I struggle to take this entire trilogy seriously, and this movie most of all. But just the change in the score here makes me take the scene seriously and actually feel SOMETHING watching it.
THANK YOU! I'm on the side that I'm not some kind of messiah that's here to save the star wars sequels, I just wanted to do an experiment with music and this was the scene I wanted to experiment on. The actual version hasn't been changed so those who hate this are in luck!
I was thinking towards that way, but this was pretty interesting to see. Avoided watching any of the newer sequels(except the first one), but I actually thought that this was pretty fitting.
@@takeshitabibito1208 yeah, go check out Binary Sunset without music: ua-cam.com/video/QVaZaXstujk/v-deo.html the scene is so incomplete without the amazing music
@@MattSipka I looked it up and since he's a force projection, he picked his age and that color to piss off Ben since that light saber belonged to Anakin, and Kylo claims that belongs to him earlier to Rey. I think Kylo was just so full of rage that his main goal was to kill Luke, but it was a subtle nod/foreshadowing that Luke wasn't there.
@Huma17 It's not supposed to have Raw Emotion or Suspense or even inspiration. Kylo Ren just has no idea what to do anymore and his hate is consuming him, Ben is on the wrong side. This is more of a tragic situation than a hopeful one, especially since The Resistance has only a hand full of people left alive. No one should be happy right now
not really it’s not suppose to be sad it’s suppose to be overcoming because luke is literally winning against ben anakins dark deeds has nothing to do with this scene tbh like sure it sounds cool but it doesn’t make sense narratively to have a music from a scene where anakin was killing people.
KnightLight yeah and the right after in the same soundtrack it shows dead people and everyone anakin has killed and tyne him looking off into the mustafar sun
@@Codgunner-jt2et kenobi was a master of trolling but as i remember he never maked someone loss time with a force personification of him which looks like a real person, he has a lot more of trolling maked than Luke but i think this stuff is in a higher level, if he had maked this when he battled vader it would have been amazing xd
Aj_Plays1229 I agree with you, The Force theme is almost as overused in SW as the Main Theme was in The Polar Express. Every time there's any plot development... (Dun dun, dun, dun dun dun, duuuunnn)
@@95v37 jj Abrams made Star Wars crappy because rey could do anything Jedi mind trick use the force anything but anakin probably couldn’t do those thing and he WAS SO MUCH BETTER THEN REY and it showed anakins trainings and it shows anakins a better character and kylo ren is a wanna be sorry to say it but it’s true and JJ could’ve made rey better but instead gave her plot armor
@FuntimeThylacine ! Dude, kylo is son of leia and han, that was told in the 7th chapter, and so his grandfather is anakin, wtf Even kylo said that he wants to be like his grandfather
@@joanember18379 Maybe he didn't know. It seems like most people didn't know, so that's possible, although a bit of a stretch considering all the ways he could have found out
@@joanember18379 well redeemed is a strong word, he had a father-son bonding moment in killing the emperor but like, he doesn't really show any regret over the thousands of people he's killed or the millions of lives he's ruined... So for a young mass murderer darth Vader is still a very inspirational idol, just don't make the mistake of having children and your unstoppable. Also I'm fairly sure right before luke met the emperor Vader was saying they should both kill the emperor and rule together, so when Vader killed the emperor I think Vader did not plan on actually being killed
It just makes it all the more tragic. I never looked at it from Ben’s POV. to him, Luke is the bad guy. And he’s been hurting, and felt so betrayed by what his uncle did. All the emotions come out, and then at the end, he’s denied satisfaction of the defeat of his uncle, all while his uncle is mocking and smiling at him.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I’m really happy someone else sees that, all it literally would’ve taken to make it clearer and also hit harder is a change in music, that’s all this video is, an experiment to see what a simple change to the movies we love could have on the ENTIRE overall product. I’m gonna make a few more of these ‘How Music Changes’ in 2020, so stick around to catch up on them!
I’m so sorry fits perfectly, because it was used on Obi Wans part of Dark Deeds, Obi Wan failed Anakin as a master, just as Luke did Kylo. Even their words were similar ‘strike me down in anger and I’ll be more powerful.’ Poetic
I think that’s what a lot of commenters on this video miss. I never tried to make the scene better but I used music to change the outcome of the scene emotionally. If you know the importance of the track ‘Anakin’s Dark Deeds/I’m So Sorry’ then you know why I put it here in conjunction with Kylo Ren and Luke Skywalker
@@KarlVeiga agreed man. So many great ways the music connects each part in Star Wars. Great job with the editing and general work too! Made the scene ten times more meaningful and powerful than the original one.
especially when Episode IX does not deliver a great war that really captivates everyone from the start, but disappoints completely and almost everyone...
1:26 I love how the beat drops perfectly on time when he starts running but my favorite part of this is how the music swells when he stops! It really helps illustrate the moral turmoil that Kylo is going through at this point. He’s trying so hard to be a Sith but he truly doesn’t know who he is. He’s filled with so much conflict here and I feel that Adam does a phenomenal job in this scene as well as the whole trilogy. Despite not being in a very coherent story. This is the perfect track for this scene.
In some ways he's much like Anakin in that regard during his siege on the Jedi temple a Anakin's emotions were very conflicted he didn't truly want to be a sith but in his mind it was the only way to safe Padme
The original is more optimistic and matches the emotions for each scene (hope, peace, rage, awe). This only feels tragic and sombre. But it is louder and more powerful. And the timing/editing was perfect!
You're absolutely right. I've gone on record and will continue to say that this edit was meant to try and help strengthen Kylo's plight, Rian Johnson clearly saw that Luke in Kylo's eyes is a villain, I wanted to match up Kylo's feelings of hurt, pain and betrayal with this piece of music.
@@KarlVeiga Honestly I think you've done a perfect job of synchronizing the music to express the pain kylo went through because of luke, and how much he hated him because of that, but luke's monologue of how there's still hope on the galaxy and him not being the last jedi and all, that part the music doesn't fit in. And after kylo tried to strike luke down with all his force, unleashing all of his anger and hate built up towards him just to realize that that was only a projection made from the force combined with the louder music just really gave the perfect feeling.
