being kept alive by machines and feels nothing but pain. He cannot tell between being awake and dreaming and wishes for death. Using Morse code, he asks for help (S.O.S.) and for them to kill him.
the question of morale here is should someone like this soldier be kept alive because it is possible? Or should this persons torture be stopped so the pain is over which means he dies? Talking landmines: in Ukraine a woman just married AFTER she stepped on such a mine and lost both legs ! There we have the scenario kind of again 30 years later!
And the original story is from a novel written by Dalton Trumbo. The title is "Johnny got his gun". English is not my first language but when I first read that book I was almost in tears throughout the reading. And then a few years later I discovered that the heavy metal band Metallica did a song about it. The video truly reflects the book.
@@christianmpassi3450 Shots are from movie Johnny Got His Gun from year 1971
@@swabia1554 not the same scenario. This woman you mentioned lost her legs. The soldier on this story, lost his legs, arms, voice, hearing and sight. Just as he says, a peace of meat who doesn't know lf he is alive or dead.
If I was in that scenario, someone better kill me.
It's the other way around - he is fighting to die, but no one will kill him. Sometimes, God likes us to suffer.
He is still alive, lifelong.
Although I thought for years that he was granted a merciful death by his nurse I later saw footage from the movie that clarifies that when the General came in and caught the nurse they were able to take action and "save" his life. So, while I thought for decades that he was allowed to escape his misery thanks to his merciful nurse he was, in fact, not allowed to die. Therefore his suffering continued. I know you said, at the end of your video, that you want him to live, but death is certainly the kinder option.
The question the novel and film the song is based on is "What is life?" If your arms, legs, eyes, ears, and ability to speak are all gone what are you? You can't really communicate with anyone even understand them if you could. You can't tell the difference between waking and sleep. You just a mind trapped in body. I don't think the person "living" that life would want to live the only people served are those around him might feel they are "saving" him, but they aren't. If you have ever had a loved one very sick or very late in life you can see the lesser version of this where being alive is a burden and continuance of pain.
He's not fighting for his life...he's begging for someone to end it, and more specifically, he's begging God to. I'd recommend pulling up lyrics to songs as you watch the videos, so you can understand what you're listening to.
You got emotional in the first 1:30 with the melodic guitar. God bless you! It shows you are listening. This song goes over a lot of reactors heads which is ashame.
It went WAAAAAY over her head, LOL. She was emotional, but clearly didn't listen to or understand the lyrics at all.
It's from the movie Johnny got his gun. One of the most moving movies I've ever seen. It's not shown that often, and that's a real shame.
Metallica owns the rights to the film.
@@logamer8183 I didn't know that. Thanks for the info
Look up the movie Johnny got his gun. And the movie based on the book was banned because of the WW1 war, but the book was brought back in 1960.
tough shit, that is.. you did great, honest moving through. men eats men for the crown...
keep your faith overall. cheers
you got it, how great is music to bring people together
The man on the bed has had his arms and legs blown off. He is blind, mute and deaf from the explosion of a landmine
Great reaction thanks I WACHT FROM COSTA RICA 🇨🇷💪🏻🇨🇷🇨🇷🇨🇷
The video in the Music video. is a movie called " Johnny got his gun "
It's war. It would defeat the purpose to have a happy ending. Its sad. War is sad
If after this you still believe in the traditional idea of the sanctity of life, you didn't watch the video or hear the song..
I'm Jerry from Texas love you take care
The Kings 🤘
I love your voice
No he's not dead at the end, he's alive. That's the true horror. Who knows how long he went on like that?
We all want him to be alive, but there are some things worse than death. That's what happened to him. The film overlayed with the video tells a great (and sad) story, but the song is worth listening to without the video. It is a great sadness, as we all should realize about war and the people involved.
The guy asks, " don't you have some message for him, Padre?(read priest)"
He responds, " He is a product of your profession, not mine."
And somehow tour take away is " at this point, only God can help"? Seriously?
Some fates are worse than death.
SOS SOS SOS father Im in terrible danger and I need help. PTSD in a nutshell.
he dead. but he was suffering, he wanted to go.
All he wants IS to die! No arms, legs, even no ears nor eyes anymore because of a landmine... that's war
sad that we will put pets down when they are suffering but we cant when we want to die.
I think you've completely misread this song.
He was no longer "alive." He was literally in hell, and the nurse liberated him.
Hey reply my companyan xit
Yes he asked for it, and the disconnect of the machines, and sure while it may have taken some time, he died. That's no way to live at all. I would even add while I don't have conditions like his, type 1 diabetes, deaf in one ear, and hearing loss in the other, can hear but need hearing aid, and also in a way isn't true life, since especially with hearing have difficulty at times with speaking to ppl think noisy situations and that sort of thing.. Was born in both ears with hearing loss. So yea I'm very empathetic to that man's want of death.
No evidence that is reasonable enough to Believe in a god we must be moral because for all we know this is the only life we have
This got weird pretty quick
100% Only gad can help you!
This sweet woman: “I hope this young man makes it”
Metallica fans: “yeah, about that…”
A decerebrated individual can not experience is the open. He's trapped in his mind. God didnt do this, war did. I won't try to take your faith but imagine a situation where you want to die because you can't move speak or communicate. You'd want to die. But murder and suicide is wrong in the old testament. I hope you learn the grey areas at least.
In the scene that the nurse is supposedly killing him, when you see him exhaling, in the movie she's not really doing that to him ... Just saying. 😉
Found the person that actually read the book (or at least saw the whole movie), lol
are you christian? love you sister.....greetings from germany
We had a understand/code. If you're messed up beyond repair, you had a duty to put your brother down. That's how it is.
Death would be mercy at that point
The sad part is WAR, that's the whole point and you didn't even mention it once....
Yeah honey he's dead. did you not pay attention to the video. Wow lol
Save him?????!!!release him from this hell.
We had a pact/understanding in war. We end each other if we get too messed up. It's a kindness, a courtesy.