You down grade the a400 for things that can be adjusted with stock spacers and the shim kit for drop. The a400 shooting high means not enough drop - for you. That is why it hit your cheek too hard. You can easily add a different shim and give it more drop and more or less LOP to make it mount better. Sounds like the browning was just lucky that it fit you correctly out of the box. The beretta can easily be made to fit you or anyone, easily.
Good points. You certainly can change felt recoil some through the available adjustments. Thank you for the comment 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
Isn't this dude sponsored by Winchester who is joined at the proverbial hip with Browning. Here in North Texas we have seen several Browning's ceracoat scrape off and the steel rust. Add to the price of the Browning's stock fit that a gunsmith would charge to cut and refit. The only negative that is legit on the A400 is the weight.
Greetings from Colorado! I have 3 Beretta Xtremes in the family plus the A400 plus. No issues, between the 4 guns, we have fired thousands of rounds through them. Not one issue. With Browning firearms, I have always had problems. I have a Citori O/U, 3.5 chamber, trigger issues, I have a Browning Gold, trigger and jamming issues. I may have pointed this out to Steve in another video. I will never buy a Browning.............even if it's given to me for FREE
A handy feature that you missed mentioning in this video as well as the in depth video on the A400 is the unloading. Much safer. Rack the shell out of the chamber and then lift the loading shelf and pull out on the bolt release. Very handy in tight quarters and as I mentioned safer. Nonetheless great videos! Adjust that beretta with the shims and you'll be in love. I had a original maxus in the past and the failures to eject had me fed up and out buying the A400 xtreme plus.
You can pull the rounds out of the mag tube on the maxus very easy by pushing up the lifter and then hitting the side catch for the rounds in the mag and then remove the round from chamber. At least that’s what I do.
Not gonna lie, I love your videos, been watching you and your brother for a while but I felt like this was a video about shilling for browning. I don't mind you saying you prefer the browning but I'd have liked to see more reasons why each gun would work for more than just you (ie, the drop of the Beretta stock is better suited for cold weather shooting so the gun doesn't have to be as high up on your shoulder, I didn't see things like that, I felt like there was more reasons given for the outside shooter to choose the browning). That's just the impression I got, but I still give it a thumbs up because I like that someone is at least taking the time to do comparison videos and spend as much time as you did doing this video, and I'll keep watching your guys' videos. Best shotgun channel on UA-cam.
I have a Browning Maxus2 and never ever had issues on the other hand I have owned 3 different Beretta guns although not the extreme plus all had ejection issues and Beretta has the absolute worst customer service I will never buy a Beretta again period
I would take the Beretta anyday. Ive had very good luck with the Beretta A300 for the past 6 years, Looking forward to shooting my new A400. I guess we all pick and choose. A very well done video sir!
Knocking on 10k on my a400. 3/4 of that being target loads and I remember once so far I shot the last shell and it didn't fully eject, I had to dump the shell out of the chamber. Mine was off for me out of the box. I used one of the shims and the wedge now its perfect every time.
@@rsharpe1985just because he’s shooting at them doesn’t mean he’s hitting them lol 5000 rounds and still hasn’t limited out! lol I’m just joking around OP
@@rsharpe1985just because he’s shooting at them doesn’t mean he’s hitting them lol 5000 rounds and still hasn’t limited out! lol I’m just joking around OP
Great job. Browning seems great in a lot of ways. Reliability is huge though. In the rice fields and marsh of south Louisiana I see way more Benellis and Berettas than anything else. I shoot a Beretta 3901. It is super reliable.
I’ve been hunting with my original maxus for over 10 years now. Dunked in the marsh a few times. Thousands of rounds while hunting and at clays, not once has it failed me. And I can count on one hand how many times it’s had problem with ammo. Twice with bum reloads, once from a factory target load that had a bad/ out of round crimp and it failed to chamber.
I pick Reliability over everything else. Ergonomics can be fixed with more training and trigger can be adjusted or replaced with aftermarket version. If the gun doesn't cycle 100% it's not for me. Beretta should have been clear winner. I don't have either brands, so it doesn't matter to me.
I enjoy watching a lot of your shotgun showdown videos. I rarely comment, but want to say that I really like how you end your videos about shooting and in life only hitting the targets that you are laser focused on. Very positive and true statement to end on. Keep doing the good work!
My experience with both guns. The maxus 2 with my shooting position i was hitting my nose with my hand (keep in mind straight out of the box with no adjustments) the a400 fit perfectly with no cheek slap out of the box. I feel that the a400 is a better build.
Kick- off system of Xtreme Plus is the best in the sector. Perceived recoil on the cheek can be as claimed but it's definitely the lightest recoil on the shoulder. To be fair, t's better to try the recoils on the table as they do it for the rifle recoils. A400 XP recoil will be much less since it's heavier and it has better recoil reduction system.
I just bought a Beretta A400 Xplor that would not cycle out of the box. Called Beretta and they said it’s a 6-8 week process to even look at the gun and even suggested that I could find my own gunsmith to look at it .At my expense . A warranty is only as good as the company behind it.
Hi Robert, sorry to hear you are having issues. I would like to get my hands on an A400 Xplor and test it out. I am surprised that you are having cycling issues. Did you give it a good cleaning and use good lubricant? I love the Otis Dry lube targetfocused.link/otisdrylube If it is cleaned well my next question would be the quality of ammo. How old is the ammo and has it been stored in a cool, dry environment? Lastly, how many rounds do you have through the gun? 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
@@TargetFocusedLife We bought the gun last week and it came disassembled in the box. I did wipe it down and swabbed the bore but did not see excessive grease or lubricant and it looked good to go. I shot about 30 rounds and included several different brands (all 2 3/4, 1 1/8 oz - Winchester AA, Remington STS and Aquilla). At this point, I decided to stop shooting it until I could get the gun checked out. It would not cycle any of the rounds into the chamber and most did not eject or jammed. We carried it to the local range (Georgia Gun Club - they have a rifle and pistol indoor range as well as sales and a gunsmith). They advised sending it to the manufacturer. Beretta should get the gun today (fingers crossed). I thoroughly enjoy watching the shooting exhibitions you do. The content and quality of your videos is outstanding. Thanks for the response and I appreciate the recommendation on the lubricant - I'll give it a try.
