"I Agree With Joey Barton" | Esther Krakue On Women Not Commentating On Mens Football | The Talk
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- Joey Barton has made controversial comments about women football commentators not being able to commentate on the men's game.
Following his tweet he appeared on Piers Morgan Uncensored where he was challenged on his views.
Discussing his comments on the The Talk panel are James Glancy, Penny Smith, JJ Anisiobi, Esther Krakue and Jonny Gould.
#football #news #sports #talktv #talkradio
He's not misogynistic, he's just correct!!!
Ye, the hypocrisy. Male referees have been banned from the women's world cup since 1995.
Misandry all round.
He's right I turn telly off if woman footie commentares on
Apparently any questioning of female competence is misogyny. Is any questioning of male competence misandry? No. You can either do the job or not.
Im suprised why it took so long for someone to come out and say what we all been thinking. Big ups to Joey
It ISN'T what "we've all been thinking". Only sexist throwbacks like Barton were thinking it
Kevin keegan said a similar thing weeks ago .
Keegan lit the fuse
Everyone else was being shamed to silence. I've held this view with plenty of criticism.
100% Correct Mr Barton
100% bigoted and sexist.
Misogynistic means to have a severe dislike or hatred of women.
Since when does disagreeing with a woman or criticism of a woman become hatred?
The word misogyny is used to silence people just like calling someone racist.
If any sex is hated and is attacked constantly by the other it's men.
Woman are shouting we HATE men etc, not a word, disagree with a woman and they want you in jail.
Nearly all people in the media use the word misogyny out of context. It's frustrating, but I don't care anymore, men should say what they think and give the finger to people who strawman their views as 'misogynistic'.
You nailed it!
It’s one of the many LGBT fairies go to insults when they are proved wrong & throw a little tantrum !!
Since women born after 1980 became adults and reinvented the rules
Very true
I'm not particularly a Joey Barton fan, but I have to say that I'm 100% behind him in this.
Absolutely, my sentiments entirely. 🙂👍
totally agree men do men's game and women do womens game @@vicwiseman2340
I concur entirely Sir. 😎
Cvvzvvvvvb or xkiijhkk9 😊 in joins g😊j😊kko😊😊😊😊bb😊😅uh😊bv😊😊h😅 b hb8vvb uh hhv bgg vvvvvvvvhvhhvbbhhhhhhhhhhhjjj in jjjhhhjhhhh99bbyjn8b1:09
@@vicwiseman2340f
Fair play to Keegan and Barton for actually having the guts to publicly say what the majority of PL fans think. Any pundit should be there on merit and not because they tick a box for Sky or the BBC.
Got no issue with Women as presenters. It’s just the pundits and commentators that’s going to ruin the Men’s game. Karen Carney on MNF is a shocker. Women’s game is in such a good place why aren’t they pushing their own game?
The only people that suffer are the fans having to these insufferable banshees .. i try to find french or portuguese commentary I cant understand rather than a women 👏
@@mitchsanderson8206 Because the money is in the men's game and the world has gone woke mad 😉
Just looking at this objectively, why is there no male former players who pundit on WSL? Also, why has Sky Sports insert WSL table in between EPL and Championship, is it because WSL is bigger than Championship? Why is there no outcry for women Mgrs in EPL if the game is the same? What makes a WSL player have priority over a Lge 1 or 2 player being an EPL pundit?
@@kelwilmush Diversity vote for the woke agenda. Welcome to Britain 2023. Men have worked hard to get their game where it is and Women have done nothing to earn being part of it. Go and grow your own game and make that a success 👍
A women commentator reduces the excitement of the game, they dont have the knowledge or personality to be any good. Agree with Joey!
Can’t convey the emotion either, no woman can describe a goal like Martin Tyler.
@@tompato476 yeh totally agree, but we are sexist pigs for stating this 🙄
If we follow this logic of Joey Barton men, then they cannot be gynecologists because the bodies of men and women are completely different. Esther messed up on this one.
@@alanklebersantszThat's a non sequentor argument and is baseless.
What a load of utter crap
Totally correct Mr Barton, I was looking forward to yesterdays match between Palace and Liverpool only for it to be ruined by the monotonous drone of Lucy Wards voice. I had to resort to playing the radio commentary while watching the TV.
He's right. It's like finding the wife in the shed.
This comment has ended me…😂 pure Gold
🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
Or a bloke washing up!
