True. Some partners will not take the divorce as an option. The only option they seek is death of their partner and or the family. Course, that depends on the person.
@@jessienegron3266 Explore with Us, you mean the pseudo-intellectual Jim Can't Swim copycat? This channel is way better, other than their outsourced / automated subtitles they don't clean up. But their analysis here is far superior.
"During the gathering, Claudia accused Karl of being emotionally abusive while he complained about her unwillingness to help clean the house. When the subject of divorce came up, Claudia fainted, then locked herself in the bedroom. Later that day, Claudia swallowed a bottle of pills and went out in her car. She was later involved in a car crash and charged with driving under the influence, according to Cleveland Scene." I'm sorry, this does not sound like someone who killed just because her husband was abusive. It sounds like someone who was controlling of her husband and wouldn't let him leave. Talking about abuse with a smile on your face? What? I'm not saying that he wasn't a terrible husband to her, I don't know. But her narrative is obviously going to only paint him in a bad light and her in a good or decent light. I have trouble believing that she's just a victim especially when all you get here is her side of it.
Life is too short to wake up in the morning with regrets. So love the people who treat you right, forget about the ones who don’t. And believe that everything happens for a reason. If you get a chance, take it. If it changes your life, let it. Nobody said it would be easy, just that it would be worth it
I wish I understood that advice 30 years ago, Would've saved a ton of valuable time and heartache. Now with a 6yr old of my own, it's words like this I can read to her and articulate how truthful and powerful they are in helping to live a healthy life. Took me till around 40 to understand so she's learning now !😃
Lots of us do not know love and cannot therefore show it. When people grow up insecure, they often carry that emotional baggage into every relationship. They compete with each other, playing games and one-ups-manship - easily contributing to not only break ups, but sadly murder too.
We live in a random chaotic reality. Nothing happens for a reason. Agree that you should leave ppl that aren't good for you. Just live life and be kind to the earth, our animal friends and each other.
I would have liked to hear testimonies from his ex-wife and girlfriend on how he treated them. I’d also have liked to hear testimony from the people she claimed ‘arranged’ the marriage/engagement party. The reason yI feel she was guilty is because he was getting ready to leave her and already had a place to move into, a friend told police she heard Claudia state ‘if he leaves me I’ll kill him’, and she could have easily enough taken the money out, caught a taxi to the airport and flown to Brazil without killing him.
It doesn't matter how he treated them. If this new person you meet changes you or triggers you in way you had never been triggered before, you can act totally different towards them. People from the past wouldn't be able to recognize you or your actions. I believe her when she says that he went into rage when she got pregnant. He probably thought he could treated like that because she was from Brazil. Why do you think the peruvian woman left? He couldn't afford to treat his american wife like that because she already had his children and she could destroy his life if she wanted. Child support is expensive.
I agree! And she also blames him about the abortions. Why wasn’t she taking birth control!? Not that what he allegedly did was wrong, but there were so many chances for her to leave/sneak BC.
This narrator always has me coming back , I feel so familiar now to his voice so respectful , no one is allowed to talk to me when I’m watching his videos , THANK YOU from uk 🇬🇧🇺🇸😉
@@Narrator_JasonForbiswhoa. I really thought this was AI. Knowing it’s not is all the more reason to watch. You might have restored a tiny bit of my faith in humanity. Thanks!
The fact that he already had a new place to live all set up ... the fact that he had a bag packed in the car to leave ... and the fact that she shot him twice in the back as he was trying to get away from her blows all her "Woe is me. I'm an abused, trapped victim" stories out of the water.
Yes I agree- that alone says it all…and then on top of that, there was even more to prove she is a killer, not an abuse victim. It’s scary to see how many people in the comments believe this manipulative woman…thank god the jury focused on evidence over stories.
What a wake up call - watching the interrogation and seeing the responses I don't actually feel I would personally always be able to sense manipulation. That's why I watch things like this, I've experienced enough of it (PTSD after long term forms of abuse) and often I find familiarity in the speech of people convicted. It makes me wonder how many times I was too close to the wrong people in my life, and made it out by luck without knowing.
I think she was abused at some point in her life. He may have been controlling and a sexual deviant. However, her actions weren’t justified. I think we tend to forget that there can still be truth to what a guilty person says. PTSD really messes with people’s impulsivity too.
This narrator is the best. He's definitely going to be moving on to bigger and better projects. Not to take anything away from this channel, because it is all very well done.. I appreciate all the videos and wish everybody working on this channel great success.
I'm sure the dead guy really appreciated it, especially before turning his murder into a youtube spectacle for bored teenagers. If "respect for the victim " was legitimately meant the video wouldn't exist..
@@dissraps People like you irritate me. He gives condolences to the victim's family and tells the facts. He doesn't glamorize it or make things gory. Do you think crimes should never make the news? That we have no right to know any history? And bored teenagers aren't the demographic that are interested in True Crime. Try +30
Narcissists love being interrogated. They know they have a captive audience that will pay devout attention to everything they choose to ramble on for hours on. They become the center of attention.
Why did she giggle/laugh when she said she put the fetus in a glass jar in the freezer because she wanted to bury it. Also, she said that the ultrasound did not show a fetus, it showed an empty sac so how did she hear a plunge in the toilet and pick up a fetus out of the toilet bowl water if there was no fetus in her uterus? 🤔
@anonymouspeople4896 you're quite right. When I had a miscarriage, the nurses thought I was delusional because the ultrasound indicated there was no baby in the uterus. A doctor then checked physically and took out the foetus.
This is the best channel in the genre by far. You post a lot and I still want you to post more. I’ve watched almost every video already lol.. these videos and stories are so well put together it keeps it interesting for the full length of the video. Never get bored here, thank you for your work. Love coming home at night to watch these stories.
I've heard other documentaries about this case, and you such a great job! The respect to the loved ones of the victim, the straight facts, no entertainment towards the murder... it's all perfect!
Very rarely do I side with the perpetrator but this one really has me questioning the entire trial and outcome. We have rapists, child molesters, teen killers, parents killing their children, etc, getting lesser sentences or getting acquitted, able to appeal and win those appeals bc of some minor technicality, etc etc etc. but this is justice? It seems like the prosecutors felt that making an example of someone who evaded capture and the first to be extradited from Brazil for a crime…deserved an unfair trial and badgering on the stand. Americans can kill their children or spouses, can rape anyone, but if one detail isn’t 100% fact… they are acquitted. (Unless they’re a minority then of course they’re guilty). Sickening.
@@kergr1603 so you really think asking someone to answer a question is a bad thing? She bought the gun and trained with it and killed him, she could have just left with the $9900 and all was good.. They were yes and no questions is all... All that other conjecture you threw out there had no bearing on this case although I do agree with the stuff
Why does he just keep screaming the same question at her over and over again when she says she doesn't understand? Saying it louder isn't going to clarify the poor wording of that confusing ass question. Very unprofessional on his part even with how guilty she was. I feel like this case was handled poorly in court.
I can't say how appreciative I am to hear you send your condolences. It reminds us all that this isn't just a scary story and many lives were changed because of this. Thank you for that.
exactly, this isn’t like the other true crime channels sensationalizing the case and making it purely content instead of honoring those who lost their lives. love this channel !
@@vannahmae7413 dawg in most videos they give their condolences and follow it with an ad-read for mobile game. this is way worse than not saying anything imo
I loathe the channels with clickbait titles such as "MOM TRAMPLES HER FOUR YEAR OLD TO DEATH". So effing insensitive. I really appreciate this channel.
I would bet anything , that when Carl called her " the love of his life" , he might actually believe it, but in reality all she was, was the best looking girl, that had ever given him attention. Our brains make us think, that we " love" good looking people. It's attraction, not love
Was there any friends and family that could speak about their relationship? I could grasp a better opinion if there were any interviews from family and friends who more likely had insight into this marriage. I think this channel could have shown those, if available. Thank you for sharing your time and effort you all have put into this video as well as the other videos. Great channel. God Bless
It’s irrelevant. Imagine if a man tried to use the same defenses in court after killing their wife? “She talked to me mean…. So I killed her”. Like come on now
@@93ajcollier Good morning Andrew. My comment, well, opinion, merely reflects on the vidoe(s) and they are put together for viewers to watch. Gathering testimonials first hand. Meaning that the people who are in direct contact and or communication with the subjects in question. Watching interviews and or testimonials makes for a better video and gives the viewers a more in depth look into the behaviors and a better understanding on why. Have a great day Andrew.
Many thanks for the coverage on this sad case. One small maths item. She will be eligible for parole in 2044, yes, but that doesn't equate to her age being 101. 79 or 80, I believe. Minor detail but just thought I would mention it.
I noticed that and I also don't understand how she will be eligible for parole in 2044. He said that she will be eligible after 28 years and she was convicted in 2019. That means she should be eligible for parole in 2047 when she's 82.
I watch alot of true crime,but this channel is at the top of the list. I find narrator's with accents difficult to understand so I thank you for speaking clearly. I enjoy the mixture of interrogation & court room "best moments" video's that you include. Your videos are informative without being boring. For example I personally don't care where he/she went to public school,or if they had a pony if it doesn't relate to the story. I have a short attention span so I just want the facts. Well done sir! You tic all the boxes for this viewer! Thank you! ⭐👍🇨🇦
@@koala6915 Aussie chicks rule. Hope you're all subbed to Disturban, Bizaare Bazaar, and The Disturban Truth. If not, get on em....💙❤🌏💙❤🌏. You'll thank me later.
