80% of our common people won't understand your speech sir, ....but if little dramatic then many will clap and enjoy , this is the truth of today's debate on News channel.
Great speaker, why BJP Flag is being displayed in the Bankground screen, Is it a BJP sponsored program. Rahul thinks he is more Intelectual than Mehta. Rahul is putting up an argument for the sake of argument.
This needs to be viewed by every youngster . There is a need for people to understand the meaning of democracy. instead of labeling people who ask questions as anti national, there is a need to stress on the imp of debate. Hats off Mr.Mehta
But he asked the right questions and the loud talker was stumped completely...he just went on mincing his words and going back on what he was tirading about... at every question... good job somewhat by Rahul Kanwal
Yeah that’s why poorest people are getting electricity, clean drinking water, food, inflation is low. The poorest of India vote for Modi, they don’t care about hindutvathey care about modis socialist policies which are making their lives better
We should be happy that the few are Indians. Else, some chinese or american companies woukd be owning them Look at the state of Africa. They have highest natural resources but owned by outsiders. They plundering it and Africa remains poor
Not a single figure of fact but abstract jingoistic statement for sake of it. How different was it when Hindustan motor and Premier Automobile and Bajaj auto ensure black market in automobile industry Many other such examples So many ordinary tecnology entrepreneurs have emerged creating value for themselves and nation But the leftist mindset of people like Mehta creates nothing but nuisance Why can't he rather incubate a new breed of such entrepreneurs in his University wherever he was or would go But that does not earn him global accolades of intelllectualism Mehta is a plain hypocrite
Pratap Banu Mehta is an erudite, intellectual of the highest calibre and a man of impeccable standards. I am an avid reader of his writings in the Opinion column of Indian Express where he sculpts his thoughts and ideas in the most objective, ideated and unprejudiced manner and I envy his articulative abilities. However, the discomfiting truth is that such intellectuals cannot make a connect with ordinary masses who lack sufficient wisdom and knowledge to appreciate such nuanced dissection of issues said in the context of exalted democratic ideals, liberty, equality and fraternity.
@ Michael: I can understand your feelings how the masses are "unable" to understand his erudite articles and why this intellectual is not receving the kind of recognition he deserves. The reason is simple - those who can , they do it and those who cannot , .....what else, preach!
@@tinyspeaker Bro, I am an avid follower of Pratap BHANU Mehta, how does it make one a congress scum? He is very neutral in his approach, do try reading sir. Also, your language is not descent sir. There are people in the country who look forward towards academic debates away from BJP VS Congress VS whatever party!
@@tinyspeaker Your hateful replies on each of the comments on this video clearly show the people reading - "who is well paid- Pratap or a random troll on the Internet"
@@newham86 I know you will support Pratap Mehta.. He couldnot answer one question straight. Waste of attendees time. All big talk and in the end, ended up with egg on his face
One of the best thinkers of India, who understands Indian culture in and out, and protects it from narrow mindedness, bigotry and hate. India needs more of him!
Here, on grand dais of media, showing them their real colors without flinching an eye. That's the real journalism, I hope the India Today Group will keep in mind. Instead of asking questions to government they are asking to the critics of the government, this is true colour of media.
@@premsunderdas watch the video dude. Those are not my comments. My family consists of multiple religions, castes, states and even nationalities. Divisive? LOL!
@@SBB1975 sir, look at the developed nations, they are not discussing about Mandir masjid, they values freedom of speech and expression. You could take USA as an example, I worked in three countries and realized it
@@kappil911 The US annihilated a major part of the indigenous population , and it happened more than eight decades after they gave themselves their great Constitution. Just concede three of the tens of thousands of Mandirs that Invaders and tyrants - with whom none should now identify themselves - razed and replaced.
These are the people borrowed each alien ideas from West and imposed on India...they love nation but not nationalism... they love culture but not Santan one..they love unity but not among Hindus.. they liberalism but without including opposite ideas, they love secularism but only for Hindus, they talk feminism but to defame Hindus.....these r bloody anti India.
These are the people borrowed each alien ideas from West and imposed on India...they love nation but not nationalism... they love culture but not Santan one..they love unity but not among Hindus.. they liberalism but without including opposite ideas, they love secularism but only for Hindus, they talk feminism but to defame Hindus.....these r bloody anti India.
is it india today or BJP today? I respect the courage and goodwill of Pratap to come the den of well payed reporter and audience ..corrupted .... to take us to the truth
There is an civilisation claimed to be 1400 Year old & There is an another civilisation which claims to be superior than the first one . Few Questions For You: Que : What UPA government did post 26/11 ? Que : Why only those mob lynching came to notice where Hindu & Muslim...Why other community cases are highlighted . As per RTI only 8% cases are there were Hindu Muslim are involved . Que : When an Indian saint did something wrong every newspaper cover it on the first page .... But what happen in the case of south India FATHER case not even a single debate ? Person who is doing wrong things must be treated equally and badly . Que : Why not even a single fighter plane was purchased in period of such a long time ? Que : When Former PM Rajiv Gandhi himself said when he sends rs 1 people get only .15 Paisa what else you need to understand the level of corruption ? Que : How Pakistan becomes nuclear power and which Indian PM did a big mistake at that time ? Que : You lost 1962 with China who was responsible ? There is lots of things on a table it just depend what you pick ?
Barha Baap : Are you really using your source of information correctly or I will suggest kindly refresh your data once. Where is the freedom of speech is at risk .. Gang of idiots in JNU shouted ‘ Bharat Tere Tukde honge Inshah Allah Inshah Allah’ & still that case is in the progress so where is danger ??? Thanks for touching MOB lynching point : Kindly Check The Data provided by Home Ministry on the same and what you came to post that Hindu vs Muslims cases are less then 10% but Yes , Dalit & Muslim , Muslim & Muslim cases are way high .... But no media will touch this point in order to get TRP ... Supreme Court judges where are these judges at the time of emergency , Where was this media ??? No will answer this simple answer that was past and that was gone but one thing you can get it from this If a government really wish to shut your mouth they can as they did 1984 so keep on barking on this government was totally untrue & I personally condemn the propaganda of CONGRESS .....