He’s 100% correct,when a woman is commentating on the men’s game I have to mute it,and I haven’t watched football focus since it became obsessed with female presenters and women’s football!!
" I have to mute it". Are you afraid the woman might know the game better than you do?
@@colinmatts Keep thinking that,simp!
@@gooders4648 I'm not the "simp" who thinks women can't talk about football
@@colinmattshe didn't say women can't speak about football, he muted it because it ruins the experience of watching the game listening to a nagging voice. I mute it for same reason. I would rather watch in silence.
@@Scotz9 I'm sure your missus would love a mute button on you
Not a fan of Barton but he is spot on about women commentating on men's football
All the women talked over one another as usual. There might be the same rules on the pitch but I can't listen to their high pitched voices, their want to be liked means they never criticise and until they come up against the physical aspect of playing against faster harder men they have no right to commentate. Male pundits will disagree with each other but male manners means they can't tell a female she doesn't know what she's talking about which is usually the case. Unfortunately the women commentators believe it's a popularity contest and Alex Scott regardless of how many womens games she's played in shouldn't have a say on a game that is played on a completely different level to what she was used to. Well said Joey!
Why is it wrong for a woman to commentate on men's football?
@@colinmatts it’s not wrong but it also not wrong if you don’t like what they have to say. The women commentators seem to only get excited when the England women play
@@colinmattsTake the time to read the comments. Duh!
@@paulnewton3059 What do you think I was responding to? Duh!
Why won't the press report that 95% of fans agree with Joey...He said what others are scared to say...Brilliant clap
He is 100% correct as probably all of the UK men would agree .
But he just made a controversial point without backing it up with any evidence. Gary Neville and jimmy carragher are 2 of the most biased and substandard commentators in the game today. Both of them think a monster climbing on the back of a defender with two hands pushing down on the neck is not a foul...I have never heard more pathetic analysis by anyone that follows the game let alone by any of the Women who are doing a much better job analysing the game.
@@om4482They are NOT doing a better job, two different sports men and women's football. They haven't got a clue
the men’s and women’s game are different.
As a man not living in the UK, I couldn't disagree more with Barton's stupid comments. If a woman understands the game and can articulate that understanding, why SHOULDN'T he be on TV doing that?
@@colinmatts This is it though, how can anyone who hasn't played at that level talk about it. Ex player pundits are the only ones I can listen to
I’m a women who loves football and totally agree with Joey !
Fully agree with Joey Barton …..The wokery has ruined sport for me ….. 👍👍👍👍👍👍
Wokery has has ruined everything
@@RootboundBotanist Can you define "wokery"?
@@colinmatts Promotion of minority ideology forced on the majority as the "norm".
@@jasongoldsworthy6149 How do you know what is the minority ideology on any subject?
@@colinmattslet him yap, it’s entertainment
I agree, let women commentate on the women's game and the men do the men's game. I also agree that the BBC are hell bent on forcing the women's game on audiences rather than letting it grow naturally.
I agree with Joey Barton.
It is NOT misogynistic to state that under-qualified people should not be passing judgement on those more skilled/qualified than they are.
Barton is 100% correct, as the majority of real foitball fans would agree.
It IS misogynistic to say women shouldn't be commenting on men's football when there are qualified women and unqualified men
@@okkDefine misogyny before you talk such nonsense.
@@steveo4991 I literally did in my post. If you're opinion is ALL women cannot perform a task/capability with no exception, that's misogynistic
@@okk Incorrect. Try again.
@@steveo4991 provide evidence.
Another thing, the mixing of men’s and women’s football news stories on Sky and the BBC is annoying and sometimes even confusing. This is on news shows, their websites and across their social media platforms. Keep them separate FFS. Don’t know how many times I’ve clicked on a “Man United make bid for ” thinking it’s a foreign player they’ve scouted, but no, it’s some woman I don’t care about for the women’s team I have no interest in. Barton is a complete knob, but he’s right on this one.
💯
Yes, it's so frustrating. The woke media are using the technique of riding on the coat tails of the identity of the men's teams.
They do it to promote the woman's game and make out we're interested
100% right I’m sure the majority of men think exactly the same. Sky are as bad as anyone, yesterday on soccer Saturday, there was 9 reporters of which 3 were women that’s 33% women covering men’s football, who cares what they think? Women commentators I like John Terry turn the sound off
Totally agree. They place it before men
Joey Barton is spot on let women commentate on women's football and leave the men's game alone.
