What We Didn't Know About 1960s Pakistan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 143

  • @ijunejo
    @ijunejo 4 місяці тому +12

    This is what I like the most, no dramatic script like every other video on this channel, no suspense. Just simple information as Podcasts.. keep these coming 🙏🏼

  • @Syedumair-ju4bo
    @Syedumair-ju4bo 3 місяці тому +1

    Raftar of Naveid Siddiqui Sahib is fantastic, Ma Sha Allah

  • @AurangzebPTI
    @AurangzebPTI 4 місяці тому +2

    Excellent program as always and Naveid Siddiqui is a gem with massive knowledge.

  • @bhanumungali6000
    @bhanumungali6000 4 місяці тому +4

    Beautifully narrated. Wonderful guest 👌👌He kept me (hopefully most viewers) hooked on to the story. I’ve read a fair deal about Pakistan. This podcast was a bit like watching a movie after having read the book. Kudos👏👏 Keep up the good work. Wishing you success.

  • @hotbud234
    @hotbud234 4 місяці тому +23

    Bengali used to say Islamabad built with the money of jute. Economic decline started after 1965 war...known as operation Gibraltar...gradually reaching in 1973-74 with nationalisation policy

    • @claymore993
      @claymore993 4 місяці тому

      1965 war of sept and operation gibraltar are two different things.

    • @girishchand444
      @girishchand444 4 місяці тому

      Even a Bengali poet of Bangladesh wrote a poem in this I remember the last line , jab jhuka bosa Dene ko me muje patsan ki khushboo aayi
      If anyone could please provide me poem name and poet name that would be great. I don't remember the poem as I had read it way beforem

    • @P.Babrah58
      @P.Babrah58 4 місяці тому +1

      Its true that Islamabad was built by using the money of jute exports from East Pakistan ie Bangladesh now. When Sheikh Muhib ur Rehman visited Islamabad...he bowed down to road which was under construction then , and uttered -- I can smell Patsan ( Jute) here.

    • @tajmuhammadkhan6476
      @tajmuhammadkhan6476 3 місяці тому

      ​@@P.Babrah58تب کوئی بنگلہ دیش نہیں تھا پاکستان کا پیسہ پاکستان میں لگا تھا۔

    • @nripshoree543
      @nripshoree543 2 місяці тому

      @@claymore993 How are they 2 different things?

  • @sonachenab
    @sonachenab 4 місяці тому +2

    Very informative and good discussion. Thanks.

  • @mtkhan646
    @mtkhan646 4 місяці тому +3

    Great job, Wonderful explained.

  • @MuhammadUsman-nz8pv
    @MuhammadUsman-nz8pv 4 місяці тому +6

    Another prime reason was, karachi being an organic city was always prone to protests and opposition to forthcoming military facism, thus a new artificial controlled city was ideal for military take over and controlled facism.

  • @ranahamza1304
    @ranahamza1304 Місяць тому

    Raftar 🔥🔥1️⃣

  • @nizamuddinahmadaali3244
    @nizamuddinahmadaali3244 4 місяці тому +6

    Ayub Khan fired all the Urdu Speaking because those senior officers did let Ayub Khan get away with bribery abuse of power.
    Your comment about Mahajirs being pushed to the sea is correct. My grandfather has mentioned several times.

    • @affansiddiqui9015
      @affansiddiqui9015 4 місяці тому

      @@nizamuddinahmadaali3244 Ayub Khan fired all Urdu speaking officers because they are not letting him to do bribel abuse of power understand

    • @affansiddiqui9015
      @affansiddiqui9015 4 місяці тому +2

      Ayub Khan fired all Urdu speaking officers because those honest officers were not allowing him to do bribal abuse of power understand

  • @Hafizulhaq-g6d
    @Hafizulhaq-g6d 4 місяці тому +1

    Excellent programme on 1960s and I am looking forward to the history of 1970s and 80s. I have some valuable information about the political negotiations between Gen Yahya Khan and Mujeeb during Jan-Feb 1971. They have never been shared in public. I would love to share them with you. I don't know how?

