The voices you hear aren't ghosts. It's you recalling memories from your past. There were supposed to be memory voices at Arthur's grave too, but that caused quite a number of players to get spooked then commit suicide by jumping off the rockface.
To me both bad endings where Micah kills Arthur were more bullshit than just sad, while the good ending where he dies from TB was just sad. Either way, his death was indeed heartbreaking...
I am not embarrassed to say that I cried throughout this entire mission, with Arthur looking at the sun rise and dying. The saddest moments in my gaming life
I finished the main story three days ago and the epilogue two days ago. I am still in deep thoughts, cried myself to sleep the same night as I finished the story, I didn't react more then being teary as I finished it, it came later, several hours after as I wrote, I don't know what to do with myself right now, I have even lost interest in any other activites I do besides gaming, even feel like not wanting to eat
Jessica Ödegaard just go back when he was alive, then skip the missions and just play as him as long as you want. I went back to episode 3-4 don’t remember anymore where the camp was full.
i was so upset as well, especially when they killed his horse and when he closed the horses eyes that did it for me... we put a lot of time into the game and we fell in love with a lot of these characters
A D I played last weekend the Moment where the horse and Arthur die and it fucked me up so much that I start to play it again from the beginning extreeem slow I cannot get over it that he died
@@mussicanttakegreece7296 and I think Dutch realized his wrong in the end, in a strange way, you could see the pain in his eyes during that scene and in the mission American Venom
Can we appreciate Micah's voice actor performance? I mean, no character in gaming managed to elicit so much and deep hatred from players- his actor really nailed his role
Absolutely! I despise the Micah character, but every video of the voice actor I’ve seen indicates he’s a super nice guy in real life. That’s true talent- to elicit such a reaction out of thousands upon thousands of fans.
@@triumphantsam for real Micah voice actor was soooo good him begging Dutch to come with him it just made him look so desperate and a cowardice rat idk how someone could nail it so well
They didn't really have much of a choice story wise for the sequel because then they'd have to hunt down Arthur and Arthur isn't mentioned in the first game. I'd personally love to see a remastered Red Dead Redemption 1.
@@templar273 that wouldnt have the emotional impact though. Rdr2 has Arthur go through everythings, and him living wouldnt give that emotion the game had the entire time
When i first played red dead redemption 2 I was mad that the main character wasn’t John at first but then I built up this passion for Arthur. Arthur’s death is the only time in a video game where I’ve actually cried my eyes out
But then after Arthur's death there's a 2nd chapter of the game where you play as John..didn't that surprise you ? it's still what you wanted initially
I got the ending where Arthur dies on that cliff watching the sunset, which as sad as it was, I think it was the best ending.... Also who lost their shit and cried a little when Arthur said goodbye to his dying horse ?
I was so upset about the horse I full on rage killed those pinkertons.. And the Arthur died too and I was crying and my mum turned up like wtf..?, 😭😂 It was so sad
I decided to get my honor all the way on the evil side so when The gunshot happened it scared the crap out of me. I thought he was just going to aim the gun and leave
Same. I'm just gonna say this. Im really happy about the ending I got. Through the entire game I kept seeing the wolf. And the wolf represents the devil or just evil or bad. And at the ending I got the stag Ending along with the sunset mountain. And the Stag represents the good and ' heaven '. So in the end, I feel like that it really says much. And how all of his (well, part of his life but whatever) life he was haunted or driven or surrounded by evil and how in the end he finally found peace. And that part really made me cry ngl Honestly, this was the first game that ever made me cry and it's probably the best one I ever played.
I just finished Arthur Morgans story and…Ive never been in such tears over a character in any movie, game there ever was…Thank you Arthur for giving me hours of happiness. God never knew a character from a video game would be one of the people I look up to. Rest in peace Arthur Morgan.
Iam so glad that we are not alone in the depth of feeling that this part of the game brings out in us all, I've been gaming a long time but the scene where Arthur is murdered by the Rat 🐀 Micha and Dutch sort of let's it happen really got to me, Arthur's Epitaph ought to be (l gave you everything I had Dutch)with out doubt the saddest moment in my gaming experience 💔 love to you all Pards.
Hello my fellow gamers, lve a serious Question for you all, when PS1came out long time ago now Did anyone play Syphon Filter there were 3games, l still have all three and iam going to play them again, the graphics are excellent for the time these games were released, along with Solid Snake 1 and 2being a double disc help me please 😀.
Seems that you are on your own làd, shame cos I know some of them you older gamers must have played them ,Don't mean to pee anyone off and I know that Syphon Filter is not a western, its just a really good game by the by lve just started chapter 3 again and i can't remember robbing so many wagons and stage coaches killing 15 drivers and guards just to watch Professor Bell half kill the bounty killer you captured alive then the poor one sod electrifies his self 😉 wife and I couldn't stop laughing and not get paid for the cool job you did you have to smile eh, Arthur Morgan is my hero,
ever since i started seeing the black wolf in arthurs visions I started going high honor because it really felt like all the dark things were the wolf and it symbolized my death. As it got closer and closer I started thinking more and more about my actions playing as him, which led me to play for high honor. Rockstar just did an amazing job with this game.
