How Harvey Milk Changed the Gay Rights Movement
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 кві 2018
- Join the Club: www.dollarshaveclub.com/filmradar
This video essay/documentary hybrid centers around Harvey Milk, and the historical context surrounding the gay rights movement of the time. Using footage from Gus Van Sant's brilliant biopic "Milk", "The Times of Harvey Milk"(the documentary that inspired it) as well as a documentary named "Stonewall Uprising". I think it's an important piece of history that's often overlooked, to look back on the way things were helps us to realize how far we've come, because of people like Harvey Milk standing up for something they believe in.
Thanks to our sponsor Dollar Shave Club, new members get their 1 st month of the ‘Sh*t, Shower, Shave’ Starter
Set including the Executive Razor and trial-sized versions of their Shave Butter, Body Cleanser and One Wipe
Charlies’ Butt Wipes for ONLY $5 with FREE shipping. After that razors are just a few bucks a month.
www.dollarshaveclub.com/filmradar
Support my videos through Patreon:
/ filmradar
Or through a one-time PayPal donation:
www.paypal.me/danielnetzel
Follow me:
/ filmradar
/ film_radar
/ thefilmradar - Фільми й анімація
Thank you for watching! If you have any suggestions for future videos I'd love to hear them! And be sure to check out the Sh*t, Shower, and Shave Trial Kit!
www.dollarshaveclub.com
Any likes or shares(here or reddit/twitter/etc) are greatly appreciated!
Thank you for the feedback! I'm glad you enjoyed it, I always like when someone can find something new in my videos :)
have you done a video on stonewall/ the stonewall movie? the real history and/or the difference from the movie would be an interesting topic
I would suggest "Victim" with Dirk Bogarde, made in 1961. It's about an English married barrister who is about to be made judge. He finds out that an acquaintance commits suicide because of a blackmail scheme going on. People were being sent telegrams threatening to "out" people and it created a panic. Bogarde is great in this, and it had to be a difficult part to play, because he himself at the time was a closeted gay man. Yet the fact that he was in it was a huge statement. Plus at the time it had to be made in the UK, the subject matter was such that the US would never have made it, due to the Production Code and the power of the Catholic Church. As an avid reader of Roger Ebert, I found out about it through his "Great Movies" column. I believe the essay is still up on his website, it's a beautiful piece of writing, as is most everything he wrote.
being gay is a sin
This is Vox visual quality but instead of an entire team it's done by a single man, take notes Vox, take notes... - Thomas
Could not have said it better myself Storytellers. His editing is truly most impressive.
Damn dude, that's a hell of a compliment coming from you! Thanks Thomas, I appreciate it. Now if Vox wanted to hire me on...I wouldn't necessarily say no to that :P
STOP IT, I'M BLUSHING.
Great stuff. Regarding Stonewall, we should clarify against what they faught back: regular police brutalizing
Oh 100%, this night in particular just happened to be that straw that broke the camel's back.
Seriously who the hell disliked
Wrong the real enemy was the oppression of the class of people ruled by emotions and closed minded
Really powerful video, I've been loving this new style you've been making-it's really blending the line between documentary and essay.
Thanks Jack, I really appreciate that! I've been trying to challenge myself to change the format a little bit, and they've been really fun to make!
I agree. This video weaves documentary, essay, (& film) masterfully well. A video like this could have been jumbled in presentation, but you make it flow wonderfully.
Daww, thanks Will, I appreciate you saying so! I worried about how the presentation would work, I'm glad you enjoyed it!
You really did quite a good job with it man. :)
I’m so grateful for Harvey Milk. My grandmother helped with his campaign in San Francisco. I’m very proud of her and the work she and her friends did.
I bet you aren't proud of Milk enabling Jim Jones, ha?
I was mentored by Harvey. Met him Jan 1 1972. I was still 18. Out. Living @ home. A fine tribute. Thanks
Did you know the boys he was dating too?
