@@amine8073 They are VERY similar thinking people. Very intelligent, same pattersns of thinking. For good and bad. Why they understand eachother so well. But also why they will never be compatible. Wow.. Girl I'm half daing right now is kind of a split image of me, why it seems like we probably aren't compatible, even though we are so alike in so many ways. Holy fuck this show man. So real.
@@amine8073good evening, Mr amine. Grammar police here. Hope you enjoyed your basketball game, because we just may see you back in court! I'm going to have to ticker you for "beggining." Had it been for Mr peanut butter, I would have let it slide, as a pun. Unfortunately, that is not the case, and you had five years, to correct it. It's going to be a very hefty fine, indeed. If you have any questions, you can speak to my supervisor Mr. Meow Meow Fuzzyface.
it's funny when mr peanutbutter says ro Diane "Now I know you don't like parties, so we will never have this argument again," and on her birthday he decided to throw her a surprise party
Yeah, even when proposing to her he says "I know you don't like big gesture and would rather have something intimate" only to unveil cameras and a party right after she says yes...
besides not growing up, Mr PB has the mentality that everything would be fine as long as everyone have as much fun as he want to have, but unlike the other dates, pickles is like his female doppleganger that just want to have fun all the time
“Why do all these idealistic, vivacious women eventually turn bitter and cruel after being with me? What’s the common denominator??” lol oh Mr Peanutbutter
the irony of diane is that in her flashback she pretended to be a party animal because she was afraid that Mr PB would get bored of her, and now they split up because he built her the belle room for the same reason, he was afraid that she get bored of him
I don’t think that was a reason for him to build the belle room. He just genuinely likes to make these big gestures to his women. Stealing the D for example
5:03 Gah, one of my favorite jokes of the episode was edited out here. After she says this line, PB thinks Pickles was quoting Sunset Boulevard (Which is a total masterpiece by the way but that's neither here nor there) but she has no idea what he's talking about, further emphasizing the awkward age barrier.
It sucks that BoJack doesn't remember Diane saying that about his show. Makes her admittance to him in series 3 episode 12 really melancholy. "How comes you never told me that before?"
@@PRATZP28 i tend to take and react to things quietly thats all. I have watched bojack 3 times going for the 4th and I saw flaws in mr peanutbutter the 4 times, he is a good soul but with no control over it, Just my opinion
@@PRATZP28 He completely disregards any sadness and tries to make up for it with money and grand gifts instead of just comforting you, that is very frustrating and annoying.
@@PRATZP28 he is annoying, because he doesn't listen, he doesn't listen he hears but he doesn't listen he isn't a bad guy but he is kinda annoying especially for some
20:27 "He is grown up." He's not tho. That's the thing. Just cause he's physically older doesn't mean he's matured. He still acts like a child. Which..is admirable, in a sense; it's hard to hold onto your innocence and carefree attitude, especially after discovering how messed up the world is. But girls don't want to date a man-child. We want guys who will challenge us to be better and who will let us challenge them in return.
@@tricksterhuaun Hmm, I don't know about that... say what you want about PB, but he doesn't come off as incel-like. Plus, isn't that the core tenet of those a**holes, that women should change? I mean, sure, they want women to change so that they fit their own ideas, that is what's messed up with them. Sorry, but I love both Diane and PB, so when someone calls PB an incel, kinda have to jump to his defense. Because here's the thing ultimately: neither of them are really in the wrong! Diane doesn't like herself, and she wants to change, and it's her right to do so, so that she can be happy with herself. PB, on the other hand, already loves himself, he's happy being who he is, and as such doesn't feel the need to change, on the contrary: if he were to change, he might loses those qualities he already love about himself, and he doesn't want that. So he doesn't really have to change, and that is just as fine. If you don't like who you are and feels the need to change, by all means do so! Meanwhile if you love who you are, feel free to remain who you are (the above statements apply under the assumption you don't hurt others in the process, obviously). That's why to me Diane and PB are both great despite being so different. The only issue is when their need/lack of needs to change is clashing with their love life. Diane shouldn't make her need to change PB's responsibility, and PB shouldn't put pressure on Diane for things to stay the same between each other. But on their own, both characters are great!
