PM Modi’s Economic Advisor On Kolkata’s Decline, Amrit Kaal & $10 Trillion Economy I Sanjeev Sanyal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 тра 2024
- This week’s episode is in discussion with PM Narendra Modi’s Economic Advisor who talks about Kolkata’s Decline, Amrit Kaal & India’s $10 Trillion Economy as we welcome Sanjeev Sanyal to the Neon Show!
What Changed in India After Liberalisation in 1991?
Does Being World’s Largest Population Help or Hinder India’s Growth?
Sanjeev Sanyal’s Role In Reforming The Banking Systems
All these JUICY topics and more in this ROUSING conversation about India’s economics. A deep dive into how India became a powerhouse economy in the world since 1991 & where it aims to be as a country by 2050… Tune in NOW!
Sponsor Shout Out
Looking to build a differentiated tech startup with a 10X better solution? Prime is the high conviction, high support investor you need. With its fourth fund of $120M, Prime actively works with star teams to accelerate building great companies.
To know more, visit primevp.in/
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
🎇CHAPTERS
00:00 - Precap
01:01 - Introducing Sanjeev Sanyal, PM Modi’s Economic Advisor
01:31 - “Kolkata DIDN’T DIE. It Was MURDERED!” Sanjeev’s Childhood Days
05:08 - Life In India After Independence & Before 1991!
08:37 - What Changed in India After Liberalisation in 1991?
10:42 - Why India’s Banking System Was Reformed Post Modi!
15:32 - Sanjeev Sanyal’s Role In Reforming The Banking Systems
21:01 - How India Maintained Its Stability Even After Covid!
23:08 - 5 Influential Economic Reforms Sanjeev Has Been Part Of!
30:35 - Can India Become Top 5 Nation In The Ease Of Doing Business Index?
36:21 - Does Being World’s Largest Population Help or Hinder India’s Growth?
41:24 - India’s Amrit Kaal: The Global Factors That Could Play A Role
46:01 - India’s Growth Rate vs China’s Growth Rate
50:55 - Can India Become a $20 Trillion Economy In The Near Future?
52:22 - Will India’s Population Continue to Grow In the Next 50 Years?
53:22 - What Economic Reforms Can Indians Expect In The Next Few Years?
56:43 - What % Of The Indian Economic Advisory’s Time Goes Into Propelling Startups?
59:59 - Concluding Remarks
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hi, I am your host Siddhartha! I have been an entrepreneur from 2012-2017 building two products AddoDoc and Babygogo. After selling my company to SHEROES, I and my partner Nansi decided to start up again. But we felt unequipped in our skillset in 2018 to build a large company. We had known 0-1 journey from our startups but lacked the experience of building 1-10 journeys.
Hence was born The Neon Show (Earlier 100x Entrepreneur) to learn from founders and investors, the mindset to scale yourself and your company. This quest still keeps us excited even after 5 years and doing 200+ episodes.
We welcome you to our journey to understand what goes behind building a super successful company. Every episode is done with a very selfish motive, that I and Nansi should come out as a better entrepreneur and professional after absorbing the learnings.
Visit our Website: neon.fund/
Follow us on Instagram:
/ theneonshoww
Follow us on Twitter:
/ theneonshoww
Follow us on LinkedIn:
/ beneon
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
🎇Hashtags🎇
#startup #entrepreneur #podcast
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
"Kolkata didn't die. It was murdered" will go down as one of best lines in the history of this channel. Mark my word. I felt these lines since from my village people used to go Kalkatta. Then they moved to Mumbai, including my grandfather. Good people are coming on the show.
It was serial murder..Commie killed Bhubaneswar,Guwahati,Ranchi, Patna along Kolkata..
@@santusanturohit4832 If any honest film-director can research the topic he/she can make a popular web-series.
" Kolkata did not die it was murdered ".... It can very much resonate with my thoughts about this unfortunate saga. 😥😥I saw it too. A long story to tell.
All eastern cities of the country@@santusanturohit4832
1977 to 2011 long 34 years Bengali are closed their 84000 industries. Big industries like Dunlop, Hindustan Motors,BATA....to midium and small industries 👍and all these happened in the name of opposed capitalism 😂 just think how hypocrite Bengali Bhadralok
As a Bengali I really felt the line "Kolkata isn't dying, it was murdered 😓"
Momota didi zindabad. Modi down down.
By the Commies, anything Communism touches it destroys!
@@rohanch07 To realize full potential of Kolkata, they need Modi
@@zanjeer7827 But Modi is Hindutwa fascist. W@ste Bengal needs a psecular leader like didi.
@@rohanch07 who told you that? Let me guess, your didi and pappu. The two most honest people on earth. So you believed them.
