TITANIC HISTORIAN REVIEWS BRIGHT SIDE TITANIC VIDEO! (Holiday Special)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 гру 2023
- In this video we take a look at another Bright Side Titanic video. Will my brain cells survive?! Watch to find out.
Discord Link
/ discord
Subscribe to the Historic Hangout channel here!!!
/ @historichangout
Support Historic Travels on Patreon
/ historictravels
Check out Historic Travels merch
historic-travels.creator-spri...
Historic Travels PO BOX address below
Samuel Pence
P.O Box 75356
Charleston WV
25375
#titanic #brightside #sinkingship #review #reaction #history
What we need is a collaborative Brightside review between Sam, Ocean Liner Designs, and Part Time Explorer.
Yes! Don't forget Big Old Boats- with the other 3, that makes 4 great ship channels, something I wouldn't have dreamed of a few short years ago.
Merry Christmas to all!
Where can I found it?
That would be awesome!
Yes
HAHA if by "collaborative" you mean "Battle Royal"
"in a cruel twist of fate, the Britannic also sank into the ocean."
Oh thank you for clarifying that, otherwise I would have thought it sank in Lake Erie or quicksand or something.
Jesus, Bright Side.
The kicker, of course, is that the Britannic did not, in fact, sink in any ocean. It sank in the Aegean, which is a sea (not an ocean) that's part of a bigger sea (not an ocean), the Mediterranean. These seas feed into the Atlantic, but they have their own currents and weather systems and are almost entirely enclosed, so they're not part of the Atlantic.
That is definitely an AI generated line.
@@Jsdo1980 At this point, I'm half convinced the voice-over is AI-generated.
Well, I mean, she could have sank in the Panama Canal…
But it sunk in the sea@@Historymaker-2001
*moment of silence for Sam’s final braincells*
🤣
😔
:salute:
Poor Sam sacrafised his Christmas Merriness to explain to us and entertain us.
You know he prefers this! Just like the rest of us! 😅
Doing it for us
I feel no remorse for voting for him to make this video
Edit: Yeah I know Sam does this for us. He’s a great guy.
Also, while I don’t think this Bright Side video that he reacted to wasn’t as bad as others I’ve seen but or course I still wish they’d educate themselves a little more and site sources where they actually find history before actually calling themselves “Bright Side”.
So still, thank you Sam!
Pls dont request Sam to react Bright side new Titanic vid
29:40 there's a show on discovery called drain the oceans where they use sonar mapping to create a detailed computer graphic of a shipwreck, they did this on an episode for the Britannic and also use subs to explore the area around the wreck and one thing they found was an anchor and chain that would have been used to tether a mine in place along with peices of shrapnel about a mile and a half south of Britannics wreck, this for me is as solid proof as it can be that it was a mine that sank the Britannic not a torpedo.
Ballard attempted to locate the mine anchor in 1995.
Yup! It is Season 2 Episode 13, “Lost Giants”!
We make you watch these because, in a way, we as the viewers are watching them with you. We don’t want to suffer and watch these alone.
And so BS’ view count doesn’t move as we watched it here instead 😂
It's extra funny for me to watch the Bright Side videos first, and see all the stuff where I'm thinking, "Oh my god, Sam is gonna have a fit when he sees/hears that."
Can we take a moment to say a rest in peace to Sams space bar on his keyboard who cops a beating during these videos :D
Y’know, i have a hard time estimating this man’s age.
He looks like he’s around 20-25 ish, but he acts like the most wholesome grandfather known to man.
Anyway, thank you Sam for sacrificing your Christmas for the sake of entertainment. We owe you one.
He is in his thirty's. His birthday is on his sister's channel or his channel a few years ago
THIS
*thirties
He’s 32
@@HospitalShip1916he looks 20-25, man doesnt age!
Merry Christmas Sam! I'm already suffering on Christmas cause I'm still somewhat sick and I was unable to visit my family for Christmas this year. I still appreciate you taking time out of your day and killing you brain cells to review Bright Side videos for us! I also have book about the Titanic on hand and I saw a picture of the HMHS Britannic while she was under construction. Timestamp for the particular photo that made me think of this is at 4:28.
Another edit: The RMS Olympic did indeed set sail on her maiden voyage on June 14, 1911. Hope that confirms what you were trying to remember!
Here's another edit: In regards to the RMS (HMT) Olympic during WW1, she did indeed come to the aid of the HMS Audacious.
