Religion, Science and Education - Pervez Hoodbhoy - Theoretical Physicist - TPE
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- Pervez Hoodbhoy has a PhD in Nuclear Physics from MIT. He was recently removed from FC college because he was told he did not meet their academic standards.
Dr. Hoodbhoy comes on The Pakistan Experience to discuss why he was removed, how our education system is rotting at the core and his thoughts about mixing religion and education. Dr. Hoodbhoy ends the podcast by remembering Dr. Abdus Salam.
The Pakistan Experience is a podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan, and Pakistanis, through the lost art of conversation.
Dr Hoodbhoy is inspiring many through his resilience and by staying local.
His academic credentials are a dream come true for many. God bless him and keep him safe!
I have been a great admirer of Dr. Hoodbhoy and have followed his talks on UA-cam for a long time . It is such a pity how a great Pakistani, a patriot, a scientist and a voice of reason is being treated. It was heartening to see the young interviewer ask good and intelligent questions and his comment at the very end that there were many people who thought the world of Dr. Hoodbhoy. I hope you all become a force to be reckoned with in the future and bring Pakistan back to its senses. If the Indian government was smart enough, it would offer Dr. Hoodbhoy a professorship in one of its top research universities. It might be just wishful thinking at present, as this might endanger his life given the politics of Pakistan.
One of the most amazing teachers from whom I had the privilege of studying Physics. His passion for teaching and expanding the minds of the youth is so prominent in each of his lectures. Really hate what he has to go through in Pakistan whereas in any othe foreign country he would have been treated with the utmost respect he deserves.
Lucky
@@DWAGON1818 science and physics can categorically advance human condition, quality of living, health and pretty much everything necessary for a human to survive happily with minimal effort and convenience. What does religion provide but hatered?.
@@DWAGON1818 not reality just an illusion and fear namely hell and heaven
Whatever Dr. Hoodbhoy says is like a rain of nectar.
The guy left a plush job in America just to teach pakistanis , sometimes I think we don't deserve anything here
Notwithstanding anyone’s noble intent and sacrifice let’s be clear- no one owes him anything if he cane of his own accord. If he thinks he’s owed it’s called a savior complex.
“ Plush job in America “ 😂 only Pakistanis think that any job in US is a “ Plush job”
pLuSh jOb iN AmEriCa, Hum ghareebon par ehsan karney agaye Sahab.
Ihtesham Tawakkal waha log second shift me bartan dho rahay hotay hain inhe yaha lagta ki waha sirf “ Plush jobs “ hoti hai 😆
@@kashmir1892 professor in MIT is not a plush job?
Thank you Shehzad for this amazing podcast 🙏❤
Great to hear you sir...
Love U from India
I recently discovered Dr Hoodboy Sb by Moroo’s podcast. N i am feeling blessed and lucky! He is such a extreme knowledgable person. Learning alot from him.
Amazing interview great work Shehzad! Keep on going, needless to say Dr. Hoodbhoy was as informative as always. However, listening to his commentary on current and/or future of Pakistani society is just scary! I mean there is just darkness!
Dr Abdus Salam was my father's cousin. Unfortunately I had not been able to tell that to a lot of people while I was living in Pakistan for all the obvious reasons 😪
We don't deserve such gems like Dr abdussalam
And its very unfortunate
@@sidrakanwal2126 true
@@malikShoaib-fj6fj I would have given my life for a chance to meet Dr.Abdus Salam
@@shahvez184 well you can just "give your life" and "meet him"
thanks for inviting Dr. hoodbhoy. next time please also invite Dr. Taimur rehman
Great interview man!! Try to get him for 2 hours next time :D
@@ThePakistanExperience YESS completely understandable. Will be waiting for the next episode!!
ua-cam.com/video/SJXWhXHOoA0/v-deo.html
جناب پروفیسر پرویز ھود بھائی
یہ ہمارے ملک کی خوش قسمتی ہے کہ ہمارے ملک میں ابھی تک سچ بولنے والے لوگ موجود ہیں جو کہ ملک و قوم کا درد رکھتے ہیں اور اس منافق معاشرے اپنی بات کہتے رہتے ہیں
شکریہ سر
Love you sir from india
Inspiration for all student ...
