The Night of the Idaho Student Murders | Full Episode
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2023
- The family of murdered student Kaylee Goncalves says they may have uncovered a connection between the suspect, their daughter, and Madison "Maddie" Mogen. "48 Hours" correspondent Peter Van Sant reports. Watch more full episodes of "48 Hours" on Pluto TV.
#48hours #mystery #crime
True crime. Real justice. "48 Hours" investigates the most intriguing crime and justice cases that touch on all areas of the human experience including greed and passion. "48 Hours," which premiered in 1988, has developed a rich history of original reporting and impact journalism that has helped exonerate wrongly convicted people, caused cold cases to be reopened and solved, and along the way changed lives.
Subscribe to the “48 Hours" UA-cam channel: / @48hours
Watch full episodes of “48 Hours”: www.cbs.com/shows/48_hours/
Listen to the "48 Hours" podcast: link.chtbl.com/48-Hours
Listen to the "My Life of Crime with Erin Moriarty" podcast: link.chtbl.com/CBSNewsMLOC
Follow “48 Hours” on Instagram: / 48hourscbs
Like "48 Hours" on Facebook: on. 1KkQuRn
Follow "48 Hours" on Twitter: / 48hours
Subscribe to our newsletter: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
Download the CBS News app: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
Try Paramount+ free: bit.ly/2OiW1kZ
For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com
Click here to watch more full episodes of "48 Hours": ua-cam.com/play/PLcFHkKbd_jTJiRmfUfLX2Ay_hnf5j3cxH.html
48 Hours, please post Linda Fishman/Fred Kretzmer in Palm Beach episode. It's definitely the best one ever. I still remember when you played it on TV. It's my and my husband's favorite episode 💯
Thank you for posting full episode. I live rural with no TV so UA-cam on my phone is my only way of watching.
😊😊ppp😊
If he did it.
HE HAS GOT TO GO.( you know what i mean?)
@@SheilaLS Me too. And I don't miss TV at all. Been TV free for over twenty years.
How the mother described her feelings. When you can’t believe the world doesn’t stop . Just goes on as normal. I had those feelings when my mother died . I was young and thought I was a freak for feeling like that . 🙏🏼😭
I had that feeling when my mother died as well when I was young. I remember looking out of the hospital window looking at how busy the world was.. in a hurry to get wherever . I was standing at the window crying thinking how can the world go on without my mother ?!
Sorry about the loss of your mother ❤ I experienced the same thing when my father died.
I also went through this and had those feelings after the night my father was murdered. I still have days that are hard to deal with. This whole idea of closure really doesn't exist for those of us who have lost a loved one in this manner. Especially when the guilty party never admits to it or says why.
@@virginiabalch6274 I can’t imagine the pain of having a loved one murdered. It’s bad enough to lose someone to natural causes or an accident. I’m sorry for your loss. ❤
Yea the statement she made is not only true but extremely relate-able as well
I lost my 17 yr old daughter in a car accident in 2016. She was in her senior year of high school. She was my only child. It's coming up on 7 years now and it feels like just yesterday. The loneliness is unbearable. Everyone else gets to see their kids enter adulthood and attain life's milestones. College, marriage, careers, etc. I get to have memories and a million thoughts of the loss of what might have been. I strongly resent the fact my daughter's school didn't think enough of her to give us a posthumous diploma. We fund a scholarship in her memory yet they were too cheap and insensitive to honor her with a diploma. People will probably scold me, but I don't care.
Scold you??! Oh momma noooo….I vehemently agree with you. An honorary diploma would have been the decent, common sense choice for the administration to have made.
7 years…it’s wild how seven years can flash by in what feels like a moment. Wish there were some combination of words, something i could type into this box that would somehow lessen the unbelievable pain you are enduring…just so deeply sorry.
What im about to tell you may seem stupid, crazy, or both but i do know, like Know Know- like I know I to breath to live, is true. I am far from religious. This isn’t based on someone else’s idea of what they’d like others to believe…I know because I’ve seen it. I can’t prove it. I’d give anything to be able to prove it to other people but I can’t. But I did see it, only for a few seconds, maybe a minute? Time moves very differently there so I’m not sure.
I can promise you, I swear on everyone and everything and everywhere i truly love- we will all be reunited again. Someday. I know this because I’ve seen where it is. I’d give anything to go back there now.
When i say Everyone was there, I do mean Everybody.
Even the pets we’ve had to say good bye to. It was wild.
It’s very green there…again I only got to see it for an excruciatingly short time, but it was so green. And the wildest experience, besides crying tears of joy when a gaggle of animals ran towards me and I scooped up what turned out to be my beloved childhood dog was when i recognized a familiar face. It was a young woman, she looked about roughly 25 years old? Certainly younger than I am.
At first I found myself unable to place how I knew her. We made eye contact and she smiled at me. Then the recognition hit me like an incoming train- I was standing across a grassy meadow, locking eyes with my Grandmother. She was young and healthy again. Everyone there was.
And just like that I was back here. In my living room. Shaking and weeping, overcome from what I had just experienced.
I totally understand if you don’t believe me, i know it sounds insane. I don’t know how I ended up there- or how it happened. But it did.
We will all be together again in the After place, that Green place…we just have to wait a bit. I’m positive your beautiful daughter is there now and that you will get to hold her again.
I promise you that, sweet momma.
I pray you find peace & comfort. That was incredibly tacky of them. I wish someone would have taken the initiative & made one especially for you & her memory.❤
🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
Scold you??? I am grieving for you. How horrible. And how could they have been so thoughtless? I am very sorry any of this was placed on your shoulders.
This is absolutely tragic 😢I’m so sorry girl, you will forever be here mother and I wholeheartedly believe y’all WILL be reunited again one day ❤
When my daughter passed away, and I looked out the window and saw people happy and running around and acting all happy and alive I was so mad that the world did not stop. I was so so angry it didn't seem possible that she was gone and they were out there, living their lives as if she never existed. I understand this feeling I think all of us feel this way I teared up when I heard that even after 25 years, the feeling never goes away.
It's been 11 years since I unexpectedly lost my husband @ 33 y/o & I still have that feeling sometimes. The most seemingly random things can trigger huge waves of anger & grief.
Time doesn't lessen the pain but it does change it.
