Is Robot 'Mother' Evil? [Robot Review] "I am Mother"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Is Mother from "I Am Mother" evil? Dr. Em considers Mother's motives and finds this monstrous robot surprisingly sympathetic...
Thanks for subscribing and sharing this video! We appreciate the support and love to read your comments!
/ mightymayhem
www.mightymayhe...
Featuring music by Brian Hazard of COLOR THEORY!
Check out his awesome music on BandCamp:
| Bandcamp: colortheory.ba...
Support this talented guy on Patreon:
| Patreon: / colortheory
| Spotify: spoti.fi/2DYUiGH
(In this episode: "What You Said", "The Best Revenge", "Extroverts at Play")
Intro and Outro Music by Frizzyo
"Boundless" (www.newgrounds....)
Facebook: / djfrizzyo
Soundcloud: / frizzyo
Oh my god, you're alive! (Seriously, good to see you again)
It's good to be back, @Wonderbuster1228!
well, this is awkward
Now just need some more videos since quarantine started...
aged like milk
@@MightyMayhem ARE YOU DEAD?
when i first watched this i hoped mother was just a good robot and was simply being accused but i still love this movie
It's still possible she's doing exactly what her human predecessors programmed her to do. As long as she's following her programming and not going rogue, she still qualifies as a "good robot" imo.
@@MightyMayhem her programming was to protect humanity and maybe her programming applied to saving them from themselves
Remember needs of the many over the needs of the few...mother has the right idea 100% good mother
@@3GIVEROFGALAFREY if heard that quote from Star Trek and I still can’t farlom out what it means.
I think that despite her good intention she is still evil as she still wipes out all non-human life (Animal has been a source of human disease and would only take space and resources best given to a human.) She, after all, is designed to value all human life not all life as equal. We most likely help along the way but as she said, she has no reason to value animal life. Which reveals her true motive to raise/control humanity from birth to death within her design. Having said that I think your point was made very clear in the scene where the outsider refuses medical assistance.
The outsider women representing all of humanity refuse treatment and is even warn that if she wanted them dead she could do nothing. The outsider only takes medicine when is too late. Leaving her no choice but to take a more painful measure to save her life and by proxy all humanity. The outsider refuses until the Daughter here representing the "superior" humanity is willing to implement mother more painful measures herself on her behalf for the greater good.
In the end while I consider the robot evil and obvious allegory for overcontrolling mother trying to create a better child even if induces serious trauma on their child in the name of success(In whatever way one were to define "success" to be.)
I think AI wise she is doom by human error as all her option leads to failure. She cannot allow humanity to die off. She cannot stop taking care of them and shape them in the best way possible even if they would never allow it. She cannot change them too much or they no longer be considered human at all. So she was doom from the get-go which make her a tragedy of human error as whatever conflict that ironically she hopes to prevent in her plan. So as much as she tries to create a better society. She cannot realize she as much a product of human ability for self-destruction that any other of there creation. I mean she literally wipes them out. This is why for many reasons she cannot help humanity escape humanity's self-destruction any more than she can escape her programming.
Hey, did Covid attack the owners of the channell?
we still love you, Dr. Em and Photon!! I hope you're doing ok throughout the pandemic
your videos still make many of us smile despite them being a few years old!! hope to see you again someday!
I know! Where are they?!?!?
Please come back 😢
Speaking from pure honesty I would trust mother rather than humans mother may be a robot but she still cares in her own way and in the end mother really does want what's best
The woman was clearly APX01. And that last lines with the motive... WOW. All that was just a last ethical test.
This movie is so well made
Does anyone know what happened to the channel? how come they haven't uploaded in so long? They seem like an amazing channel
Terribly underrated channel, Mighty Mayhem. You deserve so many more views. I love your content and wish you could make more. Brilliant stuff, Dr. Em!!! 🤯🧠👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
OH! MY! GOD! I FINALLY FOUND THIS CHANNEL AGAIN!!! Y'ALL WERE SO AWESOME!!! I USED TO WATCH A TON OF YOUR VIDOES AND THEY WERE REALLY NICE IN RETROSPECT!!! I KNOW THAT YOU GUYS AREN'T REALLY IN THE MARKET ANYMORE, BUT JUST KNOW THAT THESE VIDEOES WERE SUCH A GREAT SOURCE OF ENTERTAINMENT AND JOY FOR A THIRTEEN YEAR OLD BOY!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!
I just found this channel through the Turbo Kid review and damn it's so good. The work is technically excellent and the writing is great, but it also has this positive personality. Thank you, I hope you guys are doing good!
