Liam & Noel Gallagher, Paul Weller - Carnation

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лип 2024
  • The title pretty much sums it up. The making of. Great stuff!

КОМЕНТАРІ • 670

  • @pulvi3329
    @pulvi3329 9 років тому +651

    Say what you want about Liam Gallagher 'the person' but when he was at the top of his game, like he is here, no other rock singer could touch him in his hay day. Awesome vocal

    • @ricjones5749
      @ricjones5749 7 років тому +70

      Leo Pulvirenti he has his faults but the guy is honest doesnt hold anything back.you could never call him a hypocrite.plus he has a lot if time for the fans

    • @marianne3177
      @marianne3177 6 років тому +4

      amen

    • @vasilicarlson7425
      @vasilicarlson7425 6 років тому +3

      Very well said!

    • @makkizakki8440
      @makkizakki8440 6 років тому +8

      Obviously you haven't seen Richard Ashcroft live. Liam`s a showman. Ashcroft`s a proper frontman.
      Anyway Freddie Mercury is probably greatest frontman of all time. Even thou many don't give Freddie Mercury his credit as he was gay. I`m pretty sure Liam would be shitting bricks if he was in the same room as Freddie Mercury.

    • @pulvi3329
      @pulvi3329 6 років тому +25

      Makki Zakki - taking nothing away from Freddie, he was an outstanding talent in his own right, but he was more of a showman style frontman, Liam just had that classic rock voice that just commands attention, although these days his voice doesn’t seem what it used to be unfortunately.

  • @fog812
    @fog812 8 років тому +328

    With liam's voice, he can sound good in any song.

    • @alexthomson7465
      @alexthomson7465 2 роки тому +4

      Scorpio rising just came up on my Spotify. His voice is majestic! He is one of our greatest singers. Top 5. Arguably top 3

    • @alexthomson7465
      @alexthomson7465 2 роки тому +1

      @@hemiheritage extremely jealous! Never got to see Oasis and probably never will. Imagine the music scene without Oasis. Imagine Oasis without Liam.. Imagine a world without either!? It would be a different place that's for sure.

    • @hemiheritage
      @hemiheritage 2 роки тому +1

      @@alexthomson7465 That would def be a world I'd want no part of

    • @jawshchevyvan
      @jawshchevyvan Рік тому

      yeah he carried Oasis in spite of his shitty brother

  • @MitchelGant
    @MitchelGant 10 років тому +182

    Liam kicks the arse out of this one.

  • @anarchovegan9738
    @anarchovegan9738 7 років тому +159

    Liam Gallagher vocal on this is breath-taking. Makes the hairs stand-up all over my body

  • @jeanlucdippie
    @jeanlucdippie 4 роки тому +68

    The best voice of the 90's no question

  • @RevolutionaryMod
    @RevolutionaryMod 9 років тому +92

    Liam Gallagher at his best here, amazing!

    • @nickknowles8402
      @nickknowles8402 9 років тому +24

      people dont kno how good he was lol

    • @genevievesbroome
      @genevievesbroome 9 років тому

      Matthew Lofthouse Noel at his worst. He's admitted he can't play guitar

    • @genevievesbroome
      @genevievesbroome 8 років тому

      +Genevieve Schorr Noel put down in an interview he thinks The Beach Boys are rubbish. Hillarius! What an idiot! The Beatles idolized The Beach Boys and Brian Wilson. They changed the face of recording and harmonies. This version of the song is Rubbish!

    • @ControlDesigns
      @ControlDesigns 8 років тому +3

      +Genevieve Schorr Next time you come somewhere trying to spew your agenda, try not to be so obvious

    • @genevievesbroome
      @genevievesbroome 8 років тому

      What did I post that was so obvious. That Noel can't play guitar? Or the ridiculous thing he said"The Beach Boys Are Rubbish. Ever heard of Pet Sounds? Paul Weller rules!
      Sent from my iPhone

  • @paulblamey6087
    @paulblamey6087 6 років тому +48

    Weller and Noel are well and truly in awe of Liam here...Liam's finest hour eat it up and take the cake xxxx

  • @cenkkmusic
    @cenkkmusic 7 років тому +113

    Back in the days when Liam was the best rock and roll singer on the planet

  • @richardbuxton7285
    @richardbuxton7285 8 років тому +118

    Liams voice very strong on this song. Good set up with the musicians.

