BMW M4 vs BMW M5 | evo DEADLY RIVALS

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 бер 2015
  • BMW M4 vs BMW M5. In the first of our Deadly Rivals series, evo's road test editor Dan Prosser pits two of the best M Division cars head-to-head on track.
    Lap times, specifications and the pure 'thrill of driving' ... all is put to the test, but which will come out on top?
    To read the full article, click here: www.evo.co.uk/bmw/m4/15442/bmw...
    Watch BMW M3 vs Mercedes-Benz C63 S AMG | evo DEADLY RIVALS: • BMW M3 F80 vs Mercedes...
    Watch Mercedes AMG GT S vs Porsche 911 Turbo | evo DEADLY RIVALS: • Mercedes AMG GT S vs P...
    Follow us:
    / evomagazine
    / evomagazine
    Subscribe to the evo channel: bit.ly/1MAnWVi
    Subscribe to evo magazine: subscribe.evo.co.uk/
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 541

  • @RZFitnessTV
    @RZFitnessTV 9 років тому +32

    Awesome. This is how a car/track review should be done. A lot of work but great to watch and good info.

  • @chele089
    @chele089 9 років тому +34

    Thats a very well done show. I love how you analyze every aspect of the timed lap to show us how the cars perform instead of just cutting in a few pretty pictures. Very very nice.

    • @nickolasbowen4036
      @nickolasbowen4036 2 роки тому

      i dont mean to be offtopic but does someone know of a method to get back into an instagram account??
      I was stupid lost my account password. I would love any assistance you can offer me.

    • @archiebrock6519
      @archiebrock6519 2 роки тому

      @Nickolas Bowen Instablaster :)

    • @nickolasbowen4036
      @nickolasbowen4036 2 роки тому

      @Archie Brock thanks so much for your reply. I found the site thru google and I'm in the hacking process now.
      Seems to take a while so I will reply here later with my results.

    • @nickolasbowen4036
      @nickolasbowen4036 2 роки тому

      @Archie Brock it did the trick and I finally got access to my account again. Im so happy:D
      Thanks so much you really help me out!

    • @archiebrock6519
      @archiebrock6519 2 роки тому

      @Nickolas Bowen you are welcome xD

  • @cben86
    @cben86 9 років тому +4

    The Evo channel is on fire this week with all the uploads! Really appreciate the technical breakdown between lap times. Dan keeps getting better and better in front of the camera. Thank you for the excellent video.

  • @frankie_wmg
    @frankie_wmg 9 років тому +1

    Well done EVO. Great in-car comparison footage, especially when paused to highlight differences. More of this please!

  • @B835605B
    @B835605B 9 років тому +2

    Really good video EVO ! the lap time part with four cams and the comments is perfect and feels real ! we want more deadly rivals video like that !

  • @jameslife3692
    @jameslife3692 3 роки тому

    I’ve been looking for this exact video for 6 months! So glad I found it! Loved it!

  • @hyperlogos
    @hyperlogos 9 років тому +2

    Great format, loved the pause-and-comment.

  • @tinhead10
    @tinhead10 9 років тому +1

    Great production value in this video. Good work Dan and the team, I look forward to the series in the future.

  • @evoermine
    @evoermine 9 років тому

    Fantastic video, loved the subtle background music and great photography. Well done Evo.

  • @DrNoro
    @DrNoro 9 років тому +3

    Loved the play by play breakdown of the race

  • @MrSaxotomitry
    @MrSaxotomitry 9 років тому

    I like this format of car battles way better than previous versions. Keep it up!

  • @B00AJ
    @B00AJ 9 років тому

    Really well done video, would love to see more like this. Great job evo

  • @pascalmpower7944
    @pascalmpower7944 9 років тому +10

    The M5 and M4 have same vehicle dynamic control and stiff damper, however, the stability control is more effective in M4 due to light weight and the lighter it is, less mass pushing through the front tire for less push and understeering. However, the M5 is heavier although it's bulk through a turn but a bit more stable "physically". Anyway, I'll go for the M5.

  • @v_alexiadis
    @v_alexiadis 9 років тому

    Great, great video and very interesting series. I can't wait to see more.

  • @adriane6943
    @adriane6943 9 років тому +9

    This was a great review!

  • @Jorcap
    @Jorcap 9 років тому +2

    Do more of these type of comparisons between the model range of a brand! Absolutely enjoyed it!

