Thanks for the video MrBossFTW. Although I was there for the John Marston meeting Mayor Lemieux one and I must say, you really need to try to get these encounters with John instead of finishing these side missions as Arthur.
We need a game with Arthur Morgan as the main character as a young man. How he met Eliza and the birth of Issac would be great to see. Start it like Red Dead Revolver when he's a kid and progress chapter to chapter throughout his early life. Would love to be able to play as Arthur meeting Dutch for the first time. R* hit a home run with the character of Arthur and I feel if they gave him his own game it would probably be one of the best selling games ever. I'm not even gonna try to count the number of post I've seen of how people got so upset over Arthur's death. RIP Mr. Morgan.
They could still work John into it too since John and Arthur were the longest standing members of the Van der Linde Gang outside of Dutch and Hosea. Or we could get a game about Hosea and his life before meeting Dutch and both the early years of the Van der Linde's and Arthur and John.
They could let us follow both Arthur and Johns ascension into the gang, and it can end with the infamous black water Robbery. This time, there’s no redemption, so it’s Red Dead , Dawn of the Outlaws.
It's beautiful you can go through all of these as John, and see all of these people Arthur helped years ago. It's like Arthur's still alive through all these people who don't even know each other, like the Albert Mason and Charlotte, but they're all connected through Arthur. That's like real life right there. The people we touch are forever impacted, just as we are impacted by others. It's a never ending cycle that continues long after we're dead and gone.
@@wyattgoss6804 He has a point, most players back then would finish the mission completely, but some didn't as they payed attention more to the story. But It's also true that all players know now.
You must not have done that specific Mission with the wolves with Arthur, because that was the exact same location dialogue and everything if you do it as Arthur other than them talkin about author
Was I blind or did you miss or forget Charlotte? She won't have a blip on the map, but when you finish her storyline with Arthur and visit her with John, you'll have another unique and very nice conversation in memory of Arthur
Redoing these Arthur-missions as John is just a faster way to get John's Honor raise d, while sharing a bit of nostalgia for the memory of an old friend and brother.
If you do the first the veteran mission as aurthur but do the second one as John than hamish will say who is there and it will be a little conversation about aurthur for a second
@MrBossFTW Lol while I was going to find Micah's unique double-action revolver, I unintentionally passed through the camp from the first chapter in the snowy mountains. The kicker? I actually heard voice overs of a few of the characters saying their iconic lines from Chapter One. It was pretty terrifying, but sad at the same time.
Well Hamish dies in the 4th mission and Albert Mason gives up photography after like the 6th or 7th and you can do all these missions as Arthur if you want or leave some to do as John if you'd rather save some of these encounters for him
There's a couple stranger missions I'm saving for John JUST because I want a little remembrance for Arthur. Everyone seems to use the Wolf photo mission probably for that little bonus dialogue but I'm saving the last Eagle one hoping it gives a little added depth to Mason and Arthur's relationship
Fun Fact: if you complete every albert mason mission before you do the artists way, art museum mission, some of the painting will be replaced with albert masons photos, including one of Arthur, that does make me wonder, if you start the albert mason missions as john, finish them, and do the art exhibit mission, would it still be arthurs photo on the wall?
I didn't know you could do the stranger missions as John, I did all of them as Arthur because I wasn't sure if I can still do them after the chapter they become available in. The only one I know you have to do as John is the ones for Evelyn Miller, the writer that you meet at the mayor's house in the mission The Gilded Cage. I've done everything I possibly can as Arthur and I may do another playthrough and skip anything that's not part of the main story so I can do everything I possibly can as John.
I hope RDR3 will be as Hosea in his youth where he meets Dutch, Arthur, Annabelle and Bessie. Sort of like when the gang was all coming together rather than just falling apart. Failing that; I'd love a game where you play as Sadie Adler post RDR.
@@donlinodimeo 2 Full-time jobs, a wife and a two-year-old take up a lot of time. I think I am only 1 mission away though so it is about to be a sad evening. I try to do 1-2 mission per day on the few days I get to play.
