I rarely see it mentioned in reviews, but this bag is in direct competition with the Remote Equipment Alpha 31. Both bags look very similar with rolltop designs and similar volumes. They even use almost the exact same fabric (EPX 600 on the RE A31 and EPLX 600 on the AS ATD1). The only real functional differences between the two come in how you access the main compartment and the admin features of the smaller pouches. The pouches on the ATD1 seem to be slightly better setup for EDC use as they have better organization and are a bit easier to get into vs the vertical tube pockets on the A31. However, the front "U" main compartment opening of the A31 I think is much easier to get into vs the back panel opening of the ATD1. The A31 also has a stash pocket on the top that the ATD1 is sorely missing. The A31 has a finicky and temperamental laptop compartment but it can at least be accessed from an external side zipper. The ATD1 has a better pocket itself, but you have to take the bag off and open most of the zipper in order to get to it. The A31 is only on its 2nd production run, while the ATD1 is on its 5th. You would think that by the 5th run they would have implemented more changes and improvements (i.e. a stash pocket on top), but maybe they are set in their ways and design of this bag. If this bag piques your interests but isn't quite doing everything for you, I encourage you to check out the Remote Equipment Alpha 31. I'm in no way affiliated with them, I've just used both bags before (admittedly a v4 of the ATD1) and found the Alpha 31 to be the better bag of the two for all around EDC and travel.
Huge fan of the Alpha 31 also. It's one of my top 3 favorite bags. However, I'm probably going to pick up the ATD1 also. 1) because I'm a bag geek and I do stuff like that and 2) sometimes I need more room for travel than the Alpha 31 provides. Both are great bags and nothing wrong with owning both. I see them having different use case scenarios for me.
Really like the construction, but I agree, I'd like to see an EDC non rolltop version. Also Forza Italia, love to see some Italian made backpacks of this calibre ❤
How do you like the wear comfort, carry experience when the bag is fully loaded? Does the default hip belt or the premium hip belt purchased separately add adequate support?
For my use case ( mostly travel), the bag is comfy enough at full load. The hip belt is a must i think at full load and the included hip belt is not adequate unfortunately. The premium hip belt is good although you can stick any hip belt that can fit the passthrough, which was what ive done
Thanks for the excellent review. Very interested in this pack. Curious as to why all the roll-top haters even watched the video as it was obvious from a quick glance that the bag was a roll-top bag. Apparently they missed the fact that there is also a clamshell opening to access the main volume…best of both worlds. I doubt they even watched the video…but for some reason felt the need to comment. The benefit of the roll-top on this bag is you are able to add more volume should you need it. No need to use it to access the bag if its not your cup of tea. Great review and a very interesting bag.
Hi David! Thanks for dropping by. Glad you enjoyed our review of the ATD1 v5 and we agree with you. The roll-top and the clamshell opening are great features, and it's definitely one of the things that make the ATD1 so versatile. We think the ATD1 is a great bag and perfect for travel, hiking, or everyday use. Thanks again for watching, and I hope you have a great day! Cheers!
"This material is waterproof, so as long your rolltop is closed the stitching holds, your stuff will remain dry" - Okay, but are the seams sealed? Because if not the quality of the stitching is irrelevant to the water resistance of the bag. (I don't really get rolltop bags that aren't properly waterproof in construction as that's one of the few real advantages to rolltop openings)
Thank you for bringing up an important point regarding the water resistance of the ATD1 v5 backpack. It's crucial to consider the construction details beyond just the material itself. To address your concern, while the material of the backpack is waterproof, it's essential to ensure that the seams are properly sealed to maintain the overall water resistance of the bag. The quality of stitching alone may not guarantee full water protection if the seams are not sealed adequately. Thanks for watching!
Roland, thanks for your insightful video. What is your take on the quality of materials and finish on the ATD1 versus the Bellroy Apex? Additionally, what are some use cases where the ATD1 would be a better choice versus the ATD2? Are the ATD1 and ATD2 comparable in terms of materials quality and construction?
Thanks for watching! The ATD1 and the Apex are different beasts. I probably prefer the feel of the Apex, but the harness system on the ATD1 really is excellent. Both top quality materials and construction. The ATD2 would be a better EDC or over night bag, while the ATD1 is equipped for longer travel. Hope that helps! - Roland
Great and thorough review as always! It's rare that you see a pack and immediate think 'this is perfect', but that's the thought that first came to mind when I saw the ATD2. Interestingly that was my first exposure to Attitude Supply, not the ATD1 as seems to be the case for most people. This pack and review have done some work to solidify that thought, but there just are so few reviews on it. I would love to see you do a similar review of the ATD2 if you can get your hands on one!
To be frank, we're not entirely certain, but it seems to be from Jacques Marie Mage. We'll definitely check with Roland the next time we catch up with him!