The entire Episode 8 movie was a shame. The music is just a small thing that would’ve made it somewhat better but oh my god they should have stuck with JJ for all 3 movies. Episode 7 was meh but 9 was awesome. If they had let JJ direct 8 they would’ve probably had character development in time for 9. Instead JJ had to rush it all in one episode. Disney really put him in a bad position
It's so interesting how this piece, which was completely unintended for this scene, fits so well. The rising action of the building tension, the climax of the more intense trumpets, and the taper off with strings all coincide with the scenes same beats.
A Force Awakens --> A New Hope but without the charm or exposition. The Last Jedi --> Rian Johnson wanted to do his own sci-fi film, Disney didn't let him, so now it's a Star Wars film I guess. Something something Skywalker. Rise of Skywalker --> Reylo: the Movie I disliked the sequels as such (they're so poor story-wise in comparison to Extended Universe stuff that it's embarrassing), but honestly TLJ at least tried to do something different. It's probably going to end up a lot like The Empire Strikes Back: mixed reviews, criticized for making Han/Leia a thing, introducing Lando the charismatic chronic backstabber, isolating the protagonist from the rest of the cast because he's training or something, oh and Vader is Luke's father for some reason. People were NOT happy about TESB when it came out. A decade later and suddenly it's the high point of the franchise so far. I really wonder if the same will happen to TLJ in many years to come, you know, when Disney releases an even Star Wars trilogy xD
@@hermionestranger4964 You should check out Ivan Ortega's re-edit of The Last Jedi. It helps to fix quite a few of the issues people had with the film (so far as the available footage would allow). I do think the Sequels are a big missed opportunity; they should've been about Anakin's legacy for the next generation of Jedi, but they went with something else.
@@divergenttardis7378 Thanks, I'll check him out! I agree that the studios could have done way better with the Sequels. It's such a shame -- so much talent, money and time spent on a mediocre product. The main good that came out of it was my newfound appreciation for the prequels and fan films!
The music this guy added fits well with the scene but I felt the scene could've been redeemed a different way. I felt that the original track's 'angelic choir' (music that sounds like a breath of relief) that plays when Rey lifts the rocks fit that scene perfectly, though the scene itself falls flat because it doesn't feel like a payoff for anything. I think that scene alone of Rey and the levitating rocks could have been one of the most outstanding scenes in the film if it had the proper buildup (because this scene aside, TLJ had a lot of other problems...). Perhaps that's a different issue than the music specifically for Luke vs Kylo but that's my take on the thing nonetheless
The timing is fantastic. When Luke turns around, as he fades the music ends- it’s just as if this piece was written for this scene- but it’s such a shame it wasn’t used
The whole movie is a shame! Capital Ships running out of gas and not capable to intercept a smaller ship or target a tyny StarCraft. Luke's Green milk addiction. And how Mary Sue is more powerful than Anakin? As Darth Vader couldn't open a single mechanic door in episode IV when Luke was scaping with Han, Leia and Chewie. And this Gal lift that bunch of rocks just by blinking her eyes. What a crap!
JHL you have to be trolling. Not because you like the movie, but don't judge a movie by its story? Really?! Isn't that the main thing a movie should be focused on?
@@vanxanax933 I’m so sorry is included in Anakin’s Dark Deeds. Technically both are the same. Dark Deeds of course has more music than I’m so sorry which the music for I’m so sorry is played at the end of Dark Deeds
Adam Driver really sells it with the emotion he puts into his acting, you can tell how Kylo Ren feels at all times though the facial expressions and movements that Adam portrays.
For real, Driver put his all into this. And while not being an incredible fan of the sequels, Kylo was a good character, thanks in no small part to Driver's acting.
Him as Ben solo was cool af, but cmon. Him as kylo is funny at times, he makes that dumbass rat face wen he’s angry and is so non believable as a villain.
I can't decide who got it worse: Kylo Ren- one of the best characters out of the Disney Star Wars trilogy, that lost almost every fight he was in, and felt as intimidating as a legless puppy. OR Finn: A character with a great potential background, that went from ex-stromtrooper turned potential jedi, to comedy guy that has a crush on Rey.
Darryl Ferguson Yeah they really butchered Finn’s character, man. So disappointed. With the exception of Kylo Ren, everyone’s character development is garbage or nonexistent. Sad lol
Yeah, the theme is from Anakin's Dark Deeds, but I've only listened in star Wars videos where the dark side won, like the end of The Old Republic first trailer, or in the Fallen order with the execution of the order 66. It's a very deep song, and strong but with some grieve, that why I didn't like how it was used here, IMO
@@lordodysseus The music sounds more Star Wars than the original music in the movie lol also the recurring theme that is brought about in the end. Idk why they didn't have more recurring Star Wars themes in the sequel trilogy, it would have created a much better sense of unity across the films.
I think it helps that his character was called out for what he was: an edgy, unstable Vader fanboy. In an odd way, that destroyed the notion that he was supposed to just be a Vader knockoff and helped him become a unique character.
you can't always blame an actor for coming across as "forced and cringy". you need to remember that it is up to the director/writer how the character should be portrayed, and it is up to the actor to portray the vision of the writer/director.
This music perfectly encapsulates everything Kylo Ren/Ben Solo is feeling in this moment…it fits so well that it almost feels like the music was made for this scene.
YES THE CANTINA BAND MUSIC I listened to that on repeat from a Star Wars musical picture book I had xD damn it, the prequels gave us some of the best merch as well
I absolutely love the music in the original, but this take is incredible. While the original kinda puts you in everyone’s headspace based on who’s got the focus, this one puts you in Kylo’s shoes the entire time and creates the sense that his world is falling apart right in front of him. Very well done!
Yeah it was if Luke vs kylo was actually fighting it would have been better not all space battles and fighting on the ground it didn't had in any lightsaber duels like the of star wars from 1-6 Lucasfilm George Lucas was a better maker of the star wars franchise
“the war is over!” At no point during these films did it feel like an actual major conflict was taking place in the galaxy, just one of many issues with the sequels
tropicAces it wasn’t like there was a war going on in the original trilogy it was a rebellion against the empire them same thing here what are you on about?