Ya man exactly the point he was also making, no press freedom at all..the hindu is the only newspaper covering rafale scam..read up some editorials on rafale by the Hindu nd also emerging media houses like wire, quint..they point out everything that’s wrong now..
Barha Baap : OMG 😮Kindly Do RTI and check the facts about lynching specially : There are lynching where Muslim beaten Muslim , Muslim Beaten Dalits & Muslim / Hindu vice Versa ...Than why only Hindu Muslim lynch on discussion ??? If you do a facts check than entire picture will be clear ....
@@ramshalla664 wow what a intelligence. ask him the solution and don't count problems. He is just biased against Modi. So please keep your non sense up to you
Wow.. why do you think democracy is threaten today? I give you answer becaz this government has emphasized more on transperancy and made clear its stance against corruption andbyou people can’t tolerate the anti-corrupt government..
Democracy is sort of threatened today to "some" is purely because , TRANSPARENCY is enforced in every facet of WORK AND LIFE . Democracy is under threat to "some" because there has to ACCOUNTABILITY in what is done. Democracy is under threat to "some" because this ruling Government has ZERO TOLERANCE TO CORRUPTION . Democracy is under threat to "some" because its ONLY THIS PRESENT RULING GOVT that has created History as a TRULY PERFORMING GOVERNMENT . Democracy is under threat to "some" because this ruling Government implement all schemes to benefit all Castes, Creed , and Community without any discrimination . Last but not the least to put it in a nut shell the present ruling Government believes in ACTION and not mere ACTS ON PAPERS .
श्रीमान मेहता किस देश की बात कर रहे हैं? साफ तौर पर यह भाजपा विरोधी नागरिक हैं, अपना मत रखना और लोगों को भ्रमित करना, दो अलग अलग बातें हैं। इनकी बात को केवल इतना महत्व देना चाहिए, जितना एक आम भाजपा समर्थक या भाजपा विरोधी को। बाकी आप अच्छी अंग्रेजी को ही अंतिम सत्य का पैमाना मानें, तो यह आपकी इच्छा।
Hats off to Bhanu Pratap Mehta sir.he has said exactly what I feel about last 5 years indian democracy.i don't want my country to progress at the cost of loosing our identity of being a indian.i m proud of my country's identity as a secular country.we, the world have already a lot of country's who are based on religion.we are not one of them for sure.we are INDIA.we are leaving with so many religion for so many centuries.i am not ready to compromise on that identity of ours just for the sake of progress or for any bullet train.all this thing r not worthy enough to make us compromise with our unity and integrity
My cordial thanks to Mr Mehata for explaining in a very fine tune what is going on there in the country for the last five years. What a irony of fate to us that we will be termed as antinational if we ask any question against the undemocratic actions of the Government. Actually, some kinds of anarchism is going on in India now. we are being told in different way to accept it. Otherwise, you leave this country.
Prabir Ray who told thta you. never asked questions bro this govt has given every one freedom ok that is why he speaks it now but if ask one side question how can be possible today predusecular destroy india and create space for anthi national ok
@@prasadrao6296 What your conscience say we have freedom of speech!! The glaring example of that , people of India have experienced yesterday when a Professor was forced to beg apology with folded hands by some goons for criticising the government over recent surgical attack. If anything wrong was found in his comment it could have been treated as per law laid down in our constitution. Actually we are deviating from the highest ideology of tolerance which is the real mantra of Hinduism. But sorry to say, in the present Indian context we are being forced to follow the pseudo Hinduism which is too much injurious in the society to live in peace with harmony. We all should ask our conscience Are we doing right in the name of Nationalism?
You seem to be a typical secularist who believe in communism and the rejected theology of Karl Marx. Communism in India is almost dead but our media still gives space and time for irresponsible people like Mehta, Yechury et all. The reason why majority of Indians think about nationalism only because of pseudo secularists like Mehta. These guys who sit in the comfort of AC, sip scotch whiskey in the evening with the company of Lutyen's journalists like Rajdeep, Barkha and Sagarika, Thapar, have no understanding of India or Indians. So let him spit poison on Hindus and the nation loving Indians which fortunately are in majority. The next election will prove that people like Mehta are irrelevant in our society. It is the New India who take price in our millennia old culture and civilisations and universally acknowledged Sanatana dharma philosophy and not the ones planted by the British when they left the country. Congress starting from Nehru with the generous help from communists tried to erase our history but could not succeed. The new nationalism is all about being pride to be Indians.
@@akrishnan1382 You are seemed to be very much annoyed with my comments. I know very well communism is dead in India. But comunalisim is too much active now in our country. But feel very shy when I see throughout India imported Chinese goods are available in the market and people are much accustomed in purchasing the same. Moreover, a couple of days before Government of India sent some metroreks imported from China. We should ask our mind that 7o yrs already gone we have achieved freedom. More than 8o% people are lying below the poverty line. But we don't forget to thump the table in Parliament when the Govt. declare India is getting ready for expedition in the moon. How funny!
There was clearly no “exchange of intelligence “ (20:43) between Mr Rahul and Mr Mehta. While we did get a glimpse of Mr Mehta’s intelligence, unfortunately Rahul’s “intelligence” was no match to bring about an “intelligence exchange”.😊
@@amarbirsinghchugh3798So you agree that he does not know where to go. So how will he take nation forward? Nation needs wise men to take it forward and not intellectuals like Pratap Bhanu Mehta. Intellectuals are good in universities to teach, write thesis and guide Ph. D. students. Sorry to say this, but what such intellectuals do is called as 'Intellectual Masturbations', it does not yield any output.
I the first Indian latter we are Hindu, Muslim, Christian,Sikh.sir salute you,we the youth should come out and March for our democracy, secularity.we need to awake large number of people.
