Lawyer Defies the Judge! | Law & Order

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2022
  • Law & Order is streaming now on Peacock: pck.tv/46lNAcm
    McCoy becomes in contempt of the court, causing a mis-trail.
    Season 10, Episode 7, Patsy, A man once accused of killing his girlfriend is now accused of assaulting the girlfriend's sister. However, he vehemently claims that he is the victim of a setup in both cases.
    Subscribe: / @lawandordernbc
    Show Synopsis: In the criminal justice system, the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups: the police who investigate crime and the district attorneys who prosecute the offenders. These are their stories. From Emmy-winning creator Dick Wolf, with its groundbreaking "ripped-from-the-headlines" format, comes the highly-acclaimed, longest-running crime series in television history.
    #LawAndOrder #PeacockTV
    Channel description:
    Welcome to the official UA-cam channel for Law & Order. Watch all of the official clips from the series, some of the best moments from within the criminal justice system, where the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups: The police, who investigate crime, and the district attorneys, who prosecute the offenders.
    Google Play & iTunes links
    About Peacock: The streaming service from NBCUniversal that’s as free as a bird. Current hits. Timeless classics. Timely updates. Stream Now With Peacock, stream current hits, hundreds of movies, thousands of episodes of TV shows, and exclusive Originals - plus timely news, live sports, WWE, and daily pop culture. Peacock’s got all your faves, including Parks & Rec, Yellowstone, Modern Family, and every episode of The Office.
    Get More Peacock:
    ► Follow Peacock on TikTok: / peacocktv
    ► Follow Peacock on Instagram: / peacocktv
    ► Like Peacock on Facebook: / peacocktv
    ► Follow Peacock on Twitter: / peacocktv
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 746

  • @SirStanleytheStumbler
    @SirStanleytheStumbler 9 місяців тому +595

    "You opened the door for this" yep and you allowed him to do it despite a valid arguement from the prosecutor.

    • @mitsukai7192
      @mitsukai7192 3 місяці тому +47

      You can see the realization on her face as soon as McCoy, during his closing, references the defense being allowed to submit facts not in evidence. Great acting.

  • @blackout2189
    @blackout2189 9 місяців тому +612

    Jack McCoy's "wanna see scorched Earth?" approach when he feels justice is being manipulated is worth everything.

    • @PotentiallyCriminal
      @PotentiallyCriminal 4 місяці тому

      "scorced Earth"....you mean violate the Constitutional Rights of the Defendant

    • @bwarhol
      @bwarhol 25 днів тому +5

      Given how often McCoy 'manipulates Justice,' I don't find it quite so adorable. The character is written with an all-too-realistic portrayal of 'I think I'm right, so nothing I do in the pursuit of a conviction can be wrong.'

    • @obliviouz
      @obliviouz 2 дні тому

      Hypocritical. McCoy has done similar things numerous times.

  • @Nickkkk838
    @Nickkkk838 Рік тому +1194

    It's nice to see that the judge had enough time to hear this case in between tracking down Carmen SanDiego across the world.

    • @Ualari
      @Ualari Рік тому +49

      Kids on the 90s know although she chased Carmen she mostly was at her desk asking questions of the lower ranking investigators: aka Gum Shoe Detective 😂😂😂

    • @Vyselink
      @Vyselink Рік тому +9

      Also nice to know that Luna took time out from singing with Bear to lay down the hammer!

    • @MrGabeanator
      @MrGabeanator Рік тому +1

      @@Vyselink yep

    • @Byrnzi360
      @Byrnzi360 Рік тому +22

      That defence lawyer isn’t even a real lawyer. He’s an actor working for Consumer Recreational Services. Proof: he’s been in half a dozen episodes of Law & Order, playing different roles every time.

    • @MrGabeanator
      @MrGabeanator Рік тому +3

      @@Byrnzi360 i know a couple actors like that

  • @Otaku155
    @Otaku155 Рік тому +667

    McCoy had no choice here; it is the duty of the Judge to see that the rules are followed, and part of that duty is upholding rulings she herself makes.

    • @coltsfan755
      @coltsfan755 Рік тому

      mccoy was wrong he had tunnel vision this case he wanted to convicted this man because he didn't like him

    • @Eros4tw
      @Eros4tw Рік тому

      If this happened in reality, McCoy would be at much more at risk for a censure and possible disbarment, than the judge. But litigating an appeal of a judges ruling after a trial is already over doesnt make for good TV...so instead they just had him purposefully ignore the Judges orders and cause a mistrial. Lets not talk about the tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of dollars wasted now due to this. Lets not talk about the jury that had to sit for probably a week+ listening to all the evidence for this to happen at the very end during closing arguments. Closing arguments are NOT evidence. Thats literally all McCoy had to say. Reasonable Doubt is ALL about alluding to something else that could have happened - and its the GOVERNMENTS job to introduce evidence proving other alternatives, didnt happen. The Defense is never under any obligation to produce any evidence ever. McCoy had no choice here? Naw - he had lots of real ethically viable choices. But those dont make good TV drama.

    • @slackerman9758
      @slackerman9758 5 місяців тому +8

      Thigpen was so good as the judge here. She always played a “let’s get this done” judge and often chose expedient rulings.

    • @PotentiallyCriminal
      @PotentiallyCriminal 4 місяці тому +4

      lol, nope.
      Only one side is entitled to a fair trial, and it's not the state.

