Paul Weller is an amazing Artist. Brilliant writer, still so so relevant. He's really becoming humble as he ages. Love ya mate - thanks for the memories.
McCartney has every right to be up his own arse. He was in the greatest band of all time, he's one the greatest singers of all time, one of the best bassists of all time...the list goes on.
Definitely one of the best songwriters of all time and has an interesting voice for sure, never thought he was great solo artist though, his voice isn't quite as special as John Lennon for me.
It's been an honor watching Weller's musical genius evolve over the past 33 years. The most wondrous thing is that The Jam songs are just as great as the new music: He's always been great, since the beginning. And he's still the coolest looking guy in the world.
When a former Beatle praises your work in the business 'you've been in for 40 plus years' then you know you've done very well' he always has been a professional of the music industry of the highest order as hes stood 'and is still standing' the test of time. a national treasure who knows his way around and what hes doing.
Andrew you hit the nail on the head he has indeed become a national treasure! He surely is one of the most revered and respected figures in the music industry!!!
His last album Sonik Kicks was great, maybe even his best. Many of My friends are superfans of his and didnt like it at all, I knew that I had to buy it and find out for myself. The man is an artist in the true sense of the word. He is also a cool looking dude. Paul, I salute you Sir!
Weller is a legend! Quick correction for Macca…the first time he met Weller was in 1982 when they did a photo shoot together for Smash Hits magazine! It’s all good though, memory fades over time, and Sir Paul is still doing well for a man in his 80s. 👍🏻
Macca is so used to only being interviewed about himself or the Beatles he brings all of it back to himself. More of a compliment to Weller, Macca barely ever does interviews about other artists
wow, what a nasty comment. Maybe Paul meant first time working together. Even if his memory wasn't spot on this time, imagine all the people Paul has met in his lifetime. Easy to forget meeting someone in his case. I hope you get more mellow as you get older.
Je vous suis depuis les années 70 et je vous ADORE en tant que Génies Légendes Musicales.........I LIKE IT to the BEAT GENERATION........... Patricia LAURENT
My favourite PW quote is the one he gave in reply to being asked why he stopped being a veggie. "After 18 years, I really fucking missed Bacon sandwiches."
@@tabuencajosemanuel5102 the high flying birds 🦅, the pink Floyd, led zeppelin, simple minds,David Bowie, T,Rex,it just goes on and on the British have the best music,imo that little island has the best music ever
Thing with modfather is that Im not even native english, growing up with his music I never got much from his lyrics. That means he gotta be genious musically also as much he is well known of his lyrical talent
Weller in my eyes surpasses McCartney and the rest because of the magic he is still producing at 60 years old, listen to his new 2018 offering True Meanings and you will understand.
im assuming your eyes arent focusing on the mountain, and im talking everest, of music that will be iconic hundreds of years from now. i can appreciate your comment, but lets not get senile
@@spence7985 nope that's exactly what he was focusing on. McCartney's written some great songs and has his own mountain of work but he's half dick .. it seemed to increase with age, beatles went to his head. Everything Weller did in The Jam, the first 5 years of the Style Council, everything he did in the 90's and almost half the stuff since 2000 is brilliant, sometimes unbelievably so. After 2000 Weller's struggled I think, except with True Meanings which I'd class as a proper album again with it's own feel and at least half the songs on the record are truly great
@@digiface almost EVERYONE knows the Beatles song mostly written by Paul...yesterday, hey jude, let it be? What about Weller? Can Everyone name 3 songs he wrote off the bat? Yes, we don't think so. Weller is great. But Macca is Zeus.
@@theloniouscoltrane3778 Well you clearly haven't understood what's being said but since when did the lowest common denominator become the best? Who's 'everyone' anyway? I don't know about where you live but in the UK many kids now would struggle to name one beatles song, let alone three written by paul. But they couldn't name any paul weller songs either. I love those songs you've put, they're absolutely great, but they're all from 50 years ago now.
An All Mod CON artist! When is he gonna talk about his fathers real involvement in the Jam? Do you see any modern conveniences on the album cover of All Mod Cons?
Stuart Cook Macca's been a bit up to his arse since 80s what Ive watched his interviews, tho is also one of the few people in the world can get away with it :D really!
