How EMIYA Beat Heracles SIX TIMES In A Row

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 чер 2023
  • really gave herc a run for his money
    website - www.hollowparadise.com
    Channel Merch: teespring.com/stores/iv-12
    Subscribe for more content: goo.gl/wvduQG
    Follow me on Twitter - / tsiahiv
    Support the channel - / tsiahiv
    #FateGrandOrder #FGO #fatestaynight
    Join the discord - / discord
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 320

  • @VacadoRay
    @VacadoRay 10 місяців тому +717

    HOW...... Because he's HIM-IYA

    • @Erohimu
      @Erohimu 10 місяців тому +51

      HIM-IYA from the Hood

    • @jeffreyherrera5069
      @jeffreyherrera5069 10 місяців тому +22

      Because he showed the unbridled wrath of the hero known as Shirou FUCKING EMIYA 😁😁

    • @WroughtIronHero
      @WroughtIronHero 9 місяців тому +5

      I'm-IYA!!!

    • @prehistoriccreator9600
      @prehistoriccreator9600 3 місяці тому

      @@Erohimu Isn't HIM-IYA from the Hood EMIYA Alter?

  • @gooddudemadworld4872
    @gooddudemadworld4872 10 місяців тому +616

    Emiya sometimes is a walking option select or a 5 star masquerading as a 4 star in fgo.

    • @tamamtamam8646
      @tamamtamam8646 10 місяців тому +65

      Yes even in game play he deserves better
      İn aoe he can refill his np with proper support

    • @TrapConnoisseur.
      @TrapConnoisseur. 10 місяців тому +80

      He's the vice president of the should've been a 5 star club after all. Herc is the president of course

    • @casteanpreswyn7528
      @casteanpreswyn7528 10 місяців тому +27

      ​@@TrapConnoisseur.I swear I read somewhere in an interview that no Counter Guardian would ever be allowed to be a 5* in fgo due to most not having any mystery.

    • @aratabhist
      @aratabhist 10 місяців тому +10

      @@casteanpreswyn7528 okita alter is a 5 star tho despite being a cg

    • @casteanpreswyn7528
      @casteanpreswyn7528 10 місяців тому +12

      @abhista9272 ngl, totally forgot she exists. Lol. But I still swear I read that in an interview. Mightve been changed now though.

  • @TheWcasey
    @TheWcasey 10 місяців тому +353

    When the modern man gets the old legend to respect him. Ya love to see it. I’d go as far as to say Gil, underneath all the distain for EMIYA, also has to respect him on some level. He’d never admit it but he probably does.

    • @jayyang236
      @jayyang236 10 місяців тому +77

      He actually does because Gil is actually afraid of EMIYA. He’ll never admit it, but he is and he respects him for that.

    • @phemelomakwela8057
      @phemelomakwela8057 10 місяців тому +46

      He gave shirou the win in ubw, after the reality marble ended he straight up acknowledged Shirou as the winner of the fight despite being the only one still standing 💯💯💯

    • @drippy2x787
      @drippy2x787 10 місяців тому +11

      @@jayyang236Gil doesn’t take him seriously.there’s no way he’s scared

    • @jayyang236
      @jayyang236 10 місяців тому +12

      @@drippy2x787 he is because he knows UNW is the only counter to him. Which is why he tried to get EMIYA out of try way first.

    • @jayyang236
      @jayyang236 10 місяців тому +7

      @@Gspoink I never said anything about EMIYA winning. All I said was that Gil respects him.

  • @user-jn1qw5xp7v
    @user-jn1qw5xp7v 10 місяців тому +112

    EMIYA got even got a demigod to respect him

  • @XFG_Official
    @XFG_Official 10 місяців тому +186

    This fight and Cu vs Gilgamesh are the main reasons I want a Ufotable Fate Route adaptation. I really want to see what they would come up with in regards to actually giving these fights screentime.

    • @FlaschenJoe11
      @FlaschenJoe11 10 місяців тому +20

      Right. Cu lasted 12h against Gil, didn't he?

    • @XFG_Official
      @XFG_Official 10 місяців тому +41

      @@FlaschenJoe11 Yep, 12 hours. One of the reasons I want to see it given a proper adaptation is because a lot of people downplay Cu by saying stuff like "he was hard carried by protection from arrows, that's the only reason he stood a chance," and it really feels like ignoring how strong Cu actually is.

    • @FlaschenJoe11
      @FlaschenJoe11 10 місяців тому +27

      @@XFG_Official Irish Hercules. When he goes all out, he is a MENACE

    • @XFG_Official
      @XFG_Official 10 місяців тому +6

      @@FlaschenJoe11 Oh yeah he's an absolute monster consistently put in awful scenarios.

    • @thesurvivlist5440
      @thesurvivlist5440 10 місяців тому +9

      @@XFG_Officialthe fact that he was carried by his protection of arrows skills is basically the truth though considering Gilgamesh just uses his weapons as projectiles.

  • @Spnozilla
    @Spnozilla 10 місяців тому +125

    With all these feats I have no idea how there are Emiya down players out there. It’s like yeah he’s not the strongest in terms of raw power and unga bunga fighting ability but time and time again he proves that he can contend with them in an abstract way that’s unique to him

    • @Warrion9876
      @Warrion9876 10 місяців тому +28

      I agree but the problem is that many emiya fanboys make him out to be an s tier servant when he really isn´t. His versatility allows him to take on characters he shouldn´t be able to take on but there is a point where versatillity alone just isn´t enough. Herc is a prime example. Emiya is a hard counter to him because of his versatillity but the difference in raw power is just to great to be overcome by versatillity alone.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +1

      @@anusaukko6792 i agree

    • @desolatorstorm142
      @desolatorstorm142 10 місяців тому +3

      @@Warrion9876 It wasn't a hard counter. Shirou tracing Herc's weapon and using a superior version of Herc vs.......Herc was hard-countering him. All EMIYA did in the fight was fight a CQB fight with more effort than he usually does. The only aspect of countering Herc was his ability to not have Herc's resistance be an auto-win for him like it is with most of the other characters. What likely happened was that EMIYA probably outperformed Herc, but was getting injured in the process, and well, Herc has 12 lives.

    • @nottomiokagiyu9830
      @nottomiokagiyu9830 10 місяців тому +2

      There's also Emiya wankers in abundance.

    • @Asphyx12
      @Asphyx12 9 місяців тому

      @@nottomiokagiyu9830 I mean we should wank him though since no one could ever tell his legends, in the end he is a modern man contending with heroes and legends.