Stayed in Kolkata for a long period, that's totally true a beautiful city been destroyed. Still Kolkata has the spirit to regrow. Kolkata needs a leader who is willing to Make change
We are all eager to watch Kolkata regrow and rise up to what it was meant to be. Thank you for tuning in!
@@TheNeonShowwwont happen till Mamta is here and till we are having populist schemes.
West Bengal needs BJP
@@abhisekhkumar4948 e bihari ja drain saf kar tujhe zada soch ne ki zarurat nehi
@@abhisekhkumar4948 Yeah totally agree on this, a govt can't uplift any state's economic side by giving freebies just for the sake of some free votes!
Completely agreed that “Kolkata” was murdered during CPIM and now Trinomul created graveyard to buried “Kolkata”
Easy to destroy. Nearly impossible to rebuild. BC Roy used his influence with Nehru to bring all sorts of industries to the city, and to the state.
Calcutta did not just lose out to Bombay and Madras...
but to Pune, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Amdavad, Surat, Vadodara, Coimbatore, Noida, Gurgao...
... and Bhubaneshwar.
@@narenmenon6906 nothing is impossible.
@@narenmenon6906 it aint that bad bro literally pulled out tier 2 cities infront of the 3rd largest gdp city of India right after Delhi Mumbai💀
@@prabahadas9474
Total GDP or
Per Capita GDP?
TMC doing doing exactly what Jyoti basu did to Kolkata
Following same model
Only buddhadeb bhattacharya tried to rescue Kolkata but his own lower patry members didn't like that
That's why TMC came into picture
As a Bengali I really felt ashamed about my own city Kolkata & West Bengal for the economic collapsed in last 60 years.
😢😢
THANKS TO COMMUNISTS AND DIDI!
It pains my heart the state which produced stalwarts like Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay, Rabindranath Tagore, Jagdish Chandra Bose, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, Birla family and many business families has come to this sorry state of affairs.
I always wondered what went wrong with kolakata since it was the economical hub since Brits put foot in India.
@@rajgoyal108 truly how bad politicians can change golden lands to mud
Credit to PM/PMO for bringing in persons like Sanyal into GOI. I particularly liked his comment “ if we had listened to the US academics, perhaps we would be like Sri Lanka to day !!”
definitely.
We didn't have to print money, "thankfully", alright. But freebies are on the rise. It has the same effect if it goes up from year to year.
who did Modi listen to, when he did demonetization?
I think he meant the USA pushing India to choose sides Russia or them..
No, he didnt mean that..he meant the demand side reforms during covid@@Sarmistha9
I live in WB and i can see why sanjeev is right about kolkata. In 1947 kolkata was top city but now it seems like everything was stripped away from it.
Don't worry bro Kolkata is right now 3rd largest economy with a gdp of 160 billion dollar
Well thanks to Comminuist
@@franklyn9449😂😂 Well brother it's 60 billion not 160 and it's 4th largest
@vijaybisht3601 4th largest
@@franklyn9449 foolish
Lived in Kolkata during the same period. The genesis of 'Bengal's murder' began with the Naxal movement. My older cousin brothers had to leave Kolkata forever to save their lives. In the mid 80s, I, too, left. Now, Didi is putting the final nail in the coffin.
you know what.. even after all the stupidity from Didi, there has been economic improvements in Kolkata.. the economy was destroyed by communists..
@@thebengalurubong2047 seriously?? Give me some examples of "there is economic improvement in Kolkata" 😂 don't tell about saltlake city as we know who had estd saltlake, kalyani etc....what about your Salboni investment by sourav ganguly which was announced from foreign soil😂😂 what about singur? Every year we see economic Forum but what kind of investment is coming?? And will come😂
@@pyarabharat2746 no i am not talking about industrialisation.. definitely it didn’t happen as people expected.. but the communist ideology of strikes and unions has been disbanded which is somehow giving a better environment for the companies.. myself as a 33 year old man have witnessed the difference..TMC regime could have been much much better without corruption and unnecessary minority appeasement
@@thebengalurubong2047 hmmm dada now I can agree with you.....communists damaged our state 70% and rests by...in comparison with communists Tmc is much better but their huge corruption has made the last nail in the coffin.
@@thebengalurubong2047 i agree
" Kolkata did not die it was murdered ".... It can very much resonate with my thoughts about this unfortunate saga. 😥😥
But Bongs think their city is the best and they can have the cheapest food. They also feel they are very cultured people.
@@garygeorge-wi7co see bro best or not that's a debate but other than that all your points are correct. Food is really cheap and Kolkata may not be the economic hub but it's cultural hub for sure
@@MonkeyDArnab IIS Bangalore has large number of students , both UG and PG, from west Bengal. The economy is stagnant. no incentive for the industrial houses to invest in the state and hence intelligent people are moving to other states.
@@MonkeyDArnab then don't send bengalis to take jobs of gujratis , Tamils and kannadas.
I am a Bengali from Kolkata.. Really I agree with the tag line...