@blarf mcscarf For starters, tricksterhuaun did, or at least compared him to them. Secondly, that's, like, one of the least important thing I wrote in a 3 paragraphs comment; maybe get some focus?
@@ChevaliersEmeraude I think he was more so saying that incels need to hear the "women don't want to date an immature man-child" bit from my comment. Might help them to understand why they may struggle with finding girlfriends. Mr PB is having sex, so we already know he's not an incel at all. And yeah, he doesn't have the same mindset as incels do either. Also you said PB shouldn't have to change, and yeah you are right. However, if he doesn't, Mr PB is gunna keep struggling to find a relationship that will last. Eventually he will have to change or face ending up alone because no one will want to be with him the way he is now. The worst part is when Diane confronted Mr PB about it in that season 2 ep about her birthday (the surprise party one), Mr PB said "I'm an old dog and I won't change" (or something like that anyway). And then we see this episode and realize he was just the same in the 90s as well...20ish years before that birthday episode. It's not that he can't change. He doesn't want to. What did that one dude from Sarah Lynn's AA meeting say? "We don't change because we want to change. We change because we HAVE to change"? Something Mr PB could benefit from hearing probably..
@@xoTalim True except that, again, he doesn't have to change. Here's something about life: It's not perfect, for anyone. And yes, maybe PB's antics get at odds with his love life, but also, maybe that's the price of his own happiness. It's not like he's really lonely either: Diane and him lasted 10 years after all. And if he does change, he might end up being unhappy with himself, like Diane and Bojack are. We can also take another character as an exemple here, with Todd. That dude is probably even more childish and immature than PB. He's also extremely comfortable with himself. Yet this season, 2 women wanted him to be something he's not: Yolanda wanted him to be this ambitious businessman, and he's not. And Emily hoped their relationship could get sexual, but that won't happen either. Todd, like PB, is someone who is happy with who he is, and as childish as he may be, he doesn't need to change, and he knows changing for someone else would make him unhappy. He'd rather be alone and happy and, one day, maybe, find someone who'll love him for the childish asexual guy that he is. I guess in short my point is this: don't try to change for others. Ultimately, that will only make you unhappy. Only change for yourself, if you are already unhappy with yourself. Your life will never be perfect, maybe it will affect your love life, your job, but as long as you are happy with yourself, one can handle those life imperfections.
Andrew Kear Mr. Peanutbutter is very much Question Hound, the “This is fine” dog. He buries his head in the sand and convinces himself that everything is fine, even as everything is falling apart around him. Just look at how he avoided his brother when he was sick. He also tends to be emotionally neglectful when it comes to his wives. For instance, even if they’re not having fun at parties, he ditches them to hang with other people while ignoring their needs. He even keeps throwing the Halloween party at Bojack’s house without his consent.
@@andrewkear5639 I think one of the first scenes of Mr PB sums up really well his character : - Hi Bojack ! how are you doing ? - Well I've been a bit... - Yeah ? living the dream ? I want to TALK TO YOU. Erica ! I think he does care for the people around him, but doesn't want to talk about negative things. He knows Bojack has problems (he said it himself to Todd), he knows Diane doesn't like parties and big gestures (he said it to her when proposing right before showing a hidden surprise party) but he keeps ignoring these feelings. Maybe he thinks that if you keep ignoring your problems they will disappear...
Yeah I hate that some people don't seem to realize how shitty he can be. Whenever he does something bad, it's just turned into a joke and so he gets a pass. But when one of the other characters messes up, they instantly get so much shit for it. The point of this show is that ALL of the characters do shitty things at one point or another. None of them are just good or bad people. They all mess up and they all have the potential to be better.
This is the only episode that outright shows us the downside of PB. Everything else like the surprise party for Diane, the stolen D, going ahead with fracking, etc. is left up to interpretation and could easily be flipped around to PB being on top again. This one episode, on the other hand, is pretty clear cut.
Reminds me of the scene where PB crashes into his accountant's mailbox and physically forces his accountant into his car, taking him away from his son. He even says something along the lines of "Everything is going to be great, as it always is..from my perspective."