You kinda missed one if you visit the guy near Roanoke lake who you went hunting with but if you wait until the last one and do it with John you get completely different dialogue
If finished as Arthur so it would’ve been nice to have an actually new mission w Albert Mason where Johns like “photographer in a predicament with animals, must be the guy I read about”
Heres a request well two number 1: in the epoluge can you find Micha at his camp before your supposed to. Number 2: what happens if you skip the chapter four gang hide out in chapter 5 and go to the spot on the note you find in the house after escaping guarma
I just completed that as Arthur, the one at 1:26 And can't wait to play as John Marston for the first time I already made John Marston as my GTA ONLINE character
I don't know if this has anything to do with this topic but one time once I beat the game I went back to colter and once I entered one of the shacks I hear John having Arthur flashbacks
What's funny is that John talks with Mason like he did the first mission himself while the quote where he remember Arthur clearly says that Arthur retrieved Mason's bag
Arthur saves John two times in the game. The beginning and the end. John is dying in the beginning on a rock in the west. Arthur died on a rock to the west at the end. WTF?
Well there can be more encounters in with npcs knowing Arthur, you just have to complete all the first segments of the avaliable strangers and freaks missions playing as Arthur then wait until you've finished the epilogue
That's second side mission (Albert Mason) that you can complete as Arthur in chapter 2... Even dialogues between John and Albert are mostly the same as these between Arthur and Albert in this encounter...
I visited him as John for the first time and there was no mention of coyotes. Infact, I had to save his bag from a coyote in that first encounter as Arthur never met him before
theres a ranom encounter of a man who breaks his leg and asks for help outside valentine, if you give him medicine theres a random chance you will find him sitting outside the gunshop in town and he offers to buy you a gun of your choice using his credit.
you will only get the stranger ones if you don't complete them with arthur, especially the photographer, John won't meet him if there are no more missions left.
Did the professor mission as John. After the mission went back and *spoilers* professor was dead and the robot had escaped. There is an electric lantern which you can use.
1:17 Why haven't I had any conversations about Arthur and Albert? Now it's time 2. Mine in meeting him when the wolves attacked. he knew each other before Previously with John
I wish Jim ‘Boy’ Calloway had given his drunken discourse to his own reflection in a mirror. “Who’s this grass snake? Are you trying to be me? Well I’m somebody! And you’re nobody! And I don’t have to prove a g---n thing to you, nobody! I’m gonna kill the both of you!” That would’ve been the funniest.
The journal is pretty clear on how weird the strangers Arthur meets are. Not odd in the slightest, sweet if you think about it. He learned to read from Hosea.
@@cdogthehedgehog6923 but I mean. They talk to John like he's the one who's met them before depending on which visit it is. They'll say things like "it's you again" like you yourself have been there when it was Arthur before
@@eggsperiencedgamer997 Only happens with the barrel over the waterfall my dude. That was clearly an oversight. If you have any other examples I'd love to see it. Doing my all John stranger playthrough this year, blew through the game and have been epilogueing for months and thats the only mistake I've seen that just didnt make any sense.
@@cdogthehedgehog6923 nah. It definitely does it with all of them. I had it happen with the fossil chick and a few others. I think you need to pay attention a little more my guy
I had the encounter with Albert Mason and the wolves as Morgan in part 2 while looking for a unique knife and he said the same things except for the end before the wolves attack
6 HIDDEN Encounters Where John Marston Remembers Arthur Morgan In Red Dead Redemption 2! (RDR2)
I already know about these encounters because I watched another youtuber showing these encounters and it was a couple of weeks ago
Thanks for the video MrBossFTW. Although I was there for the John Marston meeting Mayor Lemieux one and I must say, you really need to try to get these encounters with John instead of finishing these side missions as Arthur.
Why must you always stretch your videos to 10 min?
6 encounters in which Jon talks to Arthur he remembers and 4 we hope he doesn't( secrets revealed ) YOU'LL NEVER GUESS WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
Your name is Ross right
We need a game with Arthur Morgan as the main character as a young man. How he met Eliza and the birth of Issac would be great to see. Start it like Red Dead Revolver when he's a kid and progress chapter to chapter throughout his early life. Would love to be able to play as Arthur meeting Dutch for the first time. R* hit a home run with the character of Arthur and I feel if they gave him his own game it would probably be one of the best selling games ever. I'm not even gonna try to count the number of post I've seen of how people got so upset over Arthur's death. RIP Mr. Morgan.
They could still work John into it too since John and Arthur were the longest standing members of the Van der Linde Gang outside of Dutch and Hosea. Or we could get a game about Hosea and his life before meeting Dutch and both the early years of the Van der Linde's and Arthur and John.
