I believe Faf de Klerk said it best : we may not be the best 33 individual players, but as a team we compliment each other and work for each other. That is what team sport is about.
I don’t think there has ever been a team that is more “squad” focused then this SA team. Even the way the bench is viewed and used is completely different. SA has changed rugby from a 15 man game to a 30 man game. That’s the biggest innovation this team has brought. Great video Tim! As always.
We were forced to as we had to play effectively five finals in a row at huge intensity for each game. As a starting team this was not the GOAT (prolly NZ 2011), but as a squad with sheer depth that was able to play five high intensity games week after week on the trot we were GOAT.
There is something that no one is commenting on...(during the world cup tornament .. the AB couch told the world that springboks play boring type of rugby game..we were heavily challenge by that...and his own team too...to show who comes on top.. you'll be the judge)
Tim, you actually brought tears to my eyes. At times we do feel that the rugby world is against us, for whatever reason they have. To have someone like you making the comments that you do is heart warming to say the least. A massive thank you from South Africa 🇿🇦
Not the rugby world - just the shysters who run World Rugby and in particular its Executive Committee: Bill Beaumont (Chairman) John Jeffrey (Vice-Chair) Mark Alexander Bart Campbell Su Carty Lord Mervyn Davies Bob Latham Ada Milby Brett Robinson Angela Ruggiero Jonathan Webb Alan Gilpin (CEO) Only one of these members is a South African. The rest are drawn from the UK, Australia and Ireland and represent the sides that emanate from those parts of the world. The fact that SA has the same number of representatives as the US is beyond absurd. It would be equivalent to including only one representative of Germany or Brazil on FIFA but having three South Africans as well. These are the people who steer the ship and they're as corrupt as the people who run FIFA. I'm glad they snub SA. It's a badge of honour.
@@davesmith826which of these people specifically is corrupt since you have taken great effort to name them? Let’s see if you have the balls to not remain silent
@@Bokgat The list is available on the World Rugby website. It took no 'great effort' to name them. They're corrupt because they preside over an organisation that doesn't represent the rugby family. The recent World Cup was held in France, not South Africa, despite France holding the comp ten years earlier and despite South Africa being chosen as the recommended host in a lengthy report that was subsequently abandoned. The recent 'team of the year' contained one South African and ten players from teams that didn't even make it out the quarter finals. The coach of the year is an Englishman who may have taken his side on an eighteen-match unbeaten streak but also cost them the World Cup by not rotating in the group stages. The list goes on, but I can't be bothered to continue populating it. Your attempt to goad me with a reference to 'having the balls' made me laugh. A real man calls someone out to his face, not on the interweb.
The way Siya ran over to Cheslin and embraced him in a massive man hug as the final whistle blew says everything you need to know about the way he cares for his team - each on individually! He just ran straight for the man who was hurting most just a second ago and lifted him up and celebrated. I wouldn't be surprised if he had done the same thing if they had lost.
Yes, that was another special moment from Siya. He is the best Captain at this level, and should have been in the dream team based on his skills, his comeback from major injury in such a short time and his humility as a captain who really cares for each of his team mates.
@@cosmic_diver Just thinking of a framouse Wales Capt creaming INSULTS (AND BACKED UP BY HIS COACH) at 1/2 time and looking at Siya and Cheslin tells enough of what GREAT captains are made off (and coaches)
As a kiwi, I'm conflicted year to year the all blacks are more consistent, but South Africa since returning to world rugby in the 90,s have. been better performers at rwc level, but you have to take your hats off to the bokkes
A large factor in it is what Rassie said a couple years back, (to paraphrase, since I can't remember the exact quote, but it basically along the lines of), "The only thing the Springboks care about are the World Cups, and every test match inbetween the World Cups are little more than preparation and testing in preparation for the world cup, and we don't mind or really care if we lose a couple test matches while trying different combinations and tactics". Can't remember the exact quote, but it was basically along those lines. The only thing the boks care about are RWCs
I'd say we choked, but we only at 14 players on the field for 60 minutes..and we dominated the second half....congrats to the spring boks, but best team ever, give me a break.
@@boomdiada.9009never been prouder of teams loss but fuck me some of those calls were a joke. Cards should be given for intentional foul play or repeated infringement not because an attacking player switch direction on a team and catches you out of position even siya card was ridiculous.... ufc fighters get punched in the head for 15-25mins but god forbid getting a shoulder to the head which has a bit more padding than thin gloves. World rugby will kill the game with these bullshit rules they bring in. If players want to stay safe don't play a physical game
I’m a Wales fan and follow France as a second team. When the boks beat France in the quarters I was ambivalent about them but full of respect. I then, for the first time I can remember, supported them when the final came around. And you said it. It is their teamwork and self belief that is so impressive. Along with great coaching. I thought the substitution of Libbock was a master stroke. Won that game for SA. I also now understand the trauma on the faces of SA when they were beaten by Japan IN 2015. The RWC is everything to them. Well, hats off - and look forward to seeing you in Cardiff next time!
That loss against Japan brought the country to a halt, it was like the country mourned for a week. haha But we know how NZ feels we've been there its hard but that sets the tone for the next one
England 2003 got me into rugby. I can name the entire 22. They ran a fantastic WC campaign. Springboks play for a higher purpose. It's for the people. It's for the struggle. World Rugby struggled to put that into their template of awards.
What is so amazing about this team had the all blacks gone for the poles instead of the line they would of won France was unlucky England nearly beat us so what's so special about this team I think the worst of all world squads ever scrum was pushed around
Thank you Tim!! As a South African who had to witness the relentless bashing of our team throughout the competition, this is just so much appreciated. Yes we are resilient as a nation and our rugby team is the epitome of who we are as a nation. This touched the ❤
these Bokke may not be the best players, they're maybe not playing the "sexiest" rugby but they're the team that can scrap and fight and drag a result out of every game no matter what. They're the ultimate knockouts team with the greatest captain of all time.
This Boks team deserves a lot more credit than what they get. We’ve seen top class international teams over the years but this team is exceptionally special both on and off the field. Full respect for what they have achieved 🙌🙌
I will definitely agree with you Tim, As a South Africans we've witnessed this team grow, as a Nation we grew with the team... They certainly are the Greatest. Most of these players came out harsh circumstances, Cheslin only started playing Rugby at the age of 16 after his school noticed how fast he is. Some players like Siya came from rural beginnings bare foot, food for once or twice a week. The team has soul, that is what speaks to people, people can relate, As you say if you're a real rugby fan you will spot the difference. Honestly I am grateful that the world can see what South Africa went through every rugby match in terms of critics, it's only now that the west notice what we've been saying for decades. This formed the mental strength you witness today, they are so good at blocking out the noise that nothing phased them. Thanks for seeing us, I enjoyed the journey with you. 🇿🇦
Lived there in 1976/8, great rugby then. Great team now but I think a great team in a financially stable country is better than a great team in a destroyed, corrupt South Africa of today. 4 Rand to the pound then, over 20 now even though it’s propped up. Now I will wait for the chinless liberals to attack my comments…..
The luckiest team of all time. They lost to Ireland, and scrape three wins largely due to refereeing inadequacies. Kolbie's charge down was illegal, the first penalty against England was clearly not a penalty and NZ went down to 14 before they could beat them, just. And with World Rugby disgraceful treatment of Tom Curry, it has left a bitter taste in mine and many others mouths. It seems that WR have taken up with the critical race theory, that preaches only white people can be racist.
Hi Tim. I’m a 78 year old grandmother. I have so enjoyed your commentaries. You’ve helped me understand so many aspects of the game. I just love how fair you are in your comments. I am one very proud South African. My love & gratitude to our Springbok team for bringing the sunshine in.
To have used a sport so synonymous with apartheid to unite a nation is a tremendous feat and perhaps explains to non South Africans how important rugby is to us. Thanks Tim.
It also sheds light on how wise and far-sighted Nelson Mandela was. Without his endorsement, The Boks would never have become the inspirational force they are.
This team encapsulates the best of South Africa - brotherhood, faith, perseverance and joy. It has reminded us of our roots of Ubuntu - 'I am what I am because of who we all are" and who we can be when we stand together. Their ethos: 'the sum is better than individuals' and their undying committment to give 100%, in my albeit biased viewpoint, makes them the G.O.A.T. Thank you Tim for the depth your understanding about the Springboks and South Africa!
I've been following your work since you began your YT channel Tim. What's brought me back everytime was your lack of bias, knowledge, professionalism and passion for the game delivered in a manner that one cannot help but be drawn to. Please continue your excellent work. I really appreciate you. Thank you for your kind words with regards to our Boks. It means so much to us🙏💚💛🇿🇦
Tim it has been an absolute joy to have shared your amazing coverage across all the games and all the teams during this world cup. No bias, no flogging sacred cows, just balance and great information. You have made it a pleasure to participate from afar. Thank you
Exactly & that’s why their wins mean so much more. Barnes’ RWC 2011 final was THE worst, the French were robbed due to dodgy calls & Barnes folding under the (national) pressure. Every single SA player gave it their all to topple champion teams week after week. Siya Kolisi player of the tournament (imho) what a 💯% humble, inspirational leader🎉🎉😘 And Ardie Savea as a Samoan leader & player on the field…absolute inspiring❤
@@aughalough1don't mean anything as we are the champions... World rankings also don't mean nothing but since Ireland fans were so cocky. You not #1 anymore 😭🤣
Hi Tim thank you for your great channel, I am a Scotsman living I SA since 1963, I have become a loyal South African and have supported the Boks for as long as I can remember I agree they are the goat
There is something about the Springboks team that wins in spite of every reason why they shouldn't. But I think you summed it up perfectly: as a TEAM, the Springboks are perhaps the best of all time. There are much better individual players concentrated elsewhere but hot damn do they have a ghastly willpower and determination and team spirit. Also, Kwagga Smith.