Being a lefty, I’d pretty much narrowed my search to a Beretta A400 or Benelli SBE3. I hadn’t even thought about the Maxus until the local shop told me it could be set up to fit me for both cast and drop. Being a long time Remington shooter and preferring gas over inertia, it was pretty much down to the guns in this review. After watching these head to heads and the individual reviews of each, I have the Maxus 2 with the safety flipped and the cast shims set up for my preferred setup as a lefty…even with the downside of hulls crossing my face, the Maxus 2 just hit all the boxes, and birds, for me. Thanks for your work to get this info out there!
Nice review - thanks for the in-depth. I’m considering both guns but the shim adjustability of the a400 for your cheek issue and the cycling issue of the Maxus seems like you chose the wrong one. I’m sure you can’t go wrong either way.
Give me the Beretta all day. The maxus is a very nice shotgun, but I own a400 xtreme plus and it is awesome. It’s competition barrel puts the shot right where you put the bead
My Maxus 2 out of the box but cleaned out factory grease first as recommended by Browning ran a box of 11/8 trap loads with no problems. My old Maxus would run 1 oz loads with ease and have no doubt the 2 would run them also.Very reliable. I would put it up against any shotgun.
You really need to stop hating on the A400 extreme plus. It was obvious to me that A400 walked away from that shoot. As soon as the Browning had cycling issues. Steve A400 extreme plus is the best auto loader on the Market. Also the A400 has I believe most of their parts corrosion proof. But I could be bias because I love my A400 extreme plus. But good job my friend. Stay safe. I want to see the A 400 extreme plus against all of auto loaders on the market. But I will say the franchi Affinity is an amazing gun also
Thanks for posting, I have a Berretta A400 and I got a headache blasting at snow geese, so much so I think I may downgrade to 3 inch shells only. I also had trouble mounting it, not enough to stop me from blasting pheasants and geese, but enough to be noticeable. It is also heavy, which in waterfowl, is not that big of a deal. That being said it is still one of my favorite guns, my shoulder is never soar and I love to shoot as fast as I can. Everyone who shoots it loves it as well. (Please note I am a dude, pic is of wife)
Interesting comparison but it misses the mark. The most important factor for me is the ability to practice. I shoot trap and skeet a lot to improve my skills for shooting geese. If the gun won't cycle sporting loads then it does me little or no good. For that reason I bought a Beretta.
LOVED this review, as these are the very two guns I'm currently choosing between for my next purchase! Interestingly, a few things you liked better about the Browning I actually like better about the Beretta... for example the trigger guard size & shape and the trigger safety placement. But, I like the slightly sleeker build and looks of the Browning, as well as the weight. I'm leaning towards the Beretta, but one concern is your statement about the recoil... regarding it hitting you in the cheek, even though the KO did a good job for the shoulder. So, do you think the cheek felt recoil could be resolved by adjusting the shims that come with the gun for cant, drop etc? Thanks!
24:23 I am 6'1" and had to add the 3R cast shim to get the shot to be exactly Center on target! Both shotguns come with Spacers for LOP and Cast, so once you shoot a few patterns and find the sweet spot then you can compare one shotgun against the other?
Great reviews, but maybe just a little biased seeing that the Maxus is the older cousin of the Winchester SX4, seeing Browning and Winchester are owned by the same parent company and share most of the technology with both. Let’s see if you can pick between the Maxus 2 and the SX4??? Another great parent company comparison would be the SBE3 and A400 plus.
Thanks for the reviews. Binged watched many of them onThanksgiving night. Your videos and the comments received have convinced me to buy the Beretta A400 X+. Keep up the good work! You the Man!
Hi Steve I am consistent follower of your videos I love the way you explain I learned a lot from your videos specially about dominant eye I am thankful to your detailed explanation keep it up great work. Question I have does Bretta Extreme plus is available in wood stock I am wood stock lover.
I have been using a400 for over 8 years. Shoots straight , I love it . I was going to buy maxus at the time, but I didn’t get to find in camo. Both are great toys.
Great review, got the maxus 1 myself, did test the Beretta too. Maxus 1 has the fastest breakdown of any gun. Also you did one mistake in removing the bolt of the maxus and you lost time. Also cycling issues might occur in browning if you cycle lightish loads and you hold on pressing the trigger... Maxus 2 looks great patterns better (as maxus 1 does) but I think is the same as maxus 1 just with a screw cap for adding larger magazine.
I haven't had any problems with my maxus 2, but mine also doesn't have the fancy coatings on it. I have the vintage camo one. Cycled target loads right out of the box and has yet to jam.
I have a 1st gen Maxus Wicked Wing. Absolutely love the gun. When deciding between the 2 without ever shooting either, the deciding factor was the safety location vs the A400. I have the same preference as you. Crossbolt safety feels more natural on the back side of the trigger guard. I've even shot 1oz loads out of my 3.5" Maxus on the skeet field. Never had actual cycling issues, but about 50% of the time, the bolt doesn't lock back on the final shot.
great review! I think you should get your hands on a savage renegauge for review! not a lot on them on youtube right now and you are so thorough! keep up the good work!