Let’s be honest about it, FairPlay to joey Barton a tip of the cap to you sir, this bollocks is getting ridiculous.
It is. Are we relics, living in the present? Or are we endangered peoples needing to rise and defend?
The idea that a woman can't commentate on a football match is bollox
@@colinmatts The idea that is coming from jailbird Barton is laughable.
Well said Joey. How many men commentated on the other World Cup ? Keep female commentators on female matches and vice versa.
Joey Barton is absolutely right, my wife even agrees with him. Let the women commentate on their matches with female pundits and vice versa for the mens games. You can tell the men hate having the women 'experts' and it actually gets in the way of the natural interaction we used to have . I would ask anyone who thinks otherwise what does bringing females into the mens game achieve ?
"It's inclusive" - Some lefty twat, probably
Woman's football is good for insomnia it's so boring
I don’t think anything much is lost or gained from having female pundits so for me this is all a huge non-issue.
My wife says exactly the same
female football commentators are just awful full stop, sorry not sorry.
I've never condoned any of Joey Barton's previous actions, but I completely agree with what he says here.
He speaks the truth of most football supporters. I want the best commentators (champions league players/winners, premier league players/winners) these guys are best places to comment on a mens games. I have seen womens' football and non league (NATIONAL LEAGUE NORTH) and the differnce is minimal. Champions League/Premier League....your're having a laugh
I agree with him woman shouldn't be on men footie shows
Totally correct and any man on the telly would say exactly the same if they had the balls so to speak, and were not scared to lose their job. Shout especially to the women who shrieks her way through a commentary on bbc.
Totally INCORRECT. There are laws against sexism in the work place
He’s absolutely right. There is nothing wrong with female presenters or commentators. However when it comes to pundits, we want knowledge and expertise of sport at that level from our “experts”. No woman has ever played football at that level, so they don’t have a clue what they are talking about.
I am a 60 year old woman and would say I have followed football for 50years. Esther and Joey are absolutely right. I can't listen to football commentary when a woman does it, crazy. Joey Barton can be an idiot but on this he's right and where does misogyny come into it ridiculous. Who is the fella with the gigs talks rubbish! Pity Esther isn't a politician she'd make a. great prime minister, common sense all the way!
he is a simp, he is what is wrong with today's society.
You remind me of the nanny from Gone with the Wind.
@@jamestoniknw you and Ur woke BS is what wrong with the world.. men that say there a woman can go in female changing rooms then.. people like you shud be ........
The people who are anti-woke are generally lazy school dropouts, or criminal thugs like Barton, who ended up married too young, kids too young and are bitter about how life didn't give them an opportunity. They lash out at anyone they feel has had success, vote Brexit to reinforce their multi-phobic tendencies, and as a way to cover up their own weakness and failure.
I would say that it's "common sense" that if a woman understands the game and can articulate that understanding she has as much right to be commentating as any man.
He’s just saying what everybody else is thinking … so many good men losing out to less qualified women merely because of their gender.
Joey's absolutely right with his comments
if we're gonna have women talking about football, then I want men talking about period pains and pregnancy. Woke is dead!!!
Well done Joey!
Hes right and its not just commentators its the presenters in particular the likes of laura woods alex scott are there just to full a quota
Or maybe it's because they're just good at their jobs
He’s saying that they should be appointed on merit regardless of their sex, sexuality or race, not BECAUSE of it as they clearly are in many cases. Where’s the controversy in that?
I also dislike how women’s football is being shoehorned into men’s football coverage. Let them have their own programs and thrive or bomb on their own merit.
While we’re at it let’s get rid of all the rainbows and BLM from football. It’s sport not a soapbox for political agendas. Sexuality or race really don’t matter in the arena of sport, which is the ultimate meritocracy, but promoting political and ideological agendas does not sit well on the sporting field.
A woman may have a deep knowledge and understanding of the game but to have them in the pundits seat instead of an ex professional male footballer is ridiculous its just box ticking we know it they know it she damn well knows it.
Love women, dislike women talking crap during a mens match
Morgan has jumped on yet another passing bandwagon JB is right
Agree with Joey. How can you commentate on something you will never have true knowledge and experience of. Doesn’t lead to much authenticity yet play the victim card. I’m no expert but they always simply state the obvious- I could do that.