    • @jeromemaida4933
      @jeromemaida4933 4 місяці тому

      ​@PotentiallyCriminal Loser

  • @joannakagy4095
    @joannakagy4095 8 місяців тому +250

    i love this scene because 1. jack looked almost apologetic to the judge before he gave his closing argument, and I think it's hilarious that he ignored the judge completely. 2. Abbie is watching him like: 👁👄👁 and nodding like it's the most inspirational thing she's ever heard.

    • @rcslyman8929
      @rcslyman8929 7 місяців тому +30

      That's because he wasn't apologetic. He stood there, in his closing, and practically said she was a disgrace to the bench.

    • @joes6527
      @joes6527 Місяць тому +4

      LOL, don't forget that Abbie and Jack were also sleeping together. Still, I do believe that her look of admiration was sincere.

  • @KitKatNisa
    @KitKatNisa Рік тому +696

    I love his face when he walks up to the judge. He almost looks like he wants to apologize for what he's about to do, since he knows the best chance they have to get justice is to have a mistrial declared, even if HE has to do it.

    • @FeedingFrenzy91
      @FeedingFrenzy91 Рік тому +11

      Spoiler alert. Was it justice though? I mean let's face it this more seemed to be Mr. McCoy not wanting to believe her sister killed her. Even when the stronger evidence comes in at the end he still seems reluctant.
      God bless you.

    • @stupidminotaur9735
      @stupidminotaur9735 Рік тому +4

      watching this episode i think the husband was innocent.

    • @nickelgaming786
      @nickelgaming786 Рік тому +5

      @@FeedingFrenzy91 Thank you for putting the Spoiler Alert at the beginning (I just watched this episode the other day so thankfully I already knew most but I haven't gotten to watch much of the other episodes.)

    • @FeedingFrenzy91
      @FeedingFrenzy91 Рік тому +4

      @@nickelgaming786 Your welcome.
      God bless you.

    • @billyboycinci
      @billyboycinci Рік тому +14

      Except they didn't get justice. They almost convicted an innocent man. At the very end of the episode, new evidence was discovered that heavily implied that she DID kill her sister and frame him.

  • @MarionGKeller
    @MarionGKeller 7 місяців тому +133

    "You opened the door for this."

    • @n3r0wolfe
      @n3r0wolfe 5 місяців тому +5

      judges fault for allowing it

    • @DrewSavo
      @DrewSavo Місяць тому

      He opened the door, she removed it from its frame so nobody could close it.

  • @thomastarwater2989
    @thomastarwater2989 Рік тому +209

    In memory of James Rebhorn (1948-2014), a top-notch character actor who had been diagnosed with melanoma in 1992 yet kept on trucking in movies and in television until he passed away, surrounded by his wife and family. Great thespians like him come along just once in a while.

    • @Sheikah_Mage25
      @Sheikah_Mage25 Рік тому +8

      Rip James !! He was a great actor

    • @poncho4777
      @poncho4777 9 місяців тому +3

      Bill Arnott! (Head of state was a great movie in my childhood and that’s how I’ll always remember him) lol

    • @clay3205
      @clay3205 9 місяців тому +4

      The best weasel of a Defense Secretary

    • @hotlavatube
      @hotlavatube 9 місяців тому +11

      Also, Lynne Thigpen, the judge, died in 2003 of cerebral hemorrhage. She might be best remembered as the Chief in the Carmen Sandiego TV gameshow.

    • @ellencarter2668
      @ellencarter2668 7 місяців тому +5

      ​@hotlavatube oh no! Always wondered why she stopped acting. She was the judge on many law and order episodes and she always made every scene, no matter how brief, count.

  • @bigbraz
    @bigbraz Рік тому +463

    I'm not a lawyer, but that's a hell of a tactical move. McCoy is right, the defense insinuated and wanted to 'provide' that information to the jury. The judge is correct, the defense opened the door and she had to declare it a mistrial. Great scene.

    • @IoEstasCedonta
      @IoEstasCedonta Рік тому +13

      But with prosecutorial misconduct, wouldn't it be a mistrial with prejudice?

    • @bigbraz
      @bigbraz Рік тому +5

      @@IoEstasCedonta sorry, I missed that season of law and order. That's where my curriculum comes from. 👍🏾

    • @Captain-Cosmo
      @Captain-Cosmo Рік тому +79

      Yes, the defense acted inappropriately. But the judge controls which doors are opened and which are not. McCoy objected and she allowed it. McCoy objected again and she allowed it again. All McCoy did was put the judge's own standard "on trial". The mistrial was merely collateral.

    • @IoEstasCedonta
      @IoEstasCedonta Рік тому +10

      @@bigbraz I am SO not a lawyer... but honestly, I don't think any real judge would have let it get this far.

    • @Captain-Cosmo
      @Captain-Cosmo Рік тому +9

      @@IoEstasCedonta You might be surprised!

  • @NonSenseMcGee
    @NonSenseMcGee Рік тому +353

    Brilliant. McCoy just drove through the door that the defense opened. Typical L&O...dont even need to see the previous 40 minutes to immediately understand the stakes and the drama. Brilliant!

    • @BigSlimyBlob
      @BigSlimyBlob Рік тому +35

      Well... the defense knocked on a locked door, the judge unlocked the door for the defense, and then the defense opened it.
      McCoy had no choice left but to crash a monster truck through it.