Great review! I have cycling issues as well with my Maxus II... turned in to Browning with "nothing is wrong with it". Very disappointed since it was jamming about every 7-8 shots. A lot of money for this to be happening.
Buddy of mine has the wicked wings edition and has the same problems. Jamming straight out of the box. He should’ve listened when I told him to get an a400..trade it in take what you can and get an a400. You’ll never need another shotgun your whole life.
I have been looking into both shotguns and will be picking up an A400. However I did find this video which seemed to fix a jamming problem with Maxus 2. Might work for you Good luck. ua-cam.com/video/wxtSvW9VBoU/v-deo.html
I haven’t tried to shoot a Remington 1100 overhead but I’m sure it wouldn’t function because the shell has to hit the bolt release for it to cycle if I’m not mistaking so I wouldn’t say that its a test of reliability as much as it is how the shotgun is designed
Just sold my a400xtreme plus very dependable gun but just didn’t like the way it fits and feels . Too bulky feeling bought a maxus 2 and love it. Also have benelli sbe 20 and sbe 12 guage 3 inch only .
What about tunability, the shim system of the Beretta allows changing of stock drop and cast plus you can get different length pads pre fit from Beretta.. I’m no fan of gimmicky guns so my A409 has the standard stock and I love it.
question: You said that the Maxus had cycle issues when not held fast to your shoulder. Do you thing that could have been the same issue when shooting overhead? I say that because when you shot over your head the end of the gun was not held fast to anything. You were just holding it in your hands and not anchored against anything like your shoulder.
I live in another country and I'm watching you. I want to ask a question. Which one do you think is more durable and hassle-free in terms of quality and durability? Beretta A400 XP .. SBE3 .. Browning A5 .. Browning maxus. maxus 2. ???
Not faced with any such decisions about choice. Have been shooting the A400 for 9 seasons. Just added Browning Maxus II to the stable. Big blind has room for both. Maxus will be gun of choice when the Canadas slide in, the A400 for ducks
Most reviews are basically unboxings and useless commentary from someone who doesn’t shoot much. Love seeing objective reviews and comparisons by someone that has sent a lot of lead downrange and knows what to look for!
Bryce, I appreciate your feedback. Thank you for checking out the channel and subscribing. I couldn't do what I do without people like you! 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
I have the browning gold hunter wich is better than the maxus imo, also have beretta a400 extreme, being from south louisiana the extreme weather mud and humidity reliability beats ergos and what not imo and beretta is the way to go
Go with browning. Beretta if you have a warranty claim expect to not have your firearm for a minimum of 2 months they won't respond to your emails for months at a time or answer the customer service line. If you call them out they will block you from their Facebook page.
Love your video but Which gun would you recommend if I was mostly going to use it for sporting clays but also wanted a gun to wood duck and turkey hunt with in FL. Recoil is a bit of a concern for me because a shoulder issue but so is having a consistent mount between shots and when I throw it up. I usually don’t mount the gun at address when I target shoot. Also I live in FL which means it would get wet allot. Thanks
Lance, there are a lot of good options out there that would do you well. First, I would shy away from any 3.5" gun and I would stick with a 3". If you want to minimize recoil I would stick with a semi-auto gas gun. What is your ideal budget?
I don't have the maxxus but I've got an A400, an sbe3 and an A5. I've changed the shims and drop and cast on the A400 and it still punches you in the cheek. The fit of the A400 just doesn't match that of the others I have. It's heavy, not balanced as well and what he said about the grip and trigger was spot on. It just doesn't come up as natural as the others.
Could you do a review on the stoeger M3000? I am new to waterfowl hunting i am also on a budget so I’m looking for a reliable gun but not break the bank. And maybe could you suggest other brands I should look at in the same price range. Thanks!
@@TargetFocusedLife no I have not but I have heard mixed reviews and I’m scared to buy it! Should I save my money and get something better? I am also afraid of gas action guns but I would love your word on the different brands you would recommend!
A Maxus 2 is the refinement of the original Browning Maxus and demonstrates that Browning listens to their customers and potential customers. The nickel Teflon treatment and pegs in the rear of the forearm keep the forearm from getting loose and wiggling loose. Maxus 2 with a 26 inch barrel is my choice. And at 7 pounds a nice carry weight for an all around shotgun.
I too have a Browning Maxus 2 with a 26” barrel. I love it. I tested it on the skeet range. I have 100 rounds on the Skeet Range. Not a single mis fire or mis feed issues. I was shooting handloads. Remington Gun Club 2 3/4” Hull 1200 FPS. Great shooting gun.
I’d say the reliability issues with the maxus come from it being a 3.5” chamber. I had a maxus with 3” chamber and always shot 1 oz loads and it never jammed once
Yeah I feel like these are the best two guns on the market. I went back-and-forth until I just bought one of each. The Beretta when we’re sitting in the ducks and geese. If we’re going to be walking and moving I take the browning.
You give the browning way to much credit i have both, the browning was awful for reliability and beretta was just superior and all these comments below agree but great in depth video none the less
Fair review, awesome to see all the different aspects. I have had so many issues with my Browning A5 2017 model, I'm going to have to vote the Beretta A400 E+ as two of my duck hunting friends own them. I have been lucky to shoot them, excellent guns. I am just not sold on any new model firearms from Browning based on my personal experiences.
I’m a Beretta guy. Own 4 of them. Shot browning’s all my growing up and favored them in my early years. Now at 60 I lean towards the Beretta. Definitely softer shooting. No way in hell that Browning shoots softer than the A400.
Hi bud, a Beretta extreme 400. I have not shot it yet but I’m thinking about taking it back to get the brownie wicked wing. I hope they would exchange it for me. I have not shot it. It’s still in the case. What do you think?