  • @JohnPeacekeeper
    @JohnPeacekeeper 10 місяців тому +471

    Honestly, I think he could have actually taken all 12 had he gotten proper support
    Unlimited Blade Works is cracked

    • @EliyahDaBoss
      @EliyahDaBoss 10 місяців тому +121

      He could have just done what gilgamesh did to berserker, he also could have just killed ilya but he didnt wanna harm her

    • @reaps2661
      @reaps2661 10 місяців тому +27

      He might've also been able to with an open area

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +55

      he can actually if you think about it + he was injured during the fight against Herc Thanks to Artoria injuring him beforehand

    • @JRZTT
      @JRZTT 10 місяців тому +9

      @@user-pm9ev3up5t I think someone debunk that with Archer already fully heal by the time this fight start

    • @misteris2385
      @misteris2385 10 місяців тому +7

      With unli mana he mostlikely can. Just spam caladbolg I guess? Not sure if it would work, its spacial piercing vs god hand, wonder how it would go.

  • @Feronen
    @Feronen 10 місяців тому +66

    EMIYA has always had the capacity to take on pretty much any servant and hold his own well. The problem he has is that UBW is a Noble Phantasm that is tailor-made to fight against Gilgamesh and his Gates of Babylon. Unless he's fighting against someone with a similar NP to Gates of Babylon, like Nobu's 300 Muskets, he is simply rendered into a jack-of-all-trades, master of none servant. What truly defines EMIYA as being absolutely cracked is the fact that he knows this about himself and he's able to adapt his kit through sheer skill of arms. This is what makes every servant who has fought EMIYA respect him so much - through adversity, he perseveres and overcomes by skill alone.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +17

      You literally forgot Emiyas most Broken Ability which is down Right terrifying Because he can copy stats, Skills,History of ANy NP He Projects and can use it anytime he wants. Emiya with his analysis can tell the weakness and Strength oF Servant in one Glance. He cant abuse this ability because of his limited ManaPool Thats why he is a B Tier servant

    • @SirFooplesTheThird
      @SirFooplesTheThird 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@user-pm9ev3up5this mana pool as a servant is limited. If summoned by the CF his mana is infinite which is why he could win wars for millenia

    • @philippgabainvonkries5117
      @philippgabainvonkries5117 3 місяці тому +1

      The fact that this actually true in lore is one the biggest points against Nasu's writing. Man can write detailed characters and stories but he's really bad at keeping a coherent Power system. Logicly UBW being a faster omni directional version of the gate of Babylon should be enough to completely overwhelm most servants but it's treated as if it somehow doesn't do that when he's not fighting Gilgamesh.

  • @nandan148
    @nandan148 10 місяців тому +31

    Because my man is built different

    • @en-voguepugh3472
      @en-voguepugh3472 10 місяців тому +5

      quite literally made of blades right?

  • @Faker21
    @Faker21 10 місяців тому +25

    He got that dog in him

    • @Erohimu
      @Erohimu 10 місяців тому +7

      That would be Cu if I'm not mistaken 😂

  • @lanuel2208
    @lanuel2208 10 місяців тому +54

    Be honest if EMIYA was allowed to have a legend he'd be part of the legendary tier heroic spirit type.
    And this guy went toe to toe with legendary heroes with just his skills since he's been nerfed by being a counter guardian.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +15

      Funniest Part is that It was implied that Emiya was much stronger when he was alive(i dont remember the exact time but it was stated in Material of UBW if i am not wrong)

    • @lanuel2208
      @lanuel2208 10 місяців тому +20

      @@user-pm9ev3up5t and seeing what Archer can do in fate extella yea I can see a younger Archer stronger in his prime

    • @ShizukiShirano
      @ShizukiShirano 10 місяців тому +11

      @@user-pm9ev3up5t Being a Servant is ironically basically a nerf too, since you have limited resources and the world can try to erase you at the same time lol

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +13

      @@ShizukiShirano True Being Servant is Nerf in most cases and OP in some case Bedivere, Archimedes,etc are Good Example, And Character like Saber, Gilgamesh and Emiya are heavily nerfed in Servant Form but atleast Saber and Gilgamesh have some Legend Backing them up meanwhile Emiya has none of it

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +2

      @@lanuel2208 True

  • @arabbitwhocanuseinternet9657
    @arabbitwhocanuseinternet9657 10 місяців тому +81

    Well in fate extella:
    He can summon gae bolg, galatine and nero sword. So unlimted blades can help him uses many np from other servants.

    • @cephery8482
      @cephery8482 10 місяців тому +3

      I mean the moon cell probably allowed him to see a lot of noble phantasms he didnt have a chance to as just a counter guardian so that he could place them into UBW. I feel like the reason he sticks to the much smaller range of them in stay night is just cause he very rarely got called on by the counter force to places where other heroic spirits were present, so he treasured those weapons he could actually bare witness to

    • @danboii137
      @danboii137 10 місяців тому +3

      according to the data books from extella, the moon cell allowed nameless to do things he couldn't do in a normal war. Like projecting Excalibur image and using it without hurting himself

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +9

      @@danboii137 Half correct except its not that mooncell allowed it but all Servants in Mooncells gets infinite amount of mana(because of it having different rules) and are less restricted(Since the mooncell can restore the world instantly) thats why Emiya doesnt have to worry about mana which was his biggest issue with Projecting Excalibur

    • @Infernal_Sniper
      @Infernal_Sniper 10 місяців тому +3

      @@cephery8482 we actually know that hes had those weapons from before the moon cell. One of the swords that gilgamesh fires out of the gate of babylon is excalibur galatine so we can definitively say that he has had it because nameless is post grail wars emiya. That also means hes had gae bolg. the only one we dont know where he picked it up out of the three is nero's aestus estus.

    • @tahirbhatti965
      @tahirbhatti965 9 місяців тому

      ​@@Infernal_SniperWell Emiya was the reason for the fall of the Roman Empire. He must have seen it when Nero was in her theater

  • @Lune606
    @Lune606 10 місяців тому +24

    trace ON!!!!!!!

  • @rebelblade7159
    @rebelblade7159 10 місяців тому +51

    If EMIYA is not limited by the plot, he'd be a very tough opponent to face in a Holy Grail War. His cold and calculating attitude means that he lacks the pride and arrogance that limits many heroes while his projection would also allow him to instantly learn the true names of most servants by tracing their weapons. Now he has his skills and arsenal to utilize in order to find the most effective way to win.