@@spiderdude3429 I would be happy with either bro, both sound good to me!
They could let us follow both Arthur and Johns ascension into the gang, and it can end with the infamous black water Robbery. This time, there’s no redemption, so it’s Red Dead , Dawn of the Outlaws.
Christopher Bronson I believe the character in Red Dead Revolver was a completely different person named Red Harlow.
@@gregglockmanjr.7499 Hell yeah I'd play that game!
What's funny is that I've finished all of these missions as Arthur
Tbh I never finished the gunslinger one as Arthur
Same lol
Wonderz same just not the 2 brothers and the scientist
Me 2
Same, except for o brother, I only did the bottle shooting as arthur. Still havent found the other encounters regarding them.
It's beautiful you can go through all of these as John, and see all of these people Arthur helped years ago. It's like Arthur's still alive through all these people who don't even know each other, like the Albert Mason and Charlotte, but they're all connected through Arthur.
That's like real life right there. The people we touch are forever impacted, just as we are impacted by others. It's a never ending cycle that continues long after we're dead and gone.
(John says "Arthur" to some on Arthur helped)
MrBossFTW: that was a really awesome reference
1:39 it’s so much funnier with Arthur
John doesn’t laugh like Arthur does at the painting scene
I don’t think he even laughs at all
No duh he’s not Arthur
I am you from ze future come withz me if you wunna not die moite
Boah
I will be forever pissed they killed Arthur
I hope they do a dlc where you can play as Arthur maybe during the Blackwater heist
@@kellogscornflakes2430 Arthur wasn't there.
Finished chapter 6 last weekend. I miss Arthur
Micha did it
I had a dream about blowing Micah's head off...
Felt good
This dude is like the ali-a of rdr2 lmao
true
Any rockstar game basically
These encounters are exactly the same as with Arthur with only a few different lines of dialog.
Arthur sounds better then John in these
Not at all. See the devil's in the details. Did You notice that Arthur laughs at the painting but John doesn't? One of many examples
These aren't "hidden" I knew all these were a thing
i dout that
@@wyattgoss6804 He has a point, most players back then would finish the mission completely, but some didn't as they payed attention more to the story. But It's also true that all players know now.
You must not have done that specific Mission with the wolves with Arthur, because that was the exact same location dialogue and everything if you do it as Arthur other than them talkin about author
Arthur not author
I literally started crying a bit when I saw Arthur die
@_Bagginshield I was about to say the same thing I cried like hell when him and John died
Was I blind or did you miss or forget Charlotte? She won't have a blip on the map, but when you finish her storyline with Arthur and visit her with John, you'll have another unique and very nice conversation in memory of Arthur
John: says something
This man: rEaLly AwEsOmE sTufF rIgHT tHeRE
You linearly just finished a side mission that Arthur started this inst hidden at all
Keep it to yourself
I finished them as aurthur though sooooooooo
Redoing these Arthur-missions as John is just a faster way to get John's Honor raise d, while sharing a bit of nostalgia for the memory of an old friend and brother.
If you do the first the veteran mission as aurthur but do the second one as John than hamish will say who is there and it will be a little conversation about aurthur for a second
6 hidden encounters when you talk back to your mom (gone wrong) (nearly dead)
That French artist also tells Arthur
“I hope to meet you again soon”
wow sooo cool, sooo awesome
really interesting stuff guys
@Oakly 00 be quiet
@MrBossFTW Lol while I was going to find Micah's unique double-action revolver, I unintentionally passed through the camp from the first chapter in the snowy mountains. The kicker? I actually heard voice overs of a few of the characters saying their iconic lines from Chapter One. It was pretty terrifying, but sad at the same time.
Pretty sure there's a couple more of these because I have Hamish on my game as John.
Well Hamish dies in the 4th mission and Albert Mason gives up photography after like the 6th or 7th and you can do all these missions as Arthur if you want or leave some to do as John if you'd rather save some of these encounters for him
He just casually keeps the paintings in the video without a blur effect
There's a couple stranger missions I'm saving for John JUST because I want a little remembrance for Arthur. Everyone seems to use the Wolf photo mission probably for that little bonus dialogue but I'm saving the last Eagle one hoping it gives a little added depth to Mason and Arthur's relationship
Fun Fact: if you complete every albert mason mission before you do the artists way, art museum mission, some of the painting will be replaced with albert masons photos, including one of Arthur, that does make me wonder, if you start the albert mason missions as john, finish them, and do the art exhibit mission, would it still be arthurs photo on the wall?