Thanks for the great review. I was hoping Maxus 2 wouldn't have cycling issues since it looked like such a nice gun. Can you compare A400 and SBE3? SBE3 seems like it has nice ergonomics but not sure if Benelli fixed the POI issues in recent models.
If you shoot a lot of target loads, I always advocate shooting a 3" gun instead of a 3.5". Since the Maxus 2 won this showdown I compare it to the SBE3 in an upcoming video. I do plan to do some patterning videos soon. Benelli is known for shooting high and sometimes left as well. 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
@@TargetFocusedLife Thanks man looking forward to your videos. You got some of the best in-depth review. Can't wait for the patterning videos. I hope you do multiple distances (20yd, 30yd, 40yd).
Thank you for the suggestion. I was thinking about that but they are so far off in price point I am not sure if it makes sense. The SX4 is around $700-$800 and the Maxus 2 is more than 2x the price.
Havent seen the end but I'm going to wing it and state this is a 24 minute video to pick the browning he liked from the jump. Okay now I'll finish the video.
Glad I could get it done for ya! I won't be able to do all reviews that people request but I do look at all the comments and take them into consideration. Wishing you a blessed day my friend.
I shoot left handed. I wanted a Browning shotgun but they didn't have a left handed shotgun. I sent a letter to Browning about left handed guns. I received a nice letter from them, but that was all. Beretta has a A400 left handed and I been shooting that since 2018 at the range and birds
I actually prefer a gun that doesnt automatically pull up the next shell. I often switch out my first load without unloading the 2 in the tube. Once your used to it youll love the option especially if you hunt ducks and geese at the same time and carry different shot sizes
You down grade the a400 for things that can be adjusted with stock spacers and the shim kit for drop. The a400 shooting high means not enough drop - for you. That is why it hit your cheek too hard. You can easily add a different shim and give it more drop and more or less LOP to make it mount better. Sounds like the browning was just lucky that it fit you correctly out of the box. The beretta can easily be made to fit you or anyone, easily.
Good points. You certainly can change felt recoil some through the available adjustments. Thank you for the comment 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
Out of the box the a400 comes short for cold weather shooting, ie a jacket or two is your extra spacer to get a longer LOP.
Isn't this dude sponsored by Winchester who is joined at the proverbial hip with Browning. Here in North Texas we have seen several Browning's ceracoat scrape off and the steel rust. Add to the price of the Browning's stock fit that a gunsmith would charge to cut and refit. The only negative that is legit on the A400 is the weight.
@@msb2948 yes.
Yes I run my A400 short stock no spacers I grew up where everyone cut down their stocks by an inch just shoulders fast and can get down on it
Going to get the a400 Xtreme plus tomorrow. Glad to see it’s simple to break down and is reliable 👍🏻.
Plz share me price of a400 Xtreme plus???
@@ahsanaftabawan296 1699-1899
How do you like it a year later?
Exactly my points! The review was useful for me at the end! I'm also going to buy A400. NO WAY to buy something with cycling issues! EVER!
@@ahsanaftabawan296 You can get one for $1200 on PSA with the rebate.
I've been using the beretta a400 unico for years and I love it, I just bought the new version which is the extreme plus and I'm impressed already.
Greetings from Colorado!
I have 3 Beretta Xtremes in the family plus the A400 plus. No issues, between the 4 guns, we have fired thousands of rounds through them. Not one issue. With Browning firearms, I have always had problems. I have a Citori O/U, 3.5 chamber, trigger issues, I have a Browning Gold, trigger and jamming issues. I may have pointed this out to Steve in another video. I will never buy a Browning.............even if it's given to me for FREE
A handy feature that you missed mentioning in this video as well as the in depth video on the A400 is the unloading. Much safer. Rack the shell out of the chamber and then lift the loading shelf and pull out on the bolt release. Very handy in tight quarters and as I mentioned safer.
Nonetheless great videos! Adjust that beretta with the shims and you'll be in love. I had a original maxus in the past and the failures to eject had me fed up and out buying the A400 xtreme plus.
Spot on! Unloading by cycling through the chamber is old hat and not as safe as the unloading of the A400.
You can pull the rounds out of the mag tube on the maxus very easy by pushing up the lifter and then hitting the side catch for the rounds in the mag and then remove the round from chamber. At least that’s what I do.
Adjust the firearms to fit ! 🤪
Not gonna lie, I love your videos, been watching you and your brother for a while but I felt like this was a video about shilling for browning. I don't mind you saying you prefer the browning but I'd have liked to see more reasons why each gun would work for more than just you (ie, the drop of the Beretta stock is better suited for cold weather shooting so the gun doesn't have to be as high up on your shoulder, I didn't see things like that, I felt like there was more reasons given for the outside shooter to choose the browning). That's just the impression I got, but I still give it a thumbs up because I like that someone is at least taking the time to do comparison videos and spend as much time as you did doing this video, and I'll keep watching your guys' videos. Best shotgun channel on UA-cam.
Thanks for the showdown, it was informative. It was obvious to me from the start that you would choose the browning.
Ha ! I thought the same thing !
It's got to come down to reliability if the browning has cycling issues out of the box what's it going to be like 5 years down the line ??
I have a Browning Maxus2 and never ever had issues on the other hand I have owned 3 different Beretta guns although not the extreme plus all had ejection issues and Beretta has the absolute worst customer service I will never buy a Beretta again period
I would take the Beretta anyday. Ive had very good luck with the Beretta A300 for the past 6 years, Looking forward to shooting my new A400. I guess we all pick and choose. A very well done video sir!
Thanks for sharing. You are spot on. No right or wrong, just choices. I would be happy with either shotgun. 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
@@TargetFocusedLife Always. Have a great day sir
I have an A400 Upland and its a bad a$$ gun.