    • @joeylagitan2692
      @joeylagitan2692 10 місяців тому +10

      tbf he's not limited by the plot but plot helps him do something extra ordinary

    • @L0L246
      @L0L246 5 місяців тому +2

      ​​@@joeylagitan2692 nah he'd solo the grail war if rin didnt hold him back
      Edit: I mean that she stops him form killing and using his plans(the ones that let shirou in mind of steel win it all) not mana wise since she boosts him there

  • @Wolfkiller335
    @Wolfkiller335 10 місяців тому +16

    A reminder that Emiya only fought in his own terms and was wise enough to keep some things hidden unless a threat to the balance is suspected. He didn't value himself, he was willing to die. He didn't want others to see what he could do, because he felt he didn't measure up to the "heroes" he was summoned alongside.

  • @zerx5260
    @zerx5260 10 місяців тому +16

    Emiya is just that guy

  • @murilopenagoncalves3831
    @murilopenagoncalves3831 10 місяців тому +21

    I'm pretty sure he saved them so that the 'next scene' on the ruins could happend. What a bro.
    (People who read the original VN will understand)

    • @volcanicz6739
      @volcanicz6739 10 місяців тому +7

      There's a deen illustration that really had the vibe of EMIYA saying "Aight bro u got this"

  • @maverick5169
    @maverick5169 10 місяців тому +31

    I love the fact that we don't know how Emiya defeats Berserker 6 times in Fate, because then we play UBW and realize that 1) as Shirou, he knows how Herc fights and what it's needed to win against him and 2), he has a stupidly strong NP that can put even Gilgamesh on the ropes. So the fight finally makes perfect sense.

    • @rome3521
      @rome3521 10 місяців тому +4

      UBW is not really op, it's far from "very good" it's just that Gilgamesh and Herc have some odd conditions that's why UBW is effective to them.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +13

      @@rome3521 If you think UBW isnt OP then youre Dead wrong Especially If He can just Use Multiple NP in UBW in span of seconds with No Drawbacks and copy stats of original user and Weapon Ability + Getting Rained Down by Countless Broken Phantasm from Every Direction? Thats Busted if used at its Best

    • @desolatorstorm142
      @desolatorstorm142 10 місяців тому +9

      @@rome3521 Not exactly. For Gil, it was a hard counter, but the reason why it's a hard counter is because UBW really does temporarily give him Gil levels of firepower temporarily and it's better in CQB. Herc fight had no condition. EMIYA was just a strong CQB fighter and it was odd to him that he had so many high level techniques. There's no other details than that.

    • @maverick5169
      @maverick5169 10 місяців тому

      Mofos here being pedantic as fuck and it still doesn't contradict my point

    • @L0L246
      @L0L246 4 місяці тому

      ​@desolatorstorm142 so Gils gate of Babylon isn't op cuz UBW is just a weaker version of that(it's better in some aspects, but I do think it's overall worse)

  • @sleepylmguy9968
    @sleepylmguy9968 10 місяців тому +107

    Let me add some other theoretical options for killing Herc. You mentioned the possibility of him using Excalibur, the draw back it would be a death for Emiya as well. But what if instead of EXcalibur, he could have opted to use regular Calibur? The predecessor. That one while not as powerful as the former it would theoretically not take Emiya own life to make unlike Excalibur. I mean OG human Shirou Emiya can make it even tho he’s less experience in his tracing power, I see no logical reason why Archer Emiya can’t do it too. For either to get off one or two lives. Or he could use it the entire fight. Just spit balling here.
    Another option I could see Archer using. Gáe Bolg. Now I know what you’re thinking. Can Archer even make Gáe Bolg? And most importantly can he even use its Noble Phantasm? I’m inclined to say…yes to both. Tho I’m not sure if it will be an Excalibur situation which meaning if it will take his life to do. But even if it does. He can use it for the for LAST kill. Or last resort to take one final life before disappearing.

    • @Lucaintheninjatank
      @Lucaintheninjatank 10 місяців тому +26

      Caliburn only demonstrates that level of power when used by Saber and Gae Bolg can't harm Heracles unless Cu using the original full strength version buffs it with his runes.

    • @blake3472
      @blake3472 10 місяців тому +33

      ​@@Lucaintheninjatankemiya can use durandal wich is better and equal or stronger than calibur, also gae bolg would be no problem to use but it isn't strong enough to damage herc

    • @Lucaintheninjatank
      @Lucaintheninjatank 10 місяців тому +15

      @@blake3472 Durandal is better than Caliburn for EMIYA for sure but do remember that Caliburn can match Excalibur for one shot then break but only when wielded by Artoria.
      Yes Emiya can trace Gae Bolg, my point was even regular Gae Bolg can't kill Heracles.

    • @blake3472
      @blake3472 10 місяців тому +10

      @@Lucaintheninjatank calibur even with artoria is A+ rank same of durandal also durandal is compared with excallibur so yes it is equal or even stronger than calibur, i coment that gae bolg wouldn't damage herc it is a B rank emiya's one would be C rank

    • @sleepylmguy9968
      @sleepylmguy9968 10 місяців тому +9

      @@Lucaintheninjatank Hmmm, with both weapons in their standard versions that might be true. But what if Emiya would turn them both into Broken phantasm? Couldn't that raised the power by enough?
      Also I want to mention. That before Shirou gave Calibur to Saber, I recalled a scene where Shirou cuts off Berserker hand by himself. So with that evidence it's has enough power while being wield by Artoria to cut his skin. Or was that just a Filler scene that the animators throw in to extend the fight?

  • @threadinfinite7070
    @threadinfinite7070 10 місяців тому +14

    So essentially Emiya's bag is just busted and we need to recognize he's one of the realest in the game.

  • @1mjvywrld
    @1mjvywrld 10 місяців тому +4

    Emiya’s literally the TYPE-MOON OC ,, even his Shirou version was the first and only being ,, heroic spirit or otherwise in the animes and games (to my knowledge) to even somewhat threaten Gilgamesh outside of maybe Enkidu and the Chains of Heaven ,, who’s considered to be the God of Spirits and ,, up until the introduction of Shirou Emiya ,, possibly the most broken and OP being to ever live . and it’s literally only because his Noble Phantasm ,, Unlimited Blade Works ,, was a Reality Marble literally crafted by TYPE-MOON to be the perfect counter for The Gate of Babylon (Gilgamesh’s Noble Phantasm) .