I've never had such a video game relationship as I did with Arthur. (edit): its been a year and a half since i made this comment, and i just have to say i appreciate the 700+ likes, thats a record for me! you guys are really cool for that, i hope all of you have a good life
I laugh how many times I had the same thoughts and said the same things as Arthur did some times I said the same reply as him out loud at the same time. I have never been so similar to a character in a game in my life.
charles arthur and hosea are probably the best people in the gang, charles will always ride with arthur and trusts arthur the most and hosea kept the gang together
I miss the gang when it was whole. I miss people like Lenny, Hosea, Tilly, Reverend, all those people. I know it’s just a game with a fictional group of criminals, but they really felt like an extension to my existing family.
The true ending is him peacefully passing on the cliff as the sun rises. Shows his literal rise above it all. Best story of all time and best written character ever
@@spiceredtrooper9644 But strange man makes custom music himself for every video he makes, and actually spends time to decode the secrets in the game. This guy just walked up to a place and made a 13 minute video out of it. He only has a patreon apart from the money he makes off his videos, so I think he deserves it.
Dutch knew he fucked up when that dialogue happened, you could tell he realized he fucked up. Looking down at his oldest friend dying, he realized he had killed his truest friend besides Hosea. And then he knew, that he had fucked up. He just didn't want to face facts or deal with the guilt, that's why he walked off. He didn't know what to say, it was too late to do anything.
They have to make a prequel when Arthur was a young man and joining up with Dutch and Hosea and just leaving Mary for the first time so much history to be told Arthur Morgan was the best character in gaming history.
Kaiden Flett was to be fair they would have to since the Wild West got tamed by the time you play as jack. So it’s either another prequel but maybe you play as Dutch. Or dead franchise
It still puts a tear in my eye watching how selfish Dutch stands there listening to his son dying on the floor and all he can do is wimper away like a coward still makes me angry. RIP Arthur Morgan
Unfortunately you couldn't interact with Arthur at the grave. I wish that John would have said something like You were my best friend at the end, or, thank you for what you have done
There is a semi-interaction if you donate to that veterans memorial thing in Saint Denis. They say they'll put Arthur's name as a donor when the building is complete. If you go back as John and inspect the donors list he says something along the lines of 'Arthur Morgan... Hello, old friend.'
I like the good ending when Arthur crawled to see the sun rise before he died, and after that seeing the deer (his spiritual animal) with (what I think) a happy face telling that he gets what he wants, a death with he's redemption by helping Morgan having a opportunity to live happy. (I drop many man tear in that moment)
@@camdonking1919 daaamn, reading that became even deeper. I have talked with the blind man twice with Arthur, it was kind of true what he said but now when I actually reading it now... Finished the story three days ago
The goodbye scene with Abigail and sadie fucking hurt and that life at the end what he says "I tried,and in the end, i did" it fucking broke me and when he crawled to the sunset i just continue to break like damn
watching Arthur deteriorate was heart breaking. And then, seeing him on that cliff, fighting for words, it really broke me. Arthur seemed like a family member to me. When he was sort of recounting his life, saying “I tried in the end” I was sobbing. I believe the wolf in the end scene was representing Arthur crossing over into the afterlife, hence the reason it’s slowly walking away. Arthur really was a Wolf. He was strong willed and always kept the battle going. Rest In Peace, Arthur. 🥺
Omg that's fax bro was in the same position as you tears everywhere when Arthur was in the ground with Dutch behind him as soon as Arthur got up to the cliff to watch the sunrise I lost my shit lol
I feel like it would’ve been interesting if Arthur had dropped something, like the gun that was left there, and when John comes back and picks it up it triggers a cutscene where John almost starts crying but then puts the gun in his “Personal” and it’s like one of them Legendary guns
That line…..your my brother! I know…..it makes me cry every fucking time man. I wish we could have movies now days that had 1/100th of the story telling and character development that this game series does. It truly is heartbreaking and awe inspiring
Arthur even on that fishing want to kill the Milton but Jack is near and probbably don't wont to shoot him or just decided to leave them in last second ...find that scene on youtube and check Arthur's right hand, he try to grab a revolver
Yeah I have to sit down. I literally can’t *stand* it. Okay the only joke is. My life. That’s why I’m sat on this beach waving. 90% *sure* (shore) I should just drink bleach
LMFAO 1 I'm pretty sure everyone got low honor level when they first play and 2 doesn't that suck for you dw that doesn't stop people from watching him cause no one cares what you think😂😂😂😂😂@ClodBlossom
@@liamn8669 Dutch teamed up with Micah in the epilogue because he knew Arthur was right about Micah being the traitor. So Dutch teams up with Micah to Kill him in the end.
Uhm when I completed the game and went with John on the cliff that's not how Arthur died, for me, Arthur caught Micha and Micha and Dutch ran off, and Arthur sat against a cliff wall, and died there, no one shot him or anything, he just died quietly and sadly
@@Scarycute13 thats the low honor ending when you choose the chest. there are 4 endings in total. good and bad honor at chest choosen also john choosen.
After he died, i finished the game and then stopped for over a year. IT hit me harder then the Hughes death in FMA, now on my second play through I have modded the game so Arthur can go anywhere in the game.
Michael Bacan when you have high honor and you help john you get the deer and you die from tuberculosis but when you have low honor and you help john micah shoots you.