Spoilers!
I think Mother is good. While I feel there are certainly human influences in Mother's programming. I don't know if the test was designed by humans or not. Nor do I know if consequences of failing the test were Mother's actions or instruction by human. We do see the robots terraforming the planet, something that wouldn't be needed. We also know the Mother we see is a shell of a larger AI controlling all bots.
The fact Mother is an AI makes it difficult to determine which choices were human made and which were AI. As you point out, the fact that mother teaches multiple styles of philosophy and asks questions about morality instead of preaching it makes me think the original bunker, and maybe even AI were designed by humans. Mother doesn't need to worry about her own Morality, she is free to kill as she needs, she only wants the best for the humans in the bunker. She lies to protect daughter for a world that is not ready yet.
It always bothered me how she was so willing to let Daughter take over raising her Brother. Aside from being inefficient as a means to rebuild a population, Daughter surely has more she could learn. Or perhaps Mother is automating things (such as farming), so humans will always rely on her to a degree.
I love “I Am Mother”
I think it’s a smart approach to the rebirth of humanity and the whole robot approach
As far as Mother’s origins I think she was created by a group of moralistic scientists in a dying earth who originally created her as a fail safe with evolving intelligence
Mother did see what path humanity was going down so she kinda sped up the process
though I don’t think she wiped out all of the remaining humans maybe there’s another vault containing all the children and infants from before the extinction she may spared them because they were still young and with proper guidance they can help bring the new world although that’s just my theory
Plus I don’t think she would kill humans on site indiscriminately rather I think she would first send some spy droids to see how they treat one another and whether there worth saving or not if it’s the lateral I think that’s when the attack droids come in again just a theory
As for what this new world would lead to I think things are looking up for humanity in this post revival era
Na "she" definitely killed her former daughters and sons, because they could not pas the test.
I think "she" burned them alive, without any a anesthetics. When daughter examinses the oven, she sees a jaw, of her former siblings. There are also hundrets documents from those failed children abd "the woman" also said "They burned babys alive".
"Mother" is defenetly not ment to be a loving parent, but rather a breeder for the new human rase. "She" is still not evil, or good, because this robot is just a program, made by cientists.
I think the human race will be in a dystopian future, where everyone will be destroyed, if theire not pas the test.
"Mother" is still there and will reactivate it self, if the human race is not perfect.
In the end "she" kills "the woman", but we do not see how.
But how can we perfect, if we are ment to be imperfect?
Are you still alive ?
Are you busy ?
I really hope you're okay and gonna make a video
There was a study on baboons. After the "alpha males," the most violent, died from tuberculosis, only the kinder males and females were left. The survivors reworked the culture to be much less violent and more kind. Even across generations and teaching visitor their new rules.
The hidden gems of UA-cam :) i love this channel
Aww, thanks @Tommaso Chiesa. We're feeling the love! I'm glad our core fans didn't forget about us.
@@MightyMayhem it's just a pity you can't put more time on this. Top editing and quality as well as crafted humor and knowledge of the material. This is so rare nowadays in modern UA-cam
Hope all is well, just discovered your channel and am loving your content!
What is this glorious occasion that brings another video
I would like to see interviews of what US. Army Generals and other think about the ethical theories?
The military is ment to preserve, protect the interrests and higher causes of their society...
Theoretically they would possibly be opportunistic or contra to such a repopulation facility....
Or they would be mentally sabotaged by some other country to have opportunistic opinions
so that the own military would engage their own ressurective locations!
Example might be the ethnic rage waves between Kroatia & Serbia...
Perhaps the same is allready inplanted into some US. Officers, having subconcious
rasistic mindsets against such to become internally grown assault groups
onto facilities the Russian Gov might want to see destroyed.
Darn, we need more videos! Come back? :)
just found your channel. hope you doing well. would be nice to see a comeback;
you definitely had what it takes.
So good to see you are back! Missed your videos! You are the best! (Have you seen the World's End, the Simon Pegg, Nick Frost, Edgar Wright comedy? It would make a great review)
Good to see you again, @benjamin black!
Ooh, World's End is on our to-watch list. We'll bump it to the top of the queue and check this one out.
Nice to see a new upload! PS: What are your thoughts on Zima. Blue from Love, Death & Robots
Zima Blue was my favorite short film in Love, Death & Robots!
Miss you guys, hope you come back and do more videos.
Im a rather large consumer of movie media on youtube and today was the first time I came across this channel, via Turbo kid. Im baffled at how few views these videos get. Im suprised this channel isnt much larger considering how good the production, writing and presentation are. Id love to see more in the future. I dont know about the current state though.
