I wasn't even born when this song was written yet it's still my favourite 17 years after I first heard it...so full it sounds like there should be a 100 piece orchestra playing it. They managed it with the three of them and an organ. Sooooo underrated it's criminal.
Love Bruce's bass playing on this. The 3 come together superbly on this track and to think this was live. Knockout to hear musicians who can not only really play but execute live
If you gave me a fresh carnation I would only crush it's tender petals With me you'll have now escape And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle - I trample down all life in my wake I eat it up and take the cake I just avert my eyes to the pain Of someone's loss helping my gain If you gave me a dream for my pocket You'd be plugging in the wrong socket With me there's no room for the future With me there's no room with a view at all - I am out of season all year 'round Hear machinery roar to my empty sound Touch my heart and feel winter Hold my hand and be doomed forever - If you gave me a fresh carnation I would only crush it's tender petals With me you'll have now escape And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle. And if you're wondering by now who I am Look no further than the mirror - Because I am the Greed and Fear And every ounce of Hate in you.
Hermosa canción, encierra en su tristeza la despedida de años de furia punk y new wave, 1982 fue el canto de cisne de días mejores, ustedes vivían "the thatcherite's days", y nosotros, bajo una dictadura militar, íbamos a morir a Malvinas-Falkland.
@@arebecause0 everyone’s entitled to their own opinions, I think oasis are brilliant and I think the cover they did of this song is brilliant too, but ofc nothing can top the original
I guess the way music is and the nature of concerts make attending them a little challenging at least for me. I dunno if it would be all that comfortable to see some of the great bands, just that crowds are intensely frenetic in nature. The reality may not be so acrimonious, I will sum it up as best as I can - 'Sensory Overload'!
Heard Liams version of this first, happy to hear he didn't change much. Brilliant song!! When I heard To Be Someone in the Jam version for the first time I was very dissapointed after hearing it a million times by Noel..
Mansions bigger than rooms.. i see beauty all the time. Go stare at the flowers. Yep u do that o the way to love without owing for free if the price is right.
Yeah. Very polished but not looking happy. I met them in L.A. first tour. Pretty amazing. I got to know Bruce but Paul's father whisked Paul away. I guess I don't blame him.
True m8. I wonder if Paul Weller is a good Chess player like I am. I am a mega big Human League fan and I have seen the Human League play live 18 times in total now. And I will love it if Paul Weller were 2do a great single with the 2 Human League Sweet ♥️ s IE Queens Joanne Catherall and Susan Sulley ♥️ and with me doing my drum kit sound affect impression (which is self t0 and sounds like the real thing) on the track.
One of the best products from England. As I am I proud Irish man the jam said more than class distance
Beautiful song from the greatest band ever
It's about lucifer by the way.
The Jam at absolutely top form. If this was the only song Weller had ever written, he could have stopped there... Simply brilliant...
Dogs bollocks
Sadly he didn't and went and did the Style council. He has, bless his soul redeeemed himself since ;-)
Because Weller is one of the best song writers of all time. This song is criminally underrated.
Weller good song writer but Townsend was far better
@@russelslade580 hahahahaha townsend
@@russelslade580 Ray Davies
I agree . Top notch stuff
Both best
masterpiece. never gets old.
Magnificent - and Bruce killing it on bass and 2nd vocal. At their peak.
this song is like walking alone with a cold windy day.
Wonderful music and lyrics, Paul Weller is a king.....
I was at this gig....good memories......Bingley Hall - Birmingham UK
One of my favourite Jam songs.
Drums and bass are so good
incredible music
I wasn't even born when this song was written yet it's still my favourite 17 years after I first heard it...so full it sounds like there should be a 100 piece orchestra playing it. They managed it with the three of them and an organ. Sooooo underrated it's criminal.
I wouln't say it's underated … They've had many n°1 ...
desertboyguy 4 number 1 3 straight in
This man has a power in his voice.
nushoo I dont think its as good as it was, lately though:-(
Magic. My favourite in-carnation.
Love Bruce's bass playing on this. The 3 come together superbly on this track and to think this was live. Knockout to hear musicians who can not only really play but execute live
No doubts about the song writing abilities of Weller and Co. The changes in tempo of each new song,just amazing.
Love the sound of their voices.
He looks so unhappy. He's such a great guitar player the band is soooo tight. I guess this was the peak.
Saw them as an 18 year old at Loch Lomond Bear park .....yes they removed the Bears out of the area 🤔🏴....that’s a fact lol
Drumming is amazing
Perfection
Fantastic version of this song that I've liked for so long.
Let's put this to bed. Nobody will cover a Jam song better than them 3 performed it.
ua-cam.com/video/EUQhdF_kAFI/v-deo.html
YOUR RIGHT. I DO ENJOY THE OASIS COVER THO
Oasis with weller for me sorry
Liam Gallagher does a bloody good job though 😁
Liam improved it
in my top 5 jam always ...another weller gem from an album....that i feel gets well over looked!
My favorite Jam song
SUPERB ! ONE OF THE BEST SONGS EVER
Thank you, Mr.Paul Weller!!!