@@blueproxy this so happens in real life. Like some people have certain charm that if they do something shitty or so it gets a pass and then if someone else does it it's the worst
Hi, so I wanna talk about that one scene from 10:34 to 10:50 . Last week, I saw a lot of anti-Diane comments due to her "move" in the script. But that little, 16 seconds talk here, it illustrates exactly why I think she was right. The whole thing is her trying to get him to open up. About anything, really. Like the death of his mom for exemple. And I do recall a scene where he's like "you're not even here so we can talk about my mother", and she said "so, do you want to talk about your mother", and he said no. And he basically stole her therapy sessions from her, and for no reason either, as he basically ran away from his own sessions right after that. So yeah, basically, she tried a lot, last week and for the rest of the season really, to get him to open up. She tried playing nice about it, too, but without success, so she really had to force it on him, too, hence the script she wrote. Now, that scene at 10:34 here shows that even that didn't work, but the point is, she's trying to do something right with Bojack, and even the script was a part of that. That's just the level of messed-up Bojack is, in the end.
Apparently Jessica Biel thought that the writers weren't being mean enough to her after her first appearance! She told them to not hold back for her subsequent appearances, and boy did they not hold back.
My absolute favorite part of this episode is when the transition from Diane young saying she doesn't want to leave to older Diane Screaming to the party "I wanna leave" She really grew into herself
the cracks have been there looooooooooooong before this episode, but I think this is the first time they tried to make it obvious. mabey the creators where getting sick of fans not getting it.
tarnim and I don’t agree with the last sentence. I think the writers were purposely being subtle because I honestly didn’t see it until S2 when he and Diane had the fight at the party at their house. Also when he ignored Diane on the fracking and ruined their home. I think the writers wanted us to see him as good that’s why his selfishness and self absorbedness is masked as positivity. He’s happy as long as things are going his way and if they’re not he’ll ignore it and act like they are going his way. It took me 3 whole seasons to see that and I think it was intentional.
It was always obvious (at least to me) don't get me wrong I always liked Mr.Peanutbutter but I was naive blind enough to think he was "perfect". I'm both surprised and not surprised that so many people are fooled so easily by him.
Way back to his proposal in season 1 you could see his flaws. He told Diane that he knew she didnt like big gestures so their proposal was going to be intimate and after she says yes, he reveals cameras and a surprise party. There's also all those times he asked people like Bojack how they are and when they are going to open up, he gets distracted by Erica
10:50 i never noticed these girls robbing him lmao I remember them from the color of their bikinis. I remember thinking "God damn i'd kill for a shirt that color"
9:13 why are you surprised? The first name is Mister and the last name is Peanutbutter... We saw this on the episode where they travels to mister Peanutbutter brother. The Kids were running and screaming mister mister...
@@MarshallLeeA Well it's more like the video audio is slightly earlier than the auido on their TV. If they were playing at the same exact time, there would be no echo, just like there wasn't an echo in any of the previous reactions.
@@MarshallLeeA yeah but i don't think i heard it in other episodes. I don't think there's much to do about it either since I think its not about what is done in post but how the microphone is positioned and stuff
If, after this episode, these guys STILL don’t understand that Mr. PB isnt flawless and that his relationships ended because HE’S the problem, then I don’t understand what they aren’t getting.
I love the fact that Bojack tells his party guests at the end every year to come back next Halloween but he just doesn't remember cause he ends up getting shit faced every time that's such a Hollywoo party animal lifestyle thing to do.
Amelia Earhart sure is a big influence to Princess Caroline; this being Bojack Horseman however, means she'll probably disappear piloting a plane in the series finale.
Love that at least one Normie usually gets the reference but all seemed to miss the Dazed and Confused one! (which was brilliant, even down to the hand gesture)!
11:15 a dead soul told me to exspast - what does it mean? Ouija board with the ghosts on Halloween with mr. Peanut butter whos entire episode is a Ghosts of Christmas Past type deal when he refers to his wives as the tennis balls and chains. So the ghosts reference is just an ex’s past Past mistakes present moment future and the ideas of isolation/making bad choices
Guys thank you for reacting to this show, it's awesome ! You should consider reacting to "master of none" by Aziz Ansari, I was surprised by how much I loved it ! Keep it up anyway !