By looking his eyes and dark circle , you can tell that this man is putting everything in his work in building shining India.
True, Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal sir has been trying to fix the things while he can. And you can understand that from the conversation in the podcast.
you comment show that you are watching him, but not listening him...:)
@@braj75 both are needed
I was in merchant navy and we used to go regularly to kolkota in 1980s. The ship would stay minimum two months or more. Forward block union going on strike was a every day affair. In front of my eyes I saw SCI office shifting to mumbai, then Brookbond, and scores of other companies closing their shop. Bengalis had a laid back attitude, the work culture was totally different. Singur was the final nail in kolkotas coffin. Where Kolkata was drying, Mumbai was flourishing. Most of the whose who of Indian industry shifted base to mumbai. Now with the influx of refugees the social fabric of Kolkata has changed. They have already crossed the point of no return.
Well at this point we can hope that things turn out in a different scenario! Thank you for sharing your thoughts in this!
Please read about Freight Equalization policy...Entire east was drying up not just kolkata and west was flourishing..it was a conspiracy not just local politics
@@prasunkumarray9645which east are you talking about, north east? During this time Timilnadu, Andhra flourished, Bangalore became silicon valley of India. All the who's who of India business world shifted to Mumbai and after TATA shifted to Gujarat, that state became first choice for investment
@@mohanindap2East India consits of Bihar,West Bengal,Jharkhand and Odisha.
He's right on fact that freight equalisation policy snatched resources from east and gave that to west and south also but east India's politicians are also to blame here they didn't give attention towards industrialization.
@@prasunkumarray9645who chased out Tata. The whole investment dried up in w.bengal after that. Odisha, Andhra Pradesh doing well. With so many refugees, no entrepreneur is going to invest. No problem. Maharashtra, Gujarat has jobs.
It was an absolute pleasure to host Sanjeev Sanyal Sir on Neon Show
But your questions should have been more probing!
But you turned to be an amateur as an interviewer
He is saying truth because there was a time when people used to look up to Kolkata historically.
When Singapore was formed in 60's, they tried to model themselves after Calcutta
Why in up bihar Haryana Punjab Rajasthan at least 5-6 crore female foeticide has happened? Im 1991 to 2011, as per census? Census 2021 hasn't released yet.
Why still they kill their daughter for marrying other caste man? But they dont kill their son for marrying other caste woman.
Why in Kolkata all the rapist name are hindi speaking hindu and bengali muslim. I don't see bengali hindu name as rapist.
In ur hindi speaking people are doing rape, female foeticide, honor killings. What u gonna say about it?.
Bengalis go to work in Maharashtra, marathi hates bihar up walas but they don't hate bengalis, why? Because bengalis don't go there to increase crime, to marry local woman and change demographics like up biharis. They mingle and learn local culture they dont favour their caste unlike up biharis. Accept it sanyal.
Kolkata is still safest city for 3rd time.
In last august honor killings happened in jhajjar of a 22 year old girl. Few days ago balesh dhankar from haryana raped 5 korean women and made videos. All these news are suppressed, search it. They don't wanna talk about these issues because it would crack their agenda of "hindu hindi".
@@val-schaeffer1117yes you are right .As Bhartiya we should know about how Arth work Arth is also one purusarth .Bengali people create so much economist scientist industrialist .After they choose left ideology instead of indic ideology they derail their journey .
@@abhinavsharma1104 what is indic ideology?I am a bengali i don't want some non-bengali/cowbelt people rule my city-Straight and simple.
@@gauravdas5000 You rather watch a Bengali rule and bring it to the ground
BEST QUOTE --- ' HINDUISM IS VERY MUCH ABOUT OF SEARCHING FOR A TRUTH ITS NOT ABOUT THE TELLING YOU TRUTH ' .. KUDOS MR .Sanyal
Pursuit of truth is not pleasant.
Excellent. Straight, simple and intellectually stimulating.
This is about India. It's also a lamentation on the decline of Kolkata and Bengal. Having spent my childhood in Kolkata, I find myself more Bengali than Maharashtrian. Kolkata gave me a wonderful education. It had a back up. You could clear your doubts with your seniors in your pada who patiently explained the things to you. I have thereafter lived in a lot of cities and States but nothing comes close to my Kolkata of the sixties. The lamentation on the decline of Kolkata strums a very sad note and I hope to see a prosperous Kolkata before the last grim call.
Very well said
Yes. Kolkata's descent is something we witnessed in front of our eyes. From being the corporate headquarters of multinational corporations and the happening place to a backwater now.
We still remember a scene from toe movie Anand, in one scene Amitabh Bachchan or was it some other character say about Rajesh Khanna - elaaj karaane ke liye Calcutta asya hai (from Delhi) or something to that effect.