  • @detective3728
    @detective3728 9 років тому +62

    I would like to see a match between 435i vs M4, EVO

    • @its_EZ
      @its_EZ 9 років тому +13

      No.

    • @detective3728
      @detective3728 9 років тому +17

      Yes.

    • @Abzug0386
      @Abzug0386 9 років тому +9

      For what? It's obvious the M4 is the faster car, since it has the same base while having more power and a sportier chassis.

    • @detective3728
      @detective3728 9 років тому +3

      Ya, I know that.. But how fast is it.. Both use a 3,0L Inlinesix..

    • @SusieSmart
      @SusieSmart 9 років тому +1

      ***** Surely you mean bi turbo 3.0 I6?

  • @eliotsalandybrown
    @eliotsalandybrown 9 років тому

    Love the detail given to the on board hot lap comparison. Great video.

  • @jim1013yyf
    @jim1013yyf 9 років тому +4

    awesome track comparison video!

  • @oppanheimer
    @oppanheimer 8 років тому

    I love these deadly rivals videos. Keep them coming please.

  • @thatguytom1
    @thatguytom1 9 років тому +1

    love the analysis of the timed lap.

  • @masmouta1994
    @masmouta1994 9 років тому

    awesome video EVO, keep up the good work

  • @CarToneHK
    @CarToneHK 9 років тому +1

    Wow, that was very close.
    And being the little brother at home this makes me very happy.

  • @Sgaver
    @Sgaver 3 роки тому

    Uno dei migliori video mai prodotti.Formidabole sotto tutti i punti di vista.Canale top!

  • @whynot9899
    @whynot9899 9 років тому

    I have never seen such a well done comparison. Bravo! More like this!

  • @olegdavidov555
    @olegdavidov555 9 років тому

    Great revue. Thank you.

  • @raulflores81
    @raulflores81 9 років тому +12

    E60 M5 vs. F10 M5.. Please! I would love to see the improvements between the generation and the difference in which is better to drive. Naturally aspirated or turbocharged? I would love to see that Evo.

    • @denniszzzz
      @denniszzzz 4 роки тому +1

      f10 destroys the e60 except the sound

  • @Erich2142
    @Erich2142 9 років тому +140

    It should be M3 VS M5 or M4 VS M6.

    • @xboy4331
      @xboy4331 9 років тому +26

      I'd love to see M3 v M5 v M6 Gran Coupe, it would make more sense to put the four door cars against each other.

    • @Malc180s
      @Malc180s 9 років тому +4

      Same thing.

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 9 років тому +5

      Eric M it doesn't matter they are all m cars. considering same performance figures for m3 and m4.

    • @Erich2142
      @Erich2142 9 років тому

      drdj69 Thats like comparing al AMG models and calling them all the same, or calling the Corvette a Camero. No its not the same car.

    • @SupremeMoFo
      @SupremeMoFo 9 років тому +5

      Eric M Not a valid comparison. Corvette and Camaro are different platforms. M3 and M4 are a shared platform, M5 and M6 are a shared platform. The only thing that splits the 2 door and 4 door Ms is 20kg and a few cm in height.

  • @twenty514
    @twenty514 9 років тому

    loved the side-by-side track comparison

  • @nbwinn
    @nbwinn 9 років тому

    Can tell Prosser is getting more comfortable on camera. Great video, loved the detailed lap.

  • @pperejma
    @pperejma 8 років тому

    Such a good video. Thank you!

  • @ashs1670
    @ashs1670 9 років тому

    Bloody excellent review, great stuff.

  • @jortepap
    @jortepap 9 років тому +4

    Absolutely stunning cars.
    Love the engines and the sound

  • @robgrass1
    @robgrass1 8 років тому

    Exciting to watch, with surprising results!

  • @fastlane2914
    @fastlane2914 2 роки тому

    A very good comparison I can’t wait to see more

  • @miamiluck001
    @miamiluck001 Рік тому

    Wow! This was so well done! I really appreciated the bumper camera and pausing it to see the positioning and gap. For a 4 door family saloon to be that close on track to the lighter, more nimble, shorter wheelbase M4…the M5 is mighty!

  • @xabiercruz4408
    @xabiercruz4408 2 роки тому

    Really good video. Thanks

  • @turki_wz
    @turki_wz 9 років тому +7

    5:31 What a shot!!

  • @user-hj2se6qr6f
    @user-hj2se6qr6f 9 років тому

    The detailed analysis is good I love that

  • @iSina93
    @iSina93 9 років тому

    I love the commentary you have on the hot lap

  • @hovnojede010101
    @hovnojede010101 9 років тому

    Oh, this series is gonna be awesome.