Josh Moores cuz the Empire actually felt/was established to be a powerful, far-reaching force; the First Order just seemed like angry little cult. We planet jump and no one outside Leia’s tiny Resistance seems to be oppressed or concerned
"I'm So Sorry" fits with so many scenes, from countless franchises. Whether you like the prequels or not, it's hard to argue that they weren't the peak of John Williams' career.
@@agustinbaletti Something unfitting doesn't necessarily have to be bad. Most soundtracks are actually very good, but I don't think they're always used in the appropriate scenes
@@_0raz.05_ This. I really like the Sequels music, Kylo Rens theme, Reys theme, March Of The Resistance etc, but their definitely scenes that could have had different music in it's place.
Optimaloptimus50 50 I mean he was kinda abandoned by them to even if they didn’t mean to. Leia was too busy to give him much attention and Han was most likely also pretty busy. In his eyes they did abandon him in a way when they sent him off to train.
Ratoeira Magazine eh I mean it’s not that bad, sure there’s dumb shit, and I mean really dumb shit, but I can enjoy them, at the end of the day they’re not canon to me especially when the original creator of Star Wars says they’re not so when you watch them as fan fictions you’ll realize it’s not all that bad.
Maybe not a remake, but maybe a recut where it’s edited to look a lot better. While some of the stuff you can’t get rid of, you can certainly do a hell of a job with good editing
they can fix everything by just making another episode 9, i like the last Jedi it gave unpredictable situations to the history, but the last movie made everything happen for a futile reason
![How Music Can Change A Scene - Han Solo & Kylo Ren [TFA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/saraPsW_rjo/mqdefault.jpg)
![How Music Can Change A Scene - Han Solo & Kylo Ren [TFA]](/img/tr.png)
I struggle to take this entire trilogy seriously, and this movie most of all. But just the change in the score here makes me take the scene seriously and actually feel SOMETHING watching it.
If you think about it, almost every movie would be extremely awkward without music.
1000SubsWithNoVideos!? Kind of like how most sitcoms would be awkward without a laugh track
Every *Hollywood movie, and yes I agree.
Maybe not awkward, but never as good. Music brings much depth to movies.
1000SubsWithNoVideos!? No country for old men didn’t have any music
*No Country for Old Men*
The fact that this man only changed the song and got over 5 million views is incredible.
THANK YOU! I'm on the side that I'm not some kind of messiah that's here to save the star wars sequels, I just wanted to do an experiment with music and this was the scene I wanted to experiment on. The actual version hasn't been changed so those who hate this are in luck!
Karl Veiga u hating on the sequels?
Shows how this scene could’ve been much more.
ItzSpoons where’d I say that 😂
Karl Veiga idk lol
Who else thought when they clicked on this that the music would be totally unfitting and make this comical?
I was thinking towards that way, but this was pretty interesting to see. Avoided watching any of the newer sequels(except the first one), but I actually thought that this was pretty fitting.
@@gseric4721 Same here. I watched Part 7 as a 12 year old that got hyped over everything. Frankly, that was one of my first big disappointments.
Not laugh, didn't funny.
Welp, i did chuckle a bit ngl
I dont remember the song in this scene, How was It?
@@twoocean8012 IS THAT A JOJO'S REFERENCE
I like how kylo was so mad he didnt even realize luke was using a destroyed lightsaber
Damn it dude. Never underestimate music in movies. Really did change the scene.
I cry only in one case, when music is good, even the best scene is nothing without emotional music.
Viktor Vektor Couldn’t have said it better myself.
@@takeshitabibito1208 yeah, go check out Binary Sunset without music: ua-cam.com/video/QVaZaXstujk/v-deo.html the scene is so incomplete without the amazing music
@@ImTheReverse Wow, that's one of my favorite scenes and now I know why
Never judge a book by its cover…As ppl say
This vid was so emotional And the music did change the scene
Luke: Let me practise Master Kenobi's art of trolling
Sniper20Destroyer obi wan be like:yep that’s my apprentice
“That’s my boy.”
General Kenobi!
Natahn Dolar you are a bold one
Obi-Wan Kenobi master
All the characters: Why do I hear Coruscant traffic?
@Rick Astley never gonna let you down
@DeltaWolf142 never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
@DeltaWolf142 never gonna say goodbye
@DeltaWolf142 we've known each other for so long
@DeltaWolf142 You know the rules, and so do I
Holy shit the pacing is impeccable
Me: Wow that was epic
Also me: **Doesn't even remember what the original sounded like**
omg me too
none of the soundtrack from the trilogy are memorable, its a tragedy.....
on second thought, except kylo ren's theme, that one is pretty good
Exactly
@@harry781012 Even Jedi Fallen Order has better soundtrack..
"see ya around kid" was han's line, that's what makes it very satisfying to hear from Mark.
Han doesn't actually ever say that line
@@yonicthevadgehog it sounds like something he would say
@@yonicthevadgehog Didn't he say it when he was leaving Hoth? or Yavin? or something? Sometime? Somewhere? Someplace?
@@yonicthevadgehog he definitely does in the OT.
NickToVa but thats not what he said
Oh wow only now did I just realize Luke's beard is different - Kylo was only fighting what he remembered Luke to look like
wtf how the hell did i not notice this!
SMAAAAART GOOD BOI
Not only his beard, but his hair too
Well if that’s true, why doesn’t he have the green lightsaber?