Thanks Sam for losing your brain cells with me and chat. You handle it like a champ. Captain Smith would be proud! MERRY CHRISTMAS!
11:40 Yes, if you look at a transcript of all the wireless messages from that night, Olympic did respond and reverse course. Just seeing all the messages going on, you'd think that it would be the greatest rescue of all time...but then remember what really happened and the last messages are suddenly a horror movie.
23:50 Sam just misses the ship about to crush people standing on the slipway...
The Olimpic transmitions were also loud as hell, even though it was one of the ships that was furthest away
It's ok, I'm sure there's reversing sensors for when they back up into a launching dock.
These never cease to make me laugh. 😂😂
Thank you *SO* much for enduring all of this pain for our amusement. 🎉
no problem also I love The Last of Us. :)
@@HistoricTravels if Bright side makes another titanic video are u going to regenerate your braincells or kill off the rest of your braincells 😅
As far as I’m aware, the larger turbine was there because of the modifications done to britannic after the titanic disaster that made it a bit heavier, so a larger turbine was added to keep it at 21 knots I think (don’t quote me on this)
We have been watching your videos with our 15 year old son who is a big fan of yours. He just showed us this video and it was so entertaining!! Thank you 😄 we felt your pain 😋
I have been watching your videos for a while now and I am truly very impressed with your attention to detail and your drive to do proper research to provide accurate information on all of these historical vessels. I do have a suggestion though. I would like to see you cover the USS Texas BB-35, despite the fact that it still survives. I have followed several videos covering this legendary ship and researched some details myself, but I think I would enjoy your take on this ship and her history. It is the oldest surviving Dreadnaught (New York Class) and the only ship remaining ship that served in both world wars. Please do a video or even a series of videos of her.
never in my life ive heard sam laugh that hard
‘To join the bright side life’ sounds like they’re telling you to join a cult
I didn't sub to Bright Side !!
Consider that Bright Side Titanic just goes hand in hand with Christmas, because... it's the gift that keeps on giving lol
34:54 “when the explosion occurred violet, jumped overboard” lmaoo😂😂😂 wtf yooooo
Yess! What a Christmas present!
I've been waiting for this since I discovered your channel back in July and have binged the first 7 a few times since then.
I’m already suffering on Christmas, because I had a really busy time, never be able to spend Christmas together and I never even be able to have a good Christmas, I’ve got suffering Christmas, so watching this video makes me feel better. Thank you for you sacrifice of your brain cells Sam. Merry Christmas!
Sam I love your documentaries, your live shows... but man this is the most entertaining type of video you make.
Merry Christmas!
Historic travels. Great video. I was a Titanic nerd in 1989 as a teen. Your knowledge surpasses. Awesome job.
Such an excellent review/roast, and a great Christmas present! 🙌
I’ve noticed that Brightside have started getting less things wrong in their videos lately(As opposed to getting more things right), but you’ll always be a big step ahead of them Sam, and reviews like this are just what the Internet needs!
Kudos!! 🙌 And Merry Christmas! 🎄
Merry Christmas Sam and thank you for all that you do
5:18 i’m subscribed to both of y’all for max chaos 😂
Also I’m sure now Bright Side does AI generations when they don’t have time to find stock footage or make new animations
It sure sounds like the narrator is AI too, can’t tell for certain but it doesn’t sound natural to me
I had to pause at 23:29 until I could stop laughing at 'Britannic' being launched.
Also, to all those people standing on the slipway: MOVE!
I believe that Violet Jessop wasn’t quite a nurse, but she was a stewardess in the British Red Cross, hence her uniform having the Red Cross symbol on it
This has got to be the saddest video intro out of the history of UA-cam videos.
Thank you for sacrificing your Christmas in order to fight awful history.
You're amazing, Sam. : )
18:34 your channel's best moment ever
I honestly think that Ken Marshall wouldn't be pleased with the AI art of the Britannic because it looks nothing like the actual Britannic.
Merry Christmas, Sam!! Hhahaha watching you do this is a guilty pleasure for many hahahahahhahaha....
Mahalo for your sacrifice. You gave me a "Mele Kalikimaka" this year! Aloha from your subscribers in Hawai'i.
honestly we love you and i enjoy your bright side reaction videos, i react almost the same way to them lol!
32:18 Sam bright side actually manage to get that wrong. The Titanic sink in a ocean (Atlantic) and the Britannic sink in a sea (Mediterranean).