  • @MX5Dorifto
    @MX5Dorifto 9 років тому +1

    Great review, well done Dan.

  • @Phobos_Deimos
    @Phobos_Deimos 9 років тому

    Good show, thank you!

  • @Benedocta
    @Benedocta 9 років тому

    I'm so impressed by the steering geometry on those drift shots. Awesome!

  • @TheRoggan123
    @TheRoggan123 9 років тому

    This was a very good review!! Entertaining, factual and some flamboyant driving with lots of smoke! All boxes ticked! :)

  • @jcotty7
    @jcotty7 9 років тому +8

    The new reviewer is very good! more from him!

  • @VivaBein
    @VivaBein 9 років тому

    So this guy's had two reviews already, and he's already shaken off the critics. Great review sir, Well played Mr Prosser.

  • @VtecAbuser
    @VtecAbuser 9 років тому +3

    Due to the fact he runs the M4 as a daily and will know the car inside out, you have to wonder how much influence this has had on the result of this test.

    • @richardholt1202
      @richardholt1202 4 роки тому

      He looked like he didn't hit a few apex right in the M5.

  • @WillSatchwell
    @WillSatchwell 9 років тому

    Gonna put this out there and just say Dan Prosser has some serious Drifting/driving talent that i haven't seen in Journalism other than Chris Harris and Tiff Needel! Top work!

  • @marcus37170192
    @marcus37170192 8 років тому

    beautifull review !! thanks

  • @zaphod2
    @zaphod2 9 років тому

    i enjoyed this review, well done guys.

  • @amritmcamc
    @amritmcamc 9 років тому

    Good vid. Liked it!

  • @Alezey574
    @Alezey574 9 років тому +24

    I'd still buy the M5 if i could afford it.

    • @thepro08
      @thepro08 3 роки тому +5

      i have the M5, the M4 is better for city the M5 is a distance monster to travel one country to another in comfort and luxury. they could setup more the m5 as the m4 to be less comfortable but then it wouldnt be a M5. in short you pass a ferrari in a M5 with the massage on and total relax.

  • @MarkyFormula1
    @MarkyFormula1 8 років тому

    Great video Dan!

  • @yourcoolbro688
    @yourcoolbro688 9 років тому

    Great video

  • @Queck666
    @Queck666 9 років тому

    very nice way of comparing two cars with this splitscreen!!

  • @jamescutter9868
    @jamescutter9868 9 років тому +5

    Surely it should of been the F80 M3 vs M5? Great vid anyway, love both :)

  • @taniawallace2420
    @taniawallace2420 9 років тому

    great review bud

  • @laetitiajack9596
    @laetitiajack9596 8 років тому

    Always a pleasure watching this tester ,he appears very knowledgable

  • @fun364
    @fun364 9 років тому +8

    OMG! That drift @5:29 was epic! #D1worthy

  • @danielmaia3559
    @danielmaia3559 9 років тому +40

    The difference is very slim, I wonder if BMW will let the M2 be as fast as the M3/M4 like the old 1M was.

    • @jamescutter9868
      @jamescutter9868 9 років тому +1

      Hmm will be interesting, the M2 is gonna have around 380HP (I think, not sure) and it'll weigh a hell of a lot lighter so you never know.

    • @jamescutter9868
      @jamescutter9868 9 років тому

      Oh yeah shit of course, forgot that 😂

    • @jamescutter9868
      @jamescutter9868 9 років тому +1

      Think I may have it over an M4 since it will be a better size :)

    • @J0lker
      @J0lker 9 років тому

      ***** hey Uzzy, haven't seen your comments for a while haha!
      I'd place my money on somewhere around 360 PS (at least on paper)
      Last time it was jump from 306 to 340 so now i think it will be pretty similar.
      And well, i'm a RS3 fanboy anyway haha

    • @Kaisuke971
      @Kaisuke971 9 років тому

      ***** Considering they do the hp trick with all of their ///Ms when considering a duel between two ///Ms you can just take it away...

  • @sumotherdude
    @sumotherdude 9 років тому

    great job dan!