@@MattSipka I looked it up and since he's a force projection, he picked his age and that color to piss off Ben since that light saber belonged to Anakin, and Kylo claims that belongs to him earlier to Rey. I think Kylo was just so full of rage that his main goal was to kill Luke, but it was a subtle nod/foreshadowing that Luke wasn't there.
banger edit my dude
I can't remember what the original even sounded like this fits so well
Laura Wolfe I had to go look it up it’s not that good not compared to this
@@rowanl3059 me too
Laura Wolfe same
I disagree. When rey lifts the rocks it gave me such goosebumps i never had before in the cinema
@Huma17 It's not supposed to have Raw Emotion or Suspense or even inspiration. Kylo Ren just has no idea what to do anymore and his hate is consuming him, Ben is on the wrong side. This is more of a tragic situation than a hopeful one, especially since The Resistance has only a hand full of people left alive. No one should be happy right now
“Han was the father wasn’t he?”
*”I’m so sorry”*
Revenge of the sith?
Javin Newell Nah man...
*PhaNtOm mENacE*
Digital Flayer 2 movies behind but you’ll get there
MiniDuncan r/whoosh
@@Digital_Flayer *PNOENE*
0:39 I really don't like you
Music really does change this scene
Up Next “Obi Wan: Master of Trolling”
A Classic.
Hello there
REX?
how did he know
The prophecy is for filled
he is the last jedi
Giulius' Mind that’s what I was gunna say
From the title I was expecting the music to be replaced by "Baby Elephant Walk" or "Yakety Sax".
Same honestly xD
same
Only reason I watched tbh
Ya, I was expecting that Benny Hill song.
I was just expecting some shitty default youtube video music that people who should never make UA-cam videos, keep using.
"Half your billions should go to John Williams."
Alfred Hitchcock to Steven Spielberg, 2014
ERB man!!
Now brace yourself as I reveal my Brilliance
I’m a master.
Of suspense
So intense
No defense against hitchcock when he presents
My skill’s enormous, orchestrate brilliant performance
You’re more horrible than Megan fox’s acting in Transformers
Come on
Fish muppets and puppets to stir the fears up
I liked the original scene, but I remember HATING the music chosen when I saw it in theaters. This was MUCH better. Thank you!
Kylo Ren was the best part of the sequels
Best Disney princess too.
I politely yet FIRMLY disagree
Kylo was the worse character in Jedi universe! Really like girl in 16 years
Life is Good Worse than Jar Jar?
@@racool911 oooohhh shit! Forgat him!) Ja ja forever!
The original music sounds like their trying to make it really cool.
This music makes it feel really sad. Which is more fitting in my opinion.
not really it’s not suppose to be sad it’s suppose to be overcoming because luke is literally winning against ben anakins dark deeds has nothing to do with this scene tbh like sure it sounds cool but it doesn’t make sense narratively to have a music from a scene where anakin was killing people.
1:15 *TRIGGERED*
@@giyuutomioka8072 wrong song, this is where Obi-Wan and Padme discussed dealing with anakin
KnightLight yeah and the right after in the same soundtrack it shows dead people and everyone anakin has killed and tyne him looking off into the mustafar sun
@@giyuutomioka8072 yeah but thats different then "scene where Anakin was killing people"
Two different songs
"See ya Around Kid"
can we all agree luke has made the biggest Trolling in Star Wars Universe?
I mean, it's him or Kenobi
Kenobi: am I a joke to you?
@@Codgunner-jt2et kenobi was a master of trolling but as i remember he never maked someone loss time with a force personification of him which looks like a real person, he has a lot more of trolling maked than Luke but i think this stuff is in a higher level, if he had maked this when he battled vader it would have been amazing xd
Obi wan logged out of the match before losing and rejoined as a spectator to help his team over meta-comms
@@codeender5980 Luke was the person who turned invisible at enemy base and stayed there until somebody spawned
When you aint even the protagonist anymore but still got main character type shit
Adam Driver's back must be really sore from carrying this trilogy
He didn't carry it enough. No one man could have.
Straight White Male he was really the best part of the though
Totally. Next time because of this burdain he s gonna play The hunchback of Notre Dame
He's literally the only reason why i watch the sequel trilogy. That and Reylo😂😂
I'd say Mark Hammils performance in the last Jedi was likely his best ever
The music damn near changed my whole views about the last few Star Wars movies. Music man, never underestimate the power of it.
Right? Makes it feel so much better.
Yup
Wow... This video was released in 2019 and my guy's out there hearting and pinning comments still
The power of music is endless man. Music is one of the ultimate powers of the world.
667th like
John Williams: *Anyway, I started composing.*
The timing was spot on
This scene was the only scene in the movie that actually needed the force theme
Walter Clements*
Aj_Plays1229 I agree with you, The Force theme is almost as overused in SW as the Main Theme was in The Polar Express. Every time there's any plot development... (Dun dun, dun, dun dun dun, duuuunnn)
Pretty pathetic
Not at all. The next scene already has the force theme. Perfect for his becoming one with the force.
I was so disappointed when he didn’t say “Strike me down and I will become more powerful than you can possibly imagine”
John McCuskey that wouldn’t make sense because he never heard Ben Kenobi say that in the first place
Me and you both
Would’ve been cool but wouldn’t have made snese
They wrote an original line that was just as quotable
So you're disappointed that they didn't ram fan service down our throat in this scene? Bet you loved Rise of Skywalker...
The music does fit well with what Ben is feeling here. You can feel the hurt, anger, and hate inside of him.
The music makes this good scene even better.
I can’t be the only one who gets chills at 1:14 That timing with the music is FLAWLESS
Ikr. It’s uncanny how well I’m So Sorry goes with this scene
so epic
Vader: How many pizzas should we order?
Palpatine: Order 66
Op
Lol 😂
Hmmm But Will they eat All of The Pizzas? Because That's So many Pizzas
Dew it
Almost there to 66 likes
As I’ve said before, George Lucas told the story to our eyes and John Williams told it to our ears
I agree with this
I miss George. And the those prequel hating jerks who said he raped thier childhoods.
@@fridaynightnicktoons6885 everything was good w the prequels except the writing & jar jar binks
@@BananatheCreator no they were perfect
JJ Abrams and Rian Johnson pissed to our faces.