I'm uploading part 2 of 3 of my Titanic LEGO kit assembly as I watch this.
I've been a follower for a few years now and I truly appreciate teaching me more about these ships and tradedies.
G'day from Australia. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year
According to my information, Violet was a nurse on the Britannic. I am writing a time-travel fiction novel now about the Titanic, and as part of my research I looked up her biography, as one of the side characters :)
Thanks for an entertaining and informative video! It was interesting to learn about Titanic's sister ships although I can't deny it's the RMS Titanic's tragic story that continues to have me in its thrall!
Is a Christmas Miracle! Sam survived another Brightside video review and as a great present to him, they surprised him by getting stuff right, though they still got a lot wrong and those horrible pics.... cringe. Thanks, Sam, for this video and I hope you had a Merry Christmas!
You and ocean liner designs is where I watch all my ship videos
Brother, you are a gem on youtube. I thank you for all your work. I loved Titanic before I knew your work but after I found it, I knew why I love it. You showed us all the meanings of the Titanic. Again, thank you. Best wishes for the new years that's coming. 💙💛❤️
Wonderful, another cool Bright Side reaction video. Happy holidays, Sam, and everyone else! Oh, no, the Titanic did not radio for help.
Merry Christmas Sam, thanks for risking your brain cells for us🎉!!!
Titanic, Olympic and Britannic had double hulls along the keel plate, but after Titanic happened, white star had Harland and Wolffe extend both the watertight bulkheads and the double hull so the double hull would cover the sides as well, right at the waterline
Yes but only around the coal bunkers, boilers, engine and generators... basically in the middle section of the ship
Just stumbled across your videos, and I must say you are delightful :) Instant sub
Violet Jessup did serve as a nurse on the Britannic (see photo on the Wikipedia page on her for verification).
Hey, Sam, there is film reel of the Britannic being launched. I think you can find it on youtube somewhere by the British Pathe.
To be honest it's nice to see a picture of Titanic representing Olympic instead of the more usual Olympic representing Titanic.
Watching Sam descend into utter madness is a such an entertaining thing.
Props on how much better your editing is getting Mr. Sam, I see a few of Mr. Brady's visual hallmarks in cuts & transitions, it's wonderful to see a learning creative process evolve!! Serious question though Sir, Unhinged Pompeii/Vesuvius video when? We haven't forgotten that tease...
Videos like that is the reason i struggle at my own job sometimes. 😂😂
This is probably their best video so far. Never seen Sam jump with joy on so many occasions in a Bright Side video 😂
That's no moon! That's a space station!!
Oh, wait.... I'm think Star Wars. Nevermind. My bad.
Well, maybe Bright Side was thinking about Star Wars too! That would explain the "full moon" when the Titanic sank (during no moon). 🤣🤣
You should check out the book 'Titanic in photographs'. It's full of great photos of the ship's construction, launch, fitting out and maiden voyage as she stopped in Cherbourg and Queenstown, plus a few photos after the disaster of Carpathia and the lifeboats
good book
Rest in peace Sam brain cells 😂 happy Christmas
I was listening to the part about Olympic coming to pick up Titanic passengers, and while I agree with Ismay that would be traumatic, and a horrible idea, I started to think, if I were a survivor, and was on the Carpathia, and the Olympic pulled up to pick up Titanic Survivors, I asked myself, would I start rattling off jokes about the situation? I mean, this is something seriously traumatic, escape within an inch of your life, how could anyone joke about something like that? Then I remembered how I deal with trauma, and thought the first thing I'd say while boarding is "Are ya sure this one's not gonna sink? I see the Promenade is a bit more open, is that to allow an easier escape?"
Thanks, BrightSide. You have contributed to the mental decay of my last brain cell. :P
Ohhh my god
Im sorry that you have to suffer but this is so entertaining
Merry christmas sam!
Love the content and channel
hahaha we like you suffering but we still love you Sam!! xD Merry Christmas and have a happy new year my friend! Happy holidays everyone!
it was a good train ride at first but it came off the rails more and more as it went on
great video by the way huge fan
Compared to their other videos this one was pretty good. There is that poster or concept art that shows the ship as named Gigantic. That would have been a better name because it would match the theme, but if Ismay was concerned about people's PTSD after the rescue he would probably have a think about the name of the new liner. It's like the Queen Mary's naming in that the plan changed but it was for the better in the end.