  • @mohsinafzaal7159
    @mohsinafzaal7159 2 місяці тому

    Excellent discussion ❤❤❤

  • @nizamuddinahmadaali3244
    @nizamuddinahmadaali3244 4 місяці тому +2

    Islamabad was a housing society of Karachi. Ayub Khan changed the name of Islamabad to Muslimabad and took the new city.

  • @SalmanAli-ed4yt
    @SalmanAli-ed4yt 4 місяці тому +1

    Very well discribe true story 💯

  • @Krieky
    @Krieky 4 місяці тому +5

    Factual correction - Terrestrial television in India started with experimental transmission in 1959 (not “in the 1970s”). And daily transmission began in 1965. Yes, colour formally came to Doordarshan around Asian Games in 1982.

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      Television transmissions were only available in Delhi at first. Bombay did not get television transmissions till 1970 or 71.

  • @khandadadada
    @khandadadada 4 місяці тому

    We need more of this!

  • @245manakis
    @245manakis 4 місяці тому +6

    Dear raftar your quality is best in whole pakistan but it will become more good when you use timeline cause it providd the depth of podcast please raftar team always in a podcast add timeline you might think people will only see questiom but thats wrong go study the youtube podcast data

    • @raftartv
      @raftartv  4 місяці тому +1

      We're working on it!

  • @ankushtiwari8759
    @ankushtiwari8759 4 місяці тому

    I am indian
    Thank you information of Pakistan's

  • @sunala1265
    @sunala1265 4 місяці тому +14

    *What a shame for 25 crores Pakistani can't raise voice against 22 below Rich families*
    *Indian govt made possible in 1947,but Pakistani could not*
    Here are 22 influential and politically powerful families that have governed Pakistan since its creation in 1947:
    1. Bhutto family
    2. Sharif family
    3. Pir Pagaro family
    4. Jatoi family
    5. Kasuri family
    6. Leghari family
    7. Qureshi family
    8. Tiwana family
    9. Dasti family
    10. Magsi family
    11. Bugti family
    12. Jamali family
    13. Raisani family
    14. Marri family
    15. Mengal family
    16. Gul family
    17. Mashkel family
    18. Jakhrani family
    19. Dastagir family
    20. Qambrani family
    21. Magsi family
    22. Lund /Launda family
    These powerful landowning and political dynasties have dominated Pakistan's politics and governance since independence. Many have served as governors, chief ministers, federal ministers, and in other high-level government positions over the decades.

    • @BilalQazi-ds6ot
      @BilalQazi-ds6ot 4 місяці тому +1

      💯

    • @mohammaddeen61
      @mohammaddeen61 4 місяці тому

      The main reason is that people of pakistan are self obsessed for thier personal life and hardly contribute for welfare and stability of pakistan as nation , one can call it cowardness ..and lack of education.

    • @TShawn64
      @TShawn64 4 місяці тому

      chalo indian bhi pohach gaya, in logo ko Pakistan say obsession hai.

    • @sambarve74
      @sambarve74 4 місяці тому +1

      Also, remember that the land they owned after 1947 was due to the ethnic cleansing of Hindus/Sikhs in Pakistan who were the historical owners of most of the land in Pakistan.

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      This 22 family trope is pure bullshit. Yes the families you mention are wealthy but 80% of the nation’s wealth. There are other rich and upper middle class folks not to mention the upper tier of the military and the ones who thrive on the black market be it alchol, drugs, S work, illegal entertainment, smuggling, crime. This rich have this and that is a communist marketing tactic.

  • @ashrafdost9875
    @ashrafdost9875 4 місяці тому +1

    Very nice 👌

  • @codewithuk
    @codewithuk 4 місяці тому +3

    This narrator is so eloquent. His way of story telling is very engagin!

  • @muhammadsiraaj7832
    @muhammadsiraaj7832 4 місяці тому

    Very informative

  • @HELLOGAMER761
    @HELLOGAMER761 4 місяці тому +2

    Please put hindi translation or english translation in the subtitles. I couldn't find the meaning of many words in urdu.
    Btw me from India🇮🇳
    Love your videos. 😊

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      Subtitles in Devanagari aka Hindi are available.

  • @adeelirshad228
    @adeelirshad228 4 місяці тому

    interesting.