It becomes part of you. I am so sorry for your loss.😢 💔
It's beautiful thing know the sun still raises everyday
I am so sorry for your incredible loss
@Oceangirl, I know exactly how you feel 😢my only child HollyBear passed away 30 yrs this coming June and I too was so mad, that the world kept spinning 😢
🫂 hugs
Maybe this is not the same but I felt the same way when my parents died you know we were in a car crash I survived they didn’t and I always hated that I survived. I wish I didn’t have a 13 years later. I still feel that way sometimes I know I feel like I should’ve died with them only child and you know I was really close to my parents and you know that we were they were killed by, a guy on drugs and every day I wish you know I was I died in that accident too. I feel like I should’ve died with them and I always feel like it wasn’t fair that didn’t die with him and then I had the same healing too you know I remember laying in bed for a week or whatever my aunt stayed at my house with me You know cause I live with my parents, but she stayed at my house with me for over a month but I remember I had a hard time getting out of bed for over a week but I remember thinking the same thing it’s not fair how the world was still spending. When people were living the lies I’m like you know I expect in my mind I was like the world should’ve stopped because that’s how it feels when somebody that you love dies I know it’s not the same as losing a pair and losing a kid because I know a lot worse losing a child But you know but I but I am just saying I understand that feeling you know you just feel like it’s not fair that the world still going and everybody’s living lives even though people don’t know you know they don’t know you lost somebody you just like you know if you think about we live our lives before our tragic accident you know you live your life not thinking over there’s somebody else that died because the thing is every day somebody does die and I guarantee you a lot of people feel the same way thinking you know that’s not fair that you’re going to continue to live your lifeyou know I’m not here tragic stories of somebody younger than me that passes away and I’m like but yet I’m here like at a car accident accident I was 25 and I looked back and I was like yeah I could’ve died at 25 was still young but when I hear somebody passed away at 1618 years old, I’m sad because I didn’t have a chance to live
This is a graduate student, not a trained assassin is the dumbest thing I've heard in awhile. Was Bundy a trained assassin?
It seems like he was a trained criminal. I think he just wanted to see if he could get away with it and I think he purposely chose people he didn’t have a connection to or motive for that reason.
He' s as guilty as hell. - fun fact : enough of his own students found him odd, strange, and misogynistic. Red flags, not that rare, which sadly lead to nothing
Bryan looks alot like Bundy too.
@@shakti_062 😢
Israel is trained Bundy are not but charming
Props to 48 Hours for putting the emphasis here on the victims. Truly heartbreaking story.
Except the way they have to describe the crime and scene in such obscene detail creating unnecessary drama. Also cutting Steve off when he barely gets a sentence out.
@@starsalways7922unnecessary drama? It happened.
I disagree. I want it to be more focused on the killer, the investigation, interrogation, and motive.
@@sandscripts5728 they sensationalize with the verbiage they choose.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
Hearing Kaylee’s mom talk about how kids were still playing and life was still going on, but her daughter was dead, and she felt the world should stop….I literally got chills because after my mom passed away, I said almost those exact words to my cousin. I know what she means. I feel her words in my soul. I’m sending so much love, infinite prayers, and healing hugs to all four families & friends. 🫶🏻❤️
I had a similar experience. As my mom was in her last days , I took a walk around the neighborhood and saw a woman walking with her baby in stroller . The circle of life really struck me as here was a life ending and another just beginning.
I say this all the time about anyone who experiences such a loss. Like, how are you laughing? How did the sun come up today? 😞
It’s such a prominent feeling in grief. The regular world has a deep affect on you, because it’s so different from your new world of grief and heartache. I know that comparison well.
Where can I find the part when she mentions that?
@@nicolemajcher99100:50
I’m glad they gave her a posthumous degree. That probably meant a lot to the family. RIP to the victims. Hope the families can find some peace.
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
The family have come out to say that she had graduated. She had fully earned her degree at the time.
It was on a UA-cam detective channel
Chronicles of Olivia
this happened around the same time my cousin went missing and was found dead… so every time i see anything about this case my heart breaks…💔😢
I’m so sorry for your loss 🥺❤️.
I remember wondering how one goes on when they lose a child, or a parent.. until my mom died 6 months after this tragedy happened. It’s something you don’t get over. My heart goes out to any parent who has lost a child, and to any child (I’m fully grown, but my siblings are still “kids”, same ages as Kaylee and Maddie, Xana and Ethan) who’s lost a parent. Heartbreaking 😔
What a horrible incomprehensible loss. Imagine devoting your life to raising a child. Being sure to carefully buckle them into the car seat every time. Watching them in the parking lot that they are safe from traffic. Driving to drop them off & pick them up from school everyday for 12 years. Then, when they are just at the cusp of adulthood, barely out of your sight for the first time ever....THIS!!! Multiply the horror X4!! Four families experiencing this devastating loss. Can any explanation ever suffice? Never! God be with these families. Please comfort them & help them through this nightmare.
No children here
One needn’t have children to start to imagine the sheer horror of losing an immediate family member in such a sudden, violent, painful, and cruel way. Having it be your child is undoubtedly next level too, I don’t have kids but I do have empathy and imagination. This is all so sickening. I pray that there is justice here, bc it’s one of the only things left that can be done.
Perfectly stated. I don’t think I could remain here if something like this happened to my child. There’s nothing as precious as our children. What a monster that man is. I hope he gets treated like he deserves in prison.
@@mtio2807don't need children to have empathy
Amen. Parents worst nightmare
Xana’s sister looks so much like her. It’s so heartwarming and heartbreaking at the same time. This is so freaking sad.
Hopefully shes not a little alkie too
I was paralyzed when I heard her sisters deep raspy voice. It was identical to Xana’s
Pretty much a nightmare that is ongoing. I'd be hitting a whiskey bottle for a couple of months.
Does anyone know if Dylan and the other survivor was investigated?
@PsicJCISS I know they lawyered up which I found interesting. They seem to be shielding themselves from the police &any chance of testifying at a trial.
When I lost my grandfather (my dad), I felt the same way. I felt like the world was passing me by, 100 mph, as I stood still. I wanted to scream out, “don’t you know the most wonderful man in the world has died?!??” I was so crushed
I never felt like the world didn't stop for you. I still grieve, but the world doesn't owe your family anything
@@jojosaylor8996 No it doesn’t. But at 19 yrs old, it was my first big loss. I had a tough childhood, and he saved me.
I was 13 when my dad died it was 2021 and I found him I called 911 and I had to do CPR I was grasping onto hope he would be ok and when they told me the world felt like it stopped, I stayed in my room and cried it was august so it was sunny pretty much the whole month except for the week he passed away but people kept living their lives and I was so angry because of it, well now I’m almost 16 and I understand the world doesn’t stop but I know what you went through
Beautifully done 48 hours, thank you for focusing on the families.
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
it’s incredible how Kaylee’s family found out what happened and went into detective mode. They were gonna find out who killed their daughter, and that is incredible to me. To push through such a horrifyingly sad time and muster the strength to do that.
it was odd how they were always in media. no tears for a long time, but always on some show.