This channel is underrated!! Finally we get a honest gun opinion/ review!
Why Thank you - Honesty is important me! Cheers 👊🏻
Knocking on 10k on my a400. 3/4 of that being target loads and I remember once so far I shot the last shell and it didn't fully eject, I had to dump the shell out of the chamber. Mine was off for me out of the box. I used one of the shims and the wedge now its perfect every time.
A400 all the way. Shot over 5000 rounds in the past years hunting waterfowl and upland game no issues.
Man 5000 rounds y’all shoot ducks over in China?
@@rsharpe1985just because he’s shooting at them doesn’t mean he’s hitting them lol 5000 rounds and still hasn’t limited out! lol I’m just joking around OP
@@rsharpe1985just because he’s shooting at them doesn’t mean he’s hitting them lol 5000 rounds and still hasn’t limited out! lol I’m just joking around OP
Great job. Browning seems great in a lot of ways. Reliability is huge though. In the rice fields and marsh of south Louisiana I see way more Benellis and Berettas than anything else. I shoot a Beretta 3901. It is super reliable.
Best shotguns reviews ever 👍👍👍👍👍
I’ve been hunting with my original maxus for over 10 years now. Dunked in the marsh a few times. Thousands of rounds while hunting and at clays, not once has it failed me. And I can count on one hand how many times it’s had problem with ammo. Twice with bum reloads, once from a factory target load that had a bad/ out of round crimp and it failed to chamber.
I pick Reliability over everything else. Ergonomics can be fixed with more training and trigger can be adjusted or replaced with aftermarket version. If the gun doesn't cycle 100% it's not for me. Beretta should have been clear winner. I don't have either brands, so it doesn't matter to me.
Exactly 👍
I enjoy watching a lot of your shotgun showdown videos. I rarely comment, but want to say that I really like how you end your videos about shooting and in life only hitting the targets that you are laser focused on. Very positive and true statement to end on. Keep doing the good work!
Thanks for working hard on the format. Helpful demonstrations on the differences in the products.
Thanks for watching!
My experience with both guns. The maxus 2 with my shooting position i was hitting my nose with my hand (keep in mind straight out of the box with no adjustments) the a400 fit perfectly with no cheek slap out of the box. I feel that the a400 is a better build.
Kick- off system of Xtreme Plus is the best in the sector. Perceived recoil on the cheek can be as claimed but it's definitely the lightest recoil on the shoulder. To be fair, t's better to try the recoils on the table as they do it for the rifle recoils. A400 XP recoil will be much less since it's heavier and it has better recoil reduction system.
I just bought a Beretta A400 Xplor that would not cycle out of the box. Called Beretta and they said it’s a 6-8 week process to even look at the gun and even suggested that I could find my own gunsmith to look at it .At my expense . A warranty is only as good as the company behind it.
Hi Robert, sorry to hear you are having issues. I would like to get my hands on an A400 Xplor and test it out. I am surprised that you are having cycling issues. Did you give it a good cleaning and use good lubricant? I love the Otis Dry lube targetfocused.link/otisdrylube If it is cleaned well my next question would be the quality of ammo. How old is the ammo and has it been stored in a cool, dry environment? Lastly, how many rounds do you have through the gun? 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
@@TargetFocusedLife We bought the gun last week and it came disassembled in the box. I did wipe it down and swabbed the bore but did not see excessive grease or lubricant and it looked good to go. I shot about 30 rounds and included several different brands (all 2 3/4, 1 1/8 oz - Winchester AA, Remington STS and Aquilla). At this point, I decided to stop shooting it until I could get the gun checked out. It would not cycle any of the rounds into the chamber and most did not eject or jammed. We carried it to the local range (Georgia Gun Club - they have a rifle and pistol indoor range as well as sales and a gunsmith). They advised sending it to the manufacturer. Beretta should get the gun today (fingers crossed).
I thoroughly enjoy watching the shooting exhibitions you do. The content and quality of your videos is outstanding.
Thanks for the response and I appreciate the recommendation on the lubricant - I'll give it a try.
You should a showdown between the benelli SBE 3 and the beretta A400 extreme plus
Being a lefty, I’d pretty much narrowed my search to a Beretta A400 or Benelli SBE3. I hadn’t even thought about the Maxus until the local shop told me it could be set up to fit me for both cast and drop. Being a long time Remington shooter and preferring gas over inertia, it was pretty much down to the guns in this review. After watching these head to heads and the individual reviews of each, I have the Maxus 2 with the safety flipped and the cast shims set up for my preferred setup as a lefty…even with the downside of hulls crossing my face, the Maxus 2 just hit all the boxes, and birds, for me. Thanks for your work to get this info out there!
The A400 plus comes in left handed
@@justashootin5164so does the SBE3
I walked in a gun store planning to walk out with the beretta and ended up walking out with an sbe 3 and haven’t regretted it one bit yet
Benelli makes a fine shotgun. I will be releasing a shotgun showdown video of the SBE3 vs the Maxus 2 in the coming weeks.
Did you do a pattern test on your SBE3? I have read that they tent to shoot high. I'm hoping Benelli fixed the issue.
Sbe 3 is a joke
Nice review - thanks for the in-depth. I’m considering both guns but the shim adjustability of the a400 for your cheek issue and the cycling issue of the Maxus seems like you chose the wrong one. I’m sure you can’t go wrong either way.
Bro is downgrading the best shooting gun on the market and favoring a browning over the beretta this dude crazy
Give me the Beretta all day. The maxus is a very nice shotgun, but I own a400 xtreme plus and it is awesome. It’s competition barrel puts the shot right where you put the bead
My Maxus 2 out of the box but cleaned out factory grease first as recommended by Browning ran a box of 11/8 trap loads with no problems. My old Maxus would run 1 oz loads with ease and have no doubt the 2 would run them also.Very reliable. I would put it up against any shotgun.
