Institutions Under Assault?:Justice Chelameswar, Vinod Rai & Sanjeev Sanyal At IT Conclave 2019
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
- Watch Justice (Retd) Jasti Chelameshwar- Former Judge Supreme Court, Vinod Rai - Former Controller and Auditor General and Sanjeev Sanyal - Principle Economic Advisor, Finance Ministry speaking at India Today Conclave 2019 in a session titled, ' Caged Birds: Institutions Under Assault Or Operation Clean-Up?'.
#LetsConclave19
The India Today Conclave 2019 will reflect its theme Hard Choices and more over two days of intense discussions, sparkling debates, and rare insights which will showcase the political, economic and social choices India confronts.
The year 2019 is a year of critical choices. Both for the world and for India. In India, it is especially pivotal as the country heads for a crucial general election. Just weeks ahead of the 2019 Lok Sabha polls, the India Today group will bring to you the eighteenth edition of the India Today Conclave.
The Eighteenth Edition of India Today Conclave is held at Durbar Ballroom, Taj Palace, Sardar Patel Marg from 2nd to 3rd March 2019.
SUBSCRIBE to India Today Conclave so you don't miss any session and make sure to enable Push Notifications, so you'll never miss a new video. All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
rajdeep tried his best to some how paint modi in bad light but vinod rai and sanjeev were too good for him.
Mudizee doesn't need anyone to paint him in a bad light. His actions speaks more than the misinformation he doles out.
Sanjeev sanyal raised an important issue of cases lying dormant(in the no. of millions) and holding the holier than thou judiciary accountable
True. The judiciary and all other institutions should be accountable. But to whom is the question. Surely not the elected who are accountable to none. They are free to misuse power for 5 years at least. Subsequently, they have contacts and pensions for life. I want such a job!! ;) :D
He is great brother, do read his books and listen to his lectures, Sanjeev is a gem intellectual of our times
The responsibility lies with the government.. 👇🏼
An overworked Chief Justice TS Thakur breaks down in front of PM Modi
www.google.com/amp/s/m.timesofindia.com/india/An-overworked-Chief-Justice-TS-Thakur-breaks-down-in-front-of-PM-Modi/amp_articleshow/51964732.cms
"He lamented "inaction" by the Executive in increasing the number of judges to 40,000 from the current 21,000. That, he said is the reason the judiciary is unable to handle the "avalanche" of litigation."
ask him to first make the PM TO ANSWER SENSITIVE QUESTION ....
@@samt1705 the no of judges is a problem, but more than that it's the efficiency of existing machinery, judiciary interfering in the work of legislature and executive, they heard cases on frivolous PILs filed by many superactive lawyers.
Very very nuanced points raised by Mr. Sanyal are praiseworthy.
He is gem
Tell that to the naysayers here - unfortunately their criticisms seem to be coming due to their Friday and Sunday sermons...
Lol.. according to him CBI working under the PM will act against him. What a joke!
@@anandixitin thanks , you are a stupid
Sanjeev Sanyal is on fire, this guys is really good talking accountability on every front. Whether it is RBI CBI or even Supreme Court.
He seems a reasonable and a good guy.
Media is asking questions but who will ask questions to them paid media paid questions
Their performance is worse than any other institution in India, their egos are bloated, no public good in mind , brazenly commercial....
hirendra kankerwal like income tax officials asses their own income or judge do judgments for themselves
hirendra kankerwal In this case Rajdeep is asking good questions. What is your objection?
Unfortunately this is is not Zee news man !!
Randeep sardesai does not have the gravitas to be in this panel.
hahaha, within 17 minutes he got so hyper ;p
On any panel, IMO
He could not keep his mouth shut for 2 minutes,,just keeps interrupting...
You want anjana om kashyap 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 that's called journalism.
Civil Services was created as buffer between Uniformed Forces and Politicians : Vinod Rai.... Well said Sir
Sanjeev Sanyal is capable to deal with this paid media
sanghi appreciation
@@TM-vv7tq Bhai bhai bhai...
