Cant compare Cause they are different renditions and styles all.together. Different feels. Both give me.different emotions. NE versions Id say more light hearted. B2M More contemplative If that makes any sense lol U get it
Boys to men's version was a slick rendition but if I have to choose I must go with the original, it's a certain energy you feel every time you here it.
@@tonyfelder1206 You would be surprised how many songs B2M Have covered😳 They have a huge catalog of covers ie The Temps Just my imagination, Klmaxx I Miss You, Lonestar Amazed. They have so many. They have Spanish covers and fun stuff like from The movie Grease Beauty school drop out LOL
New Edition, hands down! They had the vocals, charisma, sex appeal, and stage presence. They were overall entertainers. I'd categorize Boyz II Men as pure vocalists
This is a good one. Though NOTHING can compare to the original, I've always thought Boyz II Men's version was just as good. They did this track some serious justice💯
"Boyz II Men" 1. Ill Make Love To You 2. Its So Hard To Say Goodbye 3. End of The Road 4. Hey Lover 5. A Song For Mama 6. Motownphilly 7. Please Dont Go 8. On Bended Knee 9. I Will Get There 10. In The Still of The Night 11. Come Home With Me 12. One Sweet Day 13. 4 Seasons of Loneliness 14. If I Ever Fall In Love 15. Water Dry 16. Vibin 17. The Color of Love 18. Pass You By 19. Sensitivity 20. Let It Snow Vs "New Edition" 1. If It Isnt Love 2. Youre Not My Kind of Girl 3. Earth Angel 4. Candy Girl 5. Can You Stand The Rain 6. Count Me Out 7. A Little Bit of Love 8. Cool It Now 9. Im Comin Home 10. Mr Telephone Man 11. With You All The Way 12. One More Day 13. You Dont Have To Worry 14. Hit Me Off 15. Once In A Lifetime Groove 16. Im Still In Love With You 17. Lost In Love 18. Oh Yeah It Feels So Good 19. Is This The End 20. Hot 2Nite
After listening to both groups, I give props to both groups for holding it down. However, I give much more respect to Boyz ll Men because they did their own rendition of "Can You Stand The Rain" in a Capella. That shows me that whether it's with music or not, they can beast the song. If you get N.E. to do it in a Capella, do you think the sound will still be there? Overall, madd respect to both groups for doing their thing.
Man please New Edition perfected this song everybody else just tried to lip sync it .lol I love boys to Men but N.E. is in a class of their own. Like the Jackson's was in a class of their own.
It's a metaphor man...lol lip sync mean they just song it almost exactly like N.E. but they just did it without music to show it's their own style. But they did sound very good though.
I love both versions and cannot choose a winner. Both groups brought the song home in their own unique way. The ending of the video was so adorable and kept me smiling. :).
New Edition has more emotional clarity for me. The lead vocals of the other version undermines this clarity with all the twiddly 'vocal effects' he deploys that might be skilful but which, for me, detracts from the emotional flow contained in the melody. A lot of vocalists, especially these days, need to remember that often less is more.
The Original by New Edition the greatest version that will ever be!!!!!!! It has so much more vocal emotion, a true photograph of a outstanding time in music !!Boys to Men did a good rendition ...
This is a mood thing. Ill say NE kept their song and B2M did it justice. Acapella too! Temptations, New Edition, Boyz 2 Men, greatest pure singing groups ever. Groups made of lead singers.
I think in terms of a complete song you have to give it to NE. However the B2M version, which is the one I grew up with has a certain poignancy to it. I also think B2M have more singers in their group and it shows in the power of their voices. Doing it acapella gives it a very different feel. I love both and switch between them depending on my mood. Wanya usually can’t be topped but Johnny Gill’s whoah-ooh-oh-ooh-ohhhhhh! definitely has the edge for me in the bridge.
I listened to New Edition's version all the way through. When Boyz II Men began, I knew I was ready to comment...I waited. I waited until halfway through Boyz II Men's version. I grew up alongside New Edition. I have enjoyed Boyz II Men (we are the same ages). There is no comparison, NEW EDITION ALL THE WAY. When songs are produced and sang to perfection...every other version will fall flat in comparison. Example: Respect by Otis Redding (I am a fan) and Aretha Franklin. Her version was commercially better. There are other songs that are the same way. Boyz II Men paid great tribute to New Edition. Boyz II Men's version is good, but, in comparison; New Edition's is better. Footnote: I did not know Boyz II Men recorded this song.