JonnyKasabian Yep. He's been working on revisionism pretty much since Lennon died. It's all about leaving a legacy of him been equally as cool and hip as John.
Then again Seems he's kind of pop to John's rock Maybe a bit more talented musically - at least what comes to melodies etc. less revolutionary than john tho, but he's got wider knowledge of music) what u think ?
JonnyKasabian I think Macca was very cool in his own way and very much his own man. He has no need to try to revise history - his place in history was sealed years ago.
I dont mean to be offtopic but does anybody know of a way to log back into an Instagram account?? I stupidly forgot my password. I would love any help you can offer me.
@Esteban Van Thanks so much for your reply. I found the site through google and I'm in the hacking process atm. Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
McCartney's memory must be going, he was in and around Air Studios while The Jam were recording " Town Called Malice" SO WAS I... I think you still owe me for the bowling shoes from Melandy's Paul. Great Memory's
All these people talking trash about Macca, wth is wrong with you.. If there's someone in the music business who could remain humble it's him. He hasn't changed a thing since the beginning.
there isn't one other like paul weller and noel gallagher 2 off the most gifted both noel gallagher and Paul weller get in there please can they both do a gig together it will be a ticket left they will be first come make sure I get my tickets
Some crap talk on here, the beatles were amazing in a time of non bands, maybe the stones and kinks etc. The jam, style council etc had competition i.e start of disco, return of soul, ska, punk etc ,Weller is the best song writer ever, been going for 40 years and still going cos the guy loves his music. I watched and lived the jam for 7 years, even met the famous 3 paul bruce and rick backstage many times. Beats the shit music nowadays, listen to A VERY DEEP SEA the guy is the bollocks END OF!
Take fucking Noel out of there. Oasis is pablum on their own. Pure shite compared to Beatles, Wings, Jam, Council, Weller, McCartney (much of his solo recording is amazing but you have to dig a bit, Weller on his own has been genius).
Someone else has already said it but Noel is starting to show his age. On his last tour he still looked very youthful but he's got a bit of jowl now. Lord willing we all got to turn 47 sometime.
see, that pretty much sya it all about noel. "once you've had to throw him him out of your house at 7 i the morning' or whatever he said. can you imagine liam doing that? i dont usually go in for the whole laim and noel drama, and i certainly dont lie to take shots at legends, but their is something about noel, the fucking things he says..like even if you did "throw paul weller out of your house" you wouldn;t fuvking boast about it.
Paul Weller is an all time great. Up there with Bowie and Lennon etc etc. And stop slagging McCartney he's an old man and he was a Beatle for fuck sake he's entitled.
yes but noel Gallagher have a worst attitude than any of the beatles , and its obvious , im a fan of oasis but they have been bad dick heads in many cases , not that I know you but from what you say it just seems like you will probs be one of those oasis who gets pissed off when anyone mentions how better the beatles are than them
Did he say anything that is wrong? Many would consider him to be the greatest song writer in the history of Rock and Roll. He is certainly the greatest living singer songwriter in Rock and Roll, so saying he can "write a song" is hardly praising himself. It is stating a fact.
Ye but ur stating it as its wrong that people say noel is more vain than mcartney , and its true noel is one ignorant fuck sometimes aswell as liam , i love their music but its still a fact noels undoubtedly worse than mcartney
Why does McCartney always compare people to himself? I did this ,I did that,I was the first.Sad-he had is day but everything comes back to his ego.poor bugger can't let go
I don't know if he's doing it on purpose, but Macca seems to keep name-dropping people. I've never really understood how Macca and Weller could get on, considering that most people can't name any new songs by Macca that are from the last twenty years, while Weller always seems to be evolving, although I'm a bit biased since I'm a massive Jam Fan rather than a Wings fam. That's just my opinion, and is in no way intended to offend Sir Paul McCartney or his fans.
I can understand where you're coming from, I really can, but there is some Macca gold coming out, just not as much as there used to be. Check out 'Jenny Wren' from a couple of years back.
I don't know what Paul McCartney is on, the Mod thing was nothing, literally nothing, to do with the Beatles. The Rickenbackers maybe, but the Mod look? No.
