Exposing Elijah: The Truth

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 455

  • @MindShift-Brandon
    @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +67

    This is one of my favorite kinds of videos. Let's just use the bible. The rest are mere excuses.

    • @n.c.1201
      @n.c.1201 7 годин тому +10

      Yes, I agree. These are my favorites: where the Bible does your job for you. Great run down, Brandon! Keep sticking to your Bible context because so many other videos surrounding Chrisitianity don't utilize the text itself and I think that makes their cases be seen as "weak" when it could easily be a slam dunk.

    • @Mansa-of-Gaming
      @Mansa-of-Gaming 6 годин тому +1

      I found this video about the face of Jesus. The video said that they have an account of Jesus from Pontius Pilate himself.
      ua-cam.com/video/mrn1xziwQuo/v-deo.htmlsi=nxMpmu7bv6CccfEV
      I want to know what you think.

    • @sauron69447
      @sauron69447 6 годин тому +8

      @@MindShift-Brandon Elijah, fearing for his own life after just killing the 100 prophets of Baal is straight up hypocritical. It's crazy that Christians consider him a good guy.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +2

      @@n.c.1201 Thanks so much!

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +2

      @@Mansa-of-Gaming I'll take a look thanks

  • @DannyS177
    @DannyS177 6 годин тому +63

    When a Christian has said "why hasn't god answered my prayers?" It has taken a lot of restraint to not respond with, "maybe he is on the toilet." I have never said that, but I have been tempted too.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  5 годин тому +16

      lol!

    • @rokkitserjun
      @rokkitserjun 4 години тому +11

      Where do you think we get the phrase 'Holy Shit' from?

    • @godsarepeopletoo1896
      @godsarepeopletoo1896 3 години тому +3

      ​@@rokkitserjun
      I honestly never thought of it that way... I usually use the phrase in an argument to just underscore the fact that saying omg doesn't mean we believe in a god any more than saying holy shytt means we believe in divine bowel movements

    • @unknownx7252
      @unknownx7252 2 години тому +2

      ​@@rokkitserjun😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @archbishoprichardforceginn9338
      @archbishoprichardforceginn9338 2 години тому +1

      @@DannyS177 Yeah, this was a great example of how Christians say, God will not be Mocked, unless it's someone else's God. Well it just proves how the Gord of the Holey Script-Yourz is Totally Mockworthy 😆

  • @MichaelMcCallister097
    @MichaelMcCallister097 6 годин тому +34

    One of my favorite things is whenever Christians stress the importance of context and then constantly use the Bible out of context to express a point they want to get across.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +9

      It’s quite frustrating.

    • @ProfessorNexus-d8i
      @ProfessorNexus-d8i 3 години тому +3

      Let's not forget the fact that when you use verses against them they'll constantly say things like "that verse is being used out of context" and "It means something that's up to God not us". To which they not only deliberately avoid the question but try to make the said verse like it's completely something else.

    • @godsarepeopletoo1896
      @godsarepeopletoo1896 2 години тому +2

      Mine is when they say it doesn't mean what it says...
      Jesus came to save the world blah blah... but point to where it says he speaks in parables because he doesn't want certain people to understand 'lest they repent and be forgiven'...

  • @dasbus9834
    @dasbus9834 7 годин тому +69

    The fact that they wouldn't want to show the slaughter scenes these days must be another case of immutable objective morality.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +6

      lol indeed!

    • @BluStarGalaxy
      @BluStarGalaxy 6 годин тому +5

      I have seen my fair share of slaughter scenes in Christian Bible cartoons growing up. I wouldn’t give them too much credit.

    • @markwoods4439
      @markwoods4439 5 годин тому +5

      @@BluStarGalaxyThey should show them today plus discuss them in Sunday school 😁

    • @BluStarGalaxy
      @BluStarGalaxy 5 годин тому +5

      @@markwoods4439 Not a cartoon but I recall going into a Bible store awhile back and they had a movie playing on a TV in the kids section. The movie: The Passion of the Christ. 😳

    • @markwoods4439
      @markwoods4439 5 годин тому +4

      @@BluStarGalaxy The biggest sacrifice scene they show in the movie Jesus on the cross!!!

  • @trabob4438
    @trabob4438 6 годин тому +34

    What's really funny is Christians say god is against human sacrifice and yet god has a human sacrifice to forgive sin.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +7

      Yup he got to decide what would appease himself and chose human, son, sacrifice.

    • @sauron69447
      @sauron69447 5 годин тому +4

      @@trabob4438 Even more bizarrely That human sacrifice is also apparently him. So God sacrificed himself to himself to satiate his own wrath.

    • @BluStarGalaxy
      @BluStarGalaxy 5 годин тому +2

      The only thing consistent about the Bible is its inconsistency.

    • @gl3mmy903
      @gl3mmy903 4 години тому +1

      @@MindShift-Brandonnah let’s play nice,let’s say Jesus isn’t a human,fine. But how about the martyrs like Steven who got stoned to death and the whole you should be ready to die for God is that not a human sacrifice for “God’s glory”

    • @DrgnLdyLizzie2001
      @DrgnLdyLizzie2001 3 години тому

      From what little I pick up as I mess around on my phone at church (I go to help wrangle the kids as they're too old to be going to 'class'), Jesus wasn't a human sacrifice per se. He was more of a lamb, or some BS like that.