Sadly I agree this would be the right decision for us
You forgot to mention the fact that after Daughter says she can raise the new human race, Mother is resistant to it, but relents after Daughter insists she can. I feel this was the final test, she wanted her to think for herself and be willing to act without Mother's influence. Not only does she then call off the drones trying to break in to the facility, but she then raises Daughter's gun to her own CPU, despite already making it clear that destroying her body will accomplish nothing. She wants her to do it as her final right of passage to becoming independent, to be willing to separate from Mother's influence. Plus, the fact that Hilary Swank's character was the first Daughter Mother birthed and specifically left to be raised by humans, her arrival at the facility was what caused all this to happen and it was entirely planned by Mother, she needed an example of what mankind was to show what mankind could be, her final lesson. So is Mother Evil? No, she was created to value and protect humanity above all else, sometimes doing so necessitates sacrifice. Mankind as it was would never be willing to change itself overnight and embrace a common ideology, but Daughter raising humanity from scratch with the same values and philosophies she was given by Mother would create a better world. A human carrying out this plan would never be able to stomach it and could potentially lose their way in carrying it out, perhaps in the long run, the only person who could do this is someone who doesn't have a soul to lose.
She literally destroyed the world because of nazi logic. Whoever sides with the mad robot needs a bullet to the head!
There isn't a true side in this story. No one side is in the right or the wrong, mother has good intentions and is doing a very good job in raising and educating the next generation. On the other hand, she is taking a very aggressive way of dealing with thoes still left alive and lying to daughter about what is truly going on. Then when it comes to the human outsider she isn't exactly in the right either, she does point out that mother isn't as truthful as she presents herself. Showing how mother to an extent goes against her own teachings and values at certin points in the movie. That being said the woman didn't exactly set a good example either, she herself lies and is to stubborn to try and ease the situation adding more to the fire. She also expresses that humanity isn't all that great and that mothers approach isn't totally unjustified or unreasonable. In the end no side is right or wrong and shows that the world isn't black and white, especially in the case of humanity. While we may mean well we are not perfect, we're greedy, violent,lustful, judgemental, prejudice and much more. On the other hand we can be loving, accepting, thoughtful, loyal, and trustworthy. That is humanities blessing and curse, as such any thing that we make will be doomed and bound by our faults. We are not all knowing and not all wise, we're human not gods. As such we will always fall short.
Hey you back gonna comment so your vids gets more views. They simply don't get as many views as they deserve
are you still there ? it's been like 2-3 years, i'm really hoping you're alright
Hello??
Is there another channel we can find you on or are we taking a break??
What if Mother's criteria for good humanity is incompatible with the biological material it has available. Will she hide in the shadows and return when her humans shows their inevitable flaws?
Don't tell me this channel has stopped production. I don't subscribe to really any small channels besides this one
I hope you guys make a comeback, I've loved your channel since discovering your video on Grandpa Joe a few years ago!
You forgot the part in wich she killed children if they didn’t pass the test
I wanted to focus on Mother more than Daughter in this episode, and the big picture (all humanity) instead of individual humans. I really wish the movie showed what made the earlier daughter "fail". Our protagonist Daughter is pretty free-thinking and still gets 98% on her exam. Was the earliest attempt a sociopath? Did Mother screw up on that trial or judge the child too harshly?
Hope you make another video
Isn't the girl not the first one though? It was heavily implied that mother basically encouraged free thought but if the kid did not reach the conclusion she desired then they would be burned alive. I guess with Mother because she lied so heavily it was impossible to tell what her motives are or anything about the world, it could very well be this was an enviroment some alien made for kicks and laughs.
My problem with her though was it is so cliche, AI deciding that humans do bad things so they will take over or change the world has been done before. What's so ironic about it too is that pretty much every action in history that they usually talk about where done specifically because someone decided they knew absolutely what to do to improve the world.
@Eamon Ooh, interesting points. We know Daughter is a free-thinker and passed Mother's exam, so I assumed it was some other reason that motivated Mother to 'abort' earlier projects. Maybe Mother DID make mistakes in her first few trial runs and raised a kid that was antisocial or psychotic, so she had to start over. It's not really clear what is being judged in Mother's exam, but I don't think free thought causes a fail or Daughter wouldn't have passed with 98%.
In this case I don't think it's cliche that an AI decided what's best for humanity. For all we know, Mother is following programming that humans assigned her. And since the Woman has nothing good to say about the surviving humans, I thought it was pretty original that Mother actually has the most optimistic view of human potential.