  • @nathaneastmure
    @nathaneastmure 9 років тому +1

    good review, I like this guy

  • @BlackenedNL
    @BlackenedNL 9 років тому

    This guy makes some quality videos! Nice

  • @chris14091975
    @chris14091975 9 років тому

    you guys make awesome videos

  • @giorx5
    @giorx5 9 років тому

    Well done guys! A great review and track video comparison. I couldn't call this tie a win though. And in any F1 long circuit with 2 long straights and mix of corners, M5 would be at least some tens in front.

  • @8150shaf
    @8150shaf 9 років тому

    This video is excellent.

  • @PumpkinSpicedShart
    @PumpkinSpicedShart 9 років тому +1

    EVO is on fire lately!!

  • @102lammy
    @102lammy 9 років тому +4

    Got to love BMW's design! Looking forward to the M4 GTS.

  • @TheMaxM
    @TheMaxM 9 років тому +1

    The M4 with the manual gearbox does have 4.3 seconds from 0-62.
    But the one you tested, with the DKG only have 4.1 seconds.

  • @angelfonseca8362
    @angelfonseca8362 4 роки тому

    I have M4 on marina blue color .is just amazing. Every where i go turn heads over even me . and i leave in arizona EUA where a lots a nice cars drive around me. Very Nice video

  • @alexp-de
    @alexp-de 9 років тому

    exciting track analyse and comparison at the end, well done!

  • @Oulel77
    @Oulel77 9 років тому +1

    Good job

  • @bruth6138
    @bruth6138 8 років тому

    Great videos, guys. Like top gear but without the pretentious bullishness.

  • @momo_su57
    @momo_su57 8 років тому +10

    both are amazing but I prefer the m5 More cause it have good looking design 4 door more comfortable a handy control higher top speed and accrelation and finally it have the monster v8 yes I love the stright line 6 but that 4.4 v8 is just monster

    • @ahmatito40
      @ahmatito40 5 років тому

      mohand prince but it costs $40k more than the M4 only to loose the race lol true fact
      I personally like the sound of the in line 6 cylinder much better

  • @EVILSPAWN1003
    @EVILSPAWN1003 9 років тому

    The colour on the ///M5...... Looks mean,angry and yet gorgeous. Reminds me of the old "shadow line" option on the E28`s

  • @jaytmtb
    @jaytmtb 4 роки тому +1

    BMW M4 and BMW M5 are two fantastic cars, the M5 would be my choice, great review as always

  • @danielmaia3559
    @danielmaia3559 9 років тому +73

    The M5 looks way better than the M3.

    • @TheMpofu
      @TheMpofu 9 років тому +18

      Just like the M3 is sexier than the 4

    • @flipakine
      @flipakine 8 років тому

      +Kings mario I second this! it's night and day that comparison. 4 series is just so bulky compared to the 3 series. esp in ///M trim.
      all come up short to the e39 m5 though. there just isn't a sexier BMW than that!

    • @HURRICANEM5
      @HURRICANEM5 7 років тому

      Why ?

    • @Coctvdt
      @Coctvdt 6 років тому +3

      are you guys on planet earth??

    • @youtubemanswagroy212
      @youtubemanswagroy212 5 років тому

      Daniel Maia fr

  • @EDTTebzaah
    @EDTTebzaah 4 роки тому +1

    I love them both but that M5...😘 I'm inlove with it!

  • @jeff8827
    @jeff8827 6 років тому

    great vid, proper accurate comparson , thought the M4 would win but not by so little

  • @pranavmukesh
    @pranavmukesh 9 років тому

    Exactly like the week I spent with the M4! On the road it was bad no other word for it! I felt like it was rolling and it was uninspiring! But around willow springs it was unbelievably good! While the steering felt bland on the road, on track it was really good! More load in the tires equals more feel! The damping was really good! And it pulls so hard in a straight line! I liked it more than the 991 on track! On the road the 991 is more fun!

  • @DG-hj1nh
    @DG-hj1nh 3 роки тому

    I know this is old but Bravo brother

  • @foxhounduk2k8
    @foxhounduk2k8 9 років тому +1

    This guy is good. Very very good review style

    • @HesteBremse
      @HesteBremse 8 років тому

      +foxhounduk2k8 I totally agree. He is doing a great job, it´s serious and well held and he is consistent through all the reviews he has made. He also has an "easy" yet serious/focused personality that does not get in the way of content - Really good.

  • @dln.sweeney
    @dln.sweeney 9 років тому

    Prosser's obviously way more into M cars than new Mini's haha. Good stuff.

