Edifier S360DB vs Edifier R2750DB || Sound Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- Edifier R2750DB on amazon DE: amzn.to/3diZI1j
Edifier R2750DB on amazon UK: amzn.to/3c7C4V9
Edifier S360DB on amazon DE: amzn.to/3s5XEC0
Edifier S360DB on amazon UK: amzn.to/37aOUl6
Edifier S360DB on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/3br0Sdz
------------------------------
Follow me on:
Instagram - / digitalstereophony
Facebook - / digitalstereophony
-----------------------------
Contact me at:
digitalstereophony@gmail.com
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
-Sound recorded using pair of SE Electronics SE8 mics and Zoom H6 recorder
-Levels matched using SPL meter
-All tone controls set to neutral
Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony
Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony
A fan of your channel. On top of your head, which speakers do you think offer best sound quality for music listening on a desktop (price considered)? Thanks 🙏
Dear friend
Big fan of your work and your inputs.
I plan to purchase new speakers primarily for music in my living room and small outdoor get together.
I'm divided between edifier 2750, 350db & S1000 db and also JBL partybox 100
I really like 2750 but not sure of it's bass response via bluetooth.
News a simple setup. No amp and no sub.
Just plug n Play via BT.
Pls suggest.
I'm quite confused
@Digital Stereophony I read all the 175 Comments, but in your opinion, that eard directly the 360, with some right frequency adjustments, they sound bad? You will not get that magic hi-fi sound that floats in the air?
Can i use this comment section to aka a question? I can’t find an answer.. i have an s350db and i was thinking ti buy a pair of r2750, is there a way to connect the subwoofer from the s350db to the r2750? I’m not an expert so i’m seeking for some help
i love what you're doing. The best way to compare speakers. Very helpful!
Thanks!
The S360DB sounded like someone cut out the entire piece of the lower midrange and threw it into the ocean.
Haha 😆
R2750DB sounds just perfect with that 3 way configuration, u do always have a problem with the 2 way speakers and that's obviously the mids, S360DB and also S350DB have almost too much bass for a 2 way speaker+sub-woofer setup, if those little satellites had a separate mid-range that would be perfect but this way R2750DB is much more logical with its 3 way setup and a significantly lower price. There is only 1 problem for me, they are too big for the desk and I'm not sure if they are suitable for floor standing, any ideas?
The Edifier R2750DB has a very natural sound, one of the best heard on this channel I think. The S360DB on the other hand has some recessed mids which makes them sound hollow.
after trying both I agree, the mids, and the lows above 80 100 hz are very scarce in the 360
Yeah, the 360 was built with space in mind. You can't really get those full mids with small speakers and a sub. Not without Bose-like trickery.
yes
@@brucelivingston2220Boa noite, truques do tipo bose! Pode me explicar? Obrigado.
have u heard these both?? which has more mass ?? the 2850? do you think they go deeper?@@pantumaca9370
Most of the s360/s350 videos dont have this boomy crappy bass and lack of mids... so I took a flyer and bought a set to try. The size of these as compares to the 2750/2850 or even the 200mkiii is better for what I need so I was hoping it was just the way this particular series of videos portrayed their sound... Im glad I did. They are much more natural and balanced than this video makes them out to be for some reason. Very nice, pleasing sound from the S360 set I just brought home and I will be keeping them for sure. As others have stated, the sub isnt up to the task for bass-heavy house or rap music, but it is very balanced and the EQ and crossover is well pairs with the speakers. Overall, I am very happy with this purchase.
Thank you for this comment! It is really helpful.
TNX man, helpfull comment.
Is s350 sub is boomy? Or just sounds right in the place? Not to much, but great low?
Hey man, sorry to bother you a year later but im currently trying to decide between S351DB, S360DB, R2750DB or S2000MKIII, my friend swears i should buy the S2000MKIII's because hes worried that the smaller drivers on the s360 wont be able to compete, altho im leaning toward S360's due to, and this has to be taken with a boulder of salt ofc, the sound demos ive heard, i prefer listening to both the s360 and R2750's... How do you find the 360 to compare to the s2000MKIII?