    • @FrankWolenczak
      @FrankWolenczak Рік тому +27

      @@BigSlimyBlob A Monster truck? Please! He lead the Navy's 5th fleet through that door and when he got done wiht it, that "Door" was more stretched than mozzarella or string cheese could ever be!

    • @Princess_DYS
      @Princess_DYS Рік тому +15

      This comment thread has me ROTFL! 😂 You all are amazing.

    • @HoldenNY22
      @HoldenNY22 Рік тому +5

      I remember this episode. It ends up looking like the Defense Lawyer and the Defendent was Right that the Sister did kil her Sister to frame the Defendent, but it is not completely resolved.

    • @robertmittoniii5427
      @robertmittoniii5427 8 місяців тому +1

      No. The defense followed the law and the prosecutor committed a serious crime.

  • @SiriusMined
    @SiriusMined Рік тому +125

    One of the best scenes in the entire series run. McCoy had to challenge the judge, who was sandbagging his case, and not following their own rulings. He took a hit, but he prevented a miscarriage of justice.

    • @patrickdostie28
      @patrickdostie28 9 місяців тому +6

      Actually it was proven when new evidence was found that she did murder her own sister

    • @BlackBinderGames
      @BlackBinderGames 9 місяців тому +1

      "Prevented" The dude was innocent.

    • @jessodum3103
      @jessodum3103 9 місяців тому +3

      I've watched a lot of L&O, but the time McCoy forced a mistrial always stands out in my memory.

    • @SiriusMined
      @SiriusMined 9 місяців тому +1

      @jessodum3103 yes! That was a great moment. What episode was that?

    • @robertmittoniii5427
      @robertmittoniii5427 8 місяців тому

      Bullsh*t. He was committing prosecutorial harassment. He should have been disbarred

  • @beng4151
    @beng4151 9 місяців тому +27

    Sam Waterston IS Jack McCoy. He gives off that frustrated, crusty old lawyer vibe where he shakes his fist at the clouds. He is brilliant, and one of my favorite characters of all time.

  • @omartorrio1512
    @omartorrio1512 Рік тому +434

    Jack McCoy is a prosecutorial badass and barrister extraordinaire. Sam Waterston played the part of Jack McCoy brilliantly. He gave me (and continues to give me) many hours of intense television viewing.

    • @shalashaska9946
      @shalashaska9946 Рік тому +20

      He is very entertaining to watch but McCoy is honestly a horrible person. The more I watch I feel like he's the bad guy a lot of the time. He shoves the law in people's faces but never hesitates to break a rule when it suits him. He treats the law like a kid with a gun.

    • @sws212
      @sws212 10 місяців тому +12

      @@shalashaska9946 Uhh he's a prosecutor on Law and Order... Shoving the law in people's face is kinda the whole point. Show's not called Tea & Discussion.

    • @shalashaska9946
      @shalashaska9946 10 місяців тому +5

      @@sws212 The better way to say it is he only strictly observes the law when it's in his favor. But he always ignores it when he wants to.

    • @im_flat
      @im_flat 10 місяців тому +3

      @@shalashaska9946 if you think that's not an accurate portrayal of the average prosecutor you're kidding yourself lol

    • @kod5660
      @kod5660 9 місяців тому +1

      @@shalashaska9946 How do you think the law is applied in the real world especially the USA.

  • @lisbetterthanlight2112
    @lisbetterthanlight2112 Рік тому +97

    I love Carmichael's reactions to Jack's antics.... Intrigued and maybe a bit proud

    • @Tulane_Gargoyle
      @Tulane_Gargoyle Рік тому +15

      I was thinking the exact same thing. She should have brought popcorn.

    • @curragh4635
      @curragh4635 Рік тому +4

      She's awesome!

  • @jacobbrabo63
    @jacobbrabo63 Рік тому +165

    I guess stopping Carmen Sandiego’s crimes wasn’t good enough for the chief. Convicting her and others of them is what brought her joy. RIP Lynne Thigpen. You’re so dearly missed.

    • @stephendavis6267
      @stephendavis6267 Рік тому +12

      If only we could've seen McCoy prosecute Carmen Sandiego for her heinous crimes.

    • @Crossingman18
      @Crossingman18 Рік тому +7

      I thought she sounded familiar. I used to LOVE watching that show. So she went from being a chief to a judge.

    • @chrismartucci3005
      @chrismartucci3005 Рік тому +3

      @@Crossingman18 Then became the moon.

    • @amitkenan3878
      @amitkenan3878 4 місяці тому

      She always enjoyed catching criminals, even in her youth when she helped criminals catch other criminals

  • @mikeg8375
    @mikeg8375 Рік тому +72

    The defense attorney Charles Garnett is played by actor James Rebhorn. He portrayed several characters in the Law & Order franchise in guest roles. He was a terrific actor. RIP.

    • @hotohori69
      @hotohori69 9 місяців тому +1

      But he played the same character in everything he did... He was the smarmy a-hole that either participated in something shady or was withholding something shady. He was the guy in independence day that didn't tell the president aliens existed, he was jackass head of the school who got his car vandalized in Scent of a Woman but wanted to throw out charlie... You needed someone for the audience to hate call this guy.... That's pretty awesome actually and provided pretty decent job security.

    • @mikeg8375
      @mikeg8375 9 місяців тому

      @hotohori69 He was a character actor. Even the roles he played outside of law and order were often similar. He made a nice living for himself though. He fought cancer for years and wrote his own obituary before he died.