  • @adhikrut
    @adhikrut 4 місяці тому +1

    Local Government and Panchayat is the only way forward

  • @mehmoodkhan263
    @mehmoodkhan263 2 місяці тому

    Very good snalysis, slthough I have I have little reservations which will be forwarded later

  • @sajawaliqbal7434
    @sajawaliqbal7434 4 місяці тому +3

    sir you did not discuss how mohtarma Jinnah was treated by President during election compaign and after wining election, and how she was murdered by dictator

  • @7007ification
    @7007ification 4 місяці тому +1

    ayoub was ally aganist COLD WAR plus he was favourite of Brirish and very close to queen

  • @ashrafali-hh7io
    @ashrafali-hh7io 3 місяці тому

    BELIEVE IT OR NOT, GOLDEN DAYS OF AYUB KHAN. BHUTTO IN HIS BOOK A GREAT TRAGEDY THAT PAKISTAN IS A DIFFICULT COUNTRY TO RULE. WHICH IS STILL. ALL INDUSTRIES ESTABLISHED IN AYUB KHAN FROM WHERE V GETTING JOB. MAY GOD BLESS AYUB KHAN.

  • @nizamuddinahmadaali3244
    @nizamuddinahmadaali3244 4 місяці тому

    The price was one million dollars. Money was paid by Sir Sultan Agha Khan. Sir Feroz Khan Khan negotiated the deal.

  • @MudassarHayat-d3d
    @MudassarHayat-d3d 4 місяці тому

    bhai plz make a video on energy crisis occurring currently
    capacity, power etc

  • @muhammadsiraaj7832
    @muhammadsiraaj7832 4 місяці тому

    In 1964, the RCD agreement was also signed

  • @7007ification
    @7007ification 4 місяці тому +5

    ayoub was woking for US just like mushraff

    • @TShawn64
      @TShawn64 4 місяці тому

      so what?

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      Mercenary army for hire. Ayub, Zia, Musharraf all worked the big powers. Zia had the added advantage of Saudi largesse.

    • @limeclassic578
      @limeclassic578 3 місяці тому

      Just like every Pakistani Army General

  • @ajithubli4994
    @ajithubli4994 4 місяці тому

    What happened is discussed. What should have happened so that Pakistan's future would have been better?
    At least in future such mistakes are not committed by General's & politicians.......
    Sad state of affairs......

  • @sherya4134
    @sherya4134 4 місяці тому +1

    Ayub khan par 🖐🏽

  • @aliwattoomuhammadabbas3731
    @aliwattoomuhammadabbas3731 4 місяці тому +4

    Release Imran Khan

  • @P.Babrah58
    @P.Babrah58 4 місяці тому +1

    کسی پاکستانی کو معلوم نہیں ہوگا کہ پاکستان کے دارالحکومت اسلام آباد کا نام کہاں سے آیا۔ سب جانتے ہیں کہ یہ نام قاضی عبدالرحمن نے تجویز کیا تھا جب اس نئے شہر کے نام کے لیے تجاویز طلب کی گئیں۔ دراصل قاضی عبدالرحمٰن کے دادا اجداد امرتسر میں رہتے تھے۔ امرتسر میں ایک علاقہ تھا جس کا نام اسلام آباد تھا۔ اور یہ علاقہ امرتسر میں اب بھی موجود ہے۔ گوگل میپ پر کوئی بھی دیکھ سکتا ہے۔
    امرتسر سے پی پی سنگھ

  • @kaziahsan_habib
    @kaziahsan_habib 3 місяці тому

    Money produced in Bengal,
    Money spent in West Pakistan
    Its like, you are decorating your house with someone else money by colonizing or enslaving him

  • @abdulsattar-ox5rv
    @abdulsattar-ox5rv 4 місяці тому

    Sir jauharabad District khushab ko bhi capital k liy final kiya gia tha few federal departments jauharabad shift bhi ho gay thy. But bad mein Islamabad ko final kiya gia

  • @naranjapk1
    @naranjapk1 4 місяці тому +1

    ڈسکس کرنے کا فائدہ کیا، سب کچھ برباد کر دیا گیا ہے ۔۔۔ کس نے برباد کیا سب کو معلوم ہے، اب تو صرف ماتم رہ گیا ہے ۔۔۔ لاکھوں لوگ بھوک سے مر رہے ہیں باقی بجلی کے بل ادا کرتے گزر جائیں گے

  • @Khan_O
    @Khan_O 4 місяці тому

    17:30 I belong to one of those families.