As I stood on the cliff as John, the slow, haunting whistling came up with no music. That along with the sound of the wind, and the sun far off and glowing in the storm clouds and it was was a long, melancholy moment. There was even a deer on a distant cliff, reminding me of Arthur's recurring dream of the buck as he became more and more sick. Maybe just good coincidental timing for the soundtrack and all the other things, but even if so, the whole thing was perfect. Around the corner of the the end of the path, just beyond the little lower ledge where Arthur likely died at, was a faint rainbow stretching down into the valley below. Again, perhaps just a quirk of timing for the atmospherics, but still, perfect. I'm glad I went back as John.
I had maxed out honor, so my Arthur died watching the sun rise over the mountains. Was a grown man, I cried. What an incredible game and what an experience... And when I returned as John, a bald eagle was perched above where he died and flew away. It was beautiful and I feel even more lucky knowing that it was truly random that it was there for me...
I somehow hadn't heard that interaction where Arthur describes how he wants his grave (Hosea's is so sad too) and it's so touching and makes my heart break all over again. It's just great that they all were honored the way they wanted. I really wish more dedications/throwbacks to characters and past events had been added in the epilogue; definitely more dialogue, like have John react/say something at Arthur's grave, have more faint ghostly dialogue at different areas, maybe flashbacks, etc. It would've truly added more impact. Just feels wrong otherwise, when he doesn't react at all; maybe hearing John's inner thoughts (as opposed to him saying stuff aloud) would've added so much more.
What Happens If John Marston Visits The Cliff Where Micah Killed Arthur In Red Dead Redemption 2?
Love ur vids ur the best
I did not get shot in the head
Where is Hosea buried in red dead redemption 2 ??
The voices you hear aren't ghosts. It's you recalling memories from your past. There were supposed to be memory voices at Arthur's grave too, but that caused quite a number of players to get spooked then commit suicide by jumping off the rockface.
Mrbossfnothing
Arthur dying was one of the saddest moments in my gaming history
For me: Arthur > John
To me both bad endings where Micah kills Arthur were more bullshit than just sad, while the good ending where he dies from TB was just sad.
Either way, his death was indeed heartbreaking...
dont forget the "thank you" moment with your horse
Gabriel Tamburini keep playing as john
Micah never killed Arthur. Tuberculosis did
My Arthur had almost 100% of his honor so he died looking at the sun. It was lonely, but still beautiful. Rest In Paradise, Cowboy.
Arthur:gunslinger john:cowboy
That is correct
It matters on how much honor you have
@@trunks8576 I know
@@SparkleAndLearn do you tho 🤡🤡
@@justincook170 mmk
"Literally nothing happens so I felt the need to make a 14 minute video to tell you nothing happens."
james allee or to just kick us in the gut and remind us of what happens to Arthur.
Clickbaiter
Jimmy Jams gotta earn money somehow
Facts g
Jimmy Jams thanks for letting me know wether I’d be wasting my time or not homie 👍🏽
I am not embarrassed to say that I cried throughout this entire mission, with Arthur looking at the sun rise and dying. The saddest moments in my gaming life
Sad when the horse dies too
Same
i probaly wouldve cried too if i didnt knew everything before even playing the game
same
@@johnnyray4217 why you can just put your sadle on your other horse you dont care about
Red dead 1 - I don’t wanna play as jack I wanna play as John
Red dead 2 - I don’t wanna play as John I wanna play as arthur
Slurrzz I don’t want to play as Niko I wanna play as Roman
Slurrzz that’s how you know the game was good. They made you give a shit. The story made you care.
@@AlbeyAirtolets go bowling
We grew attached to Arthur
Red dead 3 - I don't wanna play as Arthur i wanna play as uncle
I was depressed for two days after Arthur died, it was like a member of my family died
I finished the main story three days ago and the epilogue two days ago. I am still in deep thoughts, cried myself to sleep the same night as I finished the story, I didn't react more then being teary as I finished it, it came later, several hours after as I wrote, I don't know what to do with myself right now, I have even lost interest in any other activites I do besides gaming, even feel like not wanting to eat
I cried for a week
Jessica Ödegaard just go back when he was alive, then skip the missions and just play as him as long as you want. I went back to episode 3-4 don’t remember anymore where the camp was full.
i was so upset as well, especially when they killed his horse and when he closed the horses eyes that did it for me... we put a lot of time into the game and we fell in love with a lot of these characters
A D I played last weekend the Moment where the horse and Arthur die and it fucked me up so much that I start to play it again from the beginning extreeem slow I cannot get over it that he died
I still haven’t got over that Dutch just left Morgan there...
Dutch knew that Arthurs fate was sealed, he died looking at the sunset instead of on the back of a horse
@@flamedab bruh k
@@mussicanttakegreece7296 and I think Dutch realized his wrong in the end, in a strange way, you could see the pain in his eyes during that scene and in the mission American Venom
yeah,he should have just cured his TB real quick
@@flamedab that’s why he shot Micah at the end..for some sort of redemption
Can we appreciate Micah's voice actor performance? I mean, no character in gaming managed to elicit so much and deep hatred from players- his actor really nailed his role
Absolutely! I despise the Micah character, but every video of the voice actor I’ve seen indicates he’s a super nice guy in real life. That’s true talent- to elicit such a reaction out of thousands upon thousands of fans.
I saw this funny video of the actor at a con. He hates Micah, too.