Very nice tweeter on the 360 with way more detail. Too bad the rest is very unbalanced.....
R2750DB sounds better than the source on my R2700. Lol
Edifier R2750DB
sounds better but different than the source
@@jozepff source is always gonna sound different because it's not played through speakers and then recorded through a mic to get to your ears... Source is played by your headphones 🎧
A sonoridade das caixas S360DB é muito bonita, rica em detalhes, agradável de se ouvir, requer quase nenhuma equalização, porém, o som dos monitores R2750DB são muito mais próximos da realidade, do que nossos ouvidos escutam no mundo real. R2750DB é muito flat e natural, tanto que o som quase não muda quando passa R2750DB para Source Track. Prefiro R2750DB.
Happy to hear Edifier speakers...🤘
R2750DB Great sound!
The only channel in the world who do do this perfectly 🔥👍
Edifier R2750DB тут лидер по видео
СЧ и в целом равномерность частотного спектра у 2750 получше, у 360-х ВЧ за счёт планаров почище, но СЧ по амплитуде завалены(за исключением вокала, поэтому он так рельефно "выпирает", особенно джаз). В целом - 2750 звучат более сбалансированно...Если вам важно, чтобы "цЫкало"- то 360-е... Считаю, что по АЧХ трёх полоски получше "сшиты", и, в некоторых случаях, бас на стерео будет более органичен(имею в виду некоторые старые альбомы, где бас изначально " гуляет" между каналов, - послушайте, например, начало альбома "Revolver" одной довольно известной группы - на системе 2.1 это будет что- то иное, имхо....)
R2750DB sounds WAY closer to the original track. S360DB mids sound recessed.
How does the Edifier S360DB sound more harsh than the 350DB you did a video on. I think you might need to redo the test. I don't know what you changed but even the R270 DB don't sound as good as they should.
For anyone considering either of these for TV, I have both sets and think that the S360 set sounds much better in most if not all tv shows and movies.
And What about music? Wich one is better in that case? Thanks! I'm considering R2850 or S360
@@eliancannizzaro5226 s360 only
@@eliancannizzaro5226..uh surely not for audiophile.
I got s2000mkiii
for the future comparisons of S360DB with something else or completely other speakers, test all speakers with no EQ but if speakers have bass, treble or mode changes etc. you should use these features to made them sound the best because in this video S360DB sounds like garbage which is not true at all and i know that cuz i have it... for example here you could lower the bass with bass knob or another example Edifier S3000 PRO has different modes so you should pick the best sounding mode and then compare, so my point is, use features and setting speakers have with no additional software or hardware EQ and other stuff that are not part of the speakers, maybe SW EQ which everyone could use in the end but if you want to test the most "out of the box" as possible then at least use settings on speakers to make them sound the best as possible
s360db is shit, just accept it😂
@@ercanylmaz967 if it was i would accept it and i would sell it and buy something better or would not buy in the first place 😀 but i think you can go better at that price point but you have to wait for subs on sale and buy 2.0 speakers with sub out, lets say R1700BTs and get a sub if you want / need one but good subs are going for around 300€ in Europe but sometimes are on sale for 200€
anyway, my point was if some product have a feature that you can use to make it sound better why not use it and this is simple bass knob im talking about and i agree, they tuned it badly, there is just too much bass, i have bass knob turned down -4db and even than i completed this adjustment, i used simple software EQ 31hz: -0,5db, 62hz: -1db, 125hz: -2db... but for simpler comparison video he could turned only that bass knob to -5 or -6 db and then theres sub placement but lets keep it as simple as possible 😁 i just mentioned this cuz i found a review where guy even turned that bass knob up +3db...
btw if you are looking for some speakers or headphones i could help you, im not expert but for a past year i jumped on "higher quality sound" train and im watching and reading not only reviews but about how it all works etc and i can tell, its hard to protect your wallet when this gets you 😀
something is really off on this video. i have the s351db and it sounds very clear with good mids. bass is very precise. the s360db is actually better but sounds like shit on this video.