This is a tough one they’re both great for different reasons and time periods. I grew up in the 90’s so the B2M version holds significance for me personally but both are classics.
I have to give Boyz II Men the thumbs up on this one. A Cappella requires a special skill to produce pitch and harmony so refined it sounds like a symphony orchestra in the background of the lead singer. There's no comparison to the smooth melodic tones they deliver from deep within their souls minus man made instruments. New Edition is good but Boyz II Men is better.
Without a doubt, "NE"! Still remember hearing this for the first time being played on the radio 📻 and saying, "whose voice is that?" This was my introduction to "Johnny Gill." 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶💖🔥This jam is still on my playlist.💿💃🏾💝🤳🏾
No comparison...New Edition. But kudos to B2M...they are paying homage in a beautiful way
"No comparison" was my first thought when I saw the title lol. Even the music NE did as kids outweighs B2M discography
I like the original but Boyz II Men = greatest of all time
I was going to type the same comment!
Boyz ll men sounds better.. bit the 1st is a classic.. But no comparison is stretching it very far
Cant compare
Cause they are different renditions and styles all.together.
Different feels.
Both give me.different emotions.
NE versions
Id say more light hearted.
B2M
More contemplative
If that makes any sense lol
U get it
Boys to men's version was a slick rendition but if I have to choose I must go with the original, it's a certain energy you feel every time you here it.
New Edition reigns supreme on this one. I believe this my first time hearing Boz II Men's rendition.
I wasn’t even aware boys 2 men had a version? 😭😭 New edition’s version is a staple in 80s r&b. Period.
I didn't know about the cover either. And I'm a humongous fan 🤔🤔🤔🤔.
@@tonyfelder1206 You would be surprised how many songs B2M Have covered😳 They have a huge catalog of covers ie The Temps Just my imagination, Klmaxx I Miss You, Lonestar Amazed. They have so many. They have Spanish covers and fun stuff like from The movie Grease Beauty school drop out LOL
New Edition's original just has more to it I think.
When you first hear Johnny Gill hit that note, it's on!! Love Boyz 2 Men but NE all day on this one!!
Ok, I'm 60 years old and I love the acapella rendition by Boyz II Men. The vocals are spot on. But, New Edition owns this song!
New Edition and it’s not even close
Rite
Agreed!
I’m a big fan them both I undoubtedly give this to my first favorites NE!
New Edition. The original is like when do something from the heart, it is done with more passionate intent to send a message.
I agree
darren New Edition will get EVERYBODY dancing. 💞
@@heathertea2704 No argument there.
love boyz to men but they can't stand the rain. johnny gill's voice reign supreme.
😂😂
New Edition, hands down! They had the vocals, charisma, sex appeal, and stage presence. They were overall entertainers.
I'd categorize Boyz II Men as pure vocalists
New Edition aint had NO vocals..
Their like take 6 a vocal group thus a better group
New Edition is better even though Boys II Men gave “Can You Stand The Rain” an unique twist singing acapella.🎶
Both.. Am fan of both bands.. Different voices.. Different music instruments, miss this great music nowadays ❤️❤️❤️
New Edition. Hands down!! Even though I loved both groups and both sounded beautiful💖 and that ending had me rollin😂
New Edition...nuff said
This is a good one. Though NOTHING can compare to the original, I've always thought Boyz II Men's version was just as good. They did this track some serious justice💯
New Edition hands down
I love both groups renditions of this classic song. Everyone stay safe and be blessed. 🍻💕
P. S. The ending of the vid was priceless, thank you 😄😄😘😘
I know I'm representing all South Africans when I say New Edition takes the cup!!💞
New Edition...... hands down 🥰
New Edition ☝🏽🥇❤
I felt depressed with Boyz II Men’s version and just rewinded back to New edition
LMAO
Come on man! N.E. all day!
... Tru.. But Boys 2 Men slay di acapella fi real.. Their vocals are sublime..