Where was the RBI when loans were given without any security to people like Vijay mallya.non of the governor raised their voice against Congress party
Talk about raffle, deal was given to anil Ambani without bank security, what will you say that,anyway vijay malya ran under modi chaokidar so modi government has responsible
@@akhileshverma3449 there is default in ur basic knowledge about Rafael like ur master pappu Gandhi has.anil Ambani will not make Rafael so which deal is given to Ambani. Dassault has choosen Ambani and many other companies for offset which is good for India becoz Dassault will invest half of the amount in India which will provide job.ur pappu say Modi has given 30000 crore to Ambani and the deal of aircraft is 58000 crore so why would anyone give money to Ambani ??see the problem is u belong to pappu category that's y ur argument is also like pappus argument. First have basic knowledge and then jump to the conclusion.ur argument shows ur IQ level .pls don't expose urself. Have a nice day
@@VPO2024 so poor you are guy
@@GMCreations1991 thank u
@@akhileshverma3449 who say this this offset obligation dassault aviation to invest 50% money from deal to Bharat more than 30% offset obligation .You know 59 lak crore rupees 30 lakh rupees to BHARAT in different commercial and defensive purpose .
Let us first have the Judiciary accountable to the people of India - ~36 million "real" cases pending,some decades old, in Indian courts and milords are deeply involved in vanity casess like Sabarimala, Jallikattu, Dahi handi, etc. In US judges are elected by the people, here our judges have framed a system in the 1990's called the collegium with an opaque system of appointing judges known only to them and which was not there in the original Constitution of India. Also, some "small" reforms are required like courts working regular days like the rest of us mortals and not have prolonged summer and winter holidays !
What judges select by people of America!! 😮
Not everybody is on sale.
Not on sale?In last 40 years India's ruling class sold the country out to special interests in wholesale. All branches of government are corrupt including the supreme court. India is surviving on currency devaluation and 50%tax on petroleum and nothing else.
Did you get an understanding or not Mr.Rajdeep Sirdesai?
Hold the judiciary accountable for delaying cases at the behest of a few high flying Rajya sabha lawyers?
The anchor lost the debate midway when all the guests in principle agreed that all institution must be held accountable in a dynamic democracy. Mr. Anchor's agenda foiled by eminent individuals and experts of their respective fields.
Mr Sanyal looks solid.
Justice Chelameshwar's points are so illuminating!
Rajdeep always tries to put his words in others mouth. He is always finding an opportunity how he can establish his own narratives. This is not journalism.
Look at Rajdeep, Justice Chameleshwar, was talking in general from times immomorial, Rajdeep twisting it to 2018 ..he is trying to spin against BJP...
sanjeeve sanyal nailed ....awessome
Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal with that last mic drop statement !
Enough with Chelameswar and his statement.
SC is no more Supreme Court for common people, but
such types of guys made SC as Secured Center for rich and corrupt leaders only.
Bottom line is : People of India are loosing trust on SC.
jUST BECAUSE OF PEOPLE LIKE CHELMESHWAR
JUSTICE CHELAMESHWAR GAVE DISSENTING JUDGMENT IN NJAC CASE.
Losing.
Justice justi.... hatsoff sir...thanks for questioning...
A very informative debate... At hour of biggest crisis going on in media of our country..India today has really done a stupendous job by coming up with such kinds of informative debates...
As far as the attacks on the institutions are concerned the silence of Redt. Supreme court justice on many questions revealed all the answers ......
Should be one of the best session in the conclave.. the advantages of having goood people on a discussion who can put forward their views without accusations at every single sentence. Much more of these discussions would be appreciated! :D
One who is acting over smart here-rajdeep
Anchor should b active to ask question...what's wrong in that...to ask question to the intellectual anchor needs to b active tooo
Mr sanyal is a gem!!!
All institutions of the nation should be made accountable by the constitutional amendments, and there we.should be free with regional constraints,or check and balances to change the Constitution according to the circumstances and should not made it sacrosanct....And my personal desire is to make media be made accountable first as early as possible.
Rajdeep tried desperately,but failed.
I came into this video with a jaundiced view on retired justice Chelameshwar. It felt to me like the public press conference conducted by the four judges under his apparent leadership was for some vested agenda outside the judicial workings. But in this debate he came out as a honest and intelligent person. His remarks on the need to debate the past judgements of upcoming judicial appointees and the presence of an inherent tension between the judiciary and the Govt, all seem to be valid and makes sense to me as layman. Sanjeev Sanyal's remarks come out like from a spin doctor, which given his job as an advisor to the Govt is understandable.
