@@Minirow I tend to prefer an older, crankier Doctor (points in Capaldi's favor) so I'm inclined to edge 14 over 10, but only marginally. My main gripes with 10 were how young and human he generally appeared.
Ngl I'd put Jo Martin in B tier, she's just awesome. Like yeah, we have like NOTHING with her, anf that's an issue. But what we do have, she makes a hell of an impact.
She definitely could've been great, but there was so little time to get to know her as the Doctor, and it was also in the middle of what was starting to become a very confused arc, and shaking up of the history of the show.
The Eighth Doctor made a brief comeback and got a story of his own in the runup to Day of the Doctor, albeit a short one. Would he be worthy of a place on this list? 🤔
While that is true, I ignored ones like the War Doctor and the Eight Doctor simply because they didn't have much of an inclusion in the run. If I did that, there'd also be a bunch of classic Doctors from the cameos. Both wouls be pretty high up though, especially taking the audio adventures from Big Finish into account.
@@Minirow Well, I'd definitely agree with you on that placement. Hurt I understand having just a one-off special, but poor Paul was utterly robbed of a season of his own 😟
I was pretty torn on Matt Smith, but a lot of the iffy stories stuck with me too much. I think had some slightly different decisions been made with the writing, I'd likely bump him up to A.
Swap Tennant and Smith, and you have my list.
How would you compare 10 to 14?
@@Minirow I tend to prefer an older, crankier Doctor (points in Capaldi's favor) so I'm inclined to edge 14 over 10, but only marginally. My main gripes with 10 were how young and human he generally appeared.
Ngl I'd put Jo Martin in B tier, she's just awesome. Like yeah, we have like NOTHING with her, anf that's an issue. But what we do have, she makes a hell of an impact.
She definitely could've been great, but there was so little time to get to know her as the Doctor, and it was also in the middle of what was starting to become a very confused arc, and shaking up of the history of the show.
The Eighth Doctor made a brief comeback and got a story of his own in the runup to Day of the Doctor, albeit a short one. Would he be worthy of a place on this list? 🤔
While that is true, I ignored ones like the War Doctor and the Eight Doctor simply because they didn't have much of an inclusion in the run. If I did that, there'd also be a bunch of classic Doctors from the cameos. Both wouls be pretty high up though, especially taking the audio adventures from Big Finish into account.
@@Minirow Well, I'd definitely agree with you on that placement. Hurt I understand having just a one-off special, but poor Paul was utterly robbed of a season of his own 😟
He's still a classic Doctor in my heart. 🥺
For me capaldi and matt are S and david is A
I was pretty torn on Matt Smith, but a lot of the iffy stories stuck with me too much. I think had some slightly different decisions been made with the writing, I'd likely bump him up to A.
@@Minirow season 6 felt quite messy like a lot of stories going on at once in my opinion. I much prefered the writing in the 12th doctors seasons.