One more comment: Thank you for your kind words about our country and recognizing the difference and hope this team has brought to us. I was 9 years old when I watched the 1995 final... the buildup to that was something else! As a child I hardly understood the significance of the 1994 election, though my parents were very much for the New South Africa. I did obviously see the massive inequality all around me and even as a child that struck me as really broken. After the 94 election South Africa got a new Anthem (which I think is the best in the world), but during the 95 tournament we also got a kind of second anthem in the song "Shozaloza" which was sung at every game. I have a strong memory of this song being sung in church on a Sunday morning. A song in Zulu and Ndebele sung by an all-white church choir on a Sunday morning only one year after apartheid officially ended. Something different was in the air. On Saturday evening I joined a few thousand people at a local shopping mall to watch the game on a big screen in the food court. Being part of a crowd of all races and ages all packed in pretty much shoulder to shoulder and all cheering and screaming and dancing (and lots of holding our breath) was pure joy! I'm rambling... I have too many thoughts and not enough time or skill... I am just thankful for the wonderful changes that have indeed happened in our country even if we are daily plagued with a hundred problems.
The new South Africa has never delivered the delusional peace and prosperity liberals claimed. The election might have been a big step for democracy but it’s ultimately been a destructive for the country. Even Kolisi said nothing is going right. That’s purely down to appalling corrupt governance.
I'll be humble as a South African and say those 2011-2015 AB's were completely untouchable both during and outside the World Cups. They were also filled with absolute legends of the game. Still very proud of our Boys!
@@wlk2408That’s true but you can only beat the teams that are in front of you. We did that but so did those AB’s and of the top teams in the ‘15 WC who they didn’t play, who’s betting against the AB’s if they did play?
Finally we have someone beginning to understand what our much loved, admired Springboks are all about. It is not a team its a FAMILY. GREAT show keep up the great work 👍
There is only one thing that makes me sad about this amazing team: Many will not be there anymore during the next WC. But I guess this is how legends are made :) Thank you boys for all the incredible emotions I had during this 2 months... I was lucky enough to see them playing 2 of the best ever games in Paris... If only I was South African!
South Africa is just awesome... I am not South African, however I lived in Cape Town for a while under "less nice" times... Great people there! Where Rugby is a religion 😊
Based on today's rankings, SA (ranked 1) had to play: No. 2 Ireland No. 3 New Zealand No. 4 France No. 5 England Honestly, that's a feat of note and I take what you're saying about the team being the "GOAT" - the 2023 team is definitely better than the sum of their parts! And the parts are pretty damn spectacular too! Seriously impressed and proud South African - our boys will become and remain legends of SA rugby!
No. 6 Scotland bro they no a bad team. Playing five of the top Six teams in the world. It is unheard of in any sport. Name any sport where that has happened I will wait
Great video Tim. The collective is more important than the individual. Between them and 2015 Nz it's close I will say I do believe Rassie can now be regarded as the greatest coach of all time...👌
What's his overall win percentage start to finish? What's in the trophy cabinet outside of world cups? Has he achieved a single unbeaten tour of the NH? There's levels. Steve Hansen's numbers would put every other international coach to shame, Rassie included
@@benjamindewes2345 Nope only one, he was appointed after the 2011 win. He got a 3rd place in 2019. Being assistant coach does not count in this regard. Btw I found your hat, here you go!
Undoubtedly the best RWC 2023 vlogger/blogger; impartial, objective, intuitive and insightful. All reviews are well put together with a neutral approach. Awesome!
Dear Tim, you should see how our nation welcomed the Boks at OR Tambo airport. We as a nation is so united and this will not go away. The Springboks led by example on how a country can be winners...only if by1 point.... how profound. I am quite emotional today and yes a new leader for our country is imminent in my opinion because we the people will choose and not by crooked elections. Thank you for your beautiful channel. ❤
This team is really special. An amazing group of guys. Beating the best French team of all time in QF in one of the greatest games ever. Finding a way to beat England despite struggling and looking dead in the water with 8mins to go. Beating the AB in the final again with 1 point.....their mental stength and brotherhood togetherness is what makes them the most beloved Bok team ever. I have never seen this kind of love for any Bok team. The 2007 team probably the best tbh, but this team the most special. The 2015 AB side arguably the best ever.
The only thing I would do to that "Dream Team" is to take Eben out. Our Springboks are the "DREAM TEAM". We beat the best to be the best. Thanks for the quality content as always Tim. Can't wait for more.
I can only talk for myself but I believed in this team from the start of this world cup. When we lost vs Ireland, I was not worried. I never doubted them vs France. I believed that we would take the win against England even while we were so far down. I believed throughout the Finals, even taking into account that Barret might have put that shot at goal over. Don't get me wrong, I expected tough battles (which we got, through and through) , but If a team can make me believe like this, I must consider them for the G.O.A.Ts. I would like to know what the experience was like for the ABs 2011/15 fans. And finally, thank you so much for your content and insight, Tim. It is very much appreciated!
From a kiwi perspective, it was heartbreaking knowing the final was there to be won, and we just couldn't get there, but in having said that if we couldn't win we are glad it wasn't the irish or the French in fact the bokkes were the only team we could be happy for and I think that's because our nation's share such a huge rivalry when it comes to rugby, so we as a nation are not so sad,more so just happy if we couldn't win it , atleast SA could
Tim bud ..your absolute understanding and admiration for this Springbok team makes us so proud to be South African ,to be acknowledged by your honest and objective channel..Your channel and I watch many, has fast become a channel of rugby knowledge , unbias and class with great presentation, subject matter using excellent language not slander to make educated points of interest.. Kudos to you ..keep it going bud its a rare talent and will put you in good stead going forward as this channel grows from strength to strength to sponsors..
Spot on Tim! I couldn't agree more with you. In an age where individualism is usually more valued than collective effort, SA showed the way and is a beacon of hope for not only the sport of rugby but for their country as well. I had the opportunity to enjoy an afternoon amongst SA fans in Paris before going to the semifinal vs England and all I can say is I was amazed at what I experienced! Respect, Unity, Joy and Pride for their country...hats off to the Springboks class of '23....best in class
As a South African, I must admit we don't have the most skilful players like the 2015 AB's. No McCaw's, Carters or Nonu's, but this Springbok side showed the world how to play with your heart. Most of the Boks in this team was nobody's or quotas once, and Rassie and Jacques made something out of them. Today, we can proudly say that The Springboks are the best in the World. Thanks Tim for all the work you have done during the RWC. Respect brother!!!
Wrong, we do. It's just not something the coaches have wanted us to showcase in the playoffs, rather brute force and defense. Ox has crazy offload skills, so speak Snyman. Pollard is an attacking flyhalf who loves running the ball himself. He almost scored a try in the final doing what he likes, making hard runs into contact. Eben has good offloading. Faf has superb passing range. We have loads of skills but defense wins World Cups
As a kiwi i reckon this is without a doubt the greatest ever world cup victory as they did it the hard way playing all the best teams. No other world cup victory compares and i suspect they will be a good chance to go for a three peat in 4 years. In saying that i think as far as pure statistics for winning games and dominance between and during world cups the 2011 - 2015 ABs team is superior. This current boks team is great though, no doubt about it!!
You have to admit, the springboks are the greatest team in world cup history. They already became the best world cup team in 2019 in history because their win percentage was already greater than the ABs in 2019
Bok fan here and I have to agree with you about your 2010-2015 team, they were top drawer, but the Springboks have now become what the ABs have always been a symbol of national unity, as Tim said it was a symbol of division and now the team is truly a mixture and the black support is huge now. I think the rest of the Rugby world needs to beware, the Boks may not manage a third World Cup in a row in 2027, but I think there will be such a crop of outstanding young black players (inspired by Kolisi) coming through that the 2031 will likely be won by SA. If that happens the production line gusher will open wide. That said the AB v Boks games are always the game for either side. Respect!
@@jadenphilander8799proof is in the pudding and they have the most world cups so thembeing the greatedt world cup nation goes without saying. The boks are world cup specialists. Just look at how many rugby championships or tri nations they have won since rugby became pro. Quite incredibale how they manage to pull it together for 6-8 week period every 4 years.
Tim, so good to see you still pumping out WC videos. I’m having withdrawal symptoms. I’m loving watching your channel grow. We need to start a go fund me to get you to Australia in 2027 to bring us more coverage. Great to see you continuing your good work 🇮🇪☘️
Thanks Tim you really summed it up very well in an objective manner. As a South African, I listened to many games as a child over the radio at 5 in the morning against the All Blacks .. I am now 69 years and TV has spoilt us. For many years, the 1974 British Lions was the best for me, then 2015 AB and now this team. I was at quarter finals in Paris and it was just a game I will never forgot - my son of 37 years called it already a bucket list experience ! So my dear friend keep this chats going and when there is excellence point it out please. Take care
As a grown man I sit in tears of joy hearing your comparison of a 70's South African Rugby jersey to the one we get to witness today. Thank you for that, Tim.