@@triumphantsam for real Micah voice actor was soooo good him begging Dutch to come with him it just made him look so desperate and a cowardice rat idk how someone could nail it so well
Absolutely. He was a character from the get go you didn't like. If I had my way I would of left him in that jail
Abby from The Last of Us 2 did
Arthur was actually one of the best game protagonists I've ever played seriously could not accept them killing off such a character
He had to be ded or else the first game wouldn’t make any sense
@@azeezkhan6950 i mean, they could've sent arthur to australia or smtg instead of killing him
They didn't really have much of a choice story wise for the sequel because then they'd have to hunt down Arthur and Arthur isn't mentioned in the first game. I'd personally love to see a remastered Red Dead Redemption 1.
@@templar273 that wouldnt have the emotional impact though. Rdr2 has Arthur go through everythings, and him living wouldnt give that emotion the game had the entire time
@@Gyropop exactly. People remember tragic endings more than the happier ones.
Arthur didn't get killed by Micah In my playthrough, he died by tb while looking at the sunrise
Your game is broke
@@nikkitrask2086 no, he just got the good ending
Me too my first playthrew haven't actual done it any other way
I think it depends on your honor level that how you will die.
Cinema _Games its cause you got the high honor ending
Took years to kill the Legendary Rat.
Legendary? No he’s just a rat not legendary he doesn’t deserve that title
You mean a poor rat
1 Star Micah 🐀
You have entered a legendary animal location
Imaispoild
When i first played red dead redemption 2 I was mad that the main character wasn’t John at first but then I built up this passion for Arthur. Arthur’s death is the only time in a video game where I’ve actually cried my eyes out
Weren't we all like that mate?
Like someone in another comment said
Played the game waiting and wishing to play john, left crying wanting to stay as arthur
TRUE BRO
But then after Arthur's death there's a 2nd chapter of the game where you play as John..didn't that surprise you ? it's still what you wanted initially
I shot Micah's corpse at least 50 times
I got the ending where Arthur dies on that cliff watching the sunset, which as sad as it was, I think it was the best ending.... Also who lost their shit and cried a little when Arthur said goodbye to his dying horse ?
Gareth Pritchard so did I
I was so upset about the horse I full on rage killed those pinkertons.. And the Arthur died too and I was crying and my mum turned up like wtf..?, 😭😂 It was so sad
@Philip Snegirov it's sister but I enjoy and share the sentiment 😜😁
Oh God, I cried harder at that horse part then the dying watching the sunset death I got too. 😭
I thoght I was the only one
Crazy how Lenny and Hosea ended up being buried together just like they were saying..
Tbh it feels fake trust me when i say micah wouldnt leave arthur there
@Hello Halogen micah do be into some sick shit tho...
Foreshadowing
I was waiting for someone to say this
@@peepeebandit he doesnt if you play the game like a scumbag and have low honor he shoots him in the face
Not used to Arthur getting shot. My Arthur died as peacefully as he could’ve looking at the sunrise 🥺
mine did too🤗
Me too but it depends on your honner
I decided to get my honor all the way on the evil side so when The gunshot happened it scared the crap out of me. I thought he was just going to aim the gun and leave
Same. I'm just gonna say this. Im really happy about the ending I got. Through the entire game I kept seeing the wolf. And the wolf represents the devil or just evil or bad. And at the ending I got the stag Ending along with the sunset mountain. And the Stag represents the good and ' heaven '.
So in the end, I feel like that it really says much. And how all of his (well, part of his life but whatever) life he was haunted or driven or surrounded by evil and how in the end he finally found peace. And that part really made me cry ngl
Honestly, this was the first game that ever made me cry and it's probably the best one I ever played.
Coyote * but totes agree
I just finished Arthur Morgans story and…Ive never been in such tears over a character in any movie, game there ever was…Thank you Arthur for giving me hours of happiness. God never knew a character from a video game would be one of the people I look up to. Rest in peace Arthur Morgan.
Iam so glad that we are not alone in the depth of feeling that this part of the game brings out in us all, I've been gaming a long time but the scene where Arthur is murdered by the Rat 🐀 Micha and Dutch sort of let's it happen really got to me, Arthur's Epitaph ought to be (l gave you everything I had Dutch)with out doubt the saddest moment in my gaming experience 💔 love to you all Pards.
Hello my fellow gamers, lve a serious Question for you all, when PS1came out long time ago now Did anyone play Syphon Filter there were 3games, l still have all three and iam going to play them again, the graphics are excellent for the time these games were released, along with Solid Snake 1 and 2being a double disc help me please 😀.
Seems that you are on your own làd, shame cos I know some of them you older gamers must have played them ,Don't mean to pee anyone off and I know that Syphon Filter is not a western, its just a really good game by the by lve just started chapter 3 again and i can't remember robbing so many wagons and stage coaches killing 15 drivers and guards just to watch Professor Bell half kill the bounty killer you captured alive then the poor one sod electrifies his self 😉 wife and I couldn't stop laughing and not get paid for the cool job you did you have to smile eh, Arthur Morgan is my hero,
true bro
🥺
When Arthur said “I gave you all I had” idk why that got me hella sad
Because Arthur trusted Dutch's every decision and supported even if he doubted him
Saddest part for me.
"I gave you all I had.."
*Dutch leaves him*
Yeah, same & it's the way his voice trails after he says "I did"...
My favorite part was that cuz dutch takes his foot off arthurs hand and realizes his big mistake
Because “Dutch” Cant Get his Plans Right
My Favorite rockstar character will always be Arthur Morgan he's story was perfect
RDR2 is a story telling masterpiece!