Yeah, We never fail to chuckle Those days if you wanted specialized treatment or advanced treatment you used to go to Calcutta from Delhi. And now!!!Sad
We hope that Kolkata would once again rise up to what it was meant to be ! Thank you for tuning in and sharing insights about it!
Not under Mamata
Kolkata hospitals still the cheapest yet the best 👍💯 govt hospitals r not much organized or hygienic but treatment is quite good
@@srivani991 Definitely not under Modi either as he is only interested in developing gujarat and making roads in UP to jack up its gdp without any real development of the people
@@prasunkumarray9645 find whoever will make those changes happen and elect him/her as the chosen leader.😊
Wow you guys got one of the brightest minds in India!
Agreed ... That too quite nicely !
Remarkable analysis of Kolkata by Sir Sanyal.
What a dynamic personality. Hope India gains from his indepth knowledge about Economics and History.
Already doing it.
I have huge respect for the land of Kolkata because of it's immense contribution in the independence of our country. I think With political stability, it can pose serious challenge to every other developed cities of the world. Kolkata, we want you back as one of the major engine in our journey towards Amrit Bharat.
😂
First vote out mamta
Kolkata We Want U Back as One of de main Powers in our Journey towards " Amrit Bharat ". . . ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤
First Vote Out Mamata - TMC
I am a simple man I see Sanjeev Sanyal on a podcast I click without any hesitation. Amazing podcast sir. Taught us a great deal on our Economical History and the work done in past 6-7 Years. Thanks a ton!
I have heard about it from my father about the communists. He left the country while being young, a self made man, decided to come back and start a business in the mid 70's, it failed due to the communist ideology, bandh culture, no incentive to work but to complain z he left the country for good. The state was murdered and now it's butchered by the new TMC.. Save Bengal
We need more such intellectuals from the govt to come and share the vision and work in progress of Modiji through them in these days where our leader is labelled as fascist and Hitler etc.
Those that are calling such names and infact he mentioned about why there is this confidence in the country, it is bringing back Sanatan dharma and bring back the culture of the country that was getting lost due to previous government as they were as we know better working for the enemy states for their personal gains. States like Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana Changing the culture by missionaries and Islamisation. They can say all nonsense about Sanatan dharma, calling it a virus but dare not say a word against the Islamic radicals and missionaries.
I pray sense prevails in all the citizens even more and they stand by the BJP government under the leadership of Modi if they want the progress of this country for once after a very long time.
Ohh he definitely is! All his actions including letting MAN!PU® burn, suspending members, not supporting wrestlers, controlling 80% of MEDIA and NEWS using money from Mr. A. Also what progress. India's debt quadrupled in the last 10 years to 200 lakh crore and the poor and middle class have to compensate for that by paying high inflated prices and G$T. GHI and per capita income are still one of the lowest in the world. Just GDP is no indicator of how the standard of living is especially for a large country like India.
Sanjeev Sir,
Unfortunately I am also a close Witness to the Murder of Industrial Growth. In fact a Receiver of Militant Trade Unionism. These People are again Trying to Stage a Comeback in 2024.
How Facinating. 🙏🙏
Absolutely ; still Bengalis are frenzy about the CPM party' s ideology, which is disastrous!!!
@@believe8980 because of communist attitude bengal doesn't face castism and racism. Accept the fact that north indians hindu aren't hindu they are jatt rajput yadav etc.
Accept that they were called by martial races by britishers because they acted like german Shepherd for them. They enlisted in british army and oppressed other indians.
Accept that they don't accept their girls marrying out of caste but they accept love marriage of their son.
" 22 OLD GIRL GOT KILLED BY BROTHER FOR DOING INTERCASTE MARRIAGE " august, 2023 haryana.
"Ayushi yadav was killed by father for marrying a gujjar" Delhi 2022.
Always daughter gets killed.
Accept these news aren't shown to big media. Search it.
Accept it. See the sex ratio of up bihar haryana Rajasthan Punjab from 1991 to 2023 , at least 5-6 crore female foeticide hua hy.
Accept that most henious rapes are done by these castist racist people. Accept that for them upper caste north indian fair male is entitled for most privilege.
U won't see Bengali hindu name as rapist it is always muslim and hindu from up bihar
ideology doesn't change without revolution.
Even Mamata begum won due to communist ideology of destroying nano factory.
It's so amazing to see such an intellectual person on the show.
U should also watch his speeches on Indian history
West Bengal was taken apart, brick by brick, by Shri Jyoti Basu & his cronies. They had an agenda to destroy Bengal, at whose behest, really do not know. Industry, Education, Law, were targeted. Mr. Sanyal rightly said, Bengal, / Kolkata was murdered. And currently dance of death has taken place.
Not destroyed brick by brick.. destroyed by dynamites after dynamites
We are glad that we could have Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal sir on the show and discuss about these topics! Really thank you for tuning in!