I can't choose between the two...I just can't 😭
"Boyz II Men"
1. Ill Make Love To You
2. Its So Hard To Say Goodbye
3. End of The Road
4. Hey Lover
5. A Song For Mama
6. Motownphilly
7. Please Dont Go
8. On Bended Knee
9. I Will Get There
10. In The Still of The Night
11. Come Home With Me
12. One Sweet Day
13. 4 Seasons of Loneliness
14. If I Ever Fall In Love
15. Water Dry
16. Vibin
17. The Color of Love
18. Pass You By
19. Sensitivity
20. Let It Snow
Vs
"New Edition"
1. If It Isnt Love
2. Youre Not My Kind of Girl
3. Earth Angel
4. Candy Girl
5. Can You Stand The Rain
6. Count Me Out
7. A Little Bit of Love
8. Cool It Now
9. Im Comin Home
10. Mr Telephone Man
11. With You All The Way
12. One More Day
13. You Dont Have To Worry
14. Hit Me Off
15. Once In A Lifetime Groove
16. Im Still In Love With You
17. Lost In Love
18. Oh Yeah It Feels So Good
19. Is This The End
20. Hot 2Nite
Boyz II Men’s version was super dope! First time hearing it...
Shockingly, both are classics now!
Agree and both groups are legendary
After listening to both groups, I give props to both groups for holding it down. However, I give much more respect to Boyz ll Men because they did their own rendition of "Can You Stand The Rain" in a Capella. That shows me that whether it's with music or not, they can beast the song. If you get N.E. to do it in a Capella, do you think the sound will still be there? Overall, madd respect to both groups for doing their thing.
I totally agree.
🤯 finally someone said it!
They have it here on YT acapella also!❤ Boyz 2 Men are outstanding, but Johnny's mature, classy, sensual, powerful voice, is simply unmatched!❤❤❤
This comment is blasphemy. Of course N.E. can sing it great a cappella! They were real singers, too. What do you think they are, Milli Vanilli?
This is like Lakers of the 80s vs the Bulls of the 90s!!!
Must go with the original on this one. New Edition
New Edition, no more said.
DUDE STOP PLAYING ON YOUR CHANNE, THIS IS NOT EVEN A QUESTION WORTH AN ANSWER....BUT OK NE HANDS DOWN.
gotta keep the content flowin...we bored from the quarantine
Black Butterfly IKR
Awww man why you do this? This is my first hearing Boyz to Men and they sound amazing! I don't want to pick! I enjoyed both! 😆💕
Only 17 seconds in. New Edition is the winner.
New edition
New Edition, All Day, Every Day, Nuff said!!!!! However, I still love Boys 2 Men ☺️
Of course, New Edition but B2M did great with the break down of perfectly blended harmonious vocals!💖😍👍💯
Love both groups, but new edition always.
I like both but i love ACAPELLA SINGING
Me also. Well said 😊
Yes,Agreed. Four perfect ears and vocals in concerted effort 🥰💯
Smfh. It's New Edition
Especially when it's done "right"
Love both with their own styles one relaxing music, one to getting you in the mood
😂😉💓💕👬🌻🌹🌎💋☝
NEW EDITION IT THE TRUTH, BOYS 2 MEN IS THE TRUTH WHEN IT COMES TO ACAPALA.
Man please New Edition perfected this song everybody else just tried to lip sync it .lol I love boys to Men but N.E. is in a class of their own. Like the Jackson's was in a class of their own.
The Jacksons!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It's a metaphor man...lol lip sync mean they just song it almost exactly like N.E. but they just did it without music to show it's their own style. But they did sound very good though.
New Edition
I love both versions and cannot choose a winner. Both groups brought the song home in their own unique way. The ending of the video was so adorable and kept me smiling. :).
No one touches New Edition in this groove! ....
Respeck yo elders they came b4 u and taught u some thangs n.e. all the way
I love both... too much talent to choose💞
They both are as good as each other Peace to you
Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis all day
Right.
Some songs don't need to be done over.
Thank you!
2021 New Edition
This is not fair! Do you know why? If Boyz II would have did it first we would say they did it better then New Edition.
New Edition has more emotional clarity for me. The lead vocals of the other version undermines this clarity with all the twiddly 'vocal effects' he deploys that might be skilful but which, for me, detracts from the emotional flow contained in the melody. A lot of vocalists, especially these days, need to remember that often less is more.
The Original by New Edition the greatest version that will ever be!!!!!!! It has so much more vocal emotion, a true photograph of a outstanding time in music !!Boys to Men did a good rendition ...
Yes!!!!
Hear is how great New Edition verison is. I'm not about to listen to B2M version of it, and I never heard and don't want to. Thank You.
Come on, Johnny! I want to hear it Acapoco ☺
No question about it New Edition nailed it for me !