Him and Trevor from gta5! 2 faves
Thank you son, now leave, Dutch’s attitude is crazy.
@@user-ui4si7yj4f but... your Dutch
@@matthewl3129 oh I’m very sorry son! I know who sent that message. I need to have a talk with Arthur.
When Arthur got tuberculosis I started giving him vacations after every mission I completed. Lol ik its weird
I did something along the same lines, On my 3rd play through. I really enjoy playing as Arthur Morgan
*Coronavirus has joined the chat.*
On behalf of aurthur. I salute you
a true patriot unbanned account what?
Same 😂
ever since i started seeing the black wolf in arthurs visions I started going high honor because it really felt like all the dark things were the wolf and it symbolized my death. As it got closer and closer I started thinking more and more about my actions playing as him, which led me to play for high honor. Rockstar just did an amazing job with this game.
Dutch: I have a plan
*everyone dies one by one*
Dutch: I have a plan
*commits suicide* in red dead 1.
True
John: you always have one
@@jxydvn-xd-4205 His Ghost: I have a plan
Dutch just pretending he have a plan, but in the end he fucked up
Arthur dying is the saddest thing that ever happened in my gaming life
then u have to play telltale walking dead season 1
Same
If he didn't die man... :(
I cried when arthur died it made so damn sad
Dont play Final Fantasy 7 Crisis Core.
When Arthur almost dead why doesn't Arthur drink a health cure? Works every time.
Its a painkiller not an antibiotic. Also it takes six to nine months to cure it.
Rohan Rasool R/Wooosh
It was tuberculosis you special child
Satchel is gone
You can't cure it . Even though you don't play the mission where he spits in you face if you don't play the mission you still have tb
Abigal shooting Mr.Milton was the best moment of the game
I've never had such a video game relationship as I did with Arthur. (edit): its been a year and a half since i made this comment, and i just have to say i appreciate the 700+ likes, thats a record for me! you guys are really cool for that, i hope all of you have a good life
I laugh how many times I had the same thoughts and said the same things as Arthur did some times I said the same reply as him out loud at the same time. I have never been so similar to a character in a game in my life.
@@High2GetBy at the cafe early in the morning while going to work i was like " Get out the damn way " !
@@High2GetBy same
Connor Black I miss him.
@@darkchild5233 🤣👏😂
My favourite dead characters:
Arthur
Lenny
Hosea
SHoE Berci what about John
Ve_Ex Sean Maguire
Is John here
Ve_Ex ur a bandwagon u don’t even know his name *Sean Maguire*
My favourite is Kieran.
Charles is an absolute lad i didn’t realise how good he was to everyone until I played the story again
Charles is a pearl
Would love to play as Charles
charles arthur and hosea are probably the best people in the gang, charles will always ride with arthur and trusts arthur the most and hosea kept the gang together
Love Charles top bloke
Best mission was when he was a boxer
I miss the gang when it was whole. I miss people like Lenny, Hosea, Tilly, Reverend, all those people. I know it’s just a game with a fictional group of criminals, but they really felt like an extension to my existing family.
same
The true ending is him peacefully passing on the cliff as the sun rises. Shows his literal rise above it all. Best story of all time and best written character ever
It actually signifies the Dawn of John's story
When you have a good honor that happens but if u have low honor Micah just kill u.
This literally could have been a 45 second video.
Exactly. But bossftw is stupid
But strange man's videos are long too and the words are there for like 10 seconds.
@@legoreddead dont watch him then.
yeah, but money
@@spiceredtrooper9644 But strange man makes custom music himself for every video he makes, and actually spends time to decode the secrets in the game. This guy just walked up to a place and made a 13 minute video out of it. He only has a patreon apart from the money he makes off his videos, so I think he deserves it.
Arthur: I gave you all I had....
Dutch: I...
*I HAD A PLAN*
Nah he’d be like... We... We just need money
@@Trashdumpsterrrr Where's the loyalty I just need more time
Dutch knew he fucked up when that dialogue happened, you could tell he realized he fucked up. Looking down at his oldest friend dying, he realized he had killed his truest friend besides Hosea. And then he knew, that he had fucked up. He just didn't want to face facts or deal with the guilt, that's why he walked off. He didn't know what to say, it was too late to do anything.
Nah he’d just be like Give me time, brother
"UGHH THE DOUBTS!"
the fact they have two different ending cinematics to show how well you lived is terrifying
They actually have 4. Low/high honor and help John, or low/high honor and get money.
Arthur dies a hundred times in during the story
Nobody cries.
Arthur dies once with dramatic music
Half the population cries.
Well that’s just because that death is permanent there is no respawn
In free roam he is just critically injuring himself I guess.
It's like dying in almost any other video game. It's not canon. Only the true story death is canon.
More than half the population i guess
Because you know There’s a Respwan
Arthur in heaven:
Heh heh found ya lennay!
Bruh lol When he was drunk at Valentine
That actually makes me happy, I read this in Arthur's voice
LENNY MAH BOAH!!!