Well said Joey you are 100% correct you are only saying what millions of men are thinking.👏👏👏👏👏👍ps when a woman comes on I turn off.
Well said joey you and keegan are right
100% behind Joey on this .. I watched Football Focus every Saturday for decade's but the show has now become unwatchable! Women in the men's game does not work!
BBC VERSION OF LOOSE WOMEN 😂😂😂😂😂
@@bobrail733 😂😂😂👍
@@bobrail733It’s like a hybrid of Loose Women and children’s tv.
Same. I watched football focus for as long as I can remember but haven’t watched it for years now. White English men aren’t allowed on it anymore unless they’re accompanied by a Woman and an African.
@@alambyant Too right m8 .. That Alex Scott makes my skin crawl!! Aye I used to like Focus, it was kinda like ur starter b4 the main course! I never missed it for yrs but as soon as the aforementioned A Scott took over I never even bothered watching.
Sad times, we've got some fairy captains wearing fkn rainbows on their left arms & that's meant 2 b the leader of your team!! 😂😂🤚👍🇬🇧🏴
Joay is totally right. Woman should not comment on men’s game of football or rugby. Stick to there own game. Many mates and myself switch off sooon as woman are on the panel
Women presenting a program on the men’s game, even reporting a game, I have no problem because they can do the homework and they call what they see just as good as any man. But women analysts on the men’s game, no chance. And here we get into a bit of an area of contradiction on my side with women commentator’s. They could have all the knowledge, do all the homework they like but they simply haven’t got the right tone / voice. They have to over exaggerate their normal voice or they try too hard and its basically an extremely annoying listen we’re I have to turn the volume off. I have to agree Barton is spot on. And I would guess just about every man in the industry think the same, but they wouldn’t dare say because they want the work and I can understand that.
I agree but I also feel that even among male commentators there are too few that have the right tone and language skills to add theatrics to the game. Also, the change to digital audio from analog has made a big difference. Not to mention the crowd demographics changing from mostly working class to an affluent middle class has diminished things greatly. Stadiums are so quiet now. Often I rewatch the United vs Arsenal 1999 FA Cup match at villa park and it recalls to me how much more exciting as a whole theatrical package the game used to be. Martin Tyler’s beautiful tone, Andy Gray’s perfect comments, both screaming over the noise of the crowd, the swooshing sky sports infographics, the fans storming the pitch at the end…etc. If I mistakenly choose one that’s been commented on after the fact by contemporary commentators I can’t bear it. Anyway, what I’m saying is that commentary is only one area in which the game has lost its drama. And, re: the topic of this video, let’s not forget that for every bad female commentator there is a Robbie Savage…how does that guy get work!?
@@bobobahiaTotally agree. And we are not alone.
He's 100% right and everyone who's being honest knows it. Most of what they say is totally ridiculous. "she's won 8 premier leagues". A decent u14's academy side would win the women's world cup.
He's right, we all know it
Barton never provided evidence that quotas were being used
What’s Barton achieved in the game he couldn’t even make it in the spl and has won nothing.
@@nickycleere8310 made manchester city first team , played in the premier league week in week out scoring goals
@@nickycleere8310Joey Barton played in the best and hardest league in the world for years and years. If he played in the women’s league he’d be the greatest player in the world.
He's WRONG and sexist. But anyone who remembers him as a player will know he was never the brightest
millions of men agree with Joey.
Every where you go they are forcing the women's game down out throats,, it's awful but I hope they do well it's just not for me
My wife agrees with joey and so do I. As Leeds fans for many many years, 60 in my case, we agree that not only are women out of place in the men's game, women's football is just a Mickey Mouse copy of the real thing . I've no problem with women playing football it is a game for everyone, but just stick to your own bit and leave the proper football alone
Your so. Right I think men's commentators don't want women on men's footie shows
What this is really concerning about this is the fact that you can't have an opinion without being shamed and vilified. Barton has every right to give his opinion. Opinions are not a threat. If you don't like them ignore them.
Has to be the right opinion nowadays it seems or your evil end of 😂
We are in the times when speaking the truth is increasingly becoming a revolutionary act.
100% agree. An opinion is just that, an opinion!
@dylan-pz5ee .. you mean the Woke kind
Very true, let women commentate on women’s football, and let the men do the men. The sports are 100% different and played at a much higher skills and intensity level. The woke world has gone crazy !!!
There is a difference in physicality between the men's and women's games. But why should that prevent women TALKING about the game?