Great vid, Daniel! I wrote my college thesis on this topic -- literally on this exact timeline (1945-Milk). Coming from someone who spent too long researching this, I can tell you, you nailed it. Well done. (9:03 -- Just as important as Stonewall)
Thanks, Will! That's really cool, the timeline just seemed so fitting to me, because that's the history that Harvey grew up in. These days a lot of young people might wonder why so many lived in the closet for so long, but those who think that way are forgetting just how different of a world we lived in just a few decades ago. I really appreciate that, thank you for saying so! And yes, totally agree. Stonewall was a crucial moment where the gay community decided they would no longer be bullied into submission, Harvey Milk's candidacy and subsequent stint in office sparked a movement to bring that community out into the open, without which, who knows where the movement would be today.
I wrote a paper on the gay rights movement and I absolutely hate that he is not talked about
I’m not crying, you’re crying...
How come you never mentioned marsha p johnson? A trans women who founded the pride march, without her Harvey Milk wouldnt have had the political support he gained from a politicized LGBT+ community, thanks mainly to Marsha.
This video started off after working on my last video about the Zodiac killer, and all that 60's San Francisco history led me to think about the Gus Van Sant film "Milk", so the video started with the intention of discussing the film mostly, and then I pivoted to more of the historical stuff that you see in the video now. So basically, it was always going to be about Harvey Milk, and that meant leaving out a lot of important names and events for the sake of staying on task. There were many people who were instrumental in the movement, many more than just Harvey Milk, but if I've learned anything from making these videos it's that people really don't like if you continue to stray too far off topic. I guess I could have made the video broader in scope to discuss the movement as a whole, because there are plenty of amazing stories besides just Harvey's that are worth sharing, but I had already spent a fair amount of time heading in the direction of this being a Milk-centered video that to pivot that late in the process would have meant missing my deadline.
Totally understandable, i said wrote what because you could of easily mentioned Marsha since you spoke about the Stonewall riots AND even the first pride marches. However i understand where you are coming from and it didnt detract the quality of your video. Thanks for replying and i'll be sure to share your video as well. Its a great summary anyhow on this topic and a good introductory to LGBT+ politics anyway :D Looking forward to your next vid
Oh for sure, though I have a tendency for tangents, I feel like if I mentioned her I would have felt the need to really elaborate on her full story. No problem my friend! Thank you so much, shares are greatly appreciated! Thank you for saying so, it's definitely an over-simplification of the history, but I feel that it can be a good primer for those unfamiliar.
And what do you say about the influential role Bayard Rustin played in the 1963 March on Washington? Where was he during the event? They threw him under the bus strictly because he was gay.
@@OSTARAEB4 κι
Good job. I feel like Video essays can educate people on so much more than just film, and I'm glad you're using the platform in this way.
Thank you! I agree, while film will likely stay as my main focus(It's just where I'm most passionate and most comfortable) I have every intention of continuing to branch out. Though so far, the few times I've strayed from film seem to be my least popular videos, so it's hard to gauge how to move forward. But yeah, I'd love to talk more about music, or video games, or history or anything that interests me really.
I think you did a fantastic job stepping outside your niche and writing a biography. If it's something you want to keep doing, I'd totally be for it
Thank you! That's good to know! I'll keep that in mind :)
I never knew about this guy before I clicked on the video and I really wish I had. So inspiring to learn of the people like this who have helped spread understanding and acceptance for our community throughout the world. Thank you so much Harvey, maybe we wouldn't be where we are now without your courage and refusal to hide away your heart and your dreams.
His sadly is not a name I see too often on the internet, but that's a big part of why I wanted to make this video. Beautifully said Lara
As a trans person and an activist for queer equity in this country, this video was a needed reminder. It's so exhausting but it's a good reminder that those who came before us fought just as hard.
Harvey Milk is a inspiration to both LGBTQ & straight alike.
I love the progress bar you put at the bottom of the add portion
When I was barely beginning to be a teenager is when I saw the commercials of the movie Milk. I don't know why but I always felt the urge to see that movie. My brain never fully understood the topics and what it was really about other than a movie related to the government. My parents were so confused about why I wanted to and told me it was about a gay politician which I didn't know at the time. But that never stopped me from wanting to see it. To this day, I still want to see that movie but haven't gotten the chance to despite it being 10 years old.