The "AI" art trend really needs to end before it gets good enough to alter history. It's already poisoning itself so it's definitely not sticking around too long.
I actually saw an Olympic Deck chair and also saw the Grande staircase’s Clock and Wall Carvings! I ended up being able to touch it yesterday and it felt ethereal!
Merry Christmas and happy new year historic travels fam 🎉
It's the "if I'm wrong, please correct me and I'll do better next time" that keeps me coming back.
Some might say give em a break Sam. I say don't give em a break, because they're trying to "educate and inform" but are using wrong/false information. Also if you're going to give em a break make sure its just in front of the 3rd funnel! 🤣 Hope the brain cells can recover! Merry Christmas my friend!
🤣 Love it. Happy Holidays!
Thank you An excellent presentation!
Merry Xmas Sam and all fans from historic travels
Hi Sam for Christmas I got on a sea of glass!!! Super excited
Same. I got that for my birthday this month 🚢
Merry Christmas Sam🎁🎄 Greetings from Helsinki, Finland 🇫🇮
I looked up the HMS Audacious and yes, the Olympic helped the survivors.
Can I just say, that I've had a terrible week in review with people and I am not even referring to the holiday, just insanity with friends over drama, and I saw this and smiled, because for a few seconds, I could laugh at bright side, with Sam narrating. Thanks Sam, don't worry, at least you know your fan base is smarter.
hope things get better man. Merry Christmas.
Merry Christmas @@HistoricTravels cheers.
Thanks for breaking down the headache video,,,😂 hope you had eggnog and whisky after this lol
First of all, it is kind of sad, that the bare minimum of correct information now makes you so happy. Second: It is soooo cute how happy you are, when they get something right. I think this makes your review videos so enjoyable. You are not just out to tear something down. You genuinly wish, they would do better.
Im pretty sure Violet Jessop was a nanny when she was on Titanic and she was a nurse on Britannic! That was a real pic of her in the nurse uniform! Great video Sam 😅 Best wishes for the New Year 😊
Violet was a stewardess on both Olympic and Titanic, prior to being engaged as nursing staff on Britannic. For further reading; "Titanic Survivor" , assembled/edited from her memoirs by John Maxtone-Graham.
On a more serious note, I've heard but haven't been able to verify that "Gigantic" was kind of a running gag at Harland and Wolff in the early 20th century, because White Star was always building bigger and bigger ships. 3 of the "Big Four" (the liner class that precoded the Olympic class) were the biggest ships in the world at the time of their maiden voyages, and the employees were well aware of White Star's naming convention of ending all their ship names with "-ic". So any unnamed White Star ship would be referred to as Gigantic as a sort of a jokey placeholder name until an official name was decided upon.
18:40 That Britannic looks like a hybrid between the Normandie, Olympic Class, and the Queen Mary 2
I’m late, but I saw a video with you and bright side in my suggested list, so I tapped without question lol. I googled it, you were right about Olympic’s position. She was on a return trip from New York, so only needed to change course a bit to attempt to assist Titanic. Also, they were surprisingly correct about HMS Audacious. She was a brand new King George V class battleship (not THAT King George V class battleship). She struck a mine off the coast of Ireland, and Olympic was one of the closest ships available to assist. Olympic attempted to take Audacious under tow, but Audacious quickly became untenable and unable to tow, plus I believe there was increasing risk of a magazine detonation (which did end up happening). I do somewhat overlook bright side accidentally using Titanic footage for Olympic. Being a naval history buff, it’s a very common occurrence to see pictures/clips of warships mislabeled. The most egregious I’ve recently seen was USS Nevada mislabeled as USS Arizona, and a French cruiser mislabeled as Prinz Eugen 🤦🏻♂️
Fun Fact: Bright Side’s on the naughty list for lying about the Titanic to a clickbait level
Edit: Sam I’m glad you a decided to expose their false information and sacrifice your Christmas for it!
What a christmas treat! I still think you give Bright Side way too much credit. Interesting to learn about Ismay vetoing the Olympic's assistance, though, that's not something I've heard before. Merry Christmas!