Sir aaj v student lagta hain..
I think dr Hoodbhoy is a genius and an invaluable asset for Pakistan and the world. We must appoint him chairman HEC to take benefit of his potential. Allah taala bless him.
Waooo Hoodboy !!!! Thanks for inviting him
Great Hoodbhoy, struggling to spread the light of knowledge.
Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy is a first rate Physics instructor. He knows his subject inside out. Moreover, his assessment of the rotten academic grid is correct.
However, it is foolish to project him as some sort of a polymath. He doesn't have the necessary familiarity with domains he usually trespasses on various fora.
Certainly, he is knowledgeable but not wise.
Although there is plenty in this very clip to demonstrate the validity of the aforementioned observation, let us just stick with the following two instances:
16:34 - 17:00 (
Dr. Pretentious Hoodbhoy is used to sidetracking like this, ua-cam.com/video/FDFuKhRmPJo/v-deo.html - just like this young student explores his cherry-picked bizarre arguments, Dr Sahab is known to do that a lot, and I think it only damages students, which sort of makes sense with the institute telling him that he does not meet their academic standards.
@@Detective501 When you earn 4 degrees from MIT including a PhD, come back here & feel free to be as ostentatious...
Well, now that we have your stamp of approval & your judgement, all is good in the world once again...lol
I hve always followed Pervez Hoodbhoy and I like his opinions on history and religion. The only difference between Pakistani Islam and Hinduism is that hindus can without fear say that they are atheist, which pakistani muslims dare not say. Pakistan will not make progress to their potential unless they restrict their religion to their homes. Even if you believe God or not, giving too much importance to religion smacks of getting vise like control over the gullible followers.
As a child and teenager growing up in Pakistan in the late 1970's and early 1980's, I saw the mess brought about by Zia Ul Haq. Also, for some reason, I had absolutely NO INTEREST in religion/Islam. This stuff bored me to death and put me to sleep! Yet, in order to survive, one becomes a compulsive "munafiq/mulhid" on the inside, but on the outside, one goes through the rituals and motions, oft repeating "mashallah," "alumdullilah," and so forth, all for show. I am so happy to have left that wretched system behind decades ago.
One of the very few sane personalities in Pakistan…… ❤ Dr Hoodbhoy ❤️
Dr hoodboy sir good evening, jaihind. I m a great admirer of u.i can understand your felling for Pakistan Betterment.pak govt should use his expertise in framing education policy.
Of all freedoms one may lose, freedom of expression is the hardest.
Pervez Hoodbhoy is a living legend.
خوش قسمت ہیں وہ لوگ جس کو آپ جیسے استاد میسر ہیں سدا سلامت رہو ❤
I'm an admirer of this excellent person from the other side of the border. I would request the anchor , that please honor such persons properly while addressing them. It's not Mr. , it's Dr. Hoodbhoy
کاش کہ کچھ ایسے لوگ پاکستان میں اور بھی پیدا ہو جائیں.
Prof Hoodbhoy is a highly educated and sensible person. He is wasting his time in Pakistan. He should go back to the US where his talent and knowledge will be utilised.
ھُودبھائی ملک و قوم کا ایک بہترین سرمایۂ ھیں اللہ انھیں سلامت رکھے. آمین
He is a great great man and I love him. Huge respect sir
What would you say about this verse of the Holy Quran? "What, now! When previously you rebelled and were one of the corrupters? Today we will preserve your body so you can be a Sign for people who come after you. Surely many people are heedless of Our Signs.” [10:91-92]. There is great debate as to the identity of the Pharoah in the time of Musa (عليه السلام) with some identifying him as Merneptah. However, most of the evidence backed up by verses of the Holy Quran point towards him being Rameses II. The Quran and the Bible [Exodus 14:21-30 and Exodus 15:19-21] state that the Pharaoh was drowned in the sea. However, the Qur’an differs from the Bible and it makes a very unique statement that the body of the drowned Pharaoh was saved as a sign for future generations. The Quranic statement about rescuing Pharaoh’s body would be in total agreement with the fact that the body of Rameses II has survived in a mummified form. It was discovered in 1881 among a group of royal mummies that had been removed from their original tombs for fear of theft. Priests of the 21st Dynasty had reburied them in a cache at Deir al-Bahari on Luxor’s west bank. Nothing whatsoever was known at the time of the revelation of the Quran about the mummy of Rameses II. Where did this knowledge come from?