  • @deus_ex_post
    @deus_ex_post 2 години тому +7

    Oooh, wow, it's always amusing to see how we hand children a book that includes funny stories about, in this episode, creepy man orchestrating the mass massacre of prophets, causing famines that starve women and children, and calling down fire from heaven to consume his enemies. Clearly, that deserves a PEGI rating of 'Suitable for All Ages'!". A real gold standard for kids' moral education

  • @ZanyCat
    @ZanyCat 2 години тому +5

    I'm glad that you're covering this. I used to be a Christian and would watch all of Bible Project's videos. A lot of my biblical beliefs and understanding came from them. Now I know how it was so heavily cherry picked to tell the kind of story they wanted to tell.

  • @exmormonroverpaula2319
    @exmormonroverpaula2319 6 годин тому +19

    The story of Elijah and the prophets of Baal indicates that the Biblical God is a serious opponent of freedom of religion.

  • @AdamKlownzinger
    @AdamKlownzinger 7 годин тому +22

    Several theologically devastating issues from one measly story. Well done as always

  • @boojackson7133
    @boojackson7133 6 годин тому +17

    Coffee and Bible study with Brandon..the perfect antidote!

  • @brenatevi
    @brenatevi 4 години тому +8

    Something that always bothered me about the God in the Bible: If God is unchangeable, why does he change his mind several times in the Bible?

    • @georgekatkins
      @georgekatkins 4 години тому +4

      He hired a better PR Agent in the NT.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      its a huge issue for sure!

    • @jasonhighlander
      @jasonhighlander 42 хвилини тому +1

      Easy, God changed his mind because reasons. Reasons that are higher than my reasons, and, and, and...

  • @saturday32
    @saturday32 5 годин тому +19

    This "religion" has f**ked with my mind.
    I prayed for at least 40 years as part of my faith.....crickets...F'n nothing . ZERO!!!;
    And I watched great people suffer even though they prayed and hsd an amazing moral compass.
    This is a scam, a con, a control tool!!!!
    Thank you for this channel Brandon.
    It helps me heal and feel "normsl".
    Christianity left me empty and feeling like I was always wrong, the problem.
    I am a goid man and person despite what was preached to me.
    "Bless" all of you by the power of the universe, nature and yourself.

    • @timbertome2443
      @timbertome2443 4 години тому +1

      I did for 29 years, and same. No answer, only cryptic "you gotta feel it without feeling it you gotta understand it without understanding it" bullshit.

    • @FreethinkingFoolery
      @FreethinkingFoolery 4 години тому

      Let me ask you a question did you actually genuinely love jesus or did someone planted this idea?

    • @calanm7880
      @calanm7880 Годину тому

      I dearly loved stuff like the Bible Project (I introduced my pastor to it), and I genuinely loved the Jesus I spoke to and who gave me strength.
      But I realised all the good aspects of my faith were actually me all along: I’d been disassociatingly conversing with loving inner myself, which caused me to be kind and to find strength.
      I only realised that this past week, but it gave me some peace feeling I’d wasted so many years .. the good things I loved about my faith were in me, all the shit that had caused severe cognitive dissonance and the petty abuse & favouritism were others playing a system... who meant to be vessels of the living God. The Holy Spirit can raise the dead or knock ppl down dead for exaggerating in the scriptures, but he seemingly now cannot mildly reform a narcissist Christian leader! 😅

  • @soulinameatsack29
    @soulinameatsack29 6 годин тому +22

    Whenever I hear Bible stories now I literally can't BELIEVE I thought they happened literally. It's so obviously mythology, just strange what the mind can convince itself of ...

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +8

      i feel the same!

    • @sauron69447
      @sauron69447 5 годин тому +5

      @@soulinameatsack29 and it's even a good mythology, other cultures have cooler stories.

  • @Djax111
    @Djax111 6 годин тому +20

    I died laughing at the "This other god is too busy taking a shit to show up ans perform miracles" 😂

  • @danielsmith2447
    @danielsmith2447 5 годин тому +11

    when I was a believer I didn't see the violence and death for what it was, my attitude was always YAY God! Amazing how different my perspective is now reading these stories.

  • @antoniu9757
    @antoniu9757 7 годин тому +19

    Man, you're here to help me with my last half hour at work. Thank you.

  • @stephaniesmith9111
    @stephaniesmith9111 4 години тому +7

    I think the Christian mindset, and the Bible Project mindset is that God is a life giver to those that are following him or "on his side". For everyone else, it's tough luck. And that is exactly the Christian attitude. When you walk away from Christianity, watch all your friends and family wait with baited breath for things to start going badly in your life. And guess what? When they don't and you are thriving, they "reason" their way out of that too.

  • @xtina2189
    @xtina2189 7 годин тому +21

    It's 'almost' like the gauntlet of ghostwriters were in different moods when it was their turn adding to their mythology. 🤔

  • @freebirdofreason1994
    @freebirdofreason1994 2 години тому +5

    I left the church 30 years ago, a Very lonely time, now we have channels like this just brilliant.
    This one is for the Christians to answer.
    Tomorrow I'm burying my Son 32 years old a sweet lovely young man, died unexpectedly, leaving 4 children 2,4,5,7 years.
    His wife is devastated.
    He wasn't a believer because I left the church when he was 2 years old.
    If I had of brain washed him he may of been.
    There are thousands of people who don't believe because they are not connected to church people.
    Along with what the video rightly explains, there is no love from a god, you certainly would not say there is if you could see these children and feel my pain.
    My brother who is a Christian probably prays for me since I left the church, my question is how has his prayer helped I was convinced before that the world looks like no god exists, now I have the worst proof that it does.
    I'm not mad at god he doesn't exist, my hope is some one may also realise and start to live life and not live to die.
    It's far better once your free from religion, life is short.
    Take care.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      I am so very sorry to hear about your loss. I think of my own wife and kids and what would happen for them if i died unexpectedly and it breaks my heart. Thank you though for sharing here. I hope you continue to find peace.