I look forward to reading his columns in the Indian Express. He explains the political, social and economic situation of our nation very lucidly and appropriately...
very true sir, recently, after purwanna attack or airstrike by IAF, it seems like if u don't favour Modi Govt. it seems like we are anti nationalist... ethos of Democracy and spirit has treatened alot from 2014...
On the contrary it’s the BJP + RSS combine which is deliberately creating a false hype regarding Hinduvta and Hindus are being absolved to minority in few years by so called minorities and misguide the youth from unemployment hassles.. its the unrealistic cooked up issues to create a sense of hate towards the minorities and its supporting parties of secular values to win elections.... after all this done it’s only 31% votes polled in 2014. BJP came to power only coz of unfortunate division of votes of balance 69% of secular votes...this time its a different story. 🥴
@@purushothamjames9960 What you're saying is asinine. BJP wouldn't have won the Hindu votes if Congress hadn't appeased Muslims. Modi NEVER has made an anti-Muslim comment since coming to power. BJP points put the fake "secularism" of the so-called secular parties who have an agenda to consolidate the Muslim vote. Also tell me one election since 1984 in which winning party has won more than 31%. Congress hasnt won more than 27% since 1984 and that too they won that much in 1984 because Indira died. Get your facts right before you argue a falsehood, James.
Pranav Kamath : Hmmmm Modi May not have said against the minorities directly, but if you can recall his silence every time a Lynching happened and also whenever some of his MPs or BJP MLAs speak against the Minority communities in a fashion to fill hate in the Hindu friends against their brothers & sisters of other faiths no action of any sort was taken.. The moment BJP came to power in 2014 in two months 5 churches were put on fire only in Delhi, leave alone scores done in other parts of the country, even the concerned PS was not registering the cases. It’s a daily affair in some part of 5he country all the last 5 yrs especially.... the propagation and propaganda of Hinduvta itself is enough proof that his slogan of Sab ka saath Sab ka vikas is a jumla...no one is against Hinduism but want to make this as a Hindu nation is against 5he principles of the constitution of India....no freedom of press , etc.
Answer to Rahul Kanwal first question to Pratap. Positive we have seen is Media is making too much money and is afraid of losing it if the govt changes and hence shamelessly will defend their masters.
@@asheravi9328 haha so its ok for journalists to ask questions to BJP leaders but not other way around. Cmon if you talk about tolerance then it should be for all.
Pratap Dhanu Mehta sir I solute you for your courage and clarity 👏👏👏👏👏 It’s an Herculean task for all of us to bring back hope in this malaise of hopelessness but let us do it and prove it in 2019 that our country is still a united democracy 👍🏻
Fu....Ng sanghs u are dividing India by religious base..and world is watching now.our status and our pride is questioning day by day. these bastards if u need cow hinduthva country go fu...and make it..leave real indian peoples from here.we hindu .muslim.christian all want live in piece as real indian.young generation will kick ur ass in near future..they are watching all ur act.fake national drama
futy room what are you Mr idiot you are bigger bohat than anyone ok he is agent of congress ok because currently govt nt giving any to them those who oppose the infia infdia support jinhad and Pak tyye are anthi national how VBA yee journalist speak about this first read the constitution. cow protection is there so this all liberal secular one side we dnt need this then never speak about thruth
Mr Mehta is tremendous high octane intellectual following him since 2 year in Indian Express The way of delivering ideas and view thats mind blowing that he has shows today... Salute to this debate and quite healthy.. Thanks India today fir it
@@bglr2783 haha so its ok for journalists to ask questions to BJP leaders but not other way around. Cmon if you talk about tolerance then it should be for all. Just because it doesn't suit your narrative you can't be blaming Rahul for rebuttals.
The way anchor questioned his idea was so unwelcoming that it made me think, why the hell they even invited him if they are already so sure of what people think, and thence, Bhanu Pratap’s ideas doesn’t matter at all.
My grandfather, father even my early young aged I followed congress, since i was working in middle east muslim country i have learned a huge lesson that how congress used democracy to corner hindus faith & believes, while supporting only few minority’s,
India Today's(Rahul Kanwal) Idea of India, the so called Alternate idea of india, has been shattered by Mr.B P Mehata by his articulated truth of India's very life line of Unity in Diversity. Thank you Mr.Mehata for your intellectual speech.
If he does the same to a BJP spokesperson or any bjp leader then you call him true journalist and if he asks same counter question to non bjp person then he becomes puppet of bjp.... please come out of the shadow of a non sensible person...
Simple, by narrowly defining nationalism, thereby excluding some people. For example, if you are in a slavic country with a large non slav minority, you define the character of the country as slavic, thereby alienating everyone else.
I like the nationalists much more than I like the supporters of the Naxal and other Tukde Honge gang. Because I only have India , and won't be able to find refuge in Communist or Islamist countries.
Wtf are you saying? Nationalism, democracy, freedom, press, religion all is gone because of 5 years of Modi winning (and losing) elections? How retarded is this?
Thanks Bhanu sir for giving perfect conducive for the democracy and u r one of the courageous to speak against power that too in India today conclave. And by looking anchor's attitude it's no doubt media is scaling the propaganda...
Now that's a clear cut explanation of the present situation and the facts of the day, kudos 👏👌to Mr. Mehta and look at the chamcha Rahul defending the government..this is what the media is today.
Well Said Prabhat. *Constitution is in Danger and so is Democracy and Free Journalism.* *When a big part of public convert's into Fans, you know all is not good for Democracy and the last time we had Blind Fans of a Politician, We saw the Massacre of Children,Women and Men in the Streets of Delhi.*
How can nationalism divide? We all should unite for a greater India. These guys are the divisive guys sowing seeds of differences and poosoning the minds
I have an easy Solution to war:- In 1916 an amendment was proposed to the Constitution that all acts of war would be put to a national vote. Anyone voting yes had to register as a volunteer for service in the United States Army. India also need a similar Constitutional Amendment so that who all want war(especially Media people) should volunteer in Military at LOC. Then only can innocent people will see/feel the betrayal of Media. In this way the idea of Nationalism will become crystal.