    • @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112
      @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112 7 місяців тому

      You're concerned about his voice after he just praised Lucifer?

    • @jaydenullah
      @jaydenullah Місяць тому

      @@eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112not his song brev

    • @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112
      @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112 Місяць тому

      @@jaydenullah The song was given to Paul by Lucifer, that's the whole point of the song.
      All these stars are getting their material from the fallen stars aided by demonic entities. You can't deny it friend, you heard him say it with his own words. He said is "porper Lucifer." Liam knows what he's saying because he sold his soul to the devil to get famous. They're all queers too and you can find pictures of Noel and Liam Kissing along with kissing other artists like Bono of U2 another freemasons devil worshipper. They're job is to distract humanity while the devil worshipping politici9ans turn every city into a smart city prison system. They act was gatekeepers turning men away from Christ.
      They see people like you as dumb and easily led astray. They all practice Crowley sex magic performing sodomy on one another and also child sacrifice. These people are very evil and you don't know what goes on behind closed doors.
      The Beatles has Alester Crowley the Satanist on the cover of their Srg Pepper album. The Rolling Stones bought out an album called Her Magesties Satanic Request and a single called Sympathy for the Devil. The Beatles even had a cover of dismembered baby infants while they wore bloodied butchers garments. They torture and murder innocent babies to get fame, fortune and power. They just look at us as simple peasants who they want to control while they live up on the hill like Kings as they look down on us the peasants below.

  • @Guido.Fawkes.1
    @Guido.Fawkes.1 Рік тому +8

    LG’s voice in this session is just mind blowing and he delivers it effortlessly! 🤯

  • @Sxm_8
    @Sxm_8 6 років тому +88

    This is Liam at his peak vocal powers

    • @vincevirtua
      @vincevirtua 3 роки тому +9

      Nah 94/95

    • @cormacwhite6442
      @cormacwhite6442 3 роки тому +2

      @@vincevirtua nah man 92/93 look up "up in the sky acoustic" liams vocals are angel like

    • @masonmennell8514
      @masonmennell8514 3 роки тому +5

      @@cormacwhite6442 he sounds very clear and great! But I think his peak power was 95-97

    • @cormacwhite6442
      @cormacwhite6442 3 роки тому

      @@masonmennell8514 ya he did have that growl in his voice that suited the music

  • @spiritualwholesale1910
    @spiritualwholesale1910 7 років тому +17

    What an absolute fucking breathtaking vocal from Liam,utterly priceless jamming clip,classic old Jam song,lovely harmonies from the criminally underated Craddock and the jobbing keyboard player aint bad too.

  • @TheSlashfan85
    @TheSlashfan85 7 років тому +166

    Quite possibly Liam's best vocal. Raw and unassuming. He's played some blinders in his day. Even present day he's still smashing it (Chinatown) only gimps will disagree.

    • @Mirza011
      @Mirza011 2 роки тому +1

      Love his latest stuff - chinatown is class

    • @jawshchevyvan
      @jawshchevyvan Рік тому +1

      right take

    • @reduxmod9178
      @reduxmod9178 Місяць тому +1

      Yeah mam Ii saw him the other day and he was brilliant vocally. As good as ever. He's looking after his voice.

  • @gigsandbusking8959
    @gigsandbusking8959 9 років тому +45

    This is one of my favourite all time recording, just perfect.

  • @jasonmcroberts7994
    @jasonmcroberts7994 Рік тому +9

    This tune in particular is the reason why the likes of Dave Grohl and dozens of others in the industry lament LG as the vocalist of his generation. Not too mention his stage and frontman presence. The guy is a legend.

    • @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112
      @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112 7 місяців тому +1

      did you not hear him praise Lucifer or have you totally blanked that from your mind?

    • @jasonmcroberts7994
      @jasonmcroberts7994 7 місяців тому

      @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112 what are you even on about champ? I was simply pointing out that just like an "actor's actor, LG is a frontman for all time! Deal with it I guess

  • @marclawrence66
    @marclawrence66 7 років тому +71

    Wow, never heard this before but what a brilliant cover. Liam is such an underrated singer. One of Weller's best songs, beautifully recreated here.