The thing about UA-cam reviews is that too much bass will saturate most microphones and muddy up everything else, specially those "big sounding" speakers.
S360db better for movies, r2750db - better for music :)
Had bought my r1700s after spending immense time on your channel, glad to see its still going well
I'm really surprised how bad the S360DB do in this comparison, especially in the mid section and the bass appears to be very boomy in that setup and environment, i heard other comparisons in treated rooms and it sounded so much better there even giving the S3000's a run for their money.
not to mention that it comes very sharp in some parts, where the 2750s are not so penetrating and more relaxed and even.
same here i wish it was done on a well treated room
I listen with STX + r1280dbs. s360 is punch bass. Good to movies. Maybe war action games. 2750 is soft, smooth, full frequencies. Great for music. I like detailed and soft audio.
But both are good. I want to see klipsh active PM.
Edifier R2750DB with Edifier T5 better .
i wish you could do it in a dead or not so reflective space
The sound quality for me is a comparison of how much the sound seems to be passing through a water pipe. the more open the sound, the better. Comparing the two, it seems that the sound of the S360DB is passing through a water pipe while on the R2750DB the sound is there, in front of you.
S360DB too boomy
Vote for R2750DB
Here is me hearing this video on my S360DB. Maybe it's you setup, or youtube, but the S360DB is bad in this video!
But here in my setup (computer with not much space), the mids are a little bit recessed, but the highs and lows are perfect (V shaped). Still, I enjoy the mids a lot and I do have a 6XX headphone (king of mids). Still, they are obviously not a monitor speaker, but they are VERY fun to listen to and to see movies! The bass response is excelent and it extends better than the 2750DB,but it is not overwhelming at any point.
Something in this video is off, because they did a videos on the 350b and they sounded significantly better.
Is the 2.1 setup good for pc in small room? I’m deciding to get the s350db or r2750db.
@@Darrentzx I love my S360DB. I went to the store to check all edifier models, and the S360DB is better than the s350DB! I would recommend it a lot, you just have to play with the bass positioning in your room. Because the bass is WIFI, it's very easy to move it! Also, compared to "studio monitors", i really think that they lack subbass, so the S360db is funnier to listen to
@@GabrielACGama alright i’ll definitely consider the s360db. Thanks!
Sono d'accordo con te, non ho mai sentito le 360 suonare così male. Strano che anche in questo canale qualunque video vedi per ascoltare questo sistema, suonino alla grande e non riesco a capire come mai adesso no! 🤔🤔🤔
S360db has better detail and clarity on high frequency.... but, too much and overall sound a bit boxy. R2750db lacking something or blank on low mid range. I believe both system can get better tone balance with nice EQ preamp add on.
I'd like to point out that I think the biggest reason why the S360DB's treble appears to be crispier is because of the recording microphone alignment.
In case of the S360DB they point at the tweeters, therefore their sound is captured directly.
Regarding the R2750db microphones point roughly between the sub and mid cones.
There is a reason why there is a rule to listen to speakers with tweeters at ear level (or more specifically ear level precisely between tweeter and woofer cone).
So I think that's why the R2750DB sounds less crisp, not because it's treble is inferior.
The bass won't be as good as well, a dedicated sub will always sound better than the bass reproduced on a 2.0 system.
Hi guys, I need help. I have visited several sound stores and asked about the Edififer R2850.
I have been told that Edifier in general does not provide good sound and this has come to my attention because of the very good comments I have heard on this channel. In my country, Argentina, there is not a single store that has Edifier equipment, except for the official store which, unfortunately, does not have a showroom and they only sell their products online. In other words, I would have to buy it without having heard it. Could you help me decide? Do you think I should "risk" buying it?
I have been told that Edifier is not hifi and provides sound far below any hifi stereo system. Is that true? Does this Edififer model worth it?
Are there maybe some better options for the same price?
Thank you and please excuse me for my bad English.