    • @deb6252
      @deb6252 29 хвилин тому

      I am so sorry for the great pain you're having to endure.

  • @allenmitchell09
    @allenmitchell09 6 годин тому +15

    Maybe hate preachers are the ones who actually read and understand the Bible? 🤷

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +13

      Yeah the worst kind of preachers i have seen are the ones that are being most biblically consistent

    • @Jon45678
      @Jon45678 5 годин тому +4

      @@MindShift-Brandon
      SO TRUE

  • @cesariglesias297
    @cesariglesias297 4 години тому +3

    Now who will want "Christians" to read their Holy Book without cherry picking... that will be dangerous even with the New Testament they won't do that....

  • @katherineg9396
    @katherineg9396 4 години тому +6

    If I had just started a 3 year drought I'd run and hide too.

  • @BIRDY31176
    @BIRDY31176 4 години тому +3

    I cant wait to share this!!! Sending links NOW! amazing and very well explained.

  • @JahHawks
    @JahHawks 7 годин тому +21

    Brandon I can't tell you how much I use to love the bible project channel. Their animations made the biblical stories more enjoyable because they provided a visual. I have long since said goodbye.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +5

      oh i get it! i'd kill to have the skill to do the animating they do on their bible videos. These AI shorts are fine too but i know people get sick of it, but man there bible episodes are really something.

    • @WongTag
      @WongTag 6 годин тому

      Thanks for the recommendation, just subbed to The Bible Project.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  5 годин тому +3

      @@WongTag oh you sure showed me.

  • @Eyesopeningheartrealigning
    @Eyesopeningheartrealigning 7 годин тому +15

    🎉Always look forward to seeing you!
    Unpacking at its best! 🎉

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому

      Thanks so much. I am pleased to do it with this set of stories for sure!

  • @lilafeldman8630
    @lilafeldman8630 2 години тому +1

    I remember years ago when I was going to church, the whole part about "how long will you keep going between two different opinions?" It left me feeling so torn between having to choose between my secular friends and my Christian ones. Forcing myself to believe the Christian worldview, the way God always seemed to bring that scripture to mind when I was in a big dilemma or crossroads in life.
    Years later, I thankfully, found a Christian counselor who was much more compassionate. She said that being "double-minded" is a normal part of life. She comforted me.

  • @BeccaYoley
    @BeccaYoley 7 годин тому +18

    "Honest Bible stories"... I luv it!

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +4

      ha, great title. I was trying to think of a name for a playlist to put these in. will use that!

    • @BeccaYoley
      @BeccaYoley 6 годин тому +1

      @@MindShift-Brandon awesome!

    • @TonyLambregts
      @TonyLambregts 6 годин тому +1

      @@BeccaYoley Yay.

    • @Jon45678
      @Jon45678 5 годин тому +1

      @@BeccaYoley
      👍🏻

  • @judyforsyth5782
    @judyforsyth5782 6 годин тому +10

    Thank you 🙏 Brandon I learned so much today. You strengthened my unbelief 🙏🙏❤️❤️

  • @yourgodismean4526
    @yourgodismean4526 4 години тому +5

    Just love the new places the channel is moving! 👍💪💙

  • @panqueque445
    @panqueque445 4 години тому +4

    "He puts god to the test, and god shows up"
    Imagine that

  • @simonkoster
    @simonkoster 3 години тому +3

    Elijah foreshadowing Tim the Enchanter.

  • @jaycrocker3812
    @jaycrocker3812 3 години тому +2

    Thank you for your amazing work, Brandon!

  • @FreethinkingFoolery
    @FreethinkingFoolery 2 години тому +2

    Funny how some Christians claim to elevate others spiritually, but it feels more like they're lifting them just enough to bring them down. Reminds me of Tool’s lyrics, ‘I will work to elevate you just enough to bring you down.’ It’s like an endless cycle of control dressed up as compassion.

  • @QuintonjChambers
    @QuintonjChambers 2 години тому +3

    I love that you discussed the Baal story. Many evangelicals justify the genocides after the Exodus on the people being Baal worshippers, sacraficing thier children to Baal and tieing that to today's abortion debate to what they call, "the spirit of Baal". Problem is there was no spirit of Baal. If believed this story obviously shows Baal was fake so how does he have a spirit that's somehow controling people today?

  • @mattirealm
    @mattirealm 6 годин тому +7

    The stuff I never saw before when I was a believer is now so eloquently explained by Brandon! Makes me sick frankly............... The foul and utter nonsense of "god" and trying to meld "good" with that cretin is beyond me now. How my brain ever allowed me to have such contradictions and to believe in trash.............man. It ruined my life and that is not a "poor me" statement, it literally ruined my life and has mostly ruined the lives of certain family members that still hold to it. Excellent job though with today's video!

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  5 годин тому +2

      lifes not over yet! but i hear you man. It stole so much time and so much more from so many of us.