I’m from Melbourne too. I send my condolences to the family of this crime. He was a very handsome man he had a lot to offer the right women unfortunately he got with the wrong women. I’ve been abused and had violence in a relationship l didn’t murder l just left.
I'm really sorry that this happened to this young man. I did notice that he had been married three times and they never even lasted 2 years. There must be a reason.
Sure there is. One being his choice in women based on their looks alone. That's one first thing that will make a woman feel unseen, emotionally neglected and miserable.
@@caddieohm7059 Enough to make her feel unseen, emotionally neglected, and miserable...but not enough to keep her from marrying him or enough to convince her it's okay to divorce him? What a twisted pretzel of absurd victim-blaming nonsense.
She is not only guilty but a horrible liar too. She not only ran (extremely guilty move) she also just made up lies and assassinated his character with stuff she knew no one could prove which is just plain evil
This channel has all of the same great qualities that make a lot of other channels popular too, but Beyond Evil has its own unique personality and signature style that sets it apart from the rest (I wish I could put my finger on why!) Happy Saturday, everyone!
@@crystal6368 I’m so shocked to see you say that! My grandson (12yrs old) always exaggerates that song while he makes fun of me for watching this, cuz he hears me binging it late at night when he stays over! Lol! How funny you mentioned that. I can’t wait to show him this comment! It will be a really fun moment for us, so thank you! 😂 Happy holidays from Las Vegas
@@crystal6368 (P.S. did you realize the girl in the song was saying “credulous gal?” I looked it up because my grandson thought it was saying something about love bomb, Lol)
I believe a large part of her story. The quick proposal, the "surprise" engagement party, convincing her to leave her successful career & move to his home town...all red flags of an abusive person. Then the fact that he didn't want to marry the "love of his life" because she wanted children makes me believe that he would be very angry when Claudia got pregnant. But none of that excuses his murder. She should have simply left him.
I agree with you, He seems to be a man fixated on specifics, it's not a coincidence that all his girlfriend's and ex-wife looked the same, he's seems to be into a woman more for their beauty than personality. I think he decided to divorce her after she got pregnant twice and in his eyes, she's damaged goods, therefore, in need of a replacement.
So that justifies him being shot in his head and twice in the back?? Yes the abuse no matter how bad it was he is not here to defend himself and his side cus SHE MURDERED HIM!??
Wow I am at awe at how many ppls comments are ok with how she just makes him look like a monster and all she is doing is with no emotion about the allegations of of how “abusive” he was wow🤯 👿
@@mindurbiznezz I'm not saying she has any right to murder him, but I am acknowledging the fact a series of disgusting behaviour on his part played a role in her losing control.
She’s guilty and she admits that she’s guilty, however, if I had been married to someone who treated me like that, he’d be a very dead man. I went through that and worse when I was younger and I wasn’t worldly enough to know better. I finally escaped almost losing my life… never again. I’m older and much wiser now and any man who makes me abort my children, tells me what I can and can’t wear, what I can and can’t eat, wants me to have sex with anyone and everyone he chooses while he’s doing it too… if I try to leave him, it’s best for him to allow me to leave in peace, otherwise, say his prayers because he’s good as gone. I’ll never allow a man to control me and everything I do again! It’s very sad and unfortunate, but I believe most of what she’s claiming and I think he was a sexual deviant with control issues and an extremely selfish man.
I agree. Obviously there’s no excuse for killing someone out of anger, but at the same time a person can only take so much abuse before something breaks inside of them. The straw that broke the camel’s back, so to speak. I know from personal experience that there are few things more painful that having the person you love tell you to commit suicide. Especially after she’d been put through at least one pregnancy and abortion. Sometimes victims are, themselves, terrible people.
Mmmm I’m not so sure ……she had the resources to buy a gun and learn how to use it, that costs money she was also able to leave the country after the murder which means she had access to money…..he had rented a place to live and was due to move in within three days. He was in the airforce which meant there were times he may have been away from home if it was as violent as she says she could have ran…..
NEVER say anything to the police, do not answer questions. Keep silent. ALWAYS have a lawyer. Keep a phone number of a good criminal lawyer in your phone/wallet.
I saw this on a TV show before where his friends and family all denied her claims of abuse and how he treated her like a queen! He gave her money all the time and she was constantly shopping and using all of his money towards herself and she was not even paying the bills. It was on investigation Discovery where I saw this case before. So her accounts of him being abusive are completely wrong!
@@LIBERTYSINCURSION have you ever, in the your entire life ever been mad at this person before you shot them? Were you or were you not upset with them 15 years ago for drinking the last coca cola and not replacing it? Yes or no. YES OR NO
@@user-jd8nn2lq5e I shouldn't laugh at this but literally that's how his questioning went🤣. Like what?! I would be confused too. And people can hold grudges for decades.
@@ThisIsJ.Nicole right?? Like imagine how many people she's been mad at in her life and yet only one ended up murdered 🤔 I hope all of them, including the kid who kicked her sand castle over when she was 3 is in witness protection right now
I learned about this case from a video This is Monsters published. I’m blown away by how much more detail your video contains & just overall how well you presented the case.
I really appreciate your channel: it feels so informative & educational, but you also bring recognition to the victims in a way that doesn’t feel like you’re exploiting them. It’s important that their stories and legacy’s are heard, so thank you for that. I hope to see one of my late friends on your channel 🤍
If they did, she might have seized up and stopped talking freely. These types think they're charming the room; so it's best to let them flap their mouths into a thorough confession. I don't even need to hear the entire tape to know that she has no conscious. She behaved like she's just talking about some harmless teen adventure. Sociopaths often do that.
the math at the end is a little wrong. Claudia was born in 1964 so she will be eligible for parole at the age of around 80 in 2044. She will not be close to 101 years old.
Seriously. That prosecutor had me heated. "Just answer yes or no". Umm...sometimes a response is a lot more nuanced than a "yes" or a "no". Especially when the questions are leading and obviously apparent to elicit a certain feeling for the jury. It was almost like gaslighting her on stand. Fuck prosecutors. They are just as corrupt as cops and the rest of the judicial system.
As a victim of domestic violence, I believe her. Her entire story. Yes I believe she killed him and I am sorry for his family. She also may not needed to kill him to save herself but I know she immediately flashed back to all the horrible things he did and the children she was grieving.
I believe she is guilty because she claims that he begged her to stay with him, even though he had rented a house and was ready to move out. I have seen this behavior from narcissists many times. I'm sure she does have recordings of him losing it after months of gaslighting, manipulation and devaluing him. I also don't believe for one minute that she paid all the bills. She stated that she had to buy all of his clothes, yet, he chose all of her clothes. Someone that controlling doesn't let another person buy their clothes. One other really big inconsistency is that she claims she intended to kill herself but she took $9900 and moved it to an account in Brazil before killing him. I also believe she threatened to kill herself on a regular basis as a manipulation tactic. It's very possible that she killed him because he told her to go ahead and do it, but it is more likely she planned it.
As a lady who has had multiple partners physically abuse her, not one of them ever threw me a party or let me spend their money. She is a narcissist and a liar
I mean then you’re lucky but let’s not say it absolutely can’t happen based on *your* personal experience. Because that sort of the behavior is almost the norm in my eyes.
To be fair, mine did. But he used that money against me as well, every chance he got. I wasn’t allowed to work, he wanted to “take care of me” but ended up financially abusing me. He threw parties for every event, to everyone else he was the life of the party and everybody’s best friend. Abusers do not abuse everyone around them, or they’d all know.
As someone that was abused by an ex, periodically after abusive episodes he would love bomb me with affection, expensive gifts and trips to Europe. Abusers can do this.
She claimed to the court that she had 2 years worth of solidly abusive recordings of him and she called the lawyers out for lying because they rendered her recordings inadmissable. Is this true?? Does anyone know?
Lawyers can't render judgments as to what is or is not admissible. The judge does that. It's possible that her "recordings" were judged to be "hearsay" since there is no one to be able to rebut what she says when she makes her own recordings.
@@TrulyJefferson Ok, I know what you mean but you didn't answer my question. If there are years worth of recordings of this man. I think that hearing his voice and statements for hours on end though inadmissable would be Very telling and could corroborate her claims... I had a girlfriend back in the day who used to say and do some insane and way out of control sx-t and I had a home security system that caught her behavior. She tried to make dinner claims that I abused her and I sent those "illegally" to her parents and within 2 days magically the investigator contacted me and told me that she dropped her case. I'm sure my recordings were "inadmissable" but I see that one they got out they massively saved my axs... I understand your legal explanation but I want to know if she really has those recordings and where they might be. It could tell allot about his character regardless of how they were obtained...
I'm not sure about states laws but they should have a way to annull a marriage within the first year without being expensive, complicated and time consuming.
You obviously have never been married. There is wide spectrum of abuse that isn't physical. Marriage is an ever evolving thing you must be seriously committed to or it fails...
@@aleyahaforlife first year? What if it occured years down the road? And it's not expensive, complicated and time consuming for everyone, which is the problem but perhaps not quite enough so for the abusing person.