Justice Ch. Is allways a gem of men
Sanjiv Sanyal is impressive
Oh man. You may have been a good judge, but you clearly have not read The Sign of the Four. Mary Morstan was NOT a widow.
Wow wow these three are rock solid personality .may be beast in all conclave
Juctice Chelameshwar 🙏🙏 The only person I wanted to listen but absolutely this was not the platform for you sir. 🙏🙏
32:45 Rajdeep Sardesai : "Bascially where you stand is where you sit". Sums up congress politics on 370, CAA, Triple Talaq etc. But the line is too funny as well.
A good grounding wasted...though... because of a oversimplifying anchor... wrong premises...
What a shame when you compare Judiciary with executive ......
Try to read Anita gets Bail....
These buggers are not saints!
i know nothing stupid person
@@rezaazlaan2429 nor you
Mr Binod Rai has no moral right to debate any issue since while holding a constitutional post as CAG, he leaked his report on 2G to give upper hand to the then opposition and not surprising that he got a new job on behest of present government as prize. A person who occupied a constitutional post should not accept any government assignment after retirement as done by Mr Chalameswar.
True. He is corrupt.
either sitting or retired judges should never participate in the talk shows, in fact there should be a complete ban on the judges to hold any kind of correspondence with the media, violation should result in dismissal and loss of pension in case of retirees.
Why the fuck would suggest that
20:55 if i remember correctly CJI TS Thakur in 2016 asked modi in rather emotional way to improve not only the infrastructure of courts but also a get workforce in lower courts.
and BJP man sitting there forgot that, that we dont have enough judges to clean the cases stuck in the pipeline, and blaming judiciary for the cases stuck in pipeline.
Respect Justice Chellameshwar.
Good God Bless You.
So basically rajdeep wants everything to work on its own and govt to be rubber stamp... Why elections for this sake?
I think Mr Vinod Rai is very open minded and am impressed by his answers and statements.
Few thing rajdeep should know, according to him everyone/everything should be perfect which obviously everyone want and strive for but look who is giving the sermon, a backscratcher of a family who never strived to be anything other than a licker.
I have seen this tendency in left supported idiots they have issues with every government institutions and processes (as their ideology teaches them) but zero alternative and if they have an alternative it will so unrealistic, heavenly that it would never grow after sowing as each of us at individual levels have set of belief on how things should be and they the killer mindset, authoritarian mindset who would only gel with hated and blood flow ,i.e equal distribution of wealth (Stalin killed in lakh but still that murderer is a hero).
They are the becon of misguided educated thoughts who create fallacies, fake data, concoting stories, create fake institutions just to suit them and if you don't believe them they will prove there intelligence by call you bhakts, patriarchal, intolerant...etc.
They believe in distributing certification, how good-bad or intolerant one is even if they are from that coward crowd that won't even have the guts to sit on the discussion table and listen to you if you have a different viewpoint to theirs.
They never care to look within and farther because of their foggy thoughts.
They are the only hate mongers after terrorist alive on this earth who strive to divide,break,hurt!
So well understood. I feel the same
The BEST officer is selected to head the CBI, is a reflection of how corrupt the best IPS officer is, or can be...NEEDS to be reflected upon !!
three genius of my country.this three are great in their filed but among those Binod Roy is very special.
One of the best debate on UA-cam with great insights.
Please dont defame Rottweilers, by comparing them Mr Rajdeep Sardesai. They are a very loyal and lovable breed.
Vinod roy is having good Times...a BJP man....
Completely
The hallmark of an advanced democracy is to keep judiciary, law enforcement, and defense forces kept independent of the politics. The lesser the interference by political establishment, the stronger these institutions become. That is the way to sustain democracy. Anything else is dangerous. This is more important during times when one party has just about decimated the opposition therefore law enforcement & judiciary are the two things that can ensure a high degree of integrity in the governing body's behavior.
Some like Rajdeep like things to be destroyed & corrupted silently because that is more dignified. 2 brother in family differ on so many things in home but they want trust & no fiction in institute. I feel difference which comes in public are more better as atleast we can see to it.
Justice Chelameswar😍😍
Media should understand the limits.....the way respected former judge asks him to avoid it.....but no....mr sardesai is like a spoiled brat
The executive have power but where the accountability, why the public can't question
Church hates the executive cos it is lead by Heathens.
Public do question executive and that's what legislature is made of
Hail Justice Chelameshwar. Honest man. India would do well to have more like him!