I completed all of these as Arthur and basically the same thing happens except the part John telling them that Arthur died obviously
4:59 he said something very controversial but true
16:40 the random and over the top "IMMA KILL BOTH OF YOU!" Threat gets me every time xD
I didn't know you could do the stranger missions as John, I did all of them as Arthur because I wasn't sure if I can still do them after the chapter they become available in. The only one I know you have to do as John is the ones for Evelyn Miller, the writer that you meet at the mayor's house in the mission The Gilded Cage. I've done everything I possibly can as Arthur and I may do another playthrough and skip anything that's not part of the main story so I can do everything I possibly can as John.
The professor was dead when I found him as john
Love this vid I was just watching one of your other ones XD
I hope RDR3 will be as Hosea in his youth where he meets Dutch, Arthur, Annabelle and Bessie. Sort of like when the gang was all coming together rather than just falling apart. Failing that; I'd love a game where you play as Sadie Adler post RDR.
With Albert mason if you skin the wolves there’s a new line of dialoug
Blue Fusion, what does he say?
Vishay he says that he hates wolves
“You know what, I kinda like that fella” BRUH LOL 😂😂😂 I can’t stop laughing
Maybe you could try finding Dr. Marco's robot as John in the epilogue
When John ran into the photograph guide of wolves I had Arthur as my character still
When I went to Dragic as John I just walked in and didn't get a cutscene, he was just dead on the floor.
I don't like how none of the other characters age, like Albert Mason, Charles(French guy), and Charlotte etc. Rockstar should've made them age aswell
It was only 7 years you expect them to change a lot they do change
Nice Vid
This spoiled Arthur dying for me :-( I haven’t finished the game yet.
Bryan Markham how the games been out for almost 6 months but oh well ur still working and I appreciate that
@@donlinodimeo 2 Full-time jobs, a wife and a two-year-old take up a lot of time. I think I am only 1 mission away though so it is about to be a sad evening. I try to do 1-2 mission per day on the few days I get to play.
@@donlinodimeo not everyone can play games all day and RDR2 isn't short lmao
Bryan Markham damn bro...I even spoiled myself to Arthur’s death like a two months ago but try not to spoil how exactly he died
sry that happened to me too but at least you can prepare
mentally
Red dead is daaa best
john have you ever had an incounter with wolves
john:veitnames flashbacks
Nice video 👍
nice vid btw
Cool video Mr boss good work on the video today
You kinda missed one if you visit the guy near Roanoke lake who you went hunting with but if you wait until the last one and do it with John you get completely different dialogue
Am I the only one that noticed at 13:40 John hammered the barrel with nothing
No we just dont care
If finished as Arthur so it would’ve been nice to have an actually new mission w Albert Mason where Johns like “photographer in a predicament with animals, must be the guy I read about”
Heres a request well two number 1: in the epoluge can you find Micha at his camp before your supposed to. Number 2: what happens if you skip the chapter four gang hide out in chapter 5 and go to the spot on the note you find in the house after escaping guarma
He forgot the Mary Beth encounter
And Tilly and rains falls
5:42 that punch left me crying from laughter 🤣🤣
Dude these aren't hidden, I did every one of these as Arthur, you just save them and did them as John
shanet60 How do you play as John?!
@@daltonharrold4617 complete chapter 6
@@daltonharrold4617 dumb
Those wolves came to eat but popped 😂💀
I just completed that as Arthur, the one at 1:26
And can't wait to play as John Marston for the first time
I already made John Marston as my GTA ONLINE character
I like how Marston said who needs killin
I love your videos and I think you are honestly the best rdr 2 youtuber. I never skip a day where I dont whatch your vids, nice work
I love this game but you know trusting someone that you encounter seconds a go is another thing.
the only reason I did the painting mission as Arthur is that he actually smiles and laughs at the reaction of the people
The scene in the gallery was one of my favorite moments after the main story missions (I started it after the epilogue) that I have experienced
You can find a letter saying that Marco wants to take over the world
I don't know if this has anything to do with this topic but one time once I beat the game I went back to colter and once I entered one of the shacks I hear John having Arthur flashbacks
I went to Marjorie's show as John and he was like "it was bad"
I still love this game
What's funny is that John talks with Mason like he did the first mission himself while the quote where he remember Arthur clearly says that Arthur retrieved Mason's bag
Hi john
Arthur saves John two times in the game. The beginning and the end. John is dying in the beginning on a rock in the west. Arthur died on a rock to the west at the end. WTF?