    • @jeffreysnydr
      @jeffreysnydr 8 місяців тому +2

      Don't forget he was the dad in Blank Check and the secretary of defense in Independence Day

  • @Citadel97501
    @Citadel97501 Рік тому +229

    Frankly, the judge should have been heavily punished and removed from the bench. At no time during a trial may you allude to facts not in evidence, especially after rulings preventing their entrance have been made.

    • @craithteemeghan5311
      @craithteemeghan5311 Рік тому +16

      There is a big difference between what how trials are supposed to operate and what they do in practice!

    • @Eros4tw
      @Eros4tw Рік тому +14

      Closing and Opening arguments are just that...argument. They are not real evidence. Attorneys "allude" to things all the time - and the judges will instruct the juries that closing and opening arguments are NOT evidence, and nothing said in them should be considered as much. Opening arguments are all about alluding to things that MIGHT come up in the trial. But, just because the attorney alludes to something that might come into evidence, but is never introduced - does not mean it was improper to do so. Suggesting that this judge should be removed because she didnt strike from the record a statement made in closing arguments tells me you know very little about how the law, and how our legal system, really work.

    • @jaimeduncan6167
      @jaimeduncan6167 Рік тому +7

      you have no idea how reality works. And judges do far worse than this all the time. And she instructed the defense attorney to stop doing it, but decided not to strike it down from the record. From my perspective, she did show a lack of authority by not ordering the prosecutor to be escorted out of the hall and placed under arrest.

    • @Grahamster00
      @Grahamster00 Рік тому +4

      This is a fictional television show. The judge is not a real judge. They will face no punishment because they are not a real person. These are not real people.

    • @chrissanto
      @chrissanto Рік тому

      For fucks sake, it's a TV show. That is not how it works in the real world.

  • @Dan-nt2yb
    @Dan-nt2yb 4 місяці тому +5

    These brief courtroom scenes are better than most movies out there. Sam is amazing.⭐️

  • @ponygon777
    @ponygon777 Рік тому +180

    McCoy has guts going against the Chief's orders.

    • @mashukyreilight
      @mashukyreilight Рік тому +10

      Yes
      yes he does

    • @Zaiaku666
      @Zaiaku666 Рік тому +9

      I'm so use to seeing Lynn in that afro that her hair cut short threw me off. Until she talked. Man, did Lynn Thigpin have an iconic voice.

    • @generatorx
      @generatorx Рік тому +2

      @@Zaiaku666 That's right; Thigpen was the DJ on the movie......The Warriors.

    • @bluehealer81
      @bluehealer81 Рік тому +1

      @@generatorx Nowhere to run to baby.... got nowhere to hide...

    • @excrono
      @excrono 10 місяців тому +2

      It’s like the judge was at Carmen Sandiego’ trial, and she wanted to get her off to keep her side gig against all common sense and legal precedent.

  • @xplayfan21
    @xplayfan21 Рік тому +141

    RIP to the actors who played the judge and the defense attorney both great legends

    • @gipsydanger5020
      @gipsydanger5020 Рік тому +16

      Is the judge the host from that Children's geography show Where In The World Is Carmen Sandiego? Voice sounds so familiar

    • @xplayfan21
      @xplayfan21 Рік тому +4

      @@gipsydanger5020 yes

    • @ADJackD
      @ADJackD Рік тому +8

      @@gipsydanger5020 and the radio host from The Warriors

    • @mikeg8375
      @mikeg8375 Рік тому +9

      The actor who played the defense attorney is James Rebhorn. He was in a lot of different roles in his career. He played several different characters in the law and order franchise in guest roles. When he passed away a few years back, he wrote his own obituary ahead of time.

    • @nyosito
      @nyosito 5 місяців тому +1

      And Godspell😊

  • @tompinkerton8099
    @tompinkerton8099 Рік тому +562

    I do not recall the full episode, but I am assuming McCoy did this on purpose to get the mistrial since he couldn't get the judge to do the right thing any other way.

    • @rhaspodel
      @rhaspodel Рік тому +41

      It was a season ten episode called "Patsy"; I believed it was about the death of woman, the defendant had a relationship with her and her sister; the sister probably grew jealous either purposely hurt herself to frame the defendant and push the detectives to suspect the defendant killed the woman and tried to kill her sister.

    • @noblelies
      @noblelies Рік тому +58

      Yup, and he knew that was the last card he had, because anyone knows that prosecutors enjoy extensive protection through qualified immunity. As such, McCoy knew that even if the judge held him in contempt, he would face no jail time. The worst the judge could do would be to declare a mistrial and request that the DA's office reassign the case.

    • @The-Rose-and-the-Cross
      @The-Rose-and-the-Cross Рік тому

      The irony here is... (spoilers)
      ... That the police ends up finding evidence suggesting that, maybe, the comatose lady did kill her sister (they analyse her car and find traces of the murdered sister having been in the trunk). After being told this, McCoy replies in the lines of 'Well, we'll have to ask her about it when she wakes up'.

    • @biruss
      @biruss Рік тому +25

      A deliberate mistrial causing on the state's part triggers double Jeopardy

    • @Princess_DYS
      @Princess_DYS Рік тому +38

      @@biruss Except that no one other than the viewers, the DA, and Jack himself knew it was deliberate.