Can't wait for you to get too Episode 11, my favorite episode of Season 5! My 2nd Favorite is for sure : Free Churro And my 3rd favorite is : The Amelia Earhurt Story... But Lighbulb Scene episode is also a fantastic episode! Ugh entire Season is a Masterpiece! Same goes for Season 4.
Bojack se entera del fallecimiento de su papá, entra y todos se habían ido (la soledad del artista rodeado de gente desconocida) y quien se queda con él? Todd, siempre Todd.
Its 15:00 Birdy get it . Do you get it . I need to know that you got it you know ? the movie Birdy and this is a Bird doing the famous poster pose you got it right ? goood Tell me that you got it though
Normies totally Britta'd the community reaction today. They are the worst. They are the Jim Belushi of youtube channels. They are the opposite of batman.
Why doesn't Nahid go peeing before you hit record? He is like a little girl, nervous that he wouldn't last the next half an hour without peeing. Come on, man! :D
Mr. Peanutbutter is flawed. He's stubborn and dense and inmature. But all his wives knew this when they met him. Especially Diane. So they are both responsible for the failed marriage. But mostly Diane.
Diane knew when she met Mr PB that he was stubborn and wouldn't be willing to change/try to become less toxic? That's a stretch. Why blame Diane almost entirely?
My favorite moment from this episode is Bojack instantly understanding Diane's costume
same , they unerstand eachother from the very beggining
@@amine8073 They are VERY similar thinking people. Very intelligent, same pattersns of thinking. For good and bad. Why they understand eachother so well. But also why they will never be compatible. Wow.. Girl I'm half daing right now is kind of a split image of me, why it seems like we probably aren't compatible, even though we are so alike in so many ways. Holy fuck this show man. So real.
@@Schmidteren Okay, half of your message I do not understand at all.
Really shows how much BoJack and Diane understand each other.
@@amine8073good evening, Mr amine. Grammar police here. Hope you enjoyed your basketball game, because we just may see you back in court!
I'm going to have to ticker you for "beggining." Had it been for Mr peanut butter, I would have let it slide, as a pun. Unfortunately, that is not the case, and you had five years, to correct it. It's going to be a very hefty fine, indeed. If you have any questions, you can speak to my supervisor Mr. Meow Meow Fuzzyface.
it's funny when mr peanutbutter says ro Diane "Now I know you don't like parties, so we will never have this argument again," and on her birthday he decided to throw her a surprise party
It is more like he is showing that he wants to evade conflict.
Yeah, even when proposing to her he says "I know you don't like big gesture and would rather have something intimate" only to unveil cameras and a party right after she says yes...
And on their proposal, after telling her he was not going to make it a big celebration
besides not growing up, Mr PB has the mentality that everything would be fine as long as everyone have as much fun as he want to have, but unlike the other dates, pickles is like his female doppleganger that just want to have fun all the time
“Why do all these idealistic, vivacious women eventually turn bitter and cruel after being with me? What’s the common denominator??”
lol oh Mr Peanutbutter
the irony of diane is that in her flashback she pretended to be a party animal because she was afraid that Mr PB would get bored of her, and now they split up because he built her the belle room for the same reason, he was afraid that she get bored of him
They ultimately split because their personalities were too different.
@@growingoaks i know, diane got sick of his manchild attitude
I don’t think that was a reason for him to build the belle room. He just genuinely likes to make these big gestures to his women. Stealing the D for example
5:03 Gah, one of my favorite jokes of the episode was edited out here. After she says this line, PB thinks Pickles was quoting Sunset Boulevard (Which is a total masterpiece by the way but that's neither here nor there) but she has no idea what he's talking about, further emphasizing the awkward age barrier.
You know BoJack Horseman is gold when they can make even a Halloween episode depressing.
I mean... to be fair, Halloween is horror based, so that traditionally includes depressing or disturbing scenes.
It sucks that BoJack doesn't remember Diane saying that about his show. Makes her admittance to him in series 3 episode 12 really melancholy.
"How comes you never told me that before?"
Now it makes sense why Surj keeps taking Mr. Peanutbutter’s side, because he is Mr. Peanutbutter.