Run it against an A400 and see which one has to get cleaned first.
@@techfowl It won’t be the Maxus. Those things are go to war reliable.
I shoot a first gen maxus, it's been ultra reliable for me too. Never had an FTE - but I shoot mine right side up.
How do you like the maxus after 1 year?
You really need to stop hating on the A400 extreme plus. It was obvious to me that A400 walked away from that shoot. As soon as the Browning had cycling issues.
Steve A400 extreme plus is the best auto loader on the Market. Also the A400 has I believe most of their parts corrosion proof.
But I could be bias because I love my A400 extreme plus. But good job my friend. Stay safe. I want to see the A 400 extreme plus against all of auto loaders on the market.
But I will say the franchi Affinity is an amazing gun also
You should have used the original chokes on both guns that's how they are built and just choose the same size chokes. 😉
Great, video, I really appreciate your honest opinion on both guns, keep up the good work.
This is a really great comparison, thank you.
Respect ✊ the most articulate, organized, and thorough gun review(s) I have ever seen on UA-cam!!! More please 🙏 respect
Well thank you so much for the kind words. I am just getting started! 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
I own 2 A400 Xtreme Plus, great waterfowl shotguns, never an issue. As long as both models cut em down, then it’s a win win.
I agree!
Thanks for posting, I have a Berretta A400 and I got a headache blasting at snow geese, so much so I think I may downgrade to 3 inch shells only. I also had trouble mounting it, not enough to stop me from blasting pheasants and geese, but enough to be noticeable. It is also heavy, which in waterfowl, is not that big of a deal. That being said it is still one of my favorite guns, my shoulder is never soar and I love to shoot as fast as I can. Everyone who shoots it loves it as well. (Please note I am a dude, pic is of wife)
Im a kid so I don't now too much but maybe try different shims and length of pull so it'll fit you right
Interesting comparison but it misses the mark. The most important factor for me is the ability to practice. I shoot trap and skeet a lot to improve my skills for shooting geese. If the gun won't cycle sporting loads then it does me little or no good. For that reason I bought a Beretta.
Hi, I purchased a Maxus 2. Which is the best choke tube for long shots with steel cartridges. Thanks
LOVED this review, as these are the very two guns I'm currently choosing between for my next purchase! Interestingly, a few things you liked better about the Browning I actually like better about the Beretta... for example the trigger guard size & shape and the trigger safety placement. But, I like the slightly sleeker build and looks of the Browning, as well as the weight. I'm leaning towards the Beretta, but one concern is your statement about the recoil... regarding it hitting you in the cheek, even though the KO did a good job for the shoulder. So, do you think the cheek felt recoil could be resolved by adjusting the shims that come with the gun for cant, drop etc? Thanks!
24:23 I am 6'1" and had to add the 3R cast shim to get the shot to be exactly Center on target!
Both shotguns come with Spacers for LOP and Cast, so once you shoot a few patterns and find the sweet spot then you can compare one shotgun against the other?
Great reviews, but maybe just a little biased seeing that the Maxus is the older cousin of the Winchester SX4, seeing Browning and Winchester are owned by the same parent company and share most of the technology with both. Let’s see if you can pick between the Maxus 2 and the SX4??? Another great parent company comparison would be the SBE3 and A400 plus.
Man these are the best shotgun reviews and head to head videos on youtube.
Well thank you so much, that means a lot! We're jest getting started 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
Extremely helpful
Looking at getting one
Thanks
Leave the drawing of circles to the professionals 😂& just keep doing what you do well: Making great gun review videos.
I like how the bolt handle comes out. My sx4 comes out like butter and has came out when snagged on layout blind door handles when opening to shoot.
I have a maxus 2 for the range and just ordered an a400 for hunting. Thx for the review
Good call, why have one when you can have both. BUT, if you could only have one, which one you taking? 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
Thanks for the reviews. Binged watched many of them onThanksgiving night. Your videos and the comments received have convinced me to buy the Beretta A400 X+. Keep up the good work! You the Man!
You really should go hold these in your hands and shoulder them before you ever make a purchase off of a Video
Hi Steve I am consistent follower of your videos I love the way you explain I learned a lot from your videos specially about dominant eye I am thankful to your detailed explanation keep it up great work. Question I have does Bretta Extreme plus is available in wood stock I am wood stock lover.
I have been using a400 for over 8 years. Shoots straight , I love it . I was going to buy maxus at the time, but I didn’t get to find in camo. Both are great toys.
Great review, got the maxus 1 myself, did test the Beretta too. Maxus 1 has the fastest breakdown of any gun. Also you did one mistake in removing the bolt of the maxus and you lost time. Also cycling issues might occur in browning if you cycle lightish loads and you hold on pressing the trigger... Maxus 2 looks great patterns better (as maxus 1 does) but I think is the same as maxus 1 just with a screw cap for adding larger magazine.
I haven't had any problems with my maxus 2, but mine also doesn't have the fancy coatings on it. I have the vintage camo one. Cycled target loads right out of the box and has yet to jam.
I have a 1st gen Maxus Wicked Wing. Absolutely love the gun. When deciding between the 2 without ever shooting either, the deciding factor was the safety location vs the A400. I have the same preference as you. Crossbolt safety feels more natural on the back side of the trigger guard. I've even shot 1oz loads out of my 3.5" Maxus on the skeet field. Never had actual cycling issues, but about 50% of the time, the bolt doesn't lock back on the final shot.
In your view which is better in term of pattern produced and soft shooting? Thanks in adv
great review! I think you should get your hands on a savage renegauge for review! not a lot on them on youtube right now and you are so thorough! keep up the good work!