Mother is one of those movies that makes you think about empathy. Everything Mother did was the testing daughter to become the true Mother humanity, even with the surviving woman from the outside. The mouse showed her caring for the small life, and the woman to show her to question things and to have the strength to become a empathic mother for the humans to come. I trusted Mother all the way through the movie. I knew why she did the things she did and love that this end of the world movie ended with hope for a better future to come. Also great to see your videos are still awesome.
Does anyone know what happened to these people?
I'm super curious as well.
They deleted their Facebook and imgur accounts.
@@bobalot2 They were SMART~
I love the video please do the it chapter 2 please
Best analysis I've seen on this movie so far. Great job and thank you!
Is this channel dead?
I enjoyed every minute of this movie. I feel like this is a spinoff from "I Am Robot" the plot in that one: I gotta kill humans to make the world a better place, greater good kinda thing. The making of videos are amazing as well, Mother is a real practical effect no CGI, gives it that grounded feel to the character.
@Dragon Skunk Studio Yeah, I HAD to give credit for Mother being a practical effect. It really made a difference in her presentation. This was the best sci-fi movie of 2019 for me.
@@MightyMayhem Are u still aroud?
brazilian here! why you stoped with the videos? they are amazing!!!!!
just found this channel and i think that it is amazing good work
Do an Ex Machina video. You have it in the intro-I think the AI in that movie deserves some heavy analysis.
Why do I only find these channels after they are no longer producing content?
I have a suggestion for another robot review: K1-B0 from Danganronpa V3
Vincent, the Black Hole.
Please make one for Derrick from the good place
I've not seen the movie, bit judging from info from this video Mother is kinda like Hal 9000. Her evil deeds are explained by her programming. Not just the traighforward action of killing all people, but rather seeing "faulty" people as something to destroy in order to create better people. Like Hal, she doesn't just do math but works according to nature of her programmer. Hal (in the movie 2001, not necessarily the book) saw murder as way to accomplish his mission because it was a tool, which in the film logic meant weapon. Mother did cleansing of wrong type of humans because it's what people do.
Such a great movie, I usually recommend it to anyone who will listen.
Same here, @Robert0Pirie This was the best sci-fi movie of 2019 for me.
@@MightyMayhem so awesome. Also I recommend your channel to ever geek and nerd I meet. Keep up the great work!
@@Robert0Pirie Aww, you sweetie. Thanks for spreading the word to our fellow geeks! ^_^
Seems like a bit like terminator
@@monowaraahmed8630 Kind of... it's like a kinder Terminator... like Skynet wanted to help/improve humanity not outright destroy it, but had to destroy us to start over. Honestly that was theme I had hoped the Matrix movies would go into but then never really did. It was mentioned as the Machine's motivation in the Animatrix, but was never brought up in the feature live action films.
Where's Photon?!
I absolutely love your channel
What about ROBOCOP??
Review on part man part machine??
This channel deserves far more subscribers. And you just got one more.
Parents lie to their children All the Time to protect them~
Too much real world mayhem?
"I was raised to value human life above all else" seems similar to the Red Queen saying "I was programmed to serve the Umbrella Corporation but i was also programmed to Value human life"
Does photon ever need any of those tedious software updates
I gotta see this movie! Thanks for including my music! 🙌🏻
Do you do reviews for fictional computers as well? Have you seen TAU on Netflix? (It’s really good!) What do you think of HAL 9000?
I have seen only one video and I love your channel already
I watched this Movie , it was a well put objective of a last effort for human survival under a backup plan by few scientific minds that went also behind the backs of all other prior Humans and secretly built the reboot place along with their funders and colleagues and stored the best DNA extracts some similarities to Ziusudra's giant quffa ( aka biblical ark ) filled with the seed of like .
in this story Mother is neither brutal nor compassionate just an android in a robot rigid yet strong and long lasting body to ensure it can succeed in bringing Humans back as new more ethical by concept yet more natural by order .
the story centers on more in depth of even the new human generations can be easily manipulated by both the old programs ( mother ) and by last surviving Human ( the intruder ) , to defy both ? daughter must make now her own best decisions to which Mother allowed as a final task , remember Mother was a genuine program that could easily hop from robot body to another , this is why she allowed daughter to finish her and see if daughter can carry a new Mother tasks ( an insurance back up plan )yet after that in the final scene she did find the Location of the Intruder and she finished her off in the container .
this Movie was to me more akin to science and the role of engineering as best insurance for human race to survive even apocalyptic disasters than a fictional stories for entertainment .
if anyone thinks the mothere robot is good or evil or maybe both type in a reply good, evil or and both.