"What values you want to defend is the question?" Perfectly said.. Rahul Kanwal won't get that because he has diktat set to at minimum show India Today supports central policies even though they have speakers of different thought process
What values, after admitting again and again that he Prakash Mehta as one of the psuedo intellectual bearing flags of values for creating global stature are the ones responsible for creating the fissures in society If Kanwal would have remained silent, he would have been an intellectual independent journalist, that's the truth of hypocritical intellectual that has run down this nation since 1947
@@kuntaljio8849 Exactly Rahul gave the perfect rebuttal, or I would say the crux of the whole interview that if your idea of India is losing, doesn't mean India is losing.
Totally agree. However please note the questions raised by Pratap Bhanu were not about economy. What Rahul does is try to counter questions with another set of unrelated questions to divert. Crux of the matter is there will always be different opinions in a society. Opinion not matching ours doesn't mean it is against country or government in general.
Mr. Pratap Bhanu nationalism is not personal. It is always about taking country ahead keeping your personal thought not letting country gets confused . You are a vice chancellor so you have a great duty to perform.The thought that you have would never produce great scholars; yes ofcourse it can produce vice scholars
Throwback to past. Yes because all this years we are fed lies, wrong history, wrong basic, inferiority. Without correcting our base a leap is rarely possible.
Now I understand why you left Ashoka University. All the best sir👍
Thank him for stopping corrupting more minds
Yes, Ashoka university will be better!!!
@@kuntaljio8849 Yeah Yogi Chutyanath is a real academic
Why did he leave? Please clarify
@@lksarkaar6927 he doesn't teach anywhere😂😂 this man is a pro china left leaning chutiya
80% of our common people won't understand your speech sir, ....but if little dramatic then many will clap and enjoy , this is the truth of today's debate on News channel.
Tu khud ko jyada shana mat smjh.
Ya because he's sounding so paranoid , stupid talking utter rubbish as was validated by the people's thumping mandate to modi in 2019
Finally someone with a genuine mind and heart speaking truth
Very right madom .
Great speaker, why BJP Flag is being displayed in the Bankground screen, Is it a BJP sponsored program. Rahul thinks he is more Intelectual than Mehta. Rahul is putting up an argument for the sake of argument.
Always a joy to listen to real academician!
He is true congressi not academician couldnt answer a single things.
This needs to be viewed by every youngster . There is a need for people to understand the meaning of democracy. instead of labeling people who ask questions as anti national, there is a need to stress on the imp of debate. Hats off Mr.Mehta
Are you from Palakkad?
🤣🤣🤣🤣303 seats ❤️
Go to Pakistan 😂😂😂
Rahul Kanwal courage level so high before intellectual but not before of pm and president of bjp
He goes on morning walk daily so you think he will mess with amit shah or modi?
Atleast he’s better than cowswamy of recowlic tv😂😂
Right
But he asked the right questions and the loud talker was stumped completely...he just went on mincing his words and going back on what he was tirading about... at every question... good job somewhat by Rahul Kanwal
@@jayap3557 bhakti
Perfectly said.
Few people are managing all resources of our country.
It is happening only in India???
Yeah that’s why poorest people are getting electricity, clean drinking water, food, inflation is low. The poorest of India vote for Modi, they don’t care about hindutvathey care about modis socialist policies which are making their lives better
We should be happy that the few are Indians. Else, some chinese or american companies woukd be owning them Look at the state of Africa. They have highest natural resources but owned by outsiders. They plundering it and Africa remains poor
Kiyoki unme okat h or hunme sirf sarkari nokari krni h or kuch nhi krna
Not a single figure of fact but abstract jingoistic statement for sake of it. How different was it when Hindustan motor and Premier Automobile and Bajaj auto ensure black market in automobile industry
Many other such examples
So many ordinary tecnology entrepreneurs have emerged creating value for themselves and nation
But the leftist mindset of people like Mehta creates nothing but nuisance
Why can't he rather incubate a new breed of such entrepreneurs in his University wherever he was or would go
But that does not earn him global accolades of intelllectualism
Mehta is a plain hypocrite
Pratap Banu Mehta is an erudite, intellectual of the highest calibre and a man of impeccable standards. I am an avid reader of his writings in the Opinion column of Indian Express where he sculpts his thoughts and ideas in the most objective, ideated and unprejudiced manner and I envy his articulative abilities. However, the discomfiting truth is that such intellectuals cannot make a connect with ordinary masses who lack sufficient wisdom and knowledge to appreciate such nuanced dissection of issues said in the context of exalted democratic ideals, liberty, equality and fraternity.
@ Michael: I can understand your feelings how the masses are "unable" to understand his erudite articles and why this intellectual is not receving the kind of recognition he deserves. The reason is simple - those who can , they do it and those who cannot , .....what else, preach!
Interesting take Michael.
@@lyndonsaldanha3008 lyndon Saldhana, very Indian name! I am convinced your loyalty lies totally with the Indian state and Indian people!
@@tinyspeaker Bro, I am an avid follower of Pratap BHANU Mehta, how does it make one a congress scum? He is very neutral in his approach, do try reading sir. Also, your language is not descent sir. There are people in the country who look forward towards academic debates away from BJP VS Congress VS whatever party!
@@tinyspeaker Your hateful replies on each of the comments on this video clearly show the people reading - "who is well paid- Pratap or a random troll on the Internet"
Mr Mehta great knowledge & Courage, I admire the command of language.
Rahul the host is also a undeclared Bhakt
Rahul's contribution and his manner indicates he is for the current regime
@@newham86 I know you will support Pratap Mehta.. He couldnot answer one question straight. Waste of attendees time. All big talk and in the end, ended up with egg on his face
अण्ड भक्त है कंवर
One of the best thinkers of India, who understands Indian culture in and out, and protects it from narrow mindedness, bigotry and hate. India needs more of him!