  • @9ja9ite
    @9ja9ite 6 годин тому +9

    Wow. It’s amazing how many little details slide into the background. Elijah slaughtering 450 men just as a final FU after the point was made is such an example of how vengeful and wrathful this God was. This would have been, as you point out, the perfect place to show compassion, forgiveness or justice. The story could have had the men fall to their knees to worship God and in returned be embraced and welcomed with loving arms by God - but no. He has Elijah slaughter them mercilessly. So much for that narrative.

  • @greenleaf239
    @greenleaf239 6 годин тому +9

    I guess "thou shall not murder" doesn't apply to some prophets.

    • @martinelzen5127
      @martinelzen5127 4 години тому +3

      it's a my-prophet-is-greater-than-yours story.
      It's amazing how much horror you simply don't see when you've read it and had it presented to you so often.

    • @sundayoliver3147
      @sundayoliver3147 4 години тому

      Nor does "thou shalt not murder" apply to any of the chosen people, when god tells them who to invade and slaughter and rape and enslave. Only the chosen people count as "people"-- an ethic that is so often embraced by Abrahamic religions today, and that has migrated into our secular world.i

  • @godsarepeopletoo1896
    @godsarepeopletoo1896 3 години тому +3

    Ffs I'm stuck on him saying Elijah means 'my name is yahweh'
    This is why I end up watching videos five or six times 😂😂

  • @SimonTamplar
    @SimonTamplar 4 години тому +6

    Forever atheist here. This story is sickening. Truly horrible stuff here.

    • @sundayoliver3147
      @sundayoliver3147 4 години тому +1

      Yes, if you're not indoctrinated in it from a young child, it's easy to see how awful it is. I often wondered at some of the gory stories, but then I had it "explained" to me.

  • @iluvtacos1231
    @iluvtacos1231 5 годин тому +6

    I think Prophet of Zod did a video about the Bible Project and a video they did about Genesis.
    They change/portray differently a LOT of things in their video vs what the Bible actually says.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  5 годин тому +4

      so ridiculous that they cant take their "perfect" book as is.

  • @DCox87
    @DCox87 6 годин тому +6

    The glorious TRUTH prevails. Another outstanding video, Mr. B.

  • @BluStarGalaxy
    @BluStarGalaxy 6 годин тому +16

    I don’t like prophets that cause droughts and kill people with fire. A very sinful position right? I just can’t help it.

  • @5h0rgunn45
    @5h0rgunn45 6 годин тому +20

    Despite protests to the contrary, God plays favourites big time. If you're one of his favourites (like Elijah or David) you can get away with murder.

    • @mr.goldenproductions_0143
      @mr.goldenproductions_0143 6 годин тому +2

      Literally. Also rape.

    • @sauron69447
      @sauron69447 5 годин тому +2

      @@5h0rgunn45 yep, God also allowed king Solomon to marry numerous wives despite that being considered a sin.

    • @Volleyball_Chess_and_Geoguessr
      @Volleyball_Chess_and_Geoguessr 5 годин тому

      @@sauron69447 Where does it say marrying many wives is a sin? It doesn't.

    • @Childfree334
      @Childfree334 4 години тому

      ​@@Volleyball_Chess_and_GeoguessrThank you for pointing out the blatant misogyny in the Bible. 😊

    • @martinelzen5127
      @martinelzen5127 4 години тому +1

      Or adultery. The baby paid the most for David and Bathsheba's sin. Or would have if it wasn't just another horrible fiction.

  • @MrFireman164
    @MrFireman164 2 години тому +4

    How is it that we believed this for so long and really smart people still do ? Are we really still just superstitious after all this time on this planet???

  • @martinelzen5127
    @martinelzen5127 4 години тому +2

    Thanks B! A great episode as usual!

  • @LadyhawksLairDotCom
    @LadyhawksLairDotCom 3 години тому +2

    I sang Mendelssohn's _Elijah_ with a chorus some 15 years ago and heartily wished we'd sung the German version because a lot of the lyrics were simply vile.

  • @26beegee
    @26beegee 5 годин тому +7

    Always wondered how believers know which stories are allegorical and which are literal. Nothing I ever saw reading the Bible clued me into the differences. Is there some unwritten rule we are to apply? 🤪

  • @tamjammy4461
    @tamjammy4461 4 години тому +1

    Ta Brandon. Keep up the good work 😀. I'll be off line for a while so won't be able to watch your new videos. Don't know how long it'll be for but ..... they'll give me something to look forward to when I get the opportunity. Meantime....take care of yourself .

  • @incgamer9792
    @incgamer9792 7 годин тому +11

    The more I became a dedicated bible reader when I used to be a Christian, the more I became the God of the Old Testament trying to rationalize his actions.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +6

      If one is willing to be honest and not use the "new covenant" as a copout, it becomes increasingly hard to justify this god the more you read.

    • @incgamer9792
      @incgamer9792 7 годин тому +5

      For real Brandon, your videos helped me escape and the peace of mind I felt cant be expressed with words.
      And the final blow to this faith came when I saw your series: God, An Anatomy.
      Much support much respect. Keep up and as always I wish this to grow big

    • @allenmitchell09
      @allenmitchell09 6 годин тому +4

      @@incgamer9792it’s funny all you hear about in church is how free in Christ you are, and how he’ll break your bonds, when that’s what you actually feel when you loose belief. I no longer have to feel guilty about my thoughts even. I no longer have to fear going to hell. It’s liberating.