  • @Serascale
    @Serascale 10 місяців тому +30

    He just went out of mana. I am sure he can kill 12 times

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +23

      Emiya with Infinite Mana? Yeah no one wants to see someone firing off 100s of Excalibur at you as a Broken Phantasm, That will be terrifying

    • @nicolascreo5295
      @nicolascreo5295 10 місяців тому

      @@user-pm9ev3up5tcg emiya: yes terrifying

    • @pandoraspixel3367
      @pandoraspixel3367 10 місяців тому +1

      Counter gaurdian emiya would have realistically been stronger than Archer emiya.
      Being a servant probably even nerfed him from his original power, plus he doesn't have a legend and the fame to increase his strength like other servants.
      He got so far through sheer skill

    • @nicolascreo5295
      @nicolascreo5295 10 місяців тому +1

      @@pandoraspixel3367 cg emiya could have his stats set accordingly to the threath.. bot like emiya really care. He is just so reliable

  • @sunwukong825
    @sunwukong825 10 місяців тому +5

    Berserker really said: Man, I got finessed so hard. This guy is mad lad, bro.

  • @silentfate
    @silentfate 10 місяців тому +9

    Emiya probably literally knocked some sense back into heracles there.

  • @deathoftheoldme8645
    @deathoftheoldme8645 10 місяців тому +13

    God this is why emiya is my favorite servant

  • @HeartlessAlpha
    @HeartlessAlpha 10 місяців тому +6

    Thank you for making this video! I'm glad we got more context on this legendary fight. Do people understand what kind of n***a you have to be to win respect from Heracles? And have him think if he wasn't consumed by madness, he would've enjoyed the fight AND call it a satisfying time? EMIYA is the GOAT.

  • @aaronramos5327
    @aaronramos5327 10 місяців тому +4

    Amazing video, amazing content. Thanks for all the hard work bringing more and more info and lore about Fate and Type Moon. + 1 subscriber

  • @vergilneedsmorepower473
    @vergilneedsmorepower473 9 місяців тому +2

    That's why he's The Goat, THE GOAT!

  • @thomasmcgraw8778
    @thomasmcgraw8778 10 місяців тому +19

    Yeah Emya's matchups are weird. His stats are so meh its hard to give him anythingbut a b rank. But his skillset is so good Ex servants still have a hard time. No matter who you are taking down Emya is just such a chore.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +12

      If Given the Right Condition he can Actually defeat Ex Tier servants even though he is nothing more than a B tier Servant. But at the same time his Ability to Copy stats of Projected weapons makes his Base Stats Deceptive because he can change them anytime he wants without difficulty thats why its hard to Rank him

    • @larantuka8189
      @larantuka8189 10 місяців тому +1

      So, it's like batman?

    • @thomasmcgraw8778
      @thomasmcgraw8778 10 місяців тому +2

      @@larantuka8189 eh. Not far off. Only difference is batman usually wins.

  • @ferrucciocaracciuolo8139
    @ferrucciocaracciuolo8139 10 місяців тому +9

    He really is The Side kick himself.

  • @Crimson161
    @Crimson161 10 місяців тому +7

    THE GOAT

  • @777DRay
    @777DRay 10 місяців тому

    I love these videos man

  • @phonegamer1587
    @phonegamer1587 10 місяців тому +6

    requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 19

    • @phonegamer1587
      @phonegamer1587 10 місяців тому

      requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 20

    • @phonegamer1587
      @phonegamer1587 10 місяців тому

      requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 21

    • @phonegamer1587
      @phonegamer1587 10 місяців тому +1

      requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 22

  • @Silly_Illidan
    @Silly_Illidan 10 місяців тому +7

    FSN: The only series in which the OC is the GOAT

  • @johantank5631
    @johantank5631 10 місяців тому +42

    Personally I think that Heracles kinda got nerfed in most his fights as Nasu made a character that only one or 2 characters could even beat him, so he made a bunch of different ways which are kinda lore breaking
    (Like caliburn which is b rank increasing in rank or nine lives which is a technique being able to be copied by Emiya)

    • @johantank5631
      @johantank5631 10 місяців тому +4

      @@Nekogami04 it’s not that nine lives is used to take live’s ( I’m fine with that especially considering it’s in lore origins) it’s that someone else was able to use that np in the first place as that version of the np was a technique not a physical weapon and the explanation given (Emiya copying the weapons history) also doesn’t make sense since Herk is unable to use nine lives as a berserker and the weapon he uses is one acquired after summoning
      The caliburn explanation sounds okay though (seven lives is still a little much for a broken b)

    • @r.k845
      @r.k845 10 місяців тому +25

      @@johantank5631Anything Hercules touches immediately becomes able to perform 9 lives.
      It’s a technique that’s imbued on anything Hercules uses as a weapon.

    • @DANSTER999
      @DANSTER999 10 місяців тому +5

      ​@@Nekogami04so another thing about Caliburn is that apparently when in Sabers hands it instantly jumps into an A+ rank and is capable of a Excalibur level blast

    • @f.ggaming8206
      @f.ggaming8206 10 місяців тому +3

      Well Nine Lives was only able to kill Herc because of what the Shadow had done to his body. It doesn’t show it in the movie but in the VN during the fight with Saber Alter the Shadow appeared and wrapped itself around Herc, in order to continue fighting and protect Illya he literally had to peel of his own skin in order to escape. God Hand is a conceptual NP imbued upon his skin without it he is no longer immune to attacks that aren’t A rank and he loses his adaptability to things that killed him previously. He still retains the revival portion of his NP but against a grail empowered saber alter alongside his inability to use a majority of his techniques and solely rely on his brute strength simple attacks it would only be a matter of time until he’s weakened enough for the Shadow to fully engulf him. When he was under grail corruption he was still missing his skin so Shirou was only to use nine lives and take his remaining lives.
      Also about the whole Caliburn being able to take multiple lives, to me that made sense. To people who don’t fully understand the power of NP’s as a simple C rank NP has the fire power of a A rank attack. Considering that Caliburn was a A+ NP alongside it being classified as an anti-army NP and not an anti unit it would be reasonable to assume that it would be able to kill Herc 6 times over, doubly so when you considered it was activated when it was literally inside Herc’s gut.

    • @jeffreyherrera5069
      @jeffreyherrera5069 10 місяців тому +1

      ​@@r.k845"It's a technique that's imbued on anything Hercules uses as a weapon."
      FGO Jason: *nervous sweating*

  • @namelessking8527
    @namelessking8527 10 місяців тому +1

    Ty, always thought abt this scene, need to collab on reanimating and making the fight even more realistic

  • @SSL_2004
    @SSL_2004 10 місяців тому +9

    Archer: Shirou Emiya after a literally indeterminate amount of time and training with magecraft to become a fighter on par with renowned heroes of legend. Has access to literally every physical Noble Phantasm any Shirou Emiya in any timeline has ever seen ever in the history of ever.
    >Was only capable of eradicating 6 of Heracles' 12 lives in a long fight. (Gilgamesh was able to annihilate almost all of them with Gate of Babylon, which is basically a functionally identical Noble Phantasm to Unlimited Blade Works. [Granted he had the help of Enkidu {Granted not like that matters because Archer could theoretically trace that}])
    Fate Route Shirou Emiya: Literally the same guy but millennia younger and with borderline dysfunctional magic circuits and next to no magecraft experience or ability.
    >Is capable of taking Seven of Heracles lives with a SINGLE stab of Caliburn, the inferior version of Excalibur that was previously ineffective, and a weapon that Archer literally has.
    Of all of the bullshit in Fate this is by far the bullshittiest. Nasu Moment.