I'm not gay, nor straight. But after seeing this video made me realize that I was attracted to the change. How I enjoy those that have goals and wish to make a mark on the world for the better. This video has made me want to see the movie even more so I most likely will this week. Good job and keep up the good work!
If you ever feel stupid just remember that 63 people disliked this
i loved this video! thank you for making it because it feels like schools (or at least mine) don't cover important topics like this. honestly before watching this video i've only heard of harvey milk's name but never learnt who he actually was and what he's done so i really appreciate that this video has helped me learn so much!
Mine didn't either! We skipped right past the gay rights movement in school, such a shame. I think this is an important story to tell, thanks for taking the time to watching :)
I love it how I got out of the airport of SFO and saw a whole gallery of Harvey Milk right on display. Just as I got off the plane. What a great way to identify San Francisco:)
the new generation of documentary - exactly what anyone today would need to know in a quick about Harvey Milk - everything was put together so well - the narration was perfect - appearing at the end was a good choice - good way to sign your work - with this video you've done Harvey and the movement justice Bravo! jl
I seriously love your videos, i got so excited everytime a new one pops up in my subscriptions dude, i had no idea about this so learning about it from you is awesome and hugely appreciated.
Thank you so much for saying so, it's good to know there's someone out there looking forward to these things :) Awesome, I love being able to share these sort of stories with people, I didn't even learn his name until I saw the Gus Van Sant film, and I really just wanted to help get his story out there to more people, thank you for watching my friend!
I think it speaks for itself, that this video has zero downvotes (at least while I'm writing this). Great video!
Well, as they say, good things never last(at 3 right now lol) but I appreciate you saying so!
Another great video! I love the more documentary style of your most recent work. Can't wait to see how the form of your videos develops in the future! :)
Thanks Grace! I'm glad you're enjoying it! Yeah, I'm really trying to experiment with new styles from here on out, I feel like I've been pretty rigidly held down by my own definitions of "video essay" and I'm just trying not to let that restrict trying out other things.
AMAZING AND POWERFUL VIDEO. I am originally from South Chile .. years after the Movie and documentaries about this guy Milk. Gay life, rights and big movements were pushed and changed society minds . Same-sex marriage in Chile has been legal since 10 March 2022. I am so proud of that. And so very great full for what Harvey Milk did..
Amazing! I've written several essays (and a presentation) on Harvey Milk for school and your take on his story and impact is phenomenal!
Thank you! His story is one I think everyone should know :)
I supported Harvey Milk in all four of his campaigns for office. Even in San Francisco this was an uphill struggle. LGBTQ rights were not gifted to us by the Democratic Party, we had to fight for them 🌈
Awesome video! I watched *"Milk",* starring Sean Penn as Harvey Milk. It was an awesome movie! The first time I'd heard of Harvey Milk was back in the early 1980s, long after he had been assassinated, but still remembered by those who knew Harvey Milk.
Is it strange that he is the same age as harvey milk and the film released 30 years later after the tragedy
@corduero rose Harvey Milk would've been 93 years old had he not been murdered when he was.
@@jasoncarpp7742 there's a 50% chance that mayor mosgone would be too
Wow, this video was amazing and genuinely inspiring. Everyone needs to watch this!
Thank you for the kind words!
3K8 views? You deserve atleast 1 million views mate. I love your videos.
Yeah, I was sad to see this one not getting a lot of views, hopefully that can change at some point. Thank you for saying so!
"Are the gays taking over San Francisco?" Man, the questions reporters used to ask.🙄
Harvey Milk was one of the bravest, most decent Americans to ever live. His legacy lives on!
I was just a little kiddo when Mr. Milk was murdered but I still feel sorry that he lost his life sinply for helping gain equality for everyone. RIP Mr. Milk 🙏. 12:40
Great and inspiring video, definitely would love to see more historical bio videos, you told the story really well 👍
Thank you so much for saying so! I might just have to do that :D
Off topic:
Booted from the T.M.N.T. -- you've missed one too many sessions, man. I've already had two people add to the party and now there's no room. Odyn was slain in the arena battle at the end of Act 1, though. I understand if other stuff got in the way like this, though, because you explained how hard work had gotten :) [for the confused: Film Radar was a D&D player of mine.]
