For those who don't understand, Granny doesn't like "colt cuddlers" because they can't have children. They explain that two mares can have foals, however, through magic. She discarded him because he couldn't have any foals. Even when he was with the female buffalo, he couldn't have a foal with her because she was a different species.
This fic is so well written, Granny Smith is really someone to hate in this fic, and that takes alot to hate a villain. Because everyone likes a well written villain. Bravo Scribbs
A very well-handled bit of story-telling that hits very close to home for me and mine. I've heard too damned many people make this exact excuse for their homophobia or for someone else's. Very well done. VERY well
For those who are a little confused with this story - Granny Smith disapproves of "Colt cuddlers" since they basically can't have children. She isn't a homophobe since she approves with "filly foolers" which includes the relationship between applejack and rainbowdash since via magic, they can have children. Also, brayburn (applejack's cousin from appleloosa) is in a relationship with little strong heart, a buffalo. Since she isn't a pony, they won't be able to reproduce. Granny Smith disapproves of the relationship and has told the family to reject them (photo wall = banished) Bad apple, banished son of Granny (who has been secretly in contact with applejack) - comes back to play with honour - a game of cards with the following bet: if granny wins - bad apple will leave and never talk to applejack every again. If bad apple wins - granny has to accept brayburn's relationship with little strong heart and allow her to become apart of the apple family (which goes against her views)
So, in all - granny wants the family to grow. Colt cuddlers + Interspecies relationships = no children. Filly foolers + magic = children. She only disapproves of relationships that won't lead to offspring. Btw, scribble's story telling is awesome! Great work!
I'm pretty late to the commenting here, but I just came upon this one recently, and I really loved it. I got the feeling that it was more of a 'Wall Of Shame' thing going on with the photo's Granny Smith had put up. Her son was up there for supporting Colt Cuddlers (who can't have foals) Braeburn married a buffalo, bringing the race factor into it. Therefore his pic went up too. By the temptation of him losing meant he would avoid the family forever, Bad Apple played for the picture coming down, symbolising that the family was now 'allowed' (by Granny Smith's words) to accept the buffalo bride into the family. (Even though AJ and Big Mac probably already did). By this, he forced Granny Smith into breaking with 'tradition' (also known as her pride) and having to accept that the days she was in now were more progressive and open than the days she grew up in. Just because a couple cannot produce young doesn't make them excusable targets for bigotry. Granny Smith had to choke down her disgust and accept them, because she played for her pride and lost - therefore having to honour her word to Bad Apple. Good on you, Bad Apple 😊
The VA for Bad Apple did an outstanding job I have to say. It is odd how bad the dislike/like ratio is for this story on FimFiction is though. As always, thanks for the reading Scribbler.
that was bloody amazing!! the story! the voices! the narration! the music! so spectacular, i was having a terrible day, this really turned it around :) thank you, fantastic work to everyone involved.
i don't think granny is a homophobe I think she may be racist, her problem at first was that her son was a colt cuddler, but then he decided to love a buffalo, a female buffalo. I think by the end of this story it was more an issue with race than homosexuality.
I've also considered since the time I originally wrote that comment, that maybe granny is biased o sot of like a double standard, she hates colt cuddlers, but is ok with filly foolers. I'm not completely dismissing my first assumption I'm adding to it with this comeent. in our society women are usually subject to the double standad, in this world males would be subject to it.
@@puppyhowler Apple jack isn't first born and has a sister and brother along with having a valuable spot as being one of the best workers on the sweet Apple acres, the element of honesty who has assisted in saving the world multiple times, and is a beloved friend of the princess of friendship. It wouldn't be worth throwing her out and at least she was dating another pony.
Incredible as always Miss Scribbler Ive been meaning to ask though Can you please please please put a link in your next vid to your fiction "Playing withmy heart"? Ive been listening to Goomba read it Great work btw but im dying to find out what happens next :) Thanks and keep up the good work Inkwell
(Enter eastenders outro theme at end) It just sounds like an episode from the show evan though I havent watched it in months. That was well written and well put together :)
Her thing is like... Can't reproduce? Then you failed. Two stallions can't have a baby. Different species can't have a baby. Two mares however can have a baby thanks to magic. That's the big difference for Granny Smith,having children and keep the family bloodline going.
...Did you reuse the ending of this by accident? I swear I remember you fangirling over Anna Chloe M and talking about your exercise routine in almost those exact same words. Am I going crazy?
You might well be, as this is the first time Anna has appeared in one of my readings and the whole reason I've started my new (kind of) regime is because I don't exercise enough to complain about it. O.o You're clearly psychic!
Oooo i know those mucle craps the best thing u can do to smooth them over take 2 asprins and then take a long walk the asprins will will realese tentson on the mucles and the walking wil limber u up and get your blood pumping aiding in recovery
Awesome story! The only thing that bothers me though is that it says that Braeburn is Granny Smiths son! If she's AJ's granny and Braeburn is AJ's cousin then... I don't know.