I think there was an unspoken comma or slash in what he was saying, i.e. the Mod/Beatles look, as being 2 separate entities, both of which influenced Weller. That's how I interpreted it anyway.
benolly22 I never said they were Rockers or anything else for that matter, but neither were they Mods. Their Beatnik fans were very different to the Mods, the suits were completely different cuts, the hairstyles different, even musically dissimilar. Weller's influence came from the Who and the Kinks anyway, very little of his influences came from the Beatles.
4 Great people, a Beatle, a High Flying Bird, a Shadow Puppet and an OCS member talking about one of the finest musicians in british history!
There's too much coolness in 11 minutes for a human to handle.
Paul Weller is an amazing Artist. Brilliant writer, still so so relevant. He's really becoming humble as he ages. Love ya mate - thanks for the memories.
McCartney has every right to be up his own arse. He was in the greatest band of all time, he's one the greatest singers of all time, one of the best bassists of all time...the list goes on.
I agree. .. And nobody loved the Beatles more than PW.
+TCB1965 nobody loves the Beatles like macca does
Definitely one of the best songwriters of all time and has an interesting voice for sure, never thought he was great solo artist though, his voice isn't quite as special as John Lennon for me.
Hes the tony mcarrol of oasis
Andrew Ness Macleod agreed
It's been an honor watching Weller's musical genius evolve over the past 33 years.
The most wondrous thing is that The Jam songs are just as great as the new music:
He's always been great, since the beginning.
And he's still the coolest looking guy in the world.
+BHAKTI BROPHY Paul is that you?
When a former Beatle praises your work in the business 'you've been in for 40 plus years' then you know you've done very well' he always has been a professional of the music industry of the highest order as hes stood 'and is still standing' the test of time. a national treasure who knows his way around and what hes doing.
Andrew you hit the nail on the head he has indeed become a national treasure! He surely is one of the most revered and respected figures in the music industry!!!
Noel crying in the end is like the top moment in the video
His last album Sonik Kicks was great, maybe even his best. Many of My friends are superfans of his and didnt like it at all, I knew that I had to buy it and find out for myself. The man is an artist in the true sense of the word. He is also a cool looking dude. Paul, I salute you Sir!
Was Noel getting choked up? That's fucking awesome.
Cradock, brilliant musician and makes a lovely cup of tea.
Weller is a legend!
Quick correction for Macca…the first time he met Weller was in 1982 when they did a photo shoot together for Smash Hits magazine! It’s all good though, memory fades over time, and Sir Paul is still doing well for a man in his 80s. 👍🏻
Paul can do no wrong
Macca is so used to only being interviewed about himself or the Beatles he brings all of it back to himself. More of a compliment to Weller, Macca barely ever does interviews about other artists
mcartneys memory is knackered...he didnt meet weller for first time in mid 90s for war child...he met him in the 80s...there are photos
wow, what a nasty comment. Maybe Paul meant first time working together. Even if his memory wasn't spot on this time, imagine all the people Paul has met in his lifetime. Easy to forget meeting someone in his case. I hope you get more mellow as you get older.
Thank you Snarky One for your enlightenment
did miles kane just write Don't Forget Who You Are? 1:46
Living Legend. Truly, possibly the definition of, class and an example of great artistry.
Paul knows he's a legend and knows he's great. So shut up babies.
So much talent in one video
and Miles Kane
+Graham Harley kane is class
What Oasis song is half as good as any McCartney or Weller song? (none)
@@closebits Who asked you?
I liked this....Weller is an indispensable musician....
Je vous suis depuis les années 70 et je vous ADORE en tant que Génies Légendes
Musicales.........I LIKE IT to the BEAT GENERATION...........
Patricia LAURENT
My favourite PW quote is the one he gave in reply to being asked why he stopped being a veggie. "After 18 years, I really fucking missed Bacon sandwiches."
Wait, I think he was only Veggie in the Style council years, maybe 8 years.
Thats a real shame. You can get non killed soy and plant 'bacon'.
The beatles, the stones, the jam...period!
The Who
@@tabuencajosemanuel5102 the high flying birds 🦅, the pink Floyd, led zeppelin, simple minds,David Bowie, T,Rex,it just goes on and on the British have the best music,imo that little island has the best music ever
Big boss groove, long hot summer ect love paul wellers music.
Thing with modfather is that Im not even native english, growing up with his music I never got much from his lyrics. That means he gotta be genious musically also as much he is well known of his lyrical talent
Love mccartney so fucking cool!