I would have loved to hear her recordings of how he actually was with her. Pretty crap they weren't allowed in court. (Reminded me of JD and turds libel. They should have been able to submit them as evidenced) 🤷🏼♀️
@@lingling903 I think some of these people literally didn’t see the ending of the video. Baffles me that anyone would think she has any portion of innocence. Yea maybe she was abused but if theres no police report towards that or anything and she just shoots him (with a laser aiming tool) i find that extreeeemely hard to believe. Plus she has the same traits of master manipulators that have killed. “You know I’m smart”. “I would never lie to you” yea b1tch.
Depends on recording laws in the state it occured. I love in a one party state and it would most likely be admissable. But laws are inconsistent throughout different areas...
What shit that they weren’t! They had been fighting extradition for years. Her trial was unfair as soon as she landed on American soil, and we all know it whether some will admit it or not is a different story.
Narcissisim at it's finest. She says "I'm a forgiving person' , yet you shot the man dead and escaped to another country to evade the consequencs. That is a contradiction if I have ever heard one. That dosen't sound like forgiveness to me.
This woman is so at peace and cool with the situation that gives me a strange and odd feeling that there is smth very much wrong with her. She reminds me of Nico Claux ,not bcs what they did was same but the way they speak and tell their stories as if it was all natural and normal.
because she killed him years ago, and obviously had a reason to. You want her to cry and shit her pants over a man who didn’t even respect her in the slightest? Okay
@@adoboflav4skin I don't know how he treated her, bcs I wasn't there and nor were you. What I do know is that in the meantime they have invented the divorce and no one is forced to stay where they don't want to stay . Get updated.
@@adoboflav4skinimagine being murdered FROM BEHIND no chance to defend yourself, being left like trash in your own home and then your murderer evading justice for a decade only to come back and destroy your character to everyone without anyone giving you a chance to defend your side. You are believing a story that she had to spend 10 years crafting over evidence.
True narcissist to the core Smart enough to know she needs a lawyer but crazy enough to think she’s smartest one in room and can talk her way out of it
If he was abusive and controlling, then I totally feel for her, and part of me can understand how she would "snap" like that. But the fact that she left and started a new life for so many years does make it seem like she was cold hearted with no remorse.
Exactly, there's such a thing as divorce. As tough and miserable as it is, everyone comes out alive, and gets to start again. There's no excuse for murdering your partner, except self defence - and there's no evidence this was such a case. I find her a very unconvincing defendant, and there's no corroborating evidence he was the abusive brute she claims. His ex wife was on friendly terms, and he was a much loved father. I think she not only killed him in a coldly premeditated attack, she trashed his reputation when he was no longer here to defend it. She's pretty disgusting, and I'm convinced she's in the best place, behind bars.
It's quite obvious there's nothing to her abuse allegations. That's something you say right away, not years after the fact when you're backed into a corner.
42:16 this is the most leading line of questioning I have seen so far! I’m surprised her attorney didn’t object to leading. They were clearly trying to establish that it wasn’t a heat of the moment killing, but asking questions of no relevance, that she’s even objecting to!
You are allowed to ask leading questions on cross examination. Of course they were trying to establish that it wasnt heat of the moment... they want her found guilty of 1st degree murder. The witness does not get to determine the relevance of questions... the jury does (and to the extent it is non-relevant, the judge can prohibit those questions). They actually do a pretty good job because they establish from her testimony that she wasnt upset before shooting him, which contradicts her defense that it was heat of the moment.
listening to her story, i dont know how anybody could do anything else. she sure sounds honest, eye contact, clear speech, etc. after hearing so much from women i know, i think sometimes the control ends up in a "you or me" decision and some choose "you" like this woman did. how you can send a person away for life without listening to every piece of evidence has always blown me away.
As a woman I will say this, as I tell my brothers. Women are extremely prone to lying and can twist anything to make themselves look good. Excellent actresses and story tellers. I don't believe any woman unless I see concrete evidence. Our bull sh*T is SECOND TO NONE.
I agree, if she really had recordings of him being abusive than why weren't they played? Everyone has secrets and are someone else in the privacy of their own home.
I think it was both. He forcibly made her marry him, made her do weird things, i.e., walk around the house naked, etc, watched porn and he made her get abortions because he didn't want anymore children. He took her from her home and comfort zone in NY. And in her eyes (in my opinion) he was going to commit an absolute atrocity and leave her. I would never ever condone murder, not ever. But even though she couldn't exactly prove it in the right manner, she killed him because of mental and physical abuse. I feel for the family, but the guy was no saint. Again granted she should have just left and went to Brazil in the first place, but you don't expect the person you've just married (half involuntarily) to treat you that way after taking you through so many unexpected changes especially when he told you that some of the changes wouldn't occur. I just don't like that his family acts like he was some type of saint.
@@kittykat2003uk Her hubby, the victim was born past 1960. Unless u suppose she is old enough to be his mother, it is simply wrong, not to mention that she did not look in her 70s during the interrogations and trial.
She got pregnant 3 times with a man who was up front about not wanting more children. He was fresh out of a relationship where he voiced his fear and lack of commitment. His first wife still had a friendly relationship with him. He had made arrangements to move out of the marital home. Who cares about abortions, or heals, or sex toys? This women was not used to be told no and could not handle rejection.
Claudia's lawyer needed to shut down the prosecution' injecting "before you shot him" into every question. The relation to the shooting was irrelevant, it wasn't a question of "were you upset before, during, or after the marriage" it was solely a means to yell "you shot him" for minutes straight under the guise of questioning. And particularly loaded statements "[were] you angry, [before] you shot him, [X]" . Straight up character assassination during the questioning. Its fairer than her husband got, but keep jury manipulation civil in the courtroom.
@@lonestar1637 she sent money to her family in Brazil on a regular basis. Also if you watch the actual trial you’ll see that she also researched suicide with that gun and also bought & installed a suicide device to make up for the recoil. As to the above comment- yes recoil is something you consider when you are considering suicide. The recoil can make the gun jump & instead of being dead you can end up just doing a lot of brain damage and shooting off half your face but surviving which no one would want.
@@lonestar1637 also- she went to the bank the day before & sent that $9900 to her family. You know what she didn’t do? Get her passport. She left her passport in the safety deposit box where it was. If she was planning to kill him & flee the country she would have grabbed that too. Instead after killing him she had to go to the bank again to get her passport. She’s absolutely being honest.
You just cracked me up. However, she said the laser was to help her at the gun range while "practicing" how to get acquainted with the recoil. Hahahaa! That darned recoil !!
If he trapped her, why did someone testify that she said to them “if he leaves me, I’ll kill him”, the scene indicates he was leaving and walking away- the shooting from the top of the stairs, that he had a packed suitcase in his car and had arranged alternate living for himself. None of that indicates she was trapped and abused by HIM. Also, things like how she says ‘I don’t have tattoos’ as if it indicates a better moral character, destroys his reputation, claims he was bisexual… you name it.
Seeing murderers act so matter of fact with their crime really gets me thinking about how normal the people around me at work seem, and how there’s one of them that’s one bad day away from murdering someone.
The prosecutors line of questioning is leading. She is saying that no she wasn't upset about the things he was asking at that very moment. But the way he is trying to get her to answer his questions he's leading her to say she did it out of anger.
As someone else remarked she’s had 12 years to perfect her story - fought indictment all the way so then the battered wife plea was her next option. It’s interesting how the victim was the one who was preparing to leave the marriage after two years …. And already had another place set up to move into…doesn’t sound like a domineering, controlling, dictator- type partner to me- sounds like someone who wants out and has had enough !!!!!! I don’t believe her at all-the jury got it right - it would have been revealing for viewers fir his children, brother, parents to have had some input - we weren’t privy to any of that unfortunately ( even victim statements??!)…. The guy had a record of diligence and service, and we would have to have clear evidence that he ‘never wanted children’ from his family !!! Bottom line she painted him so badly and only the rest of his family know close to the truth… her words were all rehearsed as I read her
Thank you. Finally someone that has sense instead of all these morons in the comments section defending her like she didn't plan on killing this man in cold blood. A liar she is. Like she could've just left him and gone to Brazil without killing him. I can't believe these bunch of empty headed followers are defeding her. Absurd!!!!
Weird how she doesn't have much of an accent during the interrogation but on the stand it comes out thick so she can convince the fact that she didn't understand English much
Thu killing someone is not the answer, same thing happened to our neighbor in the Philippines. She married someone who controlled everything. Her husband didn't give her anything and not even money to buy her basic needs, they lived in this really nice house and from the outside they were living a perfect life. All of the sudden one morning we just heard that the husband was killed.
Even if they can’t be used in court can she get the audio files leaked? They’re her files and her defense would have had them. I think we’re missing a huge part of the story.
Nah, they would have been like her testimony, all over the place. He was leaving her, she was free, but she didn't want that, so she killed him and then fled the country. She was free to leave the country without killing him. Bu she needed to get the murder in first.
@@RaphaelDawkinsCombatRadio Yup. Isn't it disturbing how inclined women seem to be when another woman says she was the victim? I mean, all she had to do is mention a non existent recording and they're like, "We don't have the whole story. Even though the evidence points at her, she was probably the victim". I guarantee that if the sex's were reversed, they would think the man was guilty. My favorite is when a man commits a horrible crime, they go right to, " I hope he gets brutally, analy raped in prison". All the while they complain about how America has a problem with rape culture. I get that not all women think this way but it is way too common for comfort.