    • @MrTrevormctrevor
      @MrTrevormctrevor 6 років тому +12

      not sure hes underrated, hes the best

    • @DaveTaste
      @DaveTaste Рік тому +1

      Lol. Underrated.

    • @askeladd6115
      @askeladd6115 Рік тому +1

      Everyone is underrated these days it seems 😂

    • @DaveTaste
      @DaveTaste Рік тому

      @@askeladd6115 biggest band of the 90s. Hardly anyone has heard of him.

    • @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112
      @eternallyredeemedbythebloo5112 7 місяців тому

      Like he just praised Lucifer, like giving himself away and that and you don't see anything wrong with that?

  • @cupolove1
    @cupolove1 7 років тому +30

    Alan White (ex-Oasis Drummer)'s brother Steve on drums here. He is a BEAST! He sat in with Oasis a few times as well when his brother was ill. He killed it!

  • @gallagherii
    @gallagherii 14 років тому +18

    For god sake, his voice has own life, its outta this world.

  • @stevenoasis1
    @stevenoasis1 7 років тому +22

    Forgot about this gem. Awesome performance from Liam. Craddock with some wicked harmonies too.

    • @introaether937
      @introaether937 Рік тому

      Yeah, and sculpting the sound to mimic the lead, crazy good

  • @miskay5526
    @miskay5526 8 років тому +21

    2:55 look at how focused Noel looks
    you know he's a perfectionist

  • @pbuk
    @pbuk 16 років тому +6

    Never normally a lover of covers but Liam has done good on this as he has the voice to carry it off.

  • @anycolouryoulike1275
    @anycolouryoulike1275 7 років тому +22

    Proper smashed that vocal

  • @Rubbleee
    @Rubbleee Рік тому +3

    Unbelievable vocal back then. Legend. Hero. Godlike.

  • @michelesaracino2915
    @michelesaracino2915 3 роки тому +5

    When sometimes cover overcomes the original one. BIBLICAL!!!

  • @galagalaxia6286
    @galagalaxia6286 Місяць тому

    This is how you show respect when you cover your heroes, no bullshit, no shortcuts, you put your heart into it

  • @fortsheridanmc
    @fortsheridanmc Рік тому +4

    Liam's vocals howling like thunder

  • @edwardrahadianto7318
    @edwardrahadianto7318 6 років тому +6

    Liam is a real fuckin rock star, crazy voice! Love it!

  • @asutoshmohapatra1339
    @asutoshmohapatra1339 6 років тому +6

    His voice is simply divine

  • @jonnybradshaw1752
    @jonnybradshaw1752 8 років тому +51

    Noel is in awe of Liams vocals here. I'm lucky to know them personally

    • @fvbhhhgggh8141
      @fvbhhhgggh8141 7 років тому +1

      Jonny Bradshaw do you really? please introduce me :)

    • @bobmardey8698
      @bobmardey8698 4 роки тому +1

      Jonny Bradshaw bollocks

  • @russibianca3893
    @russibianca3893 5 років тому +20

    If you gave me a fresh carnation
    I would only crush its tender petals
    With me you'll have no escape
    And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle -
    I trample down all life in my wake
    I eat it up and take the cake
    I just avert my eyes to the pain
    Of someone's loss helping my gain
    If you gave me a dream for my pocket
    You'd be plugging in the wrong socket
    With me there's no room for the future
    With me there's no room with a view at all -
    I am out of season all year 'round
    Hear machinery roar to my empty sound
    Touch my heart and feel winter
    Hold my hand and be doomed forever -
    If you gave me a fresh carnation
    I would only crush its tender petals
    With me you'll have no escape
    And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle.
    And if you're wondering by now who I am
    Look no further than the mirror -
    Because I am the Greed and Fear
    And every ounce of Hate in you

  • @beth1679
    @beth1679 6 років тому +2

    Wow never watched this before,
    What a phenomenal voice absolutely beautiful.
    Amazing how in one go Liam nailed it.