That was my favorite mission lol
"LEEEEENNNEEEEHHHHH....WHERE ARE YA LEEEENNNEEEHHHHH"
Micah didn't kill Arthur
Arthur died of TB
Don't kill the spirit of Arthur Mogan
Nithish kannan nah he dies by TB if you get the high honour ending (the one where he dies watching the sunset) and dies low honour if Micah kills him
Not to be confused with Arthur Morgan
I had high honour death
Thanks now i dont know if micah killed arthur or TB the tittle spoiled me
It depends the honor you're in.
"Okay, so the reason i showed you guys that was to burn some time so we can get to that 10 min mark"
Yeah ikr. I was literally thinking the exact same thing
They have to make a prequel when Arthur was a young man and joining up with Dutch and Hosea and just leaving Mary for the first time so much history to be told Arthur Morgan was the best character in gaming history.
John 76 they wouldn’t make another prequel
Fax
Kaiden Flett was to be fair they would have to since the Wild West got tamed by the time you play as jack. So it’s either another prequel but maybe you play as Dutch. Or dead franchise
That game if to popular it can't just end there maybe u play a o Driscoll lmfao
@@TheFPSKingsGaming Or just another storyline with another gang during the same time period
The way Arthur want to die is exactly how he did in high honor ending.
First comment I’ve seen that actually connected the dots in that part of the video
“Revenge is a fools game”-Arthur Morgan
its actually "vengeance is an idiot's game"
My most favourite quote ever
TheNumbingScorpian 207 technically i told him that so it ain’t his saying
he only said that cause its what dutch taught him but i dont think he actaully thought that
Your goddamn right
It still puts a tear in my eye watching how selfish Dutch stands there listening to his son dying on the floor and all he can do is wimper away like a coward still makes me angry. RIP Arthur Morgan
He has a Plan..
He know that Arhurs faith was sealed. He would rather die looking at the sunset than at the back of a horse.
There's a different ending if he dies with high honor (I like the good ending better).
Mine too
Ya i agree
Everyone dislikes this video
4 different endings
I got that ending too. I watched all the endings, really glad I got this one
“As you can see, nothing happened. But to me, tHiS iS kInD oF iNtErEsTiNg”
Lmfao
😂😂😂😂
IKR
Unfortunately you couldn't interact with Arthur at the grave. I wish that John would have said something like
You were my best friend at the end, or, thank you for what you have done
Once you get 100% John will go to Arthur's grave and say his goodbyes
There is a semi-interaction if you donate to that veterans memorial thing in Saint Denis. They say they'll put Arthur's name as a donor when the building is complete. If you go back as John and inspect the donors list he says something along the lines of 'Arthur Morgan... Hello, old friend.'
You can't talk to a dead person idiot
Got low honor, fuckin got Harold godwinsoned. But I liked it when Arthur said "DAMN US BOTH!" It was like a roast from the 1890s.
Maaaan when Arthur is talking to Dutch by the cliff I just feel the pain in my chest :( I got too emotionally attached 😭😂
A pain in your chest, you might have tuberculosis, don't worry, you'll get treated. Unlike poor Arthur.
“ I gave you all I had Dutch” 😭
@@ogomez53og we ain't both gonna make it
I like the good ending when Arthur crawled to see the sun rise before he died, and after that seeing the deer (his spiritual animal) with (what I think) a happy face telling that he gets what he wants, a death with he's redemption by helping Morgan having a opportunity to live happy. (I drop many man tear in that moment)
The blind man does say "Paradise" awaits him
@@camdonking1919 daaamn, reading that became even deeper. I have talked with the blind man twice with Arthur, it was kind of true what he said but now when I actually reading it now... Finished the story three days ago
The goodbye scene with Abigail and sadie fucking hurt and that life at the end what he says "I tried,and in the end, i did" it fucking broke me and when he crawled to the sunset i just continue to break like damn
watching Arthur deteriorate was heart breaking. And then, seeing him on that cliff, fighting for words, it really broke me. Arthur seemed like a family member to me. When he was sort of recounting his life, saying “I tried in the end” I was sobbing. I believe the wolf in the end scene was representing Arthur crossing over into the afterlife, hence the reason it’s slowly walking away. Arthur really was a Wolf. He was strong willed and always kept the battle going. Rest In Peace, Arthur. 🥺
Omg that's fax bro was in the same position as you tears everywhere when Arthur was in the ground with Dutch behind him as soon as Arthur got up to the cliff to watch the sunrise I lost my shit lol
Wolf? What wolf? I saw a Deer when Arthur passed. Could be an Honor thing. Did you have low or high honor? I died with maximum high honour.
Well the coyote is a signal of bad honor, the deer is good honor.
i like jelly beans you like jellybeans?
The wolf is the representation of bad honor. The deer is the representation of good honor.
I died with High Honor. When I came as John an eagle was standing close, like the one on his grave when he dies with High Honor.
The irony of dutch not showing loyalty to Arthur when loyalty is all he preached about! The character development in this game is phenomenal
6:12 "Damn us both!"
-Arthur Morgan, A True Legend.
Yes.The greatest character ever made by Rockstar.
@@itsme-jane2492 true
I'm so glad I shot micah 7 times in the nuts in epilogue
@@Pinkugumi - he actually had something down there to shoot?
@@jacrispy3275 Ha! Lol! HE AIN'T GOT NO BALLS
If you cried when Arthur died
Like ❤️
Cried*
I did when i went sleeping
Outstanding move: I disliked and took his death like a man and he’s proud.