The pocket scarf on Mr.Desai represents the tricolour of Indian National Flag.
He can make a flag badge and wear it but Should the tri colour combination be stopped in any segment except for the flag ?
Journalists should listen more than talk. Questions of journalists should, most of the time, be shorter than the answers from the guests.
Sanjeev Sir is true bhakt of Modi Sir..India need more supporter like him..
Appreciate Rajdeep for bringing a very good panel to discuss important matters.
Rajdeep's conduct of the debate is commendable for a change, though there was a veiled effort to discredit the Government/BJP.
Appaji Pawar
35:25 Rajdeep sardesai says that air chief marshals, bureaucrats etc are now writing long pieces in support of govt to show their loyalty. May be the case is that the govt is listening to them and that they are defending their own opinions in front of opposition?
Rajdeep is so fond of scolding now a days, even calm man like Chelameshwar didn't feel pity over him.
If collegium system in judiciary is justified than please allow such system in executives,CA,medical appointments....and even for president and prim ministers
Why whole conclave looks like biased towards BJP. Most of speaker from bjp
True. All become paid media under Modi
Yes it looks biased bcoz there is a combo of congressi jurno and communist propagator.
I think u r too much habituate to see everything only through a red glass even the dreams
Vinod the liar.
only matured and relevant person on stage is justice chelameshwar.he answers only the questions which are relevant to his profession and knowledge..kudos for ur judgement on privacy
Please tell about what which point you agree ? Which point they give Is Gogoi Congress leader son Cji also find not any fault
Sanjiv sanyal without appointing judge how can you ask about pending cases ... Do you know how many vacancies in the Indian judiciary.
And these vacancies were created only after 2014!!!! Only this Govt after 2014 has not be appointing the judges???? Does the society have no responsibility of producing the quality people who deserve to be appointed judges??? Just thinking out loud!!!
Maximum appointment happened in last 4yrs ,it was backlog of earlier govt.for all sins of earlier govt this govt is working overtime to wipe of their sins.there was policy paralysis in last govt which has taken Country back by 20yrs & this govt has taken this Country to new hts...
@@ramachandrarjs4075 Bullshit. Society not producing good judges? What else? Women not producing intelligent babies?
Justice Chelamaneswarar have nailed an important point that our constitution is framed based on mistrust and not trust. Today the governance is more of mistrusting the people at all departments at all aspects.
men may come and men may go but Igo for ever says Alfred Tennyson 's poem the "The brook'' that's justice.
Rajdeep banging on as usual. He seems to naïvely think that there should be no checks and balances in a democracy.
Menu of RBI canteen...well said by sanyal.....chidambaram and co., made merry by having samosas,tea and lending crores by way of crony capitalism to murky individuals and fattened their purses.
Mr raj let them answer completely.. don't interrupt..
I do not know much about Judiciary. By going through the reports and articles in newspaper, TV channels etc.,on various scams occurred so far in our country, makes me feel there's some mechanism in our democracy that perfectly supports corruption. Also there's no seminars like this by any organization on how much money we have recovered from scamsters. I believe when we are able to recover money from scamsters & black money holders will justify our institutions. What's your opinion ?
Hmmmm nobody wants to comment. Maybe all these scams, blackmoney etc is okay with us. In democracy alone raising concerns has no value.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_scandals_in_India, this website has good data on scandals. What are these " by the people and for the people" in the name of democracy ?
Who is going to upgrade the "honesty" and "intellectual honesty" of the persons heading the Institutions of this country ! Be it the Judiciary, CAG, ED, CVC, CBI, Income tax, RBI, !!!!!
All three are brilliant!
Vinod Rai... Favoured the oppositionthen and got plum jobs from Cricket judgements....as a Justice to settle BCCI... 'which is itself is politics.... '
My Qn to Vinod Rai, Why BCCI in it's report to ICC haven't named Pakistan promoting terrorism and the reason to throw it out? I thought BCCI did half hearted job.
Rajdeep, why there was never a debate on any RBI Governor leaving office after the completion of tenure. Why debate on “Extension”.
How many government servants get extension after the retirement.
Chalmeshwar , a great personality.
ONLY RAJDEEP SARDESAI IS SOLELY FIT FOR ALL THE POSTS IN THE LAND FOR HE ONLY NEEDS TO ASK QUESTIONS AND NOT DELIVER ANYTHING !!