  • @JamesSmith-rh4is
    @JamesSmith-rh4is Рік тому +128

    Can you imagine a prosecutor who has been held in contempt more than 80 times and still keeping his job in real life?

    • @Potterholic1
      @Potterholic1 Рік тому +24

      And can you imagine that prosecutor getting elected District Attorney?

    • @BillinHungary
      @BillinHungary 9 місяців тому +8

      The lack of repercussions after an episode, is called the "Magic Reset Button'

    • @shahidulkhan9566
      @shahidulkhan9566 9 місяців тому +16

      Defence attorneys and DA constantly get held for contempt. Sometimes its tactics to show judge is biased or just to delay proceedings.

    • @Iamkcs2c
      @Iamkcs2c 8 місяців тому

      "Fighting Joe" Morrissey here in Richmond VA has gotten in fist fights with opposing counsel, both as a prosecutor and later as a defense attorney, put his contractor into the hospital (literally drove him to the ER while saying "keep your mouth shut about this") tried to hide a few million days before he had to pay in the civil suit, had three kids with a 17 yo who worked in his office, may have tried to fabricate text messages to hide the affair ... now he's a state senator xd.

    • @williamzame3708
      @williamzame3708 8 місяців тому +2

      @@Potterholic1 McCoy is not the elected District Attorney.

  • @TheWingsoffury
    @TheWingsoffury 9 місяців тому +5

    I love how that judge let this nonsense happen than blame the defendant's lawyer by saying you opened the door, even though the judge let the door be opened.

  • @kathyduby8150
    @kathyduby8150 Рік тому +26

    WHOA. That's a show-stopper. What guts. Brilliant writing.

  • @Eazy-ERyder
    @Eazy-ERyder Рік тому +36

    That's why Jack is STILL the DA in the world of Law & Order! Almost 30 years later

  • @cprophetu
    @cprophetu 10 місяців тому +12

    My man was like a child about to lose at a board game… Flip the whole table over, nobody wins! Lol! I love it. Got tired of the unfair treatment and said forget it.

    • @blackdandelion5549
      @blackdandelion5549 8 місяців тому +6

      "He's breaking the rules!!!"
      Judge : "I'm not going to do anything about it"
      McCoy: "Frick it, I'll break the game!!!"

  • @AndyChilton234
    @AndyChilton234 Рік тому +50

    Jack was good. Got results when he's at his best that's why i like watching them again and again when there on. As he does amazing job

  • @kaypoots9709
    @kaypoots9709 9 місяців тому +10

    Sam Waterston as Jack McCoy is undoubtedly a top five performance in the history of television.

    • @omartorrio1512
      @omartorrio1512 8 місяців тому

      I agree. Sam Waterston is a brilliant actor and portrayed Jack McCoy with excellence.

  • @Jager1967
    @Jager1967 Рік тому +76

    Lynn Thighpen was such a wonderful yet underrated actress who was taken from this world far too soon.

    • @Aaron-io8vw
      @Aaron-io8vw Рік тому +9

      The chief

    • @shivadance1979
      @shivadance1979 Рік тому +7

      She was also in The Warriors as the radio DJ. Such a small part but so memorable.

    • @thomasbrown3356
      @thomasbrown3356 Рік тому +4

      @@shivadance1979 "Looks like we had a case of mistaken identity. Sorry bout that. Guess all we can do is play you a song."

    • @andra2377
      @andra2377 Рік тому +1

      She is always going to be Nell's sister on Gimme a Break!

    • @fromthehaven94
      @fromthehaven94 Рік тому +2

      Also to James Rebhorn, who played the prosecutor in the Seinfeld finale, among many other roles.

  • @MultiMagnis
    @MultiMagnis Рік тому +19

    that was some two fold arguing there. not only did he push the mistrial forward. he also put the judge in a bind because its on record that the judge allowed the def to bring in non evidence info with no instructions to the jury to disregard that info but also he put the judge on the hook for allowing such info and bypassing her own rules of the court. he might go to contept holding but she will have to explain why he is in holding. lets just say they wont see each other in court again anytime soon

    • @UltimaKeyMaster
      @UltimaKeyMaster Місяць тому

      I feel like her letting McCoy ramble on and on was deliberately invoking her own atonement for her actions. She knew she fucked up and let him have his moment before putting on a stern facade to "hold him in contempt" which does nothing bad for him cause he looks like a hero regardless.
      She let him finish his rant to an acceptable degree before going "alright before people think I'm losing control of this, you can actually stop now."

  • @beng4151
    @beng4151 9 місяців тому +4

    I remember when the cast of Law and Order was on Jeopardy. Yes, the questions are easier, but they crushed it. They were all very sharp. I would assume they learned a lot from the show!

  • @Evan_Almighty2049
    @Evan_Almighty2049 Рік тому +22

    There’s a reason why they call him “Hang ‘Em High McCoy”. I wouldn’t want to face him in a courtroom showdown. And I CERTAINLY wouldn’t try to play games with him. He has the Law, Justice and Conviction on his side. He'll go the distance to bring Justice. Not a smart move by opposing counsel to try to sneak in what has already been disallowed. I knew Jack would force the mistrial as soon as facts not in evidence were snuck in.

    • @greenmonsterprod
      @greenmonsterprod 9 місяців тому

      On the other hand, McCoy frequently twisted the law to suit his purposes. And when he blackmailed a defense witness into leaving the country, then conspired with the judge to ensure a guilty verdict, he outright broke the law. How did he keep his job, let alone get voted in as D.A,?