I whole heartedly agree with Xyz
@psl 5 , they will continue to defy the truth no matter what.
@Xyz You need to read the Quran and Modern Science by Dr. Maurice Bucaille www.whyislam.org/on-faith/the-quran-and-modern-science-3/
Dr pervez hoodbhoy has four degrees from MIT, why he is not eligible in FCC, I am also in FCC as employee,he is very humble personality, I met him so many times,
When he is already serving at QU and served at LUMS, he doesn't need to be eligible for FCC because FCC isn't bigger than LUMS or QU.
@@tirichmirinfotainmenttv6482 Dr sb has already left LUMS, and FCC. Dr sb was retired from his service in 2011, but he served there further two years as a visiting faculty, after that he joined LUMS, but terminated due to monapolee .
Pervez Hoodbhoy----- man with biggest ball in Pakistan. A true humanist. Anyway please don't speak like this discussion. You may be humiliated, assaulted in Pakistan.
Good luck Sir. Love and respect from India.
this man is a pure gem. Bravest person I have ever seen!
I luv and respect this man 🙏
Ik how haters find a way to hate on this great legend but this wont undermine what sir hoodboy stands for
He should be made minister of education with full powers.
ھندوستان کا بنا لو
@@TajamalGhumman q bhi
Mazak hai koi.. qualified log thodey hi banaye jatey hain. Koi sifarshi ya unpadh ho toh banatey hai., humarey India mein toh yahi hota hai..:-)
@@sibghatmansoor5125
یہ پروفیسر تو فزکس کا ھے اور فزکس میں اس نے کوئی کارنامہ نیی کیا۔۔۔لیکن مذہب اور سوشل مسائل پر ٹانگ اڑانا اپنا حق سمجھتا ھے
Islam's Contribution to Science -- Responding to Pakistani Atheist Pervez Hoodbhoy ua-cam.com/video/wCDWqsyLtuA/v-deo.html
If, I had been a. PM Pakistan,i would have been honoured as Dr Hoodboyz as a president of Pakistan like APJ Kalam of India.
Dr Pervez is a great scientist in Pakistan. He is a good human being.
We love you sir. You have great knowledge about Physics. Really amazing person you are.
Great respect from India.
You are most welcome in India sir.
I would request students and teachers of pakistan to protest and strike against this
Allah ap ke hafazat Kare (Ameen) !!!
Allah is the protector of everyone, even of atheists like Hoodbhoy.
Where is Shafqat Mahmood , the minister of education of Pakistan ? What does he think about this situation ?
It is one small question always arises in my mind about Quranic interstellar travelling; what kind of energy propulsion emitted from the backside of Burak space shuttle? Why it is not defined / explained in any Quranic Verse? Can any Muslim scholar explain it?
Respect for Dr Parvez
Thank you.
Pervez Hoodbhoy is good and great and talks sense.
Nice to hear Mr. Hoodbhoy.
If possible please sir upload some lectures for the intermediate physics, solid base is necessary, mostly professors don't have commond
An eye opening, amazing experience. All the respect.
Very good sir parveez hood bhai
It seems as if the interviewer knows nothing about Hoodbhoy from the nature of his questions
The thumbnail is made in Canva. Good work 👍
Great mind Hoodbhoy.
Hood bhoy should not stay in Pakistan,Pakistani ordinary people dont deserve to get services of this great human being and such a extra intelligent person
"Most people probably don't know you as a Nuclear Physicist, not even as a theoretical physicist, they probably know you for your socio-economic opinions."
Yeah! This should tell you a lot about Dr. Sahab.