What the bhakts don't understand is that questions have to be asked from the Govt in office, not the opposition.
How does bhakths come in the pic here? Just because you are of different religion doesn't mean you have to oppose.modi. Try removing your biased spectacles and look at things objectively
@@AGvideos1793
This religion inclusion in your point and thought clearly makes u bhakht
@@siddharthgupta3717 OK. Now get lost
@@AGvideos1793
U not just get lost even leave this country. We don't need people like you. It is just because of your kind of people our country was being ruled by outcomers even they were not even 1% of our total population. U divisor
You are insulting the democracy by calling people bhakts, opening a discussion that you are Mullah
I think this Economist is a Govt sucker... heard his. speech... no stuff and a plain liar only blah... Blah... Wonder on his credentials
Very good debate, in spite of the fact that Saradesai is conducting it! Credit to all the panelists
Govt of the day exploit all the institution
First see what to do about pending cases and slow processing of the cases. Judges need to look within first.
One of the Justices in that press conference is CJI now...then he questioned the way of allocation of cases by then CJI but when his time came...ruled that CJI is master of roster...irony at peak...The great Abe has said if you want to test man's character give him power...
And now he is a man of BJP! What a coincidence!
Rajdeep is only under threat
Wrong. We Indians are under threat. Democracy will not survive another 5 years of Modi but then foolish bhakts don't care.
@@kalidasa_in dude only u r in danger. Democracy was not in danger when money of the people were looted in various scams. Democracy was not threatened when Mumbai attack happened and no reply was given to pakistan.democracy was not in danger when manmohan Singh said Muslims should have first right on national resources.stop this hypocrsy.if u pretending to b sleeping then no one can awake u.
@@kalidasa_in and what about u chamchas. It's better to b a bhakt than to be a chamcha.atleast my IQ level is not like pappu but ur IQ level seems to be like pappu
What about accountability of supreme court
Rajdeep trying to hit Modi through the panel members with twisted questions and they cleverly refuse to fall into his trap.
Yeah until 2014 are all Judges honest and did they ever give one justice on time? Sometimes 30-40 years - they did not see new India coming. Who gets summer holidays from the work - I mean people are waiting for justice and these guys shamelessly take summer vacation.
excellent answers by Mr.Rai about institutions.
Sardesai has lost. His old touch.. Sometimes he is too loud and makes a. Fool of himself... A bad mannered anchor. 'he seems to be going the Arnab Gosami way...
Rajdeep should be commended for bringing in such intellectuals together and making a fool out of himself.
Only in India there was no mechanism to define how much funds the RBI earns will transfer to govt.
In US, Fed transfers all of it. Other countries have a formula but no such thing in India.
That's why I'm saying we got independence in 2014. Call me a Bhakt, I have facts to say what I'm saying bro.
post 2014 rajdeep has started barking more
YEAH, I QUITE AGREE. HE HAS GOT A SPITEFUL N A VERY VINDICTIVE FACE. VERY POOR DRESSER TOO. SLOPPY IS THE WORD.
@@hyd916 he has not sold his thruth workmanship....dont have enough money for fancy clothes.....as like kharida hua journalist
It's more ads than content. Seems like notebandhi caused Rajdeep dearly.
Normally, shouldn't the host be at least pretending to be unbiased? Rajdeep Sardesai doesn't even try!
25:02 bloody partial media , got silent when he said bjp, SHAME
Vinod rai has very clear thoughts..... Good to hear from such intellectuals...
Rajdeep got hammered...Simply he could nail anyone down. He clearly made that he has issues with the government of the day... very sad....
Totally agree with JUSTICE CHILAMESHVAR
Whic point you agree or not
Why people are not able to call
a spade a spade
Under upa regieme corruption was individual
Under Nda regieme corruption is institutionaled
Only difference is individual freedom is at stake now
God save the people of india
Rajdeep was badly scolded by former President Pranab Mukherjee in interview now justice chelmeshwar thrashes him for puting word "Revolt" before him.. 😂
Sanjeev Sanyal alone destroyed all left librandus news channel and rice bag converts. Lots of love Sanjeev Sir from Bihar.
We all need intellectual like you whom we all appreciate. We dont need foreign paid librandus channel like India today, the wire, print,
We only want Godi media 😂😂