    • @jorienwachukwu466
      @jorienwachukwu466 9 місяців тому +3

      To be fair, Archer had been injured by Saber earlier in the route, which meant he was already weak when he fought Heracles. And he was bound to a master, meaning he couldn't afford to be reckless with his projection otherwise it would drain Rin and possibly kill her, so he couldn't whip out too many high-ranking NPs (note how, except for Caladbolg, he only used Kansho and Bakuya). He was mainly just stalling for time, and had no intention to actually beat Heracles. Plus, he was at a disadvantage in terms of location and stats, going up against a Berserker servant with A ranked abilities in an enclosed space. He was heavily limited in what he could use, especially since any weapon he uses has its stats reduced, unlike Gil's G.O.B. He could use Broken Phantasms, but those require a lot of mana, which again would put Rin at risk. Not to mention, his broken phantasms can cause massive damage and could end up harming Illya, who he was actively avoiding, whereas Gil kept Heracles on the defensive by targeting Illya, allowing him to get free shots in.
      Shirou is definitely unrealistic, but he did have help from Saber, who as we know, can use her Mana Burst ability to massively enhance her attacks. She most likely used her Mana Burst to enhance Caliburn, allowing it to take all 7 of Heracles' lives. I highly doubt Shirou would have been able to do much on his own, or if he did, it would only be like 2 or 3 lives at best. Archer had some severe handicaps coming in to that fight, but he made the most with what he had, and being able to kill Herc 6 times in a row, while having no legend buffs, and average stats, is a testament to how strong EMIYA actually is

    • @unclecaramel
      @unclecaramel 3 місяці тому

      In fate route i think archer doesn't remeber much of himself before and i really donlt think he manage to use ubw against herc at all. Pretty sure he beat him through just pure projection while being ingured my saber beforehand

  • @yogandi8922
    @yogandi8922 10 місяців тому +4

    Emiya is just goated, simple answer

  • @heavencanceler2691
    @heavencanceler2691 6 місяців тому +2

    2:00 Nasu basically retconned his own stuff because it would make Herc too OP. In the original Novel most likely Saber Alter just killed him multiple times in one big Excaliblast and/or stab or something like that. Like how Shirou took a ton of his lives in one shot with Caliburn as you said. OG text is basically that Berserker gain 100 Resistance to anything that hits him which isn't theoretically perfect defense if someone goes "above maximum" but will negate the vast majority of things.

    • @blueperiodfan4725
      @blueperiodfan4725 2 місяці тому

      its funny that salter actually can lost if herc doesnt get corrupted. she ran out of ways to kill herc even with the retcon.
      herc god hand is way too busted especially in grail war setting.

  • @GREAT_THE_MIYA
    @GREAT_THE_MIYA 10 місяців тому +4

    One thing that we all got to remember is that canonically, Emiya is the only servant who has done this feat "properly" multiple times, and without any external help + a clearly disadvantaged state (being locked fighting on an enclosed space vs a Berserker)
    Other one would be Vanilla Saber but it was only 1 life
    Shirou got help from Rin and Saber in the fate route, its basically a gangb*ng so to say and even with Saber on their side she still couldnt do anything except help shirou trace Caliburn with the power of love
    Heavens Feel Shirou used Archer's arm
    Saber Alter was able to do so because of her infinite Mana supply from Sakura, a proper master would probably be drained as hell with a morgan or two and thats assuming theyre a proper Magus, hell maybe even less
    Gil Touched the mud and was basically Reincarnated, no master to worry about either unlike Herc who was constantly protecting Illya during their fight
    Ritsuka and his servants in Okeanos needed to set traps and lure him in
    You can argue the prillya gang but im not keen on it because class cards basically just lets you borrow a fraction of a heroic spirit's power so it depends if you count that or not

    • @Rodiacreed
      @Rodiacreed 10 місяців тому +1

      The blasts that Saber Alter used against Heracles were her mana burst skill not Excalibur which she only used at the end of the fight for the giant explosion.

  • @hollowficate
    @hollowficate 10 місяців тому +2

    *EMIYA theme INTENSIFIED*

  • @sleepyarcheremiya955
    @sleepyarcheremiya955 10 місяців тому +6

    That’s why he is the goat

  • @rozeazelios8836
    @rozeazelios8836 10 місяців тому +3

    Man with no legend Boost
    Not A Demi God
    Nor someone special with Pioneer of the stars
    Just a Man who is trapped for Eon for cleaning humanity's Trash and in doing so, becoming one of the Top class despite him being a Nobody in the Grand scheme of things...

  • @gilvan4158
    @gilvan4158 10 місяців тому +1

    Great video , what about a video of EMIYA vs fate/stay night servants ? :)

  • @faith4657
    @faith4657 10 місяців тому +2

    Being sometime seen we talked about emiya

  • @carlossique9604
    @carlossique9604 10 місяців тому

    I rewatched their fight not too long ago. And then this video came out

  • @itsarin2166
    @itsarin2166 10 місяців тому +3

    Emiya is pretty much the Batman of Heroic Spirits. While most other Heroic Spirits are demi god, dragon blood or famous figure, this guy is just a random human with third rate magecraft, persistence and a dream that somehow able to stand toe to toe against other servants even though servant statwise he should be a low tier due to him not even being a standard heroic spirit and lack of legend or fame.

  • @Joshua_Shadow_Manriguez
    @Joshua_Shadow_Manriguez 10 місяців тому +1

    Heracles felt the unbridled wrath of SHIROU FUCKING EMIYA!!!

  • @Cynical_Citizenz
    @Cynical_Citizenz 10 місяців тому +3

    Garcher

  • @stephenenetama8335
    @stephenenetama8335 6 місяців тому

    Thanks!