Annoying af
@@KAZPER5 mr. Peanut butter is good boy who just want to have fun n want other to have fun too
If that's annoying then idk
@@PRATZP28 i tend to take and react to things quietly thats all.
I have watched bojack 3 times going for the 4th and I saw flaws in mr peanutbutter the 4 times, he is a good soul but with no control over it, Just my opinion
@@PRATZP28 He completely disregards any sadness and tries to make up for it with money and grand gifts instead of just comforting you, that is very frustrating and annoying.
@@PRATZP28 he is annoying, because he doesn't listen, he doesn't listen he hears but he doesn't listen he isn't a bad guy but he is kinda annoying especially for some
Bojack not realizing he's still in costume is one of my favorite moments in the episode...
I love when he goes to buy painkillers in the costume and gets accused of being a cop.
Becomes darker and darker
20:27 "He is grown up."
He's not tho. That's the thing. Just cause he's physically older doesn't mean he's matured. He still acts like a child. Which..is admirable, in a sense; it's hard to hold onto your innocence and carefree attitude, especially after discovering how messed up the world is. But girls don't want to date a man-child. We want guys who will challenge us to be better and who will let us challenge them in return.
Man. Incels should learn this lesson.
@@tricksterhuaun Hmm, I don't know about that... say what you want about PB, but he doesn't come off as incel-like. Plus, isn't that the core tenet of those a**holes, that women should change? I mean, sure, they want women to change so that they fit their own ideas, that is what's messed up with them.
Sorry, but I love both Diane and PB, so when someone calls PB an incel, kinda have to jump to his defense. Because here's the thing ultimately: neither of them are really in the wrong! Diane doesn't like herself, and she wants to change, and it's her right to do so, so that she can be happy with herself. PB, on the other hand, already loves himself, he's happy being who he is, and as such doesn't feel the need to change, on the contrary: if he were to change, he might loses those qualities he already love about himself, and he doesn't want that. So he doesn't really have to change, and that is just as fine.
If you don't like who you are and feels the need to change, by all means do so! Meanwhile if you love who you are, feel free to remain who you are (the above statements apply under the assumption you don't hurt others in the process, obviously). That's why to me Diane and PB are both great despite being so different. The only issue is when their need/lack of needs to change is clashing with their love life. Diane shouldn't make her need to change PB's responsibility, and PB shouldn't put pressure on Diane for things to stay the same between each other. But on their own, both characters are great!
@blarf mcscarf For starters, tricksterhuaun did, or at least compared him to them. Secondly, that's, like, one of the least important thing I wrote in a 3 paragraphs comment; maybe get some focus?
@@ChevaliersEmeraude I think he was more so saying that incels need to hear the "women don't want to date an immature man-child" bit from my comment. Might help them to understand why they may struggle with finding girlfriends. Mr PB is having sex, so we already know he's not an incel at all. And yeah, he doesn't have the same mindset as incels do either.
Also you said PB shouldn't have to change, and yeah you are right. However, if he doesn't, Mr PB is gunna keep struggling to find a relationship that will last. Eventually he will have to change or face ending up alone because no one will want to be with him the way he is now.
The worst part is when Diane confronted Mr PB about it in that season 2 ep about her birthday (the surprise party one), Mr PB said "I'm an old dog and I won't change" (or something like that anyway). And then we see this episode and realize he was just the same in the 90s as well...20ish years before that birthday episode. It's not that he can't change. He doesn't want to. What did that one dude from Sarah Lynn's AA meeting say? "We don't change because we want to change. We change because we HAVE to change"? Something Mr PB could benefit from hearing probably..
@@xoTalim True except that, again, he doesn't have to change. Here's something about life: It's not perfect, for anyone. And yes, maybe PB's antics get at odds with his love life, but also, maybe that's the price of his own happiness. It's not like he's really lonely either: Diane and him lasted 10 years after all. And if he does change, he might end up being unhappy with himself, like Diane and Bojack are. We can also take another character as an exemple here, with Todd. That dude is probably even more childish and immature than PB. He's also extremely comfortable with himself. Yet this season, 2 women wanted him to be something he's not: Yolanda wanted him to be this ambitious businessman, and he's not. And Emily hoped their relationship could get sexual, but that won't happen either. Todd, like PB, is someone who is happy with who he is, and as childish as he may be, he doesn't need to change, and he knows changing for someone else would make him unhappy. He'd rather be alone and happy and, one day, maybe, find someone who'll love him for the childish asexual guy that he is.