Enough said, proper tunes, proper class
testo spietato. voce intensa . suono bellissimo . cosa volere di piu'
If you gave me a fresh carnation
I would only crush it's tender petals
With me you'll have now escape
And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle -
I trample down all life in my wake
I eat it up and take the cake
I just avert my eyes to the pain
Of someone's loss helping my gain
If you gave me a dream for my pocket
You'd be plugging in the wrong socket
With me there's no room for the future
With me there's no room with a view at all -
I am out of season all year 'round
Hear machinery roar to my empty sound
Touch my heart and feel winter
Hold my hand and be doomed forever -
If you gave me a fresh carnation
I would only crush it's tender petals
With me you'll have now escape
And at the same time there'll be nowhere to settle.
And if you're wondering by now who I am
Look no further than the mirror -
Because I am the Greed and Fear
And every ounce of Hate in you.
Played this at the Sheffield gigs same year , just blew me away.
Weller, what a song writer! Superb! Thanks for sharing.
Thank you Aceface for posting the whole gig in order. Cheers mate
Jamtastic
Simply brilliant - cheers Aceface xx
24 years after this I was born
Self assured perfection
Hermosa canción, encierra en su tristeza la despedida de años de furia punk y new wave, 1982 fue el canto de cisne de días mejores, ustedes vivían "the thatcherite's days", y nosotros, bajo una dictadura militar, íbamos a morir a Malvinas-Falkland.
david garione Malvinas, ...
i wish i have gone to this gig
Mesmorizing in an eternal way! Great ace!
they lay the Clash to waste here and elsewhere..love the clash.
Whoa agreed
hope your ok up there my dear sis sarah xxxx
I know that Liam's voice sounds incredible but in this version the bass and piano makes a difference.
Fuck oaisis
@@arebecause0 everyone’s entitled to their own opinions, I think oasis are brilliant and I think the cover they did of this song is brilliant too, but ofc nothing can top the original
@@the17thdoctor1 so then let me be entitled to mine.
👍👍👍🎸🎸🎸👍👍👍
miss u sarah my dear sis xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Una delle migliori!!
Looking forward to his gig in November. WATM
Still sounds good.
Now there’s greatness right in front of you
Amazing.
Listen Liam Gallagher,s version of this tune live is untouchable in the studio with weller playing piano Noel on guitar
Such a good cover
No where near as good as the Jam's version. On top of that Liam should be Liam instead of being obsessed trying to be John
mystery gamer Liam does a great karaoke. The Jam are untouchable live , oasis came close but couldn’t touch them .
Yeah, he says it the songs about lucifer. And throws the🤘
Second only to 'Life from a Window'.
Hairs / neck etc............ WOW.
CLASS ACT
I guess the way music is and the nature of concerts make attending them a little challenging at least for me. I dunno if it would be all that comfortable to see some of the great bands, just that crowds are intensely frenetic in nature. The reality may not be so acrimonious, I will sum it up as best as I can - 'Sensory Overload'!
FOXTON STILL GOT IT AS WELL SAW HIM IN CLITHEROE OTHER WEEK
Weller is a genius!💪
Good❤
Luv
this man or should i say boy is genius....}
Liams version is epic. Probably the only ever time a cover version was better than the original
probably not.
Definitely
No way.
Lenny Henry oooooooooooooooooooooooookkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
You are having a laugh?
Whoops there !
But he wrote this F###CKING long ago! and he is still writing n singing magic!
NOICE
Amazing song! He was pretty stingy on playing the hits on that tour. I guess signaling the end.
They were promoting The Gift album.
razor sharp
Fred Fat Suede Head barnet;-)
what a pay off line
HINO
And that’s yours present government
Imagine this song being covered by Type O Negative
Liam and Noel's version along with Paul Weller and Craddock is miles ahead
Agreed!
Heard Liams version of this first, happy to hear he didn't change much. Brilliant song!!
When I heard To Be Someone in the Jam version for the first time I was very dissapointed after hearing it a million times by Noel..
Mansions bigger than rooms.. i see beauty all the time. Go stare at the flowers. Yep u do that o the way to love without owing for free if the price is right.
1 person is completely clueless
If i hear anymore about these n's you may have to have z's painted on your eyelids. Lay on your side at least once in a while.
Weller is bizz
That is how Steve Marriott played though.
Yeah. Very polished but not looking happy. I met them in L.A. first tour. Pretty amazing. I got to know Bruce but Paul's father whisked Paul away. I guess I don't blame him.
2 people don't wear a Carnation lol.
The Jam were a million miles better live than Oasis ever were.
I agree. The jam version is the best
Oasis are nothing compared to weller.
True m8. I wonder if Paul Weller is a good Chess player like I am. I am a mega big Human League fan and I have seen the Human League play live 18 times in total now. And I will love it if Paul Weller were 2do a great single with the 2 Human League Sweet ♥️ s IE Queens Joanne Catherall and Susan Sulley ♥️ and with me doing my drum kit sound affect impression (which is self t0 and sounds like the real thing) on the track.
@@samanthajackson758 Oasis = well overrated
Lol haha calm the fuck down
jim carrey are you?
not a bad view weller heaton doultrey
Liams and Steve Craddocks version makes Wellers look well average
nowhere near the raw jam not even close
UH >????
Only him and Noel Gallagher knows how to do it :D
Only him and Noel Gallagher knows how to do it :
Oasis does a better version with Paul Weller on piano
i do hope you are joking .
no way
agree
You really are having a laugh.
Well said
Controversial opinion
Bruce on stage doesn’t fit with the grittiness of the songs
Brilliant
FOXTON STILL GOT IT AS WELL SAW HIM IN CLITHEROE OTHER WEEK
Only him and Noel Gallagher knows how to do it :