  • @sweetlorraine0
    @sweetlorraine0 13 років тому +24

    I love it when Oasis covers The Beatles and The Jam, the bands that influenced them a great deal, and generally when they all collaborate with eachother. I'm a fan of all these bands, Beatles, The Who, the Kinks, The Jam, Oasis. Weller and Liam G are among my favorite vocalists. There's something edgy and cool in their voices that really hooks me!

  • @callum0592
    @callum0592 7 років тому +2

    Three legends of music the mod-father Paul weller noel and Liam Gallagher. Two of my favourites along with stones and Beatles

  • @paweln29
    @paweln29 15 років тому +7

    How incredible voice he had just couple years ago...

  • @LeGrandeOrange
    @LeGrandeOrange 7 років тому +19

    The transcendent quality of the material forces Liam to raise his game to it's highest level. Not sure he ever matched this performance, before or since.

  • @casualkite79
    @casualkite79 6 років тому +2

    Noel was right proud when Liam eventually nailed the right lyrics. Top collective. Top song.

  • @liamobrien1110
    @liamobrien1110 3 роки тому +3

    Liam Gallagher is the greatest ever, as you were LOB X

  • @leewinnard9932
    @leewinnard9932 3 роки тому +2

    we listen to this version all the time, Liam’s vocals are unworldly to me, round the time of Lets all make believe where he sounds equally class. Brilliant, cant knock him. And Id love to be as high as steve craddock was haha good stuff 💪🏻

  • @suchasupernova
    @suchasupernova 16 років тому +3

    This is just amazing. Liams voice is enchanting

  • @rulligallaghergallagher5454
    @rulligallaghergallagher5454 10 років тому +6

    The best Colaboration

  • @gusterguy01826
    @gusterguy01826 4 роки тому +4

    This is probably the best he ever sounded. Right before the vocals fell apart, he defined his craft.

    • @davebest2001
      @davebest2001 3 роки тому

      He didn't look after his craft. Oasis live were shit after a while, as Liam's voice deteriorated after 5 or 6 songs

  • @tastemaker_87
    @tastemaker_87 12 років тому +2

    This recording is immortal. One of my favourites. God bless!

  • @moddave78
    @moddave78 15 років тому +2

    i have to agree man this is the bollocks!! liam and cradock should do an album!! liams ace voice and cradocks legendary guitar playing!!! that would be a monumental record!!!

  • @stoned466
    @stoned466 3 роки тому +2

    I like Liam's version even better.

  • @philgower5551
    @philgower5551 6 років тому +5

    Absolutely brilliant vocal by Liam! I always liked Alan White on drums but his brother Steve just tops him, especially here. Fantastic drumming!

  • @stek1961
    @stek1961 9 років тому +150

    If you gave me a fresh Carnash-ee-on....lol

    • @Lunatic4Bizcas
      @Lunatic4Bizcas 9 років тому +1

      Ste Kearney ¡Yes! Annoying as hell....¿Innit?

    • @mysterygamer9866
      @mysterygamer9866 6 років тому

      I'd that drummer Alan white,s brother

    • @samtaylor9196
      @samtaylor9196 6 років тому

      Ste Kearney shiiiiiinnnnnneeee kiddda

    • @badgasaurus4211
      @badgasaurus4211 3 роки тому +4

      @@Lunatic4Bizcas Not at all. Way better than the original

  • @oasis903s
    @oasis903s 8 років тому +48

    god Liam, so great. Liam needs to do a solo album

    • @malibuofficial9317
      @malibuofficial9317 8 років тому +6

      it'll be out next year

    • @sameoldthing23
      @sameoldthing23 6 років тому +29

      As you were LG x

    • @mickgordon5151
      @mickgordon5151 6 років тому +10

      Mark DeVito well liam did do a solo album and got it to number one you should have put a bet on him well done Mark

    • @leedisney5802
      @leedisney5802 6 років тому +3

      Mark DeVito what a great album it is nice prediction

    • @rrrick1000
      @rrrick1000 5 років тому +3

      YOU SIR WERE RIGHT.

  • @marclawrence66
    @marclawrence66 6 років тому

    Favourite Jam song ever, Liam does so well here. Great stuff.