He’s such a light, he just makes me smile. Wish he was here today to see the changes.
I think you did an great editing job. Terrible, exciting, and interesting times . Thumbs up !
Love love the video!!!
Sharing. Great Channel. Keep at it!
why didnt youtube show me this amazing video when it was released, that was one of your most beautiful videos yet, and now i feel ashamed that i haven't seen Milk
I think UA-cam basically blacklisted this video to be honest. I mean, look at the views compared to my normal videos, I don't think that's a coincidence. Oh well, UA-cam wants to avoid any potential controversy, so I imagine having the word "gay" in the title didn't help. Because sadly too many videos with that word in the title are more like "why gays are evil" or something along those lines, so I think the algorithm just tucks it away to avoid the trouble.
That said, thanks so much for saying so man, I was really proud of this one and was sad when it was barely seen by anyone. Don't feel ashamed! There's always time to check it out when you get the chance :)
The only thing I disagree with you on is, we do not have to be patient for change and equality. Equal rights should not "take time" or require "patience". We demand equality, and we work out asses off fighting for it!
All I mean to say is that it's just the unfortunate way of the world. Getting impatient means losing hope. I wish everything could change for the better overnight, but thats just not how it ever happens. It's awful, but these things do just take time, and patience is important so we stay in the fight.
Phenomenal video. Keep up the great work!
Thanks, will do!
I knew I recognized your voice. I subscribe to your other channel. Great work.
I truly inspiring look into one of the most progressive and inspiring Americans to have ever held office. I personally always been fascinated and Harvey milk, and you did a great job explaining both he and the impact that he had. Awesome!
Thank you so much! I didn't ever even hear his name until watching Gus Van Sant's film, had always wanted to make a video on it but the more I kept writing the more it started to become a sort of biography on the real guy instead of an analysis of the film, but both the film and his story have always been very inspirational to me.
Great video, although I wish you would have used more actual footage and much less footage from the bio-pic.
He is a great man , his life changed me , I love you Harvey Milk
Absolutely fantastic work, thank you for making this video!
Thank you for watching!
I used to wrestle in school, and I loved it....
Can't stop crying watching this video. ps. I really like this kind of mixture between bio pic and real life historical events, because most bio pic is only good and enjoyable to the viewers when the history background is understood by the viewers. And memoralizing history events and figures is another layer of value other fiction based films couldn't have.
I would love to do another video like this at some point, but I'm genuinely nervous considering how this one performed :/
This is such a great video, thank you for making this!
Thank you for saying so, and thank you for watching!
Thank you for making this video!!!!
Great documentary! Thanks for posting!!
This is being great! However I think you should define better your focus if you want to change somehow the way you make your videos, or better, decide more what to do with the channel in itself. I felt you went "off the script" for this video, an while the results were great because the video is really good, it does not fit almost at all with movie focus that your channel has had until now. In fact, while you used footage from the movie with Sean Penn and from the documentary, you barely addressed them, and you used their images mostly as prop for your storytelling. It could have been interesting to analyse how Milk's history has been told in these two different movies, or how they affected Milk's legacy, or to have this kind of takes on the topic. I think that you should just decide if you want to keep a more movie-oriented approach or starting doing completely different video essays. Both of the paths are cool, because you demonstrated here once again that you are so good in doing what you do. Keep on with the great work!
You're probably right, and I'll likely not stray too far off in the future as this video really didn't perform the way I had hoped. But I like the idea of changing things up every now and again, I just think I'll probably have to wait for a bigger audience before I can get away with it lol
Question- Do you think Dan White was possibly gay? Did he send the death threats to Harvey anonymously and when he didn't listen he lost it? Hmm? It's injustice that Dan White only got 5 years in prison! RIP Harvey Milk
It’s nice to know that schools offer degrees in GLBTQQIA+ studies now. We’ve got so much history, since times of antiquity, and around the globe, and so much to be proud of.