@@charlieboyanov4037 thanks ❤️
i actually didn't cry when arthur died
I feel like it would’ve been interesting if Arthur had dropped something, like the gun that was left there, and when John comes back and picks it up it triggers a cutscene where John almost starts crying but then puts the gun in his “Personal” and it’s like one of them Legendary guns
10:13 Hosea and Lenny get buried next to each other
Died the same day
😭😭😭😭😭
You came here for 8:25
Luiz Henrique thank you
Thank you
Thx
God bless
U r doing gods work
Leopold Strauss bassically killed Arthur morgan if you think about Leopold and Thomas downes
Yes
Always hated him
You right cause when you try to avoid the mission Leopold keeps bugging you about it until the game forces you to
Leopold is like me in real life lmao
Well Arthur did have the final say. We can argue all day about Leopold Strauss or Thomas Downs but at the end of the day, Arthur chose his fate.
That line…..your my brother! I know…..it makes me cry every fucking time man. I wish we could have movies now days that had 1/100th of the story telling and character development that this game series does. It truly is heartbreaking and awe inspiring
11:15 Come on man, Dutch made it up them rocks.. you just gotta have FAITH!!!
Jean Pierre Wehry he had a PLAN to get up those rocks
He came thair from Tahiti
He whent to get hes plans to clib using then
Exactly! If a man can travel 4 long hours by bus to taste some kid’s nuts.. then John can make it up them rocks. *HaVe SoMe GoDaMn FaItH!*
Do youi like Arthur Martson or Jhon Morgan?
When he died I cried and remembered that he taught jack how to fish 😢
Arthur even on that fishing want to kill the Milton but Jack is near and probbably don't wont to shoot him or just decided to leave them in last second ...find that scene on youtube and check Arthur's right hand, he try to grab a revolver
I used to think "why would I wear such a scruffy price of shit that author calls a hat" but now when im playing as John its the only thing I wear
its arthurs fathers hat
@@jimmilton7513 - sup, Jim?
6 year old piece not price arther not author
@@pugclan1602 - kid, it's "Arthur".
author? i dont think *Arthur* writes books...
Wait what? I never knew Micah could shoot Arthur. I've always gotten the good scene with him watching the sun.
Yea thats the low honer ending and doing help john go for the money is were Arthur gets stabbed and dies near camp
Why can't we just swap between John and Arthur in epilogue like you could in GTA
The story would not feel right to me
@@brutus5973 true but I would love it
Because he's dead lmfao
Because he died
@@Fernandes.Ferdinando He/She means that Arthur should've lived. There's no reason to kill the main character imo.
I can't stand watching arther wen he dies
May I? *_Stand unshaken?_*
I’ve played through it so much it doesn’t have as much effect on me... yeah it’s still sad but I’m practically immune lol
I can’t stand your grammar
Yeah I have to sit down. I literally can’t *stand* it. Okay the only joke is. My life. That’s why I’m sat on this beach waving. 90% *sure* (shore) I should just drink bleach
Ya I had to look away
I want nothing to do with MrBossFTW for getting the low honor ending
I got low honor to
LMFAO 1 I'm pretty sure everyone got low honor level when they first play and 2 doesn't that suck for you dw that doesn't stop people from watching him cause no one cares what you think😂😂😂😂😂@ClodBlossom
@@nonyabuisness990 my arthur didnt die with low honor
Nahh my Arthur was a outlaw turned hero
@@Kenixboe same here.
4:46
"I gave you all I had"
Damn that got me crying 🥲🥲🥲
MrBoss: “Arthur was buried.”
Also MrBoss 2 seconds later: “so why isn’t Arthurs body here?”
I laughed like two hours since i saw the comment
😂
Poor arther he was a great character in rdr2_ rest in peace buddy
In my version of Micah did not kill Arthur, but Arthur tossed a little further and died watching the sunset ...
You had good honor
The best ending with a high honor
Same.
Me too high honor wooo
Go to Saint Dennies and talk to everyone get that honor to max
The fact that arthur almost kills micah while dealing with tuberculosis is amazing
Without Dutch he would have shot micah
As a huge fan of this game, Arthur's death just really hits you hard...😔💔
" you're my brother"
IM SOBBING
Did anyone else see that when John arrives there is a deer (Arthur’s high honor animal)
True!
Its the sign of true redemption along with the sun rising up, the rains and thunders is a sign of a tragic end
But it can’t have anything to do with Arthur cause this guy got a low honour ending making the wolf his spirit animal.
short answer: nothing
Dutch in the end never trusted his long time friend and left him to die
On the contrary. In the very end there, he realized that Arthur was right, but knew it was too late to go back
Caleb Reid then why did he team up with Micah in the epilogue
@@liamn8669 Dutch teamed up with Micah in the epilogue because he knew Arthur was right about Micah being the traitor. So Dutch teams up with Micah to Kill him in the end.
Boi_Boi15 oh ok but why not kill him on the mountain he could have easily shot him
Liam N The mountain at the end of the game or the mountain where John went with Sadie to kill Micah (Epilogue)
I guess I liked Arthur more than most players. I came back here before John even got his guns back.
Respect. I'll give it to you, that's dedication.
JoeJitsu coming back here to see if I could find his body or something was the first thing I did after you get free roam with John,
Same arthur was one of the best characters in the game
@@emilygibbons3871 he was the best and micah was the worst
@@The-Listener yeah
I'm just curious as to why the hell you have low honor as Arthur.