Thanks for the suggestion. I have already filmed a review with the Renegauge but it will be a few weeks before it is out.
@@TargetFocusedLife NICE!! looking forward to it. have enjoyed your content for years. appreciate what you do and your outlook on life!
Great video. Thanks ! And, I shoot a Beretta A400 and love it, but realize it is not for everyone. I respect your opinion, but still love my shotgun.
Great review! I have cycling issues as well with my Maxus II... turned in to Browning with "nothing is wrong with it". Very disappointed since it was jamming about every 7-8 shots. A lot of money for this to be happening.
Buddy of mine has the wicked wings edition and has the same problems. Jamming straight out of the box. He should’ve listened when I told him to get an a400..trade it in take what you can and get an a400. You’ll never need another shotgun your whole life.
I have been looking into both shotguns and will be picking up an A400. However I did find this video which seemed to fix a jamming problem with Maxus 2. Might work for you Good luck. ua-cam.com/video/wxtSvW9VBoU/v-deo.html
I haven’t tried to shoot a Remington 1100 overhead but I’m sure it wouldn’t function because the shell has to hit the bolt release for it to cycle if I’m not mistaking so I wouldn’t say that its a test of reliability as much as it is how the shotgun is designed
Just sold my a400xtreme plus very dependable gun but just didn’t like the way it fits and feels . Too bulky feeling bought a maxus 2 and love it. Also have benelli sbe 20 and sbe 12 guage 3 inch only .
How do you like the maxus after 1 year?
Do a video of sb3 with berreta a400......
Ciao.
Quale dei 2 consiglieresti a un tuo amico?
Grazie.
What about tunability, the shim system of the Beretta allows changing of stock drop and cast plus you can get different length pads pre fit from Beretta.. I’m no fan of gimmicky guns so my A409 has the standard stock and I love it.
I would suggest using both with their factory chokes for a better representation of what the average shooter will experience. Nice video, keep it up.
But Carlson want sponsor him if he does that
question: You said that the Maxus had cycle issues when not held fast to your shoulder. Do you thing that could have been the same issue when shooting overhead? I say that because when you shot over your head the end of the gun was not held fast to anything. You were just holding it in your hands and not anchored against anything like your shoulder.
I live in another country and I'm watching you. I want to ask a question. Which one do you think is more durable and hassle-free in terms of quality and durability? Beretta A400 XP .. SBE3 .. Browning A5 .. Browning maxus. maxus 2. ???
Not faced with any such decisions about choice.
Have been shooting the A400 for 9 seasons. Just added Browning Maxus II to the stable.
Big blind has room for both. Maxus will be gun of choice when the Canadas slide in, the A400 for ducks
A400 and Maxus 2, I like the way you think!
Does the Beretta A400 also have a return spring in the stock? Because I think that's why the Maxus hangs up on over the shoulder shots
Great review,
Thanks a lot. I got A400 and like it a lot.
Most reviews are basically unboxings and useless commentary from someone who doesn’t shoot much. Love seeing objective reviews and comparisons by someone that has sent a lot of lead downrange and knows what to look for!
Bryce, I appreciate your feedback. Thank you for checking out the channel and subscribing. I couldn't do what I do without people like you! 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
I have the browning gold hunter wich is better than the maxus imo, also have beretta a400 extreme, being from south louisiana the extreme weather mud and humidity reliability beats ergos and what not imo and beretta is the way to go
Go with browning. Beretta if you have a warranty claim expect to not have your firearm for a minimum of 2 months they won't respond to your emails for months at a time or answer the customer service line. If you call them out they will block you from their Facebook page.
Love your video but Which gun would you recommend if I was mostly going to use it for sporting clays but also wanted a gun to wood duck and turkey hunt with in FL.
Recoil is a bit of a concern for me because a shoulder issue but so is having a consistent mount between shots and when I throw it up.
I usually don’t mount the gun at address when I target shoot. Also I live in FL which means it would get wet allot. Thanks
Lance, there are a lot of good options out there that would do you well. First, I would shy away from any 3.5" gun and I would stick with a 3". If you want to minimize recoil I would stick with a semi-auto gas gun. What is your ideal budget?
I don't have the maxxus but I've got an A400, an sbe3 and an A5. I've changed the shims and drop and cast on the A400 and it still punches you in the cheek. The fit of the A400 just doesn't match that of the others I have. It's heavy, not balanced as well and what he said about the grip and trigger was spot on. It just doesn't come up as natural as the others.
I just sold my a400 for the exact same reasons 4 more days maxus 2 will be here!!! #reedsoutdoors
Which gun do you prefer? Trying to decide between these 4 guns for nasty goose hunts
Wicked wing bottomlands maxus 2 is here in hand 🤯🔥💣🤯🤞 I hope it’s bomb and shoots straight
@@deadeyedail06 browning gold light 2020 10ga is my go too!!!!! With a terror tube!!
@@meclay4671 that’s just dirty talk right there
Could you do a review on the stoeger M3000? I am new to waterfowl hunting i am also on a budget so I’m looking for a reliable gun but not break the bank. And maybe could you suggest other brands I should look at in the same price range. Thanks!
Have you considered the m3500? They’re somewhat similar.
@@TargetFocusedLife no I have not but I have heard mixed reviews and I’m scared to buy it! Should I save my money and get something better? I am also afraid of gas action guns but I would love your word on the different brands you would recommend!
Nice video!!! Could you do a review of the Beretta A 300 Ultima?
Regards from Puerto Rico
Yes I can! Filmed the Ultima review this week and it should be released next week. Thanks for the suggestion.
I had the first maxus and loved the gun mostly but had repeated trigger freeze with it which never happens with my sbe 2.