  • @madunwagbo4769
    @madunwagbo4769 9 місяців тому +5

    R.I.P. Lynne Thigpen and James Rebhorn

  • @stephenhenley7452
    @stephenhenley7452 10 місяців тому +8

    Doing the wrong thing for the right reasons. Judge: "You opened the door for this." Like hell he did. The Judge was incompetent and should have stopped the defense attorney's shenanigans LONG before it got this far and she didn't...so McCoy gave her no choice.

  • @thewkovacs316
    @thewkovacs316 Рік тому +45

    immediately after this trial, the judge quit the law and went searching for carmen sandiego

    • @MrGabeanator
      @MrGabeanator Рік тому +4

      that or sang a song with a friendly bear

    • @thewkovacs316
      @thewkovacs316 Рік тому +3

      @@MrGabeanator i am so sure that had she not passed away so young, that she wouldve gotten the role in both animated jl and live action as amanda waller

    • @kingleech16
      @kingleech16 10 місяців тому +1

      @@thewkovacs316 She would've been great in the animated ones, not sure ANY actor/actress could save the live action films.

    • @thewkovacs316
      @thewkovacs316 10 місяців тому +1

      @@kingleech16 you are right....but she still wouldve been great as amanda waller

    • @kingleech16
      @kingleech16 10 місяців тому

      @@thewkovacs316 Fair.

  • @jarekbradshaw8543
    @jarekbradshaw8543 4 місяці тому +4

    Jack Mccoy was definitely standing on business by defying the judge

  • @FumetsuGolf
    @FumetsuGolf 9 місяців тому +14

    RIP Lynne Thigpen. We miss you, Chief.

  • @YTEdy
    @YTEdy 9 місяців тому +7

    I can't imagine any other actor playing Jack McCoy. He made Law and Order the entertaining show it was.

  • @bigpoppa1234
    @bigpoppa1234 Рік тому +11

    me in the jury: thank god I can go home

  • @yinwolf5976
    @yinwolf5976 9 місяців тому +3

    you opend the door for this, "yeah and you held it open your honor"

  • @adrianchannelle8651
    @adrianchannelle8651 9 місяців тому +3

    Lynn Thigpen was such a great actress. RIP.

  • @Lady_boom_bitch
    @Lady_boom_bitch Рік тому +76

    Lol I love Mccoy did that on purpose and the judge knew Mccoy was right and did Garnet just say yo near the end 😂😂

  • @philswaim392
    @philswaim392 Рік тому +5

    Quite honestly a stunt like this gets an attourney especially a prosecutor recommended to the bar for sanctions and probably gets removed from the DAs office.

  • @Jennifer_Elliott
    @Jennifer_Elliott 4 місяці тому +4

    Jack McCoy is legend.

  • @danm6695
    @danm6695 8 місяців тому +3

    One of the best Jack McCoy moments ever….even though he was probably wrong.

  • @rileysfreeman
    @rileysfreeman Рік тому +7

    Jack McCoy has always been my favourite tv lawyer. Svu should have had him too not just the main law and order.

  • @FishFreddy
    @FishFreddy Рік тому +8

    I absolutely love the actress who is the judge. She is brilliant in The District.

  • @baconstreetfilms6216
    @baconstreetfilms6216 5 місяців тому +2

    The wonderfully talented Lynne Thigpen! RIP.

  • @compscilaw
    @compscilaw Рік тому +5

    It should've been a mistrial when the defense argued about things that weren't in evidence. McCoy saw to it that it was a mistrial.

  • @hokie7373
    @hokie7373 Рік тому +12

    The judge is in contempt

  • @kimberlyhelm8556
    @kimberlyhelm8556 5 місяців тому +1

    ❤this is one of my favorite shows. The lawyer for the defense is played by my cousin James Reborn. May he RIP. He was in Independence Day my Cousin Vinny. I never had the pleasure of meeting him sadly.

  • @Brandon-qr2or
    @Brandon-qr2or Рік тому +10

    Lynne Thigpen had a voice of gold.

    • @TractorBoy521
      @TractorBoy521 Рік тому +1

      Forreal! Hard to hate her here when you hear the smooth tone

  • @wokndedfan413
    @wokndedfan413 2 місяці тому

    I remember the judge in The Warriors movie as The DJ. “ this go to all the big boppers out there.” 😂

  • @ldj7039
    @ldj7039 9 місяців тому +2

    Lynne Thigpen, who played the judge, also was the voice of Luna from "Bear in the Big Blue House."

  • @glenbateman5960
    @glenbateman5960 Рік тому +6

    Mr. Garnett didn't open the door.
    The judge did.

    • @jeffreysnydr
      @jeffreysnydr Рік тому

      And let me guess what was behind that door...rockapella?

  • @YolandaAnneBrown95726
    @YolandaAnneBrown95726 Рік тому +4

    Yet another episode of Law and Order that Peacock doesn't air. Thanks.

  • @poncho4777
    @poncho4777 9 місяців тому +1

    James Rebhorn (Bill Arnott) and Lynne Thigpen: absolute legends in the game.