I guess in short my point is this: don't try to change for others. Ultimately, that will only make you unhappy. Only change for yourself, if you are already unhappy with yourself. Your life will never be perfect, maybe it will affect your love life, your job, but as long as you are happy with yourself, one can handle those life imperfections.
Mr Penautbutter is flawed. Don't let his endearing charm hide that.
I think the broken people around him rubbed up off him tbh...
Andrew Kear Diane ultimately made him the worst version of himself
But every one of his exes knew exactly who he was when they married him. Its not his fault that they want him to change..
Andrew Kear Mr. Peanutbutter is very much Question Hound, the “This is fine” dog. He buries his head in the sand and convinces himself that everything is fine, even as everything is falling apart around him. Just look at how he avoided his brother when he was sick. He also tends to be emotionally neglectful when it comes to his wives. For instance, even if they’re not having fun at parties, he ditches them to hang with other people while ignoring their needs. He even keeps throwing the Halloween party at Bojack’s house without his consent.
@@andrewkear5639 I think one of the first scenes of Mr PB sums up really well his character :
- Hi Bojack ! how are you doing ?
- Well I've been a bit...
- Yeah ? living the dream ? I want to TALK TO YOU. Erica !
I think he does care for the people around him, but doesn't want to talk about negative things. He knows Bojack has problems (he said it himself to Todd), he knows Diane doesn't like parties and big gestures (he said it to her when proposing right before showing a hidden surprise party) but he keeps ignoring these feelings. Maybe he thinks that if you keep ignoring your problems they will disappear...
Any episode that exposes Mr. Peanutbutter is good in my book.
Yeah I hate that some people don't seem to realize how shitty he can be. Whenever he does something bad, it's just turned into a joke and so he gets a pass. But when one of the other characters messes up, they instantly get so much shit for it. The point of this show is that ALL of the characters do shitty things at one point or another. None of them are just good or bad people. They all mess up and they all have the potential to be better.
This is the only episode that outright shows us the downside of PB. Everything else like the surprise party for Diane, the stolen D, going ahead with fracking, etc. is left up to interpretation and could easily be flipped around to PB being on top again.
This one episode, on the other hand, is pretty clear cut.
Reminds me of the scene where PB crashes into his accountant's mailbox and physically forces his accountant into his car, taking him away from his son. He even says something along the lines of "Everything is going to be great, as it always is..from my perspective."
@@jaedenbaker4611 i literally forgot that happened as im sure everyone else has too.
@@blueproxy this so happens in real life. Like some people have certain charm that if they do something shitty or so it gets a pass and then if someone else does it it's the worst
bojack just didn't wanted to go to Mr PB's first party, but Mr PB basicly invaded his home, now bojack just throws the party as an excuse to get drunk
like he needs an excuse to get drunk lol
Mr. PB was always nuanced. I don't know how anyone could think he's a perfect character...
Hi, so I wanna talk about that one scene from 10:34 to 10:50 . Last week, I saw a lot of anti-Diane comments due to her "move" in the script. But that little, 16 seconds talk here, it illustrates exactly why I think she was right. The whole thing is her trying to get him to open up. About anything, really. Like the death of his mom for exemple. And I do recall a scene where he's like "you're not even here so we can talk about my mother", and she said "so, do you want to talk about your mother", and he said no. And he basically stole her therapy sessions from her, and for no reason either, as he basically ran away from his own sessions right after that. So yeah, basically, she tried a lot, last week and for the rest of the season really, to get him to open up. She tried playing nice about it, too, but without success, so she really had to force it on him, too, hence the script she wrote. Now, that scene at 10:34 here shows that even that didn't work, but the point is, she's trying to do something right with Bojack, and even the script was a part of that. That's just the level of messed-up Bojack is, in the end.
Yep! I don't think people understood this. It's hard to understand that a likable person can be this disfunctional
Apparently Jessica Biel thought that the writers weren't being mean enough to her after her first appearance! She told them to not hold back for her subsequent appearances, and boy did they not hold back.