  • @kamrantahawar
    @kamrantahawar 2 місяці тому

    military aid was given by usa coz Jinnah sab had a deal with the USA that Pakistan would help the USA against China and the USSR

  • @einfacherkerl3279
    @einfacherkerl3279 4 місяці тому +3

    why glorifying ayub dictator?
    country did better because dollars were coming. not v because Pakistan was doing good.

    • @Longlivepetergriffin
      @Longlivepetergriffin 4 місяці тому

      Or east Pakistan, ka haq bhi mara ja raha tha

    • @speakstruth2025
      @speakstruth2025 4 місяці тому +1

      Sahi. Ajj Joo Pakistan Kaa Haal Hay, Uss Kaa Zimadaar Ayub Khan Dakko Hay.

  • @kamrantahawar
    @kamrantahawar 2 місяці тому

    USA had kept Kashmir issue as per plane this is why USA did not help Pakistan

  • @omyrco
    @omyrco 4 місяці тому

    This episode worth 10+ books. Amazing . Bravo. Waiting for the next episode.....
    Only one question raftar ko salute karain ya salam?

    • @MTalha01
      @MTalha01 4 місяці тому

      Lagta ha ap ny kabi koi kitab pari nai ha jo ik podcast ko 10 kitaboon sy behtar keh rahy hain

    • @raftartv
      @raftartv  4 місяці тому +2

      Sirf duao mein yaad rakhein

    • @omairfarooq1949
      @omairfarooq1949 4 місяці тому

      @@MTalha01 :) You have liberty to judge. But I'll say your judgement isn't correct at the moment. Well tried by the way.

  • @muhammadhamzaaijazi2976
    @muhammadhamzaaijazi2976 2 місяці тому

    Dont rate ayub khan as a good leader
    Ayub made the foundation of east Pakistan

  • @mobasherahmed7451
    @mobasherahmed7451 4 місяці тому

    Very informative revealing of early Pakistan time.

    • @raftartv
      @raftartv  4 місяці тому +1

      Thanks! Please share as much as possible!

  • @hotbud234
    @hotbud234 4 місяці тому

    Recently Mian sahib elected more than the registered voters

  • @xtylish857
    @xtylish857 4 місяці тому

    Bhai aap sultan Abdul Hamid ka story bnao full

  • @Mirza001-y7f
    @Mirza001-y7f 4 місяці тому

    Make a video of general mirza Aslam

  • @AzharFarooqi-ry1ii
    @AzharFarooqi-ry1ii 4 місяці тому

    Very informative and objective run down of Pakistan’s journey from independence to date. Keep it up.

  • @syedwaqasahmed1603
    @syedwaqasahmed1603 4 місяці тому +1

    It seems Raftar is running out of topics for its subscribers

  • @WaleedAhmed-bj5og
    @WaleedAhmed-bj5og 4 місяці тому

    I think the reason why Pakistan is almost destroyed (which still remains till this date) is the assumption of Military Establishment and Bureaucracy that they can handle it better while the history tells us that they failed gloriously multiple times xD.

    • @limeclassic578
      @limeclassic578 3 місяці тому

      Now the one and only solution for Pakistan is establishing caliphate or implementing the deen.

  • @ShanMir-ry4qs
    @ShanMir-ry4qs 4 місяці тому

    Sir 1960 me salaries Kya thi ye Zara bataye ga.

    • @raftartv
      @raftartv  4 місяці тому

      Takriban Rs. 1000 aik achi salary mani jati thi.