  • @secretsecret299
    @secretsecret299 10 місяців тому +2

    He held back bruh he didn't want to murder illya

  • @coast2coast-295
    @coast2coast-295 4 місяці тому +1

    One thing of note that I liked is that both the VN and the anime showed Emiya standing up before vanishing, and Heracles bleeding out like a pin cushion of swords. Emiya didn't lose to Heracles, the dude just straight up burned through all his and Rin's mana and vanished.

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  4 місяці тому

      he definitely loss you dsing but he went out like a G

  • @dante_dmc3
    @dante_dmc3 4 місяці тому

    He is just built different like his swords man he probably loves swords

  • @ethanjohnson5085
    @ethanjohnson5085 10 місяців тому +1

    Hercules is my favorite character from fate stay night. Sometimes i feel bad when his lives are taken. Idky i like him so much but i do

  • @amenadieljoyeuse3955
    @amenadieljoyeuse3955 Місяць тому +1

    Composite Archer
    True Name: Beyond Emiya
    SPECIES: High-Servant, Saint & Magus
    GENDER: Male HEIGHT: 186cm
    WEIGHT: 90kg Type: Counter Guardian
    PARAMETER
    STRENGTH: B ENDURANCE: A AGILITY: A+
    MANA: A LUCK: B (EX) NP: A++ (EX)
    ARMAMENTS
    Mantle, Knife, Pistol, Holy Shroud & Avalon
    CLASS SKILLS
    Independent Action: A+
    Magic Resistance: A
    Presence Concealment: A+
    Personal Skills
    • Clairvoyance (A Rank):
    • Mind's Eye [True] (A Rank):
    • Magecraft (A Rank):
    • Projection Magecraft (B -> Conditionally EX Rank):
    • Trace On: Circuit Connection (EX Rank):
    • Ultimate Enchantment (EX Rank):
    • Wrought Iron Will (A+ Rank):
    • Affection of the Holy Grail (A+ Rank):
    • Bulletproof Treatment (A Rank):
    • Scapegoat (C Rank):
    Noble Phantasm
    Infinite Creation of Swords
    [Unlimited Blade Works] (E~A++ Rank)
    Forever Distant Golden Sword
    [Excalibur Image] (A Rank)
    The Everdistant Utopia [Avalon] (EX Rank)
    The Void Creation of Swords
    [Unlimited Lost Works] (E~A++ Rank)
    Gather Ye Rosebuds While Ye May
    [Chronos Rose] (B+ Rank)
    Mystery Bisection [Phantasm Punishment]
    (C+ Rank)
    Sandalphon, Lord of Execution [Judgement] (EX Rank)

  • @salty7182
    @salty7182 10 місяців тому +2

    just as you expect from definitely not satan

  • @noahhicks471
    @noahhicks471 10 місяців тому

    Hello I was just wondering is there any chance you're going to remake don't sleep on a Emiya? Since you gotten a lot better with that type of videos

  • @carlosgarza400
    @carlosgarza400 10 місяців тому +1

    Goatia

  • @spiffybadgaster8454
    @spiffybadgaster8454 10 місяців тому +6

    Now... This made me wonder how Kojiro defeated Heracles in Fate Unlimited Code What-if... I know it just what if but let's just think (Dont take it too serious)

    • @maverick5169
      @maverick5169 10 місяців тому +4

      By Nasu's own admission, anything is canon. So yeah, UC arcade modes should be considered.

    • @desolatorstorm142
      @desolatorstorm142 10 місяців тому +2

      A buff?

    • @Hetsu..
      @Hetsu.. 8 місяців тому

      In terms of swordplay isn't he on par with atoria, if he was buffed it's possible maybe

  • @jmspicer96
    @jmspicer96 10 місяців тому +2

    Let's go

  • @pippooni1787
    @pippooni1787 10 місяців тому +6

    He could have won that fight, period. EMIYA, is a way too complete Servant, for not having ONE chance to win. Worst case scenario, he could have went for the suicide attack, reproducing Excalibur killing Heracles and dying himself in the process.
    Let’s be honest, he lost this fight for ONE main reason: “Plot”

    • @mariomario-dy1kc
      @mariomario-dy1kc 10 місяців тому

      Considering how Shirou with a fraction of Emyia's power took 9 lives from Berserker in an instant, it would stand to logic EMYIA should've been able to take all 12.

    • @jorienwachukwu466
      @jorienwachukwu466 9 місяців тому

      @@mariomario-dy1kc 7. Shirou took 7 lives, and with help from Saber.

    • @mariomario-dy1kc
      @mariomario-dy1kc 9 місяців тому

      @@jorienwachukwu466 I'm talking about the Heaven's Feel route, not the Fate Route.

    • @tavoa952
      @tavoa952 8 місяців тому

      ​@@mariomario-dy1kc blackened herc didnt have god hand, and nine lives didn't work in berserker herc ( nasu said he
      can counter it)

  • @suryaandika6084
    @suryaandika6084 10 місяців тому +1

    Emiya just being considered to Rin
    He is not using his full access magical energy from Rin, in order for threesome mana transfer scene for reader!!

  • @regend7327
    @regend7327 10 місяців тому

    Emiya woke up and chose violence

  • @AllOtakuProductions
    @AllOtakuProductions 10 місяців тому +2

    Ufotable!!! I need this fight reanimated!!!! Please!!!!!!😫

  • @razz9034
    @razz9034 10 місяців тому +4

    First?
    Also Emiya built Different

  • @omariwashington2570
    @omariwashington2570 10 місяців тому +2

    Hey Tslah IV, If all the Shiro's fought each other, who would win it's just a question I know a lot of people would want an answer for.

  • @marquisburrell
    @marquisburrell 10 місяців тому

    Do u have a discord? I need to talk to u about something. U seem more open minded to listen to facts and opinions than most fate fans

  • @harryblocks
    @harryblocks 10 місяців тому +1

    Simple.
    He just makes exploding swords

  • @sourwolf95
    @sourwolf95 10 місяців тому

    Now lasengle please release new servant of him with his counter guardian form

  • @randomguy8286
    @randomguy8286 10 місяців тому +2

    EMIYA is him.

  • @smoczystrumien7908
    @smoczystrumien7908 10 місяців тому +45

    Can Herc get resistance to fist? Like if Saber punch him to death will Herc grow resistance to it?

    • @tamamtamam8646
      @tamamtamam8646 10 місяців тому +10

      Theoritecly yes why not
      But its reguire saitama level punch

    • @lazharsassi6573
      @lazharsassi6573 10 місяців тому +3

      Saber wouldn't be able to hurt/kill him because saber herself is a human with no divinity and B strength. God Hand protects him against anything that isn't divine or under A rank. Achilles might be able to hurt Heracles with bare fists, because he is part divine and has B+ strength.
      But I doubt this would be enough to inflict lethal damage since Heracles body is extremely robust even without God Hand.
      But theoretically after Achilles would take one of his lives bye beating him to death he would get resist against kicks and punches.