This certainly wasn't an aggravated murder, this was premeditated murder. Prosecutors and detectives didn't do their homework properly. She takes on shooting classes with laser pointer attached to the gun, very clearly not meant for self inflicting harm. She had already booked a flight ticket and knew exactly what she was doing. (Which the detectives should have digged the information of when she brought the plane tickets, which would have proved that it was premeditated.) Why didn't she not approach police or call 911 for abuse or domestic violence, in the entirety of two years of their marriage. (Which again proves that there was no abuse by the victim) Why would someone elope to Brazil immediately after murdering your spouse, and settling there, starting her own business, and remarrying immediately after murdering their spouse. (If they were so depressed about abuse, nobody would have rushed into another marriage in the first place.) During the interrogation, her lies were so dummy, that a kindergarten kid could beat her with their stories of fairies and unicorns. (She thought people were dumb and naive to buy her story) Good for putting where she belongs. She is a demon disguised in human form.
Ughhhhhhh I agree with everyone about her words getting twisted etc etc. That trial footage is infuriating and frustrating to watch and listen to. Shitty men standing up for other shitty men without hearing the entire story. I also hope she can get a retrial and is allowed to use her recordings as evidence. She also needs a defender and someone to help with the language barriers.
The amount of people supporting this woman is disgusting. No abuse victim retells their trauma with a smile on their face. I swear, people see a woman murder a man, most believe her and feel sympathy. A man murders a woman no matter what, he’s a monster and gets no sympathy. It’s crazy how that logic works for people like you. Also, how are you going to bring up men standing up for men when so many women (including you, probably) are defending this woman, despite her lies being very visible? Women ☕️
I'm shocked at how many commenters believe her story of abuse. It's all hearsay; where's the evidence of abuse? And if that were the case she had plenty of opportunity to flee when her husband was away for training. Attaching a laser to the gun to kill herself? Come on, put your thinking caps on folks!
The amount of people defending her actions in this comment section is disgusting. Most of them saying they believe her because it 'sounds like' typical abusive behavior. No witnesses to back her up, no police reports, no medical records AND he was the one getting ready to leave. She's a liar and a murderer and she's exactly where she belongs.
In my humble opinion, the think that tilts my decision is when he rented a house for him to move into. If he was such a deviant and a control freak, why would he move away from the ability to keep up this pattern! I'm not buying her story!
“I got a laser scope so I can pinpoint exactly where the bullet will go into my skull”🤣 this girl out her mind.. she really thought this was a good story to get away with it
I am 43 and single and sometimes it feels like its better to be alone than marrying a wrong person and ending up in miseries or grave.
Imagine not only being murdered by your spouse but also being blamed for causing your own death when you cannot defend yourself.
I am 53 and my advice to you is stay single. Don't even think about looking for the other half. You are whole by yourself.
43 is quite young. I think you’ll find the right person some day. Just gotta make yourself available.
Don't listen no evil stay single.
ALWAYS! go with your Gut! If ur 1st thought is no? Then no! It is pretty Sweet being Alone and ultra safe! Find a balance! ✌
This is so sad. It is SO dangerous. Once it is known that a divorce is eminent, and one person does not agree, you just have to get out then.
and not tell the person one bit of your plans
What is sad is this person smearing the reputation of the very person she murdered all over the court
@@chelseagirl278 I think at the end of the day no one thinks their loved one could be this evil.
Exactly! Pull a Katie Holmes lol
True. Some partners will not take the divorce as an option. The only option they seek is death of their partner and or the family. Course, that depends on the person.
A very well explained story. Almost like she has had years to think of the most perfect story. Lol
Thats the first thing I thought honestly
The irony is she talked herself into a conviction. I'd like to know what evidence they even had on her besides the fact that she had fled the scene.
It’s also funny that she still admitted to killing him without cause without realizing it
The narrator on this show has the best voice for storytelling!
Thats because u haven't heard the channel explore with us ✋😍
@@jessienegron3266 its probably the same guy
It's ai
@@jessienegron3266Are you a EWU Crew member also? 💯💯👍 I love it when a new one comes out? ❤😂
@@jessienegron3266 Explore with Us, you mean the pseudo-intellectual Jim Can't Swim copycat? This channel is way better, other than their outsourced / automated subtitles they don't clean up. But their analysis here is far superior.
"During the gathering, Claudia accused Karl of being emotionally abusive while he complained about her unwillingness to help clean the house. When the subject of divorce came up, Claudia fainted, then locked herself in the bedroom.
Later that day, Claudia swallowed a bottle of pills and went out in her car. She was later involved in a car crash and charged with driving under the influence, according to Cleveland Scene."
I'm sorry, this does not sound like someone who killed just because her husband was abusive. It sounds like someone who was controlling of her husband and wouldn't let him leave. Talking about abuse with a smile on your face? What? I'm not saying that he wasn't a terrible husband to her, I don't know. But her narrative is obviously going to only paint him in a bad light and her in a good or decent light. I have trouble believing that she's just a victim especially when all you get here is her side of it.
Life is too short to wake up in the morning with regrets. So love the people who treat you right, forget about the ones who don’t. And believe that everything happens for a reason. If you get a chance, take it. If it changes your life, let it. Nobody said it would be easy, just that it would be worth it
Needed this today 🙌🏻 thank you
❤
I wish I understood that advice 30 years ago, Would've saved a ton of valuable time and heartache. Now with a 6yr old of my own, it's words like this I can read to her and articulate how truthful and powerful they are in helping to live a healthy life. Took me till around 40 to understand so she's learning now !😃
Lots of us do not know love and cannot therefore show it. When people grow up insecure, they often carry that emotional baggage into every relationship. They compete with each other, playing games and one-ups-manship - easily contributing to not only break ups, but sadly murder too.
We live in a random chaotic reality. Nothing happens for a reason. Agree that you should leave ppl that aren't good for you. Just live life and be kind to the earth, our animal friends and each other.
I would have liked to hear testimonies from his ex-wife and girlfriend on how he treated them. I’d also have liked to hear testimony from the people she claimed ‘arranged’ the marriage/engagement party. The reason yI feel she was guilty is because he was getting ready to leave her and already had a place to move into, a friend told police she heard Claudia state ‘if he leaves me I’ll kill him’, and she could have easily enough taken the money out, caught a taxi to the airport and flown to Brazil without killing him.
Agreed
I think it’s kinda irrelevant, the dude was going to leave her, moving out, so he was going to leave her alone. So no justification for his murder.
It doesn't matter how he treated them. If this new person you meet changes you or triggers you in way you had never been triggered before, you can act totally different towards them. People from the past wouldn't be able to recognize you or your actions. I believe her when she says that he went into rage when she got pregnant. He probably thought he could treated like that because she was from Brazil. Why do you think the peruvian woman left? He couldn't afford to treat his american wife like that because she already had his children and she could destroy his life if she wanted. Child support is expensive.
I agree! And she also blames him about the abortions. Why wasn’t she taking birth control!? Not that what he allegedly did was wrong, but there were so many chances for her to leave/sneak BC.
I find it very sus that she could talk about all of this with a smile on her face
This narrator always has me coming back , I feel so familiar now to his voice so respectful , no one is allowed to talk to me when I’m watching his videos , THANK YOU from uk 🇬🇧🇺🇸😉
Thank you for your kind words :)
@@Narrator_JasonForbis oh you're the narrator? Receive my love from Nairobi, Kenya 🇰🇪. You do some impressive work
@@Narrator_JasonForbis you are most welcome 🤗
@@Narrator_JasonForbiswhoa. I really thought this was AI. Knowing it’s not is all the more reason to watch. You might have restored a tiny bit of my faith in humanity. Thanks!
@@TheUKMediaWatch I fall asleep listening to you a lot 😂
The fact that he already had a new place to live all set up ... the fact that he had a bag packed in the car to leave ... and the fact that she shot him twice in the back as he was trying to get away from her blows all her "Woe is me. I'm an abused, trapped victim" stories out of the water.
Yes I agree- that alone says it all…and then on top of that, there was even more to prove she is a killer, not an abuse victim. It’s scary to see how many people in the comments believe this manipulative woman…thank god the jury focused on evidence over stories.
@@BackrowErnie they literally withheld her evidence….
So you don't believe she was abused?
@@lydiamond12 nope doesn't sound that way and i do not believe her either..
@@lydiamond12 too much PROOF AGAINST HER
What a wake up call - watching the interrogation and seeing the responses I don't actually feel I would personally always be able to sense manipulation. That's why I watch things like this, I've experienced enough of it (PTSD after long term forms of abuse) and often I find familiarity in the speech of people convicted. It makes me wonder how many times I was too close to the wrong people in my life, and made it out by luck without knowing.
100% agree
I think she was abused at some point in her life. He may have been controlling and a sexual deviant. However, her actions weren’t justified. I think we tend to forget that there can still be truth to what a guilty person says. PTSD really messes with people’s impulsivity too.
Same and I won’t have another relationship again.
Same
Saaaame😢 Take care of yourself. These charming liar narcissists/psycho/sociopathic men&women have been lying since they were children
This narrator is the best. He's definitely going to be moving on to bigger and better projects. Not to take anything away from this channel, because it is all very well done.. I appreciate all the videos and wish everybody working on this channel great success.