I bet Harvey Milk would not be too happy with what's happening to San Francisco now. And if he were alive, he'd be fighting to change the status quo and restore The City to its former glory, if not make it better than ever.
Beautiful work my friend!
Thank you so much!
A beautiful and insightful video... thank you so much for your alliance with our community
Thank you so much for saying so! It's a shame the community still even needs allies at this point, I would have hoped for more from society after all of this time and all of this fighting, but what can you do? In the meantime, I think people need to be vocal in their support of the community, it grows more and more every day!
Those times were the best and worst of times. It's sad an oppressed minority gained resilience through it but how ironic it only made us stronger.
Oh yes! I'm so glad you focussed on Harvey for this one. Not just a typical film analysis. Really wonderful. Sharing to the max by this appreciative gay rights activist and gramma. And yes, more historical coverage of others shown in film. by you would be great.
Great video. However, don't forget that gay men weren't the only ones involved in the Stonewall Riots. Trans women (especially trans WOC) had a large role as well.
Of course! I wanted to keep the focus tight on Harvey for this video so I skimmed over a LOT of important details when discussing Stonewall, I felt like I couldn't leave it out entirely as it was such a landmark moment for the LGBTQ community, but you're absolutely right.
Thank you so much for this beautiful video
Amazing documentary ! This is what gay pride is about !
Bless you. Bless Harvey Milk. Fight for understanding LGTB rights.
rights to what? higher hiv rates? higher domestic violence rates? higher suicide rates? how could you 'fight' for that?
@@elegantelliotoffen8172 troll harder
Ass hole
That’s a quality video. 👏👏
Thank you kindly!
Great content , congratulations!
Thank you for this. You did a wonderful job. VERY informative. Very interesting. Very beautiful.
Thank you so much! I'm so glad you enjoyed it!
Big fan of the video, would love to see more
Thank you for the feedback!
Beautifully made video, I love your channel so much!
Thank you kindly! Aww, I appreciate you saying so! :)
Film Radar you're very welcome, you're content is some of the best out there
Wonderful job, really enjoyed
Much appreciated
This is an excellent video, interesting change from the film-centric ones. Why did you decide to make a video about this topic, out of interest?
Thank you so much! While I still love doing the video essays on film, I've been interested in branching out on occasion to try some new things, and it was a story I kept coming back to when writing my last video on Zodiac. I just couldn't believe how many insane things were happening in the 60s-70s in San Francisco, so I thought it would make for an interesting follow up to that video, especially given the contrast in subject matter. To think that both of these things overlapped in time and place totally blows my mind, so I wanted to explore that. As far as Harvey Milk in particular, I had never even heard his name until watching Gus Van Sant's film and I couldn't believe I was never taught about him in school. We always learn about people like Martin Luther King Jr., or Gandhi, but Harvey Milk is a name I seldom see mentioned when talking about important civil rights figures, so it was the combination of being interested in the history of that time and place, and feeling that this was a story more should here :)
fantastic video ... hes one of my heroes. keep up the incredible work :)
Thank you! One of mine as well! Thank you I will :)
Great video man! I use to work for Rob Epstein and Jefferey Friedman who made Life and Times of Harvey Milk. Great guys, gave me my start, extremely grateful.
Thank you so much! That's incredible! That must have been quite the honor to work for them.
More of this please.
Less of this please.
Awesome video. Loved it.
Thank you so much!
i am listening, thank you
Thank God for Milk!!!!!
Excellent video.
Thank you Harvey Milk, you're in my heart forever.
Beautifully made
Thank you so much
ninjas cutting onions here. thanks so much!
Bless your heart this was beautiful :)
Thank you :>
Hey Filradar,
is there any chance to get the sources that you've used for this video.
It'll be very nice, since I need them for a important presentation at school :)
Thanks in advance :)
Check out "The Times of Harvey Milk" and "Stonewall Uprising", that's where a lot of the info comes from :)
oh god this was fucking awesome im crying
Gus van sant directed a great movie in Milk. Also the fact the guy who killed him claimed eating a Twinkie is what made him do it . Wtf
Definitely, my favorite Gus Van Sant film. Right? Absolutely insane.