    • @smoczystrumien7908
      @smoczystrumien7908 10 місяців тому +2

      @@lazharsassi6573 under Rin her strength stat is A, and I was curius. But woud he be resistant only to ahilles punches or overal all fist ataks.

    • @lazharsassi6573
      @lazharsassi6573 10 місяців тому

      @@smoczystrumien7908 Dude no way Saber has strength above B. Where'd you get that from.
      Though, I think the resistance would be overall.

    • @smoczystrumien7908
      @smoczystrumien7908 10 місяців тому +3

      @@lazharsassi6573 For saber fate stay night master rin stat strength is A rank is in novel or you can check google images.
      I just think that gaining resistance to most Basic form of atak is just wierd.
      I liked it beter for avenger Acildes and his Lion skin armor where any man made wepons are nulified but unarmd ataks are fine.
      For me it just make sense that pure strength just works.

  • @lorenbrown7100
    @lorenbrown7100 10 місяців тому +3

    I need to know where this scene 5:43 Is from I don't know why but seeing archer and kiritsugu walk past emiya just seems I can't even describe how cool it is but fr we're is this scene from

  • @memedealer2018
    @memedealer2018 10 місяців тому +1

    Then in unlimited blade works he makes it very clear that even nuking Heracles wasn't going to do shit other than slowing him down

  • @foodoftherinnegan1583
    @foodoftherinnegan1583 10 місяців тому

    My head cannon is he used caliburn after spamming all his abilities that are A rank opens up and opportunity and hits him but he is to fatigued and only takes a few life’s like 2

  • @bluespeed7406
    @bluespeed7406 9 місяців тому

    i whould say emiya used ubw but did not use all his wepons in his reality marbel like oath under snow shirou did
    because he clashed with EA and held his own for a while granted he did loose the clash but it is still EA he clashed with and i doubt that even if Heracles had all his 12 lives he whould have survived EA

  • @dinocharlie1
    @dinocharlie1 10 місяців тому

    Does a broken phantasms use that much extra mana? I was under the assumption it sacrifices the weapons stability to give it a one time burst in power.
    Also, do we know every broken phantasm creates a large explosion? Because I thought the arrow in the Deen Fate route that changes from a spiral shape to a more traditional arrow shape was a broken Caladbolg.

  • @adityasingh1974
    @adityasingh1974 10 місяців тому +1

    Make a video on how powerful counter gaurdian. emiya can be

  • @M.W.2
    @M.W.2 10 місяців тому +4

    What about sasaki and Heracles fight? When did this even stated?

  • @bhanupriyainampudi6852
    @bhanupriyainampudi6852 10 місяців тому +2

    can you make a video on shiki tohno ciel and arcueid from tsukihime

  • @lazharsassi6573
    @lazharsassi6573 10 місяців тому +5

    Even tho Emily's skills with weapons might not be as good as Diarmuid or Saber's and his physical parameters are not as overwhelming like Heracles or Achilles, I often forget how versatile his arsenal in weapons is and what impact it can have in any battle.
    He has access to a lot of different strategies, in close range or long range combat.
    We saw how much Saber struggled against Herc on the graveyard and she coughed only one opening with Caliburn.
    Emiya had to land a clean hit on him 6 times.
    If Caliburn or Excalibur didn't take multiple lives, she would never be able to get this far.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +7

      Tbh you cant exactly Judge Emiya on Stats Parameter because his Stats are Deceptive, Since he can change his stats easily by using traced NP and skills of traced weapons, by overcharging his Magic circuits, Reinforcement,etc

    • @Rodiacreed
      @Rodiacreed 10 місяців тому

      Saber was nerfed in the graveyard and saying without Excalibur she wouldn't have gotten far makes no sense since the same could be applied to any servant and their noble phantasm. Would Emiya have gotten far without UBW/Projection? Would Gil have gotten far without GoB?

  • @otakunemesis34
    @otakunemesis34 10 місяців тому +1

    Attempt 1 of asking you to do a video on world of darkness.

  • @DripAlucard
    @DripAlucard 10 місяців тому +2

    Yooo what's up yall

  • @alexong2542
    @alexong2542 10 місяців тому +1

    3 words
    Unlimited Blade Works

  • @user-en8tt4uu3g
    @user-en8tt4uu3g 10 місяців тому +1

    Don't Sleep on FRANKENSTEIN Next please and more Emiya

  • @user-en8tt4uu3g
    @user-en8tt4uu3g 10 місяців тому +1

    Iskandar VS Ozymandias VS Achilles Who is the top strongest Rider?

  • @yandereneko5523
    @yandereneko5523 10 місяців тому +2

    Summer Servants ranked canonically?

  • @Acekilla99
    @Acekilla99 10 місяців тому

    okay but can we talk about how broken saber wouldve been if she had her true noble phantasm in these newer fates

  • @sergeantassassin3425
    @sergeantassassin3425 7 місяців тому

    Emiya was never going to win this fight for two reasons:
    1) Limited Kill Conditions: Requiring A-Rank or higher NP's to even SCRATCH Heracles means the weapons at Emiya's disposal are severely limited, even using Broken Phantasm/UBW-combo cheats. Most NP's are B-rank or lower, only the truly exceptional are A-Rank or higher. Start getting into EX-Rank, you start dealing with Divine Constructs more often than not, which Emiya theoretically CAN Trace, but the cost would be so absurdly high that he'd off himself doing so.
    I would argue that God Hand is far more insidious than we give it credit for: If Heracles receives enough damage to 'take' one of his lives, God Hand ensures that he cannot die from the same attack again. This is arguably for both weapon AND damage type. Question is, how far does it go? Obviously it doesn't make him immune to all sword attacks if he gets killed with a sword, but how about the same sword? Seems to not be the case, as Salter was able to kill him several times with Ex. Morgan, using several attacks, none of which were negated by God Hand. So that means that only Damage Type is affected. So Emiya can kill Herc by, say, cutting his head off, which is decapitation. After that, he'd become immune to death by decapitation. If Emiya then detonated a Broken Phantasm in his face, that would likely blow his head off...but is that decapitation, or death by brain destruction...maybe both? So would one be negated, but the other still go through, taking another life?
    Now you start to see the complications: mid-fight, you have to try and figure out different ways to kill someone who's nigh-invulnerable, and becomes even more so with every 'death' you inflict upon them. It becomes an increasingly uphill battle if you're trying to take out 12 lives individually, one after the other. The only way to counter this is to eradicate multiple lives with a single blow, like Gil using Enuma Elish, or Goetia using Ars Almadel Salomonis. Emiya, to my knowledge, does not have the ability to do so, the only possibility being UBW pulling a 'Gate of Babylon' and raining A-Rank NP's on him...which leads into our second reason.
    2) Limited Magical Energy: People in the comments have gone on and on about "Emiya's Output is X" or "Emiya's Supply is Y", completely forgetting that at the end of the day, he did NOT have enough magical energy to kill Herc 12 times over. Definitively not by himself, and it would only be possible if he was linked to someone who had infinite magical energy reserves, like Sakura. Bro could then fire with impunity, emptying the smithy until Herc was ground beef on the barren wasteland of UBW. Without someone who could provide him a large supply of magical energy, it's impossible for him to pull that kind of stuff off, even if he attempted to trade his Spirit Core for more power in a sacrificial move.
    Given the conditions of the fight, and given how disadvantaged Emiya was, there was simply no outcome where he could conceivably win. Period.