Thank you for your kind words :)
100% the narrator is awesome. So you don't think the narrator will stick around with the channel? I hope he does!
Yeah his voice is destined for true crime shows, one of the best I’ve ever heard.
I hope he stays. This channel wavered back and forth for quite some time. This narrator is the best.
@@itsruckaswife7036 I just mean that I think that his talent will take him far. But yes I also hope he stays!
Thank you for your respect of the victims. Another very well done video. Nice work.
Do you know the victim?
TRUMP IS A BOZO
In this case, the v!ctim was a narcissist s3xual deviance so he deserve no respect. Thank God he's gone.
I'm sure the dead guy really appreciated it, especially before turning his murder into a youtube spectacle for bored teenagers.
If "respect for the victim " was legitimately meant the video wouldn't exist..
@@dissraps People like you irritate me. He gives condolences to the victim's family and tells the facts. He doesn't glamorize it or make things gory. Do you think crimes should never make the news? That we have no right to know any history?
And bored teenagers aren't the demographic that are interested in True Crime. Try +30
This just shows you that even when you have 10 years to come up with a story, it's really hard to create an effective lie
Narcissists love being interrogated. They know they have a captive audience that will pay devout attention to everything they choose to ramble on for hours on. They become the center of attention.
Nailed it!
Yes, this is pure performance
I guess shes going home in jail then :)
But narcissists shouldn't be indulged quite so much the way the editor and producer of this film did.
@@stevebbuk I agree with you
Why did she giggle/laugh when she said she put the fetus in a glass jar in the freezer because she wanted to bury it. Also, she said that the ultrasound did not show a fetus, it showed an empty sac so how did she hear a plunge in the toilet and pick up a fetus out of the toilet bowl water if there was no fetus in her uterus? 🤔
Anything's possible when you lie.
It's possible that an ultrasound will show no details because of a large amount of blood obscuring the image.
I agree with the above statement and also the fetus could have already moved down past the uterus getting ready to miscarry, speaking from experience
@anonymouspeople4896 you're quite right. When I had a miscarriage, the nurses thought I was delusional because the ultrasound indicated there was no baby in the uterus. A doctor then checked physically and took out the foetus.
I know this one!! I know this one!! the answer is: she is a liar ☝️😊
Best true crime channel on UA-cam hands down!
I'm with you on this 💯
I like Trace Evidence.
Let's not go crazy
What about THAT CHAPTER?
Yea Iagree sab
bruh do you even JCS?
This is the best channel in the genre by far. You post a lot and I still want you to post more. I’ve watched almost every video already lol.. these videos and stories are so well put together it keeps it interesting for the full length of the video. Never get bored here, thank you for your work. Love coming home at night to watch these stories.
I love that you always pay respect to the victims and their families. I love your channel and how you present content. Keep up the great work!
For money you fool
I've heard other documentaries about this case, and you such a great job! The respect to the loved ones of the victim, the straight facts, no entertainment towards the murder... it's all perfect!
If badgering a person on the stand ever needed a video to show you why you need a good lawyer to look out for you on the stand
this is it.
Stay off the stand is an option
Defense attorney I guess disagrees with you.. They are simple yes or no questions, the judge should have instructed her to answer as such
Very rarely do I side with the perpetrator but this one really has me questioning the entire trial and outcome. We have rapists, child molesters, teen killers, parents killing their children, etc, getting lesser sentences or getting acquitted, able to appeal and win those appeals bc of some minor technicality, etc etc etc. but this is justice? It seems like the prosecutors felt that making an example of someone who evaded capture and the first to be extradited from Brazil for a crime…deserved an unfair trial and badgering on the stand. Americans can kill their children or spouses, can rape anyone, but if one detail isn’t 100% fact… they are acquitted. (Unless they’re a minority then of course they’re guilty). Sickening.
@Ker Gr I hate to agree 💯
@@kergr1603 so you really think asking someone to answer a question is a bad thing? She bought the gun and trained with it and killed him, she could have just left with the $9900 and all was good.. They were yes and no questions is all... All that other conjecture you threw out there had no bearing on this case although I do agree with the stuff
Why does he just keep screaming the same question at her over and over again when she says she doesn't understand? Saying it louder isn't going to clarify the poor wording of that confusing ass question. Very unprofessional on his part even with how guilty she was. I feel like this case was handled poorly in court.
They want to piss ya off on the stand that's a win for them
Agreed!!
@@peggypasson8794 They want to piss off the OTHER PERSON, not themselves. It just made him look unprofessional.
Agreed!
She was lying about not understanding. Good grief people..
I can't say how appreciative I am to hear you send your condolences. It reminds us all that this isn't just a scary story and many lives were changed because of this. Thank you for that.
exactly, this isn’t like the other true crime channels sensationalizing the case and making it purely content instead of honoring those who lost their lives. love this channel !
@@vannahmae7413 dawg in most videos they give their condolences and follow it with an ad-read for mobile game. this is way worse than not saying anything imo
I loathe the channels with clickbait titles such as "MOM TRAMPLES HER FOUR YEAR OLD TO DEATH". So effing insensitive. I really appreciate this channel.
They all do it for views and money.
You have to be sick to find joy in telling horrible stories all day.
Were messed up for watching them
@@christopheviens6468agree
I would bet anything , that when Carl called her " the love of his life" , he might actually believe it, but in reality all she was, was the best looking girl, that had ever given him attention. Our brains make us think, that we " love" good looking people. It's attraction, not love
Was there any friends and family that could speak about their relationship? I could grasp a better opinion if there were any interviews from family and friends who more likely had insight into this marriage. I think this channel could have shown those, if available. Thank you for sharing your time and effort you all have put into this video as well as the other videos. Great channel. God Bless
YYEESS!! The bias is clear.
That's what I want to hear as well. I see a pattern of relationships that abruptly ended before they got together.
This comment is so polite, I love it!
It’s irrelevant. Imagine if a man tried to use the same defenses in court after killing their wife? “She talked to me mean…. So I killed her”. Like come on now
@@93ajcollier Good morning Andrew. My comment, well, opinion, merely reflects on the vidoe(s) and they are put together for viewers to watch. Gathering testimonials first hand. Meaning that the people who are in direct contact and or communication with the subjects in question. Watching interviews and or testimonials makes for a better video and gives the viewers a more in depth look into the behaviors and a better understanding on why. Have a great day Andrew.
Many thanks for the coverage on this sad case. One small maths item. She will be eligible for parole in 2044, yes, but that doesn't equate to her age being 101. 79 or 80, I believe. Minor detail but just thought I would mention it.
Lol that's a big difference. Basically the difference of whether she dies in prison or not.
Not minor it means she may see her family again in Brazil
@@bucketree lol once she’s around 80??? Lol I’m no scientist but I highly doubt that she will see her family by then lol.
thats what i thought...
I noticed that and I also don't understand how she will be eligible for parole in 2044. He said that she will be eligible after 28 years and she was convicted in 2019. That means she should be eligible for parole in 2047 when she's 82.
I watch alot of true crime,but this channel is at the top of the list. I find narrator's with accents difficult to understand so I thank you for speaking clearly. I enjoy the mixture of interrogation & court room "best moments" video's that you include. Your videos are informative without being boring. For example I personally don't care where he/she went to public school,or if they had a pony if it doesn't relate to the story. I have a short attention span so I just want the facts. Well done sir! You tic all the boxes for this viewer! Thank you! ⭐👍🇨🇦
Thank you :)
cheers from Melbourne Australia🙏🌏💙. Love your remarkable research, visual presentation and compassionate thoughts to the victims.
Look at us Aussie chick's and our murder investigation shows 😂 greetings from the Gold Coast ❤️
@@koala6915 Under Investigation with Liz Hayes? 😄
@@koala6915 Aussie chicks rule. Hope you're all subbed to Disturban, Bizaare Bazaar, and The Disturban Truth. If not, get on em....💙❤🌏💙❤🌏. You'll thank me later.
@@Cynthiabecker24 & That chapter surely?
I’m from Melbourne too. I send my condolences to the family of this crime. He was a very handsome man he had a lot to offer the right women unfortunately he got with the wrong women. I’ve been abused and had violence in a relationship l didn’t murder l just left.
I'm really sorry that this happened to this young man. I did notice that he had been married three times and they never even lasted 2 years. There must be a reason.
Sure there is. One being his choice in women based on their looks alone. That's one first thing that will make a woman feel unseen, emotionally neglected and miserable.
He was a simp
@@caddieohm7059 Enough to make her feel unseen, emotionally neglected, and miserable...but not enough to keep her from marrying him or enough to convince her it's okay to divorce him? What a twisted pretzel of absurd victim-blaming nonsense.
@onlyJann Or she could have just left with what she entered the relationship with.
@onlyJann You look old af too.
She is not only guilty but a horrible liar too. She not only ran (extremely guilty move) she also just made up lies and assassinated his character with stuff she knew no one could prove which is just plain evil
seems like men vs women in the comment section with the women all patting each other on the back with likes.
so have a like bro
@@shammy8703 It’s unbelievable how women treat female murderers on these channels. Pretty scary tbh.
How do we know thru are lies?