First of all is the quality of your sound card. I have an old Creative 2.1 but the satellites are changed with Sony speakers from a mini hifi system. The upgrade of the quality was dramatic and miraculous. The satellites are much bigger of course but I can't do without them. Another point is that you must put 3 cones under the SW. Bronze cones and at any size you can find. (Faster bass control - less boom). Cables also can destroy sound if cheap. I tested soooo many.. I prefer now HAMA cables (rca or jack 3.5) 5 star version those with the sleeve. Great overall!. I wouldn't give 500 € for 2.1 speakers. Try to find a good sub used and add a Sony 2 way pair.. (used I paid 10 € for it).. 💪😎👍 ❤️
Listening this through s360db =)
2750DB sound level seems higher so not easy to compare.
Edifler R27500DB Sound 승 한표
the sound Edifier S360DB is much more Havier and produce quality sound as well as the Edifier R2750DB voice is much more sharp but the problem with this is that if you listen to the song in a loud voice for a long time, then it will be annoying
I like R2750DB for more soft balanced sound, but it have background noise like R2700 model? 360DB good for wireless subwoofer and more compact size. Mb 360DB even have more clearly sound btw.
No, R2750DB has very little hiss
Cặp loa R2750DB nghe chi tiết hơn cặp loa S360DB. Chính xác là như vậy!
You have to be there listening to the actual speakers to appreciate the differences and not listening through other speakers, is it just me that thinks this?
Just you
S360 is way too boomy, R2750 destroys these in every way. The S360 might go lower with the added sub. But it’s a no go if the Mids are being affected.
boomy and tinny
thanks! the R2750DB aren't bad for their price. the other pair is utter garbage IMO
What is the great option for R2750DB price?
I'm worried if it your speaker/headphone that actually sound horrible
i have S360DB and its very good but you have to turn down bass, i have -4db bass on speaker and in EQ 31hz: -1db, 62hz: -1db, 125hz: -2db, 250hz: -1db
I agree with your assessment, the S360DB has no trouble with any aspect of the sound spectrum when being fed by a good audio source, and this is key. I have mine connected to a Nu-Audio sound card and it sounds amazing. The great extra benefit with these speakers, although it drops the quality, is to simply turn off the sub late at night and just use the two speakers on low volume for a great audio experience when listening to music or watching movies.
Жал что я продал свой r2750db за 150$. Больше не слышал такой чистый звук. Сейчас они стоить у нас 180$
i have a 2700 and it has really good bass ..you almost dont need a sub. great for music AND movies. just spin that bass knob. also have a 350db and its bass is a mess, difficult to adjust. it needs more controls . is the 360 better in sub adjustment than the 350?
350 vs 360 video??
S360DB is a slap in your ears!
S360DB terrible on mid tones
The only advantage of the S360DB is deeper albeit sometimes muddy bass. The R2750DB || is the clear winner in all other frequencies. This a case where cheaper is better.
r2750 is like a can sound, it's supposed to be like that? it's light, metallic and it resonates too long.. s360db sounds like a pyramid figure.. dunno, both suck!?
Maybe your own speaker or headphone that suck.
Let me know the better option for the price, I'm still confused to decide in this price range.
У 360db - планарные твитеры, отсюда и более выраженные ВЧ, и цена... Но СЧ и в целом частотный диапазон у 2750db более сбалансированы...
Вот мучаюсь выбором между этими системами и немогу до конца понять толи у них СЧ одинаково правильные толи у 360 небольшой провал по сравнению с 2750.
@@ВладимирПынин-в2м По-моему эти системы для очень разных применений. 2750 - для прослушивания музыки в комнате, можно к телеку подключить, можно и саб докупить. 360db - мелкие сателлиты с сабом без каких-либо регулировок - больше подходит для подключения к компьютеру.
2750 более открытая середина ,более объёмный звук ,360 акцент смещен в высокочастотный спектр ,середина немного приглушена
EDIFIER is always on fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥. I Love so much EDIFIER speakers they never failed me on any way. But some more expensive brands failed do badly.