@@colinmatts because they don’t understand what it’s like at elite level. The USA World Cup winning team where beaten by under 16’s boys team, there is a massive gulf of difference. Would you want to watch me commentate on Premier Football, as I played football when I was 16, so does that make me qualified ?
@@nicklegend4513 But they understand enough to be able to TALK about it. If you could speak articulately on the game as all the women pundits do, then you'd have as much right to comment as they have. This argument is NOT about women playing with or against men. It's simply to do with TALKING about the game
Joey is spot on, I cannot listen to female commentators in the premiership they make my brain bleed.
He has a point, then brings the hysteria that someone is speaking the truth or going against mainstream agenda gets labelled far right & out of touch etc etc.
Nothing wrong with woman commentating on women's matches but sorry male commentators are much better for men's games.
@anonymousone6075I think most of the female pundits are lesbian anyway
@anonymousone6075Speak for yourself. I find them annoying to listen to but I’ve never thought women commentators can’t keep up with what’s happening.
If a woman is commentating on a game, I turn it down. There's no other way. I wish they would have a system where multiple people commentate, and you can choose who you want to listen to.
Well done Joey Barton. He says what the rest of us fear to. I suppose we are all punditaphobic now!
No. He says what only Neanderthal cavemen think
It's "you're" Randy.
Totally agree with barton, networks, channels, stations etc feel they will face criticism if no women are part of their show , vicky sparks would have a huge huge say on this and would bring a hugely huge huge contribution to thfe huge debate , so annoying and clueless , well said joey 👍👍👍👍👍
He's not wrong
It’s scandalous that there aren’t any male netball commentators out there
Esther is a national treasure and I feel her pain as a fellow Red 😢 😂
Esther is brilliant
wise up ya nugget
@@johnou.k.3780 If we follow Esther's logic, men cannot be gynecologists. What do they understand about female physiology when theirs is completely inverse?
And she's rather gorgeous
Poor Esther - I sympathise but she has no idea what City fans went through year after year....
Barton is correct. Women football and women football commentators are a joke
99% of men do not want women commentators, but 99% of men are not sexist.. it totally spoils the enjoyment hearing women commentators, who try to sound good by over stating their views... Couldn't possibly imagine a woman doing the "Agueroooooo" commentary. It just doesn't fit right that the game that has predominantly been a mens game until around the 70s. Always been men commentary, with no call for anyone wanting women.. Bring in the box ticking mindset, and all of a sudden, women want to be part of it, and tv stations feel "obliged" to accommodate. Have no issue with women commentators in their own game, but please, just stay away from ours, we don't want you, your clueless views, your shrieking etc.. Even watching women's football I've noticed the crowd sounds different..lots of high pitched shrieking and screaming.. nothing like the atmosphere of a match on the Premier League..
"99% of men do not want women commentators". Did your ass hurt after you pulled that statistic out of it?
They can commentate in women's game
@@djelalniyazi4090 It's the same game
I have to admit I’m not too keen on women’s commentators, but I’m not buying all these BS reasons people are giving for it.
The reality is it’s sexism. We’re not all perfect, but don’t try and pretend it’s for some rational reason when it’s clearly not.
You’ve even said it’s because you can’t stand the ‘shrieking’ which has very little to do with their analysis or their ability to clearly tell what’s happening in the game.
What’s the point in bringing up him going to prison? Not necessary unless they purposely want to paint him in a bad light.
Football for me is totally unwatchable, women commentators, male commentators who talk far too much , multi millionaire footballers taking the knee to a drug fuelled career criminal, rainbow armbands, rainbow laces , rainbow corner flags, rainbow placards all around the ground, footballers diving every game, footballers rolling around the pitch like they've been shot, I honestly can't stand watching a whole match anymore, VAR stopages, rubbish referees, I'm content to watch the goal highlights on UA-cam.
i have to agree with barton on this, as a 58 year old life long football fan i loathe women commentators and pundits, i don't care how 'good' they are in the roles i just cannot stand women commentating on men's football, if that makes me sexist then so be it, i stopped watching the BBC long ago for various reasons, i gave up on all their football coverage before my general boycott, we all know why the likes of the BBC and sky employ so many women in football media but unfortunately for them i think the vast majority of both men and women don't like it! football has become so infected by 'wokeism' it is untrue, the game i loved is fast disappearing and i lament that, the BBC have basically run a campaign for many years on behalf of women's football, their coverage of it is out of proportion to its popularity, it is something everyone feels 'forced' to like, when i watch premier league highlights via youtube if a female voice comes on i mute it, incidentally the standard of male commentators has dropped alarmingly
A thousand likes. It's all so irritating. What´s wrong with men for men's sport and women for women's sport? You are not alone Joey.