  • @peterpeng5904
    @peterpeng5904 7 років тому +2

    eve always makes better quality videos than anyone else

  • @twisted5544
    @twisted5544 8 років тому +8

    Good demonstration but that M5 will mop the floor with the M4 in the real world.

    • @OwenTan2
      @OwenTan2 8 років тому +9

      where do u think this video was made ?

    • @Abduldoctor
      @Abduldoctor 7 років тому

      Owen Tanaka was he referring to Narnia?

  • @jumblum
    @jumblum 9 років тому +5

    please do the new 911 gt3 rs vs 911 turbo s

  • @learningcoding6766
    @learningcoding6766 8 років тому

    cool pics

  • @tomislavkaltnecker6354
    @tomislavkaltnecker6354 9 років тому +1

    The new M5, all I can say about is, it's got 600 HP and my family/friends can come along and enjoy in comfort!.

  • @ClintWestmetal88
    @ClintWestmetal88 9 років тому +4

    Good but a road test would be far more interesting given the real use most owners will have.

  • @ytwizzle
    @ytwizzle 9 років тому +1

    Great review and I would still take the M5 over the 4. Roomier, more comfy and fast as hell in a straight line.

  • @Kylo_Ren_2033
    @Kylo_Ren_2033 8 років тому +3

    I want to see Cayman GTS vs M4

  • @goreddragon1
    @goreddragon1 9 років тому

    Is there any tread left on the tires after spending a day at the track? Seems like you are burning some serious rubber.

  • @DjPremRushOfficial
    @DjPremRushOfficial 9 років тому

    Here in the US the 0-60 that is recorded (and you could check the North America BMW website) is at 3.9sec. I'm not sure if it's different for other territories, but here it's 3.9.

    • @supaahflyy
      @supaahflyy 9 років тому

      maybe its the extra 2mph to make it to 0-62 times that make the time higher lol :P

    • @DjPremRushOfficial
      @DjPremRushOfficial 9 років тому

      supaahflyy True.

  • @M4DVILLAIN
    @M4DVILLAIN 9 років тому

    who is this guy? why am i seeing him for the first time? excelent video!!

  • @TheMpofu
    @TheMpofu 9 років тому +10

    Knowing BMW these two cars are probably putting out more power than claimed lol

    • @MichaelVincentMindset
      @MichaelVincentMindset 9 років тому +2

      Kingsley Mpofu You sir are sadly mistaken, look up motor trends video of the e63 amg-s vs the m5 and you will see how bmws overrates their engines. Just like the B7 in their b7 vs audi s8 video they go to a dyno on both videos and show bmws overrate their engines, whereas mercedes and audi highly underrate their engines. Go take a look, the numbers dont lie.

    • @mayastll
      @mayastll 9 років тому +1

      Michael Brunnhoelzl I really dont see how you can say that when all bmw models, M3, M4 and M5 can keep up if not beat the equivalent mercedes and audi. Most Bmw models put out less power than audi or mercedes but still are strong competitors because of the driving dynamics.

    • @supaahflyy
      @supaahflyy 9 років тому +2

      daisy may well that m5 in that video couldnt keep up with the e63 amg s but then again it did have 4matic. But the premise of the guy aboves comment still stands, on the dyno the e63 was makign more power than claimed and the bmw was the opposite. Also when this new c63 is properly released, im sorry, but it will most probably take a dump over the m3/m4. Nearly 80-90 bhp more and a much better interior. Why would any sane person who isnt biased buy an M3/M4 over a c63?

    • @eatmyorangemarmalade
      @eatmyorangemarmalade 9 років тому

      supaahflyy well, i'm biased. and the c63 doesn't look as good or handle quite as well.

    • @supaahflyy
      @supaahflyy 9 років тому

      ***** hah atleast you can admit it. I much prefer the m4 looks but it doesnt light a candle to the new c63 in terms of performance. The reviews ive seen of it suggest that it does handle just as well if not better than the m4 so the gap between driving characteristics has been closed by mercedes

  • @o3tomas
    @o3tomas 9 років тому +2

    I like to see this guy improve. Still lacking a bit of passion, but good enough already.

  • @colombianomd1
    @colombianomd1 9 років тому

    Did the M4 have the optional carbon ceramic brakes? I would think this would help in brake fade/distance over laps.

  • @felipemautei
    @felipemautei 8 років тому

    Wow what a video!! I'm so buying an M4

  • @derbigpr500
    @derbigpr500 9 років тому +1

    2:53 - UFO in the sky, oh mah gawd they're real and they came to watch the M battle.