@@plutoniumnitrate1201need to take into account how the laws have changed, how the game has changed, how its reffed etc. Actually not realistic to try say what would happen if they played each other. They were a great team with a great record. Only thing I'd say with certainty is that this was the toughest world cup to win in the history of world cups, with the route the boks had to take
You are correct in emphasizing TEAM! That's precisely it. I read many articles and listened to many pundits saying that taking Manie, Eben, and Siya off during the England game was brutal and embarrassing. Except that's not how the Boks see it, they all buy completely into the concept of "Team first, always!" Their moto is #StrongerTogether It's pretty simple, really.
Probably the single best Video I have watched on UA-cam this year... As a South African 🇿🇦 I could not have been prouder of our team. This Springbok team has shown everyone, what we as South Africans can achieve if we can just put politics aside, and work for the greater good of our fellow countrymen. These players are all heroes in my eyes, and listening to you (Tim) in this video, it brought a few tears in my eyes, cause every word you said is true, and add to that the history and the stories behind each of the players in this Bok team, and you will have even more respect for them. Just like I have a world of respect for you and the videos you have posted during the world cup. Thanks for that. Ps, if you can find it, look for a series called "Chasing the Sun" it's about the 2019 bok squad. I'd love to hear your view on that. Thanks for brilliant non-bias fair and very high quality commentary throughout the WC. Between you and a guy from Nzl called 2cents I have found faith in journalism again. Thank you again and I have subscribed and will be looking out for future content 😊
Agreed, it was also apparent when the Blitzbokke were winning lots of tournaments, individuals rarely appeared as most tries scored, most points scored ... and Cheslin and Kwagga were two of them. And the Blitzboks defense was legendary ... that demands trust and commitment ... two of the main characteristics of an elite TEAM.
Thank you Tim this is why we love your channel. Always showing respect, truth, love and neutrality. This bok team from 2019 till now are one of the greatest. 2x World Cups, 1x B&I Lions, 1x Rugby Championship.
I am an ex South African now living in Australia. I was following you throughout the world cup. I want to credit you on your knowledge of rugby and the passionate way you talk about it. Your summary of the great 2023 Springbok cup team was amazing. Keep up the good work. 👍
Would like to thank you for your unbiased commentary. Been watching your podcast throughout the worldcup. I would agree that given the road that the boks travelled in the WC. No-one has ever done. SA have won back to back not in there home country. NZ did it back to back at home. SA won a Lions tour plus 2 world cups with this team. No question the team is the G.O.A.T
That run is seared into my brain. That run is the one of the reasons I wanted AB’s to beat Ireland and the fact it’s 17 and not more is why I live for England being beaten. In 25 years time I recon I will get over it.
@@Wolf-hh4rv Henry was amazing on attack and defence, but his goal kicking let us down, cost us the Lions Tour. I'm a Durban boy so I am a huge fan of him, but that was the big weakness in his game.
As a country that always suffered under someone else's control, the Dutch then the British, then the absurd law of Apartheid, sanctions that isolated us all. Then we had the glorious years of Nelson Mandela,literally our father and our hearts. The best Constitution in the world,thank you Mandla🙏 we have nothing to respect in our corrupt government and failing economy. But we are standing on the shoulders of Giants, we have heroes,we have their voices. Listen to our Boks and you hear all of us. Thank you for showing them the respect they deserve
Small correction; the British & Irish Lions toured RSA in 1974. I saw them play Eastern Province in Port Elizabeth. Was stunned by the quality of Gareth Edwards and Phil Bennett. I was at Rhodes University at the time. Rugby was hugely popular amongst the Black and Coloured population in the province and there was always a huge crowd of Black and Coloured supporters that used to watch 'varsity games in an area at the end of the pitch.
I used to enjoy Dale College and Selborne College rugby in the 70's in the Eastern Cape area. Also Queens College and of course Graeme College. It was great schoolboy rugby
Tim, thank you for 7 weeks of shearing your expert advise with us. You made this World Cup tournament extra special. May your channel become the top rugby chanel on social media. Please come and visit as in South Africa 🇿🇦
Thank you for great comment on team dynamics. The Bok slogan throughout RWC has been “Stronger Together”. In Jo’burg I saw the clip of Marx and Mapimpi returning to Paris to be welcomed by the team at the hotel. Seemed to me then that no matter how wiped out the guys were after two bruising knock out matches - the return of these two would rev them up and remind them of what they do and who they do it for. Tv coverage of return home today was unlike anything I have ever seen. Was at at Madiba’s Inauguration in 1994 - this team symbolises the same hope and capacity to succeed.
I have discovered your channel only about 4 weeks ago, and I must thank you. Enjoyed your informed and unbiased commentary. I am subscribed - from South Africa.
wow, you said it best my friend. This is exactly how we feel here in South Africa. I grew up in apartheid watched and played the game. I lost my place to a black rugby player but didn't understood what they wanted to do then. this was in 1999. Played with Etienne Botha and Adrain Jacobs back then and to see how this has worked for South Africa and the transformation that happen and inspired the whole nation to play the best game in the world. We can now see the fruits of our labour in our squad today. This gives me a tear in my eye, I am so proud of my country. Thank you South Africa. Love everyone in South Africa today just because of how we can be stronger together.
Wow, what a beautiful podcast. Truly inspirational. It is true we had the hardest battle, we went to war to win this, played physical dominant sides like Tonga, Ireland, Scotland, England and France. To see muscle men go down on the knees and cry when we won the world cup was so emotional, people cried when we won, but so many cried for what South Africa was once. It is such a beautiful country, we such a proud and patriotic nation, we beset with many challenges, High unemployment, power cuts and Water 💧 cuts, but rugby 🏉 has United South Africa 🇿🇦 like no other sport, in the history of South Africa. Kudoos to you and analysis of the Springboks. They said it was impossible for the Springboks to win, but we became invincible with the indomitable spirit 🇿🇦❤️🏉🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧!
Thank you Tim, great content again. I've been saying for some time that there is something special about this team, created by Rassie and hope also please need to credit Jacques Nenieber too. Nenieber is going to be missed big time, people need to realise that.
What a lovely video While the rest of the world are up in arms re the Springboks... My favourite rugby UA-camrs has this video for us in store Incredible Tim What a lovely sentiment and fantastic vid bruv
I have great respect for your passionate love for the game of rugby, during the world cup you have given us great honest reviews of every game, well done from a proudly Springbok supporter🇿🇦
Tim just know, if you ever travel to South Africa you have a home and a friend. You are most welcome in our beautiful country. Mate you have done it again, no one can argue against this analysis. It is well researched, fair and thoughtful. Thank you for being a breath of fresh air mate. I love your platform and I have abandoned all others because they don't seem to have the interest of rugby but the interest of who they support. Thank you mate, I wish you all that is good for your platform.💚🧡
I cannot believe that you have only recently started this channel. You are a natural and should have been doing this a long time back because, other than the Keo and Zels channel, you are on another level. I love this channel. I hope that you are going to the next world cup. My children and grand children live in Melbourne . I am hoping to make that our base. Would love to meet you there to enjoy a few games. Well done on producing high quality content week in and week out.
A team is not a bunch of amazingly gifted individuals. A team is a bunch of great players that perform as a synergized unit. Like this one. I agree with you.
Great video as usual, and I couldn’t agree more! The Boks are able to produce more than what they appear to be capable of when it is needed. Arendse’s tackle was one example. Pieter-Steph was a machine in the final. Libbok giving up his spot because he knows he’s got work to do, and the team comes first. They know what victory would mean to South Africa. It is just such an absolute pity that South Africa, which is more than the sum of its parts, is ruined by politicians. South Africans are team players just like the Boks, but our leadership is the complete antithesis of the Boks’ coaching staff.
I watched a program on TV here in South Africa recently where they had an interview with Divan Serfontein scrumhalf and previous Springbok captain and he said when he started playing for Stellenbosch University the great Doc Craven said do not consider yourself the best because there was better players before you and there will be better players after you. Maybe we can say this about teams as well.
Thank you Tim. This is a special video. I did send it to my son so that we can remember it. You have different way of looking at things. I respect you for it and enjoy it. May you go from strength to strength. Take care. Emile (proudly South African)
The scenes that you was talking about with the blacks supporting the British and Irish Lions during the Apartheid years i had witnessed it first hand. The Lions had win the game in Port Elizabeth at that time. Today it is wonderful to see all the talents from all the different groups that has been jelled into one unit. Yes, in many positions you can find more talented players, but then we miss the point. The Springboks operate as a unit, they respect the coaching team and the coaching team respect the players and togethet they create this bond, one unit, support each other, play for each othet, play for the nation. Lastly, under Eddie Jones most of the Springboks would not have been pick, " they are to old" He miss the point.
Tim, yes, you brought tears to my eyes and an aching to my heart. I love this country and its people so much. Thank you. Siya for President! God bless South Africa.
Absolutely correct. All your commentaries and insights are spot on. Thank you for your fairness and great sportsmanship, even when England lost. Simply awesome!
Agreed, what an awesome human being 😱 the humility he has is so inspiring. How he has developed boys into real men is beyond words... and then to listen to how Siya and the guys speak about him really brought tears to my eyes. Nienaber is a very special human being that deserves so much more than a best coach nomination...cheers Jacques you are an absolute goat in my eyes 👌
I'm probably biased as a South African, but I couldn't agree with you more Tim. These Boks are certainly the best of all time and Siya is an incredible man and ambassador for the sport, and our country. I've never had the privilege of meeting him in person, but he has touched my family deeply - last year my (then) 10 year son underwent surgery and radiotherapy for a brain tumor. For the radiotherapy he had a custom made mask to keep his head in position which he had decorated with a Springbok emblem. This was brought to Siya's attention through a friend, and he took the time to record a video message of encouragement and support for my boy. You can probably imagine what that did to lift his spirits!!! It proves to me that he is not just that way in front of the cameras; he's genuinely humble despite being one of the greatest sporting icons of our time - or perhaps of ALL time.