I bought both to test them and I stayed with the 2750, they seem more musical and more complete, above all I think that the 360 subwoofer is not up to the task and the small size of their boxes may take their toll.
For me the 360 falters in some points like the voices that do not make the price difference attractive
do you miss the idea of having a subwoofer w/ the 2750? I'm about to commit to a purchase and I have no idea which to pick
2750DB MORE NATURAL
On my look...
360DB EDIFIER - Home, Gaming, Music, Cinema
2750 EDIFIER - PUBLIC ATMO CLASSICAL (this one is in my use now)
sounds pretty good...i may step up to the S360DB with wireless subwoofer....or the S2000MK3 or the S3000Pro .... i need them for the TV .....which of the three would you get for movies / sports / everyday TV / and music....thx in advance...cheers from Vulcan Canada
comprei r2750 db com suboofer 5t som perfeito!!
Tô pensando em comprar essa mesma configuração. Conseguiu comprar por quanto ?
Acabei de comprar hoje mas ainda não testei.. O que achas dos graves? São fortes?
Thank you very much!
2750 sounds more like a typical loud speaker to me.
both very good...
Please, Edifier R2850DB.
Yeap please... I want too to know if i should wait for them to be available on the market here in Greece.
This is completely misleading! due to the differences in size, the microphones should always be placed at the same height, opposite the small speakers!!
the r2750db sound better for music, the 360 are more for cinema. winner the 2750db
Beautiful flat sound from the 2750s
I did get the R2750 in part after watching an earlier video of urs. Thank you for all the help!!!!!
Thank you @Digital Stereophony. Your videos are so damn helpful, and no one is doing what ur doing. Really helps people, especially with some outlook of Edifier for so many out there.
S360DB does sound quite V in comparison. I think it was a wise move, picking up the s2750db, and for 80 dollars less! [not to mention, I'll be adding a sub or two with this, so no missed low ends!
did you add the sub? what sub do you recommed for this 2750db?
@@JosephKarthic I had a 12inch Chinese sub with my R2600s - so I'm going to assume one will need a sub with the 2750db's also. I don't have my system with me atm by I would recommend any decent 10inch or 12inch sub with these. I have a couple of 10inch ones - found a Taga Harmony TWS-90 at a good price, very nice sub. Anything similar should work well. A sub will definitely 'complete' the sound.
@@divinginthedeep thanks for the help, which one is better S2000 mkiii or the 2750db? Also i dont see this 2750 in edifier website..only the 2850, is this genuine?
@@JosephKarthic The 2850 is most definitely genuine - I think they must have just released it - probably the bluetooth successor the the r2800.
I've heard that the s2000 is better on specs and probably even sound. It is the premium one in these. But you'd still be looking to add a sub anyhow. The 2850 though may be quite powerful - the bass driver is 8 inches, so that's quite a lot. On this channel, there are soundtests of the 2800 I think and on the rest of YT also, so I think 2850 and s2000 may be comparable, 2850 may have more volume and bass, s2000 may have better sound quality. Again, that's what I think so, keep that in mind.
Actually i was asking abt the 2750db , maybe it's discontinued after 2850... Anyways i previously had Logitech z623 which failed after a power surge... Now 2750db is affordable to me and i add a sub later... Should i buy it ? Or is there better alternative at this price point?
would like to have an advise as I am still indecisive either S360db or R2750db+t5.
It is for the usage of living hall with approximately 8-10 feet away.
i love to have a balanced of vocal+mid+soft bass (movie/music/ps4 gaming).
I was recommended to go for s360db as it has hi-res audio but still aint sure about it as i cant get my hands to test it in-person on the sound quality for both models.
appreciate your kind advise as you have done many videos of comparison. thanks.
Hey did you ever get the 2750's? I can't I even find any for sell!
Did you choose anything ? I am right in the same position : s360 vs R2750+ T5.
This same withe me, can't really decide between 360db and 2750 +sub. Was thinking about 2000MK2 or s2000pro
Hello, you're doing great job!! I own r2750db and i want to connect them to a sub.