0:18 me when someone says their favorite dinosaur
6.9 million views as of early April 2021
Hmmm
Nice
And then it hit 7 mill
And I'm at 7 million
@@animations-ew4yf yes
this music perfectly highlights Adam drivers great acting capabilities
@Daan den Hollander Literally, Kylo is honestly a great character too. It’s sad everything else was wasted
@@95v37 jj Abrams made Star Wars crappy because rey could do anything Jedi mind trick use the force anything but anakin probably couldn’t do those thing and he WAS SO MUCH BETTER THEN REY and it showed anakins trainings and it shows anakins a better character and kylo ren is a wanna be sorry to say it but it’s true and JJ could’ve made rey better but instead gave her plot armor
@@95v37 REY and JJ Abrams made kylo ren a vader wanna be sorry to say it’s just trash
@@95v37 also anakin was trained and showed his past
@@95v37 George Lucas was the best director and movie maker ever more better then JJ
I was expecting comparassions, like a cool one vs a funny one and stuff. Kind of like, that video of the north korean army marching to that wii song.
Same.
Exactly why I went to watch it. Really disappointed
Comparisons **
You expect too much humans.
Yup
If this was the music choice in my theater experience, I would’ve been in tears dawg. So impactful Forreal
“The war is just beginning”
Next movie: hold my lightsaber.
Cue Lord of The Rings orc music
I think you mean "hold my gross, green milk"
Yooo baby yoda
Go back to sippin your soup buddy
*“Anakin is the grandfather isn’t he?”*
*“I’m so sorry”*
"Stealing comment you are?"
"I'm not so sorry actually"
@FuntimeThylacine ! Dude, kylo is son of leia and han, that was told in the 7th chapter, and so his grandfather is anakin, wtf
Even kylo said that he wants to be like his grandfather
Anakin was redeemed so why kylo want to be like him? Just don't get it.
@@joanember18379 Maybe he didn't know. It seems like most people didn't know, so that's possible, although a bit of a stretch considering all the ways he could have found out
@@joanember18379 well redeemed is a strong word, he had a father-son bonding moment in killing the emperor but like, he doesn't really show any regret over the thousands of people he's killed or the millions of lives he's ruined... So for a young mass murderer darth Vader is still a very inspirational idol, just don't make the mistake of having children and your unstoppable.
Also I'm fairly sure right before luke met the emperor Vader was saying they should both kill the emperor and rule together, so when Vader killed the emperor I think Vader did not plan on actually being killed
It just makes it all the more tragic.
I never looked at it from Ben’s POV. to him, Luke is the bad guy. And he’s been hurting, and felt so betrayed by what his uncle did. All the emotions come out, and then at the end, he’s denied satisfaction of the defeat of his uncle, all while his uncle is mocking and smiling at him.
Kyle Majerczyk yoooooo🤧🤧 that makes this even more tragic
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I’m really happy someone else sees that, all it literally would’ve taken to make it clearer and also hit harder is a change in music, that’s all this video is, an experiment to see what a simple change to the movies we love could have on the ENTIRE overall product. I’m gonna make a few more of these ‘How Music Changes’ in 2020, so stick around to catch up on them!
Karl Veiga what scenes are u thinking of doing
What did luke do to him?
noobguy80 he tried murdering him chief
It was so good I had forgotten and almost didn't notice u change the music.
Incredibly suiting👌😁👍
The fact the fall of the republic’s music wasn’t actually used really bugs me, would have changed the scene a lot..
Coldstreamer18 FOR REAL! It felt so natural that you would think that was playing right then!
Because Disney
"Anakin is the father isn't he? I'm so sorry"
Copy cat
I don’t get it lol explain pls
@@davidhatcher7016 no shit, I've seen the movie 🤭
@@mythik140 incorrect
@@allybraun4842 its what obiwan says to padme, after her realizes the dark side wasnt the only thing anikan was fuckin with.
I miss my dad
I miss him too 😐
@@KarlVeiga lmao
@@KarlVeiga my guy is still pinning comments after a year.
Edit: by the way can you make a video like this for Luke’s hallway scene.
wait didn't you kil-
@@MarkSmith-vo1vn I’m still here 🙂
This pretty much sums up in the potential of the sequels and how they were destined to fail in our eyes in one go
If this music was in the film, this probably would’ve been one of my favourite scenes in all of Star Wars
i pretend this is Canon
same
Honestly, same.
Wait you mean this isn't canon? Shame.
Salut la Francophonie
I’m so sorry fits perfectly, because it was used on Obi Wans part of Dark Deeds, Obi Wan failed Anakin as a master, just as Luke did Kylo. Even their words were similar ‘strike me down in anger and I’ll be more powerful.’ Poetic
I think that’s what a lot of commenters on this video miss. I never tried to make the scene better but I used music to change the outcome of the scene emotionally. If you know the importance of the track ‘Anakin’s Dark Deeds/I’m So Sorry’ then you know why I put it here in conjunction with Kylo Ren and Luke Skywalker
@@KarlVeiga agreed man. So many great ways the music connects each part in Star Wars. Great job with the editing and general work too! Made the scene ten times more meaningful and powerful than the original one.
i think he said "i will always be with you" instead no?
@@mejtz6279 yeah but it’s the same context. He even went out the same way as Obi Wan.
Finally I've found someone who says this
I suppose Luke saying "See you around, kid" was alot more foreboding than everyone thought.
TOO SOON
LMFAO
You really our here trying to make the Ben stans cry huh?
I'm confused. What is this referencing?
dominique eure kylo fucking dies
That just brought tears to my eyes! That was seriously amazing and beautiful!
I like how Kylo Ren has more character and personality than 99% of the characters in the sequels combined.
What about Finn?
As long as you are an upset 12 year old suburban kid mad cause mommy didn't give you candy you can relate to him.
@@hypnoskales7069 Finn had promise in force awakens but then he made to be a useless character.
@@computerguy6264 it was more complicated than that
@@hypnoskales7069 yeah another good actor and decent character but they didnt do him justice
Ok, is it just me, or do you hate it when people say “the war is only beginning” in any situation
Especially in this situation
I don't hate it but it is a bit cliche
It's so fucking cheesy
It's cliche and ridiculous in this case
@@ioanbugheanu6836 Especially because the war hasn't just begun, it's been going for like 40 years at this point
especially when Episode IX does not deliver a great war that really captivates everyone from the start, but disappoints completely and almost everyone...