Speaking truth will be rewarded by god ...
Why people are so greedy for the reward ...
Will Allah gift 72 hoors? Is Allah running a brothel?
LOL
that itself is a lie.
Mission Clean if u believe any god He will reward u for truth,even your father will reward you for truth
Great to hear Pratapji's views openly and cogently...Lovely line Rahulji too - your idea of India losing doesn't mean India is losing !
A brilliant and extraordinary view expressed by Dr. Pratap Bhanu Mehta....He deserves to be appreciated from inmost core of heart....
Here, on grand dais of media, showing them their real colors without flinching an eye. That's the real journalism, I hope the India Today Group will keep in mind. Instead of asking questions to government they are asking to the critics of the government, this is true colour of media.
Thank you for your straightforward pointers of current situation of Country
I'm here after his resignation from ashoka university🎓. He is great personality. We should learn from him.
"how many of you have a certificate to prove your nationalism" 🔥
Your comments however are certain proof that you are divisive.
@@premsunderdas watch the video dude. Those are not my comments. My family consists of multiple religions, castes, states and even nationalities. Divisive? LOL!
No....even if I had one, I'd tear it up infront of the first guy who asks me for it
Thanks you Sir let the people think and move forward our country like other civilized countries
u mean to say we r uncivilized becos we r talking about nationalism
@@SBB1975 sir, look at the developed nations, they are not discussing about Mandir masjid, they values freedom of speech and expression. You could take USA as an example, I worked in three countries and realized it
@@kappil911 The US annihilated a major part of the indigenous population , and it happened more than eight decades after they gave themselves their great Constitution. Just concede three of the tens of thousands of Mandirs that Invaders and tyrants - with whom none should now identify themselves - razed and replaced.
These are the people borrowed each alien ideas from West and imposed on India...they love nation but not nationalism... they love culture but not Santan one..they love unity but not among Hindus.. they liberalism but without including opposite ideas, they love secularism but only for Hindus, they talk feminism but to defame Hindus.....these r bloody anti India.
These are the people who love masjid masjid but if u talk Mandir... They go in coma... bloody Rascals
Truth is always bitter bhakth 😊😊😊
GREAT EYE OPENING SPEECH TO EXPOSE THE FAKE JINGOISTS AND LOOTS.
These are the people borrowed each alien ideas from West and imposed on India...they love nation but not nationalism... they love culture but not Santan one..they love unity but not among Hindus.. they liberalism but without including opposite ideas, they love secularism but only for Hindus, they talk feminism but to defame Hindus.....these r bloody anti India.
is it india today or BJP today? I respect the courage and goodwill of Pratap to come the den of well payed reporter and audience ..corrupted .... to take us to the truth
There is an civilisation claimed to be 1400 Year old & There is an another civilisation which claims to be superior than the first one .
Few Questions For You:
Que : What UPA government did post 26/11 ?
Que : Why only those mob lynching came to notice where Hindu & Muslim...Why other community cases are highlighted . As per RTI only 8% cases are there were Hindu Muslim are involved .
Que : When an Indian saint did something wrong every newspaper cover it on the first page .... But what happen in the case of south India FATHER case not even a single debate ? Person who is doing wrong things must be treated equally and badly .
Que : Why not even a single fighter plane was purchased in period of such a long time ?
Que : When Former PM Rajiv Gandhi himself said when he sends rs 1 people get only .15 Paisa what else you need to understand the level of corruption ?
Que : How Pakistan becomes nuclear power and which Indian PM did a big mistake at that time ?
Que : You lost 1962 with China who was responsible ?
There is lots of things on a table it just depend what you pick ?
Barha Baap : Are you really using your source of information correctly or I will suggest kindly refresh your data once. Where is the freedom of speech is at risk .. Gang of idiots in JNU shouted ‘ Bharat Tere Tukde honge Inshah Allah Inshah Allah’ & still that case is in the progress so where is danger ??? Thanks for touching MOB lynching point : Kindly Check The Data provided by Home Ministry on the same and what you came to post that Hindu vs Muslims cases are less then 10% but Yes , Dalit & Muslim , Muslim & Muslim cases are way high .... But no media will touch this point in order to get TRP ... Supreme Court judges where are these judges at the time of emergency , Where was this media ??? No will answer this simple answer that was past and that was gone but one thing you can get it from this If a government really wish to shut your mouth they can as they did 1984 so keep on barking on this government was totally untrue & I personally condemn the propaganda of CONGRESS .....
Ya man exactly the point he was also making, no press freedom at all..the hindu is the only newspaper covering rafale scam..read up some editorials on rafale by the Hindu nd also emerging media houses like wire, quint..they point out everything that’s wrong now..
Max Elan bro please don’t even mention cowswamy and his recowlic tv😂😂
Barha Baap : OMG 😮Kindly Do RTI and check the facts about lynching specially : There are lynching where Muslim beaten Muslim , Muslim Beaten Dalits & Muslim / Hindu vice Versa ...Than why only Hindu Muslim lynch on discussion ???
If you do a facts check than entire picture will be clear ....
Mazza aa Gaya ...hatts off to your valour
Prabhash Bahadur he is a bloody cong men ..what else you expect
@@bosslife9447 bring mobi ji c if he can speak like that this is educated people not a person from daba
@@ramshalla664 wow what a intelligence. ask him the solution and don't count problems. He is just biased against Modi. So please keep your non sense up to you
Very brave man sitting in AC Hall addressing well paid modi critics. Really picked a tough crowd.
Very true..
Yes, our democracy is threatened at this point.
By Indian people itself
But not in 1984
Wow.. why do you think democracy is threaten today? I give you answer becaz this government has emphasized more on transperancy and made clear its stance against corruption andbyou people can’t tolerate the anti-corrupt government..
@@jwalinpatel9878 it's because they are pitting ourselves against each other and we are glorifying those same people who seek to destroy us.