My absolute favorite part of this episode is when the transition from Diane young saying she doesn't want to leave to older Diane Screaming to the party "I wanna leave" She really grew into herself
The fact that Pickles is the exact age I am makes me cringe.
same. 93 baby here too
'94 baby here
95 baby here
03 baby here
96 baby here
This is really where you start to see the cracks in Mr. Peanutbutter.
the cracks have been there looooooooooooong before this episode, but I think this is the first time they tried to make it obvious. mabey the creators where getting sick of fans not getting it.
@@tarnim80 Fair point but I think this where it's the most blatant.
tarnim and I don’t agree with the last sentence. I think the writers were purposely being subtle because I honestly didn’t see it until S2 when he and Diane had the fight at the party at their house. Also when he ignored Diane on the fracking and ruined their home. I think the writers wanted us to see him as good that’s why his selfishness and self absorbedness is masked as positivity. He’s happy as long as things are going his way and if they’re not he’ll ignore it and act like they are going his way. It took me 3 whole seasons to see that and I think it was intentional.
It was always obvious (at least to me) don't get me wrong I always liked Mr.Peanutbutter but I was naive blind enough to think he was "perfect". I'm both surprised and not surprised that so many people are fooled so easily by him.
Way back to his proposal in season 1 you could see his flaws.
He told Diane that he knew she didnt like big gestures so their proposal was going to be intimate and after she says yes, he reveals cameras and a surprise party.
There's also all those times he asked people like Bojack how they are and when they are going to open up, he gets distracted by Erica
10:50 i never noticed these girls robbing him lmao I remember them from the color of their bikinis. I remember thinking "God damn i'd kill for a shirt that color"
Just had an operation and watching these videos really makes me feel like I’m chilling with you guys. Thanks for your content and keep it up guys👍🏼
The Raw Truth plot twist he performed the surgery
Hussain Attarwala 😂 I wish
Brent Pilgrim hope you experience least pain and the problem is solved!
9:13 why are you surprised? The first name is Mister and the last name is Peanutbutter... We saw this on the episode where they travels to mister Peanutbutter brother.
The Kids were running and screaming mister mister...
Same with Princess Carolyn like when she corrected Rutabaga to use her full name
The sound is kinda messed up so it sounds like demons but otherr than that its cool
Sounds like the ghost effect from the Haunted Mansion
Not exactly messed up, they played the audio in the room and also on the video they show, so it has an echo
@@MarshallLeeA Well it's more like the video audio is slightly earlier than the auido on their TV. If they were playing at the same exact time, there would be no echo, just like there wasn't an echo in any of the previous reactions.
@@MarshallLeeA yeah but i don't think i heard it in other episodes. I don't think there's much to do about it either since I think its not about what is done in post but how the microphone is positioned and stuff
If, after this episode, these guys STILL don’t understand that Mr. PB isnt flawless and that his relationships ended because HE’S the problem, then I don’t understand what they aren’t getting.
I love the fact that Bojack tells his party guests at the end every year to come back next Halloween but he just doesn't remember cause he ends up getting shit faced every time that's such a Hollywoo party animal lifestyle thing to do.
i love this episode lol, it's like a different kind of depressing
Diane being confident and just trying to leave is just too funny for me, probably more funny than it should be.
Amelia Earhart sure is a big influence to Princess Caroline; this being Bojack Horseman however, means she'll probably disappear piloting a plane in the series finale.
Nah, it'll be metaphorical.
She'll lose herself while trying to live out her dream of being a mother.
8:34 the simultaneous groan is on point.
I dont think i can remember the last time i watched a video where Nahid did not go to the bathroom right at the start just after starting to record.
The sad thing I realized is that the Halloween party with Gina was the last party Bojack will ever accidentally host.
I mean mr peanut butter can host them and doesn’t he live with him now?
22:26 FBI OPEN UP
Underated Epsiode
soo everyone missed the dazed and confused reference at 15:38
13:14 The sheep wearing pijamas and with the numbers 1, 2, 3
Love that at least one Normie usually gets the reference but all seemed to miss the Dazed and Confused one! (which was brilliant, even down to the hand gesture)!