@@janecoe9407 That's what resoluteness looks like...
They need to stop this. Its risking the case. They were not the only family to lose a child. They need to go away.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
@@jkm1611 Such empathy on your part (rolling my eyes here). If you had a murdered daughter you would do the exact same as these people and you would nót go away.
This crime happened a year ago today. I hope all the people in this episode are surrounded by loved ones right now. I still can't fathom how they must feel 💔
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
@adatewithkate can I get a date with you, Kate
Prayers seriously❤🙌🏼🙏🏼
@@sashacardenas377 Hola, Sasha
They were so wrong demolishing the house before the trial even began! Idk wtf they were thinking!
👀🤔
I know !!! It should have been a memorial
They probably collected all/any evidence they needed and I’m sure they have videos and a 3D digital model of the house inside. They probably demolished it so it didn’t turn into a morbid “tourist attraction” of sorts. I think I heard that they were going to make a memorial for them where the house once was. Hopefully them demolishing the house doesn’t affect the trial
I guess I’ve missed this in all the earlier coverage. This is the first I knew it was 8 hours before the survivor witness called 911. I really can’t wrap my mind around this.
Nor me. She saw the guy walk past, Why didn't she call 911? I have seen cases where victims were dying, and called cops as best they could. This is one thing that stands out for me, in this very sad tragedy of those 4 young lives. Maybe she could have saved one of them if alert was not 8 hours after.
My thoughts too. She heard crying coming from Xana's room came out of her bedroom to see a stranger dress in black walking down the hallway away from Xana's bedroom. Why didn't she call 911 right away and report an intruder? Why wait 8 hours? Something doesn't add up. Also, there is no way the surviving roommate's didn't heard screaming coming from the bedrooms, crying for help, stomping from upstairs especially how gruesome the scene was. It's sad that the surviving roommate's wait 8 hours to call 911. The victims didn't get help right away.
I think it makes perfect sense for a young woman to be scared and go into hiding when a tall man just started to attack your roommates.
He was in their house and she had no idea if she was really safe or not.
@@peezypeeze9140I don’t understand, instead of running she stayed in the house as a sitting duck? I’m sure she had a phone in the room she was hiding in, why wait 8 hours to call 911? For all she knew, he could’ve came to her next. I’m sorry, but that’s not logical.
@@peezypeeze9140BTW, I’m not implying she was any way involved. I just don’t understand her lack of action.
I get angry every time I hear someone say Kohberger is innocent because he had no connection with the victims. Since when does a killer get picky by only choosing people he has a connection to?
THANK YOU
This 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
Yeah, apparently they never heard of Ted Bundy, Dennis Rader, HH Holmes, David Berkowitz, John Gacy, Gary Ridgeway etc. Those are more than likely Kohberger fangirls and fanboys. Just disgusting. Bundy had them too. Right up until he died.
Ikr...thank you for saying this; I was looking for this comment!👍
Ted Bundy didn’t have any connections to his victims either.
The poor parents. Seeing Xana’s Dad broke my heart
Yes, and Kaylee's mom stating that "how can the world continue" without Kaylee. 😢
Xana's sister is so pretty - she and Xana have such a resemblance to one another. I feel terrible for everyone left behind.
He looks so lost..
Yes you can see the anger and pain in him may they get Justice
Yep. That’s what broke my heart watching when it aired. My thoughts exactly. He’s clearly the one still struggling to cope the most. Or at least: the most visible. He hardly could say a word without just breaking. Sad to witness.
They did a great job with this episode tho… just letting the family speak without pushing or pressing too much. That’s exactly how It should’ve been done and what I tuned in for the most. They handled a delicate situation extremely well. Respectful.
@@caitlynbarrett9184💔
I’ve been following this case from the day it hit the news and I still feel like there’s parts of this story/case that are missing. I have so many questions. Something feels so off on so many levels. I believe there were 6 people in the house including a young man. The roommates that survived heard one of the friends cry out they so a man in black but they took a long time to report it and then said on the 911 call that one of her friends was unresponsive. Something is missing.
Yes a lot is missing. There’s a gag order and even before that, they weren’t releasing many details. Im sure it’ll make more sense in time
Exactly . Why would you wait so long to call for help
I agree. Something is off. Took someone else 8 hours later to phone police. The first thing to do is call 911 even if distressed. Victims have done that. I don't understand this.
@@bettymermaid8346 Exactly. The 2 survivors as you said took 8 hours to call cops. Saw this man in black with bushy eyebrows, which could have been any one. They don’t tell 911 anything about the man they say one of our roommates are unresponsive. They said they heard a male voice tell a crying female it’s ok I’m not going to hurt you ,something to that effect..Right? According to the families all of these roommates were super close , are you not out of pure concern going to go find out what is going on? Then he completely passes the first floor rooms and goes to second and third where there is a man who can put up a fight with other women that could tried to defend themselves too. Why?? How ? This case is off and there is a huge part of the story missing. The “evidence “ against him is weak and still till this day they never let the public know if they interrogated the 2 survivors and if they did we have seen it. And I’m sure some people are going to get offended but it is what it is had this house been occupied by Hispanics ,blacks etc You know that the 2 survivors would of been the first persons of interest. The police probably would have interviewed them several times. But we saw none of that. I think this case is going to do a huge 360 and it’s going to be nothing that the law thinks. At all there is a huge part of this story being left out to protect someone or a few people.
@bronxbutterflyrivera78 you're gonna throw race into this saying that's the reason the survivors weren't questioned? Seems awfully racist of you.
Something strange about that whole situation. With those separate attacks, you think there would be some screaming that would wake up the other occupants. And then when the girl sees an intruder, but doesn’t call 911 for eight hours, that’s pretty shaky. What were the two survivors doing for eight hours? They had cell phones and they didn’t call friends, family, or the police.
As frustrating as it is that the roommate didn’t call 911 I can’t blame her. She didn’t know what was happening at that point and an intruder in her home would scare most people into hiding until they felt safe enough to move.
@@admirallilyok, but for 8 hours? You’d maybe wait 1 or 2 hours and call for help
@@shazzz2909 she probably convinced herself who she saw was someones friend and fell back to sleep. She had literally been out all night partying. I don't think its any deeper than that. The last thing anyone that young is going to think is that a homicidal maniac had killed all her friends
@@LaLagunz187 exactly. They were all college kids living in a house together , living the lives of college kids with parties and friends and freedom; as college kids do. No doubt that they had lots of traffic of ppl coming in and out of that house all day and night all the time. What was it six total kids living there? And each one has friends, classmates, romantic partners /dates, etc . The last thing anyone in their shoes would think when they heard someone awake and moving around in another part of the house in the middle of the night is it's some homicidal nut job on a killing spree instead of someone who had been invited there by one of their many roommates.