What kind of man are you?
I had low honor on my second playthrough so I could see what happened because I heard there were different endings
StillBetta80 there are
I was given the freedom to live out my own cowboy fantasy as the guy who kills everyone so I has max low honor by chapter 3
@@SouthtownSnob you played through the entire game again just to see a slightly different ending cut scene?
Yeah idk why
I like how parents still say that it’s “ just a video game”
I've beaten the game 3 times. I never saw Arthur die that way and it breaks my heart all over again. I'm legit upset again.
he got the low honor ending, congrats on you for always having high honor for 3 times 👍
why you gotta do me like that, showing Arthur dying again i literally cry every single time
i started bawling as soon as i saw “ride” when we are in his last ride.
You can see the sadness in Arthur's eyes, and you can see the same with John
I left jhon marston so I could cut micah in the left eye
jhon marston?
@@svency8896 Lumbago
Too.much lumbago
six sillerz same
@@svency8896 he means jhon mharzton
When he said “He’s a rat..” to Dutch in the ending, I legit wanted to cry
fear me i got chills of crying just by reading your comment
I’m having my name changed to Arthur Morgan, Hell Yeah.
When I can,I will do that too
Betryal
when you go back to the old hideouts you don’t “hear ghosts of old gang members” john is listening to flashbacks or memories
Uhm when I completed the game and went with John on the cliff that's not how Arthur died, for me, Arthur caught Micha and Micha and Dutch ran off, and Arthur sat against a cliff wall, and died there, no one shot him or anything, he just died quietly and sadly
That's the high honour ending
The low honour ending is when you get shot in the face
Kelly Mireault that means u have high honor sis
Same here and he saw the sunrise
@@Aurora42424 I thought the low honor ending is where micah stabs Arthur and he dies face down in the dirt.
@@Scarycute13 thats the low honor ending when you choose the chest. there are 4 endings in total. good and bad honor at chest choosen also john choosen.
took the whole video to say nothing happens lol?
Typical mrbossFTW xD
Mr.ClickbaitFTW
Thanks
As he usually does
That's the status quo
The" ghosts " are John's memories
After he died, i finished the game and then stopped for over a year. IT hit me harder then the Hughes death in FMA, now on my second play through I have modded the game so Arthur can go anywhere in the game.
That ending didn't happen for me my animal was a deer and on mine micha never shoot him like if you had the same ending
Michael Bacan when you have high honor and you help john you get the deer and you die from tuberculosis but when you have low honor and you help john micah shoots you.
High honor Arthur is the only Arthur
@@deadman1151 thanks dead man didn't no
As I stood on the cliff as John, the slow, haunting whistling came up with no music. That along with the sound of the wind, and the sun far off and glowing in the storm clouds and it was was a long, melancholy moment. There was even a deer on a distant cliff, reminding me of Arthur's recurring dream of the buck as he became more and more sick. Maybe just good coincidental timing for the soundtrack and all the other things, but even if so, the whole thing was perfect.
Around the corner of the the end of the path, just beyond the little lower ledge where Arthur likely died at, was a faint rainbow stretching down into the valley below. Again, perhaps just a quirk of timing for the atmospherics, but still, perfect.
I'm glad I went back as John.
Dude shut up you talk to much
Christian Alexander no
@@christianchappell4193 and yet it’s all words and he didn’t say anything you sour pitiful excuse for a human
Bro it’s not that deep
we should thank charles for being respectful with arthur the whole game
I cryed my eyes out at the death scene 😭 respect and rest in paradise cowboy you will always be in our heart 😔
Just finished the game today and I’ve never cried so hard in a game best narrative in a game I’ve ever seen and please don’t fight me on this.
i just completed the game today
I cried while fighting Micah and wanted to say " YOU GODDAMN RAT" At the end
Shh let me tell u a secret...
Nothing happened
Dam You!!!!!!!!
*damn*
@@Vampire_Queen_Blood Damn us both!
I had maxed out honor, so my Arthur died watching the sun rise over the mountains. Was a grown man, I cried. What an incredible game and what an experience... And when I returned as John, a bald eagle was perched above where he died and flew away. It was beautiful and I feel even more lucky knowing that it was truly random that it was there for me...
Do you have high honor cause I went during the day and I saw a eagle on the end of the cliff and it just sat there
Chase Mooney either eagle or coyote
He had low honor in this. That's why you saw a wolf
Ya thats what I was saying I saw the eagle
cohen anderson coyote (small wolf)
Coyote guards grave for bad honor when arthur died and good honor when he dies an eagle guards it and you find the buck nearby
That would've been great if there was only 1 Pinkerton who snipes micah when Arthur gets suprised
Maybe it's a secret ending
YES PLEASE.THAT LIL RAT
Micah is working with the pilertons
I somehow hadn't heard that interaction where Arthur describes how he wants his grave (Hosea's is so sad too) and it's so touching and makes my heart break all over again. It's just great that they all were honored the way they wanted.
I really wish more dedications/throwbacks to characters and past events had been added in the epilogue; definitely more dialogue, like have John react/say something at Arthur's grave, have more faint ghostly dialogue at different areas, maybe flashbacks, etc. It would've truly added more impact. Just feels wrong otherwise, when he doesn't react at all; maybe hearing John's inner thoughts (as opposed to him saying stuff aloud) would've added so much more.