  • @7007ification
    @7007ification 4 місяці тому

    what about signing of ceto sento and Baghad pact

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      That was profitable, you can look up Western News Docs by the BBC and other western networks that talk about the economy the rising standards of living etc. of course the mention of the pacts and aid is missing :)

  • @ZeeshanAnwar-b7j
    @ZeeshanAnwar-b7j 3 місяці тому +1

    Aray wah bhai apki nazar me bhutto acha tha mujeeb acha tha baki saray achay thy ayub acha nahi tha kyu k usny martialaw lagaya tha .. us k martiallaw se phele pakistan ki kya halat thi kesi siyasi nora kashi xhalti thi.. ayub ny atay hi axhy kaam kye lekin bhutto jese saanp ny dassa ayub ko aur yahya jesa zani ny .. mujeeb aetna acha tha tou kyu uski family samet usi ki army ny mar diya .. aur jo industry ayub ny lagayi woh bhutto ny atay hi tabah krdi .. aur jahil admi india me kuch hi families hai ambani adani wagera .. america me kuch hi aameer log hai .. asal masla yeha jaageer daar wadera sardar ka masla hai jo hal krny k lye army role ada krti hai tou mulk torny ki baat krty hai yeh log .lasani fasadad krty hai .. . had se ziyada hi jhoot bola jaraha ha raaftar ki taraf se ..

    • @limeclassic578
      @limeclassic578 3 місяці тому

      Toh apka kehna h keh Amriyat mulk ka hal h? Isse pehly ap ik nazar Islami nizam pr q nai duhra lete? Hmein islami nizam chahiye, aaaj tk pakistan azad hony k baad bhi ab tk british raaj hi chal rha h..

  • @mluqmankhan7755
    @mluqmankhan7755 4 місяці тому

    Who killed Benazir Bhutto? You posted the video yesterday and it has been deleted. ?

  • @taribkhan5468
    @taribkhan5468 4 місяці тому +1

    Just so you know those 22 families were hardworking muslim gujrati families, who built the industrial backbone of our country. They were not feudals or Exploitative. Now we complain we don't have Tata, Birla, Ambani. Some 'Arastoos' of 70s alongwith Bhutto destroyed all the growth of Pakistan. Hate him or like him, Ayub khan gave us 3 of the world's largest dams, fastest growing economy of the world, and fastest Industrialized nation of the world.

    • @duhduh666
      @duhduh666 4 місяці тому

      This is spin for sure. 22 families control 80% of Pakistan’s wealth is baloney. As a country it’s undervalued and rich folks make their money abroad too. Media likes these kinds of lines to grab attention.

  • @wajihacca
    @wajihacca 2 місяці тому

    East pakistan surplus/Export😂 gain built Islamabad
    August 1965 son zulfulqar operation gablalter want if win its mine credit if lose it Papa credit (gernal)
    In september 1965 india try get rid from gablalter operations so it start new front form pakistan officially war
    Just like kargel operation1998 is replica
    Both indian n pakistan gernal took field marshall tag 😅

  • @shahg6029
    @shahg6029 4 місяці тому

    بھائی ایمل کانسی پر سٹوری بناؤ پلیز

  • @7007ification
    @7007ification 4 місяці тому

    every army takeover brings dollars in Pakista

  • @Thesalalkhan.069
    @Thesalalkhan.069 4 місяці тому +1

    Make a video on Qaddafi life
    Appreciate your content

  • @ahsanchoudry4514
    @ahsanchoudry4514 2 місяці тому

    دارلحکومت کیوں نہیں کہتا ۔ یہاں کونسا خلیفہ جو دارلخلافہ کہ رہا ہے ۔ یہ بھی اپنے آپ کو دانشور کہتا ہوگا ۔

  • @AhmedCh-n6v
    @AhmedCh-n6v 4 місяці тому +1

    Hlo

  • @youknow6968
    @youknow6968 3 місяці тому

    Why do Pakistanis never mention the sanctions?
    Pakistan was heavily sanctioned from 1965 to 82, how is this not an important factor in your analysis. It's a supremely important factor.
    Yours is an extremely poor approach.

  • @Randomguy-z2y
    @Randomguy-z2y 4 місяці тому

    RAftaar ne lineup main itne documentaries main bhund mare hai paise leke ab mujhe aik takey ka inki documentaries pe bharosa nhi is se better hai banda khud research karle

  • @NotesandPens-ro9wx
    @NotesandPens-ro9wx 4 місяці тому

    Islamabad ka plan Bhutto ne diya tha bahi again research karain .. its biased point of view !