Did anyone else find it weird that luke projected himself with a haircut??
I think he projects himself the way kylo remembers him
@@nachoskillrec5185 +1, this is correct.
@@nachoskillrec5185 I think Kylo saw what "he" remembered of Luke.
LOLz... Well he's gotta look like he didn't just get up out of bed
Im surprized he didn't have an iPhone to go with it.
"just like you're father" you can see everyones pain and shit is enough to give u goose bumps deadass
1:26 I love how the beat drops perfectly on time when he starts running but my favorite part of this is how the music swells when he stops! It really helps illustrate the moral turmoil that Kylo is going through at this point. He’s trying so hard to be a Sith but he truly doesn’t know who he is. He’s filled with so much conflict here and I feel that Adam does a phenomenal job in this scene as well as the whole trilogy. Despite not being in a very coherent story. This is the perfect track for this scene.
In some ways he's much like Anakin in that regard during his siege on the Jedi temple a Anakin's emotions were very conflicted he didn't truly want to be a sith but in his mind it was the only way to safe Padme
wdym "beat drop" LOL
@Miroslav Kašpar Yup John Williams is a freaking musical genius
As soon as Luke said, I’ll be with you just like your father you could tell the look on his face it was guilt but also anger
Anakin is the father isnt he
I'm so sorry.
Some of the last words Obi wan ever spoke to padme
@@guywithabomb6409 that's not true. He was there when she gave birth to Luke and Leia
Sammabetic Films lol wrong
It's actually han solo
Anakin is his grandfather, Leia and Han are his parents.
Oh look, prequal music. I thought everyone hated the prequals because the internet told you to. Now look at us
No, they still suck.
anime pussy shut up boomer
The prequels movies sucked, their soundtracks were fantastic.
Dying Muffin Animations shut up boomer
Jokes on you, I wasn’t even allowed on the internet when the prequels came out.
1:16 to 2:28 this song fits perfectly 👌👌👌
Are you telling me... the music in here isn’t the same as the movies?...
Nope
Right? I need to go watch TLJ again but this is the perfect score for this scene, easily
There's no music in this scene. I remember telling me that it could use some music last time i watched it
@@hichamlemdani2502 There is music in this scene, it's just a lot worse and not emorable at all. Typical DUN DUN DUN trumpet score.
Disney ruined everything
I didn't realize this wasn't the original music for the scene until towards the end of the clip. It fits amazingly well.
I know right it's almost like they're both from Star Wars movies
The original is more optimistic and matches the emotions for each scene (hope, peace, rage, awe). This only feels tragic and sombre. But it is louder and more powerful. And the timing/editing was perfect!
You're absolutely right. I've gone on record and will continue to say that this edit was meant to try and help strengthen Kylo's plight, Rian Johnson clearly saw that Luke in Kylo's eyes is a villain, I wanted to match up Kylo's feelings of hurt, pain and betrayal with this piece of music.
@@KarlVeiga Honestly I think you've done a perfect job of synchronizing the music to express the pain kylo went through because of luke, and how much he hated him because of that, but luke's monologue of how there's still hope on the galaxy and him not being the last jedi and all, that part the music doesn't fit in. And after kylo tried to strike luke down with all his force, unleashing all of his anger and hate built up towards him just to realize that that was only a projection made from the force combined with the louder music just really gave the perfect feeling.
Its tragic and sombre that this movie was ever made
Still good point
Considering the battle of Crait was a major loss for the resistance the music is also more fitting.
@@jediknight1313 what was the point of this comment?
Subscribed! Everything, every moment of this is perfectly tuned! ❤️
I was expecting Luke to say “Are you the father? I’m so Sorry”
that “see ya ‘round kid” holds so much more weight with this music.
it’s a shame
The entire Episode 8 movie was a shame. The music is just a small thing that would’ve made it somewhat better but oh my god they should have stuck with JJ for all 3 movies. Episode 7 was meh but 9 was awesome. If they had let JJ direct 8 they would’ve probably had character development in time for 9. Instead JJ had to rush it all in one episode. Disney really put him in a bad position
American Sports Fan on top of that Disney changed a lot of JJs original episode 9 behind his back. JJ really deserves no hate.
Ikr I didn't like the way they made this movie. It was more like a joke kinda thing. I hope I made sense.
Force awakens was good.
@@americansportsfan1059 only retards think 9 was awesome
just shit movie, shame to whoever ruined star wars
It's so interesting how this piece, which was completely unintended for this scene, fits so well. The rising action of the building tension, the climax of the more intense trumpets, and the taper off with strings all coincide with the scenes same beats.
William Burnett i mean he did cut out some of the fighting between Ben and Luke but still amazing i agree
Cue George Lucas saying “it’s like poetry, it rhymes”
@@flyingfish2566 yeah and ita honestly better like this imo
Can’t tell you enough how much I love your postings
Thank you
I hated The Last Jedi, but if they had actually used this track for that scene, this part of the movie would easily have become my favorite.
A Force Awakens --> A New Hope but without the charm or exposition.
The Last Jedi --> Rian Johnson wanted to do his own sci-fi film, Disney didn't let him, so now it's a Star Wars film I guess. Something something Skywalker.
Rise of Skywalker --> Reylo: the Movie
I disliked the sequels as such (they're so poor story-wise in comparison to Extended Universe stuff that it's embarrassing), but honestly TLJ at least tried to do something different. It's probably going to end up a lot like The Empire Strikes Back: mixed reviews, criticized for making Han/Leia a thing, introducing Lando the charismatic chronic backstabber, isolating the protagonist from the rest of the cast because he's training or something, oh and Vader is Luke's father for some reason. People were NOT happy about TESB when it came out. A decade later and suddenly it's the high point of the franchise so far. I really wonder if the same will happen to TLJ in many years to come, you know, when Disney releases an even Star Wars trilogy xD
@@hermionestranger4964 You should check out Ivan Ortega's re-edit of The Last Jedi. It helps to fix quite a few of the issues people had with the film (so far as the available footage would allow). I do think the Sequels are a big missed opportunity; they should've been about Anakin's legacy for the next generation of Jedi, but they went with something else.