  • @themax2571
    @themax2571 7 років тому +7

    All credits to Paul Weller who wrote this incredible song !

    • @CarlosMX666
      @CarlosMX666 Рік тому

      Nobody is taking away the credit to Paul Weller BUT... Liam was amazing singing this song.

  • @reneisela
    @reneisela 16 років тому

    I Can't Believe..
    Just..
    Beautiful, Awesome, Amazing & Incredible..

  • @luchygomez57
    @luchygomez57 8 років тому +6

    increiiible!!!! el mejor Liam, lejos....

  • @cherrypopma1
    @cherrypopma1 4 роки тому +2

    One hell of a supergroup right there!!!

  • @norbertovelazquez6286
    @norbertovelazquez6286 4 роки тому +1

    What a voice liam! Great Song!!!

  • @micheldooley9757
    @micheldooley9757 9 років тому +4

    Amazing!!

  • @mysterygamer9866
    @mysterygamer9866 5 років тому +4

    This should have millions of veiws fucking mind boggling this is a fuckin tune

  • @TobyEllisSongwriter
    @TobyEllisSongwriter 16 років тому +2

    Ocean Colour Scene, Oasis and Paul Weller in one song? Blows me away... thank you so much for upload!

  • @MrThedonhead
    @MrThedonhead 4 роки тому +2

    The greatest rock n roll singer at this time. Untouchable even by Dhalsim

  • @dave790
    @dave790 15 років тому +2

    what a voice. what a legend.

  • @berthabutt988
    @berthabutt988 5 років тому +2

    This is fantastic! Liam is on point....

  • @FookinLiam
    @FookinLiam 15 років тому +1

    BEST SINGER EVER

  • @walcheren11
    @walcheren11 8 років тому +30

    Brilliant song, superbly delivered, arguably better than The Jam's original version. Great that Weller was involved.

    • @alfieingles3133
      @alfieingles3133 7 років тому +4

      walcheren11 the jams version was the best, can't argue!

  • @TCryda
    @TCryda 16 років тому +1

    damn, Liam put his own stamp on this classic song. badass, nuff said.

  • @xyourxnightmare
    @xyourxnightmare 17 років тому +1

    Great, great Liam!

  • @quickmuma20
    @quickmuma20 15 років тому

    Good song, excellent performance, and one of the best covers oasis that has never touched, Liam's voice is beautiful in this video, hopefully improved lately because his voice is no longer before, greetings from Peru, mad fer its around the world!!!

  • @granto6738
    @granto6738 Рік тому +1

    The Jam 4 ever

  • @chasingwords
    @chasingwords 17 років тому

    Great video, great song. Liam sounds good singing it.

  • @TobyEllisSongwriter
    @TobyEllisSongwriter 16 років тому

    Couldnt say it better myself!
    Great video!

  • @mrthinkvoid1978
    @mrthinkvoid1978 5 років тому +1

    Vocals untouchable

  • @shitcasecinema
    @shitcasecinema 15 років тому

    AMazing performance, great musical greats playing.

  • @lnconnuconnu2108
    @lnconnuconnu2108 3 роки тому +2

    Noel unleash the dog here ! He seems like anyway, look at his face when Liam starts to smash it.

  • @stephenjackson6415
    @stephenjackson6415 2 роки тому

    Class on every level

  • @rosh4
    @rosh4 17 років тому +1

    This is a right song. Liam's vocals are class on it.

  • @bungalow563
    @bungalow563 Рік тому

    This great song shows what a fantastic singer Liam is

  • @dean24uk
    @dean24uk 16 років тому

    one of the best covers oasis will ever do, and im a big big oasis fan, liams voice is mint in this and i agree cant fault a thing, i herd this song along time ago, and it still sounds as good as when i first herd it,

  • @christophercarlone9945
    @christophercarlone9945 Рік тому

    A vocal take of Liam this good in the last few years of the 90's was rare. Few instances where his actual early 90's voice and control shine through. Glad Liam did this one.

    • @tomben6180
      @tomben6180 2 місяці тому

      He was actually very up and down in the late 90s.
      I, incorrectly, for ages thought he just tailed off after ‘97 but he didn’t.
      If his voice got a decent break after a tour, his vocals would come back and would be great.