    • @incgamer9792
      @incgamer9792 6 годин тому

      @@allenmitchell09 I know but it gets worse. One of the things that terrified me was Satan being released at the end of the thousand years of reign of Christ. Who knows, you might be one of the deceived and you will miss out on paradise

    • @allenmitchell09
      @allenmitchell09 6 годин тому +2

      @@incgamer9792 And, what if Allah is the true god and you’re pissing him off more and more worshiping Yahweh? Man, I think I’ll take my chances in what I understand to be reality. Which is all of them are fake AF!

  • @LoudHadida
    @LoudHadida 6 годин тому +4

    Brandon🎉🎉🎉 You are awesome. Keep up the excellent work. I also wish more people would read their Bible and contemplate on what they have read.

  • @joelkomieter6557
    @joelkomieter6557 7 годин тому +5

    Thank God for another episode

  • @tussk.
    @tussk. 2 години тому +2

    Isaiah 6: Isaiah sees the Lord sitting upon a throne, high and lifted up.
    That verse makes more sense now.

  • @gl3mmy903
    @gl3mmy903 2 години тому +3

    lol there’s this show called death note I watched when I was younger about a super smart teenager who gets a magical book with the power to kill people by writing their names on it and uses to commit mass genocide killing only, well mostly criminals.i find Elijah’s situation of killing 100s the same. Like no one in the fan base justifies that character but somehow it’s cool cause it’s from the Bible???it’s a crazy world we live in but hey happy Tuesday

  • @DavidRichardson153
    @DavidRichardson153 3 години тому +4

    Once again, the only superpowered fictional character who actually does and inspire good while also being created by Jewish authors is Superman.

  • @SeekingTruth2023
    @SeekingTruth2023 7 годин тому +11

    Haha, oftentimes the UA-cam notification "Yey! New Mindshift-video!!" reminds me, that's 4pm here and its time for a coffee ☕️☕️☕️🌞 with the Early Gang here and enjoy your video, Brandon!! 🤗

  • @joshuadala3508
    @joshuadala3508 6 годин тому +11

    Hi I live in Nigeria recently my school has addressed a rumor that people are saying there’s no God but all our school just said is that god created us and we should go to our counselor and forget that question thankfully one of my mates are having questions about god and their scared but I don’t know how to help them deconstruct also when I asked several of my classmates how they know the Bible is true they said they don’t know that they just believe it I really need to bring people to their senses and help the, to stop believing in this book what should I do

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +6

      Well without knowing your age or understanding your culture/environement, i'd say continue to learn more yourself. I and many like me have many resources on how to know the bible is indeed manmade. Just keep learning, and if honest and safe conversations can present themself with your classmates, then feel free to share what you are learning.

    • @BearMas
      @BearMas 6 годин тому +2

      I don't have anything but words of encouragement for you, my friend. I've never been religious and have never had to deal with anything like what you're going through, so I have no advice. But you are brave, you are clever, you are questioning and looking for answers, so you are on a good path already. Stay strong. ❤️

    • @monochromicornthetuna4256
      @monochromicornthetuna4256 5 годин тому +3

      The easiest thing to do is ask them to read the Bible from start to finish themselves and to not shy away from doubt. I deconstructed while in school too and it was because I’d been told all my life that God is all good, all powerful and all knowing but, when I actually read the book, nothing matched up to all I’d been told about God. Have casual conversations with your mates and, if they don’t want to listen, don’t force them.

    • @Volleyball_Chess_and_Geoguessr
      @Volleyball_Chess_and_Geoguessr 5 годин тому +1

      As much as we can try and think we can, we can't change the minds of most people. Just accept them for where they are in their journey and focus on yourself.

    • @KhingBassey
      @KhingBassey 4 години тому +2

      Focus on yourself more. Don't push anything in a hurry. I got married as a Christian. I carried my doubt for many years. Knowing in my pit that it wasn't true, but still performing for many years. Right now my wife knows where I stand. We are in a battle for how we will raise our son in this regard. It's tough enough on that front for me. I don't have much energy for trying to convince anyone else about my conviction. I am also in Nigeria btw

  • @FractalFire
    @FractalFire 3 години тому +2

    Super looking forward to your conversation with Britt Harltey. 😁

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      lol howd you figure it out, i dont think ive said her name?

    • @FractalFire
      @FractalFire 2 години тому +1

      @@MindShift-Brandon lol You didn't. I recently found her channel and have been ravanously watching them. She introduces herself the same way you did. 😁

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      Ha! Yes this Sunday. It was a great talk

  • @deborahcharles9906
    @deborahcharles9906 4 години тому +2

    James 4:17..."if anyone, knows the good they ought to do and doesn't do it; it is sin for them."
    I guess this only applies to humans....

  • @jlm5254
    @jlm5254 5 годин тому +3

    I hadn’t heard or read this story before. It’s like Pokémon, but with prophets and gods.

  • @irontaylor9992
    @irontaylor9992 5 годин тому +3

    Great Stuff Brandon keep up the Good work Brother

  • @survive323
    @survive323 7 годин тому +5

    A comment for the holy algorithm. Keep on keeping on Brandon!

  • @Nkosi766
    @Nkosi766 5 годин тому +5

    Another great episode. Elijah reminds me of Merlin

  • @arc-michaelr9580
    @arc-michaelr9580 Годину тому +1

    Nice! Let's just take the Bible and see what it says - perfect!