Are you talking about the stallion who's playing cards with the Granny Smith because that is in Braeburn or is there something that I missed because I tend to do that sometimes even though I've heard this a thousand times
+_ Aki _ Sweet Apple Mascara? Is that the version where Big Mac tortures the CMC with make-up? Kidding. I just found it funny that no one's noticed the typo. xD
*open the letter* and the winner of best reading and everyone love her And she knows how to put sound effects,Voices and you feel like your watching a movie and >.> should be in Hollywood in or pony saying fillywood goes to... *drums goes faster* ....Scribbler! *opens another letter* And the winner of best channel with mlp stories goes to....*drums goes faster again*....Scribbler! *and open the last letter* AND the winner for being the best pony goes to....Scribbler!
I wanted to know if you could read this story. www.fimfiction.net/story/133544/of-the-hive please check it out i think it is a great story and it has me on the edge of my seat with the second one.
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Readings] ‘Paper Tigers’ by MidnightDancer (slice-of-life/drama/sadfic)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w7frvCcdAX8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Readings] ‘Paper Tigers’ by MidnightDancer (slice-of-life/drama/sadfic)](/img/tr.png)
![Sparrow Reads: Withering Bloom [MLP Fanfic Reading] (TRAGEDY/SAD/DARK)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k4cGgylWzQk/mqdefault.jpg)
!["The Bird Feeder" [Pony Grimdark]](/img/n.gif)
For those who don't understand,
Granny doesn't like "colt cuddlers" because they can't have children. They explain that two mares can have foals, however, through magic.
She discarded him because he couldn't have any foals.
Even when he was with the female buffalo, he couldn't have a foal with her because she was a different species.
I just thought she was homo phobic until I remembered the part about Applejack and Rainbow Dash.
damn, so he was gay?....damn
@@rikkapotatosalad4721 Bi. He likes both men and woman. Hence both liking colts and being with a female buffalo.
Thank you for the explanation, by the way. I didnt fully understand.
This fic is so well written, Granny Smith is really someone to hate in this fic, and that takes alot to hate a villain. Because everyone likes a well written villain. Bravo Scribbs
A very well-handled bit of story-telling that hits very close to home for me and mine. I've heard too damned many people make this exact excuse for their homophobia or for someone else's. Very well done. VERY well
For those who are a little confused with this story - Granny Smith disapproves of "Colt cuddlers" since they basically can't have children. She isn't a homophobe since she approves with "filly foolers" which includes the relationship between applejack and rainbowdash since via magic, they can have children. Also, brayburn (applejack's cousin from appleloosa) is in a relationship with little strong heart, a buffalo. Since she isn't a pony, they won't be able to reproduce. Granny Smith disapproves of the relationship and has told the family to reject them (photo wall = banished) Bad apple, banished son of Granny (who has been secretly in contact with applejack) - comes back to play with honour - a game of cards with the following bet: if granny wins - bad apple will leave and never talk to applejack every again. If bad apple wins - granny has to accept brayburn's relationship with little strong heart and allow her to become apart of the apple family (which goes against her views)
So, in all - granny wants the family to grow. Colt cuddlers + Interspecies relationships = no children. Filly foolers + magic = children. She only disapproves of relationships that won't lead to offspring.
Btw, scribble's story telling is awesome! Great work!
Thank. You.
+Mary B.F.O.E :3 no worries 😊
Alrighty that sums it up thx
Thank You !
I'm pretty late to the commenting here, but I just came upon this one recently, and I really loved it. I got the feeling that it was more of a 'Wall Of Shame' thing going on with the photo's Granny Smith had put up.
Her son was up there for supporting Colt Cuddlers (who can't have foals)
Braeburn married a buffalo, bringing the race factor into it. Therefore his pic went up too.
By the temptation of him losing meant he would avoid the family forever, Bad Apple played for the picture coming down, symbolising that the family was now 'allowed' (by Granny Smith's words) to accept the buffalo bride into the family. (Even though AJ and Big Mac probably already did).
By this, he forced Granny Smith into breaking with 'tradition' (also known as her pride) and having to accept that the days she was in now were more progressive and open than the days she grew up in. Just because a couple cannot produce young doesn't make them excusable targets for bigotry.
Granny Smith had to choke down her disgust and accept them, because she played for her pride and lost - therefore having to honour her word to Bad Apple.
Good on you, Bad Apple 😊
I love this, it's amazingly brought to life by such wonderful music combined with great voice actors, and the ending! Lovely, simply lovely
The VA for Bad Apple did an outstanding job I have to say. It is odd how bad the dislike/like ratio is for this story on FimFiction is though. As always, thanks for the reading Scribbler.
that was bloody amazing!! the story! the voices! the narration! the music! so spectacular, i was having a terrible day, this really turned it around :) thank you, fantastic work to everyone involved.
Take as much time as you need we are not going anywhere
Well done on another hit, and thank you to all the people out there that do the voice overs.
one of my favorite from your work scribbler. Truly a piece of art.