One sided ethnic cleansing of Hindus from Bangladesh was also a reason. 1971 war was part of that
They were under CCP China payroll, their target was not only Bengal but damage whole India with their labour union. They became successful bcs America was foolish & racist. They made China global factory by harming India from 1980s with a plan. They even tried to block computers in India so that India remains weak & Service sector benifit goes to China just like manufacturing sector went. Communists r very dangerous for Indias growth & well being. They will always create hurdle behalf of their CCP masters.
If that's so ? Why has Bengal better social indicators than even gujrat so "model" state . Kolkata the "murdered" City has more GDP than any city in the nation except Delhi and Mumbai. It paid 70,000 crores in income tax to the nation in 2021-22 . Delusional people like you are the problem of Bengal
I'm Singapore. Me great fan of Hon'able
Gen Naravane Sir, Dr S Jaishankar, Tiru
Annamalai & Shri Narendra Modi.
🇮🇳👏👏👏🇸🇬🙏🏻
This interview is what kids should be listening to and discuss about with Teachers and elders.
That's so sweet of you! The whole purpose was to make it even understandable for kids because there are complex terms and things which people don't understand. At least by watching this interview they could get a glimpse of it!
Exactly that's what I was also thinking at least to let my children listen to and understand which opportunity i never got as a child during my formative years.
Thank you Siddhartha for bringing thought leaders like Sanjeev Sir on the show
Sanjeev is one of the few torch bearers whom many Indians would like to emulate and serve their motherland to the best extent and be a part of the history being created to bring India back to our centries old era when India contributed hugely to world economy. We are on the way through the hard work by intellectuals and workhorses like Sanjeev. Now we have a team of thinkers who have been handpicked by government to guide the government to leapfrog to our new destiny. I adore Sanjeev and his depth of knowledge.
May God bless you and your family with along peaceful healthy life. India strongly needs such efficient, hard working and nationalistic attitude. My husband and myself who are in 73 and76 yrs old bless you.
Being a bengali and a resident of Kolkata, I can certainly say that Kolkata has been suffering due to excessive corruption, party domination, lack of public participation, political unwillingness and criminal - politician nexus. Here unfortunately entitlement prevails over empowerment. Reverse economic cycle is going on in Kolkata. Until we change the government in West Bengal, nothing for sure will change.
Unless, Untill we Change de Goverment in West Bengal, Nothing for Sure Will Change'!
I recall when I was a young boy in Kolkata (then Calcutta) in the mid 60's, I was introduced by some working colleagues to some of the concepts of C. Rajagopalachari of the then Swatantra Party. One of C Rajagopalachari's views was the stupidity of the Licence Quota Permit Raj. Looking back today I can see how very correct he was. Nehru was undoubtedly a patriot of India but a very poor judge of what was good for the country. Had Rajagopalchari's views been adopted in the 60s, India would be very close to what China is today if not supersede it in its economic power.
Economy-wise, the whole Nehru-Gandhi family was/is a disaster.
Thank you for sharing your insights on this! Thank you for tuning in!
@@goldenpencil6398they were not disaster in what way? What probably did they solved to the end?
Rajaji was a true patriot, Nehru was a Fabian socialist i.e. a British stooge.
Nehru was no patriot. He was a coward, selfish and fornicator
Thank you Mr Sanyal .. I am a silent yet huge admirer of you for your multi dimensional knowledge, your profound understanding & cool & confident demeanour! It’s indeed a blessing & coincidence to our country that such wonderful people like you are leading critical aspects in Honourable PM’s Vision for Amritkal 👍👏👏👏🙏! Thank you for such a wonderful simplified yet profound discussion on varied topics with such clarity, transparency & honesty👌🙏
Lol! What about letting MAN!PU® burn, suspending members, not supporting wrestlers, controlling 80% of MEDIA and NEWS using money from Mr. A. Also India's debt quadrupled in the last 10 years to 200 lakh crore and the poor and middle class have to compensate for that by paying high inflated prices and G$T. GHI and per capita income are still one of the lowest in the world. Just GDP is no indicator of how the standard of living is especially for a large country like India.
A real intellectual individual who bring out the truth behind Bengal's decline.