I agree with you but I don’t hit the mute button. I turn it off as I would rather miss the game than hear the screeching and shouting. You’re right about the male commentators too. Standards have well slipped the past few years 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Spot on!
i'm sure sky could do dual audio then see how many went for a woman commentator
He’s right I cannot stand woman doing the men’s games. Drives me crazy
Well said joey I have not watched a match for five years in case a woman or Lineker is on.
He is absolutely correct. They ruin the game
They ruin everything pal.
Completely agree. I’ve read all of the comments! 100% of People agree. Nobody wants to see Alex Scott presenting football Focus hence why viewers have dropped by 40% women stick to the womens game well done joey👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
He’s not hurt anyone, his views are very good & probably what most people would agree with!
Most people would say that if a woman can do the job she should be free to
@@colinmatts Hi Col, yeah I agree, but they are irritating doing the football. I also see our binmen on a Friday, never any binwomen though!
@@vo4068 I'm sure women can apply to be rubbish collectors. They have plenty of experience. Just look at some of the blokes they pick up
@@colinmatts Hi Colin, that works two ways!
Have loved football for 55yrs to such an extent that I am an anorak but when watching a game with a woman commentator I turn the sound down. Just my preference.
On the pundit panel I think it's wrong and actually laughable to have a women who has played for England ladies 150 times (equivalent level of non league) sitting between Roy Keane and Graeme Souness and taking her seriously.
I accept the world is a changing place but I agree with Joey on this issue.
People should get those jobs based on ability and knowledge not on gender or any other issues. That is definitely what is happening in football just now.
I recall a female pundit asking if Hearts would start with 4 strikers when Hearts didn't have 4 strikers at the club!!!!!!!!
I reckon a poll would be around 85% in agreement with Barton.
So what is it Roy Keane can say about football that a woman can't?
@@colinmatts
He has experienced playing at the top level. If you can't see the difference then that's up to you but it's diluting my enjoyment.
I love music but can't play an instrument.
Who do you think has the more valued opinion........me or Eric Clapton 😂 😂
Enjoy your footy if that's how you like it mate but it's not for me.
@@bobbyneely6034 There IS NO DIFFERENCE when all you are doing is commenting on it. Eric Clapton knows more about music than you. And Alex Scott knows more about football than you as well. And she's WAY better looking than Joey Barton
@@colinmatts
Canny argue with you on the looks department but we are on different planets on the punditry 😂
Everyone thinks it but no one says it 😂 well said Joey 👏🏼
Most agree with Joey but are too scared to speak up
Totally agree with him 😊
Totally agree with Joey Barton's comments on this
I don't know about women commentating on the mens game but having watched the Sheffield vs Liverpool game, I have to say it was absolutely horrible. Maybe there are better women's commentators but that game set my expectations low 😢
I’ll be blunt, most men at some point need a (to coin a current phrase) “safe space” away from women. Football was perhaps the last space they had, but it’s been taken away. We all need a break from each other from time to time. I’m just being honest. Do women want to have men around 100% of the time also?
Spot On.
I thought it was fragile no need a safe space.
@@jonathanmarkham1998 re-read what he said and then delete your comment.
@@detroid89 Nah I’m good. I think it’s funny that the same guys that constantly whinge were too sensitive these days are usually the ones calling for ‘safe spaces’.
If he’s not one of them people then I’ll delete the comment.
Barton is spot on
Joey Barton is right and everyone knows it🤷♀️
Joey Barton couldn't be more WRONG. And every woman who talks articulately about football on TV proves it
@@colinmatts No he is right. They may be articulate in your opinion but it is with no substance. The female commentators are like having tits on a bull!
110% agree
i totally agree with barton ! imagine a male going on to commentate on netball or womens synchronised swimming the outrage.
Men commentate on women's tennis all the time and there's never an issue. Just say you're a misogynistic ass and move on.
I'm sure men could commentate on any of those sports.