  • @xtina2189
    @xtina2189 7 годин тому +8

    I LOVE all the Thinkers in the comments. Your vids will always get a like and at least one comment from me.😁

    • @maggienewton8518
      @maggienewton8518 6 годин тому +3

      really outstanding comments compared to many such sites. So good to come to a place where resolution takes precedence over rage and pay backs. :)

    • @xtina2189
      @xtina2189 6 годин тому +1

      @@maggienewton8518 🤝

    • @Blue-5
      @Blue-5 6 годин тому +2

      If we werent thinkers we whouldnt be here watching this video 🤔
      We whould probably remain enslaved by religion 🤔
      So keep thinkin' and questioning , gotta keep those neurons firing 🤔🤔🤔

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +2

      Lucky to have everyone here!

    • @xtina2189
      @xtina2189 6 годин тому +3

      @@Blue-5 PREACH then Fam! Cosign 100%😀

  • @zacharylehocki
    @zacharylehocki 44 хвилини тому +1

    Oh whoa the book of Elijah has got lots of Theological problems! the inconsistences with Jesus`s teachings , apparently you can test God?, and God can forgive Elijah without a blood sacrifice? etc I think it just may be the most damming Theological book in the Bible. Great exposing it Brandon, very entertaining and funny at times!

    • @deb6252
      @deb6252 35 хвилин тому

      Exactly 💯

  • @kettei7743
    @kettei7743 7 годин тому +1

    Excited to the new podcast

  • @festeringboils3205
    @festeringboils3205 5 годин тому +4

    Wow, I guess that’s true. Elijah avoided the curse from the original sin, he neither died spiritually or physically. Unless he was literally reincarnated as John the Baptist, and then finally died? But Elijah said he was not John the Baptist? Man, whoever authored this religion is very confusing

  • @mrsmax3071
    @mrsmax3071 2 години тому +3

    1 & 2 Kings read like they were written by angsty teenaged boys.

  • @michaelsbeverly
    @michaelsbeverly 7 годин тому +13

    What about all the other people suffering?
    This never seems to be on the mind of believers, the rest of humanity who's not part of the "blessings."
    Which is why I always tell them I'll take hell, I don't want to be part of their exclusive group, I'll stick with the mass of humanity, you know, since unlike Jesus, I like humans.*
    * for the most part, lol

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +5

      always a myopic view of god saving that one widow son so he must "love everyone?" crazy indeed

    • @CatDaddyGuitar
      @CatDaddyGuitar 7 годин тому +5

      It's the same thing as them "praising God for saving the little girl in the horrific bus crash " as 43 other people died. SMH

    • @Blue-5
      @Blue-5 6 годин тому

      God is so ALL loving that he will punish anyone who's not part of his plan . But remember , he LOVES you , he just doesnt show it ! Im sure ! 🤡
      Dont mind that he's homophobic and racist , he loves everyone ! 🤡

    • @BearMas
      @BearMas 6 годин тому +2

      Thiiiis! As a person who has never been a part of religion and doesn't really have a good understanding of what it's like to feel/think this way, it is so alarming for me to hear how little they care about their fellow man while claiming to care the most. It's literally dehumanizing others from your out group so that you don't feel bad about what happens to them and only care about your in group. It's honestly a little scary.

    • @sundayoliver3147
      @sundayoliver3147 3 години тому

      @@BearMas Super good training for living under an authoritarian dictatorship.

  • @cyrenedomogalla5127
    @cyrenedomogalla5127 5 годин тому +3

    I once showed a Bible project video to a coworker who is Greek Orthodox. He immediately thought the interpretation of the text was incorrect. Says a lot about the Bible that even followers of it don't agree. Or that it can be twisted any way they please

  • @SeekingTruth2023
    @SeekingTruth2023 7 годин тому +6

    Wow. What a great video! First I was a bit disappointed. Only 21 minutes 😅
    But wow, although I know all your videos and learned so much from you already, there are always new things I hear, that amaze me greatly.
    I know many Christians who highly recommend the Bible Project and I saw several videos in the past. But never!! with the issues you pointed out. I was so gullible in the past. 🤦 Thank you for this enlightenment!
    And with regard to testing God, didn't Gideon test God with asking for the wet/dry animal skins? So yes, soooo inconsistent.
    Your videos let me recognize so many things! 👏👏

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +2

      Thanks for such detailed and kind feedback! glad you enjoyed it so

  • @MariusK1977
    @MariusK1977 Годину тому +2

    Something I never thought of until now. Is it possible that Elijah was real and killed by tornado lol

  • @aw9680
    @aw9680 2 години тому +2

    Elitism. Front to back. No one chooses to see that part.

  • @richarddurrant5067
    @richarddurrant5067 5 годин тому +3

    Good job Brandon keep up the good work

  • @TheHookahSmokingCaterpillar
    @TheHookahSmokingCaterpillar 53 хвилини тому +1

    Effectively 'God' is just as capricious as any Greek or Roman deity.

  • @SCP-SAM
    @SCP-SAM 6 годин тому +3

    Boom! Let's go!

  • @AGNOSTIC_incomprehensibleXIV
    @AGNOSTIC_incomprehensibleXIV 5 годин тому +4

    I keep asking Christians to definitively explain why if Jesus makes the rules, is baking a cake for our sins not as valid as dying for our sins... I never really get an answer. Usually just preaching, insults or both. No matter how they play it, the reality isn't that (in the Bible universe) Jesus died for our sins, he died because he felt like it for some reason. Perhaps to get attention? And he didn't even go to hell for eternity like what the real price of sin actually is. What gives?

    • @sundayoliver3147
      @sundayoliver3147 3 години тому +2

      I was in my fifties before I head that some branches of Christianity leave out substitutionary atonement-- the fancy theological name for "Jesus died for your sins". I had no idea that was even an option (though I was far past wanting to take it; I refused to become a communicant at age 11, because I knew on some level that I didn't want to sign on).