Can't stand roll-tops. They're rarely used, if ever. (For these types of city boy bags.) Wasted material. Unless you're using the roll-top on an actual backpacking bag like Granite Gear, etc. I'll stick to my Peak Design.
Thank you for sharing your preference and experience with different bags. It's important to find a bag that meets your specific requirements and suits your style. We appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts with us!
It doesn't have that innovative feel other backpacks offering. Like my Decathlon's Quechua 32L Escape 500, although is super cheap, but way way well thought out and more innovative.
Thank you for your feedback! We appreciate your perspective on the innovative features of other backpacks, such as the Decathlon's Quechua 32L Escape 500. It's true that different products have their own unique strengths and appeal to individuals based on their needs and preferences. Thanks again for watching!
I think ATD is going with the less is more approach here, which is the reason why Evergoods has been wildly popular in the carry community. Besides, the comparison is kinda apple to oranges as well. The Escape 500 looks 'innovative' on some aspects like multiple different pockets and usb passthru etc. But in practice, it can overwhelm the users. Moreover, the pockets and compartments also force the user to stick what is designed for them (fixed pocket size etc). Having a big open spaces means you have the liberty to go with the preferred pouches for organization. Downside here, extra cost. Sometimes, I personally find these features overengineered. I never like/understsand those USB power bank passthru in a backpack, these things get obsolete within a few years (charging standards etc). Besides, you need to get things setup. Easier way is just place your powerbank in the water bottle pocket while charging on the go. Besides, its unfair to judge ATD1 as not 'innovative'. If you look at the material itself thats being used here, EPLX 600, its the favourite child of Cordura's abrasion resistance and X-PAC waterproof properties. Thick EV50 foam on the shoulder strap. The thoughts that put into designing the harness system. Laser cut fabric. The list goes on. Its expensive for sure, but its quality can't be overlooked just like that.
I rarely see it mentioned in reviews, but this bag is in direct competition with the Remote Equipment Alpha 31.
Both bags look very similar with rolltop designs and similar volumes. They even use almost the exact same fabric (EPX 600 on the RE A31 and EPLX 600 on the AS ATD1).
The only real functional differences between the two come in how you access the main compartment and the admin features of the smaller pouches. The pouches on the ATD1 seem to be slightly better setup for EDC use as they have better organization and are a bit easier to get into vs the vertical tube pockets on the A31. However, the front "U" main compartment opening of the A31 I think is much easier to get into vs the back panel opening of the ATD1. The A31 also has a stash pocket on the top that the ATD1 is sorely missing. The A31 has a finicky and temperamental laptop compartment but it can at least be accessed from an external side zipper. The ATD1 has a better pocket itself, but you have to take the bag off and open most of the zipper in order to get to it.
The A31 is only on its 2nd production run, while the ATD1 is on its 5th. You would think that by the 5th run they would have implemented more changes and improvements (i.e. a stash pocket on top), but maybe they are set in their ways and design of this bag.
If this bag piques your interests but isn't quite doing everything for you, I encourage you to check out the Remote Equipment Alpha 31. I'm in no way affiliated with them, I've just used both bags before (admittedly a v4 of the ATD1) and found the Alpha 31 to be the better bag of the two for all around EDC and travel.
Huge fan of the Alpha 31 also. It's one of my top 3 favorite bags. However, I'm probably going to pick up the ATD1 also. 1) because I'm a bag geek and I do stuff like that and 2) sometimes I need more room for travel than the Alpha 31 provides. Both are great bags and nothing wrong with owning both. I see them having different use case scenarios for me.
Really like the construction, but I agree, I'd like to see an EDC non rolltop version. Also Forza Italia, love to see some Italian made backpacks of this calibre ❤
It's great to hear that you found it impressive!
Had the v1 bag from the original kickstarter. Get's better over time cause you get better at managing all the straps and buckles.
How do you like the wear comfort, carry experience when the bag is fully loaded? Does the default hip belt or the premium hip belt purchased separately add adequate support?
For my use case ( mostly travel), the bag is comfy enough at full load. The hip belt is a must i think at full load and the included hip belt is not adequate unfortunately. The premium hip belt is good although you can stick any hip belt that can fit the passthrough, which was what ive done
@@congnguyen7733 Very helpful. Thank you for your response. What are some things you enjoy about the bag?
Thanks for the excellent review. Very interested in this pack.
Curious as to why all the roll-top haters even watched the video as it was obvious from a quick glance that the bag was a roll-top bag. Apparently they missed the fact that there is also a clamshell opening to access the main volume…best of both worlds. I doubt they even watched the video…but for some reason felt the need to comment. The benefit of the roll-top on this bag is you are able to add more volume should you need it. No need to use it to access the bag if its not your cup of tea.
Great review and a very interesting bag.