Imagine getting someone on a show that cannot claim to be very big. This was how it was during the Congress times. Not just the manmohan era but throughout. But this govts leaders are different. They are more open to substance. They look at the intellectual aspect not just the numbers. Wonderful conversation this was. Heres wishing you grow more buddy. Cheers 🥂
Thank you so much Ajit for your love and wishes :) Hope you listen to more conversations
@@TheNeonShoww Definitely. Just discovered ur channel. Came for Sanjeev. Loved the conversation. Definitely Subscribing. People like u my friend are the cogs in a larger scheme of instilling the greatness of Bharat in our younger generation. Like Sanjeev said in this conversation, our minds have been ruled for far too long by the intellectuals that profess their true allegiance to outside powers. I clearly remember my history lessions in school. The chapters were more about the Mughals. There were only fleeting references to the marathas, the cholas and the mauryas. Never was i taught about the Ahom dynasty. Not even a fleeting reference to one of the greatest empires of pre India. Never was i taught about Bharath's influence in the greater south asian region. Never was i taught about the greatness of Hinduism. Never was i taught about the grand temples of the south. So many of our greatest contributions to mankind was simply hidden from inquisitive minds. Our history was mostly about the mughals. Thanks to social media we are unlearning our history and getting to know the truth. Thank you for being a part of this revival. I have no doubt we are on our way to reclaiming our true worth among the committee of nations. You, me and the 1.4 billion bharatiyaas are truly blessed.
JAI HIND 🇮🇳
the man behind indias growth
sanjeev is an articulate speaker and has Pm sirs "nation first" at heart. it shows in his demeanour and his articulation. love his thought process - logical and crystal clear..
Thank you, Siddhartha, for bringing people like Sanjeev. Please have more people like who are making India a better place in the globe ❤
One of neon show's best episode yet! Siddhartha is also growing more and more confident by the day ❤
"Kolkata didn't die but murdered" - true to the core -- young generation's got equally slaughtered along the way to the point where reversing is now out of question with the current backbone less people of the state......
just playing devil's advocate here... isn't it the creative destruction that Kolkata was so engrossed with it's past that it had to be murdered for the new and better growth. Even Sanyal sir was talking about creative destruction.
I am so sad and anguished that Kolkata our rich city has gone through this phase. Kolkata and Bengal was beacon of knowledge, intellectual, patriotism, culture and economy.
Past during independence time Rajisthani Haryanvi even Punjabi Afghani Bihari Awadh region people go to Kolkatta .Kolkatta at that time was Bengaluru Pune Hyderabad + Mumbai + Chennai .
U people voted for cpim most anti national most regressive supports unlawful activities like drug peddling rape and killing opposition parties
Strange..what patriotism do u want now..patriotism was during freedom struggle..and ki ssing a political party's a rse doesnt mean patriotism..and kolkata still produces a lot of intellectual people for eg nobel prize winner..singers musicians in bollywood/indian classical music..risen from 6th to 5th spot in gdp ranking despite the hostile negative agenda against bengal/bengalis..so what r u talking about bjp stooge ?
@@prasunkumarray9645 The sense of Patriotism should always remain - the parochialism sense create by political party there is harmful...WB produces intellectual but those intellectual go to Delhi and other cities and do not do anything for Bengal....not accepting truth and denial of reality will cost Bengal and harm India more....We need to bring back Bengal back to its past glory .. shall I say you sound like Trinamool stooge justifying present situation of WB ?.....We are all components of India, not slaves of political parties.
@@prasunkumarray9645patriotism means torturing hindu women in Sandeshkhali rohingya like sheikh shahjahan did
Now I know why Modi govt works like a well oiled machine… what a sensible thought he has … just see how many times he said the word “ value” creation
The think thank of this government is really well-spoken and honest! Thank you so much for tuning in and for sharing your thoughts!
@@TheNeonShoww He is a gem of Bengal, as he understands the blunders of communists policy making of present govt is so dynamic in handling inflation to pushing for industry & infrastructure. He will not say many things but he & we know communists not only damaged Bengal industry but also Indias industry forcing Indira Gandhi. They did it with a plan from 1980s to make China global factory. They even tried to block Computers in Bengal & India so IT sector can be transferred to China.
As long as ordinary people believe in the tv news channels and social media (both of them are financed/controlled by the Modi govt) ..modi govt will winning..stop them for 6 months and see what happens to the oil and the machine
Wow you guys were able to get Sanjeev Sanyal already! Great speaker he is and good to see you guy's growth 🎉
India is on its way to world dominance ✨
100% right. killer jothi basu.
Thank you for tuning in!
I was born and raised in the suburbs of Kolkata. Really feel bad and at the same time sad for the city. How communists devastated the state. 😢😢😢
But who voted them. Many Communist are Bangla BHADRA crowd, so called Brahmin of high intellectual 😂😂
No matter what you do, unless you fix legal system which is completely broken, you can not be business friendly destination.
You're right Sir. Legal system needs urgent reforms otherwise things may not be panning out that well in future.
A state which elects Mahua Moitra as an MP ..what can you expect. As a bengali its tragic
When a state's own son denigrate the entire motherland for political reasons/politicians it sure is tragic
MOHUA MOITRÀ HAD LOT OF POTENTIAL.Voters did not know that she did not have political integrity. TO BE FAIR ON US THR INTEGRITY IN POLITICS HAD GONE SINCE CPM came to power and stayed for 30years.
@@prasunkumarray9645 wake the fuck up . The best and the brightest are out all gone to Delhi or Mumbai . The best case for WB is to be a tourist economy like Maldives .