Everybody’s “a catch” within the first several weeks. 😁
Hahaha so true
Exactly, better off single
This is my favourite channel. You’ve got the perfect story-telling voice.
This channel has all of the same great qualities that make a lot of other channels popular too, but Beyond Evil has its own unique personality and signature style that sets it apart from the rest (I wish I could put my finger on why!) Happy Saturday, everyone!
I love the little intro tune too, it’s short but I like the sound & adds to the professionalism imo
@@crystal6368 I’m so shocked to see you say that! My grandson (12yrs old) always exaggerates that song while he makes fun of me for watching this, cuz he hears me binging it late at night when he stays over! Lol! How funny you mentioned that. I can’t wait to show him this comment! It will be a really fun moment for us, so thank you! 😂 Happy holidays from Las Vegas
@@crystal6368 (P.S. did you realize the girl in the song was saying “credulous gal?” I looked it up because my grandson thought it was saying something about love bomb, Lol)
I LOVE that you give condolences before you start your video. That is so sweet and it shows so much respect!❤️❤️
I believe a large part of her story. The quick proposal, the "surprise" engagement party, convincing her to leave her successful career & move to his home town...all red flags of an abusive person. Then the fact that he didn't want to marry the "love of his life" because she wanted children makes me believe that he would be very angry when Claudia got pregnant.
But none of that excuses his murder. She should have simply left him.
I agree with you,
He seems to be a man fixated on specifics, it's not a coincidence that all his girlfriend's and ex-wife looked the same, he's seems to be into a woman more for their beauty than personality. I think he decided to divorce her after she got pregnant twice and in his eyes, she's damaged goods, therefore, in need of a replacement.
Agreed
So that justifies him being shot in his head and twice in the back?? Yes the abuse no matter how bad it was he is not here to defend himself and his side cus SHE MURDERED HIM!??
Wow I am at awe at how many ppls comments are ok with how she just makes him look like a monster and all she is doing is with no emotion about the allegations of of how “abusive” he was wow🤯 👿
@@mindurbiznezz
I'm not saying she has any right to murder him, but I am acknowledging the fact a series of disgusting behaviour on his part played a role in her losing control.
She’s guilty and she admits that she’s guilty, however, if I had been married to someone who treated me like that, he’d be a very dead man. I went through that and worse when I was younger and I wasn’t worldly enough to know better. I finally escaped almost losing my life… never again. I’m older and much wiser now and any man who makes me abort my children, tells me what I can and can’t wear, what I can and can’t eat, wants me to have sex with anyone and everyone he chooses while he’s doing it too… if I try to leave him, it’s best for him to allow me to leave in peace, otherwise, say his prayers because he’s good as gone. I’ll never allow a man to control me and everything I do again!
It’s very sad and unfortunate, but I believe most of what she’s claiming and I think he was a sexual deviant with control issues and an extremely selfish man.
Best comment in here!
I am with you on this, never again. being too scared to enter your own house and sit in the car out the front - it's bullshit.
Yes she's guilty but I believe what she said was going on!
I agree. Obviously there’s no excuse for killing someone out of anger, but at the same time a person can only take so much abuse before something breaks inside of them. The straw that broke the camel’s back, so to speak.
I know from personal experience that there are few things more painful that having the person you love tell you to commit suicide. Especially after she’d been put through at least one pregnancy and abortion. Sometimes victims are, themselves, terrible people.
Mmmm I’m not so sure ……she had the resources to buy a gun and learn how to use it, that costs money she was also able to leave the country after the murder which means she had access to money…..he had rented a place to live and was due to move in within three days. He was in the airforce which meant there were times he may have been away from home if it was as violent as she says she could have ran…..
NEVER say anything to the police, do not answer questions. Keep silent. ALWAYS have a lawyer. Keep a phone number of a good criminal lawyer in your phone/wallet.
Don't kill pple
@@jadeanis3794 might need to one day tho ! Some Pple don’t mean everyone good
What are you planning?
@@liyahknight4423 Yeah, people gotta watch out for those like this woman.
Try just not breaking the fucking law 🤦🏼♀️
Really love this channel. Appreciate the subtitles.
Nice balance between footage and research info
There are grammatical errors in the subtitles as well as mistranscribed audio.
I saw this on a TV show before where his friends and family all denied her claims of abuse and how he treated her like a queen! He gave her money all the time and she was constantly shopping and using all of his money towards herself and she was not even paying the bills. It was on investigation Discovery where I saw this case before. So her accounts of him being abusive are completely wrong!
She had a great job why would she need his money
@@Itsjcold0 because why would you spend yours when you can spend someone elses? Duh
@@truss6282 i dont think the programs would lie, there must have been proof without word of mouth
What I was gonna say is I’ve had a lot of partners who have beat me. None of them ever threw me a fucking party. She is a bald faced liar
@@tabsg0015 They say whatever the criminal says, whatever the witnesses say. Their job is to make a good story, regardless of facts.
Every time I hear
"Declined to have a lawyer present...."
I instantly say to myself
"uh oh. This should be good"
I thought the prosecutors line of questioning was stupid
For real!!
Yeah it was.
@@LIBERTYSINCURSION have you ever, in the your entire life ever been mad at this person before you shot them? Were you or were you not upset with them 15 years ago for drinking the last coca cola and not replacing it? Yes or no. YES OR NO
@@user-jd8nn2lq5e I shouldn't laugh at this but literally that's how his questioning went🤣. Like what?! I would be confused too. And people can hold grudges for decades.
@@ThisIsJ.Nicole right?? Like imagine how many people she's been mad at in her life and yet only one ended up murdered 🤔 I hope all of them, including the kid who kicked her sand castle over when she was 3 is in witness protection right now
I learned about this case from a video This is Monsters published. I’m blown away by how much more detail your video contains & just overall how well you presented the case.
yea but THIS IS MONSTER is 🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯💯 better channel 👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿
@@MyAristocrat nah, This is Monsters fell off hard. He goes on too many cringe tirades that ruin the flow of the video.
I love t.i.M. 💖
So did they call her the monster or him?
@@peggybaby0894 Watch it and see! 💖
I really appreciate your channel: it feels so informative & educational, but you also bring recognition to the victims in a way that doesn’t feel like you’re exploiting them. It’s important that their stories and legacy’s are heard, so thank you for that. I hope to see one of my late friends on your channel 🤍
I was waiting for the cop to ask "so why not just flee and leave him alive?"
If they did, she might have seized up and stopped talking freely. These types think they're charming the room; so it's best to let them flap their mouths into a thorough confession. I don't even need to hear the entire tape to know that she has no conscious. She behaved like she's just talking about some harmless teen adventure. Sociopaths often do that.
Emotions , Satan
@@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 she's totally charming the comment section... Sad
the math at the end is a little wrong. Claudia was born in 1964 so she will be eligible for parole at the age of around 80 in 2044. She will not be close to 101 years old.
I liked the narrator. Nice voice, understandable pronunciation! Bravo! For the case she deserved the verdict.
Want children? Don’t want children? An important discussion people NEED to have BEFORE a commitment is made.
From the very beginning it was made clear that she didn't have control. Engaged and married the very day they met? Why there wasn't any contraception.
@@cdes1776 No control but able to kill in cold blood without fear or compassion. This woman was a gaslighting sicko.
Love this narrator... thank you 😁
You think it's his voice or he is using some app to make it more thick and deep?
I think it’s authentic @@simpleforex1299
@@funwithj.4999 It's out of this world, I watch this channel for the voice of it,
@@simpleforex1299 No. You are hearing my real voice, I promise. :)
@@funwithj.4999 It is! Thanks!
Really been enjoying your longer videos lately, keep up the amazing work!
It would've been beneficial to include some of his ex's testify of how he treated them. Also she should've had a lawyer.
Yes, stupid for not having a lawyer and talking with police.
@@redwingsfan3621yea sucks we get the truth
His ex wife did. He was never violent.
I’m m sure the police conducted those kind of interviews with people who knew him to get more insight into who he was as a person.
I lived next door to him and his family many years ago. Feel so bad for what happened. His parents were always so kind.
I absolutely love this channel especially when the videos are longer than 30 mins. Thanks!!!!
Good evening from Wales thank you for the upload 😀
from Essex UK
As guilty as she is, they are twisting her words and everything else
who cares? shes a fickin murderer loooool u mad
Seriously. That prosecutor had me heated. "Just answer yes or no". Umm...sometimes a response is a lot more nuanced than a "yes" or a "no". Especially when the questions are leading and obviously apparent to elicit a certain feeling for the jury. It was almost like gaslighting her on stand. Fuck prosecutors. They are just as corrupt as cops and the rest of the judicial system.
I agree....
Yes
As a victim of domestic violence, I believe her. Her entire story. Yes I believe she killed him and I am sorry for his family. She also may not needed to kill him to save herself but I know she immediately flashed back to all the horrible things he did and the children she was grieving.
I believe she is guilty because she claims that he begged her to stay with him, even though he had rented a house and was ready to move out.
I have seen this behavior from narcissists many times. I'm sure she does have recordings of him losing it after months of gaslighting, manipulation and devaluing him. I also don't believe for one minute that she paid all the bills. She stated that she had to buy all of his clothes, yet, he chose all of her clothes. Someone that controlling doesn't let another person buy their clothes. One other really big inconsistency is that she claims she intended to kill herself but she took $9900 and moved it to an account in Brazil before killing him. I also believe she threatened to kill herself on a regular basis as a manipulation tactic. It's very possible that she killed him because he told her to go ahead and do it, but it is more likely she planned it.