One thing I am going to point out about the torpedo conspiracy for Britannic (if someone hasn’t already done so), is that there is video evidence of a mine having cause the sinking. I believe sometime in either 2015 or 2016, there was an expedition to the wreck of the Britannic where they were looking for evidence as to what sank the ship. I believe they actually found the cracked open shell of a German sea mine laying in the exact spot where Britannic was reported to have been struck still laying on the sea bed. So yes, it has been 100% confirmed that the Britannic struck a mine. I also believe that this evidence was placed in an episode of the TV series Drain the Oceans. It was in Season 2, Episode 13 titled Lost Giants.
Also, there are plenty of photos online of what Britannic would have looked like as a passenger ship. Part-Time Explorer and his development team made an entire game about the Britannic, Britannic Patroness of the Mediterranean, which has an alternate mode where one can view Britannic as a passenger ship. They could’ve easily used footage from that game as opposed to using crappy AI art.
Britannic did have a more powerful central turbine (an additional 2,000 HP) but that was to compensate for the weight of the raised watertight bulkheads, double hull, and other safety improvements rather than to improve her speed. A quick google shows that she's listed as having the same top speed as her sisters, but I can't find anything showing how extensive her sea trials were. They only lasted a day, but so did Titanic's if I'm not mistaken, and being the second and third ships of the class they weren't tested as extensively as Olympic, and given the rush to fit her out for her wartime duties I'm not sure speed tests were a priority.
She wasn’t 100% complete just enough to be able to sail lots of state rooms were not finished. Britannic was heavier with all the reinforcements and upgrades.
Thanks, cant wait for the next one
A cruel twist of fate the Britannic sunk in my little 10-ft deep 50 ft long 40 ft wide pond lol
Don't worry Sam. I'll get the lifeboats ready. That picture of Titanic that you weren't sure about it is actually the Titanic. I have a Titanic book that does show that picture of it.
The Titanic in red funnels is from the failed 2012 movie Titanic 2, plus the weird Britannic image is actually a colored image, just like how some Titanic and Olympic pictures were black and white, but with software programming made colored images, it's not AI
I googled "Dr. J.T.H. Beaumont Britannic Surgeon" and got several hits so yes apparently there was a Dr. J.T.H Beaumont that did serve as a Surgeon aboard Britannic and did indeed say Britannic was the most wonderful Hospital ship.
Love your videos!
In one of my „Titanic-books“ they also mentioned the name „Gigantic“, but after the collision the name was changed in „Britanic“, a little more modest.
I love this channel so much
Bro the photo of Britannic “WHAT IS THAT”
Sam you should try a game called sinking ship survival it is a small ship from the 1920s and you can do a lot of roleplay you can give coal to the boilers turn on the electric lights close watertight doors turn on pumps lower lifeboats and some sinkings has a taskbar to save the ship and it has a engine room but it is kinda glitchy probably because all the features this game has
Hi I love your channel….I was just wondering have you done anything on the Wilhelm Gustoff? It’s definitely something I’d be interested in watching
Britannic was listing from the mine. The list caused the propeller blades to stick up out of the water the lifeboats were stuck to the side of the ship because of the list and the boats slid down the side of the moving ship right into the propeller.
F in the Chat For Historic travels
The human Blue Screen of Death experience! 🤣Yikes ❤
Her thoughts in that Lifeboat when heading towards britannic's massive propellors was: 'OMG I never knew haw to swim but i'm gonna have to jump overboard or die.'
The fact that when Sam said that he wasn’t sure if Violet Jessop was a nurse on Britannic he paused the video on a picture of Violet in her nurse outfit and I’m like dude you have a picture of her in her nurse outfit
Hi Sam! :) The weird morphing in the beginning of the video from Bright Side is due to the "3D-effects" they added to that scene when she's being built, if you look at the scene things are moving like it was 3D even tho we all know it's a 2D-photo - but yes, I am also as surprised as you that they actually got the sinking correctly tho I thought it was between 3rd and 4th funnel the break-up was?
Also, the moon in one scene you got annoyed about was probably just a thing to make people understand it was happening at night and not during the day, cause that scene itself was fairly light blue which could make people think it was on a day or to think Brightside think it happened during daytime which we all know it didn't - not to defend Bright Side, just to share my point of view of that scene.
Great video tho Sam, much fun and happy holidays to you and a lovely end of the year!
Thanks and Cheers!
My face hurts from all the facepalming and my neck from all the head shaking. Where do I send the doctor bill😂
Send it to brightside😂
Sings softly with a whistle, " Always look on the brightside of life"
Sam is like Madoka, they suffer for our entertainment.
Merry Christmas historic travels