N.E. "This we know for sure"
New edition . but I still listen to both till this day
Hell 2 the big N0 New Edition 0wn this boys 2 men didn't come🤯 close New 🧚🏿♂️Edition🧚🏿♀️.💞💞💞
I'm pretty sure Boyz II Men's version was ‘97***
Yeah u right. Evolution released 97
New Edition 💗
Johnny 💗
All day
No doubt
Thank you💗
Jimmy Jam💗
Terry Lewis💗
The absolute best generation to grow up in! We had that!
Beautiful song always. Both versions are good but NE will have my vote. The first version brings good memories and feelings behind it.
NEW EDITION ! 👏👏👏
This is a mood thing. Ill say NE kept their song and B2M did it justice. Acapella too!
Temptations, New Edition, Boyz 2 Men, greatest pure singing groups ever. Groups made of lead singers.
Come on; New Edition, obviously. The way New Edition handles the start of the song is a work of art in itself.
💯
New Edition's version is always the best classic.
Much respect ti boys 2 men..for covering their mentors with class and style
Boyz 2 Men! Timeless sound and quality. Original is a classic but the remake always sounds new.
No contest....New Edition for the win!🏆
New Edition! I remember when they first hit the scene when I was in junior high school, so they hold a close place in my heart.
The memories, Lord...
Boys 11 Men- hats off!!! Nobody without music can come close in comparison to this group.
New Edition hands down the owned that song when they sing it
The production and the feeling in the air on New Edition's version leaves no room for competition on this one. N
I think in terms of a complete song you have to give it to NE. However the B2M version, which is the one I grew up with has a certain poignancy to it. I also think B2M have more singers in their group and it shows in the power of their voices. Doing it acapella gives it a very different feel. I love both and switch between them depending on my mood. Wanya usually can’t be topped but Johnny Gill’s whoah-ooh-oh-ooh-ohhhhhh! definitely has the edge for me in the bridge.
Boyz II Mens vesion is the one I conceived my twins to, so I gotta go with that version
I'll have to say New Edition I mean Johnny Gills harmony in the background was just beautiful. But B2M did a good job.
New Edition without question. Boys II Men are one of the best vocal groups ever. I like there version also but New Editions was better.
I listened to New Edition's version all the way through. When Boyz II Men began, I knew I was ready to comment...I waited. I waited until halfway through Boyz II Men's version.
I grew up alongside New Edition. I have enjoyed Boyz II Men (we are the same ages). There is no comparison, NEW EDITION ALL THE WAY.
When songs are produced and sang to perfection...every other version will fall flat in comparison. Example: Respect by Otis Redding (I am a fan) and Aretha Franklin. Her version was commercially better. There are other songs that are the same way.
Boyz II Men paid great tribute to New Edition. Boyz II Men's version is good, but, in comparison; New Edition's is better. Footnote: I did not know Boyz II Men recorded this song.
New Edition.
This is a tough one they’re both great for different reasons and time periods. I grew up in the 90’s so the B2M version holds significance for me personally but both are classics.
The original definitely New Edition
I have to give Boyz II Men the thumbs up on this one. A Cappella requires a special skill to produce pitch and harmony so refined it sounds like a symphony orchestra in the background of the lead singer. There's no comparison to the smooth melodic tones they deliver from deep within their souls minus man made instruments. New Edition is good but Boyz II Men is better.
Hands down NE! Period ❤️❤️🔥🔥👏👏
Without a doubt, "NE"! Still remember hearing this for the first time being played on the radio 📻 and saying, "whose voice is that?" This was my introduction to "Johnny Gill." 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶💖🔥This jam is still on my playlist.💿💃🏾💝🤳🏾
Is this really a question? Millennials!!!
Love New Edition with Johnny Gill. They were much better with him. However, without a doubt Boyz I l Men. Clearly.
Don't forget if it wasn't for New Editions Mike Bivins it wouldn't be No Boyz to Men
NE did it slightly better
I lean towards the Boyz to Men version though I love both. How about Bobby Womack vs KCI " If You Think You're Lonely Now" who did it better?
B2M all the voices blended together
Please!!!!!!! Somebody don't know music
@@stylesj.4752 Yes, that'd be you.
The original is always better. B2M killed it tho.
NEW EDITION!!!
New Edition, no doubt !!!
BOYZ II MEN 🎵🎤🎙🎶
New Edition birthed Boyz II Men, it's not even a question!
New Edition of course! 🔥🔥🔥
Are y'all CRAZY😂😂😂😂 NEW EDITION all day baybee!!!!💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
New Edition all day!!!
Boyz II Men were better singers but New Editions version was better and more heart felt. I like them both but New Edition Wins!