@@m.mcc.9893 👏🏾 thank you! finally another person who is reasonable. They are literally young adults with their first real freedoms. It’s all about fun and friends during that time. Feels like you’re gonna live forever. I just don’t understand why anyone is questioning why they took so long to call. As if the roommates aren’t victims themselves. She fell asleep and thankfully she locked her door because I honestly believed she holding be here either. And if you wanna go deeper, their brains aren’t even fully developed enough to even think that far in advance to even assume a serial killer was loose in the house. Especially not an inebriated underdeveloped brain
RIP Kaylee😢
RIP Xana😢
RIP Ethan😢
RIP Madison😢
🥂 Cheers to the memories of Kaylee, Xana, Ethan, Madison, and also Kylee. (The 17yr old girl in the first comment, that was lost in a car accident.)
✨ May they all rest in eternal peace and be reunited with their loved ones in the end 💫
😢❤Amen
My daughter is in college very far away and this story haunts me... life is so unpredictable and so unfair. RIP to four of these young people.
Encourage her to install cameras at her residence.
@@musicloverchicago437 Cameras don’t stop maniacs.
@@belun6462 I agree. I should have explained. The house where Kohberger committed his murders didn't have any security cameras so the police had to do a lot of extra work to determine he was the murderer. If the house had cameras not only would they have ID'd him much more quickly, they would have the best evidence ever to convict him. It's a good think they have other great evidence, but video of him at the scene at that time would have been best.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
She might get killed too
This horror crime scene didn't make sense when i read the news that four college people were killed during sleep. Two roommates told police that they didn't hear the screams and one of the roommates saw the bad man walking with his knife through the room. They didn't report to the police until next day. I think one of the roommates lied to the police or detectives.
Ya think?
They lied , Are still covering for the cartels, They are off,
With their belief that the ride share drops the girls off
At 1122 King Road, Maddie and Kaylee were attacked on
Linda Lane not in their Bed! This attack was caught on video.
They were in a white car found burned to destroy the DNA!
The were later brought back , To 1122 King Road , Maddie
Left her jacket,To leave a clue for help! They were assaulted,
In the backseat of the car, It was later burned!
My questions about this case:
1. ok so...Ethan's sister-in-law stated on reddit Dylan allegedly "called her roommates after the crying and screaming stopped, and no one answered" So she saw that there was an unknown man in black in the house, later heard screams and cries and still didn't call 911? People comment on this stating, "she was in shock"...ok so she was in shock, but still went back to bed and fell asleep?
2. why did she call a friend to come over and check it out? did she stay in her room until noon the next day? Why didn't she call 911 herself? Was she scared of what she might say/be asked on the phone? Did the amount of blood (enough to seep out of the foundation of the house) not stand out to them?
3. If the killer stabbed Xana and Ethan due to the couple spotting him, why was Dylan spared when she not only yelled out to her roommates assuming they were partying, she was on the same floor as Xana, and also saw him face to face?
4. Bethany was stated to had initially slept through all of this, but now was allegedly texting Dylan? Bethany didn't think anything of the noise? Who lied about being asleep?
5. A security camera from the neighbor's house 50 feet away captured screams, cries, a thud and barking, but the roommates couldn't?
6. why was the dog secluded in a room by himself with the door closed?
7. wasn't the dog barking through all the commotion? The roommates didn't get concerned from the dog either?
I'm not saying she was a part of it, but I do think it's necessary to question if this was just a lapse in judgment. Because at the end of it all, she gave the killer 8 hours to flea and get himself together.
I'm not replying to your post to be hateful, but to point out just one thing.
No one knows Dylon or the fright she felt to have behaved the way she did.
Therefore no one can or should judge her response to that horrible night.
I promise she's living her own personal hell and most likely doesn't even understand her own actions or lack there of that night!
We should all be grateful he didn't add her to his senseless killing spree.
Leave her alone!
I think what I think; you think what you think!
@@katzaj yep that's why they call it AMERICA! 🇺🇸
@@katzaj Right! It's called America! 🇺🇸
She also called her boyfriend who drove 5hrs to get there before the police were called as well. Let’s not forget that.
As a true crime fan, this case just hits different. It’s haunting.
I agree. I've heard thousands of true crime cases and ones like this are incredibly rare.
grow a pair!!!
"true crime fan" brain rot
My gf and I went to the house a few hours from ours a month later. Snow still on the ground. It was alot more haunting in person
@@princesadelaoswhat
My brother was killed 3 weeks ago. I feel the same way as the mother. How does the world keep turning? How do people carry on with their lives when my brother isn't here anymore? The world isn't the same without him.
I'm so sorry about you losing your brother, I lost my son to ALS in May. It's hard to accept him being gone....it's like time stops... because he no longer exists. It's hard. I hope you have someone to lean on and talk to about it.
@@joshuacloutier840 thank you. ❤️
@mkat4271 I'm sorry for your loss. Thank you for the kind words. Losing someone tends to harden you and soften you at the same time. I'm angry, but I have so much more sympathy for what others are going through, because you never know...
I’m so sorry for the loss of your brother. 🙏
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
Someone has to explain why it took 8 hrs to call police… that’s not freezing, that’s fishy
Waiting hours to call 911 is ridiculous. That's beyond comprehension.
Must've been Kohberger's lover
Don’t judge or make assumptions. You weren’t there
Well then what are your thoughts as to why they waited so long?@@86sineadw
@@86sineadwsaid that again
@@86sineadw Do you not think it's even a little bit weird, honestly? Why did he happen to spare the girl who also happened to not report the crime? It's at least a little weird, c'mon.
48 Hours y’all definitely did the victims a service with this one….. such beautiful lives were lost. My thoughts and prayers go out to the families.
No, it is a disservice to present the obfuscations of the desperate defense team. We know they know he's guilty, otherwise they would never have waived his right to a speedy trial. If he had a plausible alibi he would not be in jail today. It's a sad, sad day when criminals have more rights than victims, or families of victims.
@@lisaforte1575 I understand what you're saying. I do still think they did a service to the victims by allowing them some time to speak. However, I definitely think it's gross to even present the potential defense counterpoints intermixed in there. Especially the drug one, which if you listen to it in length (on other videos), it holds like 1% weight compared to the evidence against Kohberger. To just casually throw that into everything (when to even explore that concept would take like 30 min) feels insincere - like a way to still be like "it's a college house and they party!" Overall, I still think it was nice to give the families an opportunity and platform to speak.
being that it's basically impossible to cope with trauma like this needs to be showed regarding this story
@@ladychelseatheundead i cant say this is particularly the reason but when it comes to ongoing court cases, you can only print or mention facts that have been mentioned in the case, and even then its still "alleged" until the charge is handed down. If they were to create a documentary where it was spoken into fact that he did do it undoubtedly when the verdict hasnt been reached yet, thats libel and grounds for suing and a whole mess more of legal mumbo jumbo.