As a lady who has had multiple partners physically abuse her, not one of them ever threw me a party or let me spend their money. She is a narcissist and a liar
Her activity on the stand is typical behavior
I mean then you’re lucky but let’s not say it absolutely can’t happen based on *your* personal experience. Because that sort of the behavior is almost the norm in my eyes.
To be fair, mine did.
But he used that money against me as well, every chance he got. I wasn’t allowed to work, he wanted to “take care of me” but ended up financially abusing me. He threw parties for every event, to everyone else he was the life of the party and everybody’s best friend. Abusers do not abuse everyone around them, or they’d all know.
As someone that was abused by an ex, periodically after abusive episodes he would love bomb me with affection, expensive gifts and trips to Europe. Abusers can do this.
She claimed to the court that she had 2 years worth of solidly abusive recordings of him and she called the lawyers out for lying because they rendered her recordings inadmissable. Is this true?? Does anyone know?
Lawyers can't render judgments as to what is or is not admissible. The judge does that. It's possible that her "recordings" were judged to be "hearsay" since there is no one to be able to rebut what she says when she makes her own recordings.
@@TrulyJefferson Ok, I know what you mean but you didn't answer my question. If there are years worth of recordings of this man. I think that hearing his voice and statements for hours on end though inadmissable would be Very telling and could corroborate her claims... I had a girlfriend back in the day who used to say and do some insane and way out of control sx-t and I had a home security system that caught her behavior. She tried to make dinner claims that I abused her and I sent those "illegally" to her parents and within 2 days magically the investigator contacted me and told me that she dropped her case. I'm sure my recordings were "inadmissable" but I see that one they got out they massively saved my axs... I understand your legal explanation but I want to know if she really has those recordings and where they might be. It could tell allot about his character regardless of how they were obtained...
Real nice meticulously detailed story....that she had 10+ years to make up and perfect.
This channel deserves millions of subscribers 👏
"Were you mad about the miscarriages before you shot him?" No, she was fkn ecstatic about them! What woman wouldn't be happy with glee? smh
The lesson I keep seeing in most cases like this: DONT GET MARRIED!
Or how about don’t get married to someone you’ve only “known” (she said it was all virtual) for two months.
100% !!!!!! Most men are depraved and unfaithful. 90% ….
marriage is a government trap don't do it the tax benefits are NOT worth it.
Disgusting lawyer . What kind of abusive tactics are those ? Sick
😂😂😂
Once Abused a marriage should be legally annulled.
I'm not sure about states laws but they should have a way to annull a marriage within the first year without being expensive, complicated and time consuming.
You obviously have never been married. There is wide spectrum of abuse that isn't physical. Marriage is an ever evolving thing you must be seriously committed to or it fails...
@@aleyahaforlife first year? What if it occured years down the road? And it's not expensive, complicated and time consuming for everyone, which is the problem but perhaps not quite enough so for the abusing person.
@@mememan2344 yes divorce should never be any of those things in the first place. People shouldn't be terrified to leave a marriage period.
What a beautiful concept ....yes!
I would have loved to hear her recordings of how he actually was with her. Pretty crap they weren't allowed in court. (Reminded me of JD and turds libel. They should have been able to submit them as evidenced) 🤷🏼♀️
I'm not sure if that part is true. why would she be recording everything, & why wouldn't that become evidence?
Get over the fact that MEN in fact can be victims of abuse. It ain’t always about the woman !!
@@lingling903 I think some of these people literally didn’t see the ending of the video. Baffles me that anyone would think she has any portion of innocence. Yea maybe she was abused but if theres no police report towards that or anything and she just shoots him (with a laser aiming tool) i find that extreeeemely hard to believe. Plus she has the same traits of master manipulators that have killed. “You know I’m smart”. “I would never lie to you” yea b1tch.
Depends on recording laws in the state it occured. I love in a one party state and it would most likely be admissable. But laws are inconsistent throughout different areas...
What shit that they weren’t! They had been fighting extradition for years. Her trial was unfair as soon as she landed on American soil, and we all know it whether some will admit it or not is a different story.
Narcissisim at it's finest. She says "I'm a forgiving person' , yet you shot the man dead and escaped to another country to evade the consequencs. That is a contradiction if I have ever heard one. That dosen't sound like forgiveness to me.
Forgiving people can reach a breaking point. Narcissism is too loosely thrown around.
Try to also imagine if you're in her position. Murder isn't justified in any way though. I would just suggest to leave the man.
it is finest...?
Wow, how was she was smiling and excited while talking about killing her husband? Crazy .
“I’m a very forgiving person.”
Riiiiiiiiiiiiight …
I’m sure you did forgive him once you killed him.
Her excuses are so exhausting to listen to…
Then click off !
Grow up B B
One of my favorite true crime narrators on YT💯
Thank you!
This woman is so at peace and cool with the situation that gives me a strange and odd feeling that there is smth very much wrong with her.
She reminds me of Nico Claux ,not bcs what they did was same but the way they speak and tell their stories as if it was all natural and normal.
because she killed him years ago, and obviously had a reason to. You want her to cry and shit her pants over a man who didn’t even respect her in the slightest? Okay
@@adoboflav4skin I don't know how he treated her, bcs I wasn't there and nor were you. What I do know is that in the meantime they have invented the divorce and no one is forced to stay where they don't want to stay .
Get updated.
@@adoboflav4skin She didn't feel sad for murdering him.
@@adoboflav4skinimagine being murdered FROM BEHIND no chance to defend yourself, being left like trash in your own home and then your murderer evading justice for a decade only to come back and destroy your character to everyone without anyone giving you a chance to defend your side. You are believing a story that she had to spend 10 years crafting over evidence.
True narcissist to the core
Smart enough to know she needs a lawyer but crazy enough to think she’s smartest one in room and can talk her way out of it
Marrying a doctor for the money and citizenship and then divorcing within a year to take half, what a red flag.
If he was abusive and controlling, then I totally feel for her, and part of me can understand how she would "snap" like that. But the fact that she left and started a new life for so many years does make it seem like she was cold hearted with no remorse.
Exactly, there's such a thing as divorce. As tough and miserable as it is, everyone comes out alive, and gets to start again. There's no excuse for murdering your partner, except self defence - and there's no evidence this was such a case.
I find her a very unconvincing defendant, and there's no corroborating evidence he was the abusive brute she claims. His ex wife was on friendly terms, and he was a much loved father. I think she not only killed him in a coldly premeditated attack, she trashed his reputation when he was no longer here to defend it. She's pretty disgusting, and I'm convinced she's in the best place, behind bars.
It's quite obvious there's nothing to her abuse allegations. That's something you say right away, not years after the fact when you're backed into a corner.
@@Bubba__Sawyer Right. She bought the gun (with laser) ahead of time. It's not like she grabbed a frying pan and smashed him with it.
@@Bubba__Sawyer I would have liked to hear those recordings
@@glamdolly30 That's the point even in this video they tell you he wanted a divorce that's why she killed him she's crazy
Nice work, as always. Thank you!
42:16 this is the most leading line of questioning I have seen so far! I’m surprised her attorney didn’t object to leading. They were clearly trying to establish that it wasn’t a heat of the moment killing, but asking questions of no relevance, that she’s even objecting to!
I believe she represented herself.
@@Yonnabelle yes. This is why people should not defend themselves.
You are allowed to ask leading questions on cross examination. Of course they were trying to establish that it wasnt heat of the moment... they want her found guilty of 1st degree murder. The witness does not get to determine the relevance of questions... the jury does (and to the extent it is non-relevant, the judge can prohibit those questions). They actually do a pretty good job because they establish from her testimony that she wasnt upset before shooting him, which contradicts her defense that it was heat of the moment.
I agree he kept saying before she shot him none of what he asked had anything to do with the same day
@@Ddub1083 no you can not…
listening to her story, i dont know how anybody could do anything else. she sure sounds honest, eye contact, clear speech, etc. after hearing so much from women i know, i think sometimes the control ends up in a "you or me" decision and some choose "you" like this woman did. how you can send a person away for life without listening to every piece of evidence has always blown me away.
As a woman I will say this, as I tell my brothers. Women are extremely prone to lying and can twist anything to make themselves look good. Excellent actresses and story tellers. I don't believe any woman unless I see concrete evidence. Our bull sh*T is SECOND TO NONE.
She is lying
She is lying
Kinda weird he was so abusive yet she killed him for wanting a divorce
I agree, if she really had recordings of him being abusive than why weren't they played? Everyone has secrets and are someone else in the privacy of their own home.
I think it was both. He forcibly made her marry him, made her do weird things, i.e., walk around the house naked, etc, watched porn and he made her get abortions because he didn't want anymore children. He took her from her home and comfort zone in NY. And in her eyes (in my opinion) he was going to commit an absolute atrocity and leave her.
I would never ever condone murder, not ever. But even though she couldn't exactly prove it in the right manner, she killed him because of mental and physical abuse. I feel for the family, but the guy was no saint. Again granted she should have just left and went to Brazil in the first place, but you don't expect the person you've just married (half involuntarily) to treat you that way after taking you through so many unexpected changes especially when he told you that some of the changes wouldn't occur. I just don't like that his family acts like he was some type of saint.