I think this was the best depth South Africa’s has ever had. I do think lots of them have been over their peak but that experience have definitely pulled through
Wow Tim you are just going from strength to strength with your work and evaluating commentaries This may be your masterpiece of the entire Tournament in being such considerate, assertive, genuine and really careful evaluation in all directions of a vibrant , most renowned happening Magnificent‼️‼️ I’m going to watch it again, but most certainly it represents a sincerity that i’ve never seen before anywhere else nor could enjoy so intensely in my interest in the wonderful Game of RU / RF ~ before Absolutely fantastic ‘the sum of the individual parts’ being greater as a whole than any other possibility ~ which Rasnaber and Stokke got right superbly AND the Coaching thinking brilliance in making their Team do and think and skillfully perform things NOBODY has EVER done before in such particular configurations OR application to brilliant and/or astounding effect…enjoyment by ALL on the green park I will get back to you on this one again FORMIDABLE standard and contribution towards making Rugby Union / Football an even greater sport than it already is… Most certainly a sterling effort generating thought of the highest, most constructive order You appear to understand the players and particular Team psychologies like nobody else ~ throughout the entire RWC Tournament it was clearly apparant which, to my mind, makes you, your EC channel performance unique… Thank you kindly Thank you most sincerely A superb joie this Channel of yours…all throughout RWC 2023🏉‼️‼️ 💫 🥂 Beste from the Fairest Cape Winelands 👊 🔥 💥 ✨ (🪖🧨) (31Oct2023)
Thank you, Tim, for your acurate and much agreed upon analysis, and conclusions reached as a result. Here are a few of my own points as to why SA is the Greatest Rugby Nation in the history of Mankind!! 1. Got to a 4th title in a quicker time span than New Zealand got 3. Having played 2 fewer world cups. 2. Didn't play for almost half off our 2019 reign due to Covid. 3.Toughest route to a final ever!! Missing key players. Still, we win! 4. Haven't lost a final. 5. Us moving to URC marked the decline of NZ rugby and, although on the up, cemented the rise of NH rugby. This is because our style of rugby forces teams to improve their set piece and attack. It also forces teams to play smart rugby. Not touch, and running the ball from everywhere and anywhere. NH received a boost due to URC SA team exposure. 6. We had the most players born in SA playing for the top tier teams in this World Cup. 7. We are one of the few top-tier nations that has 100% homegrown players. 8. World Rugby introduced a million changes in the game, all to negate SA dominance. And we still WON!! My personal conspiracy theory about all these rule changes.🤫😜 GO BOKKE!!! 👏🏿👊🏿👍🏿✌🏿🇿🇦💚💛
I agree with most you've said there. I'm just glad the 4 provinces of Ireland had quality opposition added from SA, They really only had themselves to compete against in the URC till then.
'.. the decline of NZ rugby...' South Africa beat them by 1pt with a man more and NZ missing two kicks and therefore 5 pts. Doesn't say much for South Africa then if NZ are in decline
@barrierodliffe3452 says a lot, actually. We had just gone through playing the entire top 5, week in, and week out. Playing wounded and tired with less rest and the toughest route to the final. And we could not be stopped!! Come on! Mate, this victory and the context in which it was achieved back everything I have said. NZ has lost their shine. We were playing with no hooker and a massively compromised lineout. Yet this team couldn't beat us. ABs of old would've ripped us apart. Our scrum was even struggling, yet still, we could not be beaten!! COME ON!! IT'S INCREDICBLE!!✌🏿🇿🇦💚💛
Tim, I am a Saffa and I have had a growing respect for your channel and your analysis. And with this you are 100% correct. The whole is greater than the sum of the parts. It gives a new meaning to the word "team". They look to the greater good. There is not one prima Donna amongst them. They are our pride and joy. Thank you for your genuine respect for the game and your honest appraisal of how you felt after each game. Even when England lost. I hope you will be able to visit our beautiful country with its fantastic people (most of them) and get to understand what motivates this team. Massive potential but devastated by the pure greed and opportunism of a relatively small group of individuals who cannot see beyond their own mansions and luxury cars. And for our president to have tried to emulate Madiba, was a travesty. He and his buddies are to blame for the mess we are in. Keep up the great work. I have seen you maturing with every report. Cheers.
Personally I think the 1995 South African World cup team were the G.O.A.T.S. They went into the world cup with zero experience in world cup competitions. They drew a deeply divided country together. They played stopped a rampant and unstoppable Lomu. They took the game to extra time against the widely touted to win New Zealand. You could argue that that team had home ground advantage but that is not entirely true because support for the team was not constant and non support from parliament was very vociferous. It was that Springbok team that laid the foundations for this world cup, Francois Pienaar who started the tradition of exceptional people to captain the Springboks. It was the 1995 team that went out after the world cup and started coaching grass roots rugby in the townships and started initiatives like the junior school rugby leagues. It took a generation of effort, started by the 1995 team of amateurs to create what the Springboks mean now.
I agree the 1995 team under Francois was the best South African team to ever win a world cup, those plays went into that tournament as under dogs but they play for a nation , South Africa...they had depth, passion and courage...the greats like Andre Joubert, James Small, Ollie let Roux, Joel Stranskie are just some of the legends who's names will live on for generations to come ...🇿🇦🏉
I believe Faf de Klerk said it best : we may not be the best 33 individual players, but as a team we compliment each other and work for each other. That is what team sport is about.
Totally agree
It's nice that they compliment each other lol
@@MrDeyzel did i use the terminology wrong ? I am afrikaans but i believe i got it right ?
@@5PRINGB0K Sorry ja jy het maar die spelling in daai sin is dan complement
You got it spot on!
I don’t think there has ever been a team that is more “squad” focused then this SA team. Even the way the bench is viewed and used is completely different. SA has changed rugby from a 15 man game to a 30 man game. That’s the biggest innovation this team has brought. Great video Tim! As always.
Revolutionary way of thinking about your player pool. In 2019 I thought the bench were better than the starters.
We were forced to as we had to play effectively five finals in a row at huge intensity for each game. As a starting team this was not the GOAT (prolly NZ 2011), but as a squad with sheer depth that was able to play five high intensity games week after week on the trot we were GOAT.
They play 8 man rugby, and their boring.
There is something that no one is commenting on...(during the world cup tornament .. the AB couch told the world that springboks play boring type of rugby game..we were heavily challenge by that...and his own team too...to show who comes on top.. you'll be the judge)
Tim, you actually brought tears to my eyes. At times we do feel that the rugby world is against us, for whatever reason they have. To have someone like you making the comments that you do is heart warming to say the least. A massive thank you from South Africa 🇿🇦
The reason they are against us goes back to the days when we said NO to Victoria.
Not the rugby world - just the shysters who run World Rugby and in particular its Executive Committee:
Bill Beaumont (Chairman)
John Jeffrey (Vice-Chair)
Mark Alexander
Bart Campbell
Su Carty
Lord Mervyn Davies
Bob Latham
Ada Milby
Brett Robinson
Angela Ruggiero
Jonathan Webb
Alan Gilpin (CEO)
Only one of these members is a South African. The rest are drawn from the UK, Australia and Ireland and represent the sides that emanate from those parts of the world. The fact that SA has the same number of representatives as the US is beyond absurd. It would be equivalent to including only one representative of Germany or Brazil on FIFA but having three South Africans as well. These are the people who steer the ship and they're as corrupt as the people who run FIFA. I'm glad they snub SA. It's a badge of honour.
@suewindsor5196 Thank you very Im in tears now.
@@davesmith826which of these people specifically is corrupt since you have taken great effort to name them? Let’s see if you have the balls to not remain silent
@@Bokgat The list is available on the World Rugby website. It took no 'great effort' to name them. They're corrupt because they preside over an organisation that doesn't represent the rugby family. The recent World Cup was held in France, not South Africa, despite France holding the comp ten years earlier and despite South Africa being chosen as the recommended host in a lengthy report that was subsequently abandoned. The recent 'team of the year' contained one South African and ten players from teams that didn't even make it out the quarter finals. The coach of the year is an Englishman who may have taken his side on an eighteen-match unbeaten streak but also cost them the World Cup by not rotating in the group stages. The list goes on, but I can't be bothered to continue populating it. Your attempt to goad me with a reference to 'having the balls' made me laugh. A real man calls someone out to his face, not on the interweb.
The way Siya ran over to Cheslin and embraced him in a massive man hug as the final whistle blew says everything you need to know about the way he cares for his team - each on individually!
He just ran straight for the man who was hurting most just a second ago and lifted him up and celebrated.
I wouldn't be surprised if he had done the same thing if they had lost.
Yes, that was another special moment from Siya. He is the best Captain at this level, and should have been in the dream team based on his skills, his comeback from major injury in such a short time and his humility as a captain who really cares for each of his team mates.
He would've. That is the kind of man he is.
Great insight, brought tears to my eyes as I imagined the emotions involved in this exchange.