You didn't know them.
The fact that the house was seemingly bleeding is a haunting visual of how brutal this truly was. I pray this trial is brings some closure to their families, and that the killer does get the death penalty judgement. Anybody capable of such a brutal crime, doesn’t deserve e the right to live
Absolutely
I read several reports that said it wasn’t blood, it was a rust proofing product that had been there for years. Better story, though.
Bryan is innocent though. I hope they find the real killer and get justice !
The house wasn't bleeding they tested it wasn't blood
@@hearanecho Exactly. Thank you for making this point. Before watching this I'd never considered 48 Hours to be such a sensationalized program. The U of Idaho is my alma mater and I feel very invested in this case. I'm horrified and heartbroken for these innocent young people, their families, and the university and the town of Moscow. I have been fairly obsessed with reading/watching everything to do with this case. I think the suspect in custody is guilty. I don't even want to use his name. However, I still found this episode to be sensationalized for dramatic effect. I have read (many times and different sources) that the dad flying to Pullman, Washington and driving back to Pennsylvania with his son was the plan all the way back in August when school was just starting. Not because "his son was having troubles with his job." If this individual is guilty (I believe he is) then I want him to be convicted, but in an honest way.
These stories have so many loopholes. Why would you wait 8 hours post the incident to call the cops? Was there no yelling or shouting when the stabbing took place in the very first place. Where is the door dasher info who delivered the food at 4:00AM. How can you see killer eye bro in the thick dark(I’m assuming the lights were off) the detailed description gets a lot of sus. How did he come through, like enter the house. What about the other girl
Who survived? What’s her story? I mean I do get it , the case still wide open and pretty much all evidence are confidential right now. But this story does have so many openings.
Is anybody ever going to tell us why the survivors waited so long to call the Police???
Lots held back from us web sleuths for good reasons in USA!! All in due time
the part where the sister gave her baby Maddie and Kaylee's names really got to me, may their souls rest in peace.
ME TOO !!!
So beautiful. Theodora MaddieKay. How sweet that she included Maddie's name. Love it!❤
@@danieljacot3083wow is there really any need 🙄🤫
@@danieljacot3083not yet just a sleep until judgement day
RAW !@@danieljacot3083
So sad. I couldn’t imagine life without my kids. My heart goes out to these families who lost their children.
I don't think I'll ever bring myself to forget this case.
It was a senseless act of vicious violence by someone heartless and without a soul.
I can't imagine the pain of the families.
May the souls of their loved RIP.
Being 50 years old, i cant help but think about all experiences these kids will miss the next 30 years. Heading into the best years of their lives. Im so heartbroken.
That is life. Got hit by a car when I was 17, I lived---but I also died at the same time. By the time I was revived by paramedic, I was never the same person again. Your brain doesn't heal like other organs. I missed out on everything. Had my crush approached me in college but I still could not be my usual self (before the accident) and so she left not knowing how I felt about her. No wife and no kids. Everything was stolen in a matter of seconds.
Ironically, everything I believe would happen to me in college actually happened. All my hard work was worth it, but I could not account for unforeseen circumstances that were outside of my control. Based on my life history and its involvement with certain numbers, I am 100% sure I am curse. I have experiences paranormal activities that most people don't experience in multiple lifetimes. My life is very strange, I want answer but will never get it.
They didn’t deserve to die such a horrific death,they also deserved to live life to the fullest 😢
I know the pain of losing my son. He was only 22. A pain that is there every minute of the day. We miss him so much. My heart breaks for these families.
Sending you blessings and encouragement. I dream about my loved ones and it actually help’s because of the grief 😢❤🙏🏽.
@@530MAIDU Thank you so much.
I’m sorry for your loss, I hope you are doing well and I’m sending prayers your way ❤❤ your son is always with you :) I promise and he’s looking over you. He loves you :) I’m sorry for your loss 😢
I'm so sorry for your loss💔
I have a son. I cannot imagine your pain.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
This is really hurtful for strangers, can’t imagine how it is for their families. God heal them 🙏🏽✝️
No one I'd rather watch cover this crime than the team of "48 Hours". Always top notch work and reporting and piecing crimes together in an understandable way and an effective way. Have been a fan for years.
Oh wow, the mom saying “how can you be playing, my daughter is dead!? Stop every thing! Stop!”.
This is a feeling I recognize all too well, how can others live their lives, while the most important person in my life is no longer here.
Losing a loved one is the hardest thing to get through, but to lose them at the hands of someone else must be completely unbearable.
You know their soul returns to God but their remains are still on the earth and I constantly think about my sister remains in that grave and so many times I want to dig her up and hug her and touch her hair. Hurts so bad thinking of her body in there. Destroyed by death. I’m drawn to her grave yet when I see it and her name on the head stone my heart breaks down and I cry uncontrollably. She was 19. Our lives were ruined by her loss and years after we have families she never got to meet but I still think of her and it hurts the same.
@@javayna2353 I’m really sorry to hear about your sister. 19 years old is young. I do however, understand your thinking. I do the same myself even though it’s unhealthy and we know that their spirits aren’t truly there. But it’s okay because we’re human. And I think as humans it’s hard for us to see things any other way. God bless❤️
seems a little selfish to me.. OH, STOP Playing.. stop stop." How dare she says that..let the kids play on... life needs to go fwd.
What about Brian being innocent until proven guilty?
@@trustkillxxxx it’s not selfishness, it’s grief.
RIP Kaylee, Maddie, Xana and Ethan!!! Our hearts with the poor grieving families and loved ones, and we hope justice is done!!! 💜😭
whats the blue plant growing on ur face
@@silksonic3927 😁 the kids were having their faces painted at a family party and I joined in 😁😁😁
*I hope Theresa Caputo, Long Island medium can interact with the families as they need to come to terms whether their children are at peace with God. The families needed to heal from their losses of their loved ones. It’s a sad depressing case*
May BCK get a fair trial
@@angelaknebel4156lol how cute
unbelievable that 911 was never called until 8 hours later. SMH
As frustrating as it is that the roommate didn’t call 911 I can’t blame her. She didn’t know what was happening at that point and an intruder in her home would scare most people into hiding until they felt safe enough to move.