@@divergenttardis7378 Thanks, I'll check him out! I agree that the studios could have done way better with the Sequels. It's such a shame -- so much talent, money and time spent on a mediocre product. The main good that came out of it was my newfound appreciation for the prequels and fan films!
@@hermionestranger4964 Agreed, though I've always liked the Prequels!
The music this guy added fits well with the scene but I felt the scene could've been redeemed a different way. I felt that the original track's 'angelic choir' (music that sounds like a breath of relief) that plays when Rey lifts the rocks fit that scene perfectly, though the scene itself falls flat because it doesn't feel like a payoff for anything. I think that scene alone of Rey and the levitating rocks could have been one of the most outstanding scenes in the film if it had the proper buildup (because this scene aside, TLJ had a lot of other problems...). Perhaps that's a different issue than the music specifically for Luke vs Kylo but that's my take on the thing nonetheless
The timing is fantastic. When Luke turns around, as he fades the music ends- it’s just as if this piece was written for this scene- but it’s such a shame it wasn’t used
The whole movie is a shame! Capital Ships running out of gas and not capable to intercept a smaller ship or target a tyny StarCraft. Luke's Green milk addiction. And how Mary Sue is more powerful than Anakin? As Darth Vader couldn't open a single mechanic door in episode IV when Luke was scaping with Han, Leia and Chewie. And this Gal lift that bunch of rocks just by blinking her eyes. What a crap!
GtAutoSpa Car wash it was a stupid trilogy
@@gtautospacarwash7060 Kylo Ren was the only character that kept me interested in this trilogy tbh. The rest was sadly shit.
JHL you have to be trolling. Not because you like the movie, but don't judge a movie by its story? Really?! Isn't that the main thing a movie should be focused on?
@@blaeiptekvkukurbo story is the most important thing wtf
Fun fact: the name of this beautiful music is "Im so sorry" and the first words you can hear in this video are "Im sorry"
It’s called Annakin’s Dark Deeds
@@vanxanax933 No there’s I’m so sorry and Anakin’s Dark Deeds
@@inksans6580 no there’s not thats an unofficial remix look at the soundtrack to episode 3 there’s no “I’m sorry”
@@vanxanax933 I’m so sorry is included in Anakin’s Dark Deeds. Technically both are the same. Dark Deeds of course has more music than I’m so sorry which the music for I’m so sorry is played at the end of Dark Deeds
@@inksans6580 “I’m so sorry” isn’t an official song tho
His last words were "see you around kid"
Neither of them have the high ground.
Something isn’t right about that.
No the original Luke was sitting on a high ground..
@Trooper damn I forgot about that
@@Nobody-ie6pn You are truly on to something my friend...
lowground is the real benefit in a fight
@Gandhi Anakin has the low ground and look how that turned out
I’m serious prequels had the best music anakins dark deeds is an amazing song
I grew up watching the prequels lol my first star war movies
Danny Hernandez I saw a new hope first but after that I watched all the prequels and loved them
@@deadboi3465 Then you're not a real Star Wars fan dipshit!
No they didn't dipshit! The OT music is the best!
@@Bloorgusgoorge then you're not a real Star Wars fan dipshit!
Kylo Ren was wasted on these movies, so much character to him.
No it didn't
He should’ve stayed masked
Jaxon Dickson him and Finn both had arguably the highest character potential both criminally wasted.
Jaxon Dickson WATCH THE MATRIX THEN YOU PERVERT
Mrimchaelson that’s an insult to both those characters. But I understand what you’re saying.
“Just like your father.”
DAMN
Kylo Ren broke his back from carrying the sequels
Adam Driver really sells it with the emotion he puts into his acting, you can tell how Kylo Ren feels at all times though the facial expressions and movements that Adam portrays.
Copied comment lol
For real, Driver put his all into this. And while not being an incredible fan of the sequels, Kylo was a good character, thanks in no small part to Driver's acting.
Him as Ben solo was cool af, but cmon. Him as kylo is funny at times, he makes that dumbass rat face wen he’s angry and is so non believable as a villain.
He did broke his back when he was a marine
The thing is, I don’t remember the original music in this scene...
Neither do I. Most of the sequel music is that way, except for the repeated songs like Kylo Ren's theme.
It had a much angrier tone, where as this is has that low key to it
I don't remember the movies either. Complete crap.
The thing is i've never seen the movie😬
I actually kinda likes the actual music in this scene. But this is just way better
9:15 “I will kill the last jeda!”
I can't decide who got it worse:
Kylo Ren- one of the best characters out of the Disney Star Wars trilogy, that lost almost every fight he was in, and felt as intimidating as a legless puppy.
OR
Finn: A character with a great potential background, that went from ex-stromtrooper turned potential jedi, to comedy guy that has a crush on Rey.
Darryl Ferguson Yeah they really butchered Finn’s character, man. So disappointed. With the exception of Kylo Ren, everyone’s character development is garbage or nonexistent. Sad lol
Until a point i thought i had a new hope...
@@lemmihilldrix1450 Even halfway through TFA they fucked him up by making him a janitor.
Yeah Finn was the worst
They both sucks
This Score is so powerful. Comparing this to the original clip makes me feel like I’m watching a completely different film.
I think that was the point.
Yeah, the theme is from Anakin's Dark Deeds, but I've only listened in star Wars videos where the dark side won, like the end of The Old Republic first trailer, or in the Fallen order with the execution of the order 66. It's a very deep song, and strong but with some grieve, that why I didn't like how it was used here, IMO
@@lordodysseus The music sounds more Star Wars than the original music in the movie lol also the recurring theme that is brought about in the end. Idk why they didn't have more recurring Star Wars themes in the sequel trilogy, it would have created a much better sense of unity across the films.
