Advaita, Reincarnation, Dodgy Defintions, and Falsifiability

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лип 2024
  • Vimoh Live is a weekly call-in show where I talk with callers about religion, culture, and atheism.
    Support the channel by clicking the JOIN button and becoming a member.
    Or become a patron at / vimoh
    Or make a one-time donation at www.vimoh.in
    Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard: streamyard.com/pal/d/61809340...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 230

  • @MischiefL0ki
    @MischiefL0ki 14 годин тому +45

    Everything is temporary but "mujhe btao kiss baare me baat krni hai, add me! add me! mat bolo" is permanent.

  • @vedangpathak
    @vedangpathak 14 годин тому +21

    When they say life is a dream. how do they know something exist other than this dream. what is evidence of ultimate reality not being a dream?

  • @infinity5826
    @infinity5826 14 годин тому +25

    I amazed to hear the smart and educational side of India on this channel.

  • @okeshsahu3548
    @okeshsahu3548 14 годин тому +20

    Most intellectual channel on UA-cam

  • @Harrypotter-322
    @Harrypotter-322 9 годин тому +2

    Reincarnation reality hai bro India ka case hai Shanti Devi ka vo to sb proofs or facts ke sath hai ab just because atheist ho to in chizo ko ignore krdo even though it's proven then you need to change your prospective and see the reality

  • @jagmeetjhajj
    @jagmeetjhajj 14 годин тому +1

    The way they are talking about life being a dream, it is a very ineffective way to express advaita. Life isn't a dream in the same sense as we dream when we sleep. It is a dream in a different way. The ultimate reality cannot be experienced by an individual because an individual doesn't have the means to experience it. From the time you are born you have certain tendencies, which you are conditioned to as a human. As a child you cry and want your mother's nurture. As a teenager you start feeling attraction to opposite sex. You are bound to something, in every phase of your life from birth to death. As a grown man you want to earn livelihood and start a family. You see your life in relation to all of these things and they influence how you see yourself and others. I think advaita describes this as a dream, in the sense that it is removed from the actual ultimate reality. Ultimate reality is a reality which is removed from this conditioning. A reality where you completely see the limitations of your perception.

  • @diamond_dew
    @diamond_dew 12 годин тому +1

    Why r ppl so desperate to believe any random prsn.. who said random things long time back😂😂

  • @satishboda
    @satishboda 14 годин тому

    God is Perception. God is experience. God is imagination. God is consciousness. Our experience can be categorised in 3 categories - waking world, dream world, deep sleep world. There is 4th stage which is beyond the 3 worlds where there is nothing. The 4th stage makes one realise that the reality that I experience is my own creation. I had experienced 4th stage. It is like experience of NOTHINGNESS.

  • @user-rs1ub5zk3p
    @user-rs1ub5zk3p 7 годин тому

    Day before yesterday i had a dream, that a film i wrote is in theatres housefull, it was so real, but i realized i dont know the name of the films, i asked other audience they didnt know either... i realised at that moment its a dream, why else ppl will come to watch a movie they dont know the name of...

  • @Bookisque
    @Bookisque 9 годин тому +1

    I understand Anaytra's perspective. A person who was/is extremely important to me, let's say, the most important, has become a "kattar Hindu". And it's difficult to hold a conversation with him. And I tend to get aggressive too. Who knows what'll happen! I hope taking a break helps. Maybe after a couple of years they'll come around because I'm not a calm enough person to constantly debate. Skepticism is something very personal for me. So is anti-Hindutva (not Hinduism, I'm not against any Hindus or their religion, only the rabid version of it). I cannot hold "discussions" as it's something very personal to me. Like being a woman, it's impossible to argue about Feminism because there's no other thing I can be but a feminist. Wo hi. I really hope some of our most precious relationships are salvable. It's a difficult time to be in, it's a divisive time.

  • @Manob__Human
    @Manob__Human 14 годин тому +26

    Vimoh muting and removing that Banerjee guy is best part of this podcast for me 😆😆😆

  • @The_Curious_Ra.ke01
    @The_Curious_Ra.ke01 12 годин тому +22

    (Timestamps)

  • @harshsharmap.2333
    @harshsharmap.2333 14 годин тому +12

    Abhishek don’t want to stupid so he created his own definitions

  • @kevivsinha5128
    @kevivsinha5128 12 годин тому +11

    Mai pehle caller ko batana chahunga ki ek baar dream mei maine ek aadmi se pucha tha ki kya ye real world hai ya dream world?

  • @abhisheksomani1496
    @abhisheksomani1496 14 годин тому +10

    What was that caller talking about feminism, nehru worshipers and secularism. I mean if there's a punchable caller that's who it would be.

  • @kavyam_..
    @kavyam_.. 12 годин тому +5

    That girl is the whole vibe.

  • @basantprasadsgarden8365
    @basantprasadsgarden8365 12 годин тому +4

    1:10:00

  • @bahubali100bb
    @bahubali100bb 12 годин тому +5

    22:00

  • @shiro_yasha
    @shiro_yasha 14 годин тому +5

    Dream logic is BS. If this reality is dream, then we can go to infinity with same logic. Dream within dream within dream; and there’s no ‘one infinity’.

  • @gyansahu2894
    @gyansahu2894 14 годин тому +5

    That's savage by vimoh😂