@@admirallily can we now able to send txt the 911?
shock and adrenaline can be weird things. Some people freeze and some panic. Some fight, some run. There is no way to know how you would act in a situation like that. It is unfortunate but it would have made little difference. The murders had already been committed.
I cannot understand how the surviving roommate came face to face with the murderer and didnt call cops for over an hour
8 hours. And the roommates NEVER called 911. Another student whom they called to come over made the call to 911 using one of the roommates phones.
The roommates NEVER called police.
This is a devastating case. My condolences and prayers to those affected by this tragic ordeal.
Wow did you think of this comment all on your own. 🙄
If only prayers did anything.....
You took the words out of my mind. 💔🙏🏾💜
Everyone's Prayer's & Condolences and still that is not even enough nor every will be , loved one's have this for the rest of their lives.
@@outtamindprops6545 Are you always so bitter. Cheer up mate
Grief is the worst feeling you can experience. The pain of losing someone you love is just so hard to describe. I can't even begin to imagine what the victims' families are experiencing, but i hope and pray god has mercy on their hearts. Such beautiful souls snatched away by a deranged crazy pos.
Indeed .
@@swallowedinthesea11 we would've all done the same if our loved ones were being attacked by a deranged killer. I can't imagine the horrors those poor kids had to endure in their last moments.. may god be with their families in these difficult times. The pain of losing a child, sibling, friend or cousin just never gets easier.
Grief is a giant hole in your heart that will never heal. It's living with half of yourself gone. That hole is filled with sorrow and is part of you forever
Grief....when you see happy people smiling and laughing and don't recognize that feeling anymore. When you see couples in love and all you have is a heart of sorrow. Sometimes, I envy those in love, then....I remember I had that for a long time. I wonder how many grieving people saw us and felt that twinge of envy and sadness
It's 20 yrs since my Dad died. He was very old, and had a complete life. I still cry. I can't imagine the unrelenting, needless pain these families are going through.
Hearing Zana sister talking about her in present term breaks my heart . She keeps saying “ she is “ and not “ she was “ . I pray you heal and stay strong ❤❤❤ Rest in peace all 4 angels
When Kaylee's mom said she could not believe the world did not stop and people continued smiling and laughing outside, this is EXACTLY how I felt when my mom passed away in 2017. I could not believe they could go on when my mom was no longer with us. I hated those people. The pain of losing a loved one is absolutely unbearable.
To Kaylees mom: I want you to know that my world indeed stopped and I'm still scarred forever from what happened to your beautiful daughter and her friends. A wakeup call to all about the dangers of social media.
Well said. You’re the first person to mention social media being involved and I’m glad you did. I was overwhelmed by the amount of pictures and videos that these kids put out there. It is scary, but still parents ignore it. Sad
Hi.
This is the first time I've heard about this case. Can you elaborate a little on how it's linked to social media?
I actually don't have any social media now, and took everything down a few years ago.
@@Sigma.6 Hi there. The Killer was following and 'liking' maddie's instagram posts. It probably wasn't too difficult for the killer to figure out private details of her life just based on the simple fact she posted so frequently to instagram. He most likely chose her based off of her instagram content.
@@Sigma.6most if not all of the victims were active on social media, documenting their lives, tagging the people they were with and marking the locations they were at. They were very pretty girls and clearly enjoyed the attention but sadly the stuff they posted is exactly what would catch the attention of some freak scrolling through posts from his area, looking for a victim.
@@Sigma.6 yes, basically Kohberger followed two of the victims on social media
There's something with Dylan. The fact that she waited 8 hours to call the police. I wouldn't be surprised if she had something to do with it. Because that is Weird that he didn't touch her.
Is there any connection A-B
The mothers comment about the world still going after losing her daughter, hits me hard. Thats exactly how my husband and I feel. It feels impossible to keep living when your child dies. We were shocked how quickly it seemed everyone moved on, because to us we're still stuck on that day 8 years ago.
Justice for Maddie, Kaylee, Xana, Ethan and their families.
Justice for all.
Did they show maddie’s parents??? Or did i miss that
@@redline350zHRyes they did
Thank you for giving these families a voice! They need to be the focus, not BK.
I can’t believe there are people out there that actually support BK!!! Blows my mind!
These bright, beautiful kids deserved to live their lives. To graduate, get married, have their own kids. To have four lives taken in such a violent disturbing way is just utterly heartbreaking. May Kaylee, Maddie, Xana and Ethan rest in eternal peace ❤️ My heart goes out to their families. May they get justice for their babies ❤️
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial. bunch of salty cows
If he is found guilty they should let each parent have him for 5 mins.
@@rootiyriddle636They have every reason to be "salty". Thier world as they know it has been altered forever. They lost their child in a violent & disgusting way.
Nothing they have said should have an effect on his trial.
My best friend of 30 years was violently murdered in 2022… I can tell you the amount of pain and anguish the families of these people are feeling… it’s something that will change you and your view of the world forever. I would never wish this feeling on my worst enemy… because it’s soul crushing to lose someone this way. It hits me at random times now… I will hear a song we used to like and just start crying. Doesn’t matter where I am… driving in the car, walking around the grocery store, even when I am sleeping at night. It’s always the people that deserve it the least… I will never forget the moment my wife told me… I jumped up out of bed and collapsed on the floor. All I could do was cry… I called him, no answer. I called his brother and knew right away when I heard his voice… it was the worst day of my entire life. My heart is still broken into pieces, thankfully I have amazing people around me that help remind me life is still worth living.
I guess my point here is, never pass up an opportunity to tell people you love them. I am so grateful the last thing I told my friend before he passed was that I loved him and I missed him. 2 weeks later he was gone forever…
So sorry for your loss.
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
What happened to your friend bro ?
@@AVENTUS7777 he was stabbed to death by some pos trying to get money for meth…. The guy never said a word to him.. he just ambushed him. It’s sad because if he would have just asked, my friend would have given it to him. The wounds were all to his heart and lungs, so he passed within minutes of the attack. His coworkers who were also there, tried to help him but it was too late. They did manage to hit the guy with one of their cars, but he was so high on meth he just popped right back up.
As a mother of a beautiful daughter I am still broken inside from this horrendous case. My prayers and love to everyone involved, especially the families.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
Somehow one man killed four people on different floors of a house without any screams or noise? Or blood found in the get away car? He would be covered in blood. Even his hair would be almost drenched in blood. All completed in 8 minutes? Incredible
And yet, Brian Kohberger did just that!!!
The other roommates had to be involved. There is zero chance you don't hear something, then see a man walking through your house, then not call the police for 8 hours..also she apparently called her boyfriend who drove many hours to be there. Before police were even called. Seems zero chance Dylan isn't involved. @@_MustangSally_
Plus there would be a trail of bloody footprints from house to where car was parked.