Democracy is sort of threatened today to "some" is purely because , TRANSPARENCY is enforced in every facet of WORK AND LIFE . Democracy is under threat to "some" because there has to ACCOUNTABILITY in what is done. Democracy is under threat to "some" because this ruling Government has ZERO TOLERANCE TO CORRUPTION . Democracy is under threat to "some" because its ONLY THIS PRESENT RULING GOVT that has created History as a TRULY PERFORMING GOVERNMENT . Democracy is under threat to "some" because this ruling Government implement all schemes to benefit all Castes, Creed , and Community without any discrimination . Last but not the least to put it in a nut shell the present ruling Government believes in ACTION and not mere ACTS ON PAPERS .
PB Mehta, Hats off to you. You said all that was in my mind.
श्रीमान मेहता किस देश की बात कर रहे हैं? साफ तौर पर यह भाजपा विरोधी नागरिक हैं, अपना मत रखना और लोगों को भ्रमित करना, दो अलग अलग बातें हैं।
इनकी बात को केवल इतना महत्व देना चाहिए, जितना एक आम भाजपा समर्थक या भाजपा विरोधी को। बाकी आप अच्छी अंग्रेजी को ही अंतिम सत्य का पैमाना मानें, तो यह आपकी इच्छा।
Hats off to Bhanu Pratap Mehta sir.he has said exactly what I feel about last 5 years indian democracy.i don't want my country to progress at the cost of loosing our identity of being a indian.i m proud of my country's identity as a secular country.we, the world have already a lot of country's who are based on religion.we are not one of them for sure.we are INDIA.we are leaving with so many religion for so many centuries.i am not ready to compromise on that identity of ours just for the sake of progress or for any bullet train.all this thing r not worthy enough to make us compromise with our unity and integrity
My cordial thanks to Mr Mehata for explaining in a very fine tune what is going on there in the country for the last five years. What a irony of fate to us that we will be termed as antinational if we ask any question against the undemocratic actions of the Government. Actually, some kinds of anarchism is going on in India now. we are being told in different way to accept it. Otherwise, you leave this country.
Prabir Ray who told thta you. never asked questions bro this govt has given every one freedom ok that is why he speaks it now but if ask one side question how can be possible today predusecular destroy india and create space for anthi national ok
@@prasadrao6296
What your conscience say we have freedom of speech!! The glaring example of that , people of India have experienced yesterday when a Professor was forced to beg apology with folded hands by some goons for criticising the government over recent surgical attack. If anything wrong was found in his comment it could have been treated as per law laid down in our constitution. Actually we are deviating from the highest ideology of tolerance which is the real mantra of Hinduism. But sorry to say, in the present Indian context we are being forced to follow the pseudo Hinduism which is too much injurious in the society to live in peace with harmony. We all should ask our conscience Are we doing right in the name of Nationalism?
You seem to be a typical secularist who believe in communism and the rejected theology of Karl Marx. Communism in India is almost dead but our media still gives space and time for irresponsible people like Mehta, Yechury et all. The reason why majority of Indians think about nationalism only because of pseudo secularists like Mehta. These guys who sit in the comfort of AC, sip scotch whiskey in the evening with the company of Lutyen's journalists like Rajdeep, Barkha and Sagarika, Thapar, have no understanding of India or Indians. So let him spit poison on Hindus and the nation loving Indians which fortunately are in majority. The next election will prove that people like Mehta are irrelevant in our society. It is the New India who take price in our millennia old culture and civilisations and universally acknowledged Sanatana dharma philosophy and not the ones planted by the British when they left the country. Congress starting from Nehru with the generous help from communists tried to erase our history but could not succeed. The new nationalism is all about being pride to be Indians.
@@akrishnan1382
You are seemed to be very much annoyed with my comments. I know very well communism is dead in India. But comunalisim is too much active now in our country. But feel very shy when I see throughout India imported Chinese goods are available in the market and people are much accustomed in purchasing the same. Moreover, a couple of days before Government of India sent some metroreks imported from China. We should ask our mind that 7o yrs already gone we have achieved freedom. More than 8o% people are lying below the poverty line. But we don't forget to thump the table in Parliament when the Govt. declare India is getting ready for expedition in the moon. How funny!
@@parichoygupta5859 ......those goons had no right to manhandle the professor
There was clearly no “exchange of intelligence “ (20:43) between Mr Rahul and Mr Mehta. While we did get a glimpse of Mr Mehta’s intelligence, unfortunately Rahul’s “intelligence” was no match to bring about an “intelligence exchange”.😊
What a man! What an intellectual! We need more of him to take the nation forward!
yes let him stand for an election
What forward? Pratap Bhanu Mehta does not know where to go...
That's because the politics has fallen to its nadir.
@@amarbirsinghchugh3798So you agree that he does not know where to go. So how will he take nation forward?
Nation needs wise men to take it forward and not intellectuals like Pratap Bhanu Mehta. Intellectuals are good in universities to teach, write thesis and guide Ph. D. students.
Sorry to say this, but what such intellectuals do is called as 'Intellectual Masturbations', it does not yield any output.
I the first Indian latter we are Hindu, Muslim, Christian,Sikh.sir salute you,we the youth should come out and March for our democracy, secularity.we need to awake large number of people.
I look forward to reading his columns in the Indian Express. He explains the political, social and economic situation of our nation very lucidly and appropriately...
The anchor is so pissed off hearing the truth. 😂😂😂
This is the sign of true intellectual.He is speaking truth to power.Hats off sir
very true sir,
recently, after purwanna attack or airstrike by IAF, it seems like if u don't favour Modi Govt. it seems like we are anti nationalist... ethos of Democracy and spirit has treatened alot from 2014...
He resigned from Ashoka University
Government nationalist :1
Humanity:0
God bless our of outspoken people
woven magic : India survives on such brave hearts to speak their minds. Keep it up. 👍🏽👍🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
This is just fear mongering of the dirtiest kind.