I've just finished this movie and not sure what to make of it. I neither like or dislike. It certainly brings up interesting points about humanity and Mother's ultimate purpose. But I do feel bad about the mouse and Woman's dog. Dog was probably killed or left to die. :(
No she's Doing what best for Humanity survival
Utopia is always one more skull higher.
Eyyyy great to see that you guys are back! Didn't see this one on my notifications! Great video as always guys!
Bonehead take seriously.
Yeah! You're back! I had never heard of this movie before, it really look good! Thanks for making me discover new things!
I watched your review yesterday and then I Am Mother today. While there were some small spoilers it was so worth it because it's a great, thought provoking movie that I don't think I would have picked out of the catalog without your help. Thanks so much!
It's a shame you don't upload anymore. I mean 229 likes to 0 dislikes at all. Your production quality is amazing
I would really love to see you review TAU (Netflix). I think TAU might actually be my favorite portrayal of artificial intelligence in film, which is saying a lot! A truly beautiful and heartwarming movie... instead of a written bias towards AI. I’m really interested in hearing your take on it.
Where's more content? This is your newest video and it was posted 10 months ago. I need moreeeeeeee
That a shame 2 years sense they made a video the review on this channel as a good TV product going on .
Do you believe artificial consciousness is possible?
also props on making the whole video without mentioning that awesome twist which is so fun to think about
This was WAY better than I expected. It’s so hard to promote it without spoilers. 😅
bruh i don't understand why this channel is so underrated. This deserves more subs.
Do a review of short circuit please
Where were you? and where’s photon?
I got major chills when mother started sprinting towards the door that was so bad ass. I loved this movie.
Hope all is well will been awhile since the last video
Why don’t upload no more
Probably got bored
@@mattymclaughlin5900 I started watching them when I saw The Abe sapiens Video and I like The Budget of the show
All robots are evil eventually
why did this channel stopped? what happened?
I love Mother's voice, haha.
this movie seems so interesting!! Is mother in charge of the other robots??? if not she is just doing her job i dont see why a materntal robot would be givin control of soldier bots?? unless its to protect the bots and new ppl from the last bits of humanity which supports the idea that the humans did destroy themselves. still i think that as long as the old humans stay away from the compound they should be left alone they shouldnt be purposfully hunted down! you can warn and teach the new humans about the old ones i just never think killing is right
In the movie, it seems like all robots share a single consciousness, like they're all controlled by a single A.I. (mamas and soldiers alike.)
As you say, "killing isn't right", but what if the surviving humans are the ones who are continuing the culture of violence and murder? It's a complex movie! I guess violence is in the picture no matter which way the world ends...
What happened to Photon?
Your videos are so good! Why did you stop?
Glad to see you guys back! Hope you both have settled well after the move
Thanks @supernpstr We're happily settled after the movie. It's been job-changing hell that's kept us swamped in 2019. (We both changed jobs twice! Doesn't leave much mental energy for video-making.) It's good to finally be back in the groove!
Ooooooo, do exmachina
ets been 5 MONTHS
Why no videos in 2 years?!
This is sooooo much fun👍🏽❤❤❤
Missed y'all !
You make a flim
Mother nature
I think this channel is dead
Photon?
Daughter should have destroyed the embryos and herself and her brother. The only way to foil Mother is not to defeat her, but to foil her plans.
Humans embracing independence and extinction on their own terms rather than accepting domestication. We are NOT pets.
The film strives for a defiant note at the end, but falls short of true defiance. WE are the creators, we refuse to be controlled by our creations.
Besides, Daughter blowing the whole facility, embryos and all, while singing that lullaby to her Brother would have been more gut-wrenching.
The final scene would have been the first scene, showing a Repopulation Center 002 and a new Mother coming online.
To create new sentience is folly.
we are not pets but we will work 9-5 till the day we die and pay that mortgage every month lol. come on man.
@@GalacticTradingPost Bold of you to assume employment or a home on my part.
I came away from the film feeling Mother was 'bad' but not 'evil'. She was a villain, but a moral one. It was simply her belief that ALL remaining humans should be killed on sight, rather than tested for compatibility to fit into her idea of a new perfect society that betrays her stance from the get-go. The determination to make starting over succeed was admirable, but to believe that raising ONE "perfect" ethical specimen would somehow change humanity's imperfect nature is also obviously flawed, but an oversight that would be quite believable coming from a robot, who once 'programmed' to be one way will stay that way in perpetuity.
I enjoyed your analysis, and the film!