Should I buy beretta extreme vs browning maxus 2, what are the pros and cons? Can you translate it into Turkish and write it?
What Camo pattern is the a400??
A Maxus 2 is the refinement of the original Browning Maxus and demonstrates that Browning listens to their customers and potential customers. The nickel Teflon treatment and pegs in the rear of the forearm keep the forearm from getting loose and wiggling loose. Maxus 2 with a 26 inch barrel is my choice. And at 7 pounds a nice carry weight for an all around shotgun.
Well said Jeffrey 👊
I too have a Browning Maxus 2 with a 26” barrel. I love it. I tested it on the skeet range. I have 100 rounds on the Skeet Range. Not a single mis fire or mis feed issues. I was shooting handloads. Remington Gun Club 2 3/4” Hull 1200 FPS. Great shooting gun.
Awesome video series! If possible could you do a review of either the weatherby element or the cz 712 both in 12ga? Keep up the great work.
I brought home a Weatherby Element for review yesterday! Thank you for the suggestions.
I had two cz1012s and they were great guns, inertia vs gas of 712 though.
I’d say the reliability issues with the maxus come from it being a 3.5” chamber. I had a maxus with 3” chamber and always shot 1 oz loads and it never jammed once
I have a 3.5 inch maxus she fires every thing no jams some people don't break them in rifht
I honestly think the different coatings on the wicked wing need a break in period, because my vintage camo maxus 2 has 0 of the issues he's having.
The A400 Xtreme Plus is chambered for 3.5
Was the a400 tested a 28 or 30” barrel?
Is that the standard maxus 2 or the wicked wing edition?
Never mind just hit the part where you answered my question lol
I know this gun is in a different price point and style but I’d love to see the Remington versa max waterfowl pro review
Thanks for the suggestion and for watching.
Yeah I feel like these are the best two guns on the market. I went back-and-forth until I just bought one of each. The Beretta when we’re sitting in the ducks and geese. If we’re going to be walking and moving I take the browning.
Can't go wrong if you have both!
kick off system has a break in period, the more shots the less recoil, plus you didnt mention the chrome lined barrel on the berretta
You give the browning way to much credit i have both, the browning was awful for reliability and beretta was just superior and all these comments below agree but great in depth video none the less
Beretta are shite
The A400 xtreme plus is 100% the superior gun
It in no way is.
Fair review, awesome to see all the different aspects. I have had so many issues with my Browning A5 2017 model, I'm going to have to vote the Beretta A400 E+ as two of my duck hunting friends own them. I have been lucky to shoot them, excellent guns. I am just not sold on any new model firearms from Browning based on my personal experiences.
I noticed you shot the browning with a carlsons choke. i wish you used the factory tube for patterning
Great video in details, keep it up.
Thanks, will do! 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
I’m a Beretta guy. Own 4 of them. Shot browning’s all my growing up and favored them in my early years. Now at 60 I lean towards the Beretta. Definitely softer shooting. No way in hell that Browning shoots softer than the A400.
What means 3 inch 3,5 inch ?? The length of the bullet ?
Xtrme plus ready out the box
Best shotgun ever made
I have an important question ¿Do You know what's the difference betwen the model a400 extreme plus to a400 lite?
Hi bud, a Beretta extreme 400. I have not shot it yet but I’m thinking about taking it back to get the brownie wicked wing. I hope they would exchange it for me. I have not shot it. It’s still in the case. What do you think?
Thanks for the great review. I was hoping Maxus 2 wouldn't have cycling issues since it looked like such a nice gun. Can you compare A400 and SBE3? SBE3 seems like it has nice ergonomics but not sure if Benelli fixed the POI issues in recent models.
If you shoot a lot of target loads, I always advocate shooting a 3" gun instead of a 3.5". Since the Maxus 2 won this showdown I compare it to the SBE3 in an upcoming video. I do plan to do some patterning videos soon. Benelli is known for shooting high and sometimes left as well. 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
@@TargetFocusedLife Thanks man looking forward to your videos. You got some of the best in-depth review. Can't wait for the patterning videos. I hope you do multiple distances (20yd, 30yd, 40yd).
Great review!
Most definitely a browning fan boy.. sad sad.. A400 recoil system is spot on....
Loves the video!! I think that you should do a challenge between the sx4 and the maxus 2.👍👍👍
Thank you for the suggestion. I was thinking about that but they are so far off in price point I am not sure if it makes sense. The SX4 is around $700-$800 and the Maxus 2 is more than 2x the price.
Thanks for your reply. But I think that the sx4 will beat the maxus 2.👍👍
Havent seen the end but I'm going to wing it and state this is a 24 minute video to pick the browning he liked from the jump. Okay now I'll finish the video.
Thanks for the review that I asked about. 👍
Glad I could get it done for ya! I won't be able to do all reviews that people request but I do look at all the comments and take them into consideration. Wishing you a blessed day my friend.
Would you be able to do a comparison between the beretta a400 xtreme plus vs the benelli super black eagle 3
I shoot left handed. I wanted a Browning shotgun but they didn't have a left handed shotgun. I sent a letter to Browning about left handed guns. I received a nice letter from them, but that was all. Beretta has a A400 left handed and I been shooting that since 2018 at the range and birds
Good job steve 👏, The review was great can you do a
Review for the browning a5 , I want to know your opinion
Great job Steve, Thank you so much, keep going you are the best.
Much appreciated 👊 Stay Target 🎯Focused (Hebrews 12:1-3)
I actually prefer a gun that doesnt automatically pull up the next shell. I often switch out my first load without unloading the 2 in the tube. Once your used to it youll love the option especially if you hunt ducks and geese at the same time and carry different shot sizes