On the contrary it’s the BJP + RSS combine which is deliberately creating a false hype regarding Hinduvta and Hindus are being absolved to minority in few years by so called minorities and misguide the youth from unemployment hassles.. its the unrealistic cooked up issues to create a sense of hate towards the minorities and its supporting parties of secular values to win elections.... after all this done it’s only 31% votes polled in 2014. BJP came to power only coz of unfortunate division of votes of balance 69% of secular votes...this time its a different story. 🥴
@@purushothamjames9960 What you're saying is asinine.
BJP wouldn't have won the Hindu votes if Congress hadn't appeased Muslims.
Modi NEVER has made an anti-Muslim comment since coming to power.
BJP points put the fake "secularism" of the so-called secular parties who have an agenda to consolidate the Muslim vote.
Also tell me one election since 1984 in which winning party has won more than 31%.
Congress hasnt won more than 27% since 1984 and that too they won that much in 1984 because Indira died.
Get your facts right before you argue a falsehood, James.
Pranav Kamath : Hmmmm Modi May not have said against the minorities directly, but if you can recall his silence every time a Lynching happened and also whenever some of his MPs or BJP MLAs speak against the Minority communities in a fashion to fill hate in the Hindu friends against their brothers & sisters of other faiths no action of any sort was taken.. The moment BJP came to power in 2014 in two months 5 churches were put on fire only in Delhi, leave alone scores done in other parts of the country, even the concerned PS was not registering the cases. It’s a daily affair in some part of 5he country all the last 5 yrs especially.... the propagation and propaganda of Hinduvta itself is enough proof that his slogan of Sab ka saath Sab ka vikas is a jumla...no one is against Hinduism but want to make this as a Hindu nation is against 5he principles of the constitution of India....no freedom of press , etc.
Answer to Rahul Kanwal first question to Pratap. Positive we have seen is Media is making too much money and is afraid of losing it if the govt changes and hence shamelessly will defend their masters.
Rahul you are behaving like a Agent of Bharashtachari JUMLA party.Try to digest the basic truth of today.
@@asheravi9328 haha so its ok for journalists to ask questions to BJP leaders but not other way around. Cmon if you talk about tolerance then it should be for all.
No doubt why he's such a great prof.
Thats intellectual speech that show the present image of india n its govt
Hats off to Pratap Bhanu. Public should vote to save democracy.
One of the best intellectuals of current Indian generation.... Nice Sir 👍🌸
Pratap Dhanu Mehta sir I solute you for your courage and clarity 👏👏👏👏👏 It’s an Herculean task for all of us to bring back hope in this malaise of hopelessness but let us do it and prove it in 2019 that our country is still a united democracy 👍🏻
It’s funny to see Muslims talking about democracy ha ha.
Nationalism calculated by bakth and cow
@@stormyzvox2185 u mean 🐐 can't handle what about 🐵 🐘 🐮 🐍 u chose
Democracy certified by Jihadi , and Naxal ?
Fu....Ng sanghs u are dividing India by religious base..and world is watching now.our status and our pride is questioning day by day. these bastards if u need cow hinduthva country go fu...and make it..leave real indian peoples from here.we hindu .muslim.christian all want live in piece as real indian.young generation will kick ur ass in near future..they are watching all ur act.fake national drama
futy room what are you Mr idiot you are bigger bohat than anyone ok he is agent of congress ok because currently govt nt giving any to them those who oppose the infia infdia support jinhad and Pak tyye are anthi national how VBA yee journalist speak about this first read the constitution. cow protection is there so this all liberal secular one side we dnt need this then never speak about thruth
😂😂😂😂
Great Mr Mehta. Thumbs up.
This joker called Rahul Kanwal has no idea what Mr Mehta is trying to figure out like any other bhakt joker.
And what about Parivar bhakt
Is Rahul spokesperson of BJP?
Mr Mehta is tremendous high octane intellectual following him since 2 year in Indian Express
The way of delivering ideas and view thats mind blowing that he has shows today...
Salute to this debate and quite healthy..
Thanks India today fir it
Anchor shows courage to those only who speak against government.....they became cat in front of those in power
So true. The fact is he can't question this way those in power. So he takes advantage of the civilised speakers for the trp.
@@bglr2783 haha so its ok for journalists to ask questions to BJP leaders but not other way around. Cmon if you talk about tolerance then it should be for all. Just because it doesn't suit your narrative you can't be blaming Rahul for rebuttals.
The way anchor questioned his idea was so unwelcoming that it made me think, why the hell they even invited him if they are already so sure of what people think, and thence, Bhanu Pratap’s ideas doesn’t matter at all.
My grandfather, father even my early young aged I followed congress, since i was working in middle east muslim country i have learned a huge lesson that how congress used democracy to corner hindus faith & believes, while supporting only few minority’s,
Satya Mev Jayate. 🙏
I don't want certificates of nationalism, but will give out certificates of liberalism😀
😂😂😂
Riveting all the way through! Superior stuff by many a mile. Cheers to you Pratap Bhanu Mehta.
Divide and Rule always work.
80 20 principal, focus on 80 percent 😁
India Today's(Rahul Kanwal) Idea of India, the so called Alternate idea of india, has been shattered by Mr.B P Mehata by his articulated truth of India's very life line of Unity in Diversity. Thank you Mr.Mehata for your intellectual speech.
Mehta is too nice to call out Rahul's ignorance.
Excellent
We are with Mr Pratabh Banu Mehata
Rahul listen 👂 by u questioning Mr Pratap on his ideas shows u are playing into the hands of the BJP.
Well done sir on your answers.
If he does the same to a BJP spokesperson or any bjp leader then you call him true journalist and if he asks same counter question to non bjp person then he becomes puppet of bjp.... please come out of the shadow of a non sensible person...
Rahul just said there are multiple steps we have taken..
Anyone still has any doubt which side he is own.
God bless pratap sir...for your courage
Reasonable speech expressing real concerns.
great speech. Also I believe Rahul's questions brought the much needed balance to the discussion
Rightly said that-: nationalism is being used by modi for power
Nationalism is power.