Thanks Tim, you boosted us South African and made our day through your comments😊
@@cosmic_diver Just thinking of a framouse Wales Capt creaming INSULTS (AND BACKED UP BY HIS COACH) at 1/2 time and looking at Siya and Cheslin tells enough of what GREAT captains are made off (and coaches)
As a kiwi, I'm conflicted year to year the all blacks are more consistent, but South Africa since returning to world rugby in the 90,s have. been better performers at rwc level, but you have to take your hats off to the bokkes
A large factor in it is what Rassie said a couple years back, (to paraphrase, since I can't remember the exact quote, but it basically along the lines of), "The only thing the Springboks care about are the World Cups, and every test match inbetween the World Cups are little more than preparation and testing in preparation for the world cup, and we don't mind or really care if we lose a couple test matches while trying different combinations and tactics".
Can't remember the exact quote, but it was basically along those lines.
The only thing the boks care about are RWCs
and the only team that makes it a 1 point final with 14 men...is the All blacks. Unreal, hold your head up high and be proud of your team.
Thank you. 🇿🇦
I'd say we choked, but we only at 14 players on the field for 60 minutes..and we dominated the second half....congrats to the spring boks, but best team ever, give me a break.
@@boomdiada.9009never been prouder of teams loss but fuck me some of those calls were a joke. Cards should be given for intentional foul play or repeated infringement not because an attacking player switch direction on a team and catches you out of position even siya card was ridiculous.... ufc fighters get punched in the head for 15-25mins but god forbid getting a shoulder to the head which has a bit more padding than thin gloves. World rugby will kill the game with these bullshit rules they bring in. If players want to stay safe don't play a physical game
I’m a Wales fan and follow France as a second team. When the boks beat France in the quarters I was ambivalent about them but full of respect. I then, for the first time I can remember, supported them when the final came around. And you said it. It is their teamwork and self belief that is so impressive. Along with great coaching. I thought the substitution of Libbock was a master stroke. Won that game for SA. I also now understand the trauma on the faces of SA when they were beaten by Japan IN 2015. The RWC is everything to them. Well, hats off - and look forward to seeing you in Cardiff next time!
... and Llanelli beat the the All Blacks yonks ago and drank 27 pubs dry as a bone.
That loss against Japan brought the country to a halt, it was like the country mourned for a week. haha But we know how NZ feels we've been there its hard but that sets the tone for the next one
England 2003 got me into rugby. I can name the entire 22. They ran a fantastic WC campaign. Springboks play for a higher purpose. It's for the people. It's for the struggle. World Rugby struggled to put that into their template of awards.
Thank you for these words, thank you. 🇿🇦
❤❤❤❤
What is so amazing about this team had the all blacks gone for the poles instead of the line they would of won France was unlucky England nearly beat us so what's so special about this team I think the worst of all world squads ever scrum was pushed around
Thank you Tim!! As a South African who had to witness the relentless bashing of our team throughout the competition, this is just so much appreciated. Yes we are resilient as a nation and our rugby team is the epitome of who we are as a nation. This touched the ❤
these Bokke may not be the best players, they're maybe not playing the "sexiest" rugby but they're the team that can scrap and fight and drag a result out of every game no matter what. They're the ultimate knockouts team with the greatest captain of all time.
As a proud South African, I thank you for your remarkable words, respect and honor comes to mind.
What I love about his team is the innovation in the game plus the belief that they’re part of something so much bigger sport. Amazing team 🇿🇦
As a South African it brings me to tears listening to you share our story. Wow thank you Tim 🙏🏻😌
This Boks team deserves a lot more credit than what they get. We’ve seen top class international teams over the years but this team is exceptionally special both on and off the field. Full respect for what they have achieved 🙌🙌
I will definitely agree with you Tim, As a South Africans we've witnessed this team grow, as a Nation we grew with the team... They certainly are the Greatest.
Most of these players came out harsh circumstances, Cheslin only started playing Rugby at the age of 16 after his school noticed how fast he is. Some players like Siya came from rural beginnings bare foot, food for once or twice a week.
The team has soul, that is what speaks to people, people can relate, As you say if you're a real rugby fan you will spot the difference.
Honestly I am grateful that the world can see what South Africa went through every rugby match in terms of critics, it's only now that the west notice what we've been saying for decades. This formed the mental strength you witness today, they are so good at blocking out the noise that nothing phased them.
Thanks for seeing us, I enjoyed the journey with you.
🇿🇦
Brilliant comment. My sentiments exactly.
Lived there in 1976/8, great rugby then. Great team now but I think a great team in a financially stable country is better than a great team in a destroyed, corrupt South Africa of today. 4 Rand to the pound then, over 20 now even though it’s propped up. Now I will wait for the chinless liberals to attack my comments…..
Or the 74 Lions were a great team as well
The luckiest team of all time. They lost to Ireland, and scrape three wins largely due to refereeing inadequacies.
Kolbie's charge down was illegal, the first penalty against England was clearly not a penalty and NZ went down to 14 before they could beat them, just.
And with World Rugby disgraceful treatment of Tom Curry, it has left a bitter taste in mine and many others mouths.
It seems that WR have taken up with the critical race theory, that preaches only white people can be racist.
I agree with you Victor, well said. I also praise Tim for his knowledge and well-centered opinion.
Hi Tim. I’m a 78 year old grandmother. I have so enjoyed your commentaries. You’ve helped me understand so many aspects of the game. I just love how fair you are in your comments. I am one very proud South African. My love & gratitude to our Springbok team for bringing the sunshine in.
To have used a sport so synonymous with apartheid to unite a nation is a tremendous feat and perhaps explains to non South Africans how important rugby is to us. Thanks Tim.
It also sheds light on how wise and far-sighted Nelson Mandela was. Without his endorsement, The Boks would never have become the inspirational force they are.
We witnessed it in 1995, gold watch Bevan for his decisive role in the SF and kiwis vomiting around the pitch. Rugby is beyond sport for sure in SA.
Best team. As long as they got the TMO
@@jeromeh7985 save some tears, you’ve got 4 years of crying.
@@huepix how does this relate to my comment? Those salty tears affecting your vision?
This team encapsulates the best of South Africa - brotherhood, faith, perseverance and joy. It has reminded us of our roots of Ubuntu - 'I am what I am because of who we all are" and who we can be when we stand together. Their ethos: 'the sum is better than individuals' and their undying committment to give 100%, in my albeit biased viewpoint, makes them the G.O.A.T. Thank you Tim for the depth your understanding about the Springboks and South Africa!
Thanks so much meneer! You were balanced & fair, hope this cuppa contributes a bit to motivating you to continue! There's still URC Ruggy!
A generous man🔥🔥 God bless you💚
I've been following your work since you began your YT channel Tim. What's brought me back everytime was your lack of bias, knowledge, professionalism and passion for the game delivered in a manner that one cannot help but be drawn to. Please continue your excellent work. I really appreciate you. Thank you for your kind words with regards to our Boks. It means so much to us🙏💚💛🇿🇦
Tim it has been an absolute joy to have shared your amazing coverage across all the games and all the teams during this world cup. No bias, no flogging sacred cows, just balance and great information. You have made it a pleasure to participate from afar. Thank you
Thank you, Tim, for your very kind words for the South African team. You are a noble Englishman!
Definitely the hardest route anybody has ever taken to a world cup final.
Exactly & that’s why their wins mean so much more. Barnes’ RWC 2011 final was THE worst, the French were robbed due to dodgy calls & Barnes folding under the (national) pressure.
Every single SA player gave it their all to topple champion teams week after week. Siya Kolisi player of the tournament (imho) what a 💯% humble, inspirational leader🎉🎉😘
And Ardie Savea as a Samoan leader & player on the field…absolute inspiring❤
@@teuilagracetualaulelei1609wasn't Barnes. Joubert.
Ireland the only team to beat springboks in the World Cup 🏟
@@aughalough1don't mean anything as we are the champions... World rankings also don't mean nothing but since Ireland fans were so cocky. You not #1 anymore 😭🤣
@@teuilagracetualaulelei1609yeah well the kiwis were robbed in the 2023 rwc final but hey fuck them right also ardie is a kiwi with Samoan heritage.
Hi Tim thank you for your great channel, I am a Scotsman living I SA since 1963, I have become a loyal South African and have supported the Boks for as long as I can remember I agree they are the goat
There is something about the Springboks team that wins in spite of every reason why they shouldn't. But I think you summed it up perfectly: as a TEAM, the Springboks are perhaps the best of all time. There are much better individual players concentrated elsewhere but hot damn do they have a ghastly willpower and determination and team spirit.
Also, Kwagga Smith.
One more comment: Thank you for your kind words about our country and recognizing the difference and hope this team has brought to us.
I was 9 years old when I watched the 1995 final... the buildup to that was something else!
As a child I hardly understood the significance of the 1994 election, though my parents were very much for the New South Africa. I did obviously see the massive inequality all around me and even as a child that struck me as really broken.
After the 94 election South Africa got a new Anthem (which I think is the best in the world), but during the 95 tournament we also got a kind of second anthem in the song "Shozaloza" which was sung at every game. I have a strong memory of this song being sung in church on a Sunday morning. A song in Zulu and Ndebele sung by an all-white church choir on a Sunday morning only one year after apartheid officially ended. Something different was in the air.
On Saturday evening I joined a few thousand people at a local shopping mall to watch the game on a big screen in the food court.
Being part of a crowd of all races and ages all packed in pretty much shoulder to shoulder and all cheering and screaming and dancing (and lots of holding our breath) was pure joy!