  • @burritowendel
    @burritowendel 16 років тому

    simply amazing¡¡

  • @Chrisamusic1
    @Chrisamusic1 4 роки тому +1

    Love Liam , love Weller more, and Noel's alright too. Good stuff.

  • @senorblanco4993
    @senorblanco4993 6 років тому +4

    That voice.

  • @30krp2006
    @30krp2006 16 років тому

    No it's Steve White Alans brother, who has been Weller drummer for years
    Drummer - Steve White
    Bass - Damom Minchella (former OCS)
    Acoutstic - Steve Craddock (OCS)
    Keyboard - Paul Weller
    Rhythm Guitear - Noel Gallagher (Oasis)
    Vocals - Liam Gallagher (Oasis)

  • @garryweir3775
    @garryweir3775 11 років тому +1

    liam is such a gifted man

  • @shitcasecinema
    @shitcasecinema 14 років тому +3

    Wicked performance, absolutely amazing, such an amazing line up of musicians there. It's way better than the actual recording that was released.

  • @pbuk
    @pbuk 10 років тому

    Love both the original and this cover.

  • @badolsejoli672
    @badolsejoli672 7 місяців тому +1

    This is gold

  • @topseyshakehands
    @topseyshakehands 11 років тому

    fantastic.

  • @LizaRadley1
    @LizaRadley1 16 років тому +1

    This song brings back so many memories.The last Jam tour I went with my 3 sisters to see them at Wembley. We had excellent seats in with the press. We were up and singing all their songs dancing and going mad. Weller said 'this is for the girls dancing in the press pit' then sang carnation....we were crying our eyes out. Ahh the memories. This is an excellent version but lacks some of the edge that the Jam had originally.

  • @oiergasdn
    @oiergasdn 14 років тому

    dear lord
    great vid!
    Liam is great! Impressive xD

  • @jacquelinesales1146
    @jacquelinesales1146 7 років тому

    Astonishing!

  • @oliviandrade
    @oliviandrade 11 років тому +1

    Gente, simplesmente incrível!

  • @deboranomansland6769
    @deboranomansland6769 7 років тому +1

    liam this is the best set u did with my mate weller manc land in the area best tune from the jam dx

  • @MitchelGant
    @MitchelGant 12 років тому

    just found this. wow amazing.

  • @MrKeefelm
    @MrKeefelm 6 років тому +1

    Love that Noel’s playing weller’s rickenbacker

  • @jamiestevens4384
    @jamiestevens4384 6 років тому

    Did a great job of that

  • @Hal-to
    @Hal-to 2 місяці тому

    If you gave me a fresh carnation
    I would only crush it's tender petals
    With me you'll have now escape
    And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle -
    I trample down all life in my wake
    I eat it up and take the cake
    I just avert my eyes to the pain
    Of someone's loss helping my gain
    If you gave me a dream for my pocket
    You'd be plugging in the wrong socket
    With me there's no room for the future
    With me there's no room with a view at all -
    I am out of season all year 'round
    Hear machinery roar to my empty sound
    Touch my heart and feel winter
    Hold my hand and be doomed forever -
    If you gave me a fresh carnation
    I would only crush it's tender petals
    With me you'll have now escape
    And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle.
    And if you're wondering by now who I am
    Look no further than the mirror -
    Because I am the Greed and Fear
    And every ounce of Hate in you.

  • @royalslackest
    @royalslackest 11 років тому

    So, so good.

  • @bigbrainmcflurry2425
    @bigbrainmcflurry2425 Рік тому +1

    Powerful and at his peak he’s on par with any great musical icon

  • @gregerson20
    @gregerson20 17 років тому

    class tune i remember buying that version as well

  • @dulennon
    @dulennon 15 років тому

    BRILLIANT

  • @anticlimacus81
    @anticlimacus81 16 років тому

    Great cover of a great song...

  • @stevenmair4809
    @stevenmair4809 11 років тому

    Liams delivery and commitment is truly mesmerising.......soooo good and check the Stella out hehe.....early carnage @the studio

  • @dulennon
    @dulennon 15 років тому

    Amazing