Tourism in West Bengal? I unfortunately had to WB in 2009 as I had to change train in Howrah and the dirt I had witnessed on the streets was horrifying. Plus with the Bangladeshi and Rohingya I would not like to visit that place unless I have a friend or a relative.
@@shobinyad6643 says a bimaru from a ultra filthy state pretending as if he/she is from some western country while living in old delhi or dharavi or is simply a bjpee k unt
India needs Administrative reforms more than economic reforms as we are still ruled by the same Bureaucracy which the Britishers used to make us a pauper state. During the Mugal era we were the 2nd largest economy in the world.
Before Islamic invasion, India was the top economy of the world.
He actually mentioned this in another podcast , he mentioned this few years the major focus is on infra , revamping administration and judiciary is what is coming next
Judiciary in kolkata even mird than ever, or most needs fast track Revamp thru' change of Administration.🎉 😮🎉
Sanyal Sir shud come for short Spells & work for ours & his beloved Kolkata plzzz ❤
Kolkata was de first seat & Capital of India made by de british Raj.
Justice delayed is 🎉 Justice Denied ❤ ❤
@@GTH4121: It sure was, but the Britishers took us from second to virtually last place. Should we not blame the Britishers more than the Mughals?
Excellent. Gives us the confidence to know that our country is in good hands and that we will benefit from the wisdom of people like Sanyal and the rest of the team at the helm.
At last, there's someone I admire and adore greatly. Thank you, Neon Show! It's truly remarkable how you began with local businesses and communities, and now, utilizing this platform to engage policymakers in Bharat for their feedback. It's a journey that comes full circle, making a significant difference.
FInally the much awaited episode is here!!
Well said and agree. I saw the 1960s and 70s and saw the cosmopolitan heydays because many of my neighbour's had come from other states to work in industries around us .saw the murder happily done my younger relatives struggled in colleges my family professionally kicked out of state and friends eho lingered were 100 percent college teachers. Roads were decaying at least that part the present gov brushed up a bit. I remember the beautiful kolkata of early childhood days
This Man is simply Wow ! Sanjeev sanyal is a brilliant Guy placed at right place in the Govt ...waiting eagerly for similar talks
He is truly an impeccably gifted man and one with such clear thoughts! Thank you so much for tuning in and glad you liked it so much... We will ensure to bring more policymakers and thinking minds on the show in the near future so keep a look out! 🤗
I am going to show this video to my son to give him a context of how the things were, how they evolved and what we are looking at
Simply fantastic! Hope more people from our Bengal watch this, get inspired and strive to do what is good for Bengal both economically, politically and culturally. Uproot the rotten and diseased ones and plant young and vibrant ones. There is no death of inspiration when it comes to Bengal, just be focused, dedicated and hardworking. Wishing Bengal’s brightest future brought about through positive transformation. Joy Ma Kali!
Absolutely, Kolkata is a city that is beaming to get back to its beautiful and rich past and we are equally hopefully that the inspiring and driven youth of Bengal will take it back to its roots and even further! Thank you so much for your kind words and for sharing your insights with us!
Best interview of Sanjeev sir yet
We need more people like Mr. Sanyal in the Govt.
These are the people that make me realize that India is in the right hands. Thank you so so much for bringing people like Mr. Sanyal on your show.
Am a subscriber now. 😅
Long awaited!!
Really enjoyed listening to this conversation
The ability of Sanjeev to put across facts of the economy in simple language is mesmerising to say the least!! AS PM Modi's economic adviser he is neck deep in reforming the economy and is able to give a first hand account of how this is occuring. Great interview, one of the best i have seen recently!!!
Dr. Sanyal a genius who contributing lot in economic growth under leadership of Modiji and Sitaraman ji.
May he become CM of Bengal and that may bring Kolkatta economic Capital of India was in 1911
One of our finest episodes of the Neon Show ever! Truly blessed to have been there in person for this conversation 😃
Excited ❤
The difference between business failures and scams needs to be a separate series of sessions and people should understand that. There is a huge difference and in fact are complete opposites between risk taking and cheating.
Another brilliant person like Mr.Sanyal in Modiji’s team. Thank you Mr.Sanjeev for serving us and our Nation
"KOLKATA DIDN'T DIE, BUT IT WAS MURDERED " has brought tears in my eyes. Being proper Calcuttan I love Kolkata more than me.
Ur watching next rbi governor, after general election, shaktikanta Das will become new finance minister, sanjeev becoming rbi governor
I think just make him Finance Minister. He's great communicator.
I have been waiting for this episode ❤
Being into finance world from many years. I can say IBC and NCLT process was a master stroke for our economy
As a bengali born on 1986 I completely agree with him. Kolkata had been murdered and it's going on even today. Bengali people are responsible as well as political parties.