The only discovery made by Pakistani “ Scientists “ is that it is molvis who are responsible for not being able to make any Scientific discovery .. Ab koi inse kahay ki bhai molvis have studied religion and its you who have studied Science hence you were supposed to make new discoveries
Reality is that Pakistani “ Scientific “ community has no shining star who has earned global reputation on the basis of his/her work ( there are a few names here and there but no one can be classified as a “ shining star” ) ,but they have discovered a wonderful way to earn cheap fame and deflect all criticism regarding their own incompetence -they hound poor molvis for not doing what they were supposed to do - but the questions arises that if molvis are supposed to make make Scientific Discoveries what are these “ Scientists “ supposed to do ?
@@kashmir1892 Exactly the thing, I wish Pakistanis understood that these people are only deflecting responsibilities that fall upon them and in that people consider them some kind of polymath geniuses who knows everything and have figured the root of the problem when in truth these people themselves are part of the problem.
ua-cam.com/video/iUNPq5qn3U0/v-deo.html
@@Detective501 that also tells a lot aboit the people of pakistan, if you do not know him as nuclear physicist....
جب تک مذہب اور ملا، رہے گا سائنس اس، ملک میں ترقی نہیں کر سکتی۔
Assalamualaikum Sir plz agr ho sakty to jis tara ap na calculas ki video series start ki thi ishe tara. Maths or physics ka b or subject s ki series banaein ta k hum us sa fiada hasil kr sakein or jo chezan hum nai seekh saky wo ap ki badolat seek lein .admin ho saky to mere ya request sir tk pnch dena
Shukriya
Please please never try to explain agnostic to a person who thinks there is never anything beyond god and religion.
Love you sir and air.
Great scholar I love him
You are so wrong mr.Hoodbhoy,unlike the 'aasmani kitabs' of the abrahamic religions Geeta was written by human and there are many Geetas.As far as Vedas are concerned it used to be recited by the rishis and later Ved Vyasa wrote it.Do not mix the abrahamic scams with Sanatan Dharma
another religious person defending their religion. Theres no proof of anything mentioned in geeta.
thank you for bringing him for an episode. always a pleasure to hear him.
Love Dr Hoodboyz.
Great Great Sir . You are our Proud
Pakistan is wasting an intellectual gem like him.
بالکل درست۔۔۔ہمارا تعلیی نظام ناقص ہے۔۔۔
i disagree
You are the light of the my life
Really a very impressive talk with Dr. Sahab
He . Is. Right. !!! Uniformity. In. Education. Would. Be. A. Sad. Mistake. !!! Diversity. In. Education. Is. The. Fertile. Ground. That. Gives. Birth. To. Intelligent. Unprejudiced. People. !!!
پروفیسر ہود بھائی ۔ بلکل درست فرمایا۔
V love to search n listen him.
Keeping in mind the 'pakistan' Hood buoy is brave in saying black and white .
GREAT!!!!
Dr, hoodbhoy have a 10000000 years.
Great podcast shehzad👍👍👍👍😍😍
Group ma kisi ka pas hood bhoy ka cell number ho tu baray meharbani send kardigea
I graduated from a public university in Karachi , worked for sometime there and left Pakistan the first chance I could get. About 80% of my batch mates did the same. Young people in my friends and family circle are doing the same , getting out of there the first chance they come across to Middle East , North America or who ever will offer them greener pastures. At times I wonder what kind of talent chooses or is forced to stay back in Pakistan and why.
@Shahzad , please do a podcast on this brain drain Pakistan is experiencing and the vacuum it has created there.
Oh my God i just love this guy
Sirs,if religion is handled,the rest will follow.
Sir you have resigned, now where are you sir???
Shehzad good argument: Quran needed to learn not just to study in Universities.
What I wouldn't do to have a teacher like Ammar Ali Jan and Mr Pervaiz Hoodbhoy..Pakistan doesn't give a rat's ass about the sanctity of education.