For such a tiny island we do fucking rock and cool very well
Lucky enough to meet him after a gig at Sheffield City Hall.top fella
Paul Weller = Musical Creative Genius. X🎯🎯
It's not very often you see Paul McCartney given interviews it's nice to see that (not really a McCartney fan but nice to see top guy)
Steve Craddock looks like a detective out of The Bill or Midsomer Murder.
these guys are legendary guys so it don't matter what they day it's wot thet play
legends
This is a dream team interview.
Weller helped shape who I am for sure and he’s still evolving ✌️
Craddock is a fantastic player, pretty special
Lots of people don't believe in God.Weller is a musical god in my eyes.Started in 1972 with The Jam and is still making music.
Exactly so just play his music all through the yrs and asked for nothing in return and made many ppl times lil easier n interesting too Imo
Oh leave McCartney alone ya bunch of crybabies!
surround your self with admirers
McCartney manages to make everything about him. Dude, we all know you were great but, this ISN'T ABOUT YOU!
and Weller WAS NOT making a tribute to the Beatles with his look. Once again, its not abut you.
The Jam are the best band ever, fucking class and timeless
I don't think they get the recognition or air time they deserve or wellers for that matter 😊
Weller in my eyes surpasses McCartney and the rest because of the magic he is still producing at 60 years old, listen to his new 2018 offering True Meanings and you will understand.
im assuming your eyes arent focusing on the mountain, and im talking everest, of music that will be iconic hundreds of years from now. i can appreciate your comment, but lets not get senile
@@spence7985 nope that's exactly what he was focusing on. McCartney's written some great songs and has his own mountain of work but he's half dick .. it seemed to increase with age, beatles went to his head. Everything Weller did in The Jam, the first 5 years of the Style Council, everything he did in the 90's and almost half the stuff since 2000 is brilliant, sometimes unbelievably so. After 2000 Weller's struggled I think, except with True Meanings which I'd class as a proper album again with it's own feel and at least half the songs on the record are truly great
@@digiface almost EVERYONE knows the Beatles song mostly written by Paul...yesterday, hey jude, let it be?
What about Weller? Can Everyone name 3 songs he wrote off the bat? Yes, we don't think so. Weller is great. But Macca is Zeus.
@@theloniouscoltrane3778 Well you clearly haven't understood what's being said but since when did the lowest common denominator become the best? Who's 'everyone' anyway? I don't know about where you live but in the UK many kids now would struggle to name one beatles song, let alone three written by paul. But they couldn't name any paul weller songs either. I love those songs you've put, they're absolutely great, but they're all from 50 years ago now.
A true icon a ultimate bastion of Bohemia ☮
Miles Zane's jacket sounds like an old crackly record
Has anyone mentioned they are all Gemins, Weller, Noel & Paul ?
Great vid
It's a lil bit Brian Wilson Presents SMiLE, innit?!! He was in the audience when Brian debuted it at Royal Festival Hall in London, after all!
McCartney can't stop talking about himself whereas Gallagher sounds classy and self-deprecating in comparison. It's all about Weller Macca!!
His ever-changing sublimity
An All Mod CON artist! When is he gonna talk about his fathers real involvement in the Jam? Do you see any modern conveniences on the album cover of All Mod Cons?
I think Miles Kane meant: if your fans turn on you when you change your style, they're not your fans.
The mod look was NOT a Beatles tribute!
Exactly. Old Macca tried pretty hard to get ALL the credit there.
Stuart Cook Macca's been a bit up to his arse since 80s what Ive watched his interviews,
tho is also one of the few people in the world can get away with it :D really!
JonnyKasabian Yep. He's been working on revisionism pretty much since Lennon died. It's all about leaving a legacy of him been equally as cool and hip as John.
Then again Seems he's kind of pop to John's rock
Maybe a bit more talented musically - at least what comes to melodies etc. less revolutionary than john tho,
but he's got wider knowledge of music) what u think ?
JonnyKasabian I think Macca was very cool in his own way and very much his own man. He has no need to try to revise history - his place in history was sealed years ago.
The modfather
Miles Kanes leather jacket is too loud in this interview. Turn it down.
is that you that is!?
I dont mean to be offtopic but does anybody know of a way to log back into an Instagram account??
I stupidly forgot my password. I would love any help you can offer me.