She is a liar...
I love this channel because there isn't some smart ass quips between segments. It just goes on telling the story in plain format. Thank you!
How you got to Claudia 101 years old at 2044 is beyond me.
Right, I was confused about that one too
What makes you say that?
@@kittykat2003uk Her hubby, the victim was born past 1960. Unless u suppose she is old enough to be his mother, it is simply wrong, not to mention that she did not look in her 70s during the interrogations and trial.
Thank you!!
News article shows her as 57 yo in Feb 2022.
She got pregnant 3 times with a man who was up front about not wanting more children. He was fresh out of a relationship where he voiced his fear and lack of commitment. His first wife still had a friendly relationship with him. He had made arrangements to move out of the marital home. Who cares about abortions, or heals, or sex toys? This women was not used to be told no and could not handle rejection.
Claudia's lawyer needed to shut down the prosecution' injecting "before you shot him" into every question. The relation to the shooting was irrelevant, it wasn't a question of "were you upset before, during, or after the marriage" it was solely a means to yell "you shot him" for minutes straight under the guise of questioning. And particularly loaded statements "[were] you angry, [before] you shot him, [X]" . Straight up character assassination during the questioning. Its fairer than her husband got, but keep jury manipulation civil in the courtroom.
I like the way she's attempted to "grannify" herself to make her seem more vulnerable & fragile! Haha that worked well 🤡
She’s so manipulative.. I can’t believe some top comments here, saying that they believe her. What the hell
Claudia: I am going to shoot myself in the head...... I better get a laser and go to the range to make sure my dead body can handle the recoil.
And move my money to Brazil too.
@@lonestar1637 she sent money to her family in Brazil on a regular basis. Also if you watch the actual trial you’ll see that she also researched suicide with that gun and also bought & installed a suicide device to make up for the recoil. As to the above comment- yes recoil is something you consider when you are considering suicide. The recoil can make the gun jump & instead of being dead you can end up just doing a lot of brain damage and shooting off half your face but surviving which no one would want.
@@lonestar1637 also- she went to the bank the day before & sent that $9900 to her family. You know what she didn’t do? Get her passport. She left her passport in the safety deposit box where it was. If she was planning to kill him & flee the country she would have grabbed that too. Instead after killing him she had to go to the bank again to get her passport. She’s absolutely being honest.
You just cracked me up.
However, she said the laser was to help her at the gun range while "practicing" how to get acquainted with the recoil. Hahahaa! That darned recoil !!
Rage bait comment 👎🏼
"BEFORE YOU SHOT HIM...!" * LMAO
“Please believe this story that I’ve had 11 years to come up with”
And yet hundreds of people in the comment section felt her claims of abuse should be enough to avoid a murder conviction.
A pilot “flew into a rage” 😂😂😂 nice!
If he trapped her, why did someone testify that she said to them “if he leaves me, I’ll kill him”, the scene indicates he was leaving and walking away- the shooting from the top of the stairs, that he had a packed suitcase in his car and had arranged alternate living for himself. None of that indicates she was trapped and abused by HIM. Also, things like how she says ‘I don’t have tattoos’ as if it indicates a better moral character, destroys his reputation, claims he was bisexual… you name it.
People in the comments are naive. She’s batshit crazy and manipulative af. How could anyone believe her for even a second..
Seeing murderers act so matter of fact with their crime really gets me thinking about how normal the people around me at work seem, and how there’s one of them that’s one bad day away from murdering someone.
The prosecutors line of questioning is leading. She is saying that no she wasn't upset about the things he was asking at that very moment. But the way he is trying to get her to answer his questions he's leading her to say she did it out of anger.
As someone else remarked she’s had 12 years to perfect her story - fought indictment all the way so then the battered wife plea was her next option. It’s interesting how the victim was the one who was preparing to leave the marriage after two years …. And already had another place set up to move into…doesn’t sound like a domineering, controlling, dictator- type partner to me- sounds like someone who wants out and has had enough !!!!!! I don’t believe her at all-the jury got it right - it would have been revealing for viewers fir his children, brother, parents to have had some input - we weren’t privy to any of that unfortunately ( even victim statements??!)…. The guy had a record of diligence and service, and we would have to have clear evidence that he ‘never wanted children’ from his family !!! Bottom line she painted him so badly and only the rest of his family know close to the truth… her words were all rehearsed as I read her
It's disgusting how shamelessly some women play the "I was abused" card.
It's such a great disservice and slap in the face to real abuse victims.
Thank you. Finally someone that has sense instead of all these morons in the comments section defending her like she didn't plan on killing this man in cold blood. A liar she is. Like she could've just left him and gone to Brazil without killing him. I can't believe these bunch of empty headed followers are defeding her. Absurd!!!!
Weird how she doesn't have much of an accent during the interrogation but on the stand it comes out thick so she can convince the fact that she didn't understand English much
Everytimes she's animated and lying she's got a big smile and her eyes are twinkling. Crazy..
Thu killing someone is not the answer, same thing happened to our neighbor in the Philippines. She married someone who controlled everything. Her husband didn't give her anything and not even money to buy her basic needs, they lived in this really nice house and from the outside they were living a perfect life. All of the sudden one morning we just heard that the husband was killed.
My favorite crime channel ❤️
Even if they can’t be used in court can she get the audio files leaked? They’re her files and her defense would have had them. I think we’re missing a huge part of the story.
I 💯 agree. For all we know, we could side with her. Just can’t know without the whole story.
All this was probably done, you just can't sum everything up in a 45mn video. The detectives proly did their jobs to the max.
It's almost like they don't exist...
Nah, they would have been like her testimony, all over the place. He was leaving her, she was free, but she didn't want that, so she killed him and then fled the country. She was free to leave the country without killing him. Bu she needed to get the murder in first.
@@RaphaelDawkinsCombatRadio Yup. Isn't it disturbing how inclined women seem to be when another woman says she was the victim? I mean, all she had to do is mention a non existent recording and they're like, "We don't have the whole story. Even though the evidence points at her, she was probably the victim". I guarantee that if the sex's were reversed, they would think the man was guilty. My favorite is when a man commits a horrible crime, they go right to, " I hope he gets brutally, analy raped in prison". All the while they complain about how America has a problem with rape culture. I get that not all women think this way but it is way too common for comfort.
This certainly wasn't an aggravated murder, this was premeditated murder. Prosecutors and detectives didn't do their homework properly.
She takes on shooting classes with laser pointer attached to the gun, very clearly not meant for self inflicting harm.
She had already booked a flight ticket and knew exactly what she was doing. (Which the detectives should have digged the information of when she brought the plane tickets, which would have proved that it was premeditated.)
Why didn't she not approach police or call 911 for abuse or domestic violence, in the entirety of two years of their marriage. (Which again proves that there was no abuse by the victim)
Why would someone elope to Brazil immediately after murdering your spouse, and settling there, starting her own business, and remarrying immediately after murdering their spouse. (If they were so depressed about abuse, nobody would have rushed into another marriage in the first place.)
During the interrogation, her lies were so dummy, that a kindergarten kid could beat her with their stories of fairies and unicorns. (She thought people were dumb and naive to buy her story)
Good for putting where she belongs. She is a demon disguised in human form.
The narrator keeps me wanting me... Thank you very much for this. 💯
🤔
Ughhhhhhh I agree with everyone about her words getting twisted etc etc.
That trial footage is infuriating and frustrating to watch and listen to.
Shitty men standing up for other shitty men without hearing the entire story.
I also hope she can get a retrial and is allowed to use her recordings as evidence.
She also needs a defender and someone to help with the language barriers.
so are we gonna ignore the fact that she made up all those lies? even a 5 year old can be more convincing
He was literally trying to leave her and she shot him in the back....it seems to me that she was the abuser
The amount of people supporting this woman is disgusting. No abuse victim retells their trauma with a smile on their face. I swear, people see a woman murder a man, most believe her and feel sympathy. A man murders a woman no matter what, he’s a monster and gets no sympathy. It’s crazy how that logic works for people like you. Also, how are you going to bring up men standing up for men when so many women (including you, probably) are defending this woman, despite her lies being very visible? Women ☕️
@@MentokTheMindTaker did u miss all the abuse and abortions? Y’all are fucking wild.
@@JordanC100 100% agree with you. But not surprised… we’re living through scary times
Why weren't the recordings admissible in court? If anything was going to exonerate her it would have been those recordings.
I'm shocked at how many commenters believe her story of abuse. It's all hearsay; where's the evidence of abuse? And if that were the case she had plenty of opportunity to flee when her husband was away for training. Attaching a laser to the gun to kill herself? Come on, put your thinking caps on folks!
The amount of people defending her actions in this comment section is disgusting.
Most of them saying they believe her because it 'sounds like' typical abusive behavior.
No witnesses to back her up, no police reports, no medical records AND he was the one getting ready to leave. She's a liar and a murderer and she's exactly where she belongs.
In my humble opinion, the think that tilts my decision is when he rented a house for him to move into. If he was such a deviant and a control freak, why would he move away from the ability to keep up this pattern! I'm not buying her story!
“I got a laser scope so I can pinpoint exactly where the bullet will go into my skull”🤣 this girl out her mind.. she really thought this was a good story to get away with it