  • @harleminthebuildn9234
    @harleminthebuildn9234 Рік тому +2

    THIS WAS A GOOD EPISODE. LOTS OF TWISTS AND TURNS

  • @DarrenMoore-le6pg
    @DarrenMoore-le6pg 2 місяці тому

    RIP Lynne Thigpen (December 22, 1948-March 12,2003) You were a phenomenal actress.

  • @ianking2409
    @ianking2409 9 місяців тому +1

    This was the first Law & Order episode I ever watched.

  • @Alienmojo
    @Alienmojo Рік тому +6

    How I love and adore this show.

  • @pamelawalker3085
    @pamelawalker3085 Рік тому +14

    RIP ❤❤❤🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
    ❤Lynne Thigpen!❤

  • @tcgrhetoric
    @tcgrhetoric 4 місяці тому +2

    But your honor, where in the world is Carmen Sandiego?

  • @TheFoolishNutter
    @TheFoolishNutter 3 місяці тому

    I actually burst out laughing like I was watching a comedy when she said "You opened the door for this" and I'm not sure if that was the show's intention.

  • @americansmark
    @americansmark 5 місяців тому +4

    In a real court, McCoy would be facing the bar for that outburst.

    • @richardruff8712
      @richardruff8712 3 місяці тому

      Yes, agreed.... A hell of a journey for Sam Waterston... From Capricorn 1 astronaut to 400 odd episodes of Law & Order... But, yes, I think he should have been held in ' contempt of Court ' for his outburst against the Judge....

    • @Brooklyngangsta999
      @Brooklyngangsta999 3 місяці тому +1

      Contempt of court fa sure.

  • @soupafi
    @soupafi 4 місяці тому +1

    2:32 that is a look of "don't you dare do what I think you're going to do"

  • @jimschardinger7342
    @jimschardinger7342 4 місяці тому +2

    Jack is the reason why I watch these episodes.

    • @ChadDutton
      @ChadDutton 4 місяці тому +1

      Sam Waterston is the GOAT

  • @davidhutchinson5233
    @davidhutchinson5233 10 місяців тому +2

    This episode had so many twists and turns.

  • @Luc_95
    @Luc_95 Рік тому +7

    One of the smartest moves McCoy ever made lol

    • @coltsfan755
      @coltsfan755 Рік тому +1

      jack was totally wrong in the case he didn't care about the truth

    • @vincentfichtler7758
      @vincentfichtler7758 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@coltsfan755 clearly you haven't seen the whole episode.

  • @gabrielmichaelspiritwolf3795
    @gabrielmichaelspiritwolf3795 Рік тому +1

    Love this law and order show

  • @ratedwrong
    @ratedwrong 8 місяців тому +3

    What's kind of hilarious about this whole scene, is all the righteous indignation of McCoy and the admiration in the eyes of his latest ADA as she gazes at him. All for naught, because the defense was right. The lady in the coma was a crazy stalker and she framed the guy. Whoopsie!

    • @Dave_Langer
      @Dave_Langer 5 місяців тому +1

      doesnt matter, you still need to follow the rules

    • @ratedwrong
      @ratedwrong 5 місяців тому

      If you're a big rule follower you probably wouldn't love the tactics of Jack McCoy, lol. (not that he isn't the best part of the show)@@Dave_Langer

    • @brettzforeman
      @brettzforeman 4 місяці тому

      This is not proven. There emerges a single piece of evidence that suggests it's possible. It's helpful for a defense trying to establish reasonable doubt, but it hardly proves they were right.

    • @ratedwrong
      @ratedwrong 4 місяці тому

      This isn't an actual court case. It isn't "evidence" it's a plot twist. It was introduced into the story the way it was when it was because it is what actually happened.@@brettzforeman

  • @ldj7039
    @ldj7039 10 місяців тому +1

    "Yo, Your Honor?? Wtf?"
    Lmao

  • @xxPARAMOREFANMANxx
    @xxPARAMOREFANMANxx 9 місяців тому +1

    McCoy has to be the spiciest lawyer on tv 😂😂😂

  • @tatkkyo9911
    @tatkkyo9911 9 місяців тому +3

    Fun thing is irl she would have a hard time getting sanctions on him because of the way things happened

  • @brajeshsingh2391
    @brajeshsingh2391 6 місяців тому

    always loved the show. A good courtroom drama is always appealing.

  • @stevescabin5441
    @stevescabin5441 Рік тому +16

    The last line in this episode from Abby was great - They found the victim's hair in her sister's car! .. Jack says - she was her sister - I am sure she was in that car a bunch of times .... Abby: "In her trunk????"

    • @WillCamx
      @WillCamx Рік тому +9

      Her hair could have gotten into the trunk when she was getting something out of it. Or it could have been on something that was put in the trunk. It's hardly damning evidence.

    • @darkarima
      @darkarima Рік тому +6

      @@WillCamx I've found hair on my clothing that was obviously from someone else who I hadn't embraced, touched, or anything - by indirect transfer. Unless there's more to it (blood, torn out in a clump, etc)... in this situation it's barely even circumstantial, let alone a smoking gun.

    • @palaceofwisdom9448
      @palaceofwisdom9448 Рік тому +7

      My sister once baked a cake, and some of her hair got in it. I can say based on its size that she was never in that cake. 😂

    • @julesmasseffectmusic
      @julesmasseffectmusic Рік тому +2

      I visited a mate, he got us both a beer immediately 30 minutes later he opened the fridge and found one of my 70cm hairs in this freshly made jelly. 30 minutes, I hadn't entered the kitchen.