I am thinking about Yamaha NS-SW050, whats your opinion or do you have other suggestions? My room is about 10 m2, thank you!!
2750db
S 360 only boomy bass and sparkling high frequencies
I bought R2750DB and waiting to its delivery. Now I will add a subwoofer. Not sure if I get T5 it may not make difference.
these videos must be watched with headphones to understand the difference ... if the quality is even better
I love r2750 sound
I really like the sound of yamaha. It is close to the original music in this and your other videos, not too colored but has a deep, middle and high enough.
I would like Yamaha HS8 as like Hifi speakers to listening to music and movies. Is this able to works? Left and right speaker from each other 2,5m and 3-4 from the listener. Thanks for help
Greetings from Colombia, which of the two would be ideal for a small coffee bar?
Edifier R2750DB ... that's way too obvious in MAN ON FIRE.
Get R2750 and add a sub to get best of both worlds
How the systems were connected (SPDIF or Analog RCA)?
S360 slighty better play from internal DSP, connected to optical toslink.
Hello! I listen to rock music often and mostly I do lots of online conference calls. Do you have any suggestions under $150? I want to hear the voices very clearly.
Edifier R1700BTs
R1700BTs cost $10 more ($160) than R1700BT ($150), but for the better remote, updated bluetooth, and ability to directly add a subwoofer-I would say it's worth it if you're going to go for R1700
@@DSAUDIOreview Thank you!
@@jmporkbob Thank you!
@@jmporkbob I just bought the Edifier R1700BTs and they are good. However my only comparison are a set of $50 2.1 logitechs from 2005 or a $1250 5.2 home theater system.
Now my biggest complaint is the vocals aren't clear. They sound muddy or dark to me. You could also use a sub to pull in some of the deep lows that the small 4" drivers can't recreate.
I sent an email to Edifier and see if they have another product for me. I was looking at the S1000MkII or S2000MkIII but those are $350 and $400.
You could get a set of headphones that do well in that point. I'd assume you'd be talking during an online conference call so you blasting other people's voices your mic is going to pick that up.
Wow, the shelves sounded better than the minions with a drumset
I have edifier r2750db + velodyne cht-8r = the best for my little room(11m2)
I am thinking of doing something similar as my set up, may I ask if you do this can you still control the balance (treble/bass) from the knobs on the r2750? As in if I adjust the bass on the r2750 does that also adjust the output of the sub or do you need to control the sub separately?
@@sam00951 через колонки выход саба регулируется тоже ,
Hope too hear some audio tracks from Ehrling. It's good for bass audio test. 😉
I really like the R2750DB, but aren't they two big when you have them on your desk and sit in front of your pc?
I have a similarly sized pair of speakers that I have on my desk. You just gotta have a big desk for it to work.
По мне, R2750DB лучше середину прорабатывает.
Scusami tra le 2 quale mi consigli? Grazie
2750 DB win.
Do you think you will ever get your hands on the Vanatoo t0’s?
2750 wins by a knockout!
Edifier R2750DB 👍
Not the best subwoofer solution -> Edifier S360DB 😐
Take away from this video: R2750DB can indeed take on the bass without the need for another sub.
BEHRINGER TRUTH VS JBL PLEASE!
How many millions are such speaker stands worth?
plenty of milions
S360db👉🏽⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍🏼
A 3 ways speaker always wins.
R2750 very much better!
hello, how long is the cable between the speakers 360db?
I have these speakers. I’d say it’s about 8 or 9 ft long.
R2750db better than s350db
360 bad sound! only bass!
Which edifier is top of the line ? Anyone?
i think S3000 PRO, and if you count Airpulse then maybe A300 PRO
La.rispodta ai medio alti e migliore.per le r2750
edifier r2000db vs s350db ?
s 360 лучше намного а то что бас глушить все частоты всем пофиг, буфер нужно правильно расположить в помещение
why no more REW freq test/compare?
Measuring maelfunctuion during recording session
@@DSAUDIOreview
Before or after recording, just show us the graph...
For this batch of videos there will be no frequency graphs. Sorry