How could nationalism divide people ?
Infact nationalism should unite people .
Simple, by narrowly defining nationalism, thereby excluding some people. For example, if you are in a slavic country with a large non slav minority, you define the character of the country as slavic, thereby alienating everyone else.
Did Rahul Kanwal Asked questions in the same way to MODI, AMIT SHAH, SMRITI IRANI?
India (once a democracy) and then modi destroyd it....
I hate even word bjp...
Bjp giving certificate of nationalism ...
I like the nationalists much more than I like the supporters of the Naxal and other Tukde Honge gang. Because I only have India , and won't be able to find refuge in Communist or Islamist countries.
Really? Any comments on West Bengal?
Are you a Muslim?
and you love the word congress??? the only fascist leader in our history and her name Indira- wake up and smell the coffee
Wtf are you saying? Nationalism, democracy, freedom, press, religion all is gone because of 5 years of Modi winning (and losing) elections? How retarded is this?
When a person keep saying right...right...right...is not convinced himself. Pratap bhanu represents those intolerant secularists
Its his Hubris which says Right, all his hoard of liberal goats he commands by writing *bs* on opeds.
Very good Sir !! Very good speech
Thanks Bhanu sir for giving perfect conducive for the democracy and u r one of the courageous to speak against power that too in India today conclave. And by looking anchor's attitude it's no doubt media is scaling the propaganda...
Now that's a clear cut explanation of the present situation and the facts of the day, kudos 👏👌to Mr. Mehta and look at the chamcha Rahul defending the government..this is what the media is today.
When the soul of country will be dead, what will you do with the GST?
Mr Pratap Bhanu Mehta has got something that Rahul and BJP does not....BALLS!
For the first I have seen Rahul Kanwal speak something sensible
How many of us have a certificate that we're truthful, we are intellectuals, we are honest, we're leading a happy life...? Crazy question
None is going to hurt you if you are not any of these, unlike not being a nationalist, under this regime.
Thank you, Mr. Mehta, for saying loud the real big issues with this government!
He just Nailed iT
Sir.. it's nice lecture I ever heard..he is a intellectual person and points raised by him are thinkable..
Rahul, you lost it to pratap Banu Mehta in the last 5 minutes, of your conversation.
Not really
I was waiting for the moment when India Today journalists jump to save their masters...
Now, Rahul Kanwal should ask himself with the same tone and confidence.
Thank you sir. Despite highly provocative questions (probably intended to get answers), your thinking and precise answers are just awesome.
"Nationalism is a glorified tribalism" - J.K.
So?
U r free to move out of the "tribe".
@@ayushbh6839 nd who tf r u?? Leader of the tribe🤣🤣
@@osirisgaming5544 the leader of the tribe doesn't kick out any1 it's the people who do not believe in the tribal culture who move out on their own🤦🤦
Just like their govt they talk
Great insight pbm every tyrant ruler will fall one day n be prepared for what will be left back to put together
Perfectly articulated Mr Mehta .
Nationalism brings people closer.
in the name of religion race and language ..
Well Said Prabhat.
*Constitution is in Danger and so is Democracy and Free Journalism.*
*When a big part of public convert's into Fans, you know all is not good for Democracy and the last time we had Blind Fans of a Politician, We saw the Massacre of Children,Women and Men in the Streets of Delhi.*
This time it is a more genuine grass root rooting for a politician....which is non threatening and non confrontational in nature
His name is Pratap Bhanu Mehta.
TheBeast speak about gujarat riots too.
Thanks to mehta.rahul you should analyse different dimensions not stick to one thing.
How can nationalism divide? We all should unite for a greater India. These guys are the divisive guys sowing seeds of differences and poosoning the minds
P B mehta is absolutely right of talking about the idea of India as a liberal democracy ...
The host seems to be determined with intend to argue. Instead of holding an intellectual discussion,he doesn't like to appear to lose 🤔
I have an easy Solution to war:-
In 1916 an amendment was proposed to the Constitution that all acts of war would be put to a national vote. Anyone voting yes had to register as a volunteer for service in the United States Army.
India also need a similar Constitutional Amendment so that who all want war(especially Media people) should volunteer in Military at LOC. Then only can innocent people will see/feel the betrayal of Media. In this way the idea of Nationalism will become crystal.
Outstanding speech....
Speech was good. Not many will understand but valid points raised
Democracy is nothing for bhakt...
"What values you want to defend is the question?" Perfectly said..
Rahul Kanwal won't get that because he has diktat set to at minimum show India Today supports central policies even though they have speakers of different thought process
What values, after admitting again and again that he Prakash Mehta as one of the psuedo intellectual bearing flags of values for creating global stature are the ones responsible for creating the fissures in society
If Kanwal would have remained silent, he would have been an intellectual independent journalist, that's the truth of hypocritical intellectual that has run down this nation since 1947
@@kuntaljio8849 Exactly Rahul gave the perfect rebuttal, or I would say the crux of the whole interview that if your idea of India is losing, doesn't mean India is losing.
Totally agree. However please note the questions raised by Pratap Bhanu were not about economy. What Rahul does is try to counter questions with another set of unrelated questions to divert.
Crux of the matter is there will always be different opinions in a society. Opinion not matching ours doesn't mean it is against country or government in general.
Mr. Pratap Bhanu nationalism is not personal. It is always about taking country ahead keeping your personal thought not letting country gets confused .
You are a vice chancellor so you have a great duty to perform.The thought that you have would never produce great scholars; yes ofcourse it can produce vice scholars
My worldview trumps all. - Pratap Bhanu Mehta.
It's not nationalism but jingoism that is happening in our country
Throwback to past. Yes because all this years we are fed lies, wrong history, wrong basic, inferiority. Without correcting our base a leap is rarely possible.
Rahul Kanwal, you just proved what prof said. Press is not free anymore.
So damn true!!!
Very true 😎