    • @FeedingFrenzy91
      @FeedingFrenzy91 Рік тому

      @@WillCamx If I recall though the sister got rid of the car (correct me if I'm wrong). Why would she do that?
      God bless you.

  • @PatrolOfficer161
    @PatrolOfficer161 Рік тому +1

    Guess I'm going to have to watch the series from the beginning again!

  • @detmstr341
    @detmstr341 Рік тому +5

    Wow, that Jack McCoy doesn't roll over for anyone.

  • @Tony-pk6ql
    @Tony-pk6ql 11 місяців тому +3

    This is why lawyers are the most disreputable professionals alive.

  • @briantaulbee5744
    @briantaulbee5744 10 місяців тому +1

    Abby at 3:24, admiring Jack's brazen move here. I love it.

  • @mikenichols3965
    @mikenichols3965 Рік тому +2

    James Rebhorn and Lynne Thigpen. Awesome.

  • @faye2363
    @faye2363 Рік тому +5

    Best fictional District Attorney ever

  • @avidcarsons6412
    @avidcarsons6412 Рік тому +1

    great tv.. i love it

  • @jamesdrynan
    @jamesdrynan Рік тому +15

    Always produced cogent, articulate cases throughout its run. Waterson was excellent. I also liked Michael Moriarty as Ben Stone in the first four seasons.

    • @JuricksEnterprise
      @JuricksEnterprise 5 місяців тому

      I could never watch Moriarty for too long, he came across too whiney and small to me.

  • @JedEmpleo
    @JedEmpleo Рік тому +4

    I'm just here to read "don't diss the Chief" comments haha

  • @FortunateJuice
    @FortunateJuice Рік тому +2

    "GOD DAMM YOU, JYNX."
    -Defense Attorney actor in Meet The Parents

  • @leonsmith853
    @leonsmith853 Рік тому +13

    The Great Jack mocoy at his very best

    • @biruss
      @biruss Рік тому

      Sadly double Jeopardy applies

    • @Princess_DYS
      @Princess_DYS Рік тому +1

      @@biruss Please see my responses to your other two replies. Again you are correct but only if they can prove it was deliberate as stated/implied at the very end of this episode.

    • @biruss
      @biruss Рік тому +1

      @@Princess_DYS sorry i didn't see them. Great point!

  • @tacoma50
    @tacoma50 8 місяців тому +2

    Here’s a tidbit for fans, the judge in this episode was the woman in the movie “Warriors “ and all you saw of her was her lips speaking into a microphone!

  • @jessragan6714
    @jessragan6714 Рік тому +11

    Hey! Don't talk to the Chief like that! She'll send her gumshoes after you! If they can catch Carmen Sandiego, you don't have a prayer!

  • @The-Rose-and-the-Cross
    @The-Rose-and-the-Cross Рік тому +7

    Oh yeah. For me, the most memorable scene from the original L&O.

  • @Jiltedin2007
    @Jiltedin2007 9 місяців тому +1

    Never mess with Jack McCoy in Court!

  • @N1k4_Gr1v
    @N1k4_Gr1v Рік тому +1

    I just cant look away from drama

  • @fayeslover
    @fayeslover 11 місяців тому +1

    RIP James Rebhorn and Lynne Thigpen

  • @akramhamzakangave9292
    @akramhamzakangave9292 Рік тому +1

    How can you not Love this show???

  • @seanwebb605
    @seanwebb605 Рік тому +1

    Very cool.

  • @jonathandaniel7424
    @jonathandaniel7424 11 місяців тому +9

    That judge has been trouble since the days she was harassing Mr. Clark in "Lean On Me."

  • @johnwest194
    @johnwest194 Рік тому +121

    imagine a lawyer with balls who cares about justice - am i dreaming?

    • @yvonnetomenga5726
      @yvonnetomenga5726 Рік тому

      @john west • No you're not dreaming. But the media (and before that, word-of-mouth gossip) couldn't possibly cover 10,000 attorneys, judges, police, etc. doing the right thing. The media does have time to cover the one or two or three of the most salacious and egregious wrong doers.
      Since you're only hearing about the wrong doers and never about the right doers*, your perception (aka "gut" feeling) will be skewed against the facts.
      *Well, maybe if you watch once yearly local awards dinners, you'll get a different view but it's unlikely to overcome your daily diet of "injustice" reporting.

    • @Princess_DYS
      @Princess_DYS Рік тому +9

      Nah, that's just good old Jack McCoy.

    • @yucol5661
      @yucol5661 Рік тому +11

      It’s law an order. Good cops and good lawyers dealing with the most dramatic crimes (even if they break the law in the process) is their whole show.

    • @DrProfScience1
      @DrProfScience1 Рік тому

      Yes, this a fantasy and a lawyer would never put their career in jeopardy to defend any client against a corrupt judge's wishes. The entire system is mired with sociopathic cunts.

    • @soupafi
      @soupafi Рік тому +2

      @@Princess_DYS He doesn't care about justice in the new L&O. he wants wins

  • @mikesilva3868
    @mikesilva3868 Рік тому +1

    Interesting 😊

  • @notallowed337
    @notallowed337 Рік тому +4

    Greatest TV attorney of all time

  • @thomaschitham3487
    @thomaschitham3487 Місяць тому

    "You opened the door for this."
    Yeah, and you didn't close it.