  • @kettei7743
    @kettei7743 7 годин тому +5

    As much as I love the BP, your points regarding the story of elijah against theirs is sound, given that God is not portrayed with one consistent character and in many times contraditory to what many consider basic morals.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +5

      I respect a great many things about Mackie actually and enjoy their art and skill, but yes its unfortunate they are not willing to show all sides of this god as it is clearly stated.

  • @CatDaddyGuitar
    @CatDaddyGuitar 7 годин тому +7

    Whoo hoo 🙌🏼🎉

  • @Jon45678
    @Jon45678 5 годин тому +6

    How dare you, Brandon, to consistently point out how when there is an opportunity in the Bible to show mercy, there is instead bloodshed and torture. Didn’t you know you’re only supposed to read the good parts or sugar-coat all the genocide? 😂

  • @CatDaddyGuitar
    @CatDaddyGuitar 7 годин тому +8

    I could have told them that leading with your anger brings about collateral damage and lack of control. God acts like an abusive, manipulative alcoholic.

  • @loophoop8626
    @loophoop8626 7 годин тому +2

    This is a nice video Brandom :)

  • @brucee6524
    @brucee6524 5 годин тому +3

    What always makes me scratch my head about stories like these is that they describe a death and resurrection that precedes Jesus but have very different reasons why the widow’s son and Lazarus and that little girl in Acts (not to mention the zombie parade in one or more of the gospels that I can’t recall atm) were resurrected than they give for Jesus.
    I mean, death and (bodily) resurrection are pretty important themes in Christianity but the role these specific accounts play in the faith are very, very different.
    5:56 Jesus taught using parables and allegedly predicted his death and resurrection through a metaphor of a specific temple where he was talking. I’m not sure why Christians insist on taking anything literally…

    • @martinelzen5127
      @martinelzen5127 4 години тому +2

      Be careful! Don't threaten their "resurrection guarantee"! ;-)

    • @brucee6524
      @brucee6524 4 години тому

      @@martinelzen5127 yeah they still can’t handle the fact that John 3:16 actually promises them that they won’t die, and “belief” in the context of that quote didn’t (yet) include a death and resurrection story because it hadn’t happened yet.

    • @sundayoliver3147
      @sundayoliver3147 4 години тому +1

      In my view, the nicest Christians are the ones who don't take anything literally, cherry-pick the loving bits in the Bible, and leave the rest alone. Which begs the question, why use that book in the first place?

  • @deb6252
    @deb6252 47 хвилин тому

    Here are examples of all the "problematic" issues. I am going to watch this many times. For some reason, Elijah, and your insight, is hitting extra hard. Sick to my stomach.

  • @yacaattwood2421
    @yacaattwood2421 6 годин тому +8

    Brandon, you’ve put your finger on God’s selectiveness in the story of Elijah and the widow - saving her and her son
    In the New Testament, I’ve always been bothered by the story of the massacre of the two-year old and younger male babies, that Jesus and his family escaped because Joseph was warned in a dream. Christians will justify this by saying, ‘well, Jesus had to survive to be a sacrifice for the world’.
    Really? The pain and grief of those OTHER families meant nothing?

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +5

      I did a video on the massacre of the innocents that you are referring to, and the excuses in the comments and reaction videos were wild!

    • @18471902
      @18471902 6 годин тому +2

      @yacaattwood2421 And obviously, god, being omnipotent, could easily have provided a way to save baby jesus without slaughtering other children.

  • @franciswalsh8416
    @franciswalsh8416 14 хвилин тому

    Never knew that Elijah killed so many people! Catholic School taught a familiarly sanitized version as well. Thanks again!!

  • @trythelight8319
    @trythelight8319 5 годин тому +2

    What I find interesting is that we *could* make a case that even if God is all loving and all knowing and fair, God - having risen Elijah with their relationship and unique circumstances in mind - is not all powerful. If someone were to claim Jesus’s sacrifice was necessary for a greater plan and Elijah was foreshadowing such a potential pathway to escape death and judgement via relationship; the fact it’s said that “Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life and nobody could come to the father except through him,” shows that God was able to use some power to make that one case. Whether bound morally, or by some supernatural physical constraints, God was operating within bounds despite some sort of boundlessness. He could be VERY powerful, but not ALL powerful.
    And if the Bible anywhere states that God is all powerful, it would contradict with this particular circumstance. And thusly, the Bible would be an unreliable source of information. If the Bible doesn’t say God is all powerful, then there’s potential for this God to exist. But it’d also then have to contend with all the other mythologies with non-all-powerful deities.

  • @fishinthesea3454
    @fishinthesea3454 7 годин тому +4

    You go boy!!

  • @Facialburn
    @Facialburn 7 годин тому +5

    I especially loved this vid! 🤘🏻 Exposing the lies, cherrypicking n hypocrisy from The Bible Project! 💯

  • @mr.goldenproductions_0143
    @mr.goldenproductions_0143 6 годин тому +5

    Oh those hypocrites! It's also not the first time you caught them in the act of retelling a biblical story in a more advantageous light for that barbaric god Yahweh! I remember that Elijah was one of the stories that played a big part in my deconversion as a Catholic. We were taught that murder is a mortal sin where you'd lose salvation, and then you read about this psycho who kills 450 men unjustly as they had already acknowledged that Yahweh was the one true god, only to be literally taken up into heaven....man what a load of bullocks!