"I failed you ben"
I got obi wan flashbacks
"I have failed you anakin
I have failed you"
Nooooooo whyyyyy
Its a rip off of the original no talent by these directors/ writers
I wonder why it's almost like this trilogy was a nostalgia grab or something. And is rehashing the same plot points in a different movie.
Chris West I kinda wished he felt more saddened by it
Michael Caine 🤣
1:27 is absolutely beautiful
It really does feel like these are Luke’s final moments and he’s going to make them worth it.
Yea especially with the right music
I really didn’t like adam driver at first, i thought he was forced and cringy but he ended up being the best thing about the sequels.
The senate is the best part
Ya, much better than maREY sue
Bitte Bilden Definitely.
I think it helps that his character was called out for what he was: an edgy, unstable Vader fanboy. In an odd way, that destroyed the notion that he was supposed to just be a Vader knockoff and helped him become a unique character.
you can't always blame an actor for coming across as "forced and cringy". you need to remember that it is up to the director/writer how the character should be portrayed, and it is up to the actor to portray the vision of the writer/director.
This music perfectly encapsulates everything Kylo Ren/Ben Solo is feeling in this moment…it fits so well that it almost feels like the music was made for this scene.
Shame the creators didnt think of that
Correction 7.7milion views and still growing.
I don't think it's perfect but it's definitely a lot better than the original
Maybe they made this scene with that music but changed it at the last time
@@MtnMania calm down man, it’s bad but not that bad
Thank You So Much! This is amazing 🤩
If the sequels were summarized in one single quote: "calm down Kylo"
And the prequels in: “Anakin, just don’t”
Anakin stop panakin
And the originals: “Slow down Luke”
I don't care what ppl say this will now be the canon version of this scene for me
Same
Well technically music isn't canon so you can play any song over a scene and it still would be canon. But I get what u mean 😂
They should have put in the
“agh” - LEGO StarWars
Julius Sanchez HEY
Julius Sanchez look up wilhelm scream
@@Thegoat-4L that's overused
i just spat my KFC up everywhere reading this
Those prequels had the best music, so emotional
Music of the end of the fight of Anakin and Obi-Wan
Star Wars III really has the best soundtrack in the series
The whole prequel score was a gem
C A N T I N A B A N D
YES THE CANTINA BAND MUSIC
I listened to that on repeat from a Star Wars musical picture book I had xD damn it, the prequels gave us some of the best merch as well
Actually this is from the end of Anakin's Dark Deeds aka the scene with Obi Wan and Padme in Ep III
Episode 1 had Duel of the Fates
I absolutely love the music in the original, but this take is incredible. While the original kinda puts you in everyone’s headspace based on who’s got the focus, this one puts you in Kylo’s shoes the entire time and creates the sense that his world is falling apart right in front of him. Very well done!
That’s Deep
They can’t actually it’s Made by John williams and they don’t have permission they would probably used it if they had permission
Yeah it was if Luke vs kylo was actually fighting it would have been better not all space battles and fighting on the ground it didn't had in any lightsaber duels like the of star wars from 1-6 Lucasfilm George Lucas was a better maker of the star wars franchise
@@mustafasiar7583 They definitely had the permission, they literally own the rights
@@mustafasiar7583 who do you think composed the music for the sequels
“the war is over!”
At no point during these films did it feel like an actual major conflict was taking place in the galaxy, just one of many issues with the sequels
tropicAces it wasn’t like there was a war going on in the original trilogy it was a rebellion against the empire them same thing here what are you on about?
Josh Moores cuz the Empire actually felt/was established to be a powerful, far-reaching force; the First Order just seemed like angry little cult. We planet jump and no one outside Leia’s tiny Resistance seems to be oppressed or concerned
@@genericname34 I've always assumed that line was about the war between the Jedi and the Sith, the Light and the Dark.
CatPlaysFTW oh that’s interesting. I never took it like that, but can def see how one would
tropicAces these sequel movies SucKEd
"I'm So Sorry" fits with so many scenes, from countless franchises.
Whether you like the prequels or not, it's hard to argue that they weren't the peak of John Williams' career.
Fitting music in the sequels: Doesn't exist
Fans: *Fine, I'll do it myself*
Disney is just not the same anymore. This fan made video confirms it
0raz1oPlayer YT you can't insulted John Williams like that, there is great music in the SEQUELS too, just not like prequels
@@agustinbaletti Something unfitting doesn't necessarily have to be bad. Most soundtracks are actually very good, but I don't think they're always used in the appropriate scenes
@@_0raz.05_ This. I really like the Sequels music, Kylo Rens theme, Reys theme, March Of The Resistance etc, but their definitely scenes that could have had different music in it's place.
@@_0raz.05_ bud did I ask?
Kyle Ren, the only character who was abandoned by literally everyone except his own two parents.
Optimaloptimus50 50 I mean he was kinda abandoned by them to even if they didn’t mean to. Leia was too busy to give him much attention and Han was most likely also pretty busy. In his eyes they did abandon him in a way when they sent him off to train.
calie cat now that you mention it, that makes sense.
How was he abandoned by everybody? Who other than his parents abandoned him? I’d say that goes to Rey
Caleb Nelson other than Rey everyone gave up on him.
even the writers
Anyone would like to have a re-make of the sequel trilogy ?
@@nickcool0147 shut up pls
Ratoeira Magazine eh I mean it’s not that bad, sure there’s dumb shit, and I mean really dumb shit, but I can enjoy them, at the end of the day they’re not canon to me especially when the original creator of Star Wars says they’re not so when you watch them as fan fictions you’ll realize it’s not all that bad.
Maybe not a remake, but maybe a recut where it’s edited to look a lot better. While some of the stuff you can’t get rid of, you can certainly do a hell of a job with good editing
they can fix everything by just making another episode 9, i like the last Jedi it gave unpredictable situations to the history, but the last movie made everything happen for a futile reason
Whit a diferent story or other actors,:/
But yes
0:46 Oh man, is that an actual shot in the film? The rocks look like they've just been quickly comped on top
That is indeed in the final film.