One of my former lacrosse teammates goes to university of Idaho. He was a freshman at the school when this happened. Graduated from my high school in ‘22. Lost my dad in the same year as well from a stroke and kidney failure. And lost my aunt unexpectedly just a few weeks ago to an illness that caused an emergency trip to the ICU. Those were so hard but I guarantee you they are nothing compared to what these people when through. Crazy to think though now a year later how haunting this still is. Unbelievable and I hope the whole community is doing okay. I can’t even imagine the deep mourning that had to happen it still is bone chilling🙏❤️
I remember after my dad died - my wife asked me to take her to a shop so we could get out of the apartment. I struggled with the juxtaposition that an amazing human being was gone against dance music playing in a store and people hurriedly getting on with their lives. I understand the mom - it is a weird and dark place. I’m sorry for anyone going through this. Life is bittersweet. Enjoy the sunny days you get with the ones you love.
I remember that same feeling when my father died..
thats how i felt when my dear wife died like my life just stood still while everybody was going about their lives nothing feels the same
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
Sorry to hear@@pauljones8218
When I was in college, a friend of my boyfriends was murdered at the University of Delaware. She was strangled raped, and then set on fire. We had just been at her 20th birthday a couple of weeks prior. Your stomach just drops. When you’re young and someone you know passes, it’s extremely influential. It’s a reminder of how short life can be. It’s devastating, and I feel for not only the families, but the young ones who knew these kids because that’s a really hard feeling to manage
Was the killer black?
@@HowieHoward-ti3dx he was
@@Threehuahuas I see my comment to you was deleted. Some wise guy doesn't like the truth being told.
@@HowieHoward-ti3dx what was the comment?
What was her name if you don’t mind me asking?
Those two survivors ....they should have called 911 earlier...so sus
As frustrating as it is that the roommate didn’t call 911 I can’t blame her. She didn’t know what was happening at that point and an intruder in her home would scare most people into hiding until they felt safe enough to move.
@@admirallily no
@@jodievukmir3187 yes
@@admirallily she wasn't to scared, frozen, in shock to call the boyfriend who lives 5 hours away and wait for his arrival to check out the house. 911 would of been there in minutes. Boyfriend was the one that called 911. 🤔
I really hope these families get answers.
My oldest daughter just started college this year so this really bothers me, I just couldn't imagine if something like this happened to my child, I feel so bad for their parents and loved ones 🙏
My son did as well and I am constantly worried about him and his safety.
Warn your daughter against catering to strangers 24 hours a day
8 hours before calling the police? what in the actual F**k. Afraid or not, this is beyond strange.
I was looking for this comment!. I've seen videos of 7 year Olds calling 911 in the face of danger. For a university student to be frozen for 8hours is beyond strange!
@@sandradube4456Little 7 year old called 911 in Robb Elementary School shooting in room 1215. How are these two couldn’t call 911.
I have always wondered how he was able to unalive two people sleeping in the same bed without either one run screaming and someone in the house hearing! RIP to them all
He had a large knife and ambushed them.
There’s no words to describe how horrible these murders were. What the victims went through is unimaginable. So many hugs and prayers for the families and friends involved.❤
I attended University of Idaho for my 2nd bachelor's degree 8 years ago and it's the safest town and I am still find it so tragic that this happened in such a nice community, and i partied at same bars and went to same restaurants and always felt safe, and I grew up in same area as these kids and they'll forever be missed and cherished!
Not so safe anymore
It was never safe
Was safe. Just a crazed person arrived..so sad.
Scary how all it takes for something like this to happen in an otherwise safe community is one violent psychopath
@@ReRe13-if he was still out and about instead of in jail like he is id say its safer then when he was out and nobody knew whatall he was capable of
I love Kaylee’s parents. They have difference of opinions, but understand it’s each their own opinion.
I agree but I would say the dad is just being extra careful so there is zero chance the killer gets out pretty smart of him really
@@x-raymind7778 He's not as smart as he thinks. He knows the criminal case isn't solid so he's posturing for a civil wrongful death case...
@@x-raymind7778I think he needs to stop speaking to the media.
@@Chad_Max they should hire a private investigator to be extra confident.
@@Chad_Max It may be solid, but we won't know for sure since there is a gag order. But you want to be extra confident here so as I said they should hire a private investigator too.
The parents and families are SO STRONG - your kids would be so proud. Truly.
The roommate should be investigated. There is a link between the two
They were
They say his car returned after murders. He was checking to make sure DM didn't call cops perhaps.
There doesn't have to be a connection between a murderer and their victim(s). There are people who choose evil.
Agreed
We will see. obviously there is some connection because he killed them so brutally. He must have been very angry with at least one of them.
If you knew anything about crime then you'd know there's a connection 99% of the time
@@redrocket597 yeah it’s pretty clear that kohberger hated these girls and wanted them dead
@@redrocket597yes, but the levels of connection vary. And there are ALWAYS outliers.
Not all murderers have an apparent motive theyre just psychopaths
My dad died when I was 13 and my world felt like it stopped then but I cannot imagine loosing my little brother
If Kohberger is the murderer, as most of us believe, there HAS to be some connection to these four young people that remains unknown, somewhere they may have met and interacted. This case is so haunting!
If that Instagram account can be verified and traced back to him that is all the link I need. If he was actually following two of the victims and liking their pictures he was probably stalking them.
This specific case will always stick with me. I remember exactly when it happened and for some odd reason, i was never able to just forget about it. I was so deep into this case. People all over social media - more specifically tik tok, were all trying to solve it. I mean i saw hundreds of videos about it daily. It was unbelievable the amount if impact this case had on people. The photos of the house always made my stomach turn - such an eerie feeling. That house was truly stuck in time.
My heart will forever go out to all the victims families. They have gone through the unimaginable. Those four beautiful souls had their whole lives ahead of them, so much potential, so much support. They all chose to further their education by attending the University of Idaho, and that i really admire.
What a great loss. They seemed so bright and full of life. Rest in paradise Kaylee, Madison, Ethan, and Xana :(
I remember very well that there was a lot of criticism of the police in Idaho as if they were incompetent when in fact they were collecting evidence and being quiet about it.
Bryan kohberger was fat at school bullied by other kids held him done shoved a sock down his throat and weed on him he was followed home from school beaten up his name was smeared by bullies at school no girl wanted to go near him at school he could of dealt with it a different way instead of taken it out on someone else he could of got therapy and put it in the past
Same. I will never ever forget Kaylee, Maddie, Xana and Ethan. I'm from the UK and follow lots of true crime pages. I couldn't get this case out of my head for months and months. Everyday I would think about these innocent babies. When Koberger was arrested I was so relieved. I hope they get justice.