  • @TarotReadings2
    @TarotReadings2 4 місяці тому

    Disgraceful.
    Things need to change

  • @NotesandPens-ro9wx
    @NotesandPens-ro9wx 4 місяці тому

    Raftar sari achi videos bana raha hai magar Bhutto k DALAI CAMP k bare mein kuch nahi banata... yea nahi batata k Bhutto ne kis tharan Deceive kiya tha Ayub ko aur British Ambassdor ne kya kaha tha Bhutto k bare mein like he is born to be hanged. Bhutto ka role q nahi batate k wo 1971 k baad bahar tha aur idar akay Marshallah Law Administrator ban giya .. bolo such agar himmat hai tm logo mein !

  • @dodiraj1
    @dodiraj1 2 місяці тому

    Pakistanis never talk about Haji Pir Pass which they lost and got back only at Tashkent

  • @kamrantahawar
    @kamrantahawar 2 місяці тому

    juthe bolna is kom ka pesha hy

  • @ahsanmahmood5145
    @ahsanmahmood5145 3 місяці тому

    Biased analysis about Ayub Khan .Ayub Khan was patriotic and honest man.Pakistan made a lot of progress in that era.

  • @krishanukrori2452
    @krishanukrori2452 3 місяці тому

    Most indian fighter aircrafts were destroyed on ground nd all PAF aircraft were downed in dogfights

  • @arijitmondal9637
    @arijitmondal9637 3 місяці тому

    I don’t know how you came to the conclusion that Pakistan was winning 1965 war.
    They almost lost Lahore in exchange of what? roughly 900 sq. km of land?

  • @Zeno_334
    @Zeno_334 4 місяці тому

    I wonder how a consumption based and import dependent economy like Pakistan will emerge from the current imbroglio? Frankly, there is only one way to alleviate their suffering.
    And I am confident that the Pakistani elite know well that the only way is to improve relations with India at any cost. Even if they have to give up the Kashmir pipe dream, which I suspect will be India’s price for starting trade with Pakistan.
    I know that the Pakistani elite, including the Pakistani Army knows that India is the only remedy because of the proliferation of podcasts openly and proudly discussing their Indian heritage and talking about the wars lost against India. This wouldn’t be happening without the blessing of Pakistani Army. Indeed. I wouldn’t be surprised to find out that many of such podcasts are funded, sponsored by the Pakistani Army.

    • @limeclassic578
      @limeclassic578 3 місяці тому

      Oh no.. When you put Kashmir in it, there will be no negotiations.. And FYI, our only problem is the Pakistani army itself and the corrupt Pakistani elite..
      We are in the need of a fully Islamic law, where there will be no injustice, no cast superiority etc, nothing else.
      Where if a ruler try to tedha, he will be punished first, even a local citizen would be able to ask and criticize the Khalifa.
      This is what we want and on which base the Pakistan was founded.

  • @Skjiseeker8483
    @Skjiseeker8483 4 місяці тому

    Gwadar kbhi bhi important nhi thha Vrna ab tak devloped port ban chuka hota h ye important isliye h China ko gwadar me military base chahiye anti india malka off ho jaye to counter kr ske baki gwadar pakistan ke kisi kaam ka nhi h pakistan gwadar se transportation bhi nhi kr skta bcoz China ka system left hand h pakistan ka sara system right hand h economic system pura Punjab me h mutaliya pakistan jaise pakistan apni history smjhta h vse CPEC KO GAME CHANGER SMJHTA H karja utrna nhi 500 billion h ab pakistani udao kagaz ke aeroplane gwadar port se

  • @samanwer3393
    @samanwer3393 4 місяці тому

    Karachi city banny k qabil nae, capital kahan say banta. BABEY ka dimagh bhe kahen aur laga tha lagtae

  • @nizamuddinahmadaali3244
    @nizamuddinahmadaali3244 4 місяці тому +1

    The price was one million dollars. Money was paid by Sir Sultan Agha Khan. Sir Feroz Khan Khan negotiated the deal.