Hi David! Thanks for dropping by. Glad you enjoyed our review of the ATD1 v5 and we agree with you. The roll-top and the clamshell opening are great features, and it's definitely one of the things that make the ATD1 so versatile. We think the ATD1 is a great bag and perfect for travel, hiking, or everyday use. Thanks again for watching, and I hope you have a great day! Cheers!
looking forward to mine! had the V2 and really like the changes
I have watched this video so many times now, really obsessed with this one, hopefully can secure mine soon!
Cool! Hopefully, you can get one soon🙏
"This material is waterproof, so as long your rolltop is closed the stitching holds, your stuff will remain dry" - Okay, but are the seams sealed? Because if not the quality of the stitching is irrelevant to the water resistance of the bag. (I don't really get rolltop bags that aren't properly waterproof in construction as that's one of the few real advantages to rolltop openings)
Thank you for bringing up an important point regarding the water resistance of the ATD1 v5 backpack. It's crucial to consider the construction details beyond just the material itself. To address your concern, while the material of the backpack is waterproof, it's essential to ensure that the seams are properly sealed to maintain the overall water resistance of the bag. The quality of stitching alone may not guarantee full water protection if the seams are not sealed adequately. Thanks for watching!
Roland, thanks for your insightful video. What is your take on the quality of materials and finish on the ATD1 versus the Bellroy Apex? Additionally, what are some use cases where the ATD1 would be a better choice versus the ATD2? Are the ATD1 and ATD2 comparable in terms of materials quality and construction?
Thanks for watching! The ATD1 and the Apex are different beasts. I probably prefer the feel of the Apex, but the harness system on the ATD1 really is excellent. Both top quality materials and construction. The ATD2 would be a better EDC or over night bag, while the ATD1 is equipped for longer travel. Hope that helps! - Roland
And yes, the quality of the ATD1 and ATD2 seem to be the same.
Great and thorough review as always!
It's rare that you see a pack and immediate think 'this is perfect', but that's the thought that first came to mind when I saw the ATD2. Interestingly that was my first exposure to Attitude Supply, not the ATD1 as seems to be the case for most people.
This pack and review have done some work to solidify that thought, but there just are so few reviews on it. I would love to see you do a similar review of the ATD2 if you can get your hands on one!
Fair enough!
almost thesame with my ogio alpha convoy 525r rolltop backpack
Love your glasses, what are those?
To be frank, we're not entirely certain, but it seems to be from Jacques Marie Mage. We'll definitely check with Roland the next time we catch up with him!
As a bag nerd I hate roll tops and will never buy one.
Same
Same
Love me a good roll top! Great thing about bags is that there are so many different options available.
Was interested with this bag untill I see the price😂😂💸
Can't stand roll-tops. They're rarely used, if ever. (For these types of city boy bags.) Wasted material. Unless you're using the roll-top on an actual backpacking bag like Granite Gear, etc. I'll stick to my Peak Design.
Thank you for sharing your preference and experience with different bags. It's important to find a bag that meets your specific requirements and suits your style. We appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts with us!
@@RushfasterTV Boycott boilerplate responses. 😜
Speaking frankly, it doesn't look that impressive...
Nope. No rolltops.
I hate the look of roll tops and the function is only decently helpful.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
It doesn't have that innovative feel other backpacks offering. Like my Decathlon's Quechua 32L Escape 500, although is super cheap, but way way well thought out and more innovative.
Thank you for your feedback! We appreciate your perspective on the innovative features of other backpacks, such as the Decathlon's Quechua 32L Escape 500. It's true that different products have their own unique strengths and appeal to individuals based on their needs and preferences. Thanks again for watching!
@@RushfasterTV sure! Btw, I really love your videos, keep them coming for bag nerd like me!
I think ATD is going with the less is more approach here, which is the reason why Evergoods has been wildly popular in the carry community. Besides, the comparison is kinda apple to oranges as well.
The Escape 500 looks 'innovative' on some aspects like multiple different pockets and usb passthru etc. But in practice, it can overwhelm the users. Moreover, the pockets and compartments also force the user to stick what is designed for them (fixed pocket size etc). Having a big open spaces means you have the liberty to go with the preferred pouches for organization. Downside here, extra cost. Sometimes, I personally find these features overengineered.
I never like/understsand those USB power bank passthru in a backpack, these things get obsolete within a few years (charging standards etc). Besides, you need to get things setup. Easier way is just place your powerbank in the water bottle pocket while charging on the go.
Besides, its unfair to judge ATD1 as not 'innovative'. If you look at the material itself thats being used here, EPLX 600, its the favourite child of Cordura's abrasion resistance and X-PAC waterproof properties. Thick EV50 foam on the shoulder strap. The thoughts that put into designing the harness system. Laser cut fabric. The list goes on.
Its expensive for sure, but its quality can't be overlooked just like that.