Thank you so much to both host and guest for presenting me this intangible gift...knowledge..
As a chartered accountant aspirant I approve his take on direct tax complexity😅😅
CA really give boost to people's ego, that even CA aspirant is approving opinions of someone who has spend life studying economics
Your aspiration is in danger.
After ca do phd on taxation learn in depth do masters in economics another phd in economics and have 15 years of dept in economics and international taxation then come again
Ca aspreints my foot go get a life
Excellent disclosure by respected Sanyal about BIFR and bad bank and subsequently IBC. Enjoyed every bit of his interview. Being an ex senior banker I just learnt that how much this genious contributed in cleanising banks balance sheets. 22:53
what bank
Thank you so much for your kind words and for sharing your thoughts with us! We really appreciate that you were able to gain some valuable insights! 🤗
@@TheNeonShoww 🙏🙏
What clarity of thoughts ..
what unambiguous narration ..👏👏.He has his mind thoroughly into it..
Very inspiring ..all the same.
Keep going On Neon❤😊
There was a time when Calcutta used to compete with Madras as an intellectual and creative hub. Now Kolkata cannot be compared with even the shadow of Chennai.
Bengalis have forgotten their ancient links with cholas of Tamil Nadu with Sena dynasty of Karnataka
I am a Bengali from North Bengal and I know for a reason that Kolkata is gone case now. Kolkata has reached to a point of "non reversible". Can you believe that Kolkata was once 2nd most important city after London and now Kolkata is not even counted among top 10 cities in India. Communist has destroyed out beautiful city build by British Empire.
Despite the decline (mostly due to freight equalization policy) Kolkata is still the 3rd highest gdp ranked state in the country..so all this extra negativity is nothing but a agenda of the right wing bjp social media dept
@@prasunkumarray9645Kolkata is not a state. Education system was destroyed from the roots, no English no computer in govt schools and buro gulor chele meye ICSE English medium e porbe.
IT and computer were rejected. WOW 👏🏻
I beg to differ.. kolkata wasnt murdered. It committed suicide by electing politicians like Mamta Bengum to power term after term.
CPM
Atleast cpm tried with Tata. In one interview Buddha Babu in 2009 raised the point of youth running to bangalore and other cities What is the begum doing? Except few companies opening bases for support operations, ask any IT guy where they see Kolkata in 5years if this begum stays. @@koushikdas1992 may be a few more duare prokolpos.
Thanks for this conversation
Gr8 insight.. what he said about kolkata or west bengal is fact n still happenin...
Unmeasured political ambitions murdered Kolkata,the gate way of traders and suppliers of the working hands much needed in so many parts of the world.
Priviledged to know about Indian economics from economic giant like Mr. Sanyal.. Great leaders always choose best team members..
Great episode and one of the epic episodes of Neon show ig. Congratulations team.
Really nice content
One of the finest video on internet
Country is finally in safe hands 🙏 Modiji will surely get 350+ seats in 2024 lok sabha election
We all appreciate the new point of view brought in by these new minds inducted in governance by Hon. MODIJI. SANIYAL is one of those who brought such changes. Proud to get him in and he delivering the new vision
Great episode guys 👏
One of the best episodes🎉
Good optimistic video. India is doing well.
Population decline can be compensated for by healthier aging. For example, I am 88 and all my vital organs are performing like that of a young person. What is the secret? Keep your BMI at 19 - 24 and exercise for at least an hour every day. Weight gain is largely related to excessive consumption of carbohydrates. Hardening of arteries is related to excessive consumption of saturated fats and meat. Eating lots of vegetables every day keeps you much healthier. No smoking and drinking, of course.
liar
Population decline can be sorted out by people having 2 kids
Engaging content and it was amazing
Liked video❤
I was in Calcutta last week..a very dirty city..boards are every where..keep the city clean..with Mamta photo..city is dying under the cpm and tmc
সান্যাল স্যার আপনি আমাদের বাঙালির গর্ব ।
Nice analysis of the evolution of Indian economic development post-1991.
Damnn you guys are putting Bomb Episodes every week!
30:48 India went from rank 142 to 62 in Ease of Doing Busibess rankings issued by workd BNk. After that World Bank has stopped evaluating this metric and publishing a ranking. Unsure why the interviewer feels India is not amoung top 100.
Because the interviewer is dumb. THere are multiple times in interview where he makes dumb assumptions and he gets called out
Hi there, we really appreciate the correction on this and we should have done our due diligence on making the sure the research was as up to date as possible. But we are truly grateful we have viewers who are willing to point it out so that we can improve our research with each passing episode! As for the numbers themselves, the hope is that we will reach top 10 very soon even if the metric itself has stopped being evaluated!
Didnot know itna kuchh hua last 10-15 years me. Thank god I get to grow up witnessing the epic rise of India in the coming decades