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
Goncalves family would do anything to prevent brian from having a fair trial
My husband passed away unexpectedly at 33.
I felt the same way her mom was talking about.
It seems so wrong & unfair that the world kept turning. That people kept smiling & laughing & just living life. It was almost like he was never there.
I wanted to scream for everyone to stop. That he exsisted, he was amazing & that he mattered!! It is devastating & I wouldn't wish that on anyone.
It has been 10 years & I still get that feeling sometimes.
@@Mdksupreme1 Certainly nobody will care when you pass away
@@Wft-bu5zc that's a lie, but most definitely no one will mourn or even think about you, when you pass away
❤❤❤
@@Wft-bu5zcoh you’re cool do you feel better now
@@Wft-bu5zc Whoa dude, what is wrong with you? Major mental health alert go get some help. These women in Idaho were picked because of trying to be a snooty preppy pest where everyone else in their eyes is below them. They can't even reach out to tell a guy in their DMs for the 10th time "Im not interested".
😢My God strengthen these families and give them peace ❤
RIP beautiful young people 😊
May I be honest here? To me it sounds very strange for the surviving girl to "freeze" for more than 8 hours. Am I intolerant? It just does not feel right to me. I cannot imagine what these families have to go through now until the end of their lives. Because you never come over things like that.
8 hours is a long long time! Thats a full work day 😮
Whats was she doing in those 8 hours???
She was in shock and terrified to move no doubt. That would be a horrifying scene to be in.
@@KMFBibleBelieverso horrifying that she didn’t call the police for 8 hours after seeing a masked intruder, hearing crying, and even watched him leave with the opportunity to call for help? And then decide to go to sleep instead? Odd she used her phone to call her boyfriend instead of legitimate help.
The birthing of the child with extreme similarities to the horrific night is beautiful. I hope the families can live a happy and healthy life in the face of heartbreak.
BK is innocent. he is being framed because the police are too incompetent to catch the real killer/s
My heart hurts for these beautiful victims and their families, I pray and hope they receive the justice they deserve.
Agreed
This breaks my heart . I'm so sorry to these families and friends. He needs to pay.
I was wondering why there weren’t really any updates on the case . It’s bc this monster wants to prolong this pain for as long as possible. Truly the worst
I’m glad 48 Hours gave the families a voice despite the gag order. Looking forward to a follow up episode after the trial is complete. ❤❤❤❤
I don't get upset very often while watching 48 hours but these kids losing their lives so early for no reason is just tragic my heart goes out to all the families especially Mrs Gonzales
Gonçalves
@@nhmooytis7058 Easy enough mistake to make 🙄
@@donnamccarron6342 only being That Guy to show off learning Portuguese on Duolingo 😂
@@nhmooytis7058But González is the Spanish version, and Gonçalves is the Portuguese one (I'm Brazilian).
@@VRUrban yeah I know see above. And while Brazilians speak Portuguese they and people from Portugal speak differently.
My heart just breaks for the families. It hurts to even fathom. Good on 48 to focus on the victims instead of the monster
This whole case is so sad!😢 I hope justice is served soon for these angels!❤️🩹
I’m sorry Christy, that the world doesn’t stop. It should, especially when there’s nothing stronger than a mothers love for their child. Of all the things you describe, I felt this. I’m so sorry ❤
Her world stopped
I cant begin to imagine the pain, the loss. The complete emptiness. I hurt for the parents. For thier children who were taken from them. May God bring true justice for all of them!
@debs6590 you have probably never lost a child. Her thoughts are what us moms feel when our child dies and the world keeps going. She's not saying the world should stop, she's saying her life has stopped.
@@debs6590 she was trying to explain a feeling many of us will thankfully never understand
That hit hard
This is one of those stories you will never forget, such a tragic loss of young life. These families have gone through hell, I hope one day they can find peace again. Their strength and courage are truly inspiring. My thoughts are with the families and I pray they get justice. ❤
I am inspired by their courage and I was also inspired by Sharon Tate's mom ! Mrs Tate has been my hero in life !
Loss ! Its a premeditated vicious attack on 4 human beings! A Coward, A vacuous Monster without thought for anyone or anything but himself! This heinous behavior deserves nothing less than all the state can bring against him. It is of vital importance the Justice System prevails despite the uphill battle brought
By the ignorance of those who cannot believe this type of evil exists. Just ask the parents and family and friends of the Victims of this horrific tragedy if it exists. You will be marked forever by even the faintest report of their agony. Agony that will echo throughout their lives. A loss , this was a Robbery!
This is just so sad 😢 and tragic. Prayers for victims and families.
Rip to all four of the students
I love the foundation for Ethan and the tulips! My father in law passed away and Tulips were his favourite flower so in his memory we have a big group of us that grows tulips ever year. He still lives on and so does Ethan and all the other victims. RIP to you all I hope justice is served ❤
Indeed a beautiful way to honor a loved one
❤
Sorry. Still cant get past the 8 hours before calling law enforcement.
There are no words! RIP all 4. What terrible world we live in
thank you 48 hours for letting those who do not live in the US access this on youtube. i think about this case regularly. the idaho 4 are in my thoughts here in scotland ❤
How’s Scotland? I’d love to visit there someday.
Thank you 48 hours for representing these beautiful souls in a sensitive way. I pray for justice, the victims, and their families. God bless them all.❤
My daughter is 22, but she'll always be my baby. My heart breaks for these parents. I cannot imagine. Parents, tell your child every day that you love them, no matter what is going on. Even if they aren't speaking to you. Tell them.
This is such a tragic loss for all the families of the victims. Four young innocent people taken to soon. God bless you all. RIP
My heart goes out to all of the families.
I cannot imagine the grief you are carrying. I’m so saddened you have to go through the pain of losing a child.
The fact those 4 beautiful souls had to go through the horror that was inflicted on them.
Although nothing can take your pain away, I will continue to pray and think of the families that have been impacted in this tragic incident. So sorry for your loss, 😢.
This really hit our community hard, the girls grew up in my home town and were the same age as my oldest son, its just heartbreaking.
Talk to your son. Show him what being reckless and living a party life leads to
@@mtio2807I will show my kids your comment instead so they will understand what bad education leads to.
@@mtio2807 What?? Are you somehow indicating that those kids lived a party life and that's what led to this tragedy?
@@ggurksdon’t feed the troll. Despicable people don’t deserve a response.
I grew up 30 minutes from Bryan. I hope if he did it and some how gets away with it he doesn't come back to Pennsylvania but he probably would go back to his family home.