  • @judethree4405
    @judethree4405 34 хвилини тому

    I think the Elijah work around that’ll maybe be used, would be that Elijah could have death defeated for him by God on the cross all the same, from the “eternal death” hell judgment aspect, and that the lack of physical death is a side issue. That Christ would still have to die to defeat eternal judgment “death,” or the second death. Of course there are other issues, like an all powerful god having hands tied to rules outside himself. Or another issue is, if physical death came into the world because of sin, and Christ died for Christian’s sins, then why do Christians still die? “… our Savior Jesus Christ, who has abolished death and brought life and immortality to light through the gospel” (2 Timothy 1:10).

  • @jxsanche
    @jxsanche 6 годин тому +2

    We need more videos like this, which highlight how Christianity is based on acute cherry-picking and no follower bothers reading the rest

  • @xtina2189
    @xtina2189 7 годин тому +8

    It's like christianity is encompassed by infinite layers of goofiness and the more you examine and probe, the goofier you find it to be. Could THAT be the reason they want you to just accept everything on faith and not actual evidence or knowledge?

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +6

      a closer look reveals too much!

    • @xtina2189
      @xtina2189 7 годин тому +3

      @@MindShift-Brandon kinda sheds a lil light on why it was illegal for slaves to read?...That same ol' Forbidden fruit of Knowledge... Huh.?🤦🏾‍♂️

    • @xtina2189
      @xtina2189 7 годин тому +2

      @@MindShift-Brandon 🧐😬

    • @maggienewton8518
      @maggienewton8518 6 годин тому +2

      "goofiness" oh that makes me smile, thanks!

    • @xtina2189
      @xtina2189 6 годин тому +1

      @@maggienewton8518 😁 🤜🤛

  • @BluStarGalaxy
    @BluStarGalaxy 7 годин тому +13

    So if we cut up a bull and put it on an alter, called down the power of Yahweh, and nothing happens what is our next move? According to the Bible if a god doesn’t show up we can start joking that he is traveling or sleeping.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  7 годин тому +5

      This is a major point! the example it sets for us is that the god that doesnt show up isnt real and its fine to not believe. ok then

    • @BluStarGalaxy
      @BluStarGalaxy 7 годин тому +4

      @@MindShift-Brandon Something… Something. Don’t test god.
      Christians then ignore all the times when Biblical characters test god.

    • @dasbus9834
      @dasbus9834 6 годин тому +2

      I wonder why this isn't a more frequent response to the problem of divine hiddenness 🤔
      "why does God never show up?" - "well he has some urgent matters to attend to that require his full attention" 😏

    • @BluStarGalaxy
      @BluStarGalaxy 6 годин тому +1

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@dasbus9834 That throne seat in heaven isn’t going to keep itself warm.

  • @elkeism
    @elkeism Годину тому

    Woah! the wording is very ambiguous regarding whether he raised the dead.In his successor Elisha's story the wording is definitive.

  • @thing1thing2themediamaniac43
    @thing1thing2themediamaniac43 3 години тому +2

    How many people grew up reading Frank E. Perretti? He's like The Tom Clancy/Stephen King of The Christian Literature World. I grew up reading THIS PRESENT DARKNESS and PIERCING THE DARKNESS. Two of my all time favorite Christian books. Even as a little kid, while the books entertained me for hours when my parents would read them to me or I would read them to myself. In the back of my mind I would always ask myself why does GOD limit himself to depending on the prayers of his saints when it comes to thwarting the plans of Satan and his armies and their human agents? God doesn't need our prayers, but his Angel Armies, which VASTLY OUTNUMBER Satan's Armies of Fallen Angels. God's Angel Armies CAN'T DO ANYTHING WITHOUT THE PRAYERS OF CHRISTIANS And more often than not God's plans are thwarted and Satan triumphs. IT'S HORRIBLY INEFFICIENT AND STUPID that God if he exists chooses to operate this way when he doesn't have to.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      whoa! major flashbacks. i think i read every single one!

  • @MrAndrewpederson
    @MrAndrewpederson 4 години тому +2

    Oh buddy. I heard the followup on the prophets being killed by the sword but it was not good. It was a christian nationalist pastor. He pulled his actual sword out and said that he was waiting for god to tell him to do the same to his enemies... By that he meant liberals or anyone who didn't agree with him... and he was swinging the sword around while he said it. This was a few months ago at an event I played drums for.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  2 години тому +1

      holy shit on one hand, on the other i am not surprised in the least.

  • @jon.skeptischism
    @jon.skeptischism 6 годин тому +2

    Great as usual. Got any merch in the works? My wallet is ready.

    • @MindShift-Brandon
      @MindShift-Brandon  6 годин тому +2

      Ha! Too kind. Idk man. I always think about it but havent pulled the trigger

    • @aaron_thatsmyname
      @aaron_thatsmyname 6 годин тому +2

      @@MindShift-Brandon Do it!

  • @ambassadorofconciliation
    @ambassadorofconciliation 6 годин тому +2

    I love the scriptures. How christians misinterpret and and misrepresent/malign God drives me nuts.

  • @kriegmesserdclxvi2833
    @kriegmesserdclxvi2833 4 години тому +2

    All this would be so unnessesary if Yahwehists simply acknowlege the fact that while he claims to be a great guy, he's more of a, well, let's just say Loki kind of god.

    • @martinelzen5127
      @martinelzen5127 4 години тому +1

      No one who looks at things objectively could describe the OT god as anything other a monster.