ARTHUR!!!
arthur:oh don't you arthur me!
Well there can be more encounters in with npcs knowing Arthur, you just have to complete all the first segments of the avaliable strangers and freaks missions playing as Arthur then wait until you've finished the epilogue
The guy who built the robot sounds a little bit like Roman from gta 4.
That's second side mission (Albert Mason) that you can complete as Arthur in chapter 2... Even dialogues between John and Albert are mostly the same as these between Arthur and Albert in this encounter...
the second one he didn't mention shit you are just blushing.
1:23 "Some more greedy coyotes". If this was the first time John Marston met Albert Mason, how would he recall the coyote encounter?
He said arthur told him about them
I visited him as John for the first time and there was no mention of coyotes. Infact, I had to save his bag from a coyote in that first encounter as Arthur never met him before
theres a ranom encounter of a man who breaks his leg and asks for help outside valentine, if you give him medicine theres a random chance you will find him sitting outside the gunshop in town and he offers to buy you a gun of your choice using his credit.
You miss the veteran, margret, algeron wasp, the widow, and the curse side mission
you will only get the stranger ones if you don't complete them with arthur, especially the photographer, John won't meet him if there are no more missions left.
You missed Hamish Sinclair
You should do a video where you trying to get into Davie’s
resting place in the start of the game
Did the professor mission as John. After the mission went back and *spoilers* professor was dead and the robot had escaped. There is an electric lantern which you can use.
You can also see only the body of the doctor if you go as John after the robot kills him
You probably already mentioned it but if you go to that lady lives in the cabin by herself where Arthur taught her to hunt they mention Arthur also
Dont you ever think how many things are in that satchel
The professor sounds like Roman from gta4
Good video.......
The professor kinda sounds like Roman a bit with more accent.
If you don’t want Author to die, just don’t do the Straus missions
1:17 Why haven't I had any conversations about Arthur and Albert? Now it's time 2. Mine in meeting him when the wolves attacked. he knew each other before Previously with John
You missed sooooooooooo many stranger missions in this video
Is it bad that I had no honor literally it was all the way down?
Besides Bruce Wayne I don’t think I’ve ever felt this damn attached to a character💔
I wish Jim ‘Boy’ Calloway had given his drunken discourse to his own reflection in a mirror. “Who’s this grass snake? Are you trying to be me? Well I’m somebody! And you’re nobody! And I don’t have to prove a g---n thing to you, nobody! I’m gonna kill the both of you!” That would’ve been the funniest.
I AIN'T DEAD BOAH
Guess this character
“I think his name was, Alan?”
Mickey
GAVIN
Good time correct
@@lordcomedian931 Well it obviously is Gavin
Thus might be the clickbaity thumbnail yet
Othe than that great video
Hey great vid
Arthur Morgan would awesome to hang out with in real life
My god cant belive you didint put hamish
Mickey will tall about Arthur if you see him as John
5:35 I like how he calls you french when john is scottish get your nationalitys right boah
Not really hidden encounters but still good video 👍
Have you ever noticed John speaks to all of Arthur’s old colleagues as if he seen their previous mistakes. I find that odd
The journal is pretty clear on how weird the strangers Arthur meets are. Not odd in the slightest, sweet if you think about it. He learned to read from Hosea.
@@cdogthehedgehog6923 but I mean. They talk to John like he's the one who's met them before depending on which visit it is. They'll say things like "it's you again" like you yourself have been there when it was Arthur before
@@eggsperiencedgamer997 Only happens with the barrel over the waterfall my dude. That was clearly an oversight. If you have any other examples I'd love to see it.
Doing my all John stranger playthrough this year, blew through the game and have been epilogueing for months and thats the only mistake I've seen that just didnt make any sense.
@@cdogthehedgehog6923 nah. It definitely does it with all of them. I had it happen with the fossil chick and a few others. I think you need to pay attention a little more my guy
I had the encounter with Albert Mason and the wolves as Morgan in part 2 while looking for a unique knife and he said the same things except for the end before the wolves attack