@Jett Lucas Instablaster =)
@Esteban Van Thanks so much for your reply. I found the site through google and I'm in the hacking process atm.
Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@Esteban Van It worked and I finally got access to my account again. Im so happy:D
Thanks so much, you saved my ass :D
.... NOEL GALLAGHER SEEMS TO BE A REAL COOL GUY ...
Nah Miles it’s 30 years as a Solo artist , he’s also got plenty of greatest hits from the jam & Style council, your talking 47 years in the music bizz
HAPPY NEW YEAR 2016
CONGRATULATIONS WITH TO MY RESPECTS
VIVE THE BEATLES
Patricia LAURENT
Video makes me wanna play the guitar more
Paul McCartney..... me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me.... and then some more....
McCartney's memory must be going, he was in and around Air Studios while The Jam were recording " Town Called Malice" SO WAS I...
I think you still owe me for the bowling shoes from Melandy's Paul.
Great Memory's
Melindi's, wasn't it?
Paul Weller is the Paul McCartney of the next generation, although in my opinion better
All these people talking trash about Macca, wth is wrong with you.. If there's someone in the music business who could remain humble it's him. He hasn't changed a thing since the beginning.
fuck me imagine them lot as band we can only dream
Name of the background music please . . . . 👍
there isn't one other like paul weller and noel gallagher 2 off the most gifted both noel gallagher and Paul weller get in there please can they both do a gig together it will be a ticket left they will be first come make sure I get my tickets
Some crap talk on here, the beatles were amazing in a time of non bands, maybe the stones and kinks etc. The jam, style council etc had competition i.e start of disco, return of soul, ska, punk etc ,Weller is the best song writer ever, been going for 40 years and still going cos the guy loves his music. I watched and lived the jam for 7 years, even met the famous 3 paul bruce and rick backstage many times. Beats the shit music nowadays, listen to A VERY DEEP SEA the guy is the bollocks END OF!
He's not written a decent tune since the Jam, and his solo live performances were shit, i fell asleep on the grass at one of them!
As my brother would say hes the dogs kahoonas!!!!
What's the name of song at the beginning?
Brand new toy
what is the song at the very beginning
Jon Cleary thank you
McCartney has only produced manure for the past 25 years. The Modfather and Noel proper legends!!
They wouldn't have written a note without McCartneys catalogue. The guy achieved more before be was 30 than most do in a lifetime.
I know. He wrote "Yesterday" when he was 22. It's fucking ridiculous how good he was.
Paul's too bloody rich to care, anyway!
Take fucking Noel out of there. Oasis is pablum on their own. Pure shite compared to Beatles, Wings, Jam, Council, Weller, McCartney (much of his solo recording is amazing but you have to dig a bit, Weller on his own has been genius).
You ant stole that saying off Noel by any chance have you
Someone else has already said it but Noel is starting to show his age. On his last tour he still looked very youthful but he's got a bit of jowl now. Lord willing we all got to turn 47 sometime.
Liam was the proper singer of Oasis
& copy Weller style
Looking at when these comments where posted I'm a bit late to the party 😂
Name of the first song?
Redtree9999 Brand New Toy
This video kills me
Mccarthy first met Weller in early 82 at Air studios in London not at war child project
Mccartney did, not mc carthy, thanks god!
Noel is getting on a bit..so am i
McCartney is always talking about himself
Paul's alzheimers defence mechanism.
The dude is the GOAT.
Come on people. Really?... How fu£=8ng cool-is Paul weller! 👌✌️✌️
M.O.D
Er??? Ministry of defence???🤣🤣🤣👍
Noel is getting older :'C
see, that pretty much sya it all about noel.
"once you've had to throw him him out of your house at 7 i the morning' or whatever he said.
can you imagine liam doing that?
i dont usually go in for the whole laim and noel drama, and i certainly dont lie to take shots at legends, but their is something about noel, the fucking things he says..like even if you did "throw paul weller out of your house" you wouldn;t fuvking boast about it.
What
Paul Weller is an all time great. Up there with Bowie and Lennon etc etc. And stop slagging McCartney he's an old man and he was a Beatle for fuck sake he's entitled.