I'm rambling... I have too many thoughts and not enough time or skill...
I am just thankful for the wonderful changes that have indeed happened in our country even if we are daily plagued with a hundred problems.
The new South Africa has never delivered the delusional peace and prosperity liberals claimed. The election might have been a big step for democracy but it’s ultimately been a destructive for the country. Even Kolisi said nothing is going right. That’s purely down to appalling corrupt governance.
I'll be humble as a South African and say those 2011-2015 AB's were completely untouchable both during and outside the World Cups. They were also filled with absolute legends of the game.
Still very proud of our Boys!
Ah! But there was no Rassie yet... I jest. That team was absolutely the GOAT in the professional era.
Agreed
It's apples and oranges
McCaw and Carter are cheat codes
@@wlk2408That’s true but you can only beat the teams that are in front of you. We did that but so did those AB’s and of the top teams in the ‘15 WC who they didn’t play, who’s betting against the AB’s if they did play?
Finally we have someone beginning to understand what our much loved, admired Springboks are all about. It is not a team its a FAMILY. GREAT show keep up the great work 👍
Tim you are the 2023 commentator GOAT
There is only one thing that makes me sad about this amazing team: Many will not be there anymore during the next WC. But I guess this is how legends are made :) Thank you boys for all the incredible emotions I had during this 2 months... I was lucky enough to see them playing 2 of the best ever games in Paris... If only I was South African!
thank you for your awsome compliment
As a South African citizen, we've adopted you as one of us. Thanks for a wonderful comment.
South Africa is just awesome... I am not South African, however I lived in Cape Town for a while under "less nice" times... Great people there! Where Rugby is a religion 😊
@@lebohangmaseko6949thanks mate
We’ll adopt you if you want!
Must be the best Monologue I have heard about our Springboks.Well done Mate!
As a proud South Africa, the way you tell our story sends shivers down my spine.
Based on today's rankings, SA (ranked 1) had to play:
No. 2 Ireland
No. 3 New Zealand
No. 4 France
No. 5 England
Honestly, that's a feat of note and I take what you're saying about the team being the "GOAT" - the 2023 team is definitely better than the sum of their parts! And the parts are pretty damn spectacular too! Seriously impressed and proud South African - our boys will become and remain legends of SA rugby!
And No 6 Scotland! And Tonga who are ranked lower are still a massive task physically!
No. 6 Scotland bro they no a bad team. Playing five of the top Six teams in the world. It is unheard of in any sport. Name any sport where that has happened I will wait
Sorry, can't believe I left out Scotland, they are such a great team!
@@tyroneholmes6354
The 2007 side had Fiji in the quarters and Argentina in the Semifinals. Just a bit easier.
Also don't forgot Tonga! Siya said that was their most physical game of the group stages or something of that note!
This team transcends rugby. Their values are something all other teams can only aspire to ❤
Great video Tim. The collective is more important than the individual. Between them and 2015 Nz it's close
I will say I do believe Rassie can now be regarded as the greatest coach of all time...👌
What's his overall win percentage start to finish?
What's in the trophy cabinet outside of world cups?
Has he achieved a single unbeaten tour of the NH?
There's levels. Steve Hansen's numbers would put every other international coach to shame, Rassie included
@@benjamindewes2345 DUUH! What's bigger than the world cup anyway.
@@thebha7519 Duuh Hansen won 2 of those as well
@@benjamindewes2345 LOL, that was definitely his last 2
@@benjamindewes2345 Nope only one, he was appointed after the 2011 win. He got a 3rd place in 2019. Being assistant coach does not count in this regard. Btw I found your hat, here you go!
Undoubtedly the best RWC 2023 vlogger/blogger; impartial, objective, intuitive and insightful. All reviews are well put together with a neutral approach. Awesome!
Dear Tim, you should see how our nation welcomed the Boks at OR Tambo airport. We as a nation is so united and this will not go away. The Springboks led by example on how a country can be winners...only if by1 point.... how profound. I am quite emotional today and yes a new leader for our country is imminent in my opinion because we the people will choose and not by crooked elections. Thank you for your beautiful channel. ❤
This team is really special. An amazing group of guys. Beating the best French team of all time in QF in one of the greatest games ever. Finding a way to beat England despite struggling and looking dead in the water with 8mins to go. Beating the AB in the final again with 1 point.....their mental stength and brotherhood togetherness is what makes them the most beloved Bok team ever. I have never seen this kind of love for any Bok team.
The 2007 team probably the best tbh, but this team the most special. The 2015 AB side arguably the best ever.
The only thing I would do to that "Dream Team" is to take Eben out. Our Springboks are the "DREAM TEAM". We beat the best to be the best. Thanks for the quality content as always Tim. Can't wait for more.
Yes please remove Even,he belongs to our dream team...give that spot to someone else.
😂😂 I think this is the sentiment of many Saffas...Eben plays best when he plays with his brothers 🤷🏽♀️
Man, brain exploded. Love watching a pundit that is focusing on the positive points of rugby and teams. Thank you.
I can only talk for myself but I believed in this team from the start of this world cup.
When we lost vs Ireland, I was not worried.
I never doubted them vs France.
I believed that we would take the win against England even while we were so far down.
I believed throughout the Finals, even taking into account that Barret might have put that shot at goal over.
Don't get me wrong, I expected tough battles (which we got, through and through) , but If a team can make me believe like this, I must consider them for the G.O.A.Ts.
I would like to know what the experience was like for the ABs 2011/15 fans.
And finally, thank you so much for your content and insight, Tim. It is very much appreciated!
I said this World Cup was ours long ago! Got to admit I got nervous losing players like Am and Marx!
From a kiwi perspective, it was heartbreaking knowing the final was there to be won, and we just couldn't get there, but in having said that if we couldn't win we are glad it wasn't the irish or the French in fact the bokkes were the only team we could be happy for and I think that's because our nation's share such a huge rivalry when it comes to rugby, so we as a nation are not so sad,more so just happy if we couldn't win it , atleast SA could
Tim bud ..your absolute understanding and admiration for this Springbok team makes us so proud to be South African ,to be acknowledged by your honest and objective channel..Your channel and I watch many, has fast become a channel of rugby knowledge , unbias and class with great presentation, subject matter using excellent language not slander to make educated points of interest..
Kudos to you ..keep it going bud its a rare talent and will put you in good stead going forward as this channel grows from strength to strength to sponsors..
Thanks Tim Respect for recognising their achievements on and off the field. They are a class act and should celebrated 🎉
Spot on Tim. A team that has only one decent player according to World Rugby but can still win a World Cup is something pretty special.
And back to back.
Spot on Tim! I couldn't agree more with you. In an age where individualism is usually more valued than collective effort, SA showed the way and is a beacon of hope for not only the sport of rugby but for their country as well. I had the opportunity to enjoy an afternoon amongst SA fans in Paris before going to the semifinal vs England and all I can say is I was amazed at what I experienced! Respect, Unity, Joy and Pride for their country...hats off to the Springboks class of '23....best in class
As a South African, I must admit we don't have the most skilful players like the 2015 AB's. No McCaw's, Carters or Nonu's, but this Springbok side showed the world how to play with your heart. Most of the Boks in this team was nobody's or quotas once, and Rassie and Jacques made something out of them. Today, we can proudly say that The Springboks are the best in the World. Thanks Tim for all the work you have done during the RWC. Respect brother!!!
Wrong, we do. It's just not something the coaches have wanted us to showcase in the playoffs, rather brute force and defense. Ox has crazy offload skills, so speak Snyman. Pollard is an attacking flyhalf who loves running the ball himself. He almost scored a try in the final doing what he likes, making hard runs into contact. Eben has good offloading. Faf has superb passing range. We have loads of skills but defense wins World Cups
How powerful is your video, recognizing what is truly unique and great about this springbok team. As a South African, thank you so very much
As a kiwi i reckon this is without a doubt the greatest ever world cup victory as they did it the hard way playing all the best teams. No other world cup victory compares and i suspect they will be a good chance to go for a three peat in 4 years. In saying that i think as far as pure statistics for winning games and dominance between and during world cups the 2011 - 2015 ABs team is superior.
This current boks team is great though, no doubt about it!!
You have to admit, the springboks are the greatest team in world cup history. They already became the best world cup team in 2019 in history because their win percentage was already greater than the ABs in 2019
Mate the 95 world cup final is still the benchmark final for me
Bok fan here and I have to agree with you about your 2010-2015 team, they were top drawer, but the Springboks have now become what the ABs have always been a symbol of national unity, as Tim said it was a symbol of division and now the team is truly a mixture and the black support is huge now. I think the rest of the Rugby world needs to beware, the Boks may not manage a third World Cup in a row in 2027, but I think there will be such a crop of outstanding young black players (inspired by Kolisi) coming through that the 2031 will likely be won by SA. If that happens the production line gusher will open wide. That said the AB v Boks games are always the game for either side. Respect!
@@peterlangan1181 Manny Ras ,Gianni Lombaard ,Sasha Mgumezulu, Thakir Abrahams,Abanathi Nkalbakanye,Sisonke Vumazoke ,Nabo Sokoy to name a few
@@jadenphilander8799proof is in the pudding and they have the most world cups so thembeing the greatedt world cup nation goes without saying. The boks are world cup specialists. Just look at how many rugby championships or tri nations they have won since rugby became pro. Quite incredibale how they manage to pull it together for 6-8 week period every 4 years.
Thank you Tim. Rugby is the greatest sport, rugby has the greatest fans, and you sir, are our mouthpiece!