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 6 місяців тому

      You forgot the most important point that Emiya's Spirit Core was Damaged in that Fate Route Thanks To Artoria who attacked him earlier after her summon, Which is Also the reason he was heavily limited on what he can do both with Mana he has left in Damaged core and the limited body moment he can do with While maintaining himself

  • @justaweirdtree9645
    @justaweirdtree9645 2 дні тому

    Gonna be honest, Eye of Mind (True) is a little bit broken.

  • @Nahgato
    @Nahgato 10 місяців тому +3

    so herc is pretty much doomsday from dc..

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  10 місяців тому +2

      The goat blessed us with his presence? Yeah man I myself have always likened him to the hulk cause he got crazy feats like this too. But now that you mention it, him and doom do share some similarities. This Herc weakest form btw. Crazy right?

    • @TsiahIV
      @TsiahIV  10 місяців тому +1

      You gotta peep this video that im working on. It's gonna cover everything about Archer Herc and his master in Strange Fake. It will actually blow your top.

    • @Nahgato
      @Nahgato 10 місяців тому

      @@TsiahIV thats actually busted that this isnt even his strongest form.. dude already takes everything to kill.. and he even more op than that and an archer class at that.. wild.!

  • @pandoraspixel3367
    @pandoraspixel3367 10 місяців тому +1

    If only emiya had an actual legend to back him up, he would probably contend with the higher tiered servants in fate. 😅

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +3

      He actually does have a Legend But it wasnt Just as Big as others to be recognized as a Proper Heroic Spirit(and it took years after he got recognized as one) + He was summoned in wrong Timeframe in Staynight since his Legend doesnt exist yet thats why he was even more nerfed than usual

  • @rowletthejowlet6241
    @rowletthejowlet6241 8 місяців тому

    I am still in shock that Emiya only took 6 lives but Shirou's budget Excalibur took 7. (Though maybe I missed something since i only watched the anime)

    • @sweetserenity4145
      @sweetserenity4145 7 місяців тому +2

      Caliburn was buffed by artoria and It was fired inside Heracles body

  • @swampkami
    @swampkami 10 місяців тому

    And that is why we're all GAR for GARcher.

  • @ainzooalgown1426
    @ainzooalgown1426 10 місяців тому +2

    16 days of asking for TATARI

  • @kxng_kxng1639
    @kxng_kxng1639 10 місяців тому +1

    Next person is karna

  • @lmeobuh7009
    @lmeobuh7009 10 місяців тому

    that's something quite impressive for a guy who is one of the main characters but have 0 plot armor

  • @DYhalto250
    @DYhalto250 10 місяців тому +6

    Reason and how.. plot needed it to happen. Herc keeps getting the nerf bat for story sake.

    • @14megasxlr
      @14megasxlr 10 місяців тому +2

      Just because he got positive-diff’d doesn’t meant he got nerfed.

    • @Serascale
      @Serascale 10 місяців тому +4

      pff. Emiya got nerfed in every rout

    • @user-pm9ev3up5t
      @user-pm9ev3up5t 10 місяців тому +8

      Technically Speaking Emiya is the Most nerfed Servant here since he is a CG

  • @darkwing8632
    @darkwing8632 5 місяців тому

    Nah Heracles put some respect on his name

  • @Drahcoul
    @Drahcoul 10 місяців тому

    How strong is emiya truly

    • @desolatorstorm142
      @desolatorstorm142 10 місяців тому +1

      Going by interview matchups by Nasu. Stronger than Kojirou on anything but a fight that's purely CQB fight (so yes, you can scale him off of that), and able to stalemate/fight on par with Medusa or a full-powered Saber. Story wise is also implied to be able to beat Cu if he starts at range given that EMIYA literally blocks Cu's way home in HA, and he says earlier that he'd be willing to fight if someone challenges him.

    • @Drahcoul
      @Drahcoul 10 місяців тому

      @@desolatorstorm142 🙏🏾

  • @tjjordan4207
    @tjjordan4207 10 місяців тому

    I’m curious. Is Archer the same character in every Fate route? As in the Shirou Emiya who became a heroic spirit? Or are there multiple Archers in every route?
    My head canon is that because Archer is summoned into every universe by the Grail, he ends up losing his memories for a small amount of time and ends up considering the idea of killing Shirou in that universe. Except in Heaven’s Feel, where he sees a different version of himself who is willing to walk away from the dangerous path he set down on.

    • @jorienwachukwu466
      @jorienwachukwu466 9 місяців тому +4

      Yes, Archer is the same in every route. His memories are fragmented due to Rin's botched summoning, but he remembers enough to know that he wants to kill Shirou to try and erase himself. His goal is the same in each route, but circumstances differ, which affects what he does.
      In fate, Saber injures him, which prevents him from being able to enact his plan to kill Shirou since he spends most of it recovering, and possibly observing Shirou's relationship with Saber changes his mind, as he sees that the similarities between them may help Shirou abandon his path.
      In UBW, he is not injured due to Shirou unintentionally using a command seal on Saber, he goes on to try and kill Shirou, but Shirou's passion and determination to continue on his path regardless reminds Archer of why he went down that path to begin with.
      In HF, he is again injured, and upon seeing that Shirou is willing to abandon being a hero of justice to save Sakura, sacrifices himself to save Shirou's life and give him the tool he needs to save Sakura.

    • @tjjordan4207
      @tjjordan4207 9 місяців тому

      @@jorienwachukwu466 Now it makes more sense. Thank you for clarifying how it all works.