9:41 why is Noel crying??
pisses me off how Noel is know as the vain one when McCartney is the one who praises himself the whole time.
yes but noel Gallagher have a worst attitude than any of the beatles , and its obvious , im a fan of oasis but they have been bad dick heads in many cases , not that I know you but from what you say it just seems like you will probs be one of those oasis who gets pissed off when anyone mentions how better the beatles are than them
Did he say anything that is wrong? Many would consider him to be the greatest song writer in the history of Rock and Roll. He is certainly the greatest living singer songwriter in Rock and Roll, so saying he can "write a song" is hardly praising himself. It is stating a fact.
it's a video on Weller. I didn't come here to listen to him talk about himself and that's what I got.
Ye but ur stating it as its wrong that people say noel is more vain than mcartney , and its true noel is one ignorant fuck sometimes aswell as liam , i love their music but its still a fact noels undoubtedly worse than mcartney
We'll just have to agree to disagree,
Noel is looking old man
Someone to tell Paul that you don't sit on the throne in your pajamas.
what happen to the hair of noel gallagher and miles kane ??? new look , getting influenced by liam being skinhead ??? lol
Noel's haircut has been pretty much the same during the last few years I think...
+Ted Taylor It is similar indeed, but I do also think he looks different as well. Maybe gained weight?
The mod father
cant have the likes of miles kane and noel the social climber commentating on such important stuff
Weller likes you does he? Sure he covered your music too 🤣😂
Paul Weller is better in looks, style, voice, guitar & piano playing & live performances than John & Paul M.🤨🤨🤨
Why does McCartney always compare people to himself? I did this ,I did that,I was the first.Sad-he had is day but everything comes back to his ego.poor bugger can't let go
Maybe the interviewer asked paul if there was similarities between the two?
McCartney:Me, Me, Me, lol.. No humility whatsoever, particularly when you compare him to Ringo Starr, a very humble man.
Faul McCartney
I thought this video was called Talking weller...so why is Macca talking about himself? Self obsessed much?
He may be being asked questions like 'Do you see any comparisons to your career' etc
@leo Pulvirenti you Italian beaut, don't you EVER let me catch you speaking badly of McCartney on the Internet again... I'm disgusted.
+Luke Wride - hahaha! I'll consider myself told off!
Ride W shut up ya fanny mcartney is over rated
Can imagine John, taking the piss, 'How's Sir, doing today?'
Let us not forget Paul Weller urged all young people to vote for Margaret Thatcher, back in the day.
Weller was 18 yrs old and said it for a joke - so what?
Paul Weller, known for being a right wing conservative
Who is Miles Kane?
Makes good music
Eggcups.
Macca, legend but what an egotist
I don't know if he's doing it on purpose, but Macca seems to keep name-dropping people. I've never really understood how Macca and Weller could get on, considering that most people can't name any new songs by Macca that are from the last twenty years, while Weller always seems to be evolving, although I'm a bit biased since I'm a massive Jam Fan rather than a Wings fam. That's just my opinion, and is in no way intended to offend Sir Paul McCartney or his fans.
I can understand where you're coming from, I really can, but there is some Macca gold coming out, just not as much as there used to be. Check out 'Jenny Wren' from a couple of years back.
jasrust Fair enough- I'll look into that. Thanks for the tip.
@@jasrust And English tea. And many others
Why does Mcartney always talk about himself ?
mccartney sounds more brummy than scouse
I don't know what Paul McCartney is on, the Mod thing was nothing, literally nothing, to do with the Beatles. The Rickenbackers maybe, but the Mod look? No.
I think there was an unspoken comma or slash in what he was saying, i.e. the Mod/Beatles look, as being 2 separate entities, both of which influenced Weller. That's how I interpreted it anyway.
Nothing? aw man Ok cmon Get back on youtube n look at those early suits!!! They werent fkn Rockers were they bruv ?
benolly22 I never said they were Rockers or anything else for that matter, but neither were they Mods. Their Beatnik fans were very different to the Mods, the suits were completely different cuts, the hairstyles different, even musically dissimilar. Weller's influence came from the Who and the Kinks anyway, very little of his influences came from the Beatles.
I agree. If they wanted to invite a mod band, a no brainer would have been the Who. They were even the band's biggest influence.
+JFwolves Not quite True. There's plenty of vids out there where Weller states that The Beatles are his biggest musical influence.
Weather gets in your teeth, properly.