Tim, so good to see you still pumping out WC videos. I’m having withdrawal symptoms. I’m loving watching your channel grow. We need to start a go fund me to get you to Australia in 2027 to bring us more coverage. Great to see you continuing your good work 🇮🇪☘️
Thanks Tim you really summed it up very well in an objective manner. As a South African, I listened to many games as a child over the radio at 5 in the morning against the All Blacks .. I am now 69 years and TV has spoilt us. For many years, the 1974 British Lions was the best for me, then 2015 AB and now this team. I was at quarter finals in Paris and it was just a game I will never forgot - my son of 37 years called it already a bucket list experience ! So my dear friend keep this chats going and when there is excellence point it out please. Take care
The Boks' coaching ticket & support staff is, by some distance, the greatest ever.
As a grown man I sit in tears of joy hearing your comparison of a 70's South African Rugby jersey to the one we get to witness today. Thank you for that, Tim.
Seeing this team play against 2011-2015 ABs. Oh my word how crazy good that would be
all blacks would probably beat this bok team
@@plutoniumnitrate1201 Not if it was the WC Final
Would probably be another close game if both teams are fit. Wouldn't miss that game for nothing lol.
@@plutoniumnitrate1201need to take into account how the laws have changed, how the game has changed, how its reffed etc. Actually not realistic to try say what would happen if they played each other. They were a great team with a great record. Only thing I'd say with certainty is that this was the toughest world cup to win in the history of world cups, with the route the boks had to take
Yes but with am back and marx back.
What you are saying is so real....I appreciate
You are correct in emphasizing TEAM! That's precisely it. I read many articles and listened to many pundits saying that taking Manie, Eben, and Siya off during the England game was brutal and embarrassing. Except that's not how the Boks see it, they all buy completely into the concept of "Team first, always!" Their moto is #StrongerTogether It's pretty simple, really.
Tim your summation here is exactly why you are the number 1 rugby Podcaster out there.. holistic understanding of the game..
This video made me tear up.. after all the bashing this team and coaches have received from international media. Thank you
Probably the single best Video I have watched on UA-cam this year...
As a South African 🇿🇦 I could not have been prouder of our team. This Springbok team has shown everyone, what we as South Africans can achieve if we can just put politics aside, and work for the greater good of our fellow countrymen.
These players are all heroes in my eyes, and listening to you (Tim) in this video, it brought a few tears in my eyes, cause every word you said is true, and add to that the history and the stories behind each of the players in this Bok team, and you will have even more respect for them. Just like I have a world of respect for you and the videos you have posted during the world cup.
Thanks for that.
Ps, if you can find it, look for a series called "Chasing the Sun" it's about the 2019 bok squad.
I'd love to hear your view on that.
Thanks for brilliant non-bias fair and very high quality commentary throughout the WC.
Between you and a guy from Nzl called 2cents I have found faith in journalism again. Thank you again and I have subscribed and will be looking out for future content 😊
Beautifully spoken! Especially your closing thoughts. Thank you so much for the videos. 🇿🇦
Agreed, it was also apparent when the Blitzbokke were winning lots of tournaments, individuals rarely appeared as most tries scored, most points scored ... and Cheslin and Kwagga were two of them. And the Blitzboks defense was legendary ... that demands trust and commitment ... two of the main characteristics of an elite TEAM.
Thank you Tim this is why we love your channel. Always showing respect, truth, love and neutrality. This bok team from 2019 till now are one of the greatest. 2x World Cups, 1x B&I Lions, 1x Rugby Championship.
I am an ex South African now living in Australia. I was following you throughout the world cup. I want to credit you on your knowledge of rugby and the passionate way you talk about it. Your summary of the great 2023 Springbok cup team was amazing. Keep up the good work. 👍
Would like to thank you for your unbiased commentary. Been watching your podcast throughout the worldcup. I would agree that given the road that the boks travelled in the WC. No-one has ever done. SA have won back to back not in there home country. NZ did it back to back at home. SA won a Lions tour plus 2 world cups with this team. No question the team is the G.O.A.T
Thanks, Tim I loved all your videos ❤
Never forget the 1997 Sprinbok team coached by Nick Mallet that went 17 test matches unbeaten.
That run is seared into my brain. That run is the one of the reasons I wanted AB’s to beat Ireland and the fact it’s 17 and not more is why I live for England being beaten. In 25 years time I recon I will get over it.
The 09 team was a real force as well. McCaw said it was the toughest opposition he ever faced.
Yes I remember the November tour them beating France by 40 points or so and then Scotland by a cricket score. Henry Honiball our greatest ever 10.
@@Wolf-hh4rv Henry was amazing on attack and defence, but his goal kicking let us down, cost us the Lions Tour. I'm a Durban boy so I am a huge fan of him, but that was the big weakness in his game.
As a country that always suffered under someone else's control, the Dutch then the British, then the absurd law of Apartheid, sanctions that isolated us all. Then we had the glorious years of Nelson Mandela,literally our father and our hearts. The best Constitution in the world,thank you Mandla🙏 we have nothing to respect in our corrupt government and failing economy. But we are standing on the shoulders of Giants, we have heroes,we have their voices. Listen to our Boks and you hear all of us. Thank you for showing them the respect they deserve
Small correction; the British & Irish Lions toured RSA in 1974. I saw them play Eastern Province in Port Elizabeth. Was stunned by the quality of Gareth Edwards and Phil Bennett. I was at Rhodes University at the time. Rugby was hugely popular amongst the Black and Coloured population in the province and there was always a huge crowd of Black and Coloured supporters that used to watch 'varsity games in an area at the end of the pitch.
Did you mean Gareth Edwards?
All true! I was at that 3rd Test too. Lost the game 26-9. Lost the fight too
I used to enjoy Dale College and Selborne College rugby in the 70's in the Eastern Cape area. Also Queens College and of course Graeme College. It was great schoolboy rugby
@@AfriCassie correct. Memory fade after 50 years 😁
I think Tim was referring to the 1980 Lions (he said 1970 I think)
Tim, this is an excellent, excellent piece of work! Absolutely loved it
Tim, thank you for 7 weeks of shearing your expert advise with us. You made this World Cup tournament extra special. May your channel become the top rugby chanel on social media. Please come and visit as in South Africa 🇿🇦
Thanks for those kind words, with deep appreciation from a very proud South African who has been deeply moved by this teams accomplishments.
Perfectly analyzed, could even make it the best national sports team ever given their impact beyond Rugby
Thank you for great comment on team dynamics. The Bok slogan throughout RWC has been “Stronger Together”. In Jo’burg I saw the clip of Marx and Mapimpi returning to Paris to be welcomed by the team at the hotel. Seemed to me then that no matter how wiped out the guys were after two bruising knock out matches - the return of these two would rev them up and remind them of what they do and who they do it for.
Tv coverage of return home today was unlike anything I have ever seen. Was at at Madiba’s Inauguration in 1994 - this team symbolises the same hope and capacity to succeed.
Tim..Epic video once more!! The depth of the 2019/2023 Springbok team is something out of this world..I agree with you.
You have been one of the champions of RWC 2023 Tim. Congratulations. Your humility and graciousness are destined for higher honours, I am sure.
I have discovered your channel only about 4 weeks ago, and I must thank you. Enjoyed your informed and unbiased commentary. I am subscribed - from South Africa.
You should listen to their podcast. I suggest you go back and start at 2019s semi final episode. Brilliant Monday morning commute material.
wow, you said it best my friend. This is exactly how we feel here in South Africa. I grew up in apartheid watched and played the game. I lost my place to a black rugby player but didn't understood what they wanted to do then. this was in 1999. Played with Etienne Botha and Adrain Jacobs back then and to see how this has worked for South Africa and the transformation that happen and inspired the whole nation to play the best game in the world. We can now see the fruits of our labour in our squad today. This gives me a tear in my eye, I am so proud of my country. Thank you South Africa. Love everyone in South Africa today just because of how we can be stronger together.
Wow, what a beautiful podcast. Truly inspirational. It is true we had the hardest battle, we went to war to win this, played physical dominant sides like Tonga, Ireland, Scotland, England and France.
To see muscle men go down on the knees and cry when we won the world cup was so emotional, people cried when we won, but so many cried for what South Africa was once. It is such a beautiful country, we such a proud and patriotic nation, we beset with many challenges, High unemployment, power cuts and Water 💧 cuts, but rugby 🏉 has United South Africa 🇿🇦 like no other sport, in the history of South Africa. Kudoos to you and analysis of the Springboks.
They said it was impossible for the Springboks to win, but we became invincible with the indomitable spirit 🇿🇦❤️🏉🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧!
Thank you Tim, great content again. I've been saying for some time that there is something special about this team, created by Rassie and hope also please need to credit Jacques Nenieber too. Nenieber is going to be missed big time, people need to realise that.
What a lovely video
While the rest of the world are up in arms re the Springboks... My favourite rugby UA-camrs has this video for us in store
Incredible Tim
What a lovely sentiment and fantastic vid bruv
TEAM...being the operative word, no big stars, just doing it all for each other.
Wow. One of your best videos yet!
I have great respect for your passionate love for the game of rugby, during the world cup you have given us great honest reviews of every game, well done from a proudly Springbok supporter🇿🇦
Tim just know, if you ever travel to South Africa you have a home and a friend. You are most welcome in our beautiful country. Mate you have done it again, no one can argue against this analysis. It is well researched, fair and thoughtful. Thank you for being a breath of fresh air mate. I love your platform and I have abandoned all others because they don't seem to have the interest of rugby but the interest of who they support.