I love Harvey Milk.
Gus Van Sant? The same guy that was also part of creating good will hunting made a movie about harvey milk?
Today Commemorates Harvey Milk's 90th Birthday
Big fan of Documentaries, big fan of people who fight for others. Just not a big fan of gays. He definitely did NOT deserve to die.
ugh hurts my heart
Lived in the background of this event in history.
Indeed, a very historical type video essay with lots of hopeful notes :). Similarly the same thing at the end of your video could be said about the Communist regime & the cold war; decades ago many people felt World War 3 would transpire within the 20th century and wipe everyone out, but instead the Communist Regime eventually collapsed and oppressed peoples under it's rule eventually won the day.
Also in regards to the Gay Rights Movement; I think back to my school days, and it seemed everyone I knew in middle & high school here in North Carolina in the late 00's and early 10's was pro gay marriage, or at the very least no one I knew was against it. Definitely this would have been different without the several decades long historical context & background. Ongoing & maintaining dialogue is also extremely important, it keeps society together in many ways.
Anyway, great video as always my friend :-)
Very true! I think it's true no matter what as long as you're looking at the timeline from far enough away. We have peaks and valleys on the road to progress, always, but the overall trajectory is always moving upwards. Wait, I'm confused, you were against it?
Thank you so much Will!
No no, I am for gay rights & gay marriage. What I was saying was, adding to your point(s) made in the video. That the long strand of dialogue that has spanned for decades was successful. That back when I (a 1995 born Millennial) was in Middle & High school everyone I knew was either for gay marriage or just didn't have an opinion about it or against it. See? That was my point. For example I knew several kids back in school who were say against pot or drugs entirely, but whenever gay marriage came up in conversations among peers, I cannot recall a single person really being against it in any way, which is impressive (I feel).
Lol, I totally read that wrong as "at the very least no one knew I was against it", glad to clear that up xD Right on, yeah, it was about the same experience for me, though there was a lot of homophobic rhetoric going around where I lived at the time. By high school though for sure it was a different story. Yeah, sorry, I'm just dumb and blind apparently :P
It alright, sometimes things get misread, as a school teacher of mine used to say; Typos hapen.
Also I have a good song you may or may not know, but it relates to your point in the end. :)
ua-cam.com/video/KCGlwx3L-Xk/v-deo.html
Ain't that the truth! Oh hell yeah my dude, who doesn't love Elvis Costello?
当宣布同性婚姻合法化时，证明英雄们所有一切抗争都是伟大的，值得被铭记的，我也泣不成声💙💜💚💛❤️All the struggles, the fights and the suffers of our heroes are worthy and deserve to be remembered when the government announced the same sex marriage is legal, and i burst out crying.
Well, I cried. Good film. I lived in SF at that time. That is why I left PHX. Thank you, Dan
Thank you for watching! I can only imagine what a time that must have been, it's a shame so much of that energy is gone these days :/
Hi, their is something I would like you to address. I do not know if you have the resources to do a video on this? Having worked in various Juvenile Halls, Corrections facilities, there are many issues. I want to focus on one.
It is impossible to place a Gay kid in a group home, UNLESS, they are declared him/her of being a sexual predator. The State will not pay for a Gay kid, that can not live with their family. So they have to end up having being a criminal to get placed. It puts everyone in a strange place. Just asking, maybe HRC should deal with this, but? Since you asked?
.
I assume you think I may be a ped. I am not. If you want to check this out, please do this. My name is Daniel Flatten, Tucson AZ.
Great video! So informative, I loved it! Would love to see more like it. Thank you.
Thanks so much for saying so!
He lead the way in boi touching
Happy Birthday Harvey. Rest easy.
Love this
Nice video
Thank you.
Thank you for watching!
The Army motto?
man, i really wonder what this guy would be doing now
I wish Milk was still with us but I’m just glad he came along when he did. RIP, you wonderful man. ❤