Women commentating co-commentating on high-level men’s football is like a council painter and decorator commenting on Van Gogh and Picasso
Spot on Joey, spot on
Put this debate to the football masses in a fair yes no vote with one or two balanced pinpoint questions where men or women can't get cancelled by their heartfelt responses and see what happens. I would bet my house that it would be a 90% - 10% yes in favour of Mr Bartons points.
I'm not a football fan, boxing is the sport I love and I wouldn't want a woman commentating on a mans boxing match. I can see a huge difference between men and women even when interviewing boxers on youtube. Not for me. Women for women's sports, men for men's.
how dare you
@@shamusshamus6251 I read that exactly as Greta Thunberg would've said it haha.
It's the same sport. And all the women are doing is talking about it
@@colinmattsor you a female shemale or just a gay . Do you even no what your talking about 😅😅😅😅❤🎉
He is 100% right!
Joey is 100% correct.........enough said
I put tv on "mute" whenever there is a women commenting or commentating on mens football....that said I do the same whenever gary neville and jamie carragher are on to.
Well said joey 👍👍👍
If women are occasionally asked for their opinions and they work in the industry I don't see a problem the issue has become that because of this kind of equal representation thing going on where we must have each box ticked on a panel all the time, that is the real issue imo.
The presenter used the terms "misogynistic" and 'sexist" remarks.
That is subjective and judgemental and he shouldn't have put it in that way, he should be neutral.
He should be, but like alot of men it seems he's had a simp chip implanted into his head. Watching the early kick-off today was annoying with that supposed female expert. It's like they are intentionally clowning football fans / supporters.
I thought that too and didn’t take his argument seriously because of it.
Saying that woman shouldn't be allowed to commentate on football is objectively misogynistic and sexist. Barton's an idiot
Exactly, dont try to impart the narrative and let people make up their own minds. Taking things out of context.
He’s spot on though isn’t he. Most people have absolutely no idea who these women are because they haven’t played at the top level.
Didn’t Kevin Keagan say exactly the same,100% correct don’t like Barton buts he’s right on this one.
Women stay in your own area, that’s not being sexist that’s being observant they just spoil the men’s game.
Well said JOEY, keep talking the truth, you'll do for me lad.
Womens football-female officials, pundits & commentators. Mens football- male officials, pundits & commentators. This is only offensive to those determined to be offended
There are 2 types of men that watch football, those that say they hate women pundits/commentators and those that are too scared to say they hate women pundits/commentators. I do not want to hear the opinion of someone who could not have got into the local pub team.
There's another type...those of us who just want to watch a match and don't really care about the sex of the people talking about it
@@colinmattssorry mate, I always forget about the 1%
@@Stribbo55 Where do you get your stats? Same place you get your opinions, I suppose
@@colinmattsseriously dude, get a life. Most men can’t stand women pundits. That’s a fact, no stats required. Do you know what hyperbole means 🙄
@@colinmattswell said
Barton for Prime Minister..........tells it as it is 👍
Do you not think the guy you have is bad enough
Hes far too honest to be a politician
@@geecee8864 You obviously never seen him play
Joe Is Absolutely 100 Percent RIGHT…….
he and Kevin keegan ARE RIGHT
That Alex Scott is rubbish presenter
@anonymousone6075 a propers womens team in America LOST to under 12s men sorry BOYS 0-13
they do not belong on pitch with men let alone boys
just so they will NEVER play in mens football so why comment on it
have your opinion on twitter NOT in the game
END OF
Fabulous from Joey. Got the balls to say what most men are thinking.
Agreed! I can't listen to women commentating on football, rugby (are there any?) or cricket. Horrible!
Yes female commentators ruin the commentary/ pleasure of watching a game of rugby.
How they have the audacity to employ a female ex-rugby player to pass judgement on current international male rugby players, is beyond me.
Who do they think wants to listen tobthe opinions of a woman who has never played the sport to the level of the game she is providing punditry for?
I mean, football is bad enough, but rugby!
I remember the coverage of the women's world cup where their was 4 women pundit's in the studio and no men so it smacks to me of wanting your cake and eating it. Men for men's, women for women's. Simple.
If Match of the day had presenters like Barton, it might be worth watching, instead it's just got stale and bland presenters like Lineker, Shearer and Wright, we all know that these female presenters are only token presenters.
They have as much right to COMMENT on football as men. Are you scared they might know more about the game than you do?
@@colinmatts Where exactly have I remotely stated they didn't have any rights? Are you so thick as you don't know the difference between having rights and being boring?