Thank you mate, I wish you all that is good for your platform.💚🧡
I cannot believe that you have only recently started this channel. You are a natural and should have been doing this a long time back because, other than the Keo and Zels channel, you are on another level. I love this channel. I hope that you are going to the next world cup. My children and grand children live in Melbourne . I am hoping to make that our base. Would love to meet you there to enjoy a few games.
Well done on producing high quality content week in and week out.
Beautiful video, Thank you so much Tim for the recognition of our beautiful team. World Rugby could not do it!
A team is not a bunch of amazingly gifted individuals. A team is a bunch of great players that perform as a synergized unit. Like this one.
I agree with you.
Great video as usual, and I couldn’t agree more! The Boks are able to produce more than what they appear to be capable of when it is needed. Arendse’s tackle was one example. Pieter-Steph was a machine in the final. Libbok giving up his spot because he knows he’s got work to do, and the team comes first. They know what victory would mean to South Africa. It is just such an absolute pity that South Africa, which is more than the sum of its parts, is ruined by politicians. South Africans are team players just like the Boks, but our leadership is the complete antithesis of the Boks’ coaching staff.
I watched a program on TV here in South Africa recently where they had an interview with Divan Serfontein scrumhalf and previous Springbok captain and he said when he started playing for Stellenbosch University the great Doc Craven said do not consider yourself the best because there was better players before you and there will be better players after you. Maybe we can say this about teams as well.
Thank you Tim. This is a special video. I did send it to my son so that we can remember it. You have different way of looking at things. I respect you for it and enjoy it. May you go from strength to strength. Take care. Emile (proudly South African)
The scenes that you was talking about with the blacks supporting the British and Irish Lions during the Apartheid years i had witnessed it first hand. The Lions had win the game in Port Elizabeth at that time. Today it is wonderful to see all the talents from all the different groups that has been jelled into one unit. Yes, in many positions you can find more talented players, but then we miss the point. The Springboks operate as a unit, they respect the coaching team and the coaching team respect the players and togethet they create this bond, one unit, support each other, play for each othet, play for the nation. Lastly, under Eddie Jones most of the Springboks would not have been pick, " they are to old" He miss the point.
Tim, yes, you brought tears to my eyes and an aching to my heart. I love this country and its people so much. Thank you. Siya for President! God bless South Africa.
Defo the greatest TEAM. Squad and coaches. Undeniable
Absolutely correct. All your commentaries and insights are spot on. Thank you for your fairness and great sportsmanship, even when England lost. Simply awesome!
Nienaber is my coach of the year. Showed so much bravery and pulled of the impossible.
Agreed, what an awesome human being 😱 the humility he has is so inspiring. How he has developed boys into real men is beyond words... and then to listen to how Siya and the guys speak about him really brought tears to my eyes. Nienaber is a very special human being that deserves so much more than a best coach nomination...cheers Jacques you are an absolute goat in my eyes 👌
I wish you have 1 million Subscribers already! Tim You are the GOAT of Rugby!
I'm probably biased as a South African, but I couldn't agree with you more Tim.
These Boks are certainly the best of all time and Siya is an incredible man and ambassador for the sport, and our country. I've never had the privilege of meeting him in person, but he has touched my family deeply - last year my (then) 10 year son underwent surgery and radiotherapy for a brain tumor. For the radiotherapy he had a custom made mask to keep his head in position which he had decorated with a Springbok emblem. This was brought to Siya's attention through a friend, and he took the time to record a video message of encouragement and support for my boy. You can probably imagine what that did to lift his spirits!!!
It proves to me that he is not just that way in front of the cameras; he's genuinely humble despite being one of the greatest sporting icons of our time - or perhaps of ALL time.
I think this was the best depth South Africa’s has ever had. I do think lots of them have been over their peak but that experience have definitely pulled through
Thank you Tim for your unbiased , open honest, truthful coverage of the Bokke. It's team sport
Wow Tim
you are just going from strength to strength with your work and evaluating commentaries
This may be your masterpiece of the entire Tournament
in being such considerate, assertive, genuine and really careful evaluation in all directions of a vibrant , most renowned happening
Magnificent‼️‼️
I’m going to watch it again,
but most certainly it represents a sincerity that i’ve never seen before anywhere else
nor could enjoy so intensely in my interest in the wonderful Game of RU / RF ~ before
Absolutely fantastic
‘the sum of the individual parts’ being greater as a whole than any other possibility ~ which Rasnaber and Stokke got right superbly
AND
the Coaching thinking brilliance in making their Team do and think and skillfully perform things NOBODY has EVER done before in such particular configurations OR application to brilliant and/or astounding effect…enjoyment by ALL on the green park
I will get back to you on this one again
FORMIDABLE standard and contribution towards making Rugby Union / Football an even greater sport than it already is…
Most certainly a sterling effort generating thought of the highest, most constructive order
You appear to understand the players and particular Team psychologies like nobody else ~ throughout the entire RWC Tournament it was clearly apparant
which, to my mind, makes you, your EC channel performance unique…
Thank you kindly
Thank you most sincerely
A superb joie this Channel of yours…all throughout RWC 2023🏉‼️‼️
💫
🥂
Beste from the Fairest Cape Winelands
👊
🔥
💥
✨
(🪖🧨)
(31Oct2023)
Thank you, Tim, for your acurate and much agreed upon analysis, and conclusions reached as a result. Here are a few of my own points as to why SA is the Greatest Rugby Nation in the history of Mankind!!
1. Got to a 4th title in a quicker time span than New Zealand got 3. Having played 2 fewer world cups.
2. Didn't play for almost half off our 2019 reign due to Covid.
3.Toughest route to a final ever!!
Missing key players. Still, we win!
4. Haven't lost a final.
5. Us moving to URC marked the decline of NZ rugby and, although on the up, cemented the rise of NH rugby. This is because our style of rugby forces teams to improve their set piece and attack. It also forces teams to play smart rugby. Not touch, and running the ball from everywhere and anywhere.
NH received a boost due to URC SA team exposure.
6. We had the most players born in SA playing for the top tier teams in this World Cup.
7. We are one of the few top-tier nations that has 100% homegrown players.
8. World Rugby introduced a million changes in the game, all to negate SA dominance. And we still WON!! My personal conspiracy theory about all these rule changes.🤫😜
GO BOKKE!!!
👏🏿👊🏿👍🏿✌🏿🇿🇦💚💛
I agree with most you've said there. I'm just glad the 4 provinces of Ireland had quality opposition added from SA, They really only had themselves to compete against in the URC till then.
I just want to add to that
One of the most impressive stats and unrepeatable in my humble opinion
4 finals 4 wins only one try conceded ❤️🇿🇦
'.. the decline of NZ rugby...' South Africa beat them by 1pt with a man more and NZ missing two kicks and therefore 5 pts. Doesn't say much for South Africa then if NZ are in decline
@@shaheempashua6924 As opposed to 4 finals and only scoring 2 tries.
@barrierodliffe3452 says a lot, actually. We had just gone through playing the entire top 5, week in, and week out. Playing wounded and tired with less rest and the toughest route to the final. And we could not be stopped!! Come on! Mate, this victory and the context in which it was achieved back everything I have said. NZ has lost their shine. We were playing with no hooker and a massively compromised lineout. Yet this team couldn't beat us. ABs of old would've ripped us apart. Our scrum was even struggling, yet still, we could not be beaten!! COME ON!! IT'S INCREDICBLE!!✌🏿🇿🇦💚💛
Tim, I am a Saffa and I have had a growing respect for your channel and your analysis. And with this you are 100% correct. The whole is greater than the sum of the parts. It gives a new meaning to the word "team". They look to the greater good. There is not one prima Donna amongst them. They are our pride and joy. Thank you for your genuine respect for the game and your honest appraisal of how you felt after each game. Even when England lost. I hope you will be able to visit our beautiful country with its fantastic people (most of them) and get to understand what motivates this team. Massive potential but devastated by the pure greed and opportunism of a relatively small group of individuals who cannot see beyond their own mansions and luxury cars. And for our president to have tried to emulate Madiba, was a travesty. He and his buddies are to blame for the mess we are in. Keep up the great work. I have seen you maturing with every report. Cheers.
Personally I think the 1995 South African World cup team were the G.O.A.T.S. They went into the world cup with zero experience in world cup competitions. They drew a deeply divided country together. They played stopped a rampant and unstoppable Lomu. They took the game to extra time against the widely touted to win New Zealand. You could argue that that team had home ground advantage but that is not entirely true because support for the team was not constant and non support from parliament was very vociferous. It was that Springbok team that laid the foundations for this world cup, Francois Pienaar who started the tradition of exceptional people to captain the Springboks. It was the 1995 team that went out after the world cup and started coaching grass roots rugby in the townships and started initiatives like the junior school rugby leagues. It took a generation of effort, started by the 1995 team of amateurs to create what the Springboks mean now.
Interestingly, the great Jonah Lomu never scored a try against SA.
@@martinlemaitre8691
He never scored against Tyldesley RUFC either…
I agree the 1995 team under Francois was the best South African team to ever win a world cup, those plays went into that tournament as under dogs but they play for a nation , South Africa...they had depth, passion and courage...the greats like Andre Joubert, James Small, Ollie let Roux, Joel Stranskie are just some of the legends who's names will live on for generations to come ...🇿🇦🏉