8:30 Coincidentally, this was also the year I WAS born. 😂
4:29 The bigger the expectation, the bigger the disappointment.
Anyone notice the girl with the red bathing suit and "Handmaid's Tale" bonnet in the background at 8:26?
11:15 a dead soul told me to exspast - what does it mean?
Ouija board with the ghosts on Halloween with mr. Peanut butter whos entire episode is a Ghosts of Christmas Past type deal when he refers to his wives as the tennis balls and chains. So the ghosts reference is just an ex’s past
Past mistakes present moment future and the ideas of isolation/making bad choices
I just realised.. I'm Mr Peanutbutter at all those parties... WOOOSH... :O Realization explotion in my head.
"his females" lol whenever a guy refers to women as "females" I cringe a little
In Spanish is so funny
Diane: Me ire en el helicóptero de este pendejo .
OMG, I just noticed the Handmaid's Tale costume.
Can't believe mr peanutbutter is 50+
You missed the robbers from the Telescope at 9:24! I didn't even notice that on my first viewing.
Suraj is like a train station and all the ladies come and go one by one.
"Wait, Did you say a duel??!"
11:26 sounds especially demonic lol
Guys thank you for reacting to this show, it's awesome ! You should consider reacting to "master of none" by Aziz Ansari, I was surprised by how much I loved it ! Keep it up anyway !
Lmao I love the dating stories! Couldn't stop laughing
13:06 Todd dabbing
Can't wait for you to get too Episode 11, my favorite episode of Season 5!
My 2nd Favorite is for sure : Free Churro
And my 3rd favorite is : The Amelia Earhurt Story... But Lighbulb Scene episode is also a fantastic episode! Ugh entire Season is a Masterpiece! Same goes for Season 4.
When’s the community episode coming out today?
Bojack se entera del fallecimiento de su papá, entra y todos se habían ido (la soledad del artista rodeado de gente desconocida) y quien se queda con él? Todd, siempre Todd.
Its 15:00 Birdy get it . Do you get it . I need to know that you got it
you know ? the movie Birdy
and this is a Bird doing the famous poster pose
you got it right ? goood
Tell me that you got it though
5:54 lmao steve harrington
Where's Community???
How did you guys miss the lost joke in this episode?!
guess it was lost on them
Im late- but since they are watching this episode...i feel like im the first- so pumped.
What's that beat that goes on at 8:50
I think the audio of the show and the TV aren't synced up properly.
I feel you Suraj and Mr.PB 😅
Community reaction or we riot!
the next episode is really good, it has some very depressing moments though
Halloween in January
I love the normies. Y'all are awesome 😊
Community?
Lololololol, Nahid is too awesome.
.... the echo in this episode
Did they get the mathew macconaughey reference?
Demons are whispering in my ear...
Am I Fuckin... G High??? 😕🙄🤔
its weird cuz i was born in 93 too...
it would be sick if you guys reacted to The seven deadly sins! (its on netflix btw and you can find it online!)
Normies totally Britta'd the community reaction today. They are the worst. They are the Jim Belushi of youtube channels. They are the opposite of batman.
Where's this week Community episode??
What up with the audio?
Why doesn't Nahid go peeing before you hit record? He is like a little girl, nervous that he wouldn't last the next half an hour without peeing. Come on, man! :D
WHERE'S COMMUNITY MY HOMIE
wheres the community reaction
React to Doom Patrol
*5×7...
Yay finally!
ME AND SURAJ MATCHED ON TINDER!!! ❤️
AND I OOP-
No reaction to the Simpsons credits homage? ;D
8:19 😂
Mr. Peanutbutter is flawed. He's stubborn and dense and inmature. But all his wives knew this when they met him. Especially Diane. So they are both responsible for the failed marriage. But mostly Diane.
Diane knew when she met Mr PB that he was stubborn and wouldn't be willing to change/try to become less toxic? That's a stretch. Why blame Diane almost entirely?
No community?
I keep wanting Diane to get a win but she pisses me off too much for it to last.
hey make a holi video ......and happy holi btw
The only bojack episode I dont like
Where's Community?