This is one of my favorite fanfics i listen to it again and again
This was a good story. Written and read brilliantly
i don't think granny is a homophobe I think she may be racist, her problem at first was that her son was a colt cuddler, but then he decided to love a buffalo, a female buffalo. I think by the end of this story it was more an issue with race than homosexuality.
i agree, if she threw him out for being a "colt cuddler", then aj should have been kicked out for being with rainbowdash
I've also considered since the time I originally wrote that comment, that maybe granny is biased o sot of like a double standard, she hates colt cuddlers, but is ok with filly foolers. I'm not completely dismissing my first assumption I'm adding to it with this comeent. in our society women are usually subject to the double standad, in this world males would be subject to it.
@@puppyhowler Apple jack isn't first born and has a sister and brother along with having a valuable spot as being one of the best workers on the sweet Apple acres, the element of honesty who has assisted in saving the world multiple times, and is a beloved friend of the princess of friendship. It wouldn't be worth throwing her out and at least she was dating another pony.
For the love of Luna this was so very good.... cool job all /)
i know its long but please read past sins
its my favorite fanfic and I would love an audio version
Sometimes the right thing take the wrong sort.
Incredible as always Miss Scribbler Ive been meaning to ask though Can you please please please put a link in your next vid to your fiction "Playing withmy heart"? Ive been listening to Goomba read it Great work btw but im dying to find out what happens next :) Thanks and keep up the good work
Inkwell
Damn... What a story!
(Enter eastenders outro theme at end)
It just sounds like an episode from the show evan though I havent watched it in months.
That was well written and well put together :)
Woof. All I can say really really good. And your voice fantastic.
very well done yet again! well writen and well played!
ah, so this was more about interspecies relationships then homosexual relationships.
.....I don't get it what's the story about I can barely hear her and my captions won't work
Well if you call him "Bad Apple", what else can you expect??
you meen hooves right your hoover wouldn't crary you right :)
This was great! Thx again!
It looks to me in the thumnail/thumbnail it's an older version of fluttershy
So...Granny Smith is a die hard traditionalist, hates gay stallions, but is okay with lesbians?
Her thing is like... Can't reproduce? Then you failed.
Two stallions can't have a baby. Different species can't have a baby. Two mares however can have a baby thanks to magic.
That's the big difference for Granny Smith,having children and keep the family bloodline going.
Is their anything Anna's not in? I think not. Good reading as always.
Really really good.
...Did you reuse the ending of this by accident? I swear I remember you fangirling over Anna Chloe M and talking about your exercise routine in almost those exact same words. Am I going crazy?
You might well be, as this is the first time Anna has appeared in one of my readings and the whole reason I've started my new (kind of) regime is because I don't exercise enough to complain about it. O.o You're clearly psychic!
I could have also sworn I'd read this story before, but according to Fimfiction, that wasn't the case.
SOMETHIN CRAZY GOIN ON HERE
Granny is mean.... How dare she be so mean to Bad apple just because he is happy being with a man... It's horrible :'(
+_ Aki _ Isn't a song called Bad apple? o3o
Idek
U do a grate granny smith
did...did things just get deep here?
Oooo i know those mucle craps the best thing u can do to smooth them over take 2 asprins and then take a long walk the asprins will will realese tentson on the mucles and the walking wil limber u up and get your blood pumping aiding in recovery
Poor poor scribbler
Awesome story! The only thing that bothers me though is that it says that Braeburn is Granny Smiths son! If she's AJ's granny and Braeburn is AJ's cousin then... I don't know.
Are you talking about the stallion who's playing cards with the Granny Smith because that is in Braeburn or is there something that I missed because I tend to do that sometimes even though I've heard this a thousand times
Good job keep it up
Im kinda confused explain
Thank you that was grate.
YEEEEEEEE BEAUTIFUL
You should read the sweet apple mascara
+_ Aki _ I don't think I'll ever be reading that badly written bit of gore-porn.
+ObabScribbler XD ikr that story was to messed up
+ObabScribbler hahahah
+_ Aki _ Sweet Apple Mascara? Is that the version where Big Mac tortures the CMC with make-up?
Kidding. I just found it funny that no one's noticed the typo. xD
He sounds like Herbert from family guy to me
im 3:53 in and i bet its BraeBurn lol owo
i wish you luck on getting out of bed tomorrow
im slightly confused
Me too
wow i didn't think this turn into an interracial er species hate
Could you please read "Honey Pie"?
I really liked this story. The only thing I didn't like was AppleDash.... It just isn't right. But that was really a super small complaint
*open the letter* and the winner of best reading and everyone love her And she knows how to put sound effects,Voices and you feel like your watching a movie and >.> should be in Hollywood in or pony saying fillywood goes to... *drums goes faster* ....Scribbler!
*opens another letter* And the winner of best channel with mlp stories goes to....*drums goes faster again*....Scribbler!
*and open the last letter* AND the winner for being the best pony goes to....Scribbler!
EEEEEEEEE!!!! Gabe's getting some exposure. VAs are a little shaky, needs some accent work.
Not really a fan of this story. But a good reading regardless.
le writer's block XD
I wanted to know if you could read this story. www.fimfiction.net/story/133544/of-the-hive
please check it out i think it is a great story and it has me on the edge of my seat with the second one.
??? um, scribbler I love your readings, but WTF was this???