13:55 omg i hate this so much. Like right now all dear faithful Muslims are waiting for atheists/scientists/liberals/Christians/non-muslims to develop a vaccine so that they can protect themselves from Covid. And when something gets invented ir discovered we come up with yeh to 1400 saal pehlay hmaray nabi nain btaya tha. Aray bhai if you had that head start to 1400 saal sai khamosh kyun bethay thay ap. ughhh
Hahaha so true
Be careful logic is not welcomed here lolol
Nobody from muslims is waiting for atheists/liberals/christians/non muslims to develop a vaccine , the only ppl who are eagerly waiting are muslim “ Scientists” because as soon as any non-muslim will develop the vaccine they will pounce upon Molvis and grill them for not being able to make the Vaccine , contemporary Muslim “ Scientists” have very little real work to show , most make a living by blaming Poor Molvis for something that they were supposed to do
@@kashmir1892 Almost everyone (creationists and atheists alike) who doesn't believe that Covid is a hoax is waiting for the vaccine.
It is painfully true that research is not a thing in Pakistan be it science or religion or history or anything. Majority of us studies to become salaried employees.
I wasn't even thinking of Molvis or ulamaa. Generally whenever there is a discovery my social media fills up with how it was always known to us. That is just unfair. We should give credit where it is due. Also sometimes the discovery changes, scientists find that they were mistaken... what happens to the claim of knowing it all along... that makes us look like a joke. A bad one at that.
@@tinkapatosi1314 Well, I think it was Turkish-German who created the vaccine.
Fantastic interview. Just a suggestion, may be it's better to stick to a single language when interviewing. That helps continue the flow. Cheers. :)
Dr. Is highly qualified , experienced n with back ground of noble family.
The Admn in FC is very junior team n they do not v capacity to accommodate such a heavy potential personality.
Great teacher
Ahh these 31mins were sukoon to my ears, eyes and heart.
I have read his books , he is better Muslim or in general HUMAN than all Molvis, Priests and Pandits combined in Pakistan. He is right, If every science is in Bible, Quran or Gita, why didn't any Molvi , Priest or any Pandit discovered gravity, laws of motion or medical procedures. All they do is giving you taveez , that is their medicine. C'mon people should grow up. Not, ever intellectual should be discarded as Anti-religion.
Muslims were Caliph of Half world.. Still Non Muslims are afraid of Muslims.. Non Muslims Fail at the end and Now want to eliminate our Imaan With Such Statements..Imaan pei qaim raho dosto warna bht Sakht azaab hah akhirat mei
Uncle houd looking hero
Great Sir
Islam 1400 years ago talked about the Motion of Earth and Moon. when did science discover it..... Can you answer it?
Why are we giving so much importance to Hoodboy who did nothing for science in Pakistan, his role is just to criticise everything including Islam. Can you tell me his achievements related to his contributions in the development of Science and Technology??
You hate him just because he critices islam or religion.
I hate when he is forced to identify himself as a marxist in the interview. The irony is that he is a sacrificing patriot, bearing such high level of thought and insights that would hardly going down the esophageal pipe of a state for now. The state shall always pretend to remain ever wanting of sorts just for its selfish motives at the bigwigs level. Pakistan is likely to go down to the dogs in the next 15 years until and unless starts introspecting itself and pay heed to someone like Dr. Hoodbhoy et al.
I can just say lagay rahoo sir ji
Please have Mohammad Hanif Sahab on as well.
@10:00:
Logic can't prove the origination of the laws. I think he hasn't read the works of Avicenna
@13:00
100% agree with that statement.
@14:00
That was a very ignorant response from and at that point I didn't find it interesting to go ahead and watch the whole thing as I have read better pseudo/modern atheist such as Dawkins and Hitchens and more sophisticated athiests such as Chomsky. So in that regards listening to someone who will only repeat what they say is a waste.
We don't deserve him,just like we didn't deserve Amer Iqbal.
Pakistani should follow his wisdom. But unfortunately he is being ignored.
I remember his one interview in which he was invited alongside Dr Ansar Parvez (Chairman PAEC) at that time. He had raised some serious questions on Pakistan building nuclear power plants near Karachi. He was totally destroyed by that guy who gave logical answers to all his reservations. But the problem is, mostly this guy is on a campaign regarding socioeconomic issues. He is never in a debate with